tohono
nation
argued
november
decided
april
respondent
tohono
nation
nation
filed
suit
federal
district
federal
officials
managed
tribal
assets
held
trust
federal
government
alleging
violations
fiduciary
duty
requesting
equitable
relief
next
day
nation
filed
action
federal
claims
cfc
alleging
almost
identical
violations
requesting
money
damages
cfc
case
dismissed
bars
cfc
jurisdiction
claim
plaintiff
another
suit
respect
claim
pending
agents
another
federal
circuit
reversed
finding
two
suits
respect
claim
although
shared
operative
facts
seek
overlapping
relief
held
two
suits
respect
claim
precluding
cfc
jurisdiction
based
substantially
operative
facts
regardless
relief
sought
suit
pp
since
congress
restricted
jurisdiction
cfc
predecessors
related
actions
pending
elsewhere
keene
held
two
suits
respect
claim
based
substantially
operative
facts
least
overlap
relief
requested
reserved
question
whether
jurisdictional
bar
operates
suits
based
operative
facts
seek
overlapping
relief
rule
codified
first
enacted
curb
duplicate
lawsuits
residents
confederacy
seeking
recover
cotton
taken
federal
government
sued
government
claims
time
sued
federal
officials
courts
seeking
tort
relief
actions
section
robust
response
problem
bars
cfc
jurisdiction
plaintiff
sues
identical
claim
elsewhere
also
action
related
identical
phrase
respect
resolve
doubt
bar
scope
suggests
broad
prohibition
regardless
whether
claim
carries
special
limited
meaning
pp
keene
permits
two
constructions
respect
claim
one
based
facts
alone
factual
plus
remedial
overlap
former
reasonable
interpretation
light
statute
use
similar
phrase
way
consistent
factual
overlap
cfc
bar
applies
action
person
cause
action
arose
respect
thereto
acting
color
federal
law
time
cause
action
arose
person
act
respect
relief
requested
complaint
yet
filed
although
phrase
issue
involves
claim
rather
cause
action
reason
think
phrases
refer
facts
alone
relief
keene
explained
used
synonymously
action
phrase
uses
cause
action
technical
term
embrace
concept
remedy
reasonable
conclude
neither
phrase
pp
reading
also
makes
sense
light
cfc
unique
remedial
powers
cfc
judicial
forum
nontort
requests
significant
monetary
relief
general
power
provide
equitable
relief
government
officers
statute
aimed
precluding
duplicate
cfc
suits
unlikely
require
remedial
overlap
remedial
overlap
even
unusual
rule
first
enacted
federal
circuit
identify
purpose
statute
served
light
precedent
courts
render
statutes
nugatory
construction
statute
purpose
clear
origins
need
save
government
redundant
litigation
conclusion
two
suits
respect
claim
share
substantially
operative
facts
allows
statute
achieve
aim
concentrating
operative
facts
also
consistent
doctrine
claim
preclusion
res
judicata
nation
errs
arguing
interpretation
unjustly
forces
plaintiffs
choose
partial
remedies
available
different
courts
nation
recovered
losses
cfc
alone
even
hardship
shown
enjoy
add
exception
remove
apparent
hardship
keene
supra
pp
substantial
overlap
operative
facts
nation
district
cfc
suits
precludes
jurisdiction
cfc
actions
allege
holds
assets
trust
nation
benefit
describe
almost
identical
breaches
fiduciary
duty
pp
reversed
remanded
kennedy
delivered
opinion
roberts
scalia
thomas
alito
joined
sotomayor
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
breyer
joined
ginsburg
filed
dissenting
opinion
kagan
took
part
consideration
decision
case
petitioner
tohono
nation
writ
certiorari
appeals
federal
circuit
april
justice
kennedy
delivered
opinion
tohono
nation
indian
tribe
federal
recognition
nation
main
reservation
sonoran
desert
southern
arizona
counting
reservation
lands
nation
landholdings
approximately
million
acres
nation
brought
two
actions
based
alleged
violations
fiduciary
duty
respect
nation
lands
assets
one
action
filed
federal
officials
district
federal
claims
cfc
appeals
federal
circuit
held
cfc
suit
barred
rule
cfc
lacks
jurisdiction
action
respect
claim
also
subject
action
pending
another
question
presented
whether
common
factual
basis
like
one
apparent
nation
suits
suffices
bar
jurisdiction
case
turns
relationship
two
suits
nation
filed
first
suit
filed
district
district
columbia
federal
officials
responsible
managing
tribal
assets
held
trust
federal
government
complaint
alleged
various
violations
fiduciary
duty
respect
assets
nation
claimed
example
officials
failed
provide
accurate
accounting
trust
property
refrain
use
reasonable
skill
investing
trust
assets
complaint
requested
equitable
relief
including
accounting
next
day
nation
filed
instant
action
cfc
cfc
complaint
described
trust
assets
fiduciary
duties
subject
district
complaint
alleged
almost
identical
violations
fiduciary
duty
requested
money
damages
cfc
case
dismissed
want
jurisdiction
divided
panel
appeals
federal
circuit
reversed
two
suits
respect
claim
reasoned
share
operative
facts
also
seek
overlapping
relief
finding
overlap
relief
requested
held
two
suits
issue
respect
claim
granted
certiorari
ii
since
congress
restricted
jurisdiction
cfc
predecessors
related
actions
pending
elsewhere
section
identical
respects
original
statute
provides
federal
claims
shall
jurisdiction
claim
respect
plaintiff
assignee
pending
suit
process
person
time
cause
action
alleged
suit
process
arose
respect
thereto
acting
professing
act
directly
indirectly
authority
rule
straightforward
complex
wording
suggests
cfc
jurisdiction
claim
plaintiff
another
suit
respect
claim
pending
agents
question
resolved
means
two
suits
respect
claim
keene
provided
partial
answer
held
two
suits
respect
claim
based
substantially
operative
facts
least
overlap
relief
requested
keene
case
decide
whether
jurisdictional
bar
also
operates
suits
based
operative
facts
seek
overlapping
relief
still
keene
narrows
permissible
constructions
respect
claim
one
two
interpretations
either
requires
substantial
factual
remedial
overlap
requires
substantial
factual
overlap
without
congress
first
enacted
jurisdictional
bar
codified
curb
duplicate
lawsuits
brought
residents
confederacy
following
civil
war
cotton
claimants
named
suits
recover
cotton
taken
federal
government
sued
claims
abandoned
property
collection
act
stat
time
suing
federal
officials
courts
seeking
relief
tort
law
alleged
actions
see
keene
supra
schwartz
section
judicial
code
duplicate
suits
government
agents
geo
although
rule
embodied
originated
long
ago
congress
reenacted
statute
various
times
recently
see
act
june
stat
keene
text
reflects
robust
response
problem
first
presented
cotton
claimants
bars
jurisdiction
cfc
plaintiff
sues
identical
claim
elsewhere
suit
claim
also
plaintiff
action
related
although
identical
suit
respect
claim
phrase
respect
resolve
doubt
scope
jurisdictional
bar
make
clear
congress
intend
statute
rendered
useless
narrow
concept
identity
suggests
broad
prohibition
regardless
whether
claim
carries
special
limited
meaning
cf
jones
claim
little
tucker
act
refers
requests
money
two
constructions
respect
claim
keene
permits
one
based
facts
alone
factual
plus
remedial
overlap
former
reasonable
interpretation
light
statute
use
similar
phrase
way
consistent
factual
overlap
cfc
bar
applies
even
action
government
instead
person
time
cause
action
alleged
suit
process
arose
respect
thereto
acting
professing
act
directly
indirectly
authority
statute
refers
person
acts
color
federal
law
respect
cause
action
time
arose
time
person
act
respect
relief
requested
complaint
yet
filed
use
phrase
respect
cause
action
must
refer
operative
facts
whatever
remedies
aggrieved
party
might
later
request
person
acts
color
federal
law
respect
cause
action
claiming
wielding
federal
authority
relevant
factual
context
although
two
phrases
identical
one
respect
claim
cause
action
almost
reason
think
phrases
refer
facts
alone
relief
keene
explained
term
used
synonymously
action
either
two
phrases
include
operative
facts
specific
remedy
one
uses
term
cause
action
rather
claim
cause
action
technical
term
claim
often
used
commonsense
way
mean
right
demand
reasons
stated
preceding
paragraph
respect
cause
action
refers
simply
facts
without
regard
judicial
remedies
phrase
technical
two
terms
embrace
concept
remedy
reasonable
conclude
neither
phrase
even
terms
claim
cause
action
include
request
relief
phrase
respect
gives
statutory
bar
broader
scope
reading
statute
require
factual
also
remedial
overlap
makes
sense
light
unique
remedial
powers
cfc
cfc
judicial
forum
requests
significant
monetary
relief
see
ed
supp
iii
unlike
district
courts
however
cfc
general
power
provide
equitable
relief
government
officers
compare
king
see
also
alire
wall
judgments
claims
authorized
render
government
judgments
money
found
due
government
petitioner
distinct
jurisdiction
cfc
makes
overlapping
relief
exception
distinct
relief
norm
reason
statute
aimed
precluding
suits
cfc
duplicate
suits
elsewhere
unlikely
require
remedial
overlap
remedial
overlap
cfc
actions
courts
even
unusual
rule
first
enacted
time
cfc
limited
jurisdiction
tucker
act
general
waiver
sovereign
immunity
claims
monetary
relief
yet
enacted
see
stat
district
courts
today
adjudicate
suits
money
damages
little
tucker
act
federal
tort
claims
act
sued
claims
mitchell
sisk
litigation
federal
government
ed
kinds
suits
forms
relief
available
constrained
remedial
overlap
cfc
suits
courts
even
less
common
statute
require
remedial
well
factual
overlap
limited
application
despite
broad
language
bars
identical
also
related
claims
rule
effects
significant
jurisdictional
limitation
congress
reenacted
even
changes
structure
courts
made
suits
facts
likely
arise
reaffirmed
force
bar
thus
commitment
curtailing
redundant
litigation
panel
appeals
identify
purpose
serves
today
large
part
bound
circuit
precedent
left
statute
without
meaningful
force
example
panel
cited
tecon
engineers
cl
held
prohibit
two
identical
suits
proceeding
long
action
cfc
time
claims
filed
first
tecon
holding
presented
case
cfc
action
filed
district
suit
still
appeals
wrong
allow
precedent
suppress
statute
aims
courts
render
statutes
nugatory
construction
fact
statute
purpose
clear
origins
cotton
claimants
need
save
government
burdens
redundant
litigation
purpose
less
significant
today
conclusion
two
suits
respect
claim
based
substantially
operative
facts
allows
statute
achieve
aim
keene
supra
developing
factual
record
responsible
much
cost
litigation
discovery
conspicuous
example
preparation
examination
witnesses
trial
another
form
relief
requested
matters
less
except
insofar
affects
facts
parties
must
prove
interpretation
focused
facts
rather
relief
party
seeks
preserves
provision
meant
function
keeps
provision
becoming
mere
pleading
rule
circumvented
carving
single
transaction
overlapping
pieces
seeking
different
relief
cf
casman
cl
cfc
jurisdiction
notwithstanding
common
facts
district
suit
plaintiff
sought
different
relief
forum
concentrating
operative
facts
also
consistent
doctrine
claim
preclusion
res
judicata
bars
repetitious
suits
involving
cause
action
competent
jurisdiction
entered
final
judgment
merits
commissioner
sunnen
jurisdictional
bar
enacted
part
address
problem
judgments
suits
officers
preclusive
suits
matson
nav
surprise
statute
operate
similar
fashion
test
preclusion
law
determining
whether
two
suits
involve
claim
cause
action
depends
factual
overlap
barring
claims
arising
transaction
kremer
chemical
constr
see
also
restatement
second
judgments
transactional
test
course
much
younger
rule
embodied
even
century
uncommon
identify
claim
preclusion
purposes
based
facts
rather
relief
see
wells
res
adjudicata
stare
decisis
true
distinction
demands
rights
action
single
entire
several
distinct
former
immediately
arise
one
act
contract
latter
different
acts
contracts
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
black
law
judgments
test
identity
evidence
support
establish
present
former
cause
action
reading
depend
underlying
facts
also
relief
requested
gives
effect
principles
preclusion
law
embodied
statute
merit
nation
assertion
interpretation
adopted
prevail
unjust
forcing
plaintiffs
choose
partial
remedies
available
different
courts
hardship
case
far
clear
nation
filed
cfc
alone
successful
obtained
monetary
relief
compensate
losses
caused
government
breach
duty
also
seems
likely
indian
tribes
nation
position
go
district
first
without
losing
chance
later
file
cfc
congress
provided
every
appropriations
act
department
interior
since
statute
limitations
indian
trust
mismanagement
claims
shall
run
affected
tribe
given
appropriate
accounting
see
stat
stat
even
hardship
shown
considerations
policy
divorced
statute
text
purpose
override
meaning
although
congress
permitted
claims
monetary
relief
cfc
relief
available
grace
right
see
beers
arkansas
permission
altogether
voluntary
part
sovereignty
follows
may
prescribe
terms
conditions
consents
sued
manner
suit
shall
conducted
indeed
statute
leads
incomplete
relief
plaintiffs
like
nation
dissatisfied
free
direct
complaints
congress
enjoy
add
exception
remove
apparent
hardship
keene
quoting
corona
coal
keene
reserved
question
whether
common
facts
sufficient
bar
cfc
action
similar
case
pending
elsewhere
continue
reserve
question
force
cfc
engage
unnecessary
complicated
remedial
inquiry
increase
expense
duration
litigation
question
thus
demands
answer
answer
yes
two
suits
respect
claim
precluding
jurisdiction
cfc
based
substantially
operative
facts
regardless
relief
sought
suit
iii
remaining
question
whether
nation
two
suits
sufficient
factual
overlap
trigger
jurisdictional
bar
cfc
dismissed
action
part
concluded
facts
nation
two
suits
practical
purposes
identical
fed
cl
correct
two
actions
allege
holds
assets
trust
nation
benefit
describe
almost
identical
breaches
fiduciary
duty
engaged
imprudent
investment
failed
provide
accurate
accounting
assets
held
trust
example
indeed
appears
nation
filed
two
identical
complaints
save
caption
prayer
relief
without
changing
either
suit
significant
respect
substantial
overlap
operative
facts
nation
district
cfc
suits
precludes
jurisdiction
cfc
appeals
erred
concluded
otherwise
iv
holding
precludes
cfc
exercising
jurisdiction
nation
suit
district
case
pending
nation
choose
dismiss
latter
action
upon
action
completion
nation
free
file
suit
cfc
statute
limitations
bar
meantime
light
substantial
overlap
operative
facts
two
suits
respect
claim
cfc
case
must
dismissed
contrary
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
justice
kagan
took
part
consideration
decision
case
petitioner
tohono
nation
writ
certiorari
appeals
federal
circuit
april
justice
sotomayor
justice
breyer
joins
concurring
judgment
congress
enacted
statute
currently
codified
put
end
parallel
litigation
seeking
duplicative
relief
agents
respondent
tohono
nation
seeks
federal
claims
cfc
relief
facts
pending
district
action
accordingly
applying
decision
keene
agree
bars
nation
cfc
action
nation
two
actions
seek
overlapping
relief
case
present
question
decides
today
whether
bars
action
cfc
plaintiff
actions
share
common
factual
basis
seek
different
forms
relief
nonetheless
holds
common
factual
basis
alone
suffices
bar
jurisdiction
cfc
reading
statute
plaintiff
pursue
claim
cfc
based
facts
another
pending
action
even
congress
required
plaintiff
file
separate
actions
two
courts
obtain
different
forms
relief
necessary
make
plaintiff
whole
agree
demands
result
section
bars
jurisdiction
cfc
claim
respect
plaintiff
pending
suit
process
agent
keene
construed
statute
turn
whether
plaintiff
suit
based
substantially
operative
facts
claims
action
least
overlap
relief
requested
irrelevant
purposes
observed
two
suits
proceeded
different
legal
theories
plaintiff
actions
sought
monetary
relief
albeit
different
theories
held
cfc
lacked
jurisdiction
thus
found
unnecessary
consider
whether
barred
cfc
claim
based
substantially
operative
facts
another
suit
sought
different
relief
see
construed
keene
bars
nation
cfc
action
majority
holds
see
ante
nation
cfc
district
actions
based
nearly
identical
facts
two
actions
also
seek
overlapping
relief
complaints
request
money
remedy
injury
government
alleged
breach
fiduciary
duty
maintain
accurate
accounts
nation
assets
nation
dispute
district
complaint
requests
see
brief
respondent
accounting
reveals
assets
belong
nation
appear
books
may
appropriate
order
equitable
restitution
assets
nation
cfc
complaint
fairly
read
cfc
complaint
alleges
government
failed
keep
render
clear
accurate
accounts
app
pet
cert
claims
reason
alleged
breaches
fiduciary
duty
nation
damaged
amounts
may
proven
trial
complaint
requests
determination
defendant
liable
nation
damages
injuries
losses
caused
result
defendant
breaches
fiduciary
duty
determination
amount
damages
due
nation
thus
like
district
complaint
cfc
complaint
requests
money
remedy
government
alleged
failure
keep
accurate
nation
two
complaints
based
substantially
operative
facts
least
overlap
relief
requested
keene
bars
jurisdiction
nation
cfc
action
ii
case
present
question
left
open
keene
whether
common
facts
alone
sufficient
bar
cfc
action
similar
case
pending
elsewhere
ante
indeed
history
case
government
even
argue
common
facts
sufficient
preclude
cfc
jurisdiction
petition
rehearing
appeals
government
argued
keene
required
dismissal
nation
cfc
action
nation
two
actions
based
facts
sought
overlapping
relief
deciding
case
basis
keene
far
prudent
course
recharacterizing
case
attempt
reach
premature
decision
important
question
missouri
jenkins
kennedy
concurring
part
concurring
judgment
instead
discarding
restraint
exhibited
keene
unnecessarily
chooses
hold
bars
jurisdiction
cfc
whenever
plaintiff
cfc
action
based
substantially
facts
suit
pending
reading
opinion
incorrect
since
enactment
congress
expanded
avenues
persons
legitimate
claims
may
obtain
relief
see
ante
circumstances
congress
chosen
require
plaintiffs
file
actions
two
different
courts
obtain
complete
relief
relating
single
set
operative
facts
example
exceptions
cfc
power
issue
equitable
relief
see
bowen
massachusetts
see
also
result
plaintiff
seeking
money
damages
injunctive
relief
remedy
distinct
harms
arising
set
facts
may
forced
file
actions
cfc
federal
district
half
century
cfc
recognized
preclude
jurisdiction
congress
required
plaintiff
split
claim
two
actions
obtain
different
forms
relief
necessary
make
plaintiff
whole
casman
cl
terminated
federal
employee
sought
backpay
claims
reinstatement
position
district
plaintiff
two
suits
arose
facts
termination
sought
entirely
different
forms
relief
within
exclusive
jurisdiction
two
light
previous
recognition
purpose
require
election
suit
claims
one
brought
another
quoting
matson
nav
claims
held
inapplicable
plaintiff
right
elect
two
courts
ct
hold
otherwise
acknowledged
say
plaintiff
want
job
back
must
forget
back
pay
conversely
want
back
pay
job
back
ibid
see
also
loveladies
harbor
ca
fed
en
banc
reaffirming
casman
inquiry
form
relief
sought
reserving
question
whether
two
actions
based
operative
facts
seeking
completely
different
relief
implicate
decision
keene
expressly
preserved
casman
holding
consequence
today
decision
clear
casman
rule
longer
good
law
majority
reading
casman
two
suits
based
common
facts
barred
jurisdiction
cfc
backpay
claim
even
though
obtained
backpay
district
action
jurisdictional
scheme
governing
actions
often
requires
plaintiffs
file
two
actions
different
courts
obtain
complete
relief
connection
one
set
facts
one
example
action
seeking
injunctive
relief
set
aside
agency
action
must
proceed
district
claim
agency
action
constitutes
taking
property
requiring
compensation
must
proceed
cfc
see
alaska
fed
cl
today
decision
may
well
prevent
plaintiff
pursuing
takings
claim
cfc
action
set
aside
agency
action
pending
district
type
plaintiff
may
face
choice
equally
unattractive
options
forgo
injunctive
relief
district
preserve
claim
monetary
relief
cfc
pursue
injunctive
relief
hope
statute
limitations
takings
claim
see
expire
district
action
text
purpose
history
provide
strong
reason
believe
congress
intend
put
plaintiffs
choice
two
nonduplicative
remedies
congress
made
available
exclusively
two
forums
statute
bars
jurisdiction
cfc
claim
respect
plaintiff
suit
process
pending
elsewhere
congress
first
enacted
predecessor
statute
establishing
jurisdiction
claims
used
term
claims
refer
demands
money
damages
see
act
mar
stat
see
jones
noting
statute
provisions
inconsistent
enforcement
claims
law
except
claims
money
congress
thus
understood
term
claim
describe
particular
relief
sought
claims
cf
commissioner
keystone
consol
industries
determining
meaning
claim
part
inquiry
however
question
remains
constitutes
suit
process
respect
cfc
claim
purpose
history
statute
elucidate
meaning
ambiguous
phrase
majority
explains
congress
enacted
statute
prevent
duplicative
lawsuits
brought
cotton
claimants
aftermath
civil
war
keene
see
ante
cotton
claimants
sought
monetary
compensation
seized
cotton
claims
pursuant
abandoned
property
collection
act
stat
difficulty
satisfying
statutory
requirement
obtain
compensation
must
given
aid
comfort
participants
rebellion
see
act
also
sought
relief
either
form
money
damages
actual
cotton
separate
lawsuits
federal
officials
tort
theories
conversion
duplicative
lawsuits
induced
congress
enact
predecessor
keene
historical
backdrop
sheds
light
congress
understood
suit
process
respect
claim
claims
congress
undoubtedly
intended
preclude
claim
money
claims
plaintiff
pursuing
suit
money
district
however
cotton
claimants
sought
return
cotton
district
also
necessary
preclude
jurisdiction
claims
plaintiff
action
respect
demand
money
plaintiff
seeking
duplicative
relief
courts
awarded
plaintiffs
cotton
money
damages
plaintiffs
obtained
twice
deserved
way
congress
eschewed
narrow
concept
identity
permitted
plaintiffs
pursue
obtain
duplicative
relief
remedy
harm
legislative
history
confirms
congress
intent
preclude
requests
duplicative
relief
statute
sponsor
explained
purpose
statute
put
election
large
class
persons
cotton
claims
time
endeavoring
prosecute
claims
filed
claims
put
government
expense
beating
law
turn
around
try
whole
question
claims
cong
globe
statement
edmunds
see
also
matson
nav
congress
thus
appears
mind
cases
whole
question
tried
claims
statute
history
suggest
congress
intended
require
election
two
nonduplicative
forms
relief
available
exclusively
two
different
courts
case
whole
question
tried
either
none
majority
reasons
contrary
construction
statute
convincing
first
majority
reasons
phrase
claim
respect
must
refer
factual
overlap
statute
uses
phrase
cause
action
respect
thereto
majority
paraphrases
respect
cause
action
way
consistent
factual
overlap
ante
point
rests
misreading
statutory
text
statute
asks
whether
plaintiff
pending
suit
process
respect
plaintiff
cfc
claim
whether
pending
cause
action
respect
even
term
cause
action
refers
operative
facts
inquiry
whether
person
acting
color
federal
law
respect
cause
action
purely
factual
nature
suit
process
inevitably
include
request
relief
second
majority
light
unique
remedial
powers
cfc
requiring
remedial
overlap
make
sense
result
limited
application
statute
ante
majority
overlooks
nearly
history
statute
cotton
claimants
parallel
requests
duplicative
relief
prompted
passage
first
place
since
litigants
continued
seek
duplicative
relief
government
two
courts
keene
case
illustrate
see
seeking
tort
damages
district
compensation
takings
theory
cfc
supra
seeking
restitution
disgorgement
district
money
damages
cfc
see
also
ex
parte
skinner
eddy
seeking
money
damages
claims
federal
entity
state
corona
coal
seeking
money
damages
claims
federal
agent
district
british
american
tobacco
cl
per
curiam
seeking
tort
damages
district
contract
damages
claims
cases
make
clear
interpreting
prohibit
requests
duplicative
relief
hardly
renders
statute
limited
application
third
majority
suggests
construction
necessary
achieve
statute
aim
sav
ing
government
burdens
redundant
litigation
ante
parallel
actions
seeking
duplicative
relief
different
forms
relief
available
entirely
one
redundant
actions
seeking
different
forms
relief
congress
made
available
exclusively
different
courts
extent
majority
concerned
burdens
parallel
discovery
federal
courts
ample
tools
disposal
stays
prevent
burdens
see
schwartz
section
judicial
code
duplicate
suits
government
agents
geo
finally
majority
contends
focusing
operative
facts
consistent
principles
claim
preclusion
embodied
statute
claim
preclusion
ordinarily
bar
claims
arising
transaction
kremer
chemical
constr
however
exception
rule
plaintiff
unable
obtain
certain
remedy
earlier
action
see
restatement
second
judgments
claim
preclusion
apply
plaintiff
unable
rely
certain
theory
case
seek
certain
remedy
form
relief
first
action
limitations
subject
matter
jurisdiction
courts
see
also
marrese
american
academy
orthopaedic
surgeons
wright
miller
cooper
federal
practice
procedure
ed
principle
long
informed
claim
preclusion
law
see
restatement
judgments
comment
plaintiff
brings
action
state
courts
jurisdiction
reference
one
portion
cause
action
barred
maintaining
action
proper
portion
black
law
judgments
judgment
conclusive
matter
nature
case
form
action
character
pleadings
adjudicated
former
suit
reasons
preclusion
doctrine
actually
undermines
majority
position
sum
majority
offers
coherent
justification
conclusion
congress
intended
preclude
jurisdiction
cfc
whenever
plaintiff
claim
based
substantially
facts
suit
pending
elsewhere
without
reference
relief
sought
even
today
decision
described
anachronistic
keene
harsh
stevens
dissenting
arbitrar
fed
cl
judges
commentators
long
called
congressional
attention
statute
see
keene
stevens
dissenting
schwartz
supra
today
decision
unnecessarily
considers
repudiates
casman
rule
renders
attention
pressing
construction
plaintiffs
congress
forced
file
parallel
actions
cfc
district
obtain
complete
relief
must
choose
either
forgo
relief
district
file
first
district
risk
expiration
statute
limitations
claims
cfc
agree
congress
intended
intends
produce
result
reasons
respectfully
concur
judgment
petitioner
tohono
nation
writ
certiorari
appeals
federal
circuit
april
justice
ginsburg
dissenting
dissent
immoderate
reading
affirm
federal
circuit
judgment
according
federal
claims
cfc
lacks
jurisdiction
tohono
nation
nation
claim
tribe
simultaneously
pursuing
district
action
common
factual
basis
ante
matters
holds
gain
complete
relief
nation
launch
two
suits
neither
two
courts
whose
jurisdiction
tribe
invoked
alone
provide
full
redress
see
ante
concludes
claim
cause
action
terms
considers
synonymous
used
see
ante
refers
operative
facts
remedies
plaintiff
seeks
see
ante
section
speaks
time
cause
action
arose
time
antedating
commencement
suit
infers
therefore
claim
cause
action
discrete
pleading
request
relief
see
ante
fact
however
entitlement
relief
essential
existence
claim
cause
action
arises
person
suffers
harm
capable
judicial
redress
see
story
equity
jurisprudence
ed
cause
action
arises
party
right
apply
plaintiff
may
instructs
petition
cfc
district
invoking
distinct
legal
theory
appropriate
forum
seeking
redress
single
injury
congress
bars
plaintiff
obtaining
complete
relief
one
suit
however
call
election
remedies
congress
sensibly
read
comprehended
operative
facts
give
rise
two
discrete
claims
casman
cl
justice
sotomayor
spells
see
ante
paradigm
case
discharged
federal
employee
complaining
wrongful
termination
sought
reinstatement
action
backpay
claims
section
stand
way
claims
held
casman
plaintiff
suffered
two
distinct
injuries
seeks
discrete
forms
relief
within
exclusive
competence
different
courts
see
ct
claim
backpay
entirely
different
claim
reinstatement
federal
circuit
view
rightly
adhered
casman
loveladies
harbor
en
banc
rightly
case
agree
much
justice
sotomayor
opinion
concurring
judgment
agree
conclusion
bars
nation
cfc
action
justice
sotomayor
joins
judgment
although
reasoning
tohono
nation
seeks
cfc
relief
facts
pending
district
action
ante
emphasis
added
extent
nation
two
actions
seek
overlapping
relief
disposition
less
harsh
order
ordinarily
plaintiff
allegations
demands
relief
excessive
complaint
instantly
dismissed
account
instead
may
seek
leave
trim
pleading
permission
freely
give
justice
requires
rule
cfc
cf
rule
cfc
judgment
default
need
conform
demand
relief
grant
relief
party
entitled
justice
sotomayor
nation
recognize
avoid
duplication
running
statute
limitations
cfc
suit
stayed
companion
district
action
proceeds
see
ante
brief
respondent
common
practice
prior
action
pending
see
pennsylvania
instructing
claims
stay
pending
proceedings
enable
litigant
obtain
district
review
relevant
agency
order
creppel
ca
fed
federal
claims
may
stay
takings
action
pending
completion
related
action
district
positioned
direct
cfc
disregard
requests
relief
simultaneously
sought
action
least
recognize
amended
cfc
complaint
save
case
see
impediment
either
course
law
rule
footnotes
majority
characterizes
nation
district
complaint
seeking
equitable
relief
ante
mention
complaint
seeks
among
things
equitable
monetary
relief
disgorgement
restitution
see
app
pet
cert
reaching
opposite
conclusion
appeals
relied
fact
nation
district
complaint
seeks
equitable
relief
whereas
cfc
complaint
seeks
damages
see
ca
fed
keene
makes
clear
however
actions
based
substantially
operative
facts
implicate
long
seek
overlapping
relief
see
keene
formal
label
affixed
form
relief
sought
irrelevant
case
nation
cfc
complaint
district
complaint
seek
money
remedy
government
alleged
failure
keep
accurate
accounts
majority
contend
facts
case
require
decide
question
justifies
decision
reach
question
ground
rule
eliminate
unnecessary
complicated
remedial
inquiry
decrease
expense
duration
litigation
ante
provides
reason
believe
however
inquiry
relief
requested
unduly
complicated
vast
majority
cases
cf
loveladies
harbor
ca
fed
en
banc
principles
casman
cl
difficult
comprehend
apply
importantly
majority
explain
benefits
perceives
result
deciding
question
today
outweigh
potential
reading
statute
leave
plaintiffs
incomplete
recompense
injuries
see
infra
page
congress
since
enacted
legislation
permit
plaintiffs
casman
situation
obtain
complete
relief
cfc
see
act
stat
permitting
cfc
issue
orders
directing
restoration
office
position
placement
appropriate
duty
retirement
status
correction
applicable
records
majority
apparently
doubts
holding
puts
nation
similarly
difficult
choice
first
suggests
nation
file
solely
cfc
obtain
damages
government
alleged
breaches
fiduciary
duty
see
ante
nation
indeed
choose
file
cfc
plaintiff
choose
forgo
injunctive
relief
pursue
money
damages
cfc
nation
believes
entitled
monetary
relief
nation
district
action
seeks
equitable
accounting
remedy
breaches
fiduciary
duty
cfc
held
lacks
jurisdiction
issue
preliability
accounting
see
klamath
modoc
tribes
cl
see
eastern
shawnee
tribe
ca
fed
suggesting
dicta
cfc
order
equitable
accounting
ancillary
relief
cert
pending
majority
next
suggests
congress
tolled
statute
limitations
governing
nation
cfc
claims
see
ante
cited
statute
applies
claims
concerning
losses
mismanagement
trust
funds
stat
appear
toll
statute
limitations
claims
concerning
assets
funds
tangible
assets
see
app
pet
cert
seeking
damages
government
mismanagement
nation
mineral
estates
expiration
statute
limitations
governing
claims
cfc
real
prospect
cases
nation
district
action
pending
four
years
majority
notes
see
ante
validity
claims
holding
tecon
engineers
cl
presented
case
never
considered
holding
accordingly
consider
whether
nation
avoided
application
altogether
filing
cfc
action
first
congress
consistently
used
term
claim
refer
demand
money
context
cfc
see
conferring
jurisdiction
cfc
claim
founded
either
upon
constitution
act
congress
regulation
executive
department
upon
express
implied
contract
liquidated
unliquidated
damages
cases
sounding
tort
emphasis
added
course
since
enactment
congress
authorized
cfc
issue
relief
money
damages
certain
cases
see
jurisdictional
bar
applies
suit
pending
good
argument
even
first
enacted
statute
actually
perform
preclusion
function
emphasized
sponsor
keene
section
refers
cause
action
alleged
suit
process
limited
purpose
determining
whether
suit
process
agent
plaintiff
action
term
cause
action
relevance
inquiry
footnotes
action
simultaneously
technical
term
ante
technical
means
precise
clear
certain
incorrect
see
memphis
cotton
oil
action
may
mean
one
thing
one
purpose
something
different
discourse
term
fallen
old
error
drafters
federal
rules
endeavored
eliminate
unfortunate
rigidity
confusion
surrounding
words
action
wright
miller
federal
practice
procedure
ed
today
invocation
supposed
particular
exact
meaning
phrase
risks
reviving
confusion