navajo
nation
argued
december
decided
march
indian
mineral
leasing
act
imla
provides
nallotted
lands
within
indian
reservation
otherwise
federal
jurisdiction
may
approval
secretary
interior
secretary
leased
mining
purposes
authority
tribal
council
authorized
spokesmen
indians
act
aims
provide
indian
tribes
profitable
source
revenue
foster
tribal
giving
indians
greater
say
use
disposition
resources
lands
navajo
nation
tribe
permitted
predecessor
peabody
coal
company
peabody
mine
coal
tribe
lands
pursuant
lease
lease
lease
lease
established
maximum
royalty
rate
cents
per
ton
coal
made
figure
subject
reasonable
adjustment
secretary
anniversary
lease
every
ten
years
thereafter
lease
anniversary
approached
cents
per
ton
rate
yielded
tribe
gross
proceeds
return
higher
ten
cents
per
ton
minimum
established
regulations
implementing
imla
substantially
lower
however
rate
congress
established
minimum
permissible
royalty
coal
mined
federal
lands
mineral
leasing
act
june
area
director
bureau
indian
affairs
acting
pursuant
authority
delegated
secretary
tribe
request
sent
peabody
opinion
letter
raising
lease
rate
percent
gross
proceeds
peabody
administrative
appeal
pending
deputy
assistant
secretary
indian
affairs
john
fritz
peabody
wrote
secretary
hodel
asking
either
postpone
decision
appeal
rule
peabody
favor
peabody
representatives
also
met
privately
hodel
period
july
hodel
sent
memorandum
fritz
suggest
ing
inform
parties
decision
imminent
urging
continue
efforts
resolve
matter
mutually
agreeable
fashion
tribe
resumed
negotiations
peabody
november
parties
agreed
amend
lease
provide
among
things
royalty
rate
percent
monthly
gross
proceeds
rate
coal
leases
federal
indian
lands
pursuant
imla
secretary
hodel
approved
amended
lease
december
tribe
brought
action
damages
alleging
inter
alia
secretary
approval
lease
amendments
constituted
breach
trust
although
granting
summary
judgment
federal
claims
found
secretary
flagrantly
dishonored
government
general
fiduciary
duties
tribe
acting
peabody
best
interests
rather
tribe
nevertheless
concluded
tribe
entirely
failed
link
breach
duty
statutory
regulatory
obligation
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
government
actions
federal
circuit
reversed
relying
regulations
promulgated
thereunder
appeals
determined
measure
control
secretary
exercised
leasing
indian
lands
mineral
development
sufficed
warrant
money
judgment
agreeing
federal
claims
secretary
actions
regarding
peabody
administrative
appeal
violated
government
fiduciary
obligations
tribe
appeals
remanded
proceedings
including
determination
damages
held
mitchell
mitchell
mitchell
mitchell
ii
control
case
controversy
falls
within
mitchell
domain
tribe
claim
compensation
government
fails
derive
provision
imla
implementing
regulations
pp
state
litigable
claim
tribal
plaintiff
must
invoke
source
substantive
law
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
damages
sustained
mitchell
ii
although
indian
tucker
act
confers
jurisdiction
upon
federal
claims
cases
requirement
met
act
source
substantive
rights
mitchell
ii
pp
mitchell
mitchell
ii
pathmarking
precedents
question
whether
statute
regulation
combination
thereof
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
mitchell
ii
mitchell
held
indian
general
allotment
act
gaa
authorized
president
allot
agricultural
grazing
land
individual
tribal
members
residing
reservation
provided
government
hold
land
thus
allotted
trust
sole
use
benefit
allottee
authorize
award
money
damages
alleged
mismanagement
forests
located
allotted
lands
concluded
gaa
created
limited
trust
relationship
impose
duty
upon
government
manage
timber
resources
mitchell
mitchell
ii
however
held
network
statutes
regulations
impose
judicially
enforceable
fiduciary
duties
upon
management
forested
allotted
lands
relevant
prescriptions
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
breached
duties
state
claim
cognizable
indian
tucker
act
mitchell
mitchell
ii
instruct
tribe
must
identify
substantive
source
law
establishes
specific
fiduciary
duties
allege
government
failed
faithfully
perform
duties
see
mitchell
ii
threshold
passed
must
determine
whether
relevant
source
substantive
law
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
damages
sustained
result
breach
duties
governing
law
impose
although
undisputed
existence
general
trust
relationship
indian
people
reinforc
conclusion
relevant
statute
regulation
imposes
fiduciary
duties
relationship
alone
insufficient
support
jurisdiction
indian
tucker
act
instead
analysis
must
train
specific
statutory
regulatory
prescriptions
prescriptions
however
need
expressly
provide
money
damages
availability
damages
may
inferred
see
pp
statutes
regulations
issue
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
government
alleged
breach
trust
case
imla
regulations
provide
requisite
substantive
law
mandat
es
compensation
federal
government
mitchell
ii
impose
obligations
resembling
detailed
fiduciary
responsibilities
mitchell
ii
found
adequate
support
claim
money
damages
imla
simply
requires
secretarial
approval
coal
mining
leases
negotiated
tribes
third
parties
become
effective
authorizes
secretary
generally
promulgate
regulations
governing
mining
operations
unlike
elaborate
provisions
mitchell
ii
although
gaa
required
government
hold
allotted
land
trust
allottees
act
authoriz
much
less
requir
government
manage
timber
resources
benefit
indian
allottees
similarly
imla
regulations
assign
secretary
managerial
control
coal
leasing
even
establish
limited
trust
relationship
existing
gaa
provision
imla
regulations
contains
trust
language
respect
coal
leasing
moreover
mitchell
imposing
fiduciary
duties
government
line
one
statute
principal
purposes
enhancing
tribal
see
pp
rejects
tribe
arguments
secretary
actions
case
violated
discrete
statutory
regulatory
provisions
whose
breach
redressable
damages
action
tribe
misplaces
reliance
part
imla
govern
lease
enacted
almost
years
imla
authorizes
secretary
lease
certain
unallotted
indian
lands
mining
purposes
terms
sets
provide
input
tribes
concerned
authorization
bear
secretary
limited
approval
role
imla
similarly
unavailing
tribe
reliance
indian
mineral
development
act
imda
et
seq
imda
governs
secretary
approval
agreements
development
certain
indian
mineral
resources
exploration
like
activities
establish
standards
governing
approval
mining
leases
negotiated
tribe
third
party
lease
tribe
vigorously
pressed
arguments
headlining
imla
general
prescription
fare
better
asserting
secretary
hodel
violated
duty
review
approve
proposed
coal
leases
extent
tribe
best
interests
tribe
points
various
government
reports
identifying
percent
appropriate
royalty
secretary
decision
made
receiving
ex
parte
communications
peabody
withhold
departmental
action
circumstances
presented
tribe
maintains
hodel
eventual
approval
percent
royalty
rate
violated
two
ways
improvident
allowed
conveyance
tribe
coal
hodel
knew
half
value
unfair
hodel
intervention
lease
adjustment
process
skewed
bargaining
depriving
tribe
percent
rate
arguments
fail
assume
substantive
prescriptions
found
first
argument
neither
imla
regulations
establishes
anything
bare
minimum
royalty
textual
basis
concluding
secretary
approval
function
includes
duty
enforceable
action
money
damages
ensure
higher
rate
return
tribe
similarly
tribe
second
argument
grounded
specific
statutory
regulatory
language
nothing
imla
implementing
regulations
proscribed
ex
parte
communications
case
occurred
administrative
appeal
process
largely
unconstrained
formal
requirements
moreover
even
deputy
assistant
secretary
fritz
rendered
opinion
affirming
percent
royalty
approved
area
director
secretary
set
aside
modified
subordinate
decision
exercise
authority
head
interior
department
accordingly
rejection
peabody
appeal
fritz
necessarily
yielded
higher
royalty
tribe
pp
reversed
remanded
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
scalia
kennedy
thomas
breyer
joined
souter
filed
dissenting
opinion
stevens
joined
petitioner
navajo
nation
writ
certiorari
appeals
federal
circuit
march
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
case
concerns
indian
mineral
leasing
act
imla
stat
et
role
assigns
secretary
interior
secretary
respect
coal
leases
executed
indian
tribe
private
lessee
controversy
centers
amendments
coal
lease
entered
predecessor
peabody
coal
company
peabody
navajo
nation
tribe
federally
recognized
indian
tribe
tribe
seeks
recover
money
damages
alleged
breach
trust
connection
secretary
approval
coal
lease
amendments
negotiated
tribe
peabody
decisions
mitchell
mitchell
mitchell
mitchell
ii
control
case
concluding
controversy
falls
within
mitchell
domain
hold
tribe
claim
compensation
federal
government
fails
derive
imposing
provision
imla
implementing
regulations
imla
governs
aspects
mineral
leasing
indian
tribal
lands
unallotted
lands
within
indian
reservation
otherwise
federal
jurisdiction
may
approval
secretary
leased
mining
purposes
authority
tribal
council
authorized
spokesmen
indians
terms
exceed
ten
years
long
thereafter
minerals
produced
paying
quantities
addition
provid
ing
indian
tribes
profitable
source
revenue
cotton
petroleum
new
mexico
imla
aimed
foster
tribal
giv
ing
indians
greater
say
use
disposition
resources
found
indian
lands
bhp
minerals
prior
enactment
imla
decisions
whether
grant
mineral
leases
indian
land
generally
rested
government
see
act
june
ch
stat
amended
see
also
infra
describing
indian
consent
required
leases
sometimes
granted
tribal
objections
see
sess
fed
cl
imla
designed
advance
tribal
independence
empowers
tribes
negotiate
mining
leases
coal
leasing
assigns
primarily
approval
role
secretary
although
imla
covers
mineral
leasing
generally
number
discrete
provisions
deals
particularly
oil
gas
leases
see
requirements
public
auctions
oil
gas
leases
oil
gas
leases
subject
terms
reasonable
cooperative
unit
plan
approved
prescribed
secretary
avoid
waste
promote
conservation
natural
resources
welfare
indians
secretary
may
approve
leases
indian
lands
subsurface
storage
oil
imla
contains
similarly
specific
prescriptions
coal
leases
simply
remits
coal
leases
common
mineral
leases
governance
rules
regulations
promulgated
secretary
times
relevant
imla
regulations
provided
indian
tribes
may
approval
secretary
authorized
representative
lease
land
mining
purposes
cfr
line
imla
regulations
treated
oil
gas
leases
detail
coal
leases
regulations
regarding
royalties
example
specified
procedures
applicable
oil
gas
leases
including
criteria
secretary
employ
setting
royalty
rates
coal
royalties
contrast
regulations
required
rate
less
cents
per
ton
limitation
placed
tribe
negotiating
capacity
secretary
approval
tribe
involved
case
occupies
largest
indian
reservation
past
century
large
deposits
coal
discovered
tribe
reservation
lands
held
trust
year
tribe
receives
millions
dollars
royalty
payments
pursuant
mineral
leases
private
companies
peabody
mines
coal
tribe
lands
pursuant
leases
covered
imla
case
principally
concerns
lease
lease
lease
took
effect
upon
approval
secretary
app
lease
established
maximum
royalty
rate
cents
per
ton
coal
made
figure
subject
reasonable
adjustment
secretary
interior
authorized
representative
anniversary
lease
every
ten
years
thereafter
anniversary
lease
approached
royalty
rate
cents
per
ton
yielded
tribe
gross
proceeds
ca
fed
return
higher
ten
cents
per
ton
minimum
established
imla
regulations
see
cfr
substantially
lower
however
percent
gross
proceeds
rate
congress
established
minimum
permissible
royalty
coal
mined
federal
lands
mineral
leasing
act
see
pub
stat
amended
years
starting
gain
favorable
return
tribe
endeavored
renegotiate
existing
mineral
leases
private
lessees
including
peabody
see
app
march
chairman
navajo
tribal
council
wrote
secretary
asking
exercise
contractually
conferred
authority
adjust
royalty
rate
lease
june
director
bureau
indian
affairs
navajo
area
acting
pursuant
authority
delegated
secretary
sent
peabody
opinion
letter
raising
rate
percent
gross
proceeds
app
contesting
area
director
rate
determination
peabody
filed
administrative
appeal
july
pursuant
cfr
fed
appeal
referred
deputy
assistant
secretary
indian
affairs
john
fritz
acting
commissioner
indian
affairs
assistant
secretary
indian
affairs
march
fritz
permitted
peabody
supplement
brief
requested
additional
cost
revenue
investment
data
fed
thereafter
appeared
ready
reject
peabody
appeal
ibid
app
undated
draft
letter
june
peabody
tribe
anticipated
announcement
favorable
tribe
imminent
app
july
peabody
vice
president
wrote
interior
secretary
donald
hodel
asking
either
postpone
decision
peabody
appeal
parties
seek
negotiated
settlement
rule
peabody
favor
copy
peabody
letter
sent
tribe
submitted
letter
urging
secretary
reject
peabody
request
secure
department
prompt
release
decision
tribe
favor
peabody
representatives
met
privately
secretary
hodel
july
fed
representative
tribe
present
received
notice
meeting
july
secretary
hodel
sent
memorandum
deputy
assistant
secretary
fritz
app
memorandum
suggest
ed
fritz
inform
involved
parties
decision
th
appeal
imminent
urge
continue
efforts
resolve
matter
mutually
agreeable
fashion
royalty
adjustment
imposed
parties
without
concurrence
memorandum
stated
almost
certainly
subject
protracted
costly
appeals
well
impair
future
contractual
relationship
parties
secretary
hodel
added
however
memorandum
intended
determination
merits
arguments
parties
respect
issues
subject
appeal
tribe
told
secretary
memorandum
fritz
learned
washington
urged
return
bargaining
table
fed
see
app
facing
severe
economic
pressure
app
tribe
resumed
negotiations
peabody
august
fed
september
parties
reached
tentative
agreement
package
amendments
lease
agreed
raise
royalty
rate
percent
monthly
gross
proceeds
make
new
rate
retroactive
february
app
percent
rate
time
customary
leases
mine
coal
federal
lands
indian
amendments
acknowledged
legitimacy
tribal
taxation
coal
production
stipulated
tax
rate
capped
eight
percent
addition
peabody
agreed
pay
tribe
million
amendments
became
effective
million
peabody
began
mining
additional
coal
authorized
lease
amendments
agreement
also
addressed
ancillary
matters
provisions
future
royalty
adjustments
arbitration
procedures
rights
way
establishment
tribal
scholarship
fund
payment
peabody
back
royalties
bonuses
water
payments
fed
consideration
benefits
associated
lease
amendments
parties
agreed
move
jointly
vacate
area
director
june
decision
raised
royalty
percent
app
august
navajo
tribal
council
approved
amendments
fed
parties
signed
final
agreement
november
app
secretary
hodel
approved
december
shortly
thereafter
pursuant
parties
stipulation
area
director
decision
vacated
fed
tribe
brought
suit
federal
claims
alleging
inter
alia
secretary
approval
amendments
lease
constituted
breach
trust
tribe
sought
million
federal
claims
granted
summary
judgment
fed
cl
uncertain
terms
found
government
owed
general
fiduciary
duties
tribe
view
secretary
flagrantly
dishonored
acting
best
interests
peabody
rather
tribe
nevertheless
concluded
tribe
entirely
failed
link
breach
duty
statutory
regulatory
obligation
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
government
fiduciary
wrongs
accordingly
held
entitled
judgment
matter
appeals
federal
circuit
reversed
government
liability
tribe
said
turned
whether
controls
indian
resources
relying
regulations
promulgated
thereunder
appeals
determined
measure
control
secretary
exercised
leasing
indian
lands
mineral
development
sufficed
warrant
money
judgment
breaches
fiduciary
duties
connected
coal
leasing
see
infra
appeals
agreed
federal
claims
secretary
actions
regarding
peabody
administrative
appeal
violated
government
fiduciary
obligations
tribe
actions
suppress
ed
conceal
ed
decision
deputy
assistant
secretary
thereby
favor
ed
peabody
interests
detriment
navajo
interests
based
determinations
appeals
remanded
proceedings
including
determination
damages
judge
schall
concurred
part
dissented
part
enough
maintained
tribe
show
violation
general
fiduciary
relationship
stemming
federal
involvement
particular
area
indian
affairs
rather
tribe
must
show
breach
specific
fiduciary
obligation
falls
within
contours
statutes
regulations
create
general
fiduciary
relationship
issue
view
government
action
case
implicated
specific
fiduciary
responsibility
secretary
approval
lease
amendments
secretary
deficient
judge
schall
concluded
approving
amendments
without
first
conducting
independent
economic
analysis
amended
agreement
appeals
denied
rehearing
granted
certiorari
reverse
ii
axiomatic
may
sued
without
consent
existence
consent
prerequisite
jurisdiction
mitchell
ii
tribe
asserts
federal
jurisdiction
known
indian
tucker
act
act
provides
federal
claims
shall
jurisdiction
claim
accruing
august
favor
tribe
whenever
claim
one
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
executive
orders
president
one
otherwise
cognizable
federal
claims
claimant
indian
tribe
band
group
claim
falls
within
terms
indian
tucker
act
presumptively
consented
suit
mitchell
ii
although
indian
tucker
act
confers
jurisdiction
upon
federal
claims
source
substantive
rights
ibid
see
mitchell
state
litigable
claim
tribal
plaintiff
must
invoke
source
substantive
law
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
damages
sustained
mitchell
ii
indian
tucker
act
provides
necessary
consent
suit
however
statute
regulation
need
contain
second
waiver
sovereign
immunity
mitchell
mitchell
ii
pathmarking
precedents
question
whether
statute
regulation
combination
thereof
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
mitchell
ii
mitchell
considered
whether
indian
general
allotment
act
gaa
stat
amended
et
seq
ed
repealed
authorized
award
money
damages
alleged
mismanagement
forests
located
lands
allotted
tribal
members
gaa
authorized
president
allot
agricultural
grazing
land
individual
tribal
members
residing
reservation
provided
hold
land
thus
allotted
trust
sole
use
benefit
indian
allotment
shall
made
held
gaa
create
private
rights
enforceable
suit
money
damages
indian
tucker
act
examining
gaa
language
history
purpose
concluded
created
limited
trust
relationship
allottee
impose
duty
upon
government
manage
timber
resources
mitchell
particular
stressed
sections
gaa
removed
standard
element
trust
relationship
making
indian
allottee
representative
responsible
using
land
agricultural
grazing
purposes
see
scheme
allottee
manage
also
determined
congress
decided
land
trust
wished
government
control
use
land
simply
wished
prevent
alienation
land
ensure
allottees
immune
state
taxation
act
authoriz
much
less
requir
government
manage
timber
resources
benefit
indian
allottees
held
gaa
established
right
recover
money
damages
mismanagement
resources
left
open
however
possibility
sources
law
might
support
plaintiffs
claims
damages
mitchell
ii
held
network
statutes
regulations
impose
judicially
enforceable
fiduciary
duties
upon
management
forested
allotted
lands
contrast
bare
trust
created
gaa
observed
statutes
regulations
us
clearly
give
federal
government
full
responsibility
manage
indian
resources
land
benefit
indians
managing
forests
selling
timber
noted
congress
instructed
secretary
mindful
needs
best
interests
indian
owner
heirs
specifically
take
account
state
growth
timber
need
maintaining
productive
capacity
land
benefit
owner
heirs
highest
best
use
land
including
advisability
practicality
devoting
uses
benefit
owner
heirs
present
future
financial
needs
owner
heirs
ibid
proceeds
timber
sales
paid
land
owners
disposed
benefit
ibid
congress
prescriptions
interior
department
regulations
daily
supervision
harvesting
management
tribal
timber
department
bureau
indian
affairs
emphasized
combined
place
federal
control
irtually
every
stage
process
mitchell
ii
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
describing
comprehensive
timber
management
statutes
regulations
promulgated
thereunder
determined
statutes
regulations
establish
ed
fiduciary
obligations
government
management
operation
indian
lands
resources
concluded
relevant
legislative
executive
prescriptions
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
federal
government
damages
sustained
damages
remedy
explained
furthe
purposes
statutes
regulations
clearly
require
secretary
manage
indian
resources
generate
proceeds
indians
state
claim
cognizable
indian
tucker
act
mitchell
mitchell
ii
thus
instruct
tribe
must
identify
substantive
source
law
establishes
specific
fiduciary
duties
allege
government
failed
faithfully
perform
duties
see
threshold
passed
must
determine
whether
relevant
source
substantive
law
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
damages
sustained
result
breach
duties
governing
law
impose
although
undisputed
existence
general
trust
relationship
indian
people
reinforc
conclusion
relevant
statute
regulation
imposes
fiduciary
duties
relationship
alone
insufficient
support
jurisdiction
indian
tucker
act
instead
analysis
must
train
specific
statutory
regulatory
prescriptions
prescriptions
need
however
expressly
provide
money
damages
availability
damages
may
inferred
see
substantive
source
law
may
grant
claimant
right
recover
damages
either
expressly
implication
internal
quotation
marks
citation
omitted
consider
whether
imla
implementing
regulations
fairly
interpreted
mandating
compensation
government
alleged
breach
trust
case
conclude
tribe
principal
contention
imla
statutory
regulatory
scheme
viewed
entirety
attaches
fiduciary
duties
government
function
scheme
secretary
acted
contravention
duties
approving
percent
royalty
contained
amended
lease
see
brief
respondent
read
imla
differently
see
statute
regulations
issue
provide
requisite
substantive
law
mandat
es
compensation
federal
government
mitchell
ii
imla
implementing
regulations
impose
obligations
resembling
detailed
fiduciary
responsibilities
mitchell
ii
found
adequate
support
claim
money
imla
simply
requires
secretarial
approval
coal
mining
leases
negotiated
tribes
third
parties
become
effective
authorizes
secretary
generally
promulgate
regulations
governing
mining
operations
yet
dissent
concludes
imla
imposes
one
specific
statutory
obligations
mitchell
ii
level
fiduciary
duty
whose
breach
compensable
damages
post
endeavor
align
case
mitchell
ii
rather
mitchell
however
valiant
falls
short
mark
unlike
elaborate
provisions
mitchell
ii
imla
regulations
give
federal
government
full
responsibility
manage
indian
resources
benefit
indians
secretary
neither
assigned
comprehensive
managerial
role
time
relevant
expressly
invested
responsibility
secure
needs
best
interests
indian
owner
heirs
ibid
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
quoting
instead
secretary
involvement
coal
leasing
imla
closely
resembles
role
provided
government
gaa
regarding
allotted
forest
lands
see
mitchell
although
gaa
required
government
hold
allotted
land
trust
sole
use
benefit
indian
allotment
shall
made
quoting
act
authoriz
much
less
requir
government
manage
timber
resources
benefit
indian
allottees
mitchell
similarly
imla
regulations
assign
secretary
managerial
control
coal
leasing
even
establish
limited
trust
relationship
existing
gaa
provision
imla
regulations
contains
trust
language
respect
coal
leasing
moreover
mitchell
imposing
fiduciary
duties
government
line
one
statute
principal
purposes
gaa
designed
allottee
manage
land
imposing
upon
government
fiduciary
duty
oversee
management
allotted
lands
served
purpose
imla
aims
enhance
tribal
giving
tribes
government
lead
role
negotiating
mining
leases
third
parties
see
supra
federal
claims
recognized
ideal
indian
directly
odds
secretarial
control
leasing
fed
tribe
nevertheless
argues
actions
secretary
targeted
case
violated
discrete
statutory
regulatory
provisions
whose
breach
redressable
action
damages
regard
tribe
relies
extensively
see
brief
respondent
upon
appeals
placed
considerable
weight
well
see
supra
provision
however
part
imla
govern
lease
enacted
almost
years
imla
authorizes
secretary
lease
certain
unallotted
indian
lands
mining
purposes
terms
sets
provide
input
tribes
concerned
see
supra
exercising
authority
secretary
authorized
perform
acts
may
necessary
proper
protection
interests
indians
purpose
carrying
provisions
section
full
force
effect
provision
describes
secretary
leasing
authority
bear
secretary
limited
approval
role
imla
similarly
unavailing
tribe
reliance
indian
mineral
development
act
imda
et
seq
see
brief
respondent
imda
governs
secretary
approval
agreements
development
certain
indian
mineral
resources
exploration
like
activities
establish
standards
governing
secretary
approval
mining
leases
negotiated
tribe
third
party
lease
case
short
falls
outside
imda
domain
see
reply
brief
citing
imla
general
prescription
see
supra
tribe
next
asserts
secretary
violated
duty
review
approve
proposed
coal
lease
care
promote
imla
basic
purpose
tribe
best
interests
brief
respondent
support
assertion
tribe
points
various
government
reports
identifying
percent
appropriate
royalty
see
secretary
decision
made
receiving
ex
parte
communications
peabody
withhold
departmental
action
see
circumstances
presented
tribe
maintains
secretary
eventual
approval
percent
royalty
violated
duties
two
ways
first
secretary
approval
improvident
tr
oral
arg
allowed
tribe
coal
conveyed
secretary
knew
half
value
second
secretary
hodel
intervention
lease
adjustment
process
skewed
bargaining
depriving
tribe
percent
rate
rendering
secretary
subsequent
approval
percent
rate
unfair
tribe
vigorously
pressed
arguments
headlining
fare
better
arguments
tied
imda
arguments
fail
assume
substantive
prescriptions
found
improviden
ce
secretary
approval
tribe
point
guides
standards
circumscribing
secretary
affirmation
coal
mining
leases
negotiated
tribe
private
lessee
regulations
imla
effect
established
minimum
royalty
ten
cents
per
ton
see
cfr
royalty
contained
lease
well
exceeded
regulatory
floor
see
supra
time
secretary
approved
amended
lease
bears
repetition
percent
rate
customarily
received
leases
mine
coal
federal
lands
similarly
customary
rate
coal
leases
indian
lands
issued
readjusted
exceed
percent
see
supra
sum
neither
imla
regulations
establishes
anything
bare
minimum
royalty
hence
textual
basis
concluding
secretary
approval
function
includes
duty
enforceable
action
money
damages
ensure
higher
rate
return
tribe
concerned
similarly
pertinent
statutory
regulatory
provision
requires
secretary
pain
damages
conduct
independent
economic
analysis
reasonableness
royalty
tribe
third
party
agreed
concurring
opinion
finding
duty
tribe
second
argument
concentrates
skew
ing
effect
secretary
hodel
intervention
direction
deputy
assistant
secretary
fritz
withhold
action
peabody
appeal
area
director
decision
setting
royalty
rate
percent
tr
oral
arg
see
supra
secretary
actions
intervening
administrative
appeal
process
approving
amended
lease
tribe
urges
based
upon
assessment
merits
royalty
issue
instead
tribe
maintains
attributable
entirely
undue
influence
peabody
exerted
ex
parte
communications
secretary
see
brief
respondent
underscoring
tribe
knowledge
communications
secretary
hodel
direction
fritz
see
supra
tribe
asserts
bargaining
position
seriously
compromised
resumed
negotiations
peabody
see
tr
oral
arg
secretary
ultimate
approval
percent
royalty
tribe
concludes
thus
outcome
fundamentally
unfair
tribe
federal
claims
ultimately
determined
see
supra
tribe
assertions
grounded
specific
statutory
regulatory
provision
fairly
interpreted
mandating
money
damages
nothing
imla
basic
provision
imla
implementing
regulations
proscribed
ex
parte
communications
case
occurred
administrative
appeal
process
largely
unconstrained
formal
requirements
see
cfr
commissioner
may
rely
information
available
whether
formally
part
record
supra
either
party
effected
transfer
peabody
appeal
board
indian
appeals
see
cfr
supra
exercise
option
triggered
review
formal
character
ex
parte
communications
prohibited
see
cfr
tribe
elect
transfer
matter
board
regulatory
proscription
ex
parte
contacts
applicable
board
proceedings
thus
govern
note
moreover
even
deputy
assistant
secretary
fritz
rendered
opinion
affirming
percent
royalty
approved
area
director
open
secretary
set
aside
modify
subordinate
decision
see
supra
head
department
interior
secretary
authority
review
decision
employee
employees
department
cfr
cf
michigan
citizens
independent
press
thornburgh
cadc
upholding
attorney
general
approval
contrary
conclusions
administrative
law
judge
justice
department
antitrust
division
joint
operating
agreement
newspaper
preservation
act
aff
equally
divided
per
curiam
accordingly
rejection
peabody
appeal
deputy
assistant
secretary
necessarily
yielded
higher
royalty
tribe
however
one
might
appraise
secretary
intervention
case
warrant
relevant
statute
regulation
conclude
conduct
implicated
duty
enforceable
action
damages
indian
tucker
act
judgment
appeals
federal
circuit
accordingly
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
petitioner
navajo
nation
writ
certiorari
appeals
federal
circuit
march
justice
souter
justice
stevens
justice
join
dissenting
issue
case
whether
indian
mineral
leasing
act
regulations
imply
specific
duty
secretary
interior
part
cause
action
damages
case
breach
recognize
imla
indicates
fiduciary
duty
intended
need
provide
damages
remedy
explicitly
statutory
regulatory
provision
found
create
specific
fiduciary
obligation
right
damages
inferred
general
trust
principles
amenability
suit
indian
tucker
act
see
white
mountain
apache
tribe
ante
mitchell
mitchell
ii
part
majority
take
secretary
obligation
approve
mineral
leases
raising
substantial
fiduciary
obligation
navajo
nation
tribe
pleaded
shown
enough
survive
government
motion
summary
judgment
affirm
judgment
federal
circuit
imla
requires
secretary
approval
effectiveness
lease
negotiated
tribe
third
party
see
also
cfr
accepts
government
position
see
brief
imla
approval
responsibility
places
substantive
obligation
secretary
save
minimal
duty
withhold
assent
leases
calling
less
minimum
royalty
rate
set
imla
regulations
whatever
may
ante
since
rate
merely
general
standard
may
bargain
rate
applied
extractable
material
high
quality
obligation
demand
may
amount
much
legislative
history
purposes
imla
however
illuminated
secretary
historical
role
reviewing
conveyances
indian
lands
point
fiduciary
responsibility
make
ambitious
assessment
best
interest
tribe
signing
protective
purpose
secretary
approval
power
appeared
discussions
statutes
governing
indian
lands
years
tiger
western
investment
example
upheld
constitutionality
act
apr
ch
stat
made
alienation
certain
allotted
lands
citizen
indians
subject
approval
secretary
interior
although
allotment
conferral
citizenship
given
tribal
members
greater
responsibility
interest
see
choteau
burnet
nevertheless
understood
requirement
prior
approval
supposed
satisfy
national
government
trust
responsibility
indians
tiger
supra
accord
sunderland
restraints
alienation
indian
property
enacted
fulfillment
congress
duty
protect
indians
shortly
tiger
anicker
gunsburg
held
secretary
authority
approve
leases
allotted
lands
act
may
ch
stat
unquestionably
given
protection
indians
improvidence
designs
obtain
property
inadequate
compensation
secretary
approval
power
understood
significant
component
government
general
trust
responsibility
see
clinton
isolated
country
defense
federal
protection
indian
autonomy
stan
rev
chambers
price
regulating
sovereignty
secretarial
discretion
leasing
indian
lands
stan
rev
congress
decision
imla
give
secretary
approval
authority
well
understood
terms
background
enactment
imla
congress
devised
scheme
divided
responsibility
reminiscent
old
allotment
legislation
changed
prior
law
transferring
negotiating
authority
government
tribes
hedged
augmentation
tribal
authority
leaving
secretary
certain
powers
oversight
including
authority
approve
reject
leases
tribes
negotiated
secretary
signature
final
step
scheme
uniform
leasing
procedures
designed
protect
indians
montana
blackfeet
tribe
imposed
concern
existing
laws
adequate
give
indians
greatest
return
property
basic
purpose
secretary
powers
imla
thus
maximize
tribal
revenues
reservation
lands
navajo
tribe
see
blackfeet
tribe
supra
consistent
aim
secretary
imla
regulations
effect
provide
administrative
actions
including
lease
approvals
taken
best
interest
indian
mineral
owner
cfr
see
also
stating
overarching
purpose
imla
regulations
ensure
indians
mineral
resources
developed
manner
maximizes
best
economic
interests
thus
viewed
light
imla
legislative
history
general
trust
relationship
indians
see
mitchell
ii
supports
existence
fiduciary
responsibility
review
mineral
leases
substance
safeguard
indians
mean
suggest
devising
specific
standard
responsibility
simple
matter
ignore
tension
imla
two
objectives
thought
solely
terms
aim
ensure
negotiated
leases
maximize
tribal
revenues
supra
ignore
object
imla
provide
greater
tribal
responsibility
secretary
oversight
acting
hedge
see
royster
mineral
development
indian
country
evolution
tribal
control
mineral
resources
tulsa
rev
noting
twin
aims
imla
stringent
substantive
obligation
secretary
less
scope
tribal
responsibility
however
errs
opposite
direction
giving
overriding
weight
interest
tribal
autonomy
point
concluding
secretary
approval
obligation
onerous
one
ante
thus
losing
sight
mixture
congressional
objectives
standard
responsibility
simply
give
whole
hog
one
congressional
policy
case
essay
ultimate
formulation
balanced
standard
even
reticent
formulation
fiduciary
obligation
require
secretary
withhold
approval
good
reason
doubt
negotiated
rate
within
range
reasonable
market
rates
coal
question
reason
know
tribe
placed
unfair
disadvantage
negotiating
table
acts
see
restatement
second
trusts
modest
standards
enough
keep
present
suit
tribe
pleaded
breach
trust
respect
submitted
evidence
get
past
summary
judgment
either
alternative
record
discloses
serious
indications
percent
royalty
rate
lease
amendments
substantially
less
fair
market
value
tribe
high
quality
coal
course
deciding
percent
reasonable
adjustment
terms
lease
area
director
board
indian
affairs
bia
considered
several
independent
economic
studies
one
recommending
rates
around
percent
one
specifically
rejecting
percent
inadequate
app
conclusions
confirmed
expert
bia
energy
mineral
division
supplemental
report
submitted
peabody
appealed
area
director
decision
report
endorsed
percent
rate
expressly
found
royalty
rate
much
higher
federal
government
receives
coal
navajo
coal
extremely
valuable
federal
study
ever
recommended
royalty
rate
percent
yet
secretary
approved
rate
little
half
case
federal
circuit
judge
schall
took
sensible
position
secretary
obligated
obtain
independent
market
study
assess
rate
circumstances
see
opinion
concurring
part
dissenting
part
record
stands
shows
secretary
clearly
open
claim
fiduciary
breach
approving
rate
information
said
course
recognize
secretary
obligation
approve
leases
royalty
rates
isolation
allegation
approved
otherwise
unjustified
rate
apparently
well
market
particular
resource
deposit
certainly
raises
claim
breach
tribe
made
powerful
showing
secretary
knew
perfectly
well
intervention
behalf
peabody
derailed
lease
adjustment
proceeding
probability
yielded
percent
rate
ex
parte
meeting
peabody
representatives
secretary
put
name
memorandum
drafted
peabody
directing
deputy
assistant
secretary
fritz
withhold
decision
affirming
percent
rate
directing
mislead
tribe
telling
decision
merits
adjustment
imminent
fact
affirmance
prepared
fritz
signature
directing
encourage
tribe
shift
attention
area
director
appealed
award
percent
return
negotiating
table
percent
never
even
possibility
app
purpose
predictable
effect
actions
induce
tribe
take
deep
discount
royalty
rate
face
tribe
feared
otherwise
prolonged
revenue
loss
uncertainty
point
evidence
secretary
violated
rule
procedure
administrative
appeals
ante
statutory
duty
regarding
royalty
adjustments
terms
earlier
lease
facts
support
tribe
claim
secretary
defaulted
fiduciary
responsibility
withhold
approval
inadequate
lease
accepted
tribe
disadvantage
secretary
intentionally
say
tribe
end
recovery
end
day
disputed
facts
tried
negotiations
affected
lease
subject
adjustment
demand
also
leases
apparently
subject
option
tribe
benefit
renegotiated
terms
affected
lease
provisions
royalties
including
tax
terms
say
net
changes
may
overall
bargain
tribe
interest
despite
smaller
royalty
figure
lease
approved
issue
whether
tribe
claims
address
one
specific
statutory
obligations
mitchell
ii
level
fiduciary
duty
whose
breach
compensable
damages
tribe
pleaded
duty
record
shows
tribe
case
try
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
well
events
issue
minimum
rate
new
coal
leases
increased
percent
value
production
produced
sold
lease
fed
reg
cfr
amended
regulations
state
however
lower
royalty
rate
shall
allowed
determined
best
interest
indian
mineral
owner
required
regulations
see
cfr
peabody
served
notice
appeal
tribe
exercised
right
file
response
see
regulations
effect
required
deputy
assistant
secretary
ender
written
decision
appeal
efer
appeal
board
indian
appeals
board
ithin
days
time
pleadings
expired
days
elapsed
june
app
either
party
entitled
matter
transferred
board
cfr
neither
peabody
tribe
chose
go
route
entailed
formalized
possibly
protracted
additional
administrative
process
see
appeals
board
indian
appeals
shall
made
manner
provided
department
hearings
appeals
procedures
cfr
part
subpart
cfr
general
rules
applicable
proceedings
appeal
board
special
rules
applicable
appeals
administrative
actions
officials
bureau
indian
affairs
conclusion
proceedings
board
either
side
sought
reconsideration
requested
review
director
office
hearings
appeals
secretary
interior
deputy
assistant
secretary
draft
opinion
letter
stated
ruling
based
exercise
discretionary
authority
final
department
app
letter
issued
peabody
entitled
seek
review
board
see
cfr
board
may
review
decisions
commissioner
indian
affairs
decision
based
interpretation
law
see
also
supra
deputy
assistant
secretary
acting
commissioner
indian
affairs
even
opinion
letter
issued
drafted
peabody
asked
secretary
hodel
exercise
authority
review
decision
employee
employees
department
cfr
secretary
render
ed
final
decision
direct
ed
deputy
assistant
secretary
reconsider
decision
parties
also
agreed
raise
royalty
rate
another
lease
issue
covered
coal
located
within
former
joint
use
area
shared
navajo
nation
hopi
tribe
fed
cl
unlike
lease
lease
contain
provision
subjecting
rate
reasonable
adjustment
secretary
twelve
percent
minimum
royalty
rate
set
congress
leases
mine
coal
federal
lands
see
also
customary
rate
found
leases
issued
readjusted
see
department
interior
minerals
management
minerals
revenue
management
general
eral
american
indian
mineral
lease
terms
http
available
clerk
case
file
tribe
identifies
single
federal
coal
lease
royalty
rate
percent
see
brief
respondent
government
points
lease
part
experimental
leasing
policy
tried
department
short
time
reply
brief
quoting
peabody
coal
department
interior
practice
approve
imla
leases
royalties
less
minimum
rate
federal
coal
percent
see
app
ca
fed
late
customary
royalty
rate
coal
leases
indian
lands
issued
readjusted
exceed
percent
see
department
interior
minerals
management
mineral
revenues
report
receipts
federal
indian
leases
table
http
available
clerk
case
file
tribe
argues
presentation
percent
provided
amended
lease
facial
royalty
rate
brief
respondent
actual
rate
lower
see
tr
oral
arg
assertion
based
part
tribe
agreement
amended
lease
relinquish
claim
million
back
taxes
million
back
royalties
see
fed
part
proposed
findings
fact
tribe
submitted
federal
claims
government
specifically
dispute
see
app
ca
fed
pp
proposed
findings
stated
provision
amended
lease
signifying
method
calculating
royalty
app
proposed
findings
resulted
royalty
payments
lower
minimum
allowable
federal
coal
proposed
findings
extent
tribe
assails
secretary
approval
lease
inconsistent
federal
policy
approve
rates
percent
pursue
point
tribe
failed
rely
see
fed
claim
tribe
secretary
approval
lease
ran
afoul
th
federal
policy
approving
imla
leases
royalty
rates
less
decision
navajo
tribe
unsettled
whether
tribe
levy
taxes
without
approval
secretary
interior
imposition
severance
tax
course
augmented
amount
payable
lessee
tribe
see
fed
royalties
taxes
combined
permit
tribe
realize
much
percent
see
tr
oral
arg
ca
tax
percent
coal
goes
navajo
enerating
tation
tax
waiver
plant
site
tribe
filed
separate
action
peabody
claiming
improper
influence
government
actions
respect
lease
see
navajo
nation
peabody
holding
civ
action
june
tribe
complaint
action
alleges
violations
federal
racketeer
influenced
corrupt
organizations
act
et
related
wrongdoing
inter
alia
breach
contract
interference
fiduciary
relationship
conspiracy
fraudulent
concealment
see
navajo
nation
peabody
holding
supp
dc
ruling
pretrial
motions
federal
claims
also
rejected
tribe
claim
breach
contract
determining
secretary
party
lease
contractual
authority
adjust
royalty
rate
carried
obligation
fed
tribe
appeal
ruling
reference
claims
otherwise
cognizable
federal
claims
incorporates
tucker
act
see
mitchell
ii
tucker
act
grants
federal
claims
jurisdiction
render
judgment
upon
claim
founded
either
upon
constitution
act
congress
regulation
executive
department
upon
express
implied
contract
liquidated
unliquidated
damages
cases
sounding
tort
rule
government
role
coal
leasing
process
imla
earlier
recounted
see
supra
imla
implementing
regulations
address
oil
gas
leases
considerably
detail
coal
leases
whether
secretary
fiduciary
obligations
enforceable
action
money
damages
respect
oil
gas
leases
us
tribe
dissent
refer
portions
cfr
pt
require
administrative
decisions
affecting
tribal
mineral
interests
made
best
interests
tribal
mineral
owner
see
brief
respondent
post
note
however
referenced
regulatory
provisions
adopted
decade
events
issue
case
see
fed
reg
lease
authorized
secretary
make
reasonable
royalty
adjustment
app
noted
however
see
supra
federal
claims
determined
tribe
dispute
secretary
signatory
lease
lease
contractually
binding
see
fed
thus
perceive
basis
infusing
secretary
approval
function
substantive
standards
might
derived
adjustment
authority
lease
certainly
basis
concluding
alleged
breach
standards
cognizable
action
money
damages
indian
tucker
act
tribe
contend
amended
lease
failed
meet
minimum
royalty
regulations
effect
need
decide
whether
secretary
approval
lease
trigger
money
damages
see
reply
brief
may
assume
present
purposes
failure
secretary
ensure
prior
approving
proposed
lease
terms
amendments
comply
regulation
specifying
minimum
royalty
rate
parties
may
agree
support
claim
tucker
customary
rate
also
statutorily
defined
minimum
federal
coal
leases
see
supra
section
applies
federal
lands
general
apply
leases
indian
lands
cfr
promulgated
see
reply
brief
times
relevant
sole
specific
provision
governing
lessee
coal
leases
ten
cents
per
ton
minimum
prescribed
cfr
citing
language
legislative
history
dissent
stresses
imla
aimed
part
give
indians
greatest
return
property
post
quoting
suggests
secretary
approval
role
encompasses
enforceable
duty
objective
see
post
cautioned
according
talismanic
effect
senate
report
reference
greatest
return
indian
property
observed
overstates
congress
aim
attribute
legislature
purpose
guarantee
indian
tribes
maximum
profit
available
cotton
petroleum
new
mexico
beyond
doubt
imla
designed
provide
indian
tribes
profitable
source
revenue
quoted
supra
congress
concrete
objective
regard
removal
certain
impediments
applied
particularly
mineral
leases
indian
land
see
cotton
congress
concerned
matters
unavailability
extralateral
mineral
rights
indian
land
public
domain
discoverer
mineral
deposit
gets
extralateral
rights
follow
ore
beyond
side
lines
indefinitely
indian
lands
act
june
limited
confines
survey
markers
exceed
feet
feet
one
claim
draft
bill
herewith
permit
obtaining
sufficient
acreage
remove
necessity
extralateral
rights
attending
controversies
objective
discrete
secretary
lease
approval
role
imla
find
solid
basis
imla
regulations
lofty
statements
legislative
history
legally
enforceable
command
secretary
disapprove
indian
coal
leases
unless
survive
independent
market
study
post
satisfy
extratextual
criterion
tribal
profitability
footnotes
addition
interior
department
times
relevant
case
place
internal
policy
providing
mineral
leases
approved
terms
conditions
lease
best
interest
indian
landowner
app
majority
seeks
distinguish
mitchell
ii
saying
timber
management
statutes
issue
gave
secretary
comprehensive
managerial
role
stated
explicitly
timber
sales
made
consideration
needs
best
interests
indian
owner
heirs
ante
comprehensiveness
secretary
role
described
made
mitchell
ii
easy
case
mitchell
ii
say
however
fiduciary
duties
found
government
elaborate
control
mitchell
ii
reference
statute
explicit
best
interests
language
foreclose
use
standard
interpretive
tools
like
legislative
history
determine
whether
statute
establishes
fiduciary
duty
majority
proceeds
discount
imla
legislative
history
suggesting
congress
concern
indian
revenues
limited
elimination
certain
constraints
peculiar
indian
mineral
leases
ante
cited
imla
legislative
reports
indicate
congress
aims
restricted
curing
specific
deficiencies
prior
law
nothing
detract
consistent
recognition
precedents
imla
leasing
procedures
designed
protect
indian
interests
mineral
resources
bureau
mines
recommended
adjusted
royalty
rate
percent
bia
division
energy
mineral
resources
recommended
percent
separate
report
several
private
studies
also
endorsed
rates
percent
range
one
conducted
council
energy
resource
tribes
concluded
rate
percent
another
prepared
private
management
consultant
firm
request
navajo
advocated
rate
percent
report
significantly
lower
rate
report
submitted
peabody
recommended
rate
percent
figure
based
current
fair
value
rather
rate
restore
benefits
originally
contemplated
lease
signed
parties
possibility
secretary
set
aside
fritz
rejection
peabody
appeal
despite
suggestion
ante
defeat
tribe
claim
initial
matter
whatever
formal
authority
secretary
may
nothing
cited
parties
suggests
secretary
considering
action
painted
plainly
catering
peabody
hence
cautious
qualification
memorandum
fritz
emphasizing
intervention
intended
determination
merits
percent
rate
adjustment
app
given
federal
economic
surveys
unanimously
endorsed
percent
unclear
basis
secretary
reject
rate
merits
importantly
gravamen
tribe
claim
entitled
percent
rate
adjustment
lease
rather
secretary
actions
deceiving
tribe
status
peabody
appeal
skewed
subsequent
bargaining
process
resulting
royalty
rate
peabody
favor
issue
whether
secretary
might
ultimately
favored
peabody
appeal
perhaps
subject
relevant
evidence
dispositive