samantar
yousuf
et
argued
march
decided
june
respondents
persecuted
somali
government
filed
damages
action
alleging
petitioner
held
high
level
government
positions
exercised
command
control
military
forces
committing
abuses
knew
known
acts
aided
abetted
commission
district
concluded
lacked
jurisdiction
granted
petitioner
motion
dismiss
suit
resting
decision
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
fsia
act
provides
foreign
state
shall
immune
jurisdiction
federal
state
courts
except
provided
act
fourth
circuit
reversed
holding
fsia
apply
officials
foreign
state
held
fsia
govern
petitioner
claim
immunity
pp
doctrine
foreign
sovereign
immunity
see
schooner
exchange
mcfaddon
cranch
state
department
granted
sovereign
diplomatic
request
suggestion
immunity
district
surrendered
jurisdiction
ex
parte
peru
state
department
refused
decide
immunity
issue
state
department
moved
policy
requesting
immunity
actions
friendly
sovereigns
restrictive
theory
confined
immunity
suits
involving
foreign
sovereign
public
acts
verlinden
central
bank
nigeria
inconsistent
application
sovereign
immunity
followed
leading
fsia
whose
primary
purposes
endorse
codify
restrictive
theory
transfer
primary
responsibility
deciding
claims
foreign
immunity
state
department
courts
act
governs
determination
whether
foreign
state
entitled
sovereign
immunity
pp
reading
fsia
whole
nothing
suggest
foreign
state
read
include
official
acting
behalf
state
act
specifies
foreign
state
includes
political
subdivision
agency
instrumentality
state
specifically
delimits
counts
agency
instrumentality
textual
clues
agency
instrumentality
definition
entity
matching
three
specified
characteristics
cut
reading
include
foreign
official
entity
typically
refers
organization
required
statutory
characteristics
separate
legal
person
apply
awkwardly
individuals
section
foreign
state
definition
also
inapplicable
list
set
even
illustrative
rather
exclusive
suggest
officials
included
since
listed
defendants
entities
conclusion
also
supported
fact
congress
expressly
mentioned
officials
elsewhere
fsia
wished
count
acts
equivalent
foreign
state
moreover
fsia
provisions
point
away
reading
foreign
state
include
foreign
officials
pp
fsia
history
purposes
also
support
petitioner
argument
act
governs
immunity
claim
little
reason
presume
congress
codified
state
immunity
intended
codify
sub
silentio
official
immunity
canon
construction
statutes
interpreted
consistently
common
law
help
decide
question
whether
statute
coverage
ambiguous
congress
intended
govern
particular
field
state
official
immunities
may
coextensive
historically
government
suggested
immunity
individual
officials
even
foreign
state
qualify
though
foreign
state
immunity
may
circumstances
extend
individual
official
acts
follow
congress
intended
codify
immunity
fsia
official
immunity
simply
problem
congress
addressing
enacting
act
construction
act
affected
risk
plaintiffs
may
use
artful
pleading
attempt
select
application
fsia
common
law
case
respondents
sued
petitioner
personal
capacity
seek
damages
pockets
governed
common
law
claim
foreign
state
defined
fsia
pp
whether
petitioner
may
entitled
immunity
whether
may
valid
defenses
matters
addressed
first
instance
district
affirmed
remanded
stevens
delivered
opinion
roberts
kennedy
ginsburg
breyer
alito
sotomayor
joined
alito
filed
concurring
opinion
thomas
filed
opinion
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
scalia
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
mohamed
ali
samantar
petitioner
bashe
abdi
yousuf
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
june
justice
stevens
delivered
opinion
petitioner
mohamed
ali
samantar
first
vice
president
minister
defense
somalia
served
prime
minister
respondents
natives
somalia
allege
members
families
victims
torture
extrajudicial
killings
years
seek
damages
petitioner
based
alleged
authorization
acts
narrow
question
must
decide
whether
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
fsia
act
et
provides
petitioner
immunity
suit
based
actions
taken
official
capacity
hold
fsia
govern
determination
petitioner
immunity
suit
respondents
members
isaaq
clan
included
prosperous
somalis
subjected
systematic
persecution
military
regime
governing
somalia
allege
petitioner
exercised
command
control
members
somali
military
forces
tortured
killed
arbitrarily
detained
members
families
petitioner
knew
known
abuses
perpetrated
subordinates
aided
abetted
commission
respondents
complaint
sought
damages
petitioner
pursuant
torture
victim
protection
act
stat
note
following
alien
tort
statute
petitioner
charge
somalia
armed
forces
military
regime
collapsed
fled
somalia
resident
virginia
recognized
entity
government
somalia
since
fall
military
regime
see
brief
amicus
curiae
respondents
filed
complaint
november
petitioner
promptly
moved
dismiss
district
stayed
proceedings
give
state
department
opportunity
provide
statement
interest
regarding
petitioner
claim
sovereign
immunity
month
ensuing
two
years
petitioner
advised
state
department
matter
consideration
ed
app
pet
cert
received
response
state
department
district
reinstated
case
active
docket
concluded
jurisdiction
granted
petitioner
motion
dismiss
district
decision
rested
squarely
fsia
provides
foreign
state
shall
immune
jurisdiction
federal
state
courts
except
provided
act
district
noted
none
parties
argued
exception
applicable
app
pet
cert
although
characterizing
statute
silent
applicability
officials
foreign
state
district
followed
appellate
decisions
holding
foreign
state
sovereign
immunity
act
extends
individual
acting
official
capacity
behalf
foreign
state
official
acts
beyond
scope
authority
quoting
velasco
government
indonesia
rejected
respondents
argument
petitioner
necessarily
acting
beyond
scope
authority
allegedly
violated
international
appeals
reversed
rejecting
district
ruling
fsia
governs
petitioner
immunity
suit
acknowledged
majority
view
among
circuits
fsia
applies
individual
officials
foreign
state
disagreed
view
however
concluded
based
language
structure
statute
fsia
apply
individual
foreign
government
agents
like
petitioner
found
fsia
govern
whether
petitioner
enjoys
immunity
suit
appeals
remanded
case
proceedings
including
determination
whether
petitioner
entitled
immunity
common
law
granted
certiorari
ii
doctrine
foreign
sovereign
immunity
developed
matter
common
law
long
fsia
enacted
verlinden
central
bank
nigeria
explained
schooner
exchange
mcfaddon
cranch
chief
justice
marshall
concluded
impliedly
waived
jurisdiction
certain
activities
foreign
sovereigns
specific
holding
schooner
exchange
federal
lacked
jurisdiction
national
armed
vessel
emperor
france
opinion
interpreted
extending
virtually
absolute
immunity
foreign
sovereigns
matter
grace
comity
verlinden
following
schooner
exchange
procedure
developed
resolving
foreign
state
claim
sovereign
immunity
typically
asserted
behalf
seized
vessels
see
republic
mexico
hoffman
ex
parte
peru
compania
espanola
de
navegacion
maritima
navemar
procedure
diplomatic
representative
sovereign
request
suggestion
immunity
state
department
ex
parte
peru
request
granted
district
surrendered
jurisdiction
see
also
hoffman
absence
recognition
immunity
department
state
district
authority
decide
whether
requisites
immunity
existed
ex
parte
peru
see
also
compania
espanola
approving
judicial
inquiry
sovereign
immunity
department
state
declined
act
heaney
government
spain
evaluating
sovereign
immunity
state
department
responded
request
views
making
decision
district
inquired
whether
ground
immunity
one
established
policy
state
department
recognize
hoffman
although
cases
involving
individual
foreign
officials
defendants
rare
procedure
typically
followed
foreign
official
asserted
immunity
see
heaney
waltier
thomson
supp
sdny
prior
state
department
followed
general
practice
requesting
immunity
actions
friendly
sovereigns
year
department
announced
adoption
restrictive
theory
sovereign
immunity
verlinden
see
also
letter
jack
tate
acting
legal
adviser
department
state
acting
attorney
general
philip
perlman
may
reprinted
dept
state
bull
theory
immunity
confined
suits
involving
foreign
sovereign
public
acts
extend
cases
arising
foreign
state
strictly
commercial
acts
verlinden
change
threw
immunity
determinations
disarray
political
considerations
sometimes
led
department
file
immunity
cases
immunity
available
restrictive
theory
republic
austria
altmann
quoting
verlinden
congress
responded
inconsistent
application
sovereign
immunity
enacting
fsia
altmann
see
also
verlinden
section
describes
act
two
primary
purposes
endorse
codify
restrictive
theory
sovereign
immunity
transfer
primary
responsibility
deciding
claims
foreign
immunity
state
department
enactment
fsia
act
common
law
indisputably
governs
determination
whether
foreign
state
entitled
sovereign
immunity
must
decide
whether
act
also
covers
immunity
claims
foreign
officials
begin
statute
text
consider
petitioner
reliance
history
purpose
iii
fsia
provides
foreign
state
shall
immune
jurisdiction
courts
except
provided
act
thus
defendant
foreign
state
within
meaning
act
defendant
immune
jurisdiction
unless
one
exceptions
act
applies
see
enumerating
exceptions
act
applies
sole
basis
obtaining
jurisdiction
foreign
state
federal
argentine
republic
amerada
hess
shipping
question
face
case
whether
individual
sued
conduct
undertaken
official
capacity
foreign
state
within
meaning
act
act
defines
foreign
state
follows
state
includes
political
subdivision
foreign
state
agency
instrumentality
foreign
state
defined
subsection
instrumentality
foreign
state
means
entity
separate
legal
person
corporate
otherwise
organ
foreign
state
political
subdivision
thereof
majority
whose
shares
ownership
interest
owned
foreign
state
political
subdivision
thereof
neither
citizen
state
defined
section
title
created
laws
third
country
term
foreign
state
face
indicates
body
politic
governs
particular
territory
see
restatement
defining
state
entity
defined
territory
population
control
government
engages
foreign
relations
however
act
establishes
foreign
state
broader
meaning
mandating
inclusion
state
political
subdivisions
agencies
instrumentalities
act
specifically
delimits
counts
agency
instrumentality
petitioner
argues
either
foreign
state
agency
instrumentality
read
include
foreign
official
although
agree
petitioner
interpretation
literally
possible
analysis
entire
statutory
text
persuades
us
petitioner
reading
meaning
congress
enacted
turn
first
term
agency
instrumentality
foreign
state
true
individual
official
agency
instrumentality
term
given
meaning
thing
person
action
accomplished
terrorist
attacks
congress
specifically
defined
agency
instrumentality
fsia
textual
clues
definition
cut
broad
construction
first
statute
specifies
instrumentality
means
entity
matching
three
specified
characteristics
emphasis
added
entity
typically
refers
organization
rather
individual
see
black
law
dictionary
ed
furthermore
several
required
characteristics
apply
awkwardly
individuals
phrase
separate
legal
person
corporate
otherwise
conceivably
refer
natural
person
solely
virtue
word
person
phrase
separate
legal
person
typically
refers
legal
fiction
allows
entity
hold
personhood
separate
natural
persons
shareholders
officers
cf
first
nat
city
bank
banco
para
el
comercio
exterior
de
cuba
separate
legal
personality
described
almost
indispensable
aspect
public
similarly
awkward
refer
person
organ
foreign
state
see
third
part
definition
applied
natural
person
natural
person
citizen
state
defined
section
subsections
refer
citizenship
corporations
estates
natural
person
created
laws
third
country
thus
terms
congress
chose
simply
evidence
intent
include
individual
officials
within
meaning
agency
instrumentality
cf
dole
food
patrickson
describing
containing
indicia
congress
corporate
formalities
mind
petitioner
proposes
second
textual
route
including
official
within
meaning
foreign
state
argues
definition
foreign
state
sets
nonexhaustive
list
includes
political
subdivisions
agencies
instrumentalities
limited
see
brief
petitioner
true
use
word
include
signal
list
follows
meant
illustrative
rather
sure
fewer
textual
clues
within
within
interpret
congress
silence
regarding
foreign
officials
even
list
merely
illustrative
still
suggests
foreign
state
encompass
officials
types
defendants
listed
entities
see
russell
motor
car
word
may
known
company
keeps
moreover
elsewhere
fsia
congress
expressly
mentioned
officials
wished
count
acts
equivalent
foreign
state
suggests
officials
included
within
unadorned
term
foreign
state
cf
kimbrough
drawing
meaning
silence
particularly
inappropriate
congress
shown
knows
address
issue
express
terms
example
congress
provided
exception
general
grant
immunity
cases
money
damages
sought
foreign
state
injury
caused
tortious
act
omission
foreign
state
official
employee
foreign
state
acting
within
scope
office
emphasis
added
reference
officials
made
similar
later
enacted
exception
see
supp
eliminating
immunity
suits
money
damages
sought
foreign
state
certain
acts
engaged
official
employee
agent
foreign
state
acting
within
scope
office
employment
agency
see
also
creating
cause
action
foreign
state
official
employee
agent
thereof
term
foreign
state
definition
includes
individual
acting
within
scope
office
phrase
official
employee
unnecessary
see
dole
food
construe
statute
manner
strained
time
render
statutory
term
superfluous
provisions
statute
also
point
away
reading
foreign
state
include
foreign
officials
congress
made
express
mention
service
process
individuals
governs
service
upon
foreign
state
political
subdivision
although
methods
listed
used
serve
individuals
example
delivery
accordance
applicable
international
convention
methods
specified
best
roundabout
ways
serving
individual
official
furthermore
congress
made
specific
remedial
choices
different
types
defendants
see
allowing
punitive
damages
agency
instrumentality
foreign
state
affording
plaintiff
greater
rights
attach
property
agency
instrumentality
compared
property
foreign
state
adopting
petitioner
reading
foreign
state
subject
claims
officials
limited
remedies
available
suits
without
much
whisper
congress
subject
instead
adopt
petitioner
textual
argument
subject
claims
different
expansive
remedial
scheme
agencies
act
careful
calibration
remedies
among
listed
types
defendants
suggests
congress
mean
cover
types
defendants
never
mentioned
text
sum
construe
statutory
phrases
isolation
read
statutes
whole
morton
reading
fsia
whole
nothing
suggest
read
foreign
state
include
official
acting
behalf
foreign
state
much
indicate
meaning
congress
text
expressly
foreclose
petitioner
reading
supports
view
respondents
act
address
official
claim
immunity
iv
petitioner
argues
fsia
best
read
cover
claim
immunity
history
purpose
discussed
outset
one
primary
purposes
fsia
codify
restrictive
theory
sovereign
immunity
congress
recognized
consistent
extant
international
law
see
observed
related
purpose
codification
international
law
time
fsia
enactment
permanent
mission
india
nations
city
new
york
examined
relevant
common
law
international
practice
interpreting
act
relationship
act
common
law
codified
petitioner
argues
construe
fsia
consistently
common
law
regarding
individual
immunity
petitioner
view
coextensive
law
state
immunity
always
immunized
foreign
official
acts
taken
behalf
foreign
state
even
reading
act
light
congress
purpose
codifying
state
sovereign
immunity
however
think
act
codified
common
law
respect
immunity
individual
officials
canon
construction
statutes
interpreted
consistently
common
law
helps
us
interpret
statute
clearly
covers
field
formerly
governed
common
canon
help
us
decide
antecedent
question
whether
statute
coverage
ambiguous
congress
intended
statute
govern
particular
field
case
whether
congress
intended
fsia
supersede
common
law
official
petitioner
argues
state
official
immunities
coextensive
congress
must
codified
official
immunity
codified
state
immunity
see
brief
petitioner
relationship
state
immunity
official
immunity
complicated
petitioner
suggests
although
need
resolve
dispute
among
parties
precise
scope
official
immunity
common
law
authority
petitioner
points
us
previously
found
instructive
see
permanent
mission
immunity
individual
officials
subject
caveat
applicable
entities
foreign
state
immunity
extends
restatement
provides
immunity
foreign
state
extends
public
minister
official
agent
state
respect
acts
performed
official
capacity
effect
exercising
jurisdiction
enforce
rule
law
state
restatement
emphasis
added
historically
government
sometimes
suggested
immunity
common
law
individual
officials
even
foreign
state
qualify
see
greenspan
crosbie
civ
glg
wl
sdny
therefore
little
reason
presume
congress
set
codify
state
immunity
must
also
sub
silentio
intended
codify
official
immunity
petitioner
urges
suit
official
must
always
equivalent
suit
state
acts
taken
state
official
behalf
state
acts
state
see
brief
petitioner
recognized
context
act
state
doctrine
official
acts
considered
acts
foreign
state
courts
one
country
sit
judgment
acts
done
within
territory
foreign
state
see
underhill
hernandez
although
act
state
doctrine
distinct
immunity
instead
provides
foreign
substantive
defense
merits
altmann
doubt
circumstances
immunity
foreign
state
extends
individual
acts
taken
official
capacity
follow
premise
congress
intended
codify
immunity
fsia
hardly
furthers
congress
purpose
clarifying
rules
judges
apply
resolving
sovereign
immunity
claims
lump
individual
officials
foreign
without
much
word
spelling
individual
officials
petitioner
stronger
case
indication
congress
intent
enact
comprehensive
solution
suits
extended
suits
individual
officials
extent
congress
contemplated
act
effect
upon
officials
evidence
points
opposite
direction
already
mentioned
legislative
history
points
toward
intent
leave
official
immunity
outside
scope
act
see
supra
although
questions
official
immunity
arise
period
far
immunity
officials
simply
particular
problem
congress
responding
enacted
fsia
fsia
adopted
rather
address
modern
world
foreign
state
enterprises
every
day
participants
commercial
activities
assure
litigants
decisions
regarding
claims
enterprises
made
purely
legal
grounds
given
reason
believe
congress
saw
problem
wanted
eliminate
state
department
role
determinations
regarding
individual
official
finally
reading
fsia
effect
make
statute
optional
courts
appeals
feared
allowing
litigants
artful
pleading
take
advantage
act
provisions
alternatively
choose
proceed
old
common
law
chuidian
philippine
nat
bank
even
suit
governed
act
may
still
barred
foreign
sovereign
immunity
common
law
every
suit
successfully
pleaded
individual
official
even
plaintiff
names
foreign
official
may
case
foreign
state
political
subdivision
agency
instrumentality
required
party
party
interest
relating
subject
action
disposing
action
person
absence
may
practical
matter
impair
impede
person
ability
protect
interest
fed
rule
civ
proc
case
entity
immune
suit
fsia
district
may
dismiss
suit
regardless
whether
official
immune
common
law
see
republic
philippines
pimentel
sovereign
immunity
asserted
claims
sovereign
frivolous
dismissal
action
must
ordered
potential
injury
interests
absent
sovereign
may
case
actions
official
official
capacity
treated
actions
foreign
state
state
real
party
interest
cf
kentucky
graham
suit
respects
name
treated
suit
entity
suit
official
personally
real
party
interest
entity
citation
omitted
thus
persuaded
construction
statute
text
affected
risk
plaintiffs
may
use
artful
pleading
attempt
select
application
fsia
common
law
think
case
respondents
sued
petitioner
personal
capacity
seek
damages
pockets
properly
governed
common
law
claim
foreign
state
act
defines
term
although
congress
clearly
intended
supersede
regime
claims
foreign
find
nothing
statute
origin
aims
indicate
congress
similarly
wanted
codify
law
foreign
official
immunity
review
text
purpose
history
fsia
leads
us
conclusion
appeals
correctly
held
fsia
govern
petitioner
claim
immunity
act
therefore
deprive
district
jurisdiction
emphasize
however
narrowness
holding
whether
petitioner
may
entitled
immunity
common
law
whether
may
valid
defenses
grave
charges
matters
addressed
first
instance
district
remand
judgment
appeals
affirmed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
mohamed
ali
samantar
petitioner
bashe
abdi
yousuf
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
june
justice
alito
concurring
join
opinion
although
think
citations
legislative
history
little
value
mohamed
ali
samantar
petitioner
bashe
abdi
yousuf
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
june
justice
thomas
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
join
opinion
except
parts
relying
legislative
history
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
et
seq
view
textual
analysis
sufficient
resolve
case
see
post
scalia
concurring
judgment
mohamed
ali
samantar
petitioner
bashe
abdi
yousuf
et
al
writ
certiorari
appeals
fourth
circuit
june
justice
scalia
concurring
judgment
admirably
careful
textual
analysis
ante
demonstrates
term
foreign
state
provision
foreign
state
shall
immune
jurisdiction
courts
include
foreign
officials
yet
insists
adding
legislative
history
analysis
understand
though
agree
absence
supposed
support
reach
different
result
even
something
legislative
history
clearly
contradicted
result
explained
away
situation
least
opinion
think
assures
us
however
thought
assurance
legislative
history
generally
used
ante
quoting
wisconsin
public
intervenor
mortier
surely
damning
faint
praise
mention
past
practice
using
legislative
history
ante
support
use
today
past
practice
practice
using
legislative
history
purpose
giving
authoritative
content
meaning
statutory
text
mortier
supra
scalia
concurring
judgment
introduction
legislative
history
serves
purpose
except
needlessly
inject
opinion
mode
analysis
justices
consider
valid
boot
fashion
isolate
superfluous
legislative
history
section
us
disagree
categorically
use
least
disagree
superfluous
use
decline
join
therefore
join
opinion
concur
result
relies
legislative
history
support
three
positions
first
explaining
phrase
agency
instrumentality
definition
foreign
state
see
refer
natural
persons
ante
says
anything
legislative
history
suggest
congress
intended
term
instrumentality
include
individuals
ante
according
legislative
history
like
statute
speaks
terms
entities
ibid
apparently
legislative
history
must
consulted
show
supports
textual
analysis
even
explain
seeming
contradiction
analysis
inconsequential
show
nothing
contains
ambiguous
language
text
beyond
reason
second
concluding
review
statute
text
legislative
history
makes
clear
congress
intend
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
address
individual
immunities
diplomatic
consular
immunity
ante
see
also
ante
cites
proposition
house
committee
report
reason
believe
read
much
less
approved
senate
indeed
members
house
committee
even
matter
members
committee
never
voted
report
case
quoted
excerpt
address
individual
immunities
general
consular
diplomatic
immunity
issue
unless
consular
diplomatic
immunity
one
hand
hand
issue
immunity
always
treated
doubt
attempt
establish
passage
contributes
nothing
analysis
present
case
also
quotes
portion
house
report
follows
bill
attempt
deal
questions
discovery
plaintiff
sought
depose
diplomat
official
foreign
government
diplomatic
official
immunity
apply
ante
anything
passage
cuts
result
two
sentences
omitted
quotation
read
follows
existing
law
appears
adequate
area
example
private
plaintiff
sought
production
sensitive
governmental
documents
foreign
state
concepts
governmental
privilege
apply
thus
house
report
makes
clear
bill
failure
deal
discovery
applies
discovery
sovereigns
discovery
foreign
officials
latter
unnecessary
bill
dealt
sovereigns
implication
bill
provisions
regarding
immunity
suit
apply
sovereigns
foreign
officials
third
finally
points
legislative
history
establish
purpose
statute
see
ante
particularly
puzzling
enacted
statutory
text
includes
findings
declaration
purpose
purpose
surprise
finds
evidenced
legislative
history
see
make
matters
worse
notes
statutory
declaration
purpose
twice
earlier
body
opinion
see
ante
textual
references
statute
deleted
footnoted
citation
legislative
history
least
perform
function
however
adds
nothing
except
demonstration
assiduous
research
cause
wonder
upon
careful
examination
opinion
excerpts
legislative
history
turn
best
nonprobative
entirely
duplicative
text
legislative
history
almost
never
real
reason
decision
deserve
lot
time
footnotes
although
set
respondents
allegations
detail
district
written
opinion
contains
comprehensive
summary
describing
abuses
respondents
suffered
also
historical
context
abuses
occurred
well
attempts
establish
stable
government
somalia
recent
years
see
ed
app
pet
cert
petitioner
argued
addition
immunity
fsia
complaint
dismissed
number
grounds
district
reach
see
hold
fsia
govern
whether
individual
foreign
official
enjoys
immunity
suit
need
reach
respondents
argument
official
immune
fsia
acts
torture
extrajudicial
killing
see
brief
respondents
note
determining
petitioner
acted
beyond
scope
authority
district
afforded
great
weight
letters
somali
transitional
federal
government
tfg
state
department
app
pet
cert
tfg
supported
petitioner
claim
immunity
stated
actions
attributed
petitioner
lawsuit
taken
petitioner
official
capacities
app
although
district
described
tfg
recognized
governing
body
somalia
app
pet
cert
recognize
tfg
entity
government
somalia
see
brief
amicus
curiae
compare
holding
fsia
govern
immunity
individual
foreign
officials
enahoro
abubakar
chuidian
philippine
nat
bank
concluding
suit
individual
official
acts
committed
official
capacity
must
analyzed
fsia
terrorist
attacks
september
keller
central
bank
nigeria
byrd
corporacion
forestal
industrial
de
olancho
central
bank
jordan
cadc
alternative
basis
decision
appeals
held
even
current
official
covered
fsia
former
official
see
agree
appeals
broader
ground
individual
officials
covered
fsia
petitioner
status
former
official
irrelevant
analysis
diplomatic
consular
officers
also
claim
specialized
immunities
accorded
officials
restatement
second
foreign
relations
law
comment
hereinafter
restatement
officials
qualifying
head
state
claim
immunity
basis
see
schooner
exchange
mcfaddon
cranch
describing
exemption
person
sovereign
jurisdiction
incompatible
dignity
full
text
entitled
findings
declaration
purpose
reads
follows
congress
finds
determination
courts
claims
foreign
immunity
jurisdiction
courts
serve
interests
justice
protect
rights
foreign
litigants
courts
international
law
immune
jurisdiction
foreign
courts
insofar
commercial
activities
concerned
commercial
property
may
levied
upon
satisfaction
judgments
rendered
connection
commercial
activities
claims
foreign
immunity
henceforth
decided
courts
conformity
principles
set
forth
chapter
petitioner
points
describes
defendants
agencies
instrumentalities
suggests
therefore
tells
us
nothing
defendants
covered
term
brief
petitioner
even
reading
petitioner
suggests
leave
us
odd
result
corporation
citizen
state
excluded
definition
thus
immune
whereas
natural
person
citizen
state
excluded
thus
retains
immunity
anything
legislative
history
suggest
congress
intended
term
agency
instrumentality
include
individuals
contrary
legislative
history
like
statute
speaks
terms
entities
see
hereinafter
first
criterion
entity
separate
legal
person
intended
include
corporation
association
foundation
entity
law
foreign
state
created
sue
sued
name
justice
scalia
may
well
correct
strictly
necessary
confirm
reading
statutory
text
consulting
legislative
history
see
post
opinion
concurring
judgment
explained
years
ago
opinion
authored
justice
white
propriety
using
legislative
history
common
sense
suggests
inquiry
benefits
reviewing
additional
information
rather
ignoring
chief
justice
marshall
put
mind
labours
discover
design
legislature
seizes
every
thing
aid
derived
fisher
cranch
legislative
history
materials
generally
misleading
jurists
never
employ
effort
discern
legislative
intent
precedents
demonstrate
practice
utilizing
legislative
history
reaches
well
past
see
wallace
parker
pet
suspect
practice
likewise
reach
well
future
wisconsin
public
intervenor
mortier
alteration
original
see
singer
singer
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
word
usually
term
enlargement
limitation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
petitioner
argues
abrogates
immunity
certain
acts
individual
officials
superfluous
officials
otherwise
immune
see
brief
petitioner
import
precisely
opposite
first
eliminates
immunity
state
certain
acts
officers
says
foreign
state
shall
immune
suit
money
damages
sought
foreign
state
expressly
refer
immunity
individual
officers
adds
nothing
petitioner
argument
second
creation
cause
action
foreign
state
official
employee
agent
thereof
reinforces
idea
foreign
state
definition
include
foreign
officials
case
fsia
legislative
history
even
hint
intent
exclude
individual
officials
chuidian
legislative
history
makes
clear
congress
intend
fsia
address
individual
immunities
diplomatic
consular
immunity
bill
intended
affect
either
diplomatic
consular
immunity
also
suggests
general
official
immunity
something
separate
subject
bill
see
bill
attempt
deal
questions
discovery
plaintiff
sought
depose
diplomat
official
foreign
government
diplomatic
official
immunity
apply
congress
understood
legislate
background
principles
astoria
fed
sav
loan
assn
solimino
statute
covers
issue
previously
governed
common
law
interpret
statute
presumption
congress
intended
retain
substance
common
law
see
isbrandtsen
johnson
statutes
invade
common
law
read
presumption
favoring
retention
familiar
principles
except
statutory
purpose
contrary
evident
find
similarly
inapposite
petitioner
invocation
canon
statute
interpreted
compliance
international
law
see
murray
schooner
charming
betsy
cranch
argument
foreign
relations
reciprocal
protection
officials
abroad
undermined
adopt
reading
act
deciding
fsia
bars
petitioner
immunity
rather
act
address
question
need
determine
whether
declining
afford
immunity
petitioner
consistent
international
law
restatement
apply
caveat
head
state
head
government
foreign
minister
see
restatement
whether
petitioner
may
entitled
head
state
immunity
immunity
common
law
question
leave
open
remand
see
express
view
whether
restatement
correctly
sets
scope
common
law
immunity
applicable
current
former
foreign
officials
respondents
contend
caveat
refers
compulsive
effect
judgment
state
brief
respondents
petitioner
disputes
meaning
reply
brief
petitioner
need
resolve
dispute
enough
present
purposes
restatement
indicates
foreign
official
immunity
may
turn
upon
requirement
applicable
type
defendant
courts
appeals
develop
complete
absence
statutory
text
rules
governing
official
entitled
immunity
fsia
example
courts
appeals
applied
rule
foreign
sovereign
immunity
extends
individual
official
acts
committed
official
capacity
official
acts
beyond
scope
authority
chuidian
may
correct
matter
principles
derive
clarification
codification
congress
furthermore
congress
intended
fsia
reach
individuals
one
expect
act
addressed
whether
former
officials
covered
issue
settled
respect
instrumentalities
see
dole
food
patrickson
nstrumentality
status
must
determined
time
suit
filed
study
attempted
gather
state
department
decisions
related
sovereign
immunity
adoption
restrictive
theory
enactment
fsia
reveals
four
decisions
related
official
immunity
two
related
head
state
immunity
total
decisions
sovereign
immunity
decisions
dept
state
may
sandler
vagts
ristau
eds
digest
practice
law
hereinafter
digest
fsia
introduced
accordance
recommendation
state
department
department
sought
supported
elimination
role
respect
claims
foreign
agencies
instrumentalities
see
hearings
subcommittee
administrative
law
governmental
relations
house
representatives
committee
judiciary
testimony
monroe
leigh
legal
adviser
dept
state
judgment
advantages
judicial
determination
greatly
outweigh
advantage
able
intervene
lawsuit
department
time
fsia
enactment
understood
act
leave
intact
department
role
official
immunity
cases
see
digest
decisions
department
regarding
immunity
officials
may
future
significance
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
deal
immunity
individual
officials
foreign
political
subdivisions
agencies
instrumentalities
furthermore
plaintiff
seeking
sue
foreign
official
able
rely
act
service
process
jurisdictional
provisions
thus
plaintiff
establish
district
personal
jurisdiction
official
without
benefit
fsia
provision
makes
personal
jurisdiction
foreign
state
automatic
exception
immunity
applies
service
process
accomplished
accordance
see
personal
jurisdiction
foreign
state
shall
exist
every
claim
relief
district
courts
jurisdiction
subsection
claims
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
service
made
section
title