phillips
petroleum
wisconsin
argued
decided
june
company
involved
engages
production
gathering
processing
sale
natural
gas
engage
interstate
transmission
gas
producing
fields
consumer
markets
affiliated
company
sells
natural
gas
five
interstate
pipeline
companies
transport
resell
gas
consumers
local
distributing
companies
gas
flows
producing
wells
network
converging
pipelines
one
processing
plants
extractable
products
impurities
removed
thence
flows
short
distance
delivery
point
sold
delivered
interstate
pipeline
company
continues
flow
interstate
pipeline
system
delivered
held
company
company
within
meaning
natural
gas
act
sales
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
resale
subject
jurisdiction
rate
regulation
federal
power
commission
pp
company
admittedly
engaged
sale
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
resale
within
meaning
act
sales
company
part
production
gathering
natural
gas
excluded
commission
jurisdiction
since
production
gathering
end
sales
occur
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
pp
congress
intend
regulate
interstate
pipeline
companies
rather
legislative
history
indicates
congressional
intent
give
commission
jurisdiction
rates
wholesales
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
whether
pipeline
company
whether
occurring
transmission
interstate
pipeline
company
pp
cities
service
gas
peerless
oil
gas
phillips
petroleum
oklahoma
require
different
result
pp
regulation
sales
interstate
commerce
resale
made
independent
producer
essentially
different
regulation
sales
made
affiliate
interstate
pipeline
company
together
texas
et
al
wisconsin
et
al
federal
power
commission
wisconsin
et
also
certiorari
hugh
cox
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
rayburn
foster
harry
turner
stanley
temko
dan
moody
argued
cause
petitioners
brief
john
ben
shepperd
attorney
general
charles
crenshaw
special
assistant
attorney
general
moody
state
texas
et
mac
williamson
attorney
general
oklahoma
corporation
commission
oklahoma
richard
robinson
attorney
general
george
graham
special
assistant
attorney
general
state
new
mexico
et
petitioners
paull
marshall
also
counsel
solicitor
general
sobeloff
argued
cause
federal
power
commission
petitioner
brief
assistant
attorney
general
burger
melvin
richter
willard
gatchell
william
grove
louis
kaplan
stewart
honeck
deputy
attorney
general
wisconsin
william
torkelson
charles
rhyne
james
lee
harry
slater
argued
causes
respondents
joint
brief
vernon
thomson
attorney
general
honeck
state
wisconsin
torkelson
public
service
commission
wisconsin
lee
city
detroit
michigan
david
proctor
rhyne
kansas
city
missouri
walter
mattison
slater
city
milwaukee
wisconsin
respondents
brief
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
fred
leblanc
attorney
general
state
louisiana
coleman
attorney
general
state
mississippi
christianson
attorney
general
state
north
dakota
howard
black
attorney
general
state
wyoming
jay
kyle
state
corporation
commission
kansas
paull
marshall
also
counsel
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
burnquist
attorney
general
george
sjoselius
state
minnesota
john
bonner
city
minneapolis
minnesota
leo
hoegh
attorney
general
state
iowa
clarence
beck
attorney
general
state
nebraska
anderson
john
mortimer
dale
fillmore
john
banks
henry
curtis
abraham
freedman
alexander
brown
dion
holm
charles
rhyne
national
institute
municipal
law
officers
justice
minton
delivered
opinion
cases
present
common
question
concerning
jurisdiction
federal
power
commission
rates
charged
producer
gatherer
sale
interstate
commerce
gas
resale
three
cases
outgrowth
proceeding
power
commission
involve
facts
issues
phillips
petroleum
company
large
integrated
oil
company
also
engages
production
gathering
processing
sale
natural
gas
concerned
operations
phillips
known
independent
producer
engage
interstate
transmission
gas
producing
fields
consumer
markets
affiliated
interstate
pipeline
company
revealed
record
us
however
phillips
sell
natural
gas
five
interstate
pipeline
transmission
companies
transport
resell
gas
consumers
local
distributing
companies
fourteen
approximately
gas
produced
phillips
remainder
purchased
producers
substantial
part
casinghead
gas
produced
connection
production
oil
gas
flows
producing
wells
instances
well
pressure
network
converging
pipelines
progressively
larger
size
one
twelve
processing
plants
extractable
products
impurities
removed
nine
networks
pipelines
involved
cases
five
located
entirely
texas
one
oklahoma
one
new
mexico
two
extend
texas
oklahoma
processing
completed
gas
flows
processing
plant
outlet
pipe
varying
lengths
hundred
feet
delivery
point
gas
sold
delivered
interstate
pipeline
company
gas
continues
flow
interstate
pipeline
system
delivered
federal
power
commission
october
instituted
investigation
determine
whether
phillips
company
within
jurisdiction
commission
whether
rates
unjust
unreasonable
extensive
hearings
examiner
facts
described
developed
well
much
additional
information
intermediate
decision
dispensed
commission
issued
opinion
order
held
phillips
company
within
meaning
term
used
natural
gas
act
therefore
within
commission
jurisdiction
rates
consequently
commission
proceed
investigate
reasonableness
rates
charged
phillips
appeals
decision
commission
reversed
appeals
district
columbia
circuit
one
judge
dissenting
app
granted
certiorari
power
commission
authorized
natural
gas
act
regulate
rates
charges
made
demanded
received
company
connection
transportation
sale
natural
gas
subject
jurisdiction
commission
company
defined
act
mean
person
engaged
transportation
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
sale
interstate
commerce
gas
resale
jurisdiction
commission
set
forth
follows
provisions
act
shall
apply
transportation
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
sale
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
resale
ultimate
public
consumption
domestic
commercial
industrial
use
companies
engaged
transportation
sale
shall
apply
transportation
sale
natural
gas
local
distribution
natural
gas
facilities
used
distribution
production
gathering
natural
gas
agree
view
statutory
language
pertinent
legislative
history
past
decisions
support
conclusion
appeals
phillips
company
within
meaning
term
defined
natural
gas
act
sales
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
resale
subject
jurisdiction
regulation
federal
power
commission
commission
found
phillips
sales
part
production
gathering
process
least
exempt
incident
thereof
determination
appears
based
primarily
commission
reading
legislative
history
interpretation
certain
decisions
also
testimony
record
effect
meaning
gathering
commonly
accepted
industry
comprehends
sales
incident
physical
activity
collecting
processing
gas
petitioners
contend
commission
finding
reasonable
basis
law
supported
substantial
evidence
record
therefore
accepted
courts
particularly
since
commission
consistently
interpreted
act
conferring
jurisdiction
companies
phillips
see
gray
powell
labor
board
hearst
publications
opinion
however
finding
without
adequate
basis
law
production
gathering
sense
terms
used
end
sales
phillips
occur
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
observed
natural
clear
meaning
phrase
production
gathering
natural
gas
encompasses
producing
properties
gathering
facilities
company
similarly
colorado
interstate
gas
federal
power
commission
stated
ransportation
sale
include
production
gathering
indicated
production
gathering
exemption
applies
physical
activities
facilities
properties
used
production
gathering
natural
gas
see
also
federal
power
commission
hope
natural
gas
peoples
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
app
cf
public
utilities
commission
even
directly
point
decision
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
interstate
company
produced
purchased
natural
gas
turn
sold
delivered
three
interstate
pipeline
companies
activities
occurring
within
state
noted
xceptions
primary
grant
jurisdiction
section
strictly
construed
held
conferred
jurisdiction
sales
federal
power
commission
stating
petitioner
asserts
sales
three
companies
part
gathering
process
consequently
within
commission
power
regulation
basic
contention
given
rise
great
many
subsidiary
questions
whether
sales
made
petitioner
gathering
lines
petitioner
transmission
lines
whether
gathering
process
continued
points
sale
commission
found
completed
point
prior
surrender
custody
passage
title
found
unnecessary
resolve
issues
gas
moved
petitioner
points
sale
consisted
gas
produced
petitioner
wells
commingled
produced
gathered
companies
introduced
petitioner
system
course
movement
time
sales
consummated
nothing
gathering
process
remains
done
held
sales
interstate
commerce
doubted
regulation
predominantly
matter
national
contrasted
local
concern
gas
sold
transactions
destined
consumption
louisiana
unreasonable
charges
exacted
stage
interstate
movement
become
perpetuated
large
part
fixed
items
costs
must
covered
rates
charged
subsequent
purchasers
gas
including
ultimate
consumer
avoid
situations
natural
gas
act
passed
interstate
case
also
said
distinguishable
involve
asserted
conflict
state
regulation
federal
control
opposed
state
authorities
instant
cases
said
conflicting
state
regulations
federal
jurisdiction
vigorously
opposed
producing
short
answer
contention
jurisdiction
federal
power
commission
intended
vary
state
state
depending
upon
degree
state
regulation
state
opposition
federal
control
expressly
rejected
implication
contrary
interstate
case
see
federal
power
commission
hope
natural
gas
supra
cases
discussed
supply
ready
answer
determination
commission
also
petitioners
suggestion
production
gathering
construed
mean
business
production
gathering
sale
product
considered
integral
part
business
see
reason
depart
previous
decisions
especially
since
consistent
language
legislative
history
natural
gas
act
general
petitioners
contend
congress
intended
regulate
interstate
pipeline
companies
since
certain
alleged
excesses
companies
evil
brought
legislation
case
difficulty
perceiving
commission
jurisdiction
transportation
sale
resale
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
granted
disjunctive
sufficed
give
commission
jurisdiction
companies
engage
transportation
transportation
sale
resale
interstate
commerce
interstate
pipeline
companies
intended
covered
see
federal
power
commission
east
ohio
gas
rather
believe
legislative
history
indicates
congressional
intent
give
commission
jurisdiction
rates
wholesales
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
whether
pipeline
company
whether
occurring
transmission
interstate
pipeline
company
dispute
overriding
congressional
purpose
plug
gap
regulation
companies
resulting
judicial
decisions
prohibiting
federal
constitutional
grounds
state
regulation
many
interstate
commerce
aspects
business
significant
part
gap
created
cases
holding
regulation
wholesale
rates
gas
electrical
energy
moving
interstate
commerce
beyond
constitutional
powers
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
supra
committee
reports
bill
became
natural
gas
act
specifically
referred
two
cases
necessity
federal
regulation
occupy
hiatus
created
thus
satisfied
congress
sought
regulate
wholesales
natural
gas
occurring
ends
interstate
transmission
systems
petitioners
cite
recent
decisions
cities
service
gas
peerless
oil
gas
phillips
petroleum
oklahoma
authority
proposition
may
regulate
sales
question
hence
sales
within
gap
natural
gas
act
intended
fill
cases
upheld
constitutional
state
minimum
price
orders
justified
conservation
measures
applying
sales
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
well
settled
gap
referred
thought
exist
time
natural
gas
act
passed
jurisdiction
commission
affected
subsequent
decisions
somewhat
loosened
constitutional
restrictions
state
activities
affecting
interstate
commerce
absence
conflicting
federal
regulation
illinois
natural
gas
central
illinois
public
service
federal
power
commission
east
ohio
gas
supra
federal
power
commission
participate
cities
service
phillips
petroleum
cases
appellants
assert
possible
conflict
federal
authority
natural
gas
act
consequently
expressly
refused
consider
time
hether
gas
act
authorizes
power
commission
set
field
prices
sales
independent
producers
leaves
function
regulation
sales
interstate
commerce
resale
made
independent
producer
essentially
different
regulation
sales
made
affiliate
interstate
pipeline
company
cases
rates
charged
may
direct
substantial
effect
price
paid
ultimate
consumers
protection
consumers
exploitation
hands
companies
primary
aim
natural
gas
act
federal
power
commission
hope
natural
gas
supra
attempts
weaken
protection
amendatory
legislation
exempting
independent
producers
federal
regulation
repeatedly
failed
refuse
achieve
result
strained
interpretation
existing
statutory
language
judgment
affirmed
footnotes
stat
amended
et
seq
one
commissioner
concurred
decision
one
dissented
consistency
commission
regard
may
questioned
compare
columbian
fuel
interstate
natural
gas
brief
federal
power
commission
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
brief
federal
power
commission
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
federal
power
commission
order
fed
reg
federal
power
commission
order
fed
reg
see
scanlan
administrative
abnegation
face
congressional
coercion
interstate
natural
gas
company
affair
notre
dame
law
note
yale
matter
even
consistent
error
still
error
referring
taking
natural
gas
purchasing
interstate
pipeline
companies
outlet
processing
plants
recently
observed
pipeline
companies
obviously
engaged
gathering
gas
within
meaning
term
ordinary
usage
pipe
line
calvert
committee
reports
bill
enacted
natural
gas
act
reveal
construction
production
gathering
exemption
substantially
limit
affirmative
grant
jurisdiction
commission
contemplated
quoting
exemptive
clause
house
report
quoted
words
actually
necessary
matters
specified
therein
said
fairly
covered
language
affirmatively
stating
jurisdiction
commission
similar
language
previous
bills
rather
invite
contention
however
unfounded
elimination
negative
language
broaden
scope
act
committee
included
bill
sess
senate
report
adopted
reprinted
house
report
bill
sess
despite
fact
urged
commission
basis
decision
brief
federal
power
commission
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
wording
suggested
rejected
house
committee
considering
enactment
natural
gas
act
chairman
state
new
york
department
public
service
public
service
commission
hearings
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
sess
earlier
bill
limited
jurisdiction
power
commission
transportation
natural
gas
mains
interstate
commerce
companies
engaged
transportation
much
legislative
history
advanced
support
petitioners
position
developed
connection
bill
including
testimony
dozier
devane
solicitor
federal
power
commission
much
different
jurisdictional
provision
testimony
little
relevance
bill
held
hearings
leading
passage
natural
gas
act
introduced
provided
commission
jurisdiction
sale
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
resale
public
similarly
company
defined
including
person
engaged
sale
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
resale
public
general
solicitor
national
association
railroad
utilities
commissioners
suggested
language
changed
manner
almost
identical
contained
natural
gas
act
referring
proposed
changes
commented
another
designed
make
certain
bill
apply
intercompany
sales
natural
gas
wholesale
even
though
sale
one
company
another
company
resell
another
corporation
gas
finally
sold
public
hearings
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
sess
see
also
federal
power
commission
east
ohio
gas
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
public
service
commission
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
colorado
interstate
gas
federal
power
commission
federal
power
commission
hope
natural
gas
illinois
natural
gas
central
illinois
public
service
missouri
kansas
natural
gas
public
utilities
commission
attleboro
steam
electric
state
corporation
commission
wichita
gas
cf
milling
bondurant
lemke
farmers
grain
shafer
farmers
grain
see
jersey
central
power
light
federal
power
commission
course
many
years
regulated
sales
natural
gas
consumers
intrastate
transactions
also
able
regulate
sales
consumers
even
though
sales
interstate
commerce
sales
considered
local
character
absence
congressional
prohibition
subject
state
regulation
intention
enacting
present
legislation
disturb
exercise
jurisdiction
however
case
sales
resale
wholesale
sales
interstate
commerce
example
sales
producing
companies
distributing
companies
legal
situation
different
transactions
considered
local
character
even
absence
congressional
action
subject
state
regulation
see
missouri
kansas
gas
public
service
commission
attleboro
steam
electric
basic
purpose
present
legislation
occupy
field
held
may
act
sess
sess
among
bills
introduced
recent
congresses
restrict
existing
jurisdiction
federal
power
commission
producers
sess
sess
sess
sess
justice
frankfurter
concurring
join
opinion
one
consideration
leading
conclusion
decisive
deem
appropriate
give
emphasis
section
construed
face
comes
us
authoritative
gloss
must
construe
though
congress
words
added
present
text
language
following
however
since
sales
resale
wholesale
sales
interstate
commerce
local
character
constitutionally
subject
state
regulation
see
missouri
kansas
gas
public
utilities
commission
attleboro
steam
electric
basic
purpose
legislation
occupy
field
may
act
sure
kansas
gas
case
excluded
business
piping
gas
supply
company
one
state
distributing
companies
another
attleboro
case
involved
transmission
electric
current
producing
company
took
one
state
boundary
another
state
sold
distributing
company
resale
state
case
sale
phillips
made
texas
interstate
pipeline
transmission
companies
transported
gas
resale
distributing
companies
consumers
fact
phillips
pipe
gas
state
boundary
directly
another
state
slightest
alter
constitutional
applicability
attleboro
doctrine
situation
us
fact
continuous
transmission
facilities
phillips
facilities
phillips
connecting
pipelines
transmitting
gas
change
interstate
character
transaction
reason
decision
attleboro
relying
peoples
gas
public
service
commission
barred
state
regulation
may
well
problem
attleboro
case
came
today
constitutional
doctrine
laid
found
compelling
immaterial
congress
leave
determination
whether
attleboro
situation
subject
state
regulation
wrote
doctrine
attleboro
case
natural
gas
act
said
effect
attleboro
situation
taken
federal
regulation
left
fluctuation
adjudications
commerce
clause
course
many
years
regulated
sales
natural
gas
consumers
intrastate
transactions
also
able
regulate
sales
consumers
even
though
sales
interstate
commerce
sales
considered
local
character
absence
congressional
prohibition
subject
state
regulation
see
pennsylvania
gas
public
service
commission
intention
enacting
present
legislation
disturb
exercise
jurisdiction
however
case
sales
resale
wholesale
sales
interstate
commerce
example
sales
producing
companies
distributing
companies
legal
situation
different
transactions
considered
local
character
even
absence
congressional
action
subject
state
regulation
see
missouri
kansas
gas
public
service
commission
attleboro
steam
electric
basic
purpose
present
legislation
occupy
field
held
may
act
sess
justice
douglas
dissenting
question
whether
sales
natural
gas
independent
producer
mouth
interstate
pipeline
subject
regulation
federal
power
commission
natural
gas
act
question
never
decided
indeed
one
expressly
reserved
decision
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
much
said
national
point
view
regulating
sales
ends
interstate
pipelines
power
congress
unquestioned
whether
natural
gas
act
political
legal
controversy
raged
commission
congress
years
question
free
doubts
act
makes
regulatory
provisions
applicable
sale
interstate
commerce
natural
gas
resale
ultimate
public
consumption
also
makes
inapplicable
production
gathering
natural
gas
sale
independent
producer
sale
interstate
commerce
resale
also
integral
part
production
gathering
natural
gas
justice
clark
makes
clear
opinion
end
phase
producing
gathering
process
must
make
choice
choice
easy
one
legislative
history
helpful
congress
concerned
interstate
pipelines
independent
producers
thoughtful
comment
yale
points
one
judge
reports
federal
trade
commission
preceded
act
doc
pt
sess
hearings
debates
congress
bills
evolved
act
little
consideration
given
need
regulating
sales
independent
producers
pipelines
gap
filled
existing
pipelines
brought
regulation
sales
distributors
along
pipelines
opinion
justice
clark
demonstrates
view
commission
decision
followed
heels
act
columbian
fuel
decision
exempted
regulation
independent
producer
phillips
material
respects
comparable
decision
made
men
intimately
familiar
background
history
act
leland
olds
basil
manly
claude
draper
clyde
seavey
one
commissioner
john
scott
dissented
construction
act
commission
persisted
time
see
billings
gas
oil
gas
production
tennessee
gas
transmission
decision
present
case
construction
commission
especially
since
contemporaneous
american
trucking
long
continued
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
entitled
great
weight
obtuse
questions
less
legal
character
terms
production
gathering
gas
entrusted
administrative
agency
charged
regulation
see
shields
utah
idaho
central
sunshine
anthracite
coal
adkins
gray
powell
practical
considerations
buttress
position
lead
conclude
reverse
commission
present
case
phillips
sales
regulated
commission
set
rate
base
phillips
rate
base
phillips
must
necessity
include
phillips
producing
gathering
properties
supervision
operating
expenses
necessarily
includes
supervision
producing
gathering
expenses
held
colorado
interstate
gas
federal
power
commission
commission
control
extended
far
case
interstate
pipeline
company
owned
producing
gathering
properties
regulation
pipelines
owned
gas
supplies
effective
understanding
regulation
entails
lead
different
result
case
fastening
rate
regulation
independent
producer
brings
production
gathering
natural
gas
effective
federal
control
spite
fact
congress
made
phase
natural
gas
business
exempt
regulation
effect
certain
profound
price
independent
producer
sell
gas
determines
price
able
willing
pay
buys
wells
sales
price
determines
profits
profits
profits
gatherers
whose
gas
moves
interstate
pipelines
profound
effects
rate
production
methods
production
old
wells
continued
production
new
ones
explored
etc
regulating
price
independent
producer
sell
gas
regulates
business
vital
way
business
regulated
regulation
largely
nullifies
exemption
granted
congress
much
said
terms
policy
position
commissioner
scott
dissented
first
time
commission
ruled
jurisdiction
sales
history
language
act
ground
taken
battle
congress
regulation
business
producing
gathering
natural
gas
involves
considerations
know
little
competent
deal
justice
clark
justice
burton
concurs
dissenting
perhaps
congress
included
control
production
gathering
natural
gas
among
powers
gave
federal
power
commission
natural
gas
act
congress
contrary
congress
provided
act
shall
apply
production
gathering
natural
gas
language
express
clearer
command
majority
renders
language
almost
entirely
nugatory
holding
rates
charged
wholly
independent
producer
gatherer
may
regulated
federal
power
commission
stop
sweep
opinion
rates
wholesales
natural
gas
interstate
commerce
whether
pipeline
company
whether
occuring
transmission
interstate
pipeline
company
covered
act
ante
emphasis
supplied
face
language
brings
every
gas
operator
smallest
producer
largest
pipeline
federal
regulatory
control
acts
contrary
intention
congress
understanding
federal
power
commission
federal
power
commission
thereby
thrust
regulatory
domain
traditionally
reserved
natural
gas
industry
like
ancient
gaul
divided
three
parts
parts
production
gathering
interstate
transmission
pipeline
distribution
consumers
local
distribution
companies
business
unit
may
perform
one
functions
typically
production
gathering
addition
interstate
transmission
phillips
natural
gas
operations
confined
exclusively
first
part
production
gathering
interstate
transmission
trunk
lines
sell
distribution
companies
course
distribute
ultimate
consumer
nine
gathering
systems
merely
bring
gas
producers
wells
central
plants
producing
fields
rendered
usable
fuel
since
facilities
storage
amount
gas
casinghead
produced
gathered
day
depends
demands
interstate
pipelines
turn
depend
weather
conditions
consuming
areas
gas
wells
cut
market
demand
gas
requires
gathering
takes
place
well
pressure
forcing
gas
numerous
small
pipes
connecting
well
central
gathering
plant
processing
station
gas
first
comes
common
header
processed
use
fuel
processing
gas
central
gathering
plant
necessary
remove
hydrocarbons
hydrogen
sulphide
foreign
elements
order
permit
use
fuel
plant
operates
wells
producing
phillips
operations
including
acreage
wells
produce
gas
wells
lines
connect
run
central
plant
form
closely
knit
unit
entirely
local
field
involved
processing
gas
immediately
delivered
interstate
pipelines
sales
contracts
commission
found
hough
technically
consummated
interstate
commerce
sales
phillips
pipelines
made
course
production
gathering
sales
closely
connected
local
incidents
production
gathering
render
rate
regulation
commission
inconsistent
substantial
interference
exercise
affected
regulatory
functions
believe
finding
correct
approved
doubt
congress
thought
production
gathering
exemption
saved
phillips
sales
federal
power
commission
regulation
act
legislative
history
removes
solicitor
commission
dozier
devane
hearings
connection
predecessor
bill
finally
became
natural
gas
act
testified
federal
power
commission
jurisdiction
rates
natural
gas
paid
gathering
field
hearings
subcommittee
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
bill
said
attempt
regulate
gathering
rates
gathering
business
see
also
bill
devane
testified
described
substantially
similar
natural
gas
act
views
treated
authoritative
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
see
also
federal
power
commission
east
ohio
gas
face
well
federal
power
commission
adherence
devane
views
ever
since
first
cases
subject
columbian
fuel
billings
gas
absence
specific
matter
act
legislative
history
refuting
devane
views
today
erroneously
finds
devane
testimony
little
relevance
ante
dispute
congress
intended
natural
gas
act
close
gap
created
decisions
barring
state
regulation
certain
interstate
gas
sales
legislative
history
act
refers
two
decisions
missouri
kansas
natural
gas
public
utilities
commission
attleboro
steam
electric
see
pp
cases
nothing
sales
interstate
pipelines
wholly
independent
unintegrated
unaffiliated
producers
gatherers
phillips
neither
companies
involved
cases
engaged
exclusively
production
gathering
producing
transportation
companies
kansas
natural
gas
attleboro
electricity
kansas
attleboro
sold
distributing
companies
course
interstate
transmission
thus
house
report
expressed
act
aim
regulate
wholesales
sales
producing
companies
distributing
companies
immediately
thereafter
cited
kansas
attleboro
cases
report
unmistakable
reference
sales
integrated
local
distributor
refer
independent
producer
gatherer
first
independent
never
sells
local
distributors
secondly
two
cited
cases
support
reference
independents
congress
aimed
abuses
resulting
gap
end
transmission
process
integrated
unintegrated
pipelines
abuses
prior
transmission
clear
final
report
federal
trade
commission
senate
malpractices
natural
gas
industry
doc
sess
report
stimulus
federal
intervention
industry
federal
trade
commission
outlined
abuses
industry
gap
made
powerless
prevent
abuses
monopolistically
situated
pipelines
gouged
consumer
charging
local
distribution
companies
unreasonable
rates
federal
trade
commission
find
abusive
pricing
independent
producers
gatherers
anything
independents
producing
end
pipelines
likewise
victims
monopolistic
practices
pipelines
decisions
certainly
indicated
gap
distribution
end
transmission
process
thus
federal
power
commission
hope
natural
gas
observed
federal
power
commission
given
authority
production
gathering
natural
gas
producing
power
protect
interests
sell
gas
interstate
operator
emphasis
supplied
five
years
later
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
supra
said
approval
commission
inclusion
cost
production
gathering
facilities
interstate
pipeline
latter
rate
base
precedent
regulation
part
production
marketing
emphasis
supplied
today
decision
restricts
phrase
production
gathering
physical
activities
facilities
properties
used
production
gathering
gloss
strips
words
substance
congress
intended
left
state
regulation
mass
empty
pipe
vacant
processing
plants
thousands
hollow
wells
scarecrow
derricks
monuments
new
extension
federal
power
understood
years
enforcing
regulatory
laws
covering
production
gathering
including
pricing
proration
gas
ratable
taking
unitization
fields
processing
casinghead
gas
including
priority
gases
well
spacing
repressuring
abandonment
wells
marginal
area
development
devices
everyone
fully
aware
direct
relationship
price
conservation
federal
power
commission
panhandle
eastern
pipe
line
supra
power
regulate
producers
gatherers
prices
upheld
cities
service
gas
peerless
oil
gas
phillips
petroleum
oklahoma
doubt
commission
found
federal
regulation
production
gathering
collide
substantially
interfere
hinder
enforcement
state
regulatory
measures
square
result
house
report
act
subsequently
enacted
bill
drawn
complement
manner
usurp
state
regulatory
authority
supra
majority
rely
heavily
interstate
natural
gas
federal
power
commission
support
position
sure
language
case
face
seems
govern
present
case
case
involved
materially
different
fact
situation
interstate
gas
company
already
subject
federal
power
commission
jurisdiction
interstate
pipeline
operations
company
affiliated
one
pipelines
sold
addition
emphasized
fact
interstate
claim
state
regulatory
authority
made
indeed
interstate
company
successfully
resisted
state
attempts
regulate
hence
possibility
conflict
case
either
federal
power
commission
moved
interstate
remained
unregulated
perhaps
significant
factual
distinction
terms
reasoning
case
rests
fact
total
volume
gas
interstate
sold
roughly
purchased
others
produced
gathered
almost
enough
supply
needs
three
interstate
pipelines
interstate
sold
already
gathered
processed
moved
interstate
branch
trunk
main
trunk
lines
short
interstate
equivalent
middleman
gatherers
pipelines
almost
gas
sold
pipelines
performed
function
transporting
gas
purchased
gatherers
branch
trunk
main
trunk
lines
phillips
performs
middleman
transmission
function
addition
late
chief
justice
vinson
case
specifically
stated
express
opinion
validity
jurisdictional
tests
employed
commission
cases
columbian
billings
supra
since
cases
federal
power
commission
established
policy
declining
jurisdiction
rates
charged
wholly
independent
producers
gatherers
difficult
see
interstate
control
present
case
look
interstate
guidance
better
focus
following
words
late
chief
justice
clearly
among
powers
thus
reserved
power
regulate
physical
production
gathering
natural
gas
interests
conservation
consideration
legitimate
local
concern
intention
congress
give
full
freedom
matters
thus
sales
though
technically
consummated
interstate
commerce
made
course
production
gathering
closely
connected
local
incidents
process
render
rate
regulation
federal
power
commission
inconsistent
substantial
interference
exercise
state
regulatory
functions
jurisdiction
federal
power
commission
attach
words
justice
jackson
believe
observance
good
faith
requires
interpret
act
represented
time
urged
enactment
terms
read
today
declared
supplement
supplant
state
regulation
federal
power
commission
east
ohio
gas
supra
casinghead
gas
produced
oil
furnishes
pressure
latter
brought
surface
gas
shut
without
closing
oil
production
therefore
produced
regardless
demand
since
primary
recovery
oil
available
purchasers
gas
flared
burned
fields
much
casinghead
gas
still
flared
since
market
immediately
available
sound
conservation
practice
dictates
whenever
possible
casinghead
gas
used
satisfy
demand
natural
gas
wells
turned