home
concrete
supply
llc
et
argued
january
decided
april
ordinarily
government
must
assess
deficiency
taxpayer
within
years
return
filed
period
extended
years
taxpayer
omits
gross
income
amount
properly
includible
therein
excess
percent
amount
gross
income
stated
return
respondent
taxpayers
overstated
basis
certain
property
sold
result
returns
understated
gross
income
received
sale
amount
excess
commissioner
asserted
deficiency
outside
limitations
period
within
period
fourth
circuit
concluded
taxpayers
overstatements
basis
resulting
understatements
gross
income
trigger
extended
limitations
period
held
judgment
affirmed
affirmed
justice
breyer
delivered
opinion
except
part
concluding
apply
overstatement
basis
pp
colony
commissioner
interpreted
provision
internal
revenue
code
containing
language
materially
indistinguishable
language
issue
holding
taxpayer
misstatements
overstate
basis
property
fall
within
statute
scope
recognized
overstatement
wrongly
understates
taxpayer
income
concluded
phrase
omits
amount
limited
statute
scope
situations
specific
receipts
left
computation
gross
income
also
noted
statute
language
unambiguous
statutory
history
showed
congress
intended
restrict
extended
limitations
period
situations
include
overstatements
basis
finally
found
conclusion
harmony
unambiguous
language
provision
enacted
part
internal
revenue
code
applicable
pp
colony
determines
outcome
case
operative
language
provision
provision
issue
identical
difficult
give
language
different
interpretation
without
overruling
colony
course
action
stare
decisis
counsels
john
sand
gravel
government
suggests
differences
nearby
parts
code
favor
different
interpretation
one
adopted
colony
however
arguments
fragile
bear
significant
weight
seeks
place
upon
pp
also
rejects
government
argument
recently
promulgated
treasury
regulation
interpreting
statute
operative
language
favor
granted
deference
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
see
national
cable
telecommunications
assn
brand
internet
services
colony
already
interpreted
statute
longer
different
construction
consistent
colony
available
adoption
agency
pp
breyer
delivered
opinion
except
part
roberts
thomas
alito
joined
opinion
full
scalia
joined
except
part
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
kennedy
filed
dissenting
opinion
ginsburg
sotomayor
kagan
joined
opinion
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
petitioner
home
concrete
supply
llc
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
april
justice
breyer
delivered
opinion
except
part
ordinarily
government
must
assess
deficiency
taxpayer
within
years
return
filed
period
extended
years
however
taxpayer
omits
gross
income
amount
properly
includible
therein
excess
percent
amount
gross
income
stated
return
emphasis
added
question
us
whether
latter
provision
applies
extends
ordinary
limitations
period
taxpayer
overstates
basis
property
sold
thereby
understating
gain
received
sale
following
colony
commissioner
hold
provision
apply
overstatement
basis
hence
period
apply
present
purposes
relevant
underlying
circumstances
dispute
consequently
assume
respondent
taxpayers
filed
relevant
tax
returns
april
returns
overstated
basis
certain
property
taxpayers
sold
result
returns
understated
gross
income
taxpayers
received
sale
property
understatement
exceeded
statute
threshold
also
take
undisputed
commissioner
asserted
relevant
deficiency
within
extended
limitations
period
outside
default
period
thus
unless
statute
limitations
applies
government
efforts
assert
tax
deficiency
came
late
conclusion
extended
limitations
period
apply
follows
directly
earlier
decision
colony
ii
colony
interpreted
provision
internal
revenue
code
operative
language
identical
language
us
commissioner
determined
taxpayer
understated
gross
profits
sales
certain
lots
land
residential
purposes
result
overstated
lots
erroneously
including
cost
certain
unallowable
items
development
expense
commissioner
assessment
came
ordinary
limitations
period
run
consequently
timely
taxpayer
words
code
omit
ted
gross
income
amount
properly
includible
therein
excess
per
centum
amount
gross
income
stated
return
code
provision
applicable
case
adopted
contains
materially
indistinguishable
language
see
ed
replacing
per
centum
percent
see
also
appendix
infra
colony
held
taxpayer
misstatements
overstating
basis
property
fall
within
scope
statute
recognized
commissioner
contrary
argument
inclusion
code
defined
gross
income
context
difference
gross
revenue
often
amount
taxpayer
received
upon
selling
property
basis
often
amount
taxpayer
paid
property
compare
ed
commissioner
pointed
overstatement
basis
diminish
amount
gain
leaving
item
entirely
return
might
either
way
error
wrongly
understates
taxpayer
income
added
commissioner
argument
fully
account
provision
language
particular
word
omit
key
phrase
says
omits
amount
word
omits
unlike
say
reduces
understates
means
leave
unmentioned
insert
include
name
ibid
quoting
webster
new
international
dictionary
ed
thus
taken
literally
omit
limits
statute
scope
situations
specific
receipts
accruals
income
left
computation
gross
income
inflate
basis
however
omit
specific
item
even
profit
finding
latter
interpretation
language
plausibl
also
noted
language
unambiguous
colony
examined
various
congressional
reports
discussing
relevant
statutory
language
found
reports
persuasive
indications
congress
merely
mind
failures
report
particular
income
receipts
accruals
intend
extended
limitation
apply
whenever
gross
income
understated
history
said
shows
congress
intended
exception
usual
statute
limitations
restricted
type
situation
already
described
situation
include
overstatements
basis
wrote
congress
enacting
provision
manifested
broader
purpose
give
commissioner
additional
two
three
years
investigate
tax
returns
cases
taxpayer
omission
report
taxable
item
commissioner
special
disadvantage
return
face
provides
clue
existence
omitted
item
hen
overstatement
basis
issue
understatement
tax
arises
error
reporting
item
disclosed
face
return
commissioner
disadvantage
whether
error
one
affecting
income
one
overstated
deductions
affecting
parts
return
ibid
emphasis
added
finally
noted
congress
recently
enacted
internal
revenue
code
observed
conclusion
reach
harmony
unambiguous
language
provision
relevant
present
case
iii
view
colony
determines
outcome
case
provision
us
reenactment
provision
colony
interpreted
operative
language
identical
difficult
perhaps
impossible
give
language
different
interpretation
without
effectively
overruling
colony
course
action
basic
principles
stare
decisis
wisely
counsel
us
take
john
sand
gravel
tare
decisis
respect
statutory
interpretation
special
force
congress
remains
free
alter
done
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
patterson
mclean
credit
union
government
effort
convince
us
interpret
operative
language
us
differently
points
differences
nearby
parts
code
suggests
differences
counsel
favor
different
interpretation
one
adopted
colony
example
government
points
new
provision
says
case
trade
business
term
income
means
total
amounts
received
accrued
sale
goods
services
amounts
required
shown
return
prior
diminution
cost
sales
services
section
basic
phrase
omi
ssion
gross
income
apply
overstatements
basis
colony
held
need
clause
leads
result
specific
subset
cases
government
adds
later
paragraph
referring
gifts
estates
speak
taxpayer
omits
items
includible
gross
estate
see
emphasis
added
speaking
items
imply
omission
amount
covers
omission
individual
items
indeed
includes
overstatements
basis
diminish
amount
profit
reported
gross
income
view
points
fragile
bear
significant
argumentative
weight
government
seeks
place
upon
example
least
one
plausible
reason
congress
might
added
clause
nothing
desire
change
meaning
general
rule
rather
congress
wrote
code
prior
colony
yet
know
interpret
provision
operative
language
least
one
lower
decided
provision
apply
overstatements
cost
goods
business
later
sold
see
uptegrove
lumber
commissioner
see
reis
commissioner
congress
well
wanted
ensure
come
may
uptegrove
interpretation
remain
law
trade
business
issue
interpretation
leave
clause
without
work
trw
andrews
noting
canon
statutes
read
avoid
making
provision
superfluous
void
insignificant
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
provision
also
explains
calculate
denominator
purposes
determining
whether
conceded
omission
amounts
gross
income
example
tells
us
merchant
fails
include
revenue
sold
goods
met
test
total
revenue
regardless
cost
paid
merchant
acquire
goods
without
clause
general
statutory
definition
gross
income
requires
subtracting
cost
sales
price
see
definition
gross
income
calculation
take
total
revenue
sales
minus
cost
sales
say
revenue
thus
amount
gross
income
clause
work
respect
omissions
gross
income
irrespective
interpretation
regarding
overstatements
basis
government
argument
subsection
use
word
item
instead
amount
yet
weaker
colony
addressed
similar
argument
word
amount
wrote
commissioner
draftsman
use
word
instead
example
suggests
concentration
quantitative
aspect
error
whether
gross
income
understated
much
recognizing
commissioner
logic
rejected
argument
significance
word
amount
insufficient
prove
commissioner
conclusion
addition
word
item
different
subsection
similarly
fails
exert
interpretive
force
sufficiently
strong
affect
conclusion
word
appearance
subsection
concede
new
rely
case
us
solitary
word
change
different
subsection
like
hoping
new
batboy
change
outcome
world
series
iv
finally
government
points
treasury
regulation
promulgated
final
form
december
see
cfr
regulation
relevant
departs
colony
interprets
operative
language
statute
government
favor
regulation
says
understated
amount
gross
income
resulting
overstatement
unrecovered
cost
basis
constitutes
omission
gross
income
iii
government
view
new
regulation
effect
overturns
colony
interpretation
statute
government
points
treasury
regulation
constitutes
agency
construction
statute
administers
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
see
also
mayo
foundation
medical
ed
research
applying
chevron
tax
context
written
prior
judicial
construction
statute
trumps
agency
construction
otherwise
entitled
chevron
deference
prior
decision
holds
construction
follows
unambiguous
terms
statute
national
cable
telecommunications
assn
brand
internet
services
emphasis
added
government
notes
colony
wrote
said
language
unambiguous
hence
government
concludes
colony
govern
outcome
case
question
rather
whether
agency
construction
permissible
construction
statute
chevron
supra
since
government
argues
regulation
embodies
reasonable
hence
permissible
construction
statute
government
believes
must
win
accept
argument
view
colony
already
interpreted
statute
longer
different
construction
consistent
colony
available
adoption
agency
fatal
flaw
government
contrary
argument
overlooks
reason
brand
held
prior
judicial
construction
unless
reflecting
unambiguous
statute
trump
different
agency
construction
statute
reveals
reason
points
agencies
courts
fill
statutory
gaps
ibid
fact
statute
unambiguous
means
gap
agency
fill
thus
room
agency
discretion
stating
sought
encapsulate
earlier
opinions
including
chevron
made
clear
opinions
identify
underlying
interpretive
problem
deciding
whether
particular
statute
effect
delegates
agency
power
fill
gap
thereby
implicitly
taking
power
void
reasonable
interpretation
thus
chevron
said
congress
explicitly
left
gap
agency
fill
express
delegation
authority
agency
elucidate
specific
provision
statute
regulation
sometimes
legislative
delegation
agency
particular
question
implicit
rather
explicit
either
instance
may
substitute
construction
statutory
provision
reasonable
interpretation
made
administrator
agency
see
also
mead
smiley
citibank
south
dakota
ins
morton
ruiz
chevron
later
cases
find
unambiguous
language
clear
sign
congress
delegate
authority
agency
find
ambiguous
language
least
presumptive
indication
congress
delegate
authority
thus
chevron
wrote
statute
silence
ambiguity
particular
issue
means
congress
directly
addressed
precise
question
issue
thus
likely
delegating
power
agency
mead
describing
chevron
explained
congress
may
expressly
delegated
authority
responsibility
implement
particular
provision
fill
particular
gap
yet
still
apparent
agency
generally
conferred
authority
statutory
circumstances
congress
expect
agency
able
speak
force
law
addresses
ambiguity
statute
fills
space
enacted
law
even
one
congress
actually
intent
particular
result
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
chevron
added
employing
traditional
tools
statutory
construction
ascertains
congress
intention
precise
question
issue
intention
law
must
given
effect
emphasis
added
government
points
colony
stated
statutory
language
issue
unambiguous
decided
case
nearly
years
decided
chevron
reason
believe
linguistic
ambiguity
noted
colony
reflects
conclusion
congress
delegated
power
agency
time
every
reason
believe
thought
congress
directly
spoken
question
hand
thus
left
gap
agency
fill
chevron
supra
one
thing
said
taxpayer
better
side
textual
argument
colony
another
examination
legislative
history
led
believe
congress
decided
question
definitively
leaving
room
agency
reach
contrary
result
found
history
persuasive
indications
congress
intended
overstatements
basis
fall
outside
statute
scope
said
satisfied
congress
intended
exception
restricted
type
situation
already
described
thought
commissioner
interpretation
interpretation
advanced
create
patent
incongruity
tax
law
reached
conclusion
despite
fact
years
leading
colony
commissioner
consistently
advocated
opposite
circuit
courts
see
uptegrove
reis
goodenow
commisioner
american
liberty
oil
commissioner
cf
slaff
commisioner
davis
hightower
thus
aware
rejecting
expert
opinion
commissioner
internal
revenue
finally
completing
analysis
colony
found
interpretation
code
harmony
unambiguous
language
code
minimum
suggests
saw
nothing
code
inconsistent
conclusion
may
judges
today
use
methods
determine
whether
congress
left
gap
fill
beside
point
question
whether
colony
concluded
statute
left
gap
view
opinion
written
justice
harlan
makes
clear
given
principles
stare
decisis
must
follow
interpretation
gap
fill
government
regulation
change
colony
interpretation
statute
agree
taxpayer
overstatements
basis
resulting
understatement
gross
income
trigger
extended
limitations
period
appeals
reached
conclusion
see
judgment
affirmed
ordered
appendix
reproduce
applicable
sections
two
relevant
versions
code
section
amended
reorganized
see
hiring
incentives
restore
employment
act
stat
parties
agree
amendments
affect
case
therefore
referred
reproduce
section
appears
edition
code
title
ed
period
limitation
upon
assessment
collection
general
rule
amount
income
taxes
imposed
chapter
shall
assessed
within
three
years
return
filed
proceeding
without
assessment
collection
taxes
shall
begun
expiration
period
omission
gross
income
taxpayer
omits
gross
income
amount
properly
includible
therein
excess
per
centum
amount
gross
income
stated
return
tax
may
assessed
proceeding
collection
tax
may
begun
without
assessment
time
within
years
return
filed
title
ed
limitations
assessment
collection
general
rule
except
otherwise
provided
section
amount
tax
imposed
title
shall
assessed
within
years
return
filed
whether
return
filed
date
prescribed
tax
payable
stamp
time
tax
became
due
expiration
years
date
part
tax
paid
proceeding
without
assessment
collection
tax
shall
begun
expiration
period
substantial
omission
items
except
otherwise
provided
subsection
income
taxes
case
tax
imposed
subtitle
general
rule
taxpayer
omits
gross
income
amount
properly
includible
therein
excess
percent
amount
gross
income
stated
return
tax
may
assessed
proceeding
collection
tax
may
begun
without
assessment
time
within
years
return
filed
purposes
subparagraph
case
trade
business
term
income
means
total
amounts
received
accrued
sale
goods
services
amounts
required
shown
return
prior
diminution
cost
sales
services
ii
determining
amount
omitted
gross
income
shall
taken
account
amount
omitted
gross
income
stated
return
amount
disclosed
return
statement
attached
return
manner
adequate
apprise
secretary
nature
amount
item
estate
gift
taxes
case
return
estate
tax
chapter
return
gift
tax
chapter
taxpayer
omits
gross
estate
total
amount
gifts
made
period
return
filed
items
includible
gross
estate
total
gifts
case
may
exceed
amount
percent
gross
estate
stated
return
total
amount
gifts
stated
return
tax
may
assessed
proceeding
collection
tax
may
begun
without
assessment
time
within
years
return
filed
opinion
scalia
petitioner
home
concrete
supply
llc
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
april
justice
scalia
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
reasonable
think
deny
precedential
effect
colony
commissioner
overrule
holding
obviously
contrary
later
law
agency
resolutions
ambiguities
accorded
deference
justifiable
taxpayer
reliance
take
course
neither
opinion
says
colony
determines
outcome
case
ante
end
matter
plurality
however
goes
address
government
argument
treasury
regulation
effectively
overturned
colony
see
cfr
view
decided
upon
de
novo
construction
statute
longer
different
construction
consistent
holding
available
adoption
agency
national
cable
telecommunications
assn
brand
internet
services
scalia
dissenting
citation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
view
course
carry
day
brand
government
quite
reasonably
relies
brand
majority
innovative
pronouncement
prior
judicial
construction
statute
trumps
agency
construction
otherwise
entitled
chevron
deference
prior
decision
holds
construction
follows
unambiguous
terms
statute
cases
decided
inkling
must
utter
magic
words
ambiguous
unambiguous
order
poof
expand
abridge
executive
power
poof
enable
disable
administrative
contradiction
indeed
unaware
even
utility
much
less
necessity
making
determination
cases
decided
opinion
made
step
determination
ambiguity
vel
non
customary
though
hardly
part
analysis
many
earlier
cases
therefore
incredibly
difficult
determine
whether
decision
purported
giving
meaning
ambiguous
rather
unambiguous
statute
thus
one
thought
brand
majority
breathe
sigh
relief
present
case
involving
opinion
mirabile
dictu
makes
inescapably
clear
thought
statute
ambiguous
said
language
unambiguous
colony
supra
emphasis
added
today
plurality
opinion
explains
colony
said
taxpayer
better
side
textual
argument
ante
emphasis
added
brand
requires
foreclose
administrative
revision
decisions
permissible
reading
statute
thus
decided
stand
colony
stand
brand
well
plurality
found
order
reach
decision
treasury
department
current
interpretation
unreasonable
instead
brand
require
however
plurality
manages
sustain
justifiable
reliance
taxpayers
revising
yet
meaning
chevron
revising
yet
direction
create
confusion
uncertainty
see
mead
scalia
dissenting
bressman
mead
muddled
judicial
review
agency
action
vand
rev
course
doubt
regard
internal
revenue
code
treasury
department
satisfies
mead
requirement
indication
congress
delegated
authority
agency
generally
make
rules
carrying
force
law
given
chevron
deference
treasury
regulation
see
mayo
foundation
medical
ed
research
slip
order
evade
brand
yet
reaffirm
colony
plurality
add
yet
another
story
ugly
improbable
structure
law
administrative
review
become
trigger
brand
power
authorized
agency
give
content
ambiguous
text
determination
language
ambiguous
alone
suffice
must
addition
found
congress
wanted
particular
ambiguity
question
resolved
agency
today
plurality
opinion
finds
reason
believe
linguistic
ambiguity
noted
colony
reflects
conclusion
congress
delegated
power
agency
ante
notion
seemingly
finding
ambiguity
accompanied
finding
agency
authority
resolve
ambiguity
premise
false
cases
conclude
congress
wanted
particular
ambiguity
resolved
agency
simply
legal
effect
ambiguity
legal
effect
obtain
whenever
language
fact
colony
found
ambiguous
plurality
feel
give
effect
colony
determination
ambiguity
know
era
importance
determination
empower
agency
effect
revise
determination
statutory
meaning
suggested
earlier
ignorance
cases
shared
really
matter
whether
resolving
ambiguity
setting
forth
statute
clear
meaning
opinion
might
might
advert
point
course
analysis
either
way
interpretation
statute
law
small
number
cases
today
plurality
opinion
exile
land
uncertainty
perhaps
sensing
fragility
new
approach
plurality
opinion
pivots
la
mode
vernacular
focusing
whether
colony
concluded
authority
focusing
whether
colony
concluded
gap
filled
question
whether
colony
concluded
statute
left
gap
view
opinion
makes
clear
ante
plurality
know
justice
harlan
opinion
said
taxpayer
better
side
textual
argument
found
legislative
history
indicated
congress
intended
overstatements
basis
fall
outside
statute
scope
concluded
commissioner
interpretation
create
patent
incongruity
tax
law
found
interpretation
harmony
unambiguous
language
code
ante
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
sorts
arguments
courts
always
use
resolving
ambiguities
prove
ambiguity
existed
unless
one
believes
ambiguity
resolved
ambiguity
never
existed
first
place
colony
said
unambiguously
text
ambiguous
end
matter
unless
one
wants
simply
deny
stare
decisis
effect
colony
decision
rather
making
jurisprudence
curiouser
curiouser
abandon
opinion
produces
contortions
brand
join
judgment
announced
indisputable
colony
resolved
construction
statutory
language
issue
construction
must
therefore
control
join
opinion
except
part
must
add
word
peroration
dissent
asserts
ur
legal
system
presumes
continuing
dialogue
among
three
branches
government
questions
statutory
interpretation
application
constructive
discourse
ations
instructive
exchanges
foreclosed
insistence
adhering
earlier
interpretations
statute
even
light
new
relevant
statutory
amendments
post
opinion
kennedy
passage
reminiscent
professor
davis
vision
administrative
procedure
developed
partnership
legislators
judges
working
partners
produce
better
law
legislators
alone
possibly
produce
romantic
image
obliterated
vermont
yankee
nuclear
power
natural
resources
defense
council
held
congress
prescribes
obey
discretion
add
administrative
procedures
congress
created
seems
dissent
vision
troika
partnership
similar
mirage
discourse
conversation
exchange
dissent
perceives
peculiarly
congress
prescribes
congress
prescription
ambiguous
executive
within
scope
ambiguity
clarify
prescription
product
constitutional
courts
obey
hardly
think
amounts
discourse
congress
allow
brand
decision
executive
change
prescription
render
prior
holding
irrelevant
needed
system
work
congress
executive
private
parties
subject
dispositions
able
predict
meaning
courts
give
instructions
goal
obstructed
judicially
established
meaning
technical
legal
term
used
specific
context
overturned
basis
statutory
indications
feeble
asserted
kennedy
dissenting
petitioner
home
concrete
supply
llc
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
april
justice
kennedy
justice
ginsburg
justice
sotomayor
justice
kagan
join
dissenting
case
involves
provision
internal
revenue
code
establishing
extended
statute
limitations
tax
assessment
cases
substantial
income
omitted
tax
return
see
supp
iv
treasury
department
determined
taxpayers
omit
income
section
fail
report
sale
property
also
overstate
basis
property
sold
see
treas
reg
cfr
question
whether
otherwise
reasonable
interpretation
foreclosed
contrary
reading
earlier
version
statute
colony
commissioner
colony
need
decide
whether
meaning
provision
changed
congress
part
revision
tax
code
although
main
text
statute
remained
congress
added
new
provisions
leading
permissible
conclusion
different
meaning
going
forward
colony
decision
reserved
judgment
issue
view
amended
statute
leaves
room
department
reading
summary
reasons
concluding
department
interpretation
permissible
respectful
dissent
follows
statute
issue
colony
ed
enacted
part
internal
revenue
code
provided
longer
period
limitations
government
assessed
income
taxes
taxpayer
omit
ted
gross
income
amount
excess
per
centum
amount
gross
income
stated
return
disagreement
courts
meaning
provision
statute
first
enacted
tax
appeals
sixth
circuit
held
overstatement
basis
constituted
omission
gross
income
trigger
extended
limitations
period
see
reis
commissioner
american
liberty
oil
commissioner
appeals
third
circuit
came
opposite
conclusion
case
corporation
misreported
income
inflating
cost
goods
sold
inventory
see
uptegrove
lumber
commissioner
third
circuit
view
omission
taxpayer
left
entire
item
gain
computation
gross
income
colony
decision
issued
resolved
dispute
government
acknowledging
said
language
unambiguous
relying
large
part
legislative
history
code
concluded
mere
overstatement
basis
constitute
omission
gross
income
government
prevail
instant
case
regulation
question
must
proper
implementation
language
considered
colony
statutory
interpretation
issue
resolved
colony
decision
deemed
controlling
without
first
considering
inferences
drawn
added
statutory
text
additional
language
part
statute
governed
taxpayer
liability
colony
consider
case
congress
revised
internal
revenue
code
several
years
colony
decided
tax
years
question
case
although
interpretation
adopted
colony
proper
beginning
point
interpretation
revised
statute
end
central
language
new
provision
remained
old
longer
period
limitations
still
applicable
taxpayer
omit
ted
gross
income
amount
excess
per
cent
amount
gross
income
stated
return
colony
however
left
open
whether
congress
nonetheless
manifested
intention
clarify
change
code
revisions
course
provide
direct
response
colony
yet
decided
indications
whatever
earlier
version
statute
meant
congress
expected
overstatement
basis
considered
omission
gross
income
general
rule
going
forward
example
new
law
created
special
exception
businesses
defining
gross
income
total
amounts
received
accrued
sale
goods
services
without
factoring
cost
sales
services
ed
supp
iv
purpose
provision
perhaps
motivated
facts
third
circuit
uptegrove
decision
seems
ensure
extended
statute
limitations
activated
business
overstatement
cost
goods
sold
important
work
unique
complexities
involved
calculating
inventory
costs
see
whittington
pany
principles
auditing
assurance
services
ed
audit
inventories
presents
auditors
significant
risk
often
represent
substantial
portion
current
assets
numerous
valuation
methods
used
inventories
valuation
inventories
directly
affects
cost
goods
sold
determination
inventory
quality
condition
value
inherently
complex
see
also
internal
revenue
service
publication
accounting
periods
methods
rev
mar
discussing
methods
identifying
cost
items
inventory
congress
sought
fit
make
clear
errors
kinds
calculations
extend
limitations
period
colony
might
classified
special
business
inventory
case
unlike
taxpayers
taxpayer
colony
claimed
business
income
sale
goods
though
goods
held
sale
real
estate
lots
see
intermountain
ins
serv
vail
commissioner
cadc
tatel
colony
described
taxpayer
trade
business
income
sale
goods
services
falling
within
clause
scope
subsection
applied
turn
observed
construction
statute
favor
taxpayer
harmony
unambiguous
language
newly
enacted
clause
new
provision
noted
ensured
extended
limitations
period
cover
overstated
costs
goods
sold
revised
statute
special
treatment
costs
suggests
overstatements
basis
cases
effect
extending
limitations
period
also
significant
statute
continued
address
omission
substantial
amount
included
gross
income
round
revisions
tax
code
congress
established
extended
limitations
period
certain
cases
items
omitted
estate
gift
tax
return
least
evidence
term
used
time
mak
clear
extended
limitations
period
apply
merely
differences
taxpayer
government
valuation
property
staff
joint
committee
internal
revenue
taxation
summary
new
provisions
internal
revenue
code
comm
print
congress
decision
use
term
items
achieve
result
reenacted
statutory
provision
issue
presumed
purposeful
see
russello
consideration
casts
doubt
premise
new
version
statute
supp
iv
necessarily
meaning
predecessor
ii
instant
case
concludes
statutory
changes
fragile
bear
significant
argumentative
weight
government
seeks
place
upon
ante
context
changes
meaningful
colony
made
clear
text
earlier
version
statute
described
unambiguous
ultimately
concluded
overstatement
basis
omission
gross
income
see
statutory
revisions
considered
colony
may
compel
opposite
conclusion
new
statute
strongly
favor
result
room
treasury
department
interpret
new
provision
manner
see
chevron
natural
resources
defense
council
earlier
case
unrelated
controversy
implicating
internal
revenue
code
held
judicial
construction
ambiguous
statute
foreclose
agency
later
inconsistent
interpretation
provision
national
cable
telecommunications
assn
brand
internet
services
judicial
precedent
holding
statute
unambiguously
forecloses
agency
interpretation
therefore
contains
gap
agency
fill
displaces
conflicting
agency
construction
general
rule
recognizes
filling
gaps
left
statute
involves
difficult
policy
choices
agencies
better
equipped
make
courts
opportunity
decide
whether
analysis
different
agency
sought
interpret
ambiguous
statute
way
inconsistent
earlier
reading
law
see
stevens
concurring
issues
implicated
colony
interpret
phrase
must
interpreted
case
language
predecessor
statute
however
congress
added
new
language
view
controls
analysis
instruct
reach
different
outcome
today
treasury
department
regulations
promulgated
light
statutory
revisions
issue
serious
difficulty
insisting
today
ambiguous
provision
must
continue
read
way
even
reenacted
additional
language
suggesting
congress
permit
different
interpretation
agencies
responsibility
expertise
necessary
administer
ongoing
regulatory
schemes
latitude
discretion
implement
interpretation
provisions
reenacted
new
statutory
framework
especially
new
language
enacted
congress
seems
favor
interpretation
issue
approach
taken
instead
forecloses
later
interpretations
law
changed
relevant
ways
cf
mead
scalia
dissenting
worst
majority
approach
lead
ossification
large
portions
statutory
law
chevron
applies
statutory
ambiguities
remain
subject
agency
ongoing
clarification
goes
far
respectful
view
constricting
congress
ability
leave
agencies
charge
filling
statutory
gaps
legal
system
presumes
continuing
dialogue
among
three
branches
government
questions
statutory
interpretation
application
see
blakely
washington
kennedy
dissenting
constant
constructive
discourse
courts
legislatures
integral
admirable
part
constitutional
design
mistretta
principle
separation
powers
anticipates
coordinate
branches
converse
matters
vital
common
interest
cases
congress
set
general
principle
administered
detail
agency
exercise
discretion
agency
may
proper
position
evaluate
best
means
implementing
statute
practical
application
agency
exceeds
authority
course
courts
must
invalidate
regulation
agency
interpretations
lead
unjust
unfair
consequences
corrected
much
like
disfavored
judicial
interpretations
congressional
action
instructive
foreclosed
insistence
adhering
earlier
interpretations
statute
even
light
new
relevant
statutory
amendments
courts
instead
open
agency
adoption
different
interpretation
congress
given
new
instruction
amended
statute
circumstances
treasury
department
authority
adopt
reasonable
interpretation
new
tax
provision
issue
see
mayo
foundation
medical
ed
research
slip
also
conclusion
reached
opinions
issued
several
cases
courts
appeals
intermountain
reaching
conclusion
colony
never
purported
interpret
new
provision
new
provision
gross
income
text
least
ambiguous
best
read
include
overstatements
basis
neither
section
structure
history
context
removes
ambiguity
department
clarification
ambiguous
statute
applicable
taxpayers
upset
legitimate
settled
expectations
given
statutory
changes
described
taxpayers
reason
question
whether
colony
holding
extended
revised
see
cc
western
operations
commissioner
whether
colony
main
holding
carries
section
least
doubtful
worked
change
law
instead
interpreted
statutory
provision
without
established
meaning
department
regulation
impermissible
retroactive
effect
cf
smiley
citibank
south
dakota
rejecting
retroactivity
argument
manhattan
equipment
commissioner
controls
case
reasons
respect
dissent
footnotes
step
never
essential
part
chevron
analysis
whether
particular
statute
ambiguous
makes
difference
interpretation
adopted
agency
clearly
reasonable
waste
time
conduct
inquiry
see
entergy
riverkeeper
true
agency
interpretation
clearly
beyond
scope
conceivable
ambiguity
matter
whether
word
yellow
ambiguous
agency
interpreted
mean
purple
see
stephenson
vermeule
chevron
one
step
rev
davis
administrative
law
treatise