miller
superintendent
pendleton
correctional
facility
et
al
french
et
argued
april
decided
june
prison
inmates
pendleton
correctional
facility
brought
class
action
district
issued
injunction
remains
effect
remedy
violations
eighth
amendment
regarding
conditions
confinement
congress
subsequently
enacted
prison
litigation
reform
act
plra
relevant
sets
standard
entry
termination
prospective
relief
civil
actions
challenging
prison
conditions
specifically
provides
defendant
intervenor
may
move
terminate
prospective
relief
existing
injunction
meet
standard
provides
may
terminate
relief
makes
certain
findings
dictates
motion
terminate
relief
shall
operate
stay
relief
beginning
days
motion
filed
ending
rules
motion
petitioner
prison
officials
hereinafter
state
filed
motion
terminate
remedial
order
respondent
prisoners
moved
enjoin
operation
automatic
stay
arguing
violates
due
process
separation
powers
principles
district
enjoined
stay
state
appealed
intervened
defend
constitutionality
affirming
seventh
circuit
concluded
precluded
courts
exercising
equitable
powers
enjoin
stay
statute
construed
unconstitutional
separation
powers
grounds
held
congress
clearly
intended
make
operation
plra
automatic
stay
provision
mandatory
precluding
courts
exercising
equitable
power
enjoin
stay
government
contends
interpret
statute
displacing
courts
traditional
equitable
authority
preserve
status
quo
pending
resolution
merits
absent
clearest
command
contrary
reading
remove
equitable
power
raise
serious
separation
powers
questions
therefore
avoided
canon
constitutional
doubt
congress
made
intent
clear
must
give
effect
intent
sinclair
refining
atkinson
stay
automatic
state
defendant
filed
motion
command
shall
operate
stay
specified
time
period
indicates
mandatory
throughout
period
statute
plain
meaning
subverted
interpreted
merely
mechanism
prevent
courts
suspending
stay
viewing
automatic
stay
provision
context
whole
confirms
conclusion
section
provides
appeal
order
preventing
automatic
stay
operation
denial
motion
enjoin
stay
provision
nature
makes
sense
stay
required
operate
specific
time
period
attempt
district
circumvent
mandatory
stay
immediately
reviewable
mandamus
appropriate
remedy
granted
exercise
sound
discretion
given
curbing
courts
equitable
discretion
principal
objective
plra
odd
congress
left
enforcement
discretion
section
also
support
government
view
permits
stay
starting
point
delayed
days
affect
stay
operation
begins
construing
remove
courts
equitable
discretion
raises
constitutional
questions
canon
constitutional
doubt
permits
avoid
questions
saving
construction
plainly
contrary
congress
intent
pp
section
violate
separation
powers
principles
constitution
prohibits
one
branch
government
encroaching
central
prerogatives
another
article
iii
gives
federal
judiciary
power
merely
rule
cases
decide
subject
review
superior
article
iii
courts
plaut
spendthrift
farm
respondents
contend
violates
separation
powers
principle
legislatively
suspending
final
judgment
article
iii
violation
plaut
hayburn
case
dall
unlike
situation
hayburn
case
involve
direct
review
judicial
decision
legislative
executive
branch
involve
reopening
final
judgment
addressed
plaut
plaut
careful
distinguish
legislation
attempted
reopen
dismissal
money
damages
suit
altering
prospective
effect
injunctions
entered
article
iii
courts
prospective
relief
continuing
executory
decree
remains
subject
alteration
due
changes
underlying
law
cf
landgraf
usi
film
products
conclusion
follows
decision
pennsylvania
wheeling
belmont
bridge
wheeling
bridge
ii
prospective
relief
issued
pennsylvania
wheeling
belmont
bridge
wheeling
bridge
became
unenforceable
congress
altered
law
underlying
ongoing
relief
applied
wheeling
bridge
ii
principles
demonstrate
automatic
stay
unconstitutionally
suspend
reopen
article
iii
judgment
tell
judges
reflects
change
implemented
establishes
new
standards
prospective
relief
plaut
wheeling
bridge
ii
instruct
congress
changes
law
underlying
judgment
awarding
relief
relief
longer
enforceable
extent
inconsistent
new
law
although
remedial
injunction
final
judgment
purposes
appeal
last
word
judicial
department
subject
continuing
supervisory
jurisdiction
therefore
may
altered
according
subsequent
changes
law
reasons
violate
separation
powers
principle
articulated
klein
wall
found
unconstitutional
statute
purporting
prescribe
rules
decision
federal
judiciary
cases
pending
amend
legal
standard
help
respondents
read
context
whole
provision
prescribe
rule
decision
imposes
consequences
application
new
legal
standard
finally
congress
imposition
time
limit
offend
structural
concerns
underlying
separation
powers
whether
time
short
deprives
litigants
opportunity
heard
due
process
question
occasion
decide
whether
time
constraint
judicial
action
severe
implicated
structural
separation
powers
concerns
pp
reversed
remanded
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
scalia
kennedy
thomas
joined
souter
ginsburg
joined
parts
ii
souter
filed
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
ginsburg
joined
breyer
filed
dissenting
opinion
stevens
joined
charles
miller
superintendent
pendleton
correctional
facility
et
petitioners
richard
french
et
al
petitioner
richard
french
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
seventh
circuit
june
justice
delivered
opinion
prison
litigation
reform
act
plra
establishes
standards
entry
termination
prospective
relief
civil
actions
challenging
prison
conditions
stat
prospective
relief
existing
injunction
satisfy
standards
defendant
intervenor
entitled
immediate
termination
relief
supp
iv
plra
automatic
stay
provision
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
shall
operate
stay
relief
period
beginning
days
filing
motion
extendable
days
good
cause
ending
rules
motion
superintendent
pendleton
correctional
facility
currently
operating
ongoing
injunction
remedy
violations
eighth
amendment
regarding
conditions
confinement
filed
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
plra
respondent
prisoners
moved
enjoin
operation
automatic
stay
provision
arguing
unconstitutional
district
enjoined
stay
appeals
seventh
circuit
affirmed
must
decide
whether
district
may
enjoin
operation
plra
automatic
stay
provision
whether
provision
violates
separation
powers
principles
litigation
began
four
inmates
pendleton
correctional
facility
brought
class
action
rev
stat
behalf
persons
confined
facility
predecessors
office
petitioners
hereinafter
state
record
doc
trial
district
found
living
conditions
prison
violated
state
federal
law
including
eighth
amendment
prohibition
cruel
unusual
punishment
issued
injunction
correct
violations
french
owens
supp
sd
ind
aff
part
vacated
remanded
part
state
appeal
pending
decided
pennhurst
state
school
hospital
halderman
held
eleventh
amendment
deprives
federal
courts
jurisdiction
claims
injunctive
relief
state
officials
based
state
law
accordingly
appeals
seventh
circuit
remanded
action
district
reconsideration
remand
district
concluded
state
law
violations
also
ran
afoul
eighth
amendment
issued
amended
remedial
order
address
constitutional
violations
order
also
accounted
improvements
living
conditions
pendleton
facility
occurred
interim
ibid
appeals
affirmed
amended
remedial
order
aspects
governing
overcrowding
double
celling
use
mechanical
restraints
staffing
quality
food
medical
services
vacated
portions
pertaining
exercise
recreation
protective
custody
fire
occupational
safety
standards
ongoing
injunctive
relief
remained
effect
ever
since
last
modification
occurring
october
parties
resolved
joint
stipulation
remaining
issues
related
fire
occupational
safety
standards
record
doc
congress
enacted
plra
relevant
plra
establishes
standards
entry
termination
prospective
relief
civil
actions
challenging
conditions
prison
facilities
specifically
shall
grant
approve
prospective
relief
unless
finds
relief
narrowly
drawn
extends
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
least
intrusive
means
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
supp
iv
criteria
apply
existing
injunctions
defendant
intervenor
may
move
terminate
prospective
relief
meet
standard
see
particular
provides
civil
action
respect
prison
conditions
defendant
intervener
shall
entitled
immediate
termination
prospective
relief
relief
approved
granted
absence
finding
relief
narrowly
drawn
extends
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
least
intrusive
means
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
may
terminate
prospective
relief
however
makes
written
findings
based
record
prospective
relief
remains
necessary
correct
current
ongoing
violation
federal
right
extends
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
prospective
relief
narrowly
drawn
least
intrusive
means
necessary
correct
violation
plra
also
requires
courts
rule
promptly
motions
terminate
prospective
relief
mandamus
available
remedy
failure
finally
provision
issue
dictates
certain
circumstances
prospective
relief
shall
stayed
pending
resolution
motion
terminate
specifically
subsection
entitled
automatic
stay
motion
modify
terminate
prospective
relief
made
subsection
shall
operate
stay
period
beginning
day
motion
filed
case
motion
made
paragraph
subsection
ending
date
enters
final
order
ruling
motion
one
several
amendments
plra
congress
permitted
courts
postpone
entry
automatic
stay
days
good
cause
include
general
congestion
docket
stat
codified
june
state
filed
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
governing
conditions
confinement
pendleton
correctional
facility
record
doc
response
prisoner
class
moved
temporary
restraining
order
preliminary
injunction
enjoin
operation
automatic
stay
arguing
unconstitutional
violation
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
separation
powers
principles
district
granted
prisoners
motion
enjoining
automatic
stay
see
doc
see
also
french
duckworth
state
appealed
intervened
pursuant
defend
constitutionality
appeals
seventh
circuit
affirmed
district
order
concluding
although
precluded
courts
exercising
equitable
powers
enjoin
operation
automatic
stay
statute
construed
unconstitutional
separation
powers
grounds
see
reasoned
congress
drafted
unequivocal
terms
clearly
providing
motion
terminate
shall
operate
stay
specified
time
period
acknowledging
courts
lightly
assume
congress
meant
restrict
equitable
powers
federal
courts
appeals
found
impossible
read
language
anything
less
ibid
turning
constitutional
question
characterized
legislative
determination
specific
decree
federal
must
set
aside
least
period
time
concluded
directly
suspends
order
violation
separation
powers
doctrine
plaut
spendthrift
farm
mandates
particular
rule
decision
least
pendency
termination
motion
contrary
klein
wall
see
concluded
unconstitutional
separation
powers
grounds
appeals
reach
prisoners
due
process
claims
dissent
three
judges
denied
rehearing
en
banc
see
easterbrook
dissenting
denial
rehearing
en
banc
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
among
courts
appeals
whether
permits
federal
courts
exercise
traditional
equitable
authority
enjoin
operation
plra
automatic
stay
provision
review
appeals
judgment
construed
unconstitutional
compare
ruiz
johnson
holding
district
courts
retain
equitable
discretion
suspend
automatic
stay
therefore
constitutional
hadix
johnson
case
ii
address
statutory
question
first
state
prisoner
class
agree
majority
dissenting
judges
precludes
district
exercising
equitable
powers
enjoin
automatic
stay
government
argues
however
construed
leave
intact
federal
courts
traditional
equitable
discretion
stay
stay
invoking
two
canons
statutory
construction
first
government
contends
interpret
statute
displacing
courts
traditional
equitable
authority
preserve
status
quo
pending
resolution
merits
bsent
clearest
command
contrary
califano
yamasaki
second
government
asserts
reading
remove
equitable
power
raise
serious
separation
powers
questions
therefore
avoided
canon
constitutional
doubt
like
appeals
lightly
assume
congress
meant
restrict
equitable
powers
federal
courts
agree
constitutionally
doubtful
constructions
avoided
fairly
possible
communications
workers
beck
congress
made
intent
clear
must
give
effect
intent
sinclair
refining
atkinson
text
provides
ny
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
subsection
shall
operate
stay
fixed
period
time
days
motion
filed
enters
final
order
ruling
motion
supp
iv
emphasis
added
stay
automatic
state
defendant
filed
motion
statutory
command
motion
shall
operate
stay
specified
time
period
indicates
stay
mandatory
throughout
period
time
see
lexecon
milberg
weiss
bershad
hynes
lerach
mandatory
shall
normally
creates
obligation
impervious
judicial
discretion
nonetheless
government
contends
reading
statute
preserve
courts
traditional
equitable
powers
enter
appropriate
injunctive
relief
consistent
text
view
simply
mechanism
purpose
automatic
stay
provision
merely
relieve
defendants
burden
establishing
prerequisites
stay
eliminate
courts
discretion
deny
stay
even
prerequisites
established
based
public
interest
hardship
plaintiffs
thus
reading
nothing
prevents
courts
subsequently
suspending
automatic
stay
applying
traditional
standards
injunctive
relief
interpretation
however
subvert
plain
meaning
statute
making
mandatory
language
merely
permissive
section
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
shall
operate
stay
specified
time
period
days
filing
motion
rules
motion
emphasis
added
thus
statute
employ
mandatory
term
shall
also
specifies
points
operation
stay
begin
end
words
contrary
justice
breyer
suggestion
language
says
nothing
district
power
modify
suspend
operation
stay
post
dissenting
opinion
unequivocally
mandates
stay
shall
operate
specific
interval
allow
courts
exercise
equitable
discretion
prevent
stay
operating
statutorily
prescribed
period
contradict
plain
terms
mean
motion
terminate
merely
may
operate
stay
despite
statute
command
shall
effect
congress
intended
accomplish
nothing
relieve
state
defendants
burden
establishing
prerequisites
stay
language
best
awkward
indirect
means
achieve
result
viewing
automatic
stay
provision
context
whole
confirms
congress
intended
prohibit
federal
courts
exercising
equitable
authority
suspend
operation
automatic
stay
specific
appeal
provision
contained
ny
order
staying
suspending
delaying
barring
operation
automatic
stay
shall
appealable
pursuant
first
blush
provision
might
read
supporting
view
congress
expressly
recognized
possibility
district
exercise
equitable
discretion
enjoin
stay
two
courts
appeals
construed
preserving
federal
courts
equitable
powers
reached
conclusion
based
reading
see
ruiz
johnson
hadix
johnson
reasoned
congress
provided
expedited
review
orders
intended
district
courts
retain
power
enter
orders
first
place
see
ibid
words
congress
understood
cases
conscientious
district
acting
good
faith
perceive
equity
required
suspend
stay
congress
therefore
permitted
district
subject
appellate
review
ruiz
johnson
supra
critical
flaw
construction
however
provides
appeal
order
preventing
operation
automatic
stay
order
staying
suspending
delaying
barring
operation
automatic
stay
shall
appealable
rationale
provision
situations
equity
demands
automatic
stay
suspended
presumably
denial
motion
enjoin
stay
also
appealable
nature
appeal
provision
makes
sense
automatic
stay
required
operate
specific
time
period
attempt
district
circumvent
mandatory
stay
immediately
reviewable
government
contends
congress
goal
prevent
courts
circumventing
plra
plain
commands
mandamus
appropriate
remedy
appellate
review
proposition
doubtful
mandamus
extraordinary
remedy
granted
exercise
sound
discretion
whitehouse
illinois
central
given
curbing
equitable
discretion
district
courts
one
plra
principal
objectives
odd
congress
left
enforcement
discretion
instead
congress
sensibly
chose
make
available
immediate
appeal
resolve
situations
courts
mistakenly
believe
novel
scheme
created
plra
authority
enjoin
automatic
stay
rather
extraordinary
remedy
mandamus
requires
showing
clear
indisputable
right
issuance
writ
see
mallard
dist
southern
dist
iowa
event
originally
enacted
provide
interlocutory
review
courts
refused
enter
automatic
stay
appeals
fifth
circuit
review
refusal
congress
amended
provide
interlocutory
review
see
scott
ruiz
johnson
supra
see
also
supp
iv
finally
government
finds
support
view
provision
authorizes
extension
good
cause
starting
point
automatic
stay
days
motion
filed
days
motion
filed
government
explains
allowing
prevent
entry
stay
days
relatively
generous
good
cause
standard
congress
negative
implication
preserved
courts
discretion
suspend
stay
time
stringent
standard
injunctive
relief
sure
allowing
delay
entry
stay
days
based
good
cause
standard
necessarily
imply
reason
preventing
operation
stay
example
basis
traditional
equitable
principles
precluded
read
isolation
read
together
clear
district
enjoin
operation
automatic
stay
motion
shall
operate
stay
specific
time
period
section
adjusts
starting
point
stay
merely
permits
starting
point
delayed
period
passed
motion
shall
operate
stay
rules
motion
time
attempt
enjoin
stay
irreconcilable
plain
language
statute
thus
although
construe
statute
displace
courts
traditional
equitable
authority
absent
clearest
command
califano
yamasaki
convinced
congress
intent
remove
discretion
unmistakable
construction
raises
constitutional
questions
canon
constitutional
doubt
permits
us
avoid
questions
saving
construction
plainly
contrary
intent
congress
edward
debartolo
florida
gulf
coast
building
constr
trades
council
press
statutory
construction
point
disingenuous
evasion
even
avoid
constitutional
question
locke
quoting
george
moore
ice
cream
rose
see
also
pennsylvania
dept
corrections
yeskey
constitutional
doubt
canon
apply
statute
unambiguous
commodity
futures
trading
schor
constitutional
doubt
canon
give
prerogative
ignore
legislative
like
appeals
find
unambiguous
accordingly
adopt
justice
breyer
flexible
interpretation
statute
post
construction
preserved
courts
equitable
discretion
enjoin
automatic
stay
effectively
convert
plra
mandatory
stay
discretionary
one
plainly
contrary
congress
intent
enacting
stay
provision
must
confront
constitutional
issue
iii
constitution
enumerates
separates
powers
three
branches
government
articles
ii
iii
structure
constitution
exemplifies
concept
separation
powers
ins
chadha
boundaries
three
branches
hermetically
sealed
see
constitution
prohibits
one
branch
encroaching
central
prerogatives
another
see
loving
buckley
valeo
per
curiam
powers
judicial
branch
set
forth
article
iii
judicial
power
shall
vested
one
inferior
courts
congress
may
time
time
ordain
establish
provides
federal
courts
shall
staffed
judges
hold
office
good
behavior
whose
compensation
shall
diminished
tenure
office
explained
plaut
spendthrift
farm
article
iii
gives
federal
judiciary
power
merely
rule
cases
decide
subject
review
superior
courts
article
iii
hierarchy
respondent
prisoners
contend
encroaches
central
prerogatives
judiciary
thereby
violates
separation
powers
doctrine
prisoners
assert
legislatively
suspending
final
judgment
article
iii
violation
plaut
hayburn
case
dall
according
prisoners
remedial
order
governing
living
conditions
pendleton
correctional
facility
final
judgment
article
iii
constitutes
impermissible
usurpation
judicial
power
commands
district
suspend
prospective
relief
order
albeit
temporarily
analysis
principles
underlying
hayburn
case
plaut
well
examination
interaction
provisions
makes
clear
offend
separation
powers
principles
hayburn
case
arose
statute
authorized
pensions
veterans
revolutionary
war
see
act
mar
ch
stat
statute
provided
circuit
courts
review
applications
determine
appropriate
amount
pension
secretary
war
discretion
either
adopt
reject
courts
findings
hayburn
case
supra
although
reach
constitutional
issue
hayburn
case
opinions
five
justices
sitting
circuit
courts
reported
since
recognized
case
stands
principle
congress
vest
review
decisions
article
iii
courts
officials
executive
branch
plaut
supra
see
also
morrison
olson
recognized
plaut
effort
coequal
branch
annul
final
judgment
assumption
judicial
power
therefore
forbidden
quoting
bates
kimball
chipman
unlike
situation
hayburn
case
involve
direct
review
judicial
decision
officials
legislative
executive
branches
nonetheless
prisoners
suggest
falls
within
hayburn
prohibition
indirect
legislative
suspension
reopening
final
judgment
addressed
plaut
see
plaut
supra
quoting
hayburn
case
supra
opinion
iredell
sitgreaves
decision
circumstances
liable
revision
even
suspension
egislature
judicial
power
kind
appears
plaut
held
federal
statute
required
federal
courts
reopen
final
judgments
entered
statute
enactment
unconstitutional
separation
powers
grounds
suits
must
commenced
within
one
year
discovery
facts
constituting
violation
within
three
years
violation
light
intervening
decision
plaut
plaintiffs
suit
untimely
district
accordingly
dismissed
action
time
barred
plaut
supra
judgment
dismissing
case
become
final
congress
enacted
statute
providing
reinstatement
actions
including
plaut
plaintiffs
dismissed
lampf
timely
previously
applicable
statute
limitations
concluded
retroactive
command
federal
courts
reopen
final
judgments
exceeded
congress
authority
decision
inferior
within
article
iii
hierarchy
final
word
department
unless
time
appeal
expired
obligation
last
hierarchy
rules
case
give
effect
congress
latest
enactment
even
effect
overturning
judgment
inferior
since
every
level
must
decide
according
existing
laws
quoting
schooner
peggy
cranch
judicial
decision
achieves
finality
becomes
last
word
judicial
department
article
iii
gives
federal
judiciary
power
merely
rule
cases
decide
subject
review
superior
courts
article
iii
hierarchy
judicial
power
one
render
dispositive
judgments
congress
retroactively
command
article
iii
courts
reopen
final
judgments
quoting
easterbrook
presidential
review
case
res
rev
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
plaut
however
careful
distinguish
situation
case
legislation
attempted
reopen
dismissal
suit
seeking
money
damages
legislation
altered
prospective
effect
injunctions
entered
article
iii
courts
intervening
statute
authorizes
affects
propriety
prospective
relief
application
new
provision
retroactive
conclusion
follows
decisions
pennsylvania
wheeling
belmont
bridge
wheeling
bridge
pennsylvania
wheeling
belmont
bridge
wheeling
bridge
ii
wheeling
bridge
held
bridge
across
ohio
river
low
unlawfully
obstruct
ed
navigation
ohio
ordered
bridge
raised
permanently
removed
shortly
thereafter
congress
enacted
legislation
declaring
bridge
lawful
structur
establishing
bridge
passage
mails
declaring
wheeling
belmont
bridge
company
authorized
maintain
bridge
site
elevation
wheeling
bridge
ii
bridge
destroyed
storm
pennsylvania
sued
enjoin
bridge
reconstruction
arguing
statute
legalizing
bridge
unconstitutional
effectively
annulled
decision
wheeling
bridge
rejected
argument
concluding
decree
wheeling
bridge
provided
ongoing
relief
directing
abatement
obstruction
enjoined
defendants
continuance
reconstruction
obstruction
intervening
statute
altered
underlying
law
bridge
longer
unlawful
obstruction
held
quite
plain
decree
enforced
wheeling
bridge
ii
explained
wheeling
bridge
awarded
money
damages
action
law
judgment
final
congress
later
action
affected
plaintiff
right
damages
see
decree
entered
wheeling
bridge
provided
prospective
relief
continuing
injunction
continuation
reconstruction
bridge
ongoing
validity
injunctive
relief
depended
whether
bridge
interferes
right
navigation
congress
altered
underlying
law
bridge
longer
unlawful
obstruction
injunction
maintenance
bridge
enforceable
see
applied
principles
wheeling
bridge
ii
demonstrate
automatic
stay
unconstitutionally
suspend
reopen
judgment
article
iii
section
tell
judges
easterbrook
dissenting
denial
rehearing
en
banc
instead
merely
reflects
change
implemented
heavy
lifting
statutory
scheme
establishing
new
standards
prospective
relief
see
berwanger
cottey
section
prohibits
continuation
prospective
relief
approved
granted
absence
finding
relief
narrowly
drawn
extends
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
least
intrusive
means
correct
violation
absence
findings
based
record
prospective
relief
remains
necessary
correct
current
ongoing
violation
federal
right
extends
necessary
correct
violation
federal
right
prospective
relief
narrowly
drawn
least
intrusive
means
necessary
correct
violation
accordingly
prospective
relief
existing
decree
granted
approved
absent
findings
prospective
relief
must
cease
see
unless
makes
findings
record
relief
remains
necessary
correct
ongoing
violation
narrowly
tailored
see
plra
automatic
stay
provision
assists
enforcement
requiring
stay
prospective
relief
due
change
underlying
standard
longer
enforceable
prospective
relief
supported
findings
specified
establishing
new
standards
enforcement
prospective
relief
congress
altered
relevant
underlying
law
plra
restricted
courts
authority
issue
enforce
prospective
relief
concerning
prison
conditions
requiring
relief
supported
findings
precisely
tailored
needed
remedy
violation
federal
right
see
benjamin
jacobson
en
banc
imprisoned
citizens
union
ridge
tyler
murphy
inmates
suffolk
county
jail
rouse
note
constitutionality
challenged
assume
without
deciding
new
standards
pronounces
effective
plaut
wheeling
bridge
ii
instruct
congress
changes
law
underlying
judgment
awarding
prospective
relief
relief
longer
enforceable
extent
inconsistent
new
law
although
remedial
injunction
final
judgment
purposes
appeal
last
word
judicial
department
plaut
prospective
relief
must
modified
later
turns
one
obligations
placed
upon
parties
become
impermissible
federal
law
ibid
see
also
railway
employees
wright
authority
alter
prospective
effect
injunction
reflect
change
circumstances
whether
law
fact
occurred
since
injunction
entered
lauf
shinner
applying
act
prohibition
district
entry
injunctive
relief
absence
findings
entry
automatic
stay
helps
implement
change
law
caused
prospective
relief
existing
decree
supported
findings
required
made
findings
required
prospective
relief
longer
enforceable
must
stayed
entry
stay
reopen
suspend
previous
judgment
divest
authority
decide
merits
termination
motion
rather
stay
merely
reflects
changed
legal
circumstances
prospective
relief
existing
decree
longer
enforceable
remains
unenforceable
unless
makes
findings
required
reasons
violate
separation
powers
principle
articulated
klein
wall
case
klein
executor
estate
confederate
sympathizer
sought
recover
value
property
seized
civil
war
statute
recoverable
klein
demonstrate
decedent
given
aid
comfort
rebellion
see
padelford
wall
held
presidential
pardon
satisfied
burden
proving
aid
comfort
given
klein
case
pending
congress
enacted
statute
providing
pardon
instead
taken
proof
pardoned
individual
fact
aided
enemy
claimant
offered
proof
pardon
must
dismiss
case
lack
jurisdiction
klein
concluded
statute
unconstitutional
purported
prescribe
rules
decision
judicial
department
government
cases
pending
prisoners
argue
congress
similarly
prescribed
rule
decision
period
time
district
makes
final
decision
merits
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
mandates
particular
outcome
termination
prospective
relief
noted
plaut
however
hatever
precise
scope
klein
later
decisions
made
clear
prohibition
take
hold
congress
amend
applicable
law
prisoners
concede
point
contend
amend
legal
standard
klein
still
applicable
explained
however
must
read
isolation
context
whole
section
operates
conjunction
new
standards
continuation
prospective
relief
new
standards
met
stay
shall
operate
unless
makes
findings
required
rather
prescribing
rule
decision
simply
imposes
consequences
application
new
legal
standard
finally
prisoners
assert
even
fall
within
recognized
prohibitions
hayburn
case
plaut
klein
still
offends
principles
separation
powers
places
deadline
judicial
decisionmaking
thereby
interfering
core
judicial
functions
congress
imposition
time
limit
however
offend
structural
concerns
underlying
constitution
separation
powers
example
plra
granted
courts
years
determine
whether
make
required
findings
certainly
plra
raise
apprehensions
congress
encroached
core
function
judiciary
decide
cases
controversies
properly
raines
respondents
concern
time
limit
must
relative
brevity
whether
time
short
deprives
litigants
meaningful
opportunity
heard
due
process
question
issue
us
leave
open
therefore
question
whether
time
limit
particularly
complex
case
may
implicate
due
process
concerns
contrast
due
process
principally
serves
protect
personal
rights
litigants
full
fair
hearing
separation
powers
principles
primarily
addressed
structural
concerns
protecting
role
independent
judiciary
within
constitutional
design
action
occasion
decide
whether
time
constraint
judicial
action
severe
implicated
structural
separation
powers
concerns
plra
deprive
courts
adjudicatory
role
merely
provides
new
legal
standard
relief
encourages
courts
apply
standard
promptly
plra
congress
clearly
intended
make
operation
automatic
stay
mandatory
precluding
courts
exercising
equitable
powers
enjoin
stay
conclude
provision
violate
separation
powers
principles
accordingly
judgment
appeals
seventh
circuit
reversed
action
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
charles
miller
superintendent
pendleton
correctional
facility
et
petitioners
richard
french
et
al
petitioner
richard
french
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
seventh
circuit
june
justice
breyer
justice
stevens
joins
dissenting
prison
litigation
reform
act
plra
says
party
intervener
may
move
terminate
prospective
relief
previously
granted
supp
iv
shall
terminate
modify
relief
unless
necessary
correct
current
ongoing
violation
federal
right
extends
necessary
correct
violation
least
intrusive
means
consider
related
procedural
provision
plra
says
ny
motion
modify
terminate
prospective
relief
shall
operate
stay
prospective
relief
period
beginning
later
day
filing
motion
ending
motion
decided
provision
means
approximately
following
suppose
district
entered
injunction
governing
present
future
prison
conditions
suppose
party
filed
motion
plra
asking
terminate
modify
injunction
district
days
decide
whether
grant
motion
days
injunction
terminate
automatically
regaining
life
extent
judge
eventually
decided
deny
plra
motion
majority
interprets
words
shall
operate
stay
mean
terms
example
injunction
must
become
ineffective
day
matter
solicitor
general
however
believes
view
adopted
majority
interpretation
rigid
calls
doubt
constitutionality
provision
argues
statute
silent
whether
district
modify
suspend
operation
automatic
stay
find
silence
sufficient
authority
create
exception
time
limit
circumstances
make
necessary
read
statute
neither
displace
courts
traditional
equitable
authority
raise
significant
constitutional
difficulties
see
califano
yamasaki
clearest
congressional
command
displaces
courts
traditional
equity
powers
edward
debartolo
florida
gulf
coast
building
constr
trades
council
construe
statute
avoid
constitutional
problems
less
construction
plainly
contrary
intent
congress
agree
solicitor
general
believe
adopt
reasonable
statute
ibid
quoting
hooper
california
stating
every
reasonable
construction
must
resorted
order
save
statute
outset
one
must
understand
flexible
interpretation
statute
might
needed
one
must
keep
mind
extreme
circumstances
least
prison
litigation
originally
sought
correct
complexity
resulting
judicial
decrees
potential
difficulties
arising
subsequent
need
review
decrees
order
make
certain
follow
congress
plra
directives
hypothetical
example
based
actual
circumstances
may
help
january
federal
district
made
factual
findings
describing
extremely
poor
indeed
barbaric
shocking
prison
conditions
commonwealth
puerto
rico
morales
feliciano
romero
barcelo
supp
pr
conditions
included
prisons
typically
operating
twice
number
prisoners
designed
hold
inmates
living
square
feet
space
feet
feet
inmates
without
medical
care
without
psychiatric
care
without
beds
without
mattresses
without
hot
water
without
soap
towels
toothbrushes
underwear
food
prepared
budget
per
day
tons
food
destroyed
rats
vermin
worms
spoilage
working
toilets
showers
urinals
flush
sinks
plumbing
systems
state
collapse
stench
omnipresent
exposed
wiring
fire
extinguisher
poor
ventilation
calabozos
dungeons
like
cages
bars
top
two
slits
steel
door
opening
onto
central
corridor
floors
covered
raw
sewage
contained
prisoners
severe
mental
illnesses
caged
like
wild
animals
sometimes
months
areas
prison
mentally
ill
inmates
kept
cells
naked
without
beds
without
mattresses
without
private
possessions
without
toilets
work
without
drinking
water
conditions
led
epidemics
communicable
diseases
untreated
mental
illness
suicides
murders
district
held
conditions
amounted
constitutionally
forbidden
cruel
unusual
punishment
entered
specific
orders
designed
produce
constitutionally
mandated
improvement
requiring
prison
system
example
screen
food
handlers
communicable
diseases
close
calabozos
move
mentally
ill
patients
hospitals
fix
broken
plumbing
provide
least
square
feet
feet
feet
living
space
prisoner
pervasiveness
seriousness
conditions
described
opinion
made
conditions
difficult
cure
quickly
next
decade
district
entered
orders
embodied
published
opinions
affecting
prison
institutions
orders
concerned
inter
alia
overcrowding
security
disciplinary
proceedings
prisoner
classification
rehabilitation
parole
drug
addiction
treatment
surprisingly
related
proceedings
involved
extensive
evidence
argument
consuming
thousands
pages
transcript
see
morales
feliciano
romero
barcelo
supp
pr
implementation
involved
services
two
monitors
two
assistants
special
master
along
way
documented
degree
administrative
chaos
prison
system
morales
feliciano
hernandez
colon
supp
pr
entered
findings
contempt
commonwealth
followed
assessment
collection
million
fines
see
morales
feliciano
hernandez
colon
supp
pr
prison
conditions
subsequently
improved
respects
morales
feliciano
rossello
gonzalez
supp
pr
express
opinion
whether
earlier
orders
still
needed
brief
summary
litigation
illustrate
potential
difficulties
involved
making
determination
continuing
necessity
required
plra
prison
litigation
complex
litigation
described
may
prove
difficult
district
reach
fair
accurate
decision
orders
remain
necessary
least
intrusive
means
available
prevent
correct
continuing
violation
federal
law
orders
needed
resolve
serious
constitutional
problems
may
still
needed
compliance
yet
assured
complex
interrelated
applicable
many
different
institutions
ninety
days
might
provide
sufficient
time
ascertain
views
several
different
parties
including
monitors
allow
present
evidence
permit
respond
arguments
evidence
others
least
possible
statute
majority
reads
sometimes
terminate
complex
system
orders
entered
period
years
familiar
local
problem
perhaps
reinstate
orders
later
termination
motion
decided
automatic
termination
leave
constitutionally
prohibited
conditions
unremedied
least
temporarily
alternatively
threat
termination
lead
district
abbreviate
proceedings
fairness
otherwise
demand
minimum
mandatory
automatic
stay
provide
recipe
uncertainty
complex
judicial
orders
long
governed
administration
particular
prison
systems
suddenly
turn
perhaps
selectively
back
read
statute
directly
interferes
exercise
traditional
equitable
authority
rendering
temporarily
ineffective
remedies
aimed
correcting
past
perhaps
ongoing
violations
constitution
interpretation
majority
concedes
might
give
rise
serious
constitutional
problems
ante
ii
solicitor
general
flexible
reading
statute
avoids
problems
notes
relevant
language
says
motion
modify
terminate
prospective
relief
shall
operate
stay
period
days
extendable
good
cause
days
see
also
brief
language
says
nothing
however
district
power
modify
suspend
operation
stay
solicitor
general
view
stay
determine
legal
status
quo
district
retain
traditional
equitable
power
change
status
quo
party
seeking
modification
suspension
operation
stay
demonstrates
stay
cause
irreparable
injury
termination
motion
likely
defeated
merits
motion
resolved
automatic
stay
takes
effect
ibid
shown
discretion
suspend
automatic
stay
require
prison
officials
comply
outstanding
orders
resolves
termination
motion
merits
subject
immediate
appellate
review
interpretation
reasonable
construction
statute
edward
debartolo
party
demonstrates
need
accordance
traditional
equitable
criteria
irreparable
injury
likelihood
success
merits
balancing
possible
harms
parties
public
see
doran
salem
inn
yakus
logical
inconsistency
saying
motion
terminate
shall
operate
stay
retains
power
modify
delay
operation
stay
appropriate
circumstances
statutory
language
says
nothing
power
silent
direct
district
leave
stay
place
come
may
flexible
interpretation
deprive
procedural
provision
meaning
filing
motion
terminate
prospective
relief
still
certain
period
operate
stay
without
action
thus
motion
automatically
changes
status
quo
imposes
upon
party
wishing
suspend
automatic
stay
burden
demonstrating
strong
special
reasons
word
automatic
various
subsection
titles
prove
contrary
word
often
means
unstoppable
see
websters
third
new
international
dictionary
indeed
bankruptcy
act
uses
words
automatic
stay
describe
provision
stating
petition
filed
operates
stay
certain
judicial
proceedings
despite
fact
later
portion
provision
makes
clear
certain
circumstances
bankruptcy
may
terminate
annul
modify
stay
see
also
cong
rec
statement
abraham
explaining
modeled
bankruptcy
act
provision
poultry
producers
financial
protection
act
specifies
appeals
decree
affirming
order
secretary
agriculture
shall
operate
injunction
restraining
live
poultry
dealer
violating
order
yet
appears
one
ever
suggested
appeals
lacks
power
modify
injunction
appropriate
moreover
change
legal
status
quo
automatic
stay
bring
need
demonstrate
special
need
lift
stay
according
traditional
equitable
criteria
mean
stay
remain
effect
highly
unusual
cases
addition
surrounding
procedural
provisions
naturally
read
favoring
flexible
interpretation
immediately
preceding
provision
requires
rule
promptly
upon
motion
terminate
says
andamus
shall
lie
remedy
failure
issue
prompt
ruling
motion
terminate
takes
effect
automatically
stay
days
difficult
understand
purpose
served
providing
mandamus
procedure
complicated
matter
take
several
weeks
automatic
stay
might
modified
lifted
unusual
case
providing
mandamus
makes
considerable
sense
guarantees
appellate
make
certain
unusual
circumstances
fact
justify
modification
lifting
stay
later
provision
provides
immediate
appeal
order
staying
suspending
delaying
barring
operation
automatic
stay
read
providing
similar
appellate
review
similar
reasons
legislative
history
neutral
silent
issue
yet
relevant
judicial
precedent
precedent
read
statutory
silence
denying
judges
authority
exercise
traditional
equitable
powers
rather
reads
statutory
silence
authorizing
exercise
powers
said
example
ne
thing
clear
congress
wished
deprive
courts
historic
power
knew
use
apt
words
done
statute
born
exigencies
war
supra
compare
lockerty
phillips
finding
courts
deprived
equity
powers
statute
explicitly
removed
jurisdiction
essence
equity
jurisdiction
power
chancellor
equity
mould
decree
necessities
particular
case
finally
flexible
interpretation
consistent
congress
purposes
revealed
statute
purposes
include
avoidance
new
judicial
relief
overly
broad
longer
necessary
reassessment
relief
bring
conformity
standards
congress
simultaneously
expressed
intent
maintain
relief
narrowly
drawn
necessary
end
unconstitutional
practices
see
statute
flexibly
interpreted
risks
interfering
first
set
objectives
extent
speedy
appellate
review
provided
statute
fails
control
district
error
interpretation
avoids
improper
provisional
termination
relief
constitutionally
necessary
risk
occasional
small
additional
delay
seems
comparatively
small
price
pay
terms
statute
entire
set
purposes
avoid
serious
constitutional
problems
accompany
majority
rigid
interpretation
upshot
statute
read
light
language
structure
purpose
history
open
interpretation
allow
modify
suspend
automatic
stay
party
accordance
traditional
equitable
criteria
demonstrated
need
exception
interpretation
reflects
historic
reluctance
read
statute
depriving
courts
traditional
equitable
powers
also
avoids
constitutional
difficulties
might
arise
unusual
cases
argue
interpretation
reflects
natural
reading
statute
language
assert
individual
legislator
endorsed
reading
time
interpretation
reasonable
construction
statute
reading
harmonizes
statute
language
basic
legal
principles
including
constitutional
principles
better
fits
full
set
legislative
objectives
embodied
statute
rigid
reading
majority
adopts
reasons
believe
solicitor
general
flexible
reading
proper
reading
statute
us
consequently
vacate
decision
appeals
remand
action
proceedings
charles
miller
superintendent
pendleton
correctional
facility
et
petitioners
richard
french
et
al
petitioner
richard
french
et
al
writs
certiorari
appeals
seventh
circuit
june
justice
souter
justice
ginsburg
joins
concurring
part
dissenting
part
agree
supp
iv
unambiguous
join
parts
ii
majority
opinion
also
agree
applying
automatic
stay
may
raise
due
process
issue
whether
plaintiff
fair
chance
preserve
existing
judgment
valid
entered
ante
believe
applying
statute
may
also
raise
serious
issue
time
allows
turns
inadequate
determine
whether
new
prerequisite
relief
satisfied
particular
thus
join
part
iii
opinion
remand
require
proceedings
consistent
one
respectfully
dissent
terms
disposition
prospective
remedial
order
may
rest
least
three
different
legal
premises
underlying
right
meant
secured
rules
procedure
obtaining
relief
defining
requisites
pleading
notice
cases
rules
lying
two
defining
required
level
certainty
remedy
may
ordered
permissible
scope
relief
issue
rules
last
congress
authority
change
rules
sort
imposing
new
conditions
precedent
continuing
enforcement
existing
prospective
remedial
orders
requiring
courts
apply
new
rules
orders
cf
plaut
spendthrift
farm
legislation
gives
courts
adequate
time
determine
applicability
new
rule
old
order
take
action
necessary
apply
vacate
order
seems
little
basis
claiming
congress
crossed
constitutional
line
interfere
performance
judicial
function
determining
whether
new
rule
applies
requires
time
say
new
factfinding
statute
provides
insufficient
time
make
determination
statute
invalidates
extant
remedial
order
application
statute
raises
serious
question
whether
congress
practical
terms
assumed
judicial
function
case
prospective
order
suddenly
turns
unenforceable
made
judgment
terminate
due
changed
law
fact
one
tell
time
allowed
whether
new
rule
requires
modification
old
order
one
way
view
result
see
congress
mandating
modification
order
may
turn
perfectly
enforceable
new
rule
depending
judicial
factfinding
facts
taken
way
new
statute
might
well
treated
usurping
judicial
function
determining
applicability
general
rule
particular
factual
cf
klein
wall
whether
constitutional
issue
arises
facts
action
however
something
yet
tell
district
address
sufficiency
time
provided
statute
make
findings
required
particular
absent
determination
decide
question
simply
remand
proceedings
district
determined
lacked
adequate
time
make
requisite
findings
period
automatic
stay
become
effective
applying
stay
violate
separation
powers
question
properly
presented
footnotes
together
french
et
also
certiorari
footnotes
originally
enacted
provided
ny
prospective
relief
subject
pending
motion
termination
shall
automatically
stayed
period
beginning
day
motion
filed
ending
date
enters
final
order
ruling
motion
stat
amendments
plra
revised
automatic
stay
provision
current
form
congress
specified
amendments
shall
apply
pending
cases
note
supp
iv
footnotes
forecloses
possibility
challenge
based
insufficient
time
plra
action
occasion
decide
whether
time
constraint
judicial
action
severe
implicated
structural
separation
powers
concerns
plra
deprive
courts
adjudicatory
role
merely
provides
new
legal
standard
relief
encourages
courts
apply
standard
promptly
ante
provisions
plra
narrow
scope
underlying
entitlements
order
protect
orders
may
issued
secure
constitutional
rights
unaffected
plra
event
concern
solely
plra
changes
requisites
relief
constitutional
question
inherent
possible
circumstances
seem
squarely
addressed
cases
congress
engage
discretionary
review
particular
judicial
judgment
cf
plaut
spendthrift
farm
characterizing
hayburn
case
dall
try
modify
final
judgment
cf
stay
result
judicial
application
change
underlying
law
cf
pennsylvania
wheeling
belmont
bridge
plaut
supra
characterizing
klein
wall
instead
time
insufficient
make
judicial
determination
applicability
new
rules
stay
result
inability
judicial
branch
exercise
judicial
power
determining
whether
new
rules
applied
cf
marbury
madison
cranch
emphatically
province
duty
judicial
department
say
law
neither
appeals
merely
speculated
may
cases
courts
able
carry
adjudicative
function
responsible
way
within
time
limits
imposed
french
duckworth
without
deciding
whether
case
presented
situation
concluded
klein
congress
take
away
power
particular
case
preserve
status
quo
ponders
weighty
questions
ibid