milner
department
navy
argued
december
decided
march
freedom
information
act
foia
requires
federal
agencies
make
government
records
available
public
subject
nine
exemptions
case
concerns
exemption
protects
disclosure
material
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
provision
replaced
administrative
procedure
act
apa
exemption
matter
relating
solely
internal
management
agency
congress
believed
sweep
phrase
internal
management
led
excessive
withholding
drafted
exemption
narrower
reach
department
air
force
rose
rose
found
exemption
invoked
withhold
air
force
academy
honor
ethics
hearing
summaries
exemption
suggested
primarily
targets
material
concerning
employee
relations
human
resources
stated
possible
caveat
understanding
provision
coverage
governed
least
situation
one
disclosure
may
risk
circumvention
agency
regulation
circuit
subsequently
converted
caveat
new
definition
exemption
scope
finding
exemption
also
covered
predominantly
internal
materials
whose
disclosure
significantly
ris
circumvention
agency
regulation
statutes
crooker
bureau
alcohol
tobacco
firearms
courts
use
term
low
human
resources
employee
relations
records
high
records
whose
disclosure
risk
circumvention
law
petitioner
milner
submitted
foia
requests
explosives
data
maps
used
respondent
department
navy
navy
government
storing
munitions
naval
base
washington
state
stating
disclosure
threaten
security
base
surrounding
community
navy
invoked
exemption
refused
release
data
district
granted
navy
summary
judgment
appeals
affirmed
relying
high
interpretation
held
exemption
encompasses
records
relating
employee
relations
human
resources
issues
explosives
maps
data
requested
qualify
withholding
exemption
pp
exemption
shields
records
relating
personnel
rules
practices
used
adjective
manner
key
statutory
word
personnel
refers
human
resources
matters
example
personnel
department
deals
employee
problems
interviews
applicants
jobs
foia
exemption
provides
another
example
protecting
certain
personnel
files
disclosure
common
congressional
meaning
file
maintained
human
resources
office
collecting
personal
information
employees
examination
results
work
performance
evaluations
rose
supra
exemption
uses
personnel
exact
way
agency
personnel
rules
practices
share
critical
feature
concern
conditions
employment
federal
agencies
matters
hiring
firing
work
rules
discipline
compensation
benefits
items
currently
fall
within
low
exemption
construction
statutory
language
low
foia
purpose
reinforces
reading
statute
goal
broad
disclosure
exemptions
must
given
narrow
compass
department
justice
tax
analysts
narrow
construction
stands
especially
firm
footing
respect
exemption
intended
hem
expansive
withholding
occurred
prior
apa
exemption
internal
management
records
exemption
interpreted
reach
requested
explosives
information
data
maps
calculate
visually
portray
magnitude
hypothetical
detonations
way
relate
personnel
rules
practices
term
naturally
understood
pp
government
two
alternative
readings
exemption
squared
statute
pp
navy
strong
security
interest
shielding
explosives
data
maps
public
disclosure
government
tools
hand
protect
information
foia
exemption
prevents
access
classified
documents
exemption
applies
records
statute
exempts
disclosure
exemption
protects
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
release
inter
alia
reasonably
expected
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
navy
argument
explosives
information
exempt
exemption
remains
open
ninth
circuit
address
remand
exemptions
cover
records
whose
release
threaten
nation
vital
interests
government
may
course
seek
relief
congress
pp
reversed
remanded
kagan
delivered
opinion
roberts
scalia
kennedy
thomas
ginsburg
alito
sotomayor
joined
alito
filed
concurring
opinion
breyer
filed
dissenting
opinion
glen
scott
milner
petitioner
department
navy
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
march
justice
kagan
delivered
opinion
freedom
information
act
foia
requires
federal
agencies
make
government
records
available
public
subject
nine
exemptions
specific
categories
material
case
concerns
scope
exemption
protects
disclosure
material
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
respondent
department
navy
navy
government
invoked
exemption
deny
foia
request
data
maps
used
help
store
explosives
naval
base
washington
state
hold
exemption
stretch
far
congress
enacted
foia
overhaul
section
administrative
procedure
act
apa
section
apa
plagued
vague
phrases
gradually
became
withholding
statute
disclosure
statute
epa
mink
congress
intended
foia
permit
access
official
information
long
shielded
unnecessarily
public
view
foia
thus
mandates
agency
disclose
records
request
unless
fall
within
one
nine
exemptions
exemptions
explicitly
made
exclusive
must
narrowly
construed
fbi
abramson
issue
exemption
shields
compelled
disclosure
documents
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
congress
enacted
exemption
replace
apa
exemption
matter
relating
solely
internal
management
agency
believing
sweep
phrase
internal
management
led
excessive
withholding
congress
drafted
exemption
narrower
reach
department
air
force
rose
considered
extent
reach
department
air
force
rose
rejected
government
invocation
exemption
withhold
case
summaries
honor
ethics
hearings
air
force
academy
exemption
suggested
primarily
targets
material
concerning
employee
relations
human
resources
use
parking
facilities
regulations
lunch
hours
statements
policy
sick
leave
like
quoting
hereinafter
see
rose
general
thrust
exemption
explained
simply
relieve
agencies
burden
assembling
maintaining
information
public
inspection
concluded
case
summaries
fall
within
exemption
id
concern
routine
matters
merely
internal
significance
stated
possible
caveat
interpretation
exemption
understanding
provision
coverage
governed
wrote
least
situation
one
disclosure
may
risk
circumvention
agency
regulation
crooker
bureau
alcohol
tobacco
firearms
circuit
converted
caveat
new
definition
exemption
scope
crooker
approved
use
exemption
shield
manual
designed
train
government
agents
law
enforcement
surveillance
techniques
circuit
noted
previously
understood
exemption
refe
pensions
vacations
hours
work
lunch
hours
parking
etc
quoting
jordan
department
justice
thought
exemption
also
cover
predominantly
internal
crooker
whose
disclosure
significantly
ris
circumvention
agency
regulations
statutes
construction
exemption
reasoned
flowed
foia
overall
design
legislative
history
even
common
sense
congress
meant
enac
statute
whose
provisions
undermined
effectiveness
law
enforcement
agencies
ibid
ensuing
years
three
courts
appeals
adopted
circuit
interpretation
exemption
see
case
massey
fbi
kaganove
epa
interpretation
spawned
new
terminology
courts
applying
crooker
approach
refer
low
exemption
discussing
materials
concerning
human
resources
employee
relations
high
exemption
assessing
records
whose
disclosure
risk
circumvention
law
see
schiller
nlrb
cadc
congress
well
took
notice
circuit
decision
borrowing
language
crooker
amend
exemption
next
enacting
revisions
foia
amended
version
exemption
shields
certain
records
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
disclosure
reasonably
expected
risk
circumvention
law
see
freedom
information
reform
act
stat
ii
foia
request
issue
arises
navy
operations
naval
magazine
indian
island
base
puget
sound
washington
navy
keeps
weapons
ammunition
explosives
island
aid
storage
transport
munitions
navy
uses
data
known
explosive
safety
quantity
distance
esqd
information
esqd
information
prescribes
minimum
separation
distances
explosives
helps
navy
design
construct
storage
facilities
prevent
chain
reactions
case
detonation
ibid
esqd
calculations
often
incorporated
specialized
maps
depicting
effects
hypothetical
explosions
see
app
petitioner
glen
milner
puget
sound
resident
submitted
foia
requests
esqd
information
relating
indian
island
navy
refused
release
data
stating
disclosure
threaten
security
base
surrounding
community
support
decision
withhold
records
navy
invoked
exemption
district
granted
summary
judgment
navy
appeals
affirmed
relying
high
interpretation
developed
crooker
appeals
explained
esqd
information
predominantly
used
internal
purpose
instructing
agency
personnel
jobs
disclosure
material
determined
risk
circumvention
law
point
ing
best
targets
bent
wreaking
havoc
example
terrorist
wished
hit
damaging
target
esqd
information
concluded
therefore
qualified
high
exemption
granted
certiorari
light
circuit
split
respecting
exemption
meaning
reverse
iii
consideration
exemption
scope
starts
text
see
park
fly
dollar
park
fly
statutory
construction
must
begin
language
employed
congress
assumption
ordinary
meaning
language
accurately
expresses
legislative
purpose
judicial
decisions
since
foia
enactment
analyzed
reanalyzed
meaning
exemption
comparatively
little
attention
focused
provision
simple
words
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
key
word
dozen
one
clearly
marks
provision
boundaries
personnel
used
adjective
modify
rules
practices
term
refers
human
resources
matters
personnel
common
parlance
means
selection
placement
training
employees
formulation
policies
procedures
relations
involving
employees
representatives
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
hereinafter
webster
example
personnel
department
department
business
firm
deals
problems
affecting
employees
firm
usually
interviews
applicants
jobs
random
house
dictionary
hereinafter
random
house
personnel
management
similarly
phase
management
concerned
engagement
effective
utilization
manpower
obtain
optimum
efficiency
human
resources
webster
personnel
agency
agency
placing
employable
persons
jobs
employment
agency
random
house
foia
provides
additional
example
exemption
see
ratzlaf
term
appearing
several
places
statutory
text
generally
read
way
time
appears
exemption
short
paragraphs
exemption
protects
disclosure
personnel
medical
files
similar
files
disclosure
constitute
clearly
unwarranted
invasion
personal
privacy
statute
uses
term
personnel
modifier
meaning
human
resources
see
tr
oral
arg
file
right
government
generally
true
recognized
rose
common
congressional
meaning
file
showing
example
employee
born
names
parents
lived
time
time
school
records
results
examinations
evaluations
work
performance
file
typically
maintained
human
resources
office
otherwise
known
recall
example
offered
personnel
department
ibid
exemption
uses
personnel
exact
way
agency
personnel
rules
practices
rules
practices
dealing
employee
relations
human
resources
circuit
decision
gave
examples
matters
relating
pay
pensions
vacations
hours
work
lunch
hours
parking
etc
jordan
see
supra
etc
important
doubt
know
enough
federal
government
operations
formulate
comprehensive
list
rules
practices
referenced
exemption
share
critical
feature
concern
conditions
employment
federal
agencies
matters
hiring
firing
work
rules
discipline
compensation
courts
practice
little
difficulty
identifying
records
qualify
withholding
reading
commonly
fall
within
low
exemption
construction
statutory
language
simply
makes
clear
low
high
see
infra
statute
purpose
reinforces
understanding
exemption
often
noted
act
goal
broad
disclosure
insisted
exemptions
given
narrow
compass
department
justice
tax
analysts
see
department
interior
klamath
water
users
protective
practice
constru
ing
foia
exemptions
narrowly
department
justice
landano
stands
especially
firm
footing
respect
exemption
described
earlier
congress
worded
provision
hem
prior
apa
exemption
matter
relating
solely
internal
management
agency
agencies
used
prevent
access
masses
documents
see
rose
congress
purpose
construing
exemption
reauthorize
expansive
withholding
congress
wanted
halt
reading
instead
gives
exemption
narrower
reach
congress
intended
simple
device
confining
provision
meaning
words
government
resists
giving
personnel
plain
meaning
ground
congress
drafting
exemption
considered
chose
enact
language
exempting
internal
employment
rules
practices
brief
respondent
drafting
history
navy
maintains
proves
congress
wish
limit
exemption
matters
even
adjective
personnel
conveys
meaning
contexts
think
navy
evidence
insufficient
scant
history
concerning
word
change
easily
supports
inference
congress
merely
swapped
one
synonym
another
cf
mead
tilley
noting
respect
unexplained
disappearance
one
word
unenacted
bill
mute
intermediate
legislative
maneuvers
reliable
aids
statutory
interpretation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
us
make
use
legislative
history
believe
clear
evidence
congressional
intent
may
illuminate
ambiguous
text
take
opposite
tack
allowing
ambiguous
legislative
history
muddy
clear
statutory
language
exemption
construed
reach
esqd
information
issue
data
maps
calculate
visually
portray
magnitude
hypothetical
detonations
stretch
imagination
relate
personnel
rules
practices
term
naturally
understood
concern
physical
rules
governing
explosives
workplace
rules
governing
sailors
address
handling
dangerous
materials
treatment
employees
navy
therefore
may
use
exemption
interpreted
accord
plain
meaning
cover
human
resources
matters
prevent
disclosure
requested
maps
data
iv
government
offers
two
alternative
readings
exemption
support
withholding
esqd
information
square
either
statute
navy
first
encourages
us
adopt
construction
exemption
pioneered
crooker
shields
material
meets
criteria
set
low
also
predominant
ly
interna
disclosure
significantly
risk
circumvention
federal
agency
functions
high
brief
respondent
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
dissent
favors
reading
statute
post
crooker
interpretation
already
suggested
suffers
patent
flaw
disconnected
exemption
text
high
test
addition
substituting
word
predominantly
solely
see
supra
ignores
plain
meaning
adjective
personnel
see
supra
adopts
circumvention
requirement
basis
referent
exemption
language
indeed
way
arrive
high
taking
red
pen
statute
cutting
words
pasting
others
little
actual
provision
remains
elliott
department
agriculture
cadc
high
better
labeled
non
low
support
approach
statute
government
relies
primarily
legislative
history
placing
particular
emphasis
house
report
concerning
foia
see
brief
respondent
statement
report
buttresses
high
understanding
exemption
indeed
specifically
rejects
low
construction
according
report
operating
rules
guidelines
manuals
procedure
government
investigators
examiners
exempt
disclosure
exemption
exemption
cover
employee
relations
working
conditions
routine
administrative
procedures
senate
report
says
exactly
opposite
explaining
support
low
interpretation
phrase
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
means
rules
personnel
use
parking
facilities
regulation
lunch
hours
statements
policy
sick
leave
like
rose
gave
reasons
thinking
senate
report
reliable
two
see
fundamental
point
said
legislative
history
take
account
meant
clear
ambiguity
create
see
supra
wong
yang
sung
mcgrath
declining
consult
legislative
history
history
conflicting
text
ambiguous
presented
one
hand
clear
statutory
language
dueling
committee
reports
must
choose
language
government
also
advances
support
crooker
high
approach
argument
based
subsequent
legislative
action
congress
government
notes
amended
exemption
cover
law
enforcement
records
whose
production
disclose
techniques
procedures
law
enforcement
investigations
prosecutions
disclose
guidelines
law
enforcement
investigations
prosecutions
disclosure
expected
risk
circumvention
law
amendment
government
contends
codified
crooker
circumvention
law
standard
ratified
crooker
holding
brief
respondent
dissent
likewise
counts
significant
congress
ook
note
crooker
revising
foia
post
see
post
government
dissent
neglect
key
feature
amendment
congress
modified
exemption
subject
crooker
instead
exemption
crooker
construction
exemption
renders
exemption
superfluous
deprives
amendment
effect
see
trw
andrews
noting
canon
statutes
read
avoid
making
provision
superfluous
void
insignificant
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
think
document
eligible
withholding
exemption
high
reading
capture
circumvention
standard
law
enforcement
records
listed
exemption
predominantly
internal
congress
agreed
crooker
reading
exemption
reason
alter
exemption
event
congress
either
left
statute
alone
theory
crooker
necessary
work
amended
exemption
specifically
ratify
crooker
decision
instead
amend
exemption
suggests
congress
approved
circumvention
standard
law
enforcement
materials
wider
set
records
high
covers
perhaps
legislative
action
show
congress
affirmatively
disagreed
crooker
maybe
congress
agnostic
whether
circumvention
standard
apply
records
one
thing
clear
amendment
ratify
approve
otherwise
signal
agreement
crooker
interpretation
exemption
argument
therefore
save
high
construction
dissent
offers
one
last
reason
embrace
high
indeed
stakes
wager
argument
crooker
dissent
asserts
consistently
relied
upon
followed
years
lower
courts
post
see
post
claim
trips
starting
gate
immaterial
even
true
warrant
ignore
clear
statutory
language
ground
courts
done
event
true
prior
crooker
three
circuits
adopted
reading
exemption
think
right
changed
minds
see
since
crooker
three
circuits
accepted
high
reading
see
supra
one
circuit
reserved
judgment
high
debate
see
audubon
society
forest
rest
considered
matter
one
think
crooker
extensively
discussed
debated
courts
appeals
past
three
decades
crooker
analysis
exemption
cited
sum
total
five
times
federal
appellate
decisions
outside
circuit
average
every
six
years
result
split
among
flout
usual
rules
statutory
interpretation
take
side
bare
majority
presumably
crooker
departs
exemption
language
government
also
offers
another
construction
says
might
adopt
clean
slate
based
plain
text
alone
brief
respondent
reading
exemption
encompasses
records
concerning
agency
internal
rules
practices
personnel
follow
discharge
governmental
functions
see
also
exemption
applies
generally
matters
concerning
internal
rules
practices
guide
agency
personnel
performing
duties
according
government
interpretation
makes
sense
phrase
rules
practices
agency
logically
understood
mean
agency
rules
practices
personnel
emphasis
added
purported
logic
government
definition
eludes
us
say
ordinary
parlance
personnel
file
file
employee
uses
personnel
department
department
employee
serves
say
personnel
rule
practice
rule
practice
assists
employee
job
use
term
personnel
phrases
connotes
file
department
personnel
rather
file
department
personnel
relates
employee
relations
human
resources
case
well
illustrates
point
records
requested
earlier
noted
explosives
data
maps
showing
distances
potential
blasts
travel
information
doubt
assists
navy
personnel
storing
munitions
say
data
maps
relate
personnel
rules
practices
one
staring
charts
explosions
using
ordinary
language
describe
manner
indeed
government
clean
slate
construction
reaches
documents
stripping
word
personnel
real
meaning
interpretation
agency
internal
personnel
rules
practices
appears
mean
internal
rules
practices
agencies
necessarily
operate
personnel
internal
rules
practices
personnel
modifier
personnel
modifying
work
limit
class
internal
rules
practices
exemption
covers
naturally
viewed
provision
key
word
term
define
scope
nothing
state
truism
agency
personnel
follow
internal
rules
practices
odd
reading
produce
sweeping
exemption
posing
risk
foia
become
less
disclosure
withholding
statute
mink
many
documents
agency
generates
way
aid
employees
carrying
responsibilities
exemption
reach
records
tend
engulf
foia
exemptions
rendering
ineffective
limitations
congress
placed
application
exemption
example
shields
records
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
one
six
specified
criteria
met
yet
government
view
agency
bypass
restrictions
invoking
exemption
whenever
law
enforcement
records
guide
personnel
performing
duties
indeed
agency
use
exemption
provision
withhold
sensitive
records
fall
within
foia
targeted
interpreted
way
exemption
call
super
extend
rather
narrow
apa
former
exemption
records
relating
internal
management
agency
doubt
even
internal
management
provision
congress
thought
allowed
much
withholding
see
supra
protected
information
guides
employees
discharge
duties
including
explosives
data
maps
case
perhaps
needless
say
reading
exemption
violates
rule
favoring
narrow
construction
foia
exemptions
see
abramson
rose
super
fact
basis
text
context
purpose
foia
accordingly
reject
although
interpret
exemption
government
proposes
recognize
strength
navy
interest
protecting
esqd
data
maps
similar
information
government
informed
us
ublicly
disclosing
esqd
information
significantly
risk
undermining
navy
ability
safely
securely
store
military
ordnance
brief
respondent
reason
doubt
representation
ninth
circuit
similarly
cautioned
disclosure
information
used
wrea
havoc
make
catastrophe
likely
concerns
kind
sense
certain
sensitive
information
exempt
disclosure
part
led
crooker
formulate
high
standard
see
contending
common
sense
supported
high
interpretation
congress
wanted
foia
undermin
effectiveness
law
enforcement
agencies
acknowledge
decision
today
upsets
three
decades
agency
practice
relying
crooker
therefore
may
force
considerable
adjustments
also
note
however
government
tools
hand
shield
national
security
information
sensitive
materials
notably
exemption
foia
prevents
access
classified
documents
see
fletcher
dissenting
exemption
specifically
designed
allow
government
agencies
withhold
information
might
jeopardize
national
security
government
generally
may
classify
material
even
receiving
foia
request
see
exec
order
fed
reg
agency
therefore
may
wait
time
decide
whether
dangers
disclosure
outweigh
costs
classification
see
tr
oral
arg
exemption
also
may
mitigate
government
security
concerns
provision
applies
records
statute
exempts
disclosure
thus
offering
congress
established
streamlined
method
authorize
withholding
specific
records
foia
otherwise
protect
exemption
already
noted
protects
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
meets
one
six
criteria
including
release
reasonably
expected
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
navy
argued
esqd
data
maps
fall
within
exemption
see
supra
claim
remains
open
ninth
circuit
address
remand
exemptions
cover
records
whose
release
threaten
nation
vital
interests
government
may
course
seek
relief
congress
see
tr
oral
arg
hold
today
congress
enacted
foia
exemption
government
desires
leave
congress
appropriate
question
whether
vi
exemption
consistent
plain
meaning
term
personnel
rules
practices
encompasses
records
relating
issues
employee
relations
human
resources
explosives
maps
data
requested
qualify
withholding
exemption
therefore
reverse
judgment
appeals
remand
case
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
glen
scott
milner
petitioner
department
navy
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
march
justice
alito
concurring
agree
text
exemption
freedom
information
act
support
high
interpretation
courts
adopted
applied
years
explains
however
government
may
avail
numerous
exemptions
see
ante
exemptions
may
overshadowed
recent
years
broad
reach
high
write
separately
underscore
alternative
argument
navy
raised
rested
exemption
remain
open
remand
see
ante
exemption
applies
specific
categories
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
particular
exemption
permits
withholding
records
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
disclosed
reasonably
expected
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
cases
involving
security
information
difficult
show
disclosure
may
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
difficult
question
however
whether
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
see
john
doe
agency
john
doe
may
invoke
exemption
government
burden
proving
existence
compilation
purpose
view
phrase
reasonably
encompasses
information
used
fulfill
official
security
crime
prevention
duties
law
enforcement
purposes
ordinary
understanding
law
enforcement
includes
investigation
prosecution
offenses
already
committed
also
proactive
steps
designed
prevent
criminal
activity
maintain
security
law
enforcement
officer
defined
one
whose
duty
preserve
peace
black
law
dictionary
ed
fulfilling
duty
involves
range
activities
police
beat
aim
prevent
crime
occurring
less
carry
law
enforcement
purposes
officers
investigating
crime
scene
similarly
agency
charged
apprehension
alleged
offenders
well
crime
detection
prevention
de
sola
crime
dictionary
emphasis
added
crime
prevention
security
measures
critical
effective
law
enforcement
know
doubt
example
secret
service
acts
law
enforcement
purpose
protects
federal
officials
attack
even
though
investigation
may
ongoing
likewise
steps
law
enforcement
officers
prevent
terrorism
surely
fulfill
law
enforcement
purposes
particularly
recent
years
terrorism
prevention
national
security
measures
recognized
vital
effective
law
enforcement
efforts
nation
indeed
fter
september
attacks
america
priorities
federal
bureau
investigation
shifted
dramatically
fbi
top
priority
became
prevention
another
terrorist
attack
hearings
subcommittee
science
departments
state
justice
commerce
related
agencies
house
committee
appropriations
pt
testimony
fbi
director
robert
mueller
iii
today
fbi
number
one
priority
continues
prevention
terrorist
attacks
hearings
senate
committee
homeland
security
governmental
affairs
sess
testimony
mueller
crime
prevention
security
measures
serve
law
enforcement
purposes
charged
law
enforcement
responsibilities
little
chance
fulfilling
duty
preserve
peace
context
exemption
confirms
read
naturally
law
enforcement
purposes
involve
investigation
prosecution
exemption
subparagraphs
demonstrate
congress
knew
refer
narrower
activities
see
information
reasonably
expected
interfere
enforcement
proceedings
information
disclose
techniques
procedures
law
enforcement
investigations
prosecutions
congress
decision
use
different
language
trigger
exemption
confirms
concept
law
enforcement
purposes
sweeps
activities
beyond
investigation
prosecution
see
sosa
applying
usual
rule
legislature
uses
certain
language
one
part
statute
different
language
another
assumes
different
meanings
intended
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
given
fairly
broad
meaning
compiled
john
doe
agency
held
information
need
originally
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
satisfy
exemption
threshold
requirement
rather
even
though
documents
put
together
earlier
time
different
purpose
may
fall
within
exemption
later
assembled
law
enforcement
purposes
example
documents
originally
gathered
routine
business
purposes
may
fall
within
exemption
later
compiled
use
criminal
investigation
similarly
federal
building
plans
related
information
may
compiled
originally
architectural
planning
internal
purposes
may
fall
within
exemption
information
later
compiled
given
law
enforcement
officers
security
purposes
documents
compiled
multiple
purposes
necessarily
deprived
exemption
protection
text
exemption
require
information
compiled
solely
law
enforcement
purposes
cf
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
therefore
may
enough
law
enforcement
purposes
significant
reason
compilation
case
navy
fair
argument
explosive
safety
quantity
distance
esqd
information
falls
within
exemption
esqd
information
navy
argues
used
purpose
identifying
addressing
security
issues
protection
people
property
base
well
nearby
community
damage
loss
death
injury
occur
accident
breach
security
brief
appellee
pp
indeed
esqd
information
compiled
part
effort
prevent
crimes
terrorism
maintain
security
reasonable
argument
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
assuming
threshold
requirement
satisfied
esqd
information
may
fall
comfortably
within
exemption
glen
scott
milner
petitioner
department
navy
writ
certiorari
appeals
ninth
circuit
march
justice
breyer
dissenting
justice
stevens
explained
statute
construed
either
consistent
course
decision
federal
judges
agencies
acquire
clear
meaning
hesitate
change
see
express
mcmahon
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
emphasis
added
see
also
commissioner
fink
stevens
dissenting
cardozo
nature
judicial
process
apply
principal
case
accept
decision
circuit
crooker
bureau
alcohol
tobacco
firearms
en
banc
properly
stating
law
one
thing
crooker
decision
joined
sitting
circuit
judges
consistently
followed
favorably
cited
every
appeals
considered
matter
past
years
see
ibid
written
judge
edwards
joined
chief
judge
robinson
judges
wright
mackinnon
robb
wald
mikva
ginsburg
judge
tamm
concurring
result
judge
wilkey
dissenting
massey
fbi
kaganove
epa
cert
denied
dirksen
hhs
three
circuits
adopted
different
approach
crooker
decided
see
ante
read
subsequent
decisions
two
circuits
adhering
early
positions
see
abraham
rose
plc
finding
crooker
textual
analysis
sound
persuasive
noting
fbi
symbols
used
internally
identify
confidential
sources
may
withheld
sladek
bensinger
expressly
reserving
judgment
crooker
issue
remaining
circuit
district
courts
understand
crooker
apply
see
gavin
sec
wl
see
also
mcqueen
supp
sd
tex
aff
fed
appx
per
curiam
tickel
irs
wl
ed
recognize
reasonable
ground
disagreement
precise
status
certain
precedents
crooker
interpretation
exemption
guided
nearly
every
freedom
information
act
foia
case
decided
last
years
see
generally
dept
justice
guide
freedom
information
act
pp
foia
guide
identifying
district
decisions
applying
crooker
approach
one
appearing
reject
congress
moreover
well
aware
crooker
left
exemption
untouched
amended
foia
five
years
later
see
discussing
crooker
freedom
information
reform
act
stat
amending
exemption
found
circumstances
kind
offer
significant
support
retaining
interpretation
statute
settled
lower
courts
see
general
dynamics
land
systems
cline
evans
monessen
southwestern
morgan
lindahl
office
personnel
management
herman
maclean
huddleston
cannon
university
chicago
blue
chip
stamps
manor
drug
stores
gulf
oil
copp
paving
blau
lehman
see
generally
eskridge
frickey
garrett
cases
materials
legislation
ed
acquiescence
rule
also
support
implicit
congressional
ratification
uniform
line
federal
appellate
interpretations
another
thing
even
majority
analysis
persuaded
written
blank
slate
crooker
analysis
careful
holding
reasonable
circuit
examined
statute
language
legislative
history
precedent
recognized
exemption
words
related
solely
internal
personnel
rules
practices
agency
easily
read
reads
today
refer
human
resources
rules
practices
see
also
thought
words
read
broadly
referring
internal
rules
practices
set
forth
criteria
guidelines
agency
personnel
follow
respect
purely
internal
matters
long
information
issue
legitimate
public
interest
circuit
agreed
today
senate
report
described
exemption
referring
matters
giving
examples
use
parking
facilities
sick
leave
like
quoting
also
noted
house
report
described
exemption
protecting
disclosure
perating
rules
guidelines
manuals
procedure
government
investigators
examiners
quoting
pon
reflection
thought
views
two
houses
reconcilable
one
understood
sets
examples
referring
internal
staff
information
minor
personnel
matters
staff
instruction
matters
public
legitimate
interest
learning
accepted
view
light
hesitation
apply
individual
provisions
statute
woodenly
oblivious
congress
intention
foia
frustrate
law
enforcement
efforts
time
found
exemption
protect
internal
documents
legitimate
public
interest
disclosure
category
includes
say
building
plans
safe
combinations
computer
passwords
evacuation
plans
like
examining
depth
legislative
history
relevant
precedent
adopted
approach
based
prior
opinion
circuit
judge
leventhal
well
language
used
department
air
force
rose
circuit
held
document
fits
within
literal
language
exemption
exempt
disclosure
meets
test
internality
document
legitimate
public
interest
disclosure
significantly
risks
circumvention
agency
regulations
statutes
crooker
supra
see
also
rose
supra
suggesting
exemption
might
apply
disclosure
may
risk
circumvention
agency
regulation
test
based
upon
congress
broader
foia
objectives
common
sense
view
information
congress
want
make
available
crooker
supra
takes
practical
approach
consistently
taken
interpreting
foia
john
doe
agency
john
doe
underestimate
importance
practical
approach
reflects
longstanding
recognition
interpret
foia
administrative
procedure
act
apa
part
linguistic
literalism
fit
interpretations
tax
code
see
generally
pierce
administrative
law
treatise
ed
judicial
interpretation
malleable
language
apa
produced
changes
rulemaking
procedure
characterized
revolutionary
affected
day
year
rather
gradually
period
decades
cf
sunstein
vermeule
interpretation
institutions
rev
observing
congress
appears
rely
courts
long
periods
time
give
meaning
apa
justifies
interpreting
less
formalistically
statutes
like
internal
revenue
code
large
part
foia
like
apa
unlike
tax
code
must
govern
affairs
vast
executive
branch
numerous
different
agencies
bureaus
departments
performing
numerous
tasks
many
different
kinds
narrow
interpretation
working
well
case
one
agency
may
seriously
interfere
congressional
objectives
applied
another
circuit
answer
legal
problem
interpret
exemption
light
congress
basic
effort
achieve
workable
balance
interests
public
greater
access
information
needs
government
protect
certain
kinds
information
disclosure
john
doe
agency
supra
see
also
emphasizing
workable
balance
years
experience
crooker
holding
suggests
seriously
interfered
foia
informational
objectives
time
permitted
agencies
withhold
much
information
view
congress
wanted
force
public
realm
focus
case
law
courts
held
information
protected
exemption
includes
blueprints
department
agriculture
buildings
store
biological
agents
elliot
department
agriculture
supp
dc
documents
help
hackers
access
national
aeronautics
space
administration
computers
knight
nasa
wl
ed
agency
credit
card
numbers
judicial
watch
department
commerce
supp
dc
commodity
futures
trading
commission
guidelines
settling
cases
loop
kendrick
llp
commodity
futures
trading
cv
dist
lexis
nd
ohio
may
trigger
figures
alert
department
education
possible
mismanagement
federal
funds
wiesenfelder
riley
supp
dc
security
plans
building
justices
voinche
fbi
supp
dc
vulnerability
assessments
commerce
department
security
plans
schreibman
department
commerce
supp
dc
bureau
prisons
guidelines
controlling
riots
storing
hazardous
chemicals
miller
doj
wl
dc
guidelines
assessing
sensitivity
military
programs
institute
policy
studies
department
air
force
supp
dc
guidelines
processing
medicare
reimbursement
claims
dirksen
exemption
cases
withholding
may
seem
less
reasonable
courts
ordered
disclosure
cf
ante
citing
audubon
society
forest
maricopa
audubon
soc
forest
see
generally
foia
guide
citing
nine
decisions
applying
crooker
approach
nonetheless
requiring
disclosure
majority
acknowledges
decision
today
upsets
three
decades
agency
practice
relying
crooker
therefore
may
force
considerable
adjustments
ante
adjustments
made
government
rely
upon
exemptions
provide
protection
believes
necessary
justice
alito
notes
exemption
applies
documents
consist
records
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
release
disclose
techniques
procedures
law
enforcement
investigations
reasonably
expected
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
building
plans
computer
passwords
credit
card
numbers
safe
deposit
combinations
government
much
experience
litigating
foia
cases
warns
us
exemption
targets
subset
important
agency
functions
may
circumvented
brief
respondent
today
decision
confirms
point
insistence
narrow
construction
might
persuade
judges
avoid
reading
exemption
broadly
enough
provide
protection
majority
suggests
government
classify
documents
remain
private
ante
see
permitting
withholding
material
properly
classified
authorized
kept
secret
interest
national
defense
foreign
policy
classification
best
partial
solution
takes
time
subject
rules
government
points
hinder
sharing
information
government
buildings
first
responders
local
fire
police
departments
brief
respondent
congress
president
believe
nation
currently
faces
problem
much
little
classified
material
see
reducing
act
stat
exec
order
cfr
indeed
congress
recently
found
commission
others
observed
information
interferes
accurate
actionable
timely
information
sharing
increases
cost
information
security
needlessly
limits
stakeholder
public
access
information
information
causes
considerable
confusion
regarding
information
may
shared
negatively
affects
dissemination
information
within
federal
government
state
local
tribal
entities
private
sector
reducing
act
stat
legislative
findings
suggest
crooker
poses
serious
threat
foia
public
information
objectives
leaves
congressional
action
points
congress
remains
free
correct
whatever
problems
finds
today
narrowing
exemption
legislative
action
takes
time
congress
much
matters
compared
foia
revision
may
warrant
higher
legislative
priority
view
courts
appropriate
interpretation
turn
congress
public
information
objectives
workable
agency
practice
adhere
interpretations
settled
courts
already
interpreted
exemption
interpretation
consistently
relied
upon
followed
years
congress
taken
note
interpretation
amending
parts
statute
interpretation
reasonable
proved
practically
helpful
achieved
commonsense
results
consistent
foia
overall
statutory
goals
new
different
interpretation
raises
serious
problems
new
interpretation
require
congress
act
preserve
status
quo
let
sleeping
legal
dogs
lie
reasons
respect
dissent
footnotes
adopted
predominantly
internal
standard
way
implementing
exemption
requirement
materials
relat
solely
agency
internal
personnel
rules
practices
word
solely
reasoned
given
construction
consonant
reasonableness
otherwise
solely
conflict
expansive
term
related
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
three
courts
appeals
previously
taken
narrower
view
exemption
scope
consistent
interpretation
adopted
rose
see
cox
department
justice
concluding
exemption
covers
agency
internal
housekeeping
matters
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
stokes
brennan
holding
exemption
must
read
broadly
exempt
occupational
safety
health
administration
manual
training
compliance
officers
hawkes
irs
internal
practices
policies
referred
exemption
relate
type
concerns
circuits
never
revised
understandings
exemption
see
infra
navy
also
invoked
exemption
applies
records
information
compiled
law
enforcement
purposes
extent
production
records
reasonably
expected
endanger
life
physical
safety
individual
courts
decide
whether
navy
withhold
esqd
data
exemption
wd
app
pet
cert
wl
government
records
also
must
satisfy
requirements
exemption
exempt
disclosure
information
must
relat
solely
meaning
usual
exclusively
random
house
agency
personnel
rules
practices
information
must
internal
agency
must
typically
keep
records
use
see
webster
internal
means
existing
situated
within
limits
something
agency
human
resources
documents
often
meet
conditions
dissent
reject
longstanding
rule
construction
favor
approach
asking
courts
turn
congress
public
information
objectives
workable
agency
practice
post
opinion
breyer
nothing
foia
either
explicitly
implicitly
grants
courts
discretion
expand
contract
exemption
basis
enacting
foia
congress
struck
balance
thought
right
generally
favoring
disclosure
subject
handful
specified
exemptions
across
length
breadth
federal
government
see
john
doe
agency
john
doe
judicial
role
enforce
congressionally
determined
balance
rather
dissent
suggests
post
assess
case
case
department
department
task
task
whether
disclosure
interferes
good
government
perplexed
dissent
takes
seriously
crooker
notion
reports
reconcilable
post
strip
matter
essentials
house
report
says
exemption
means
senate
report
says
exemption
means
definition
irreconcilable
dissent
view
two
th
ese
circuits
adher
ed
early
positions
incorrect
post
abraham
rose
cited
dissent
sixth
circuit
rejected
government
claim
exemption
shielded
records
federal
tax
lien
filings
nowhere
discussed
high
versus
low
question
issue
reference
crooker
concerned
part
decision
interpreting
solely
mean
predominantly
see
see
also
supra
subsequently
sixth
circuit
held
rugiero
department
justice
exemption
applies
routine
matters
merely
internal
significance
sladek
bensinger
dissent
also
cites
fifth
circuit
insisted
government
disclose
drug
enforcement
administration
agent
manual
type
trivial
rule
allocation
parking
facilities
covered
exemption
confirming
low
interpretation
statute
acknowledged
another
circuit
embraced
high
standard
however
declined
consider
alternative
interpretation
changed
case
outcome
see
ibid
finally
eighth
circuit
last
word
exemption
clear
dissent
say
otherwise
exemption
according
recent
eighth
circuit
decision
applies
agency
housekeeping
matters
cox
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
dissent
surely
right
say
post
crooker
guided
nearly
every
foia
case
decided
last
years
circuits
applying
crooker
statement
hold
circuits
using
low
approach
notably
even
courts
approving
crooker
disagreed
apply
high
fault
lines
include
whether
risk
circumvention
must
significant
see
hidalgo
fbi
supp
dc
pet
cert
whether
courts
consider
public
interest
disclosure
calculating
risk
see
department
justice
guide
freedom
information
act
whether
agency
must
regulate
person
entity
threatening
circumvention
compare
fletcher
dissenting
disagreement
surprising
high
nowhere
evident
statute
courts
lack
normal
guideposts
ascertaining
coverage
dissent
asserts
years
experience
expansive
interpretation
exemption
suggests
seriou
interfere
nce
foia
informational
objectives
post
objectives
suffer
time
agency
denies
foia
request
based
improper
interpretation
statute
give
one
example
forest
service
wrongly
invoked
exemption
multiple
occasions
withhold
information
things
bird
nesting
sites
see
audubon
society
forest
maricopa
audubon
soc
forest
recent
statistics
raise
concern
federal
agencies
may
readily
use
exemption
refuse
disclosure
according
amicus
public
citizen
reliance
exemptions
overall
rose
reliance
exemption
rose
time
period
brief
public
citizen
et
al
amici
curiae
alone
federal
departments
cited
exemption
times
prevent
access
records
see
brief
allied
daily
newspapers
washington
et
al
amici
curiae
doubt
many
foia
denials
appropriate
unable
accept
dissent
unsupported
declaration
sweeping
construction
exemption
interfered
congress
goal
broad
disclosure