marek
chesny
argued
december
decided
june
petitioner
police
officers
answering
call
domestic
disturbance
shot
killed
respondent
adult
son
respondent
behalf
administrator
son
estate
filed
suit
petitioners
federal
district
state
tort
law
prior
trial
petitioners
made
timely
offer
settlement
expressly
including
accrued
costs
attorney
fees
respondent
accept
offer
case
went
trial
respondent
awarded
claim
violation
punitive
damages
respondent
filed
request
attorney
fees
provides
prevailing
party
action
may
awarded
attorney
fees
part
costs
claimed
attorney
fees
included
fees
work
performed
subsequent
settlement
offer
district
declined
award
latter
fees
pursuant
federal
rule
civil
procedure
provides
timely
pretrial
offer
settlement
accepted
judgment
finally
obtained
offeree
favorable
offer
offeree
must
pay
costs
incurred
making
offer
appeals
reversed
held
petitioners
liable
attorney
fees
incurred
respondent
petitioners
offer
settlement
pp
petitioners
offer
valid
rule
rule
require
defendant
offer
itemize
respective
amounts
tendered
settlement
underlying
substantive
claim
costs
drafters
concern
much
particular
components
offers
judgments
allowed
defendants
whether
offer
recites
costs
included
specifies
amount
costs
offer
allowed
judgment
entered
defendant
damages
caused
challenged
conduct
costs
construction
rule
furthers
objective
encouraging
settlements
pp
view
rule
drafters
awareness
various
federal
statutes
exception
american
rule
authorize
award
attorney
fees
prevailing
parties
part
costs
particular
cases
reasonable
inference
term
costs
rule
intended
refer
costs
properly
awardable
relevant
substantive
statute
thus
underlying
statute
defines
costs
include
attorney
fees
fees
included
costs
purposes
rule
expressly
includes
attorney
fees
costs
available
prevailing
plaintiff
suit
fees
subject
provision
rule
rather
cutting
grain
applying
rule
context
action
consistent
policies
objectives
encouraging
plaintiffs
bring
meritorious
civil
rights
suits
rule
simply
encourages
settlements
pp
burger
delivered
opinion
white
powell
rehnquist
stevens
joined
powell
post
rehnquist
post
filed
concurring
opinions
brennan
filed
dissenting
opinion
marshall
blackmun
joined
post
donald
peterson
argued
cause
petitioners
brief
elizabeth
hubbard
jerrold
ganzfried
argued
cause
amicus
curiae
urging
reversal
brief
solicitor
general
lee
acting
assistant
attorney
general
willard
deputy
solicitor
general
geller
deputy
assistant
attorney
general
kuhl
katheryn
oberly
robert
greenspan
barbara
woodall
victor
stone
argued
cause
respondent
brief
james
montgomery
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
state
florida
jim
smith
attorney
general
mitchell
franks
linda
huber
bruce
minnick
assistant
attorneys
general
city
new
york
frederick
schwarz
leonard
koerner
ronald
sternberg
evelyn
jonas
john
woods
equal
employment
advisory
council
robert
williams
douglas
mcdowell
thomas
bagby
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
alliance
justice
laura
macklin
american
civil
liberties
union
et
al
roger
pascal
burt
neuborne
richard
larson
harvey
grossman
lawyers
committee
civil
rights
law
fred
fishman
robert
kapp
norman
redlich
william
robinson
norman
chachkin
harold
tyler
sara
lister
committee
federal
courts
association
bar
city
new
york
sheldon
elsen
michael
schwartz
sidney
rosdeitcher
edmund
kerr
john
koeltl
naacp
legal
defense
educational
fund
barry
goldstein
julius
levonne
chambers
charles
stephen
ralston
chief
justice
burger
delivered
opinion
granted
certiorari
decide
whether
attorney
fees
incurred
plaintiff
subsequent
offer
settlement
federal
rule
civil
procedure
must
paid
defendant
plaintiff
recovers
judgment
less
offer
petitioners
three
police
officers
answering
call
domestic
disturbance
shot
killed
respondent
adult
son
respondent
behalf
administrator
son
estate
filed
suit
officers
district
state
tort
law
prior
trial
petitioners
made
timely
offer
settlement
sum
including
costs
accrued
attorney
fees
one
hundred
thousand
dollars
respondent
accept
offer
case
went
trial
respondent
awarded
wrongful
death
claim
violation
punitive
damages
respondent
filed
request
costs
including
attorney
fees
amount
included
costs
incurred
settlement
offer
petitioners
opposed
claim
postoffer
costs
relying
federal
rule
civil
procedure
shifts
plaintiff
costs
incurred
subsequent
offer
judgment
exceeded
ultimate
recovery
trial
petitioners
argued
attorney
fees
part
costs
covered
rule
district
agreed
petitioners
declined
award
respondent
costs
including
attorney
fees
incurred
offer
judgment
supp
nd
parties
subsequently
agreed
fairly
represented
allowable
costs
including
attorney
fees
accrued
prior
petitioners
offer
settlement
respondent
appealed
denial
postoffer
costs
appeals
reversed
rejected
termed
rather
mechanical
linking
rule
section
stated
district
reading
rule
sense
logical
put
civil
rights
plaintiffs
counsel
predicament
cuts
grain
section
plaintiffs
attorneys
reasoned
forced
think
hard
rejecting
even
inadequate
offer
deterred
bringing
actions
prospect
losing
right
attorney
fees
settlement
offer
favorable
ultimate
recovery
rejected
concluded
legislators
enacted
section
wanted
effectiveness
blunted
little
known
rule
granted
certiorari
reverse
ii
rule
provides
timely
pretrial
offer
settlement
accepted
judgment
finally
obtained
offeree
favorable
offer
offeree
must
pay
costs
incurred
making
offer
emphasis
added
plain
purpose
rule
encourage
settlement
avoid
litigation
advisory
committee
note
rules
civil
procedure
report
proposed
amendments
delta
air
lines
august
rule
prompts
parties
suit
evaluate
risks
costs
litigation
balance
likelihood
success
upon
trial
merits
case
requires
us
decide
whether
offer
case
proper
one
rule
whether
term
costs
used
rule
includes
attorney
fees
awardable
first
question
address
whether
petitioners
offer
valid
rule
respondent
contends
offer
invalid
lumped
petitioners
proposal
damages
proposal
costs
respondent
argues
rule
requires
offer
must
separately
recite
amount
defendant
offering
settlement
substantive
claim
amount
offering
cover
accrued
costs
offer
bifurcated
contends
clear
much
defendant
offering
substantive
claim
plaintiff
possibly
assess
whether
wise
accept
offer
apparently
bases
argument
language
rule
providing
defendant
may
serve
upon
adverse
party
offer
allow
judgment
taken
money
property
effect
specified
offer
costs
accrued
emphasis
added
appeals
rejected
respondent
claim
holding
offer
money
property
specified
effect
force
rule
plus
costs
accrued
whatever
amount
costs
reject
respondent
argument
read
rule
require
defendant
offer
itemize
respective
amounts
tendered
settlement
underlying
substantive
claim
costs
critical
feature
portion
rule
offer
one
allows
judgment
taken
defendant
damages
caused
challenged
conduct
costs
accrued
words
drafters
concern
much
particular
components
offers
judgments
allowed
defendants
offer
recites
costs
included
specifies
amount
costs
plaintiff
accepts
offer
judgment
necessarily
include
costs
offer
state
costs
included
amount
costs
specified
obliged
terms
rule
include
judgment
additional
amount
discretion
see
delta
air
lines
august
supra
powell
concurring
determines
sufficient
cover
costs
either
case
however
offer
allowed
judgment
entered
defendant
damages
caused
challenged
conduct
costs
accordingly
immaterial
whether
offer
recites
costs
included
whether
specifies
amount
defendant
allowing
costs
matter
whether
refers
costs
long
offer
implicitly
explicitly
provide
judgment
include
costs
timely
offer
valid
construction
rule
best
furthers
objective
rule
encourage
settlements
defendants
allowed
make
offers
accepted
represent
total
liability
understandably
reluctant
make
settlement
offers
appeals
observed
many
defendant
unwilling
make
binding
settlement
offer
terms
left
exposed
liability
attorney
fees
whatever
amount
might
fix
motion
plaintiff
contrary
respondent
suggestion
reading
rule
way
frustrate
plaintiffs
efforts
determine
whether
defendants
offers
adequate
time
offer
made
plaintiff
knows
amount
damages
caused
challenged
conduct
plaintiff
also
knows
ascertain
costs
accrued
reasonable
determination
whether
accept
offer
made
simply
adding
two
figures
comparing
sum
amount
offered
respondent
troubled
plaintiff
know
whether
offer
substantive
claim
exceeded
trial
whenever
offer
settlement
made
event
requiring
itemization
damages
separate
costs
way
help
plaintiffs
know
advance
whether
judgment
trial
exceed
defendant
offer
curiously
respondent
also
maintains
petitioners
settlement
offer
exceed
judgment
obtained
respondent
regard
respondent
notes
offer
great
sum
damages
preoffer
costs
claimed
postoffer
costs
argument
assumes
however
postoffer
costs
included
comparison
appeals
correctly
recognized
postoffer
costs
merely
offset
part
expense
continuing
litigation
trial
included
calculus
second
question
address
whether
term
costs
rule
includes
attorney
fees
awardable
time
federal
rules
civil
procedure
adopted
federal
statutes
authorized
defined
awards
costs
prevailing
parties
years
see
act
stat
see
generally
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
unlike
england
costs
generally
included
attorney
fees
american
rule
party
required
bear
attorney
fees
american
rule
applied
federal
courts
however
become
subject
certain
exceptions
late
exceptions
evolved
product
inherent
power
courts
allow
attorney
fees
particular
situations
alyeska
supra
exceptions
found
federal
statutes
directed
courts
award
attorney
fees
part
costs
particular
cases
section
communications
act
example
provided
relevant
part
petitioner
shall
finally
prevail
shall
allowed
reasonable
attorney
fee
taxed
collected
part
costs
suit
identical
language
railway
labor
act
section
copyright
act
ed
allowed
award
prevailing
party
reasonable
attorney
fee
part
costs
statutes
contained
similar
provisions
included
attorney
fees
part
awardable
costs
see
clayton
act
ed
securities
act
ed
securities
exchange
act
authors
federal
rule
civil
procedure
fully
aware
exceptions
american
rule
advisory
committee
note
rule
contains
extensive
list
federal
statutes
allowed
costs
particular
cases
statutes
costs
set
forth
final
paragraph
note
fewer
allowed
attorney
fees
part
costs
background
varying
definitions
costs
drafters
rule
define
term
explanation
whatever
intended
meaning
history
rule
setting
given
importance
costs
rule
unlikely
omission
mere
oversight
contrary
reasonable
inference
term
costs
rule
intended
refer
costs
properly
awardable
relevant
substantive
statute
authority
words
costs
properly
awardable
action
considered
within
scope
rule
costs
thus
absent
congressional
expressions
contrary
underlying
statute
defines
costs
include
attorney
fees
satisfied
fees
included
costs
purposes
rule
see
fulps
springfield
waters
heublein
supp
nd
cal
scheriff
beck
supp
see
also
delta
air
lines
august
powell
concurring
respondent
sued
pursuant
civil
rights
attorney
fees
awards
act
stat
amended
prevailing
party
action
may
awarded
attorney
fees
part
costs
since
congress
expressly
included
attorney
fees
costs
available
plaintiff
suit
fees
subject
provision
rule
plain
meaning
interpretation
interplay
rule
construction
gives
meaning
word
rule
unlike
appeals
believe
plain
meaning
construction
statute
rule
frustrate
congress
objective
ensuring
civil
rights
plaintiffs
obtain
effective
access
judicial
process
hensley
eckerhart
quoting
merely
subjecting
civil
rights
plaintiffs
settlement
provision
rule
curtail
access
courts
significantly
deter
bringing
suit
application
rule
serve
disincentive
plaintiff
attorney
continue
litigation
defendant
makes
settlement
offer
evidence
however
congress
considering
thought
civil
rights
claims
different
footing
civil
claims
insofar
settlement
concerned
indeed
congress
made
clear
concern
civil
rights
plaintiffs
penalized
helping
lessen
docket
congestion
settling
cases
see
supra
moreover
rule
policy
encouraging
settlements
neutral
favoring
neither
plaintiffs
defendants
expresses
clear
policy
favoring
settlement
lawsuits
civil
rights
plaintiffs
along
plaintiffs
reject
offer
favorable
thereafter
recovered
trial
recover
attorney
fees
services
performed
offer
rejected
since
rule
neutral
many
civil
rights
plaintiffs
benefit
offers
settlement
encouraged
rule
plaintiffs
receive
compensation
settlement
trial
might
recovered
recovered
less
offered
even
prevail
trial
settlement
provide
compensation
earlier
date
without
burdens
stress
time
litigation
short
settlements
rather
litigation
serve
interests
plaintiffs
well
defendants
sure
application
rule
require
plaintiffs
think
hard
whether
continued
litigation
worthwhile
precisely
rule
contemplates
effect
rule
however
sense
inconsistent
congressional
policies
underlying
section
authorizes
courts
award
reasonable
attorney
fees
prevailing
parties
hensley
eckerhart
supra
held
critical
factor
determining
reasonable
fee
degree
success
obtained
specifically
noted
prevailing
trial
may
say
little
whether
expenditure
counsel
time
reasonable
relation
success
achieved
ibid
case
rejected
settlement
offer
exceeds
ultimate
recovery
plaintiff
although
technically
prevailing
party
received
monetary
benefits
postoffer
services
attorney
case
presents
good
example
postoffer
legal
services
resulted
recovery
less
petitioners
settlement
offer
given
congress
focus
success
achieved
persuaded
shifting
postoffer
costs
respondent
circumstances
sense
thwart
intent
rather
cutting
grain
appeals
held
convinced
applying
rule
context
action
consistent
policies
objectives
section
encourages
plaintiffs
bring
meritorious
civil
rights
suits
rule
simply
encourages
settlements
nothing
incompatible
two
objectives
iii
congress
course
well
aware
rule
enacted
included
attorney
fees
part
recoverable
costs
plain
language
rule
subjects
fees
provision
rule
nothing
revealed
review
policies
underlying
constitutes
necessary
clear
expression
congressional
intent
required
exempt
statute
operation
rule
califano
yamasaki
hold
petitioners
liable
costs
incurred
respondent
petitioners
offer
settlement
judgment
appeals
reversed
footnotes
respondent
suggests
roadway
express
piper
requires
different
result
roadway
express
however
relevant
decision
today
roadway
attorney
fees
sought
part
costs
allows
imposition
costs
penalty
attorneys
vexatiously
multiplying
litigation
held
roadway
express
came
statutory
definition
costs
definition
include
attorney
fees
critical
distinction
rule
come
definition
costs
rather
incorporates
definition
costs
otherwise
applies
case
justice
powell
concurring
delta
airlines
august
offer
rule
stated
amount
shall
include
attorney
fees
together
costs
accrued
date
brief
concurring
opinion
expressed
view
offer
comport
rule
requirements
seemed
offer
judgment
consist
two
identified
components
substantive
relief
proposed
ii
costs
including
reasonable
attorney
fee
amount
fee
ultimately
within
discretion
offer
accepted
questioning
form
offer
delta
influenced
part
fact
title
vii
case
concluded
costs
component
rule
offer
judgment
title
vii
case
must
include
reasonable
attorney
fees
accrued
date
offer
view
however
specificity
substantive
relief
component
offer
depend
solely
fact
delta
title
vii
case
justice
joined
delta
concurrence
decision
upon
different
ground
although
think
better
practice
offer
judgment
expressly
identify
components
important
clear
interpretation
rule
noted
delta
parties
litigation
public
whole
interest
often
overriding
one
settlement
rather
exhaustion
protracted
proceedings
ibid
purpose
rule
facilitat
early
resolution
marginal
suits
defendant
perceives
claim
without
merit
plaintiff
recognizes
speculative
nature
ibid
see
also
agreed
specifically
required
rule
accordingly
join
opinion
justice
rehnquist
concurring
delta
airlines
august
expressed
dissent
view
term
costs
rule
include
attorney
fees
examination
question
convinced
view
wrong
therefore
join
opinion
chief
justice
cf
mcgrath
kristensen
jackson
concurring
justice
brennan
justice
marshall
justice
blackmun
join
dissenting
question
presented
case
whether
term
costs
used
rule
federal
rules
civil
procedure
elsewhere
throughout
rules
refers
simply
taxable
costs
defined
traditionally
understood
costs
fees
printing
expenses
like
instead
includes
attorney
fees
underlying
statute
happens
refer
fees
part
awardable
costs
relying
recurrently
emphasizes
plain
language
one
statute
today
holds
prevailing
civil
rights
litigant
entitled
fees
statute
per
se
barred
rule
recovering
fees
work
performed
rejecting
settlement
offer
ultimately
recovers
less
proffered
amount
settlement
dissent
reasoning
wholly
inconsistent
history
structure
federal
rules
application
attorney
fees
statutes
enacted
congress
produce
absurd
variations
rule
operation
based
nothing
picayune
differences
statutory
phraseology
neither
congress
drafters
rules
possibly
intended
inexplicable
variations
settlement
incentives
moreover
interpretation
seriously
undermine
purposes
behind
attorney
fees
provisions
civil
rights
laws
delta
air
lines
august
rehnquist
dissenting
provisions
imposed
congress
pursuant
fourteenth
amendment
today
decision
therefore
violates
basic
limitations
rulemaking
authority
set
forth
rules
enabling
act
summarized
alyeska
pipeline
wilderness
society
finally
congress
judicial
conference
engaged
years
considering
possible
amendments
rule
bring
attorney
fees
within
operation
rule
process
strongly
suggests
rule
previously
viewed
governing
fee
awards
illustrates
wisdom
deferring
avenues
amending
rule
rather
engaging
standardless
judicial
lawmaking
delta
air
lines
august
supra
rehnquist
dissenting
plain
language
analysis
ante
goes
follows
section
provides
prevailing
party
may
recover
reasonable
attorney
fee
part
costs
rule
turn
provides
offeree
obtains
judgment
less
amount
previous
settlement
offer
offeree
must
pay
costs
incurred
making
offer
attorney
fees
costs
concludes
plain
meaning
rule
per
se
prohibits
prevailing
civil
rights
plaintiff
recovering
fees
incurred
rejected
proposed
settlement
ante
plain
language
approach
judge
posner
opinion
noted
sense
logical
however
starting
point
interpreting
statutes
rules
always
plain
words
particular
inquiry
abstract
force
words
may
comprehend
sense
intended
understood
understanding
convey
used
particular
act
previously
confronted
superficially
appealing
argument
strikingly
similar
adopted
today
found
survive
careful
consideration
roadway
express
piper
roadway
express
petitioner
argued
ed
time
allowed
imposition
excess
costs
attorney
unreasonably
vexatiously
delayed
proceedings
costs
interpreted
include
attorney
fees
underlying
statute
provided
fees
part
costs
rejected
argument
concluding
costs
used
meaning
limited
traditional
taxable
items
costs
set
forth
found
congress
consistently
sought
standardize
treatment
costs
federal
courts
make
uniform
make
law
explicit
definite
petitioner
interpretation
result
virtually
random
application
basis
laws
address
problem
controlling
abuses
judicial
processes
specifically
allowing
definition
costs
vary
depending
phraseology
underlying
statute
create
system
attorney
sanctions
roadway
view
lawyers
cases
brought
statutes
authorizing
fees
part
costs
face
stiffer
penalties
prolonging
litigation
attorneys
persuasive
justification
subjecting
lawyers
different
areas
practice
differing
sanctions
dilatory
conduct
processes
may
abused
commercial
case
civil
rights
action
without
express
indication
congressional
intent
must
hesitate
reach
imaginative
outcome
urged
roadway
particularly
plausible
construction
flows
viewing
costs
uniformly
limited
items
set
forth
number
reasons
costs
term
used
federal
rules
interpreted
uniformly
accordance
definition
costs
set
forth
first
limited
history
costs
provisions
federal
rules
suggests
drafters
intended
costs
mean
taxable
costs
traditionally
allowed
common
law
pursuant
statutory
predecessor
nowhere
suggested
meaning
taxable
costs
might
vary
case
case
depending
language
substantive
statute
involved
practice
cut
drafters
intent
create
uniform
procedures
applicable
every
action
federal
fed
rule
civ
proc
second
rules
provide
costs
may
automatically
taxed
clerk
one
day
notice
fed
rule
civ
proc
strongly
suggesting
costs
intended
refer
routine
readily
determinable
charges
appropriately
left
clerk
single
day
notice
settlement
appropriate
attorney
fees
awardable
frequently
entail
lengthy
disputes
hearings
obviously
fall
within
category
third
particular
provisions
federal
rules
intended
encompass
attorney
fees
explicitly
eleven
different
provisions
rules
authorize
award
attorney
fees
expenses
particular
circumstances
demonstrating
drafters
knew
difference
intended
difference
costs
expenses
attorney
fees
fourth
exception
one
recent
appeals
opinion
two
recent
district
opinions
point
authority
suggesting
courts
attorneys
ever
viewed
provisions
rule
including
attorney
fees
yet
rule
effect
years
potentially
applied
numerous
fee
statutes
time
fact
defense
bar
develop
practice
seeking
shift
reduce
fees
rule
persuasive
evidence
trial
lawyers
interpreted
rule
accordance
definition
costs
delta
air
lines
august
fifth
previously
held
words
phrases
federal
rules
must
given
consistent
usage
read
pari
materia
reasoning
otherwise
attribute
schizophrenic
intent
drafters
applying
plain
language
approach
consistently
throughout
rules
however
produce
absurd
results
turn
statutes
like
heads
plainly
violate
restraints
imposed
judicial
rulemaking
rules
enabling
act
example
rule
provides
costs
shall
allowed
course
prevailing
party
unless
otherwise
directs
similarly
plain
language
rule
provides
plaintiff
covered
rule
must
pay
costs
incurred
making
offer
language
requiring
plaintiff
bear
postoffer
costs
defendant
postoffer
costs
costs
used
provisions
interpreted
include
attorney
fees
virtue
wording
losing
civil
rights
plaintiffs
required
plain
language
rule
pay
defendant
attorney
fees
prevailing
plaintiffs
falling
within
rule
required
bear
defendant
postoffer
attorney
fees
addressed
troubling
consequence
plain
language
approach
perhaps
acknowledged
reading
conflict
directly
allows
award
attorney
fees
prevailing
defendant
suit
vexatious
frivolous
brought
harass
embarrass
defendant
substantive
standard
set
forth
therefore
overrides
otherwise
plain
meaning
rules
precisely
point
ways
unless
engage
schizophrenic
construction
delta
air
lines
august
supra
word
costs
used
federal
rules
either
allow
inclusion
attorney
fees
word
costs
subsume
attorney
fees
alter
fundamentally
nature
attorney
fee
legislation
roadway
express
piper
avoid
extreme
result
still
interpreting
rule
include
fees
circumstances
however
select
ad
hoc
basis
features
read
rule
process
construction
constitute
nothing
short
standardless
judicial
lawmaking
ibid
sixth
federal
rules
drafters
intended
rule
uniform
consistent
application
proceedings
federal
see
supra
accordance
intent
rule
interpreted
provide
uniform
consistent
incentives
encourage
settlement
litigation
delta
air
lines
august
supra
yet
today
decision
lead
dramatically
different
settlement
incentives
depending
minor
variations
phraseology
underlying
statutes
distinctions
appear
nothing
short
irrational
plausible
explanation
congress
enacted
well
attorney
fees
statutes
many
appear
affected
today
decision
appendix
dissent
illustrates
congress
employed
variety
slightly
different
wordings
statutes
sometimes
referred
awarding
attorney
fees
part
costs
costs
including
attorney
fees
attorney
fees
litigation
costs
plain
language
approach
today
decision
rule
operate
include
potential
loss
otherwise
recoverable
attorney
fees
incentive
settlement
litigation
statutes
congress
frequently
referred
statutes
awarding
costs
reasonable
attorney
fee
costs
together
reasonable
attorney
fee
simply
attorney
fees
without
reference
costs
plain
language
analysis
rule
obviously
include
potential
loss
otherwise
recoverable
attorney
fees
settlement
incentive
litigation
statutes
refer
fees
costs
result
sanction
senseless
patchwork
fee
shifting
flies
face
fundamental
purpose
federal
rules
provision
uniform
consistent
procedure
federal
courts
construction
introduce
rule
distinctions
unrelated
goal
result
virtually
random
application
rule
roadway
express
piper
supra
example
two
consumer
safety
statutes
motor
vehicle
information
cost
savings
act
consumer
product
safety
act
enacted
congressional
session
similar
purpose
structure
authorize
promulgation
safety
standards
provide
private
rights
action
violations
requirements
authorize
awards
attorney
fees
motor
vehicle
act
however
authorizes
award
fees
costs
consumer
product
safety
act
authorizes
costs
including
fees
today
decision
successful
plaintiff
requirements
rule
otherwise
met
barred
recovering
otherwise
reasonable
attorney
fees
defective
toaster
consumer
product
safety
act
defective
bumper
motor
vehicle
act
yet
nothing
history
either
act
history
rule
supports
bizarre
differentiation
untenable
character
distinctions
illustrated
reference
various
civil
rights
laws
example
suits
involving
alleged
discrimination
housing
frequently
brought
fair
housing
act
suits
involving
alleged
gender
discrimination
often
brought
equal
pay
act
title
vii
civil
rights
act
yet
variations
wording
attorney
fee
provisions
statutes
today
decision
require
fees
excluded
rule
purposes
fair
housing
act
included
purposes
fees
excluded
purposes
equal
pay
act
included
purposes
title
vii
difficult
enough
apply
rule
numerous
cases
seeking
relief
fees
costs
fees
costs
statutes
importantly
absolutely
reason
believe
either
congress
drafters
rules
eager
induce
settlement
litigation
fair
housing
act
litigation
intended
sterner
settlement
incentives
title
vii
cases
equal
pay
act
cases
moreover
many
statutes
contain
several
provisions
governing
actions
arising
different
subsections
phraseology
provisions
sometimes
differs
slightly
section
section
simply
preposterous
think
congress
drafters
rules
intended
sanction
differing
applications
rule
depending
particular
subsection
inter
alia
privacy
act
home
owners
loan
act
outer
continental
shelf
lands
act
amendments
interstate
commerce
act
plaintiff
happened
invoke
sum
nothing
history
structure
rules
history
underlying
attorney
fee
statutes
justify
incomprehensible
distinctions
based
simply
fine
linguistic
variations
among
underlying
statutes
particularly
roadway
express
cost
provision
read
embodying
uniform
definition
derived
partners
congress
responsibility
carry
plain
language
constructions
point
producing
untenable
distinctions
unreasonable
results
american
tobacco
patterson
see
also
supra
justice
rehnquist
joined
chief
justice
justice
stewart
cogently
reasoned
delta
air
lines
august
dissenting
opinion
interpreting
rule
allow
system
attribute
woode
pervers
motives
congress
drafters
rules
persuasive
justification
exists
subjecting
plaintiffs
differing
penalties
failure
accept
rule
offer
persuasive
justification
offered
reading
rule
way
intent
rule
encourage
settlement
uniform
basis
ii
although
opinion
fails
discuss
problems
reviewed
devote
space
arguing
interpretation
rule
sense
inconsistent
congressional
policies
underlying
ante
goes
far
assert
interpretation
fits
smoothly
interpreted
hensley
eckerhart
ante
wrong
congress
instructed
attorney
fee
entitlement
governed
reasonableness
standard
today
always
recognized
standard
precludes
reliance
mechanical
rules
automatically
denying
portion
fees
acknowledging
mathematical
approach
es
provide
little
aid
determining
reasonable
fee
light
relevant
factors
although
starting
point
always
number
hours
reasonably
expended
litigation
end
inquiry
number
considerations
set
forth
legislative
history
may
lead
district
adjust
fee
upward
downward
emphasis
added
also
emphasized
district
necessarily
discretion
making
equitable
judgment
superior
understanding
litigation
section
reasonableness
standard
sum
acutely
sensitive
merits
action
antidiscrimination
policy
roadway
express
piper
rule
hand
sensitive
merits
action
antidiscrimination
policy
mechanical
per
se
provision
automatically
shifting
costs
incurred
offer
rejected
deprives
district
discretion
respect
matter
using
strongest
verb
type
known
english
language
must
delta
air
lines
august
supra
potential
conflict
rule
apparent
course
civil
rights
plaintiff
unreasonably
fails
accept
settlement
offer
thereafter
recovers
less
proffered
amount
settlement
barred
recovering
fees
unproductive
work
performed
wake
rejection
extent
plaintiff
success
crucial
factor
determining
proper
amount
award
attorney
fees
emphasis
added
hours
excessive
redundant
otherwise
unnecessary
must
excluded
calculus
extent
results
might
sometimes
either
reasonableness
inquiry
wooden
application
rule
allowed
seventh
circuit
remand
instant
case
stand
example
district
conducting
appropriate
inquiry
might
well
determined
much
even
respondent
postoffer
fees
unreasonably
incurred
therefore
properly
awardable
results
rule
always
congruent
mandates
careful
consideration
broad
range
factors
accords
appropriate
leeway
district
informed
discretion
contrary
protestations
clear
case
presents
good
example
smooth
interplay
rule
ante
never
evidentiary
consideration
reasonableness
unreasonableness
respondent
fee
request
clear
however
interpretation
rule
plaintiff
ultimately
recovers
slightly
less
proffered
amount
settlement
per
se
barred
recovering
trial
fees
even
otherwise
obtained
excellent
results
litigation
benefit
public
interest
hensley
eckerhart
supra
today
decision
necessarily
require
disallowance
fees
otherwise
passed
muster
reasonableness
standard
nothing
legislative
history
even
vaguely
suggesting
congress
intended
result
argues
however
interpretation
rule
neutral
favoring
neither
plaintiffs
defendants
ante
contention
also
plainly
wrong
judicial
conference
advisory
committee
federal
rules
civil
procedure
noted
twice
recent
years
rule
street
available
defending
claims
claimants
interpreting
rule
current
version
include
attorney
fees
lead
number
skewed
settlement
incentives
squarely
conflict
congress
intent
discuss
one
example
rule
allows
offer
made
time
complaint
filed
gives
plaintiff
days
accept
reject
decision
inevitably
encourage
defendants
know
violated
law
make
offers
immediately
suit
filed
plaintiffs
able
obtain
information
entitled
way
discovery
assess
strength
claims
reasonableness
offers
result
put
severe
pressure
plaintiffs
settle
basis
inadequate
information
order
avoid
risk
bearing
fees
even
reasonable
discovery
might
reveal
defendants
subject
far
greater
liability
indeed
rule
offers
may
made
recurrently
without
limitation
defendants
well
advised
make
larger
offers
throughout
discovery
process
plaintiffs
conducted
reasonably
necessary
discovery
sort
incentive
fundamentally
incompatible
congress
goals
congress
intended
private
citizens
able
assert
civil
rights
violate
nation
fundamental
laws
able
proceed
impunity
accordingly
civil
rights
plaintiffs
appear
cloaked
mantle
public
interest
promote
vigorous
enforcement
modern
civil
rights
legislation
congress
directed
private
attorneys
general
shall
deterred
bringing
good
faith
actions
vindicate
fundamental
rights
involved
yet
requiring
plaintiffs
make
wholly
uniformed
decisions
settlement
offers
risk
automatically
losing
postoffer
fees
matter
circumstances
notwithstanding
excellent
results
might
achieve
full
picture
emerges
work
deterrent
effect
difficulties
follow
decision
example
plaintiff
recovers
less
money
offered
trial
obtains
potentially
injunctive
declaratory
relief
altogether
unclear
intends
judges
go
quantifying
value
plaintiff
success
decision
raises
additional
problems
concerning
representation
conflicts
interest
context
civil
rights
class
actions
difficult
policy
questions
mean
suggest
stronger
settlement
incentives
necessarily
conflict
effective
enforcement
civil
rights
laws
contrary
discussion
policy
considerations
point
one
direction
question
whether
extent
attorney
fees
included
within
rule
provoked
sharp
debate
congress
advisory
committee
federal
rules
among
commentators
offered
interesting
arguments
based
economic
analysis
settlement
incentives
aggregate
results
ante
believe
judge
posner
better
argument
concluding
incentives
created
interpreting
rule
current
form
include
attorney
fees
cu
grain
section
event
modification
rule
encompass
fees
congress
courts
indeed
judgment
appeals
turned
determination
interpretation
rule
include
attorney
fees
beyond
pale
judiciary
rulemaking
authority
ibid
congress
delegated
authority
prescribe
general
rules
practice
procedure
district
courts
courts
appeals
civil
actions
grant
limited
however
condition
uch
rules
shall
abridge
enlarge
modify
substantive
right
ibid
right
attorney
fees
substantive
reasonable
definition
term
section
enacted
pursuant
fourteenth
amendment
house
senate
reports
recurrently
emphasized
fee
awards
integral
part
remedies
necessary
obtain
compliance
civil
rights
laws
redress
violations
statutory
attorney
fees
remedies
set
forth
far
like
new
causes
action
tied
specific
rights
like
background
procedural
rules
governing
litigation
hensley
eckerhart
brennan
concurring
part
dissenting
part
see
also
make
litigation
process
accurate
efficient
parties
even
clearly
statute
limitations
issue
ragan
merchants
transfer
warehouse
designed
instead
achieve
substantive
objective
compliance
civil
rights
laws
construed
today
rule
surely
operate
abridge
modify
statutory
right
reasonable
attorney
fees
test
must
whether
rule
really
regulates
procedure
judicial
process
enforcing
rights
duties
recognized
substantive
law
justly
administering
remedy
redress
disregard
infraction
instead
operates
abridge
substantive
right
guise
regulating
procedure
sibbach
wilson
emphasis
added
see
also
hanna
plumer
unlike
provisions
federal
rules
explicitly
authorize
award
attorney
fees
rule
addressed
unreasonable
litigation
conduct
courts
always
inherent
authority
assess
fees
parties
act
bad
faith
vexatiously
wantonly
oppressive
reasons
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
assessment
fees
parties
whose
unreasonable
conduct
violated
rules
litigation
falls
comfortably
courts
authority
administer
remedy
redress
disregard
infraction
rules
sibbach
wilson
supra
rule
hand
contains
reasonableness
component
see
supra
interpreted
operate
divest
prevailing
plaintiff
fees
otherwise
might
entitled
reasonableness
standard
simply
guessed
wrong
information
reasonably
necessary
evaluate
offer
unforeseen
changes
law
evidence
offer
interpretation
rule
therefore
clearly
collides
congressionally
prescribed
substantive
standards
rules
enabling
act
requires
interpretation
give
way
addressed
central
issue
perhaps
reasoned
rule
interpreted
include
attorney
fees
merely
procedural
device
designed
important
policy
encouraging
efficient
prompt
resolution
disputes
respect
refashioning
settlement
incentives
squarely
foreclosed
decision
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
held
inappropriate
judiciary
without
legislative
guidance
reallocate
burdens
litigation
beyond
handful
limited
circumstances
encompass
today
decision
apparent
circumstances
attorney
fees
awarded
range
discretion
courts
making
awards
matters
congress
determine
emphasis
added
courts
free
fashion
drastic
new
rules
respect
allowance
disallowance
attorney
fees
permitting
mechanical
per
se
rule
supplant
congressionally
prescribed
reasonableness
standard
divesting
courts
discretion
congress
intended
exercise
assumed
forbidden
roving
authority
make
major
inroads
policy
matter
congress
reserved
matters
whether
roving
authority
exercised
basis
interpreting
federal
rule
promulgated
pursuant
congress
delegation
rulemaking
authority
either
event
result
abridge
modify
substance
guise
regulating
procedure
sibbach
wilson
supra
iii
several
years
judicial
conference
congress
engaged
extensive
reexamination
rule
considered
numerous
proposals
amend
rule
include
attorney
fees
advisory
committee
federal
rules
initially
proposed
amendment
rule
august
applied
equally
plaintiffs
defendants
left
application
rule
fee
provisions
informed
discretion
proposal
received
extensive
criticism
subsequently
replaced
revised
version
september
attorney
fee
provisions
proposal
apply
determined
offer
rejected
unreasonably
proposal
sets
forth
detailed
factors
assessing
reasonableness
rejection
public
hearings
proposed
amendment
held
several
months
ago
meantime
numerous
revisions
proposed
congress
recent
years
proposal
imposed
rule
similar
adopted
today
drew
sharp
opposition
legislative
hearings
never
voted
subcommittee
subsequent
proposals
effect
similar
fate
legislation
introduced
adopted
rule
subject
qualification
failure
accept
settlement
offer
reasonable
time
failure
occurred
hearings
held
legislation
never
voted
subcommittee
activity
relevant
two
respects
first
rather
strongly
suggests
neither
advisory
committee
congress
viewed
rule
currently
governing
attorney
fees
else
proposals
amend
rule
include
attorney
fees
largely
unnecessary
second
committee
congress
given
close
consideration
broad
range
troubling
issues
raised
application
rule
attorney
fees
whether
import
reasonableness
standard
rule
whether
extent
district
courts
discretion
applying
rule
need
revise
rule
ensure
offerees
sufficient
time
discovery
evaluate
strength
cases
reasonableness
settlement
offers
application
rule
suits
nonpecuniary
relief
application
rule
litigation
conflicts
interest
attorneys
clients
rule
might
create
precise
nature
scope
sanction
many
proposals
discussed
carefully
crafted
address
problems
see
nn
supra
congress
judicial
conference
far
institutionally
competent
resolve
matter
issue
us
least
ambiguous
plain
language
approach
leads
many
inexplicable
inconsistencies
operation
rules
substantive
statutes
stayed
hand
allowed
avenues
amending
rule
pursued
circumstances
decision
contrary
constitutes
poor
judicial
administration
well
poor
law
renders
even
imperative
need
congress
judicial
conference
resolve
problem
dispatch
appendix
opinion
brennan
dissenting
statutes
refer
attorney
fees
part
costs
variations
include
attorney
fees
taxed
collected
part
costs
costs
including
attorney
fees
attorney
fees
litigation
costs
plain
language
approach
various
formulations
defin
costs
include
attorney
fees
ante
thus
action
otherwise
governed
rule
attorney
fees
potentially
awardable
statutes
included
costs
purposes
rule
ibid
statutes
refer
attorney
fees
part
costs
many
fee
statutes
describe
fees
costs
instead
item
separate
costs
typical
formulations
include
costs
reasonable
attorney
fee
costs
together
reasonable
attorney
fee
costs
expenses
reasonable
attorney
fee
statutes
simply
authorize
awards
fees
without
reference
costs
plain
language
approach
none
formulations
defin
costs
include
attorney
fees
ibid
thus
action
otherwise
governed
rule
attorney
fees
potentially
awardable
statutes
subject
rule
instead
evaluated
solely
reasonableness
standard
summarized
hensley
eckerhart
statutes
may
may
refer
attorney
fees
part
costs
number
statutes
authorize
award
costs
expenses
including
attorney
fees
altogether
uncertain
statutes
categorized
plain
language
approach
rule
one
hand
phrase
including
attorney
fees
read
modifying
word
costs
least
part
attorney
fees
potentially
awardable
statutes
arguably
subject
rule
hand
including
attorney
fees
read
modifying
word
expenses
seems
plausible
plain
meaning
fees
statutes
subject
rule
instead
governed
solely
reasonableness
standard
summarized
hensley
eckerhart
supra
following
summary
statutes
enacted
congress
authorizing
courts
award
attorney
fees
broken
three
categories
discussed
explained
either
congress
drafters
federal
rules
might
intended
create
disparate
settlement
incentives
based
minor
variations
phraseology
attorney
fee
statutes
attorney
fees
referred
costs
privacy
act
government
sunshine
act
commodity
exchange
act
stat
amended
packers
stockyard
act
stat
amended
perishable
agricultural
commodities
act
stat
amended
agricultural
fair
practices
act
stat
home
owners
loan
act
stat
amended
bank
holding
company
act
amendments
stat
clayton
antitrust
act
stat
amended
antitrust
improvements
act
stat
amended
unfair
competition
act
stat
securities
act
stat
amended
trust
indenture
act
stat
securities
exchange
act
stat
amended
jewelers
act
stat
amended
consumer
product
safety
act
stat
amended
hobby
protection
act
stat
export
trading
company
act
stat
national
cooperative
research
act
stat
supp
iii
national
historic
preservation
act
amendments
stat
endangered
species
act
stat
amended
public
utility
regulatory
policies
act
stat
copyright
act
stat
semiconductor
chip
protection
act
stat
supp
iii
racketeer
influenced
corrupt
organizations
act
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
jury
system
improvement
act
rehabilitation
act
stat
surface
mining
control
reclamation
act
stat
deep
seabed
hard
mineral
resources
act
stat
federal
oil
gas
royalty
management
act
stat
federal
water
pollution
control
act
stat
marine
protection
research
sanctuaries
act
stat
deepwater
ports
act
stat
act
prevent
pollution
ships
stat
safe
drinking
water
act
stat
amended
ii
voting
rights
act
stat
amended
civil
rights
attorney
fees
awards
act
stat
civil
rights
institutionalized
persons
act
stat
title
ii
civil
rights
act
stat
title
iii
civil
rights
act
stat
title
vii
civil
rights
act
stat
privacy
protection
act
stat
noise
control
act
stat
comprehensive
older
americans
act
amendments
stat
energy
policy
conservation
act
stat
resource
conservation
recovery
act
stat
clean
air
act
stat
clean
air
act
amendments
stat
powerplant
industrial
fuel
use
act
stat
ocean
thermal
energy
conversion
act
stat
outer
continental
shelf
lands
act
amendments
stat
railway
labor
act
stat
amended
shipping
act
stat
amended
merchant
marine
act
stat
amended
shipping
act
stat
app
supp
iii
communications
act
stat
cable
communications
policy
act
stat
supp
iii
natural
gas
pipeline
safety
act
stat
amended
app
hazardous
liquid
pipeline
safety
act
stat
app
interstate
commerce
act
foreign
intelligence
surveillance
act
stat
attorney
fees
referred
costs
plant
variety
act
stat
bankruptcy
act
amended
home
owners
loan
act
stat
amended
national
housing
act
stat
amended
federal
credit
union
act
stat
amended
federal
deposit
insurance
act
stat
amended
real
estate
settlement
procedures
act
stat
amended
right
financial
privacy
act
stat
securities
exchange
act
stat
amended
trademark
act
stat
amended
national
traffic
motor
vehicle
safety
act
stat
act
stat
amended
consumer
leasing
act
stat
consumer
credit
protection
act
stat
consumer
credit
protection
act
stat
consumer
credit
protection
act
stat
electronic
fund
transfer
act
stat
interstate
land
sales
full
disclosure
act
stat
amended
motor
vehicle
information
cost
savings
act
stat
amended
toxic
substances
control
act
stat
petroleum
marketing
practices
act
stat
condominium
cooperative
abuse
relief
act
stat
alaska
national
interest
lands
conservation
act
stat
navajo
hopi
indian
relocation
amendments
act
stat
tax
reform
act
stat
judicial
code
equal
access
justice
act
act
stat
fair
labor
standards
act
stat
amended
reporting
disclosure
act
stat
age
discrimination
employment
act
stat
amended
employee
retirement
income
security
act
stat
amended
multiple
mineral
development
act
stat
state
local
fiscal
assistance
act
stat
amended
longshoremen
harbor
workers
compensation
act
stat
amended
patent
infringement
act
stat
servicemen
group
life
insurance
act
stat
social
security
act
stat
amended
atomic
energy
act
stat
legal
services
corporation
act
stat
amended
fair
housing
act
stat
mobile
home
construction
safety
standards
act
stat
amended
comprehensive
environmental
response
compensation
liability
act
stat
outer
continental
shelf
lands
act
amendments
stat
alaska
national
interest
lands
conservation
act
stat
act
mar
stat
interstate
commerce
act
household
goods
transportation
act
stat
amended
costs
expenses
including
attorney
fees
warranty
federal
trade
commission
improvement
act
stat
multiemployer
pension
plan
amendments
act
stat
federal
mine
safety
health
act
stat
stat
surface
mining
control
reclamation
act
stat
uniform
relocation
assistance
real
property
acquisition
policies
act
stat
nuclear
regulatory
commission
appropriations
authorization
stat
railroad
revitalization
regulatory
reform
act
stat
amended
rule
provides
time
days
trial
begins
party
defending
claim
may
serve
upon
adverse
party
offer
allow
judgment
taken
money
property
effect
specified
offer
costs
accrued
within
days
service
offer
adverse
party
serves
written
notice
offer
accepted
either
party
may
file
offer
notice
acceptance
together
proof
service
thereof
thereupon
clerk
shall
enter
judgment
offer
accepted
shall
deemed
withdrawn
evidence
thereof
admissible
except
proceeding
determine
costs
judgment
finally
obtained
offeree
favorable
offer
offeree
must
pay
costs
incurred
making
offer
fact
offer
made
accepted
preclude
subsequent
offer
liability
one
party
another
determined
verdict
order
judgment
amount
extent
liability
remains
determined
proceedings
party
adjudged
liable
may
make
offer
judgment
shall
effect
offer
made
trial
served
within
reasonable
time
less
days
prior
commencement
hearings
determine
amount
extent
liability
section
provides
judge
clerk
may
tax
costs
following
fees
clerk
marshal
fees
reporter
part
stenographic
transcript
necessarily
obtained
use
case
fees
disbursements
printing
witnesses
fees
exemplification
copies
papers
necessarily
obtained
use
case
docket
fees
section
title
compensation
appointed
experts
compensation
interpreters
salaries
fees
expenses
costs
special
interpretation
services
section
title
bill
costs
shall
filed
case
upon
allowance
included
judgment
decree
civil
rights
attorney
fees
awards
act
stat
amended
section
provides
relevant
part
action
proceeding
enforce
provision
sections
title
title
ix
public
law
title
vi
civil
rights
act
discretion
may
allow
prevailing
party
reasonable
attorney
fee
part
costs
see
pp
pp
sands
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
see
also
absolutely
literal
reading
statutory
provision
irreconcilably
war
clear
congressional
purpose
less
literal
construction
must
considered
lynch
overholser
decisions
repeatedly
warned
dangers
approach
statutory
construction
confines
bare
words
statute
literalness
may
strangle
meaning
brown
canon
favor
strict
construction
inexorable
command
override
common
sense
evident
statutory
purpose
require
magnified
emphasis
upon
single
ambiguous
word
order
give
meaning
contradictory
fair
import
whole
remaining
language
cf
harrison
northern
trust
words
inexact
tools
best
section
provided
attorney
multiplies
proceedings
case
increase
costs
unreasonably
vexatiously
may
required
satisfy
personally
excess
costs
section
amended
roadway
express
require
payment
excess
costs
expenses
attorneys
fees
reasonably
incurred
conduct
pub
stat
taken
logical
limit
argument
federal
rules
come
definition
costs
mean
courts
applying
rules
costs
provisions
altogether
ignore
defining
taxable
costs
surely
mean
endorse
result
proper
question
seems
instead
whether
sets
forth
definition
costs
purposes
applying
rules
whether
courts
may
pick
choose
among
statutes
adding
items
enumeration
set
forth
rule
modifies
general
provisions
set
forth
rule
see
delta
air
lines
august
infra
advisory
committee
notes
rule
emphasized
terms
statutory
predecessor
unaffected
rule
suggesting
drafters
intend
alter
uniform
definition
costs
set
forth
statute
moreover
drafters
cited
article
authority
present
rule
emphasized
fundamental
essential
common
law
doctrines
distinctions
costs
fees
distinction
costs
fees
carefully
borne
mind
payne
costs
common
law
actions
federal
courts
rev
emphasis
original
cited
article
continued
stating
statutory
predecessor
designed
reduce
expense
proceedings
federal
courts
secure
uniform
rules
throughout
intention
congress
establish
provisions
act
exclusive
law
costs
courts
seems
clear
declarations
interdictions
act
seem
object
substitute
provisions
secure
uniform
rules
emphasis
added
probably
provision
federal
rules
important
mandate
wright
miller
federal
practice
procedure
wright
miller
see
also
moore
federal
practice
ed
moore
major
argument
rule
drafted
already
disparity
phraseology
statutes
many
provisions
authorized
award
fees
costs
therefore
unlikely
drafters
intended
uniform
definition
costs
ante
set
forth
however
limited
history
strongly
indicates
drafters
intended
secure
uniform
rules
costs
uniform
definition
contained
statutory
predecessor
unaffected
rules
see
supra
page
moreover
application
interpretation
statutes
effect
led
inexplicable
variations
settlement
incentives
see
infra
variations
plausible
explanation
absence
indication
drafters
congress
intended
schizophrenic
application
rules
delta
air
lines
august
supra
reasonable
inference
ante
contrary
pronouncement
rule
intended
conform
general
policy
uniformity
applying
rules
see
generally
derfner
wolf
awarded
attorney
fees
chs
chs
see
fed
rules
civ
proc
signing
pleadings
motions
papers
violation
rule
noncompliance
rules
respecting
pretrial
conferences
certification
discovery
requests
responses
objections
made
violation
rule
failure
party
giving
notice
deposition
attend
failure
party
giving
notice
deposition
serve
subpoena
witness
conduct
necessitating
motion
compel
discovery
failure
obey
discovery
orders
expenses
failure
admit
failure
party
attend
deposition
serve
answers
interrogatories
respond
request
inspection
failure
participate
good
faith
framing
discovery
plan
affidavits
made
bad
faith
ante
citing
fulps
springfield
waters
heublein
supp
nd
cal
scheriff
beck
supp
cases
contrary
see
dowdell
apopka
white
new
hampshire
dept
employment
security
rev
grounds
piguead
mclaren
association
retarded
citizens
olson
supp
nd
modified
greenwood
stevenson
ri
rule
provides
full
except
express
provision
therefor
made
either
statute
rules
costs
shall
allowed
course
prevailing
party
unless
otherwise
directs
costs
officers
agencies
shall
imposed
extent
permitted
law
costs
may
taxed
clerk
one
day
notice
motion
served
within
days
thereafter
action
clerk
may
reviewed
precisely
rule
applied
respect
ordinary
items
taxable
costs
see
generally
wright
miller
moore
hensley
eckerhart
see
also
hughes
rowe
per
curiam
christiansburg
garment
eeoc
also
might
argued
defendant
may
recover
postoffer
attorney
fees
plain
language
rule
prevailing
party
within
meaning
made
clear
however
party
may
prevail
elements
litigation
others
see
hensley
eckerhart
supra
thus
plaintiff
prevail
purposes
preoffer
fees
defendant
viewed
prevailing
party
purposes
postoffer
fees
shifting
fees
defendant
circumstances
plainly
violate
reasons
set
forth
text
substantive
standards
must
therefore
override
otherwise
plain
language
approach
taken
congress
also
enacted
statutes
providing
award
costs
expenses
including
attorney
fees
see
infra
unclear
plain
language
provisions
interacts
rule
including
attorney
fees
read
referring
least
part
costs
fees
awards
statutes
subject
rule
including
attorney
fees
naturally
read
modifying
preceding
word
expenses
fees
awards
statutes
governed
rule
stat
amended
et
seq
stat
amended
et
seq
stat
costs
reasonable
attorney
fee
shall
awarded
stat
amended
costs
suit
including
reasonable
attorney
fees
stat
et
seq
section
provides
citizens
shall
right
every
state
territory
enjoyed
white
citizens
thereof
inherit
purchase
lease
sell
hold
convey
real
personal
property
see
generally
jones
alfred
mayer
stat
stat
amended
et
seq
stat
costs
reasonable
attorney
fees
emphasis
added
attorney
fee
awards
actions
governed
terms
see
supra
attorney
fee
awards
actions
equal
pay
act
governed
fee
provisions
fair
labor
standards
act
flsa
stat
amended
reasonable
attorney
fee
costs
action
emphasis
added
stat
reasonable
attorney
fee
part
costs
emphasis
added
noted
hensley
eckerhart
many
civil
rights
cases
involve
common
core
facts
based
related
legal
theories
make
difficult
apportion
attorney
fee
request
among
various
claims
lawsuit
viewed
series
discrete
claims
instead
district
focus
significance
overall
relief
obtained
plaintiff
relation
hours
reasonably
expended
litigation
ibid
offers
guidance
lower
courts
go
applying
hensley
standard
cases
rule
requires
conflicting
results
closely
related
claims
fact
senate
report
specifically
addressed
interplay
fair
housing
act
emphasized
congress
intent
abolish
anomalous
gaps
two
statutes
make
consistent
respect
attorney
fee
awards
respect
statutes
enacted
prior
relies
evidence
drafters
congress
intent
sanction
chameleonic
definition
costs
ante
inexplicable
scheme
result
example
flsa
stat
et
railway
labor
act
stat
et
designed
regulate
hours
wages
covered
employees
provide
private
causes
action
recovery
reasonable
attorney
fees
flsa
provides
fees
costs
stat
whereas
railway
labor
act
provides
fees
part
costs
stat
point
nothing
suggesting
congress
intended
similarly
situated
employees
subject
different
attorney
fee
standards
statutes
compare
privacy
act
reasonable
attorney
fees
litigation
costs
costs
action
together
reasonable
attorney
fees
compare
home
owners
loan
act
stat
amended
cost
suit
including
reasonable
attorney
fee
stat
amended
reasonable
expenses
attorneys
fees
compare
outer
continental
shelf
lands
act
amendments
stat
costs
litigation
including
reasonable
attorney
expert
witness
fees
stat
damages
including
reasonable
attorney
expert
witness
fees
costs
attorneys
fees
compare
interstate
commerce
act
attorney
fee
part
costs
reasonable
attorney
fee
addition
costs
majority
delta
air
lines
reach
issue
rule
application
attorney
fees
chief
justice
implicitly
justice
rehnquist
explicitly
today
repudiated
view
delta
air
lines
see
ante
ante
rehnquist
concurring
among
factors
congress
intended
courts
consider
time
labor
required
novelty
difficulty
questions
skill
requisite
perform
legal
service
properly
preclusion
employment
attorney
due
acceptance
case
customary
fee
whether
fee
fixed
contingent
time
limitations
imposed
client
circumstances
amount
involved
results
obtained
experience
reputation
ability
attorneys
undesirability
case
nature
length
professional
relationship
client
awards
cases
hensley
eckerhart
see
also
might
argued
rule
provisions
merely
serve
define
one
aspect
reasonableness
within
meaning
hensley
eckerhart
supra
argument
foreclosed
congress
rejection
per
se
mathematical
approach
es
end
inquiry
without
allowing
consideration
relevant
factors
indeed
plain
language
authorizes
inclusion
costs
attorney
fees
determined
reasonable
see
supra
provisions
rule
necessarily
come
play
respect
reasonable
attorney
fees
given
congress
enumerated
factors
consider
applying
reasonableness
standard
see
nn
supra
given
per
se
provisions
rule
nowhere
mentioned
legislative
history
basis
believe
congress
intended
modify
reasonableness
standard
context
settlement
offers
moreover
previously
noted
congress
use
word
costs
one
purpose
one
purpose
permit
award
attorney
fees
state
notwithstanding
eleventh
amendment
see
hutto
finney
advisory
committee
note
proposed
amendment
rule
advisory
committee
note
proposed
amendment
rule
emphasis
added
see
generally
northcross
memphis
board
education
per
curiam
newman
piggie
park
enterprises
per
curiam
hensley
eckerhart
judicial
conference
advisory
committee
federal
rules
emphasized
unfairness
forcing
party
make
decision
enough
discovery
appraise
strengths
weaknesses
claim
defense
thus
proposed
extension
rule
attorney
fees
connection
measures
ensure
offeree
information
entitled
way
discovery
rules
appraise
fairness
offer
advisory
committee
note
proposed
amendment
rule
example
plaintiff
unable
prove
actual
damages
trial
recovers
nominal
damages
nevertheless
demonstrates
unconstitutionality
challenged
practice
obtains
injunction
surely
prevailing
party
within
meaning
plaintiff
earlier
rejected
offer
get
rid
controversy
damages
portion
suit
fall
within
rule
interpreted
today
decision
yet
previously
emphasized
plaintiff
failed
recover
damages
obtained
injunctive
relief
vice
versa
may
recover
fee
award
based
hours
reasonably
expended
relief
obtained
justified
expenditure
attorney
time
hensley
eckerhart
supra
see
also
brennan
concurring
part
dissenting
part
civil
rights
remedies
often
benefit
large
number
persons
many
involved
litigation
making
difficult
evaluate
particular
lawsuit
really
worth
stand
gain
spread
costs
obtaining
relief
among
problem
compounded
fac
monetary
damages
often
important
part
recovery
sought
statutes
enumerated
although
courts
must
therefore
evaluate
value
nonpecuniary
relief
deciding
whether
judgment
favorable
offer
within
meaning
rule
uncertainty
making
assessments
surely
add
pressures
plaintiff
settle
suit
even
abandons
opportunity
obtain
potentially
nonmonetary
relief
discouraging
incentive
entirely
odds
congress
intent
see
course
difficulties
assessing
value
nonpecuniary
relief
inherent
rule
operation
whether
rule
applies
attorney
fees
rule
interpreted
simply
affecting
several
hundred
several
thousand
dollars
traditionally
taxable
costs
inherent
problems
little
practical
significance
rule
applies
situations
vital
question
attorney
fees
problems
assume
major
significance
like
question
injunctive
relief
see
supra
problems
inherent
rule
inconsequential
long
operation
rule
limited
taxable
costs
defined
rule
extended
many
attorney
fee
provisions
difficulties
expected
create
substantial
problems
administering
class
actions
uits
alleging
racial
ethnic
discrimination
often
nature
class
suits
involving
classwide
wrongs
general
telephone
falcon
rule
makes
distinctions
individual
class
actions
yet
advisory
committee
recently
cautioned
context
offeree
rejection
burden
named
risk
exposure
heavy
liability
costs
expenses
recouped
unnamed
class
members
lead
conflict
interest
named
representatives
members
class
advisory
committee
note
proposed
amendment
rule
moreover
rule
requires
approval
class
action
compromised
rule
protects
class
members
unjust
unfair
settlements
affecting
rights
representatives
lose
interest
able
secure
satisfaction
individual
claims
compromise
moreland
rucker
pharmacal
wd
la
yet
rule
mesh
careful
supervision
plain
language
requires
simply
upon
plaintiff
acceptance
clerk
shall
enter
judgment
addition
rule
sets
nondiscretionary
limit
plaintiff
power
acceptance
virtually
impossible
amount
time
many
cases
consider
likely
merits
complex
claims
relief
give
notice
class
members
secure
approval
addition
sources
cited
nn
infra
see
branham
offer
judgment
rule
response
chief
justice
john
marshall
rev
fiss
comment
settlements
yale
shavell
suit
settlement
trial
theoretical
analysis
alternative
methods
allocation
legal
costs
legal
studies
simon
rule
crossroads
relationship
offer
judgment
statutory
attorney
fees
cin
rev
notes
impact
proposed
rule
civil
rights
litigation
colum
rev
note
rule
new
tool
litigation
duke
offer
judgment
statutorily
authorized
attorney
fees
reconciliation
scope
purpose
rule
rev
offer
judgment
rule
employment
discrimination
actions
fundamental
incompatibility
golden
gate
rev
notes
proposed
amendment
federal
rule
civil
procedure
toughening
sanctions
iowa
rev
section
provides
relevant
part
shall
power
prescribe
general
rules
forms
process
writs
pleadings
motions
practice
procedure
district
courts
courts
appeals
civil
actions
including
admiralty
maritime
cases
appeals
therein
practice
procedure
proceedings
review
courts
appeals
decisions
tax
judicial
review
enforcement
orders
administrative
agencies
boards
commissions
officers
rules
shall
abridge
enlarge
modify
substantive
right
shall
preserve
right
trial
jury
common
law
declared
seventh
amendment
constitution
emphasis
added
see
also
maine
thiboutot
helpful
way
defining
substantive
rule
particularly
substantive
right
act
refers
right
granted
one
nonprocedural
reasons
purpose
purposes
fairness
efficiency
litigation
process
ely
irrepressible
myth
erie
harv
rev
exceptions
include
recovery
attorney
fees
common
fund
recovery
attorney
fees
opposing
party
acted
bad
faith
willful
disobedience
order
see
summit
valley
industries
carpenters
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
untenable
assert
congress
although
determined
prevent
courts
judicial
interpretation
mak
ing
major
inroads
policy
matter
congress
reserved
approve
identical
result
achieved
judicial
rulemaking
note
conflict
rule
civil
rights
attorneys
fee
statute
reinterpreting
rules
enabling
act
harv
rev
quoting
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
supra
proposed
rule
provided
time
days
trial
begins
party
may
serve
upon
adverse
party
offer
denominated
offer
rule
settle
claim
money
property
effect
specified
offer
enter
stipulation
dismissing
claim
allow
judgment
entered
accordingly
offer
shall
remain
open
days
unless
authorizes
earlier
withdrawal
offer
accepted
writing
within
days
shall
deemed
withdrawn
evidence
offer
admissible
except
proceeding
enforce
settlement
determine
costs
expenses
judgment
finally
entered
favorable
offeree
unaccepted
offer
remained
open
days
offeree
must
pay
costs
expenses
including
reasonable
attorneys
fees
incurred
offeror
making
offer
interest
date
offer
amount
money
claimant
offered
accept
extent
interest
otherwise
included
judgment
amount
expenses
interest
may
reduced
extent
expressly
found
statement
reasons
excessive
unjustified
circumstances
determining
whether
final
judgment
less
favorable
offeree
offer
costs
expenses
parties
shall
excluded
consideration
costs
expenses
interest
shall
awarded
offeror
found
made
offer
bad
faith
fact
offer
made
accepted
preclude
subsequent
offer
liability
one
party
another
determined
verdict
order
judgment
amount
extent
liability
remains
determined
proceedings
party
may
make
offer
settlement
rule
shall
effective
period
time
days
authorized
rule
shall
apply
class
derivative
actions
rules
committee
rules
practice
procedure
judicial
conference
preliminary
draft
proposed
amendment
federal
rules
civil
procedure
reprinted
see
generally
proposed
amendments
federal
rules
civil
procedure
hearings
advisory
committee
civil
rules
judicial
conference
washington
proposed
amendments
federal
rules
civil
procedure
hearings
advisory
committee
federal
rules
civil
procedure
judicial
conference
los
angeles
revised
proposed
rule
provides
time
days
service
summons
complaint
party
less
days
days
trial
either
party
may
serve
upon
party
shall
file
written
offer
denominated
offer
rule
settle
claim
money
property
relief
specified
offer
enter
stipulation
dismissing
claim
allow
judgment
entered
accordingly
offer
shall
remain
open
days
unless
sooner
withdrawn
writing
served
offeree
prior
acceptance
offeree
offer
remains
open
may
accepted
rejected
writing
offeree
offer
neither
withdrawn
accepted
within
days
shall
deemed
rejected
fact
offer
made
accepted
preclude
subsequent
offer
evidence
offer
admissible
except
proceedings
enforce
settlement
determine
sanctions
rule
upon
motion
offeror
within
days
entry
judgment
determines
offer
rejected
unreasonably
resulting
unnecessary
delay
needless
increase
cost
litigation
may
impose
appropriate
sanction
upon
offeree
making
determination
shall
consider
relevant
circumstances
time
rejection
including
apparent
merit
lack
merit
claim
subject
offer
closeness
questions
fact
law
issue
whether
offeror
unreasonably
refused
furnish
information
necessary
evaluate
reasonableness
offer
whether
suit
nature
test
case
presenting
questions
importance
affecting
relief
might
reasonably
expected
claimant
prevail
amount
additional
delay
cost
expense
offeror
reasonably
expected
incur
litigation
prolonged
determining
amount
sanction
imposed
rule
also
shall
take
account
extent
delay
amount
parties
costs
expenses
including
reasonable
attorney
fees
incurred
offeror
result
offeree
rejection
interest
earned
prevailing
rates
amount
claimant
offered
accept
extent
interest
otherwise
included
judgment
burden
sanction
offeree
rule
shall
apply
class
derivative
actions
rules
committee
rules
practice
procedure
judicial
conference
preliminary
draft
proposed
amendments
federal
rules
civil
procedure
reprinted
see
generally
proposed
amendments
federal
rules
civil
procedure
hearings
standing
committee
rules
practice
procedure
advisory
committees
civil
criminal
rules
judicial
conference
washington
proposed
amendments
federal
rules
civil
procedure
hearings
standing
committee
rules
practice
procedure
advisory
committees
civil
criminal
rules
judicial
conference
san
francisco
subcommittee
hearings
senator
hatch
submitted
proposed
amendment
sess
provided
fee
shall
awarded
compensation
part
litigation
subsequent
declined
offer
settlement
offer
substantially
favorable
prevailing
party
relief
ultimately
awarded
attorney
fees
awards
hearings
subcommittee
constitution
senate
committee
judiciary
see
see
also
municipal
liability
hearings
supra
see
sess
sess
sess
award
attorney
fees
related
expenses
subject
provisions
act
may
made
services
performed
subsequent
time
written
offer
settlement
made
party
offer
accepted
administrative
officer
finds
relief
finally
obtained
party
favorable
party
offer
settlement
failure
party
accept
offer
settlement
reasonable
time
failure
occurred
see
legal
fees
equity
act
hearings
constitution
senate
committee
judiciary
sess
list
purport
complete
enumeration
statutes
authorizing
attorney
fees
moreover
suggest
statutes
necessarily
governed
rule
provisions