kucana
holder
attorney
general
argued
november
decided
january
illegal
immigration
reform
immigrant
responsibility
act
iirira
amended
immigration
nationality
act
ina
act
codifying
certain
rules
earlier
prescribed
attorney
general
govern
process
reopening
removal
proceedings
iirira
also
added
provision
stating
jurisdiction
review
action
attorney
general
authority
specified
subchapter
discretion
attorney
general
ii
regulation
amended
months
iirira
enactment
provides
decision
grant
deny
motion
reopen
within
discretion
board
immigration
appeals
bia
cfr
adjudicator
immigration
cases
bia
exercises
authority
delegated
attorney
general
petitioner
kucana
moved
reopen
removal
proceedings
asserting
new
evidence
support
plea
asylum
immigration
judge
denied
motion
bia
sustained
ruling
seventh
circuit
concluded
lacked
jurisdiction
review
administrative
determination
holding
ii
bars
judicial
review
administrative
decisions
made
discretionary
statute
also
made
discretionary
regulation
held
section
proscription
judicial
review
applies
attorney
general
determinations
made
discretionary
statute
determinations
declared
discretionary
attorney
general
regulation
pp
motion
reopen
important
safeguard
intended
ensure
proper
lawful
disposition
immigration
proceedings
dada
mukasey
review
administrative
decisions
denying
motions
reopen
removal
proceedings
dates
back
least
courts
employing
deferential
standard
review
attorney
general
regulation
point
cfr
places
reopening
decision
within
bia
discretion
statute
codify
prescription
otherwise
specif
decisions
attorney
general
discretion
pp
section
proscribe
judicial
review
denials
motions
reopen
pp
amicus
defending
seventh
circuit
judgment
urges
regulations
suffice
trigger
ii
proscription
comprehends
authority
specified
subchapter
mean
pursuant
subordinate
administrative
regulations
count
purposes
submits
issued
pursuant
measures
subordinate
legislation
serve
implement
reading
ii
bar
judicial
review
decision
executive
regulation
places
within
bia
discretion
including
decision
deny
motion
reopen
parties
hand
read
statutory
language
mean
specified
specified
subchapter
reading
ii
precludes
judicial
review
statute
specifies
discretionary
character
attorney
general
authority
pp
word
many
dictionary
definitions
must
draw
meaning
context
ardestani
ins
examining
provision
issue
statutory
context
parties
position
stands
firmer
ground
section
ii
far
iirira
jurisdictional
limitation
sandwiched
two
subsections
dependent
statutory
provisions
regulation
define
scope
given
statutory
placement
one
expect
cover
statutory
provisions
alone
pp
section
places
within
category
judgment
regarding
granting
relief
section
referenced
statutory
provisions
addresses
different
form
discretionary
relief
removal
contains
language
indicating
decision
entrusted
attorney
general
discretion
clause
refer
regulatory
provision
proximity
clause
clause
ii
catchall
words
linking
decision
suggests
congress
mind
decisions
genre
made
discretionary
legislation
read
harmoniously
clauses
convey
congress
barred
review
discretionary
decisions
congress
set
attorney
general
discretionary
authority
statute
pp
also
significant
character
decisions
insulated
judicial
review
listed
determinations
substantive
decisions
executive
makes
involving
whether
aliens
stay
country
decisions
specified
statute
discretion
attorney
general
therefore
shielded
oversight
ii
like
kind
see
decisions
reopening
motions
made
discretionary
regulation
contrast
adjunct
rulings
decision
reversing
denial
motion
reopen
direct
executive
afford
alien
substantive
relief
ordinarily
touches
concerns
question
whether
alien
claims
accorded
reasonable
hearing
congress
wanted
jurisdictional
bar
encompass
decisions
specified
discretionary
regulation
well
statute
moreover
congress
easily
said
provisions
enacted
simultaneously
ii
see
iirira
stat
pp
history
relevant
statutory
provisions
corroborates
determination
attorney
general
regulations
long
addressed
reopening
requests
enacting
iirira
congress
simultaneously
codified
process
filing
motions
reopen
acted
bar
judicial
review
number
executive
decisions
regarding
removal
congress
codify
regulation
delegating
bia
discretion
grant
deny
reopening
motions
legislative
silence
indicates
congress
left
matter
bia
broad
discretion
conferred
attorney
general
grant
deny
motion
reopen
cfr
courts
retain
jurisdiction
review
bia
decision
unsurprising
congress
leave
place
judicial
oversight
important
procedural
safeguard
dada
alien
underlying
asylum
claim
reviewable
real
id
act
amended
ina
adding
reformulating
provisions
asylum
protection
removal
even
judicial
review
disturb
unbroken
line
decisions
upholding
review
administrative
denials
motions
reopen
pp
lingering
doubt
ii
proper
interpretation
dispelled
familiar
statutory
construction
principle
presumption
favoring
judicial
review
administrative
action
statute
reasonably
susceptible
divergent
interpretation
adopts
reading
executive
determinations
generally
subject
judicial
review
gutierrez
de
martinez
lamagno
consistently
applied
interpretive
guide
legislation
regarding
immigration
particularly
questions
concerning
preservation
jurisdiction
see
reno
catholic
social
services
presumption
assumes
congress
legislates
knowledge
mcnary
haitian
refugee
center
therefore
takes
clear
convincing
evidence
dislodge
presumption
catholic
social
services
evidence
finally
reading
ii
apply
matters
discretion
conferred
bia
regulation
ignore
congress
design
retain
control
jurisdiction
seventh
circuit
construction
free
executive
shelter
decisions
appellate
review
simply
issuing
regulation
declaring
decisions
discretionary
extraordinary
delegation
authority
extracted
statute
congress
enacted
pp
reversed
remanded
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
roberts
stevens
scalia
kennedy
thomas
breyer
sotomayor
joined
alito
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
agron
kucana
petitioner
eric
holder
attorney
general
writ
certiorari
appeals
seventh
circuit
january
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
petitioner
agron
kucana
moved
reopen
removal
proceedings
asserting
new
evidence
support
plea
asylum
immigration
judge
ij
denied
motion
board
immigration
appeals
bia
board
sustained
ij
ruling
appeals
seventh
circuit
concluded
lacked
jurisdiction
review
administrative
determination
conclusion
relied
provision
added
immigration
nationality
act
ina
act
stat
et
illegal
immigration
reform
immigrant
responsibility
act
iirira
stat
provision
found
dispositive
seventh
circuit
shall
jurisdiction
review
action
attorney
general
authority
specified
subchapter
discretion
attorney
general
ii
emphasis
added
granted
certiorari
decide
whether
proscription
judicial
review
stated
applies
attorney
general
determinations
made
discretionary
statute
also
determinations
declared
discretionary
attorney
general
regulation
hold
key
words
specified
subchapter
refer
statutory
regulatory
specifications
rule
based
longstanding
exercise
judicial
review
administrative
rulings
reopening
motions
text
context
history
relevant
statutory
provisions
take
account
well
presumption
favoring
interpretations
statutes
allow
judicial
review
administrative
action
reno
catholic
social
services
quoting
mcnary
haitian
refugee
center
concerns
moreover
caution
us
reading
legislation
absent
clear
statement
place
executive
hands
authority
remove
cases
judiciary
domain
iirira
congress
first
time
codified
certain
rules
earlier
prescribed
attorney
general
governing
reopening
process
amended
act
instructs
reopening
motions
shall
state
new
facts
proven
hearing
held
motion
granted
shall
supported
affidavits
evidentiary
material
congress
also
prescribed
motion
reopen
shall
filed
within
days
date
entry
final
administrative
order
removal
among
matters
excepted
limitation
motions
reopen
asylum
applications
changed
conditions
country
nationality
removal
ii
section
captioned
matters
subject
judicial
review
contains
provision
case
turns
subparagraph
paragraph
headed
denials
discretionary
relief
notwithstanding
provision
law
statutory
nonstatutory
except
provided
subparagraph
regardless
whether
judgment
decision
action
made
removal
proceedings
shall
jurisdiction
review
judgment
regarding
granting
relief
section
title
ii
decision
action
attorney
general
authority
specified
subchapter
discretion
attorney
general
granting
relief
section
title
regulation
amended
months
congress
enacted
iirira
fed
reg
pt
decision
grant
deny
motion
reopen
within
discretion
board
cfr
adjudicator
immigration
cases
board
exercises
authority
delegated
attorney
general
see
cfr
see
also
cfr
governing
motions
reopen
filed
ij
kucana
citizen
albania
entered
business
visa
remained
visa
expired
alleging
persecuted
based
political
beliefs
returned
albania
kucana
applied
asylum
withholding
removal
ij
determined
kucana
removable
scheduled
hearing
evaluate
eligibility
asylum
kucana
failed
appear
hearing
ij
immediately
ordered
removal
absentia
kucana
filed
motion
reopen
explaining
missed
hearing
overslept
ij
denied
motion
bia
affirmed
kucana
seek
judicial
review
leave
kucana
filed
second
motion
reopen
removal
proceedings
contending
conditions
albania
bia
denied
relief
concluded
conditions
albania
actually
improved
since
arguing
bia
abused
discretion
denying
motion
kucana
filed
petition
review
seventh
circuit
fractured
decision
seventh
circuit
dismissed
petition
lack
jurisdiction
kucana
mukasey
held
ii
bars
judicial
review
administrative
decisions
made
discretionary
statute
also
agency
discretion
specified
regulation
rather
statute
ruling
seventh
circuit
created
split
courts
appeals
holding
denials
reopening
motions
reviewable
judge
ripple
concurred
dubitante
acknowledged
following
earlier
decision
ali
gonzales
suggest
ed
congress
intended
deprive
th
jurisdiction
done
explicitly
concluded
revisit
ali
kucana
chart
course
closely
adher
ing
statutory
language
chosen
enacted
congress
judge
cudahy
dissented
given
absence
specific
statutory
language
entrusting
decision
motion
reopen
discretion
attorney
general
ibid
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
saw
impediment
exercise
jurisdiction
kucana
petition
support
position
judge
cudahy
invoked
strong
presumption
congress
intends
judicial
review
administrative
action
quoting
traynor
turnage
four
judges
dissenting
seventh
circuit
denied
kucana
petition
rehearing
en
banc
see
dissenting
statement
ripple
joined
rovner
wood
williams
granted
certiorari
resolve
circuit
conflict
seventh
circuit
government
agrees
kucana
ii
remove
jurisdiction
review
denial
reopening
motion
appointed
amanda
leiter
brief
argue
case
amicus
curiae
support
seventh
circuit
judgment
leiter
ably
discharged
assigned
responsibilities
ii
motion
reopen
important
safeguard
intended
ensure
proper
lawful
disposition
immigration
proceedings
dada
mukasey
slip
cf
stone
ins
analogizing
motions
reconsider
immigration
decisions
motions
relief
judgment
federal
rule
civil
procedure
review
administrative
decisions
denying
motions
reopen
removal
proceedings
dates
back
least
see
dada
slip
citing
cases
ultimately
reviewed
reopening
decisions
numerous
occasions
see
ins
doherty
ins
abudu
ins
ins
jong
ha
wang
per
curiam
mindful
board
broad
discretion
matters
however
courts
employed
deferential
standard
review
see
doherty
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
seventh
circuit
held
congress
removed
authority
long
exercised
federal
courts
review
denials
alien
reopening
request
congress
appeals
said
ii
removes
jurisdiction
review
decision
attorney
general
authority
specified
subchapter
discretion
attorney
general
agree
attorney
general
regulation
cfr
places
decision
grant
deny
motion
reopen
within
discretion
board
statute
codify
otherwise
specif
reopening
decisions
discretion
attorney
general
iii
board
discretionary
authority
act
motion
reopen
thus
far
explained
specified
statute
attorney
general
regulation
instructs
decision
grant
deny
motion
reopen
within
discretion
board
subject
restrictions
section
board
discretion
deny
motion
reopen
even
party
moving
made
prima
facie
case
relief
cfr
nevertheless
defense
seventh
circuit
judgment
amicus
urges
regulations
suffice
trigger
ii
proscription
judicial
review
provision
amicus
reminds
refers
authority
specified
subchapter
reads
formulation
word
key
comprehends
mean
pursuant
subordinate
lower
inferior
rank
importance
reason
authority
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
citing
inter
alia
florida
dept
revenue
piccadilly
cafeterias
slip
ardestani
ins
administrative
regulations
count
purposes
urges
issued
pursuant
measures
subordinate
legislation
serve
implement
parties
hand
read
specified
subchapter
mean
specified
specified
reading
amicus
advances
ii
bar
judicial
review
decision
executive
regulation
places
within
bia
discretion
including
decision
deny
motion
reopen
parties
reading
however
ii
precludes
judicial
review
statute
specifies
discretionary
character
attorney
general
authority
parties
amicus
recognize
diverse
renderings
standing
alone
equip
us
resolve
case
word
chameleon
many
dictionary
definitions
must
draw
meaning
context
ardestani
examining
statutory
context
provision
word
embedded
conclude
parties
position
stands
firmer
ground
section
ii
provision
issue
far
jurisdictional
limitation
iirira
see
dada
slip
reading
statute
must
look
merely
particular
clause
consider
connection
whole
statute
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
davis
michigan
dept
treasury
words
statute
must
read
context
view
place
overall
statutory
section
titled
matters
subject
judicial
review
lists
variety
agency
determinations
federal
courts
lack
jurisdiction
review
determinations
divide
three
categories
first
concerns
immigration
officers
determinations
whether
aliens
applying
admission
admissible
next
statutory
order
provision
us
involves
denials
discretionary
relief
last
category
concerns
final
orders
removal
entered
criminal
aliens
depend
statutory
provisions
regulation
define
scope
latter
provision
criminal
alien
bar
precludes
judicial
review
final
order
removal
alien
removable
reason
committed
criminal
offense
covered
iii
certain
offenses
covered
ii
defining
references
statutory
none
invokes
regulation
holds
admissibility
bar
given
statutory
placement
sandwiched
subsections
one
expect
cover
statutory
provisions
alone
focusing
note
lead
line
serving
introduce
subparagraph
two
clauses
shall
jurisdiction
review
clause
places
within
category
judgment
regarding
granting
relief
section
statutory
provisions
referenced
clause
addresses
different
form
discretionary
relief
removal
see
supra
contains
language
indicating
decision
entrusted
attorney
general
discretion
see
attorney
general
may
discretion
waive
inadmissibility
based
certain
criminal
offenses
clause
refer
regulatory
provision
clause
enumeration
administrative
judgments
insulated
judicial
review
congress
added
clause
ii
catchall
provision
covering
decision
authority
specified
subchapter
proximity
clauses
ii
words
linking
decision
suggests
congress
mind
decisions
genre
made
discretionary
clause
enumeration
find
instructive
determining
meaning
clause
ii
catchall
read
harmoniously
clauses
convey
congress
barred
review
discretionary
decisions
congress
set
attorney
general
discretionary
authority
statute
see
hall
street
associates
mattel
slip
hen
statute
sets
series
specific
items
ending
general
term
general
term
confined
covering
subjects
comparable
specifics
follows
also
find
significant
character
decisions
congress
enumerated
thereby
insulating
judicial
review
government
explained
oral
argument
determinations
listed
substantive
decisions
made
executive
immigration
context
matter
grace
things
involve
whether
aliens
stay
country
tr
oral
arg
include
waivers
inadmissibility
based
certain
criminal
offenses
based
fraud
misrepresentation
cancellation
removal
permission
voluntary
departure
adjustment
status
decisions
specified
statute
discretion
attorney
general
therefore
shielded
oversight
ii
like
kind
see
discretion
admit
refugees
determined
special
humanitarian
concern
discretion
waive
requirement
documentation
readmission
iv
discretion
waive
certain
cases
inadmissibility
aliens
affiliated
totalitarian
party
decisions
reopening
motions
made
discretionary
regulation
contrast
adjunct
rulings
motion
reopen
procedural
device
serving
ensure
aliens
getting
fair
chance
claims
heard
tr
oral
arg
decision
reversing
denial
motion
reopen
direct
executive
afford
alien
substantive
relief
ordinarily
touches
concerns
question
whether
alien
claims
accorded
reasonable
hearing
congress
wanted
jurisdictional
bar
encompass
decisions
specified
discretionary
regulation
along
made
discretionary
statute
moreover
congress
easily
said
provisions
enacted
simultaneously
ii
congress
expressed
precisely
meaning
see
iirira
stat
immigration
benefits
pursuant
act
regulations
promulgated
thereunder
codified
iirira
stat
powers
privileges
duties
conferred
imposed
act
regulations
issued
thereunder
codified
congress
includes
particular
language
one
section
statute
omits
another
section
act
generally
presumed
congress
acts
intentionally
purposely
disparate
inclusion
exclusion
nken
holder
slip
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
history
relevant
statutory
provisions
corroborates
determination
ii
proscribe
judicial
review
denials
motions
reopen
attorney
general
regulations
long
addressed
reopening
requests
see
fed
reg
current
regulations
adopted
fed
reg
derive
rules
published
see
fed
reg
dada
slip
enacting
iirira
congress
transform
ed
motion
reopen
regulatory
procedure
statutory
form
relief
available
alien
slip
iirira
largely
codified
attorney
general
directions
filing
reopening
motions
see
guaranteeing
right
file
one
motion
prescribing
contents
setting
deadlines
legislation
congress
amended
ina
aggressively
expedite
removal
aliens
lacking
legal
basis
remain
see
reno
among
iirira
several
proscriptions
judicial
review
one
issue
ii
barring
review
administrative
decisions
congress
placed
within
attorney
general
discretion
congress
thus
simultaneously
codified
process
filing
motions
reopen
acted
bar
judicial
review
number
executive
decisions
regarding
removal
congress
codify
regulation
delegating
bia
discretion
grant
deny
motions
reopen
see
cfr
reopening
may
entertained
application
board
may
time
reopen
motion
case
rendered
decision
congress
elected
insulate
denials
motions
reopen
judicial
review
specified
together
codification
directions
filing
reopening
motions
legislature
silence
discretion
attorney
general
delegate
board
reopening
motions
see
supra
take
congress
left
matter
bia
broad
discretion
conferred
attorney
general
grant
deny
motion
reopen
cfr
courts
retain
jurisdiction
review
due
respect
board
unsurprising
congress
leave
place
judicial
oversight
important
procedural
safeguard
designed
ensure
proper
lawful
disposition
immigration
proceedings
dada
slip
alien
underlying
claim
asylum
real
id
act
congress
amended
ina
two
courts
appeals
already
ruled
ii
preclude
reviewing
denials
motions
reopen
see
infanzon
ashcroft
ashcroft
reached
contrary
result
although
adding
reformulating
provisions
asylum
stat
protection
removal
even
judicial
review
real
id
act
disturb
unbroken
line
decisions
upholding
review
administrative
denials
motions
reopen
see
supra
supra
iv
lingering
doubt
proper
interpretation
ii
dispelled
familiar
principle
statutory
construction
presumption
favoring
judicial
review
administrative
action
statute
reasonably
susceptible
divergent
interpretation
adopt
reading
accords
traditional
understandings
basic
principles
executive
determinations
generally
subject
judicial
review
gutierrez
de
martinez
lamagno
consistently
applied
interpretive
guide
legislation
regarding
immigration
particularly
questions
concerning
preservation
jurisdiction
see
ins
cyr
catholic
social
services
mcnary
presumption
favoring
interpretations
statutes
allow
judicial
review
administrative
action
catholic
social
services
quoting
mcnary
assumes
congress
legislates
knowledge
presumption
therefore
takes
clear
convincing
evidence
dislodge
presumption
catholic
social
services
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
evidence
finally
stress
paramount
factor
decision
render
today
defining
various
jurisdictional
bars
reference
provisions
ina
congress
ensured
limit
federal
courts
jurisdiction
read
ii
apply
matters
discretion
conferred
board
regulation
rather
attorney
general
statute
ignore
congressional
design
seventh
circuit
construction
ii
prevail
executive
free
hand
shelter
decisions
appellate
review
simply
issuing
regulation
declaring
decisions
discretionary
extraordinary
delegation
authority
extracted
statute
congress
enacted
statute
affecting
federal
jurisdiction
must
construed
precision
fidelity
terms
congress
expressed
wishes
cheng
fan
kwok
ins
noted
see
supra
amicus
emphasizes
many
provisions
iirira
aimed
protecting
review
exercises
executive
discretion
emphasis
deleted
law
pursues
purpose
costs
textual
limitations
upon
law
scope
less
part
substantive
authorizations
rapanos
plurality
opinion
congress
pared
back
judicial
review
iirira
delegate
executive
authority
action
motions
reopen
made
discretionary
attorney
general
therefore
remain
subject
judicial
review
reasons
stated
judgment
appeals
seventh
circuit
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
agron
kucana
petitioner
eric
holder
attorney
general
writ
certiorari
appeals
seventh
circuit
january
justice
alito
concurring
judgment
agree
appeals
jurisdiction
review
denial
petitioner
motion
reopen
removal
proceeding
decide
case
narrower
grounds
controlling
statutory
provision
ii
shall
jurisdiction
review
decision
attorney
general
authority
specified
subchapter
discretion
attorney
general
emphasis
added
phrase
subchapter
refers
subchapter
ii
chapter
title
see
ante
notes
provision
subchapter
ii
confers
discretionary
authority
attorney
general
decide
motions
reopen
see
ante
appeals
however
held
attorney
general
decision
case
unreviewable
regulation
cfr
made
decision
discretionary
regulation
promulgated
pursuant
authority
conferred
provision
subchapter
ii
confront
question
opinion
addresses
seems
clear
cfr
least
insofar
gave
attorney
general
discretionary
authority
exercised
case
grounded
authority
conferred
subchapter
chapter
title
see
ed
giving
attorney
general
authority
establish
regulations
deems
necessary
carrying
authority
chapter
title
code
amicus
curiae
appointed
defend
decision
appeals
attempted
link
cfr
subchapter
ii
notes
attorney
general
promulgating
regulation
cited
also
provision
subchapter
ii
see
fed
reg
latter
statutory
conferred
authority
reopen
narrow
set
deportation
orders
issued
alien
failed
appear
deportation
hearing
although
statutory
provision
apply
petitioner
motion
reopen
amicus
argues
section
brief
allusion
motions
reopen
clearly
presupposed
attorney
general
place
general
procedure
reviewing
motions
reopen
removal
proceedings
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
amicus
argument
ingenious
ultimately
unpersuasive
ed
may
read
implicitly
authorizing
promulgation
regulation
giving
attorney
general
discretion
reopen
certain
deportation
orders
issued
absentia
petitioner
second
motion
reopen
however
seeks
reopening
grounds
outside
therefore
cfr
insofar
applies
petitioner
case
issued
pursuant
subchapter
ii
implement
provision
subchapter
reasons
case
decided
narrow
ground
even
regulations
render
decision
attorney
general
unreviewable
regulation
issue
case
effect
footnotes
subparagraph
enacted
real
id
act
real
id
act
stat
adds
nothing
subparagraph
provision
act
section
limits
eliminates
judicial
review
shall
construed
precluding
review
constitutional
claims
questions
law
raised
upon
petition
review
filed
appropriate
appeals
accordance
section
addition
change
operative
language
ii
enacted
real
id
act
amendments
also
inserted
introductory
clause
inter
alia
words
statutory
nonstatutory
ii
stat
introductory
clause
however
define
scope
ii
jurisdictional
bar
simply
informs
scope
bar
determined
jurisdiction
precluded
regardless
provision
source
law
might
say
sections
address
waivers
inadmissibility
based
certain
criminal
offenses
fraud
misrepresentation
respectively
addresses
cancellation
removal
voluntary
departure
adjustment
status
subchapter
refers
title
chapter
subchapter
ii
code
codified
titled
immigration
exception
relief
refers
administrative
decisions
whether
grant
asylum
kucana
petition
judicial
review
limited
denial
motion
reopen
challenge
proceeding
decision
denying
application
asylum
statute
guarantees
alien
right
file
motion
reopen
proceedings
dada
mukasey
slip
quoting
attorney
general
regulations
permit
motions
reopen
seek
asylum
withholding
removal
based
changed
conditions
country
nationality
removal
see
cfr
ii
recognizing
regulation
rather
ina
confers
board
discretion
grant
deny
motion
reopen
appeals
said
regulation
draw
force
provisions
act
allowing
immigration
officials
govern
proceedings
force
according
seventh
circuit
comes
described
providing
authority
reopening
board
section
however
directed
agency
discretion
grant
deny
motions
reopen
main
simply
lays
requirements
alien
must
fulfill
filing
motion
reopen
cudahy
dissenting
emphasis
added
see
also
infra
see
singh
mukasey
jahjaga
attorney
zhao
gonzales
miah
mukasey
ashcroft
infanzon
ashcroft
ali
involved
decision
made
discretionary
regulation
denying
alien
request
continuance
earlier
noted
see
supra
seventh
circuit
stated
regulation
specifying
board
discretion
motions
reopen
cfr
draw
force
provisions
act
citing
hard
see
regulation
draw
force
regulation
already
force
statutory
provision
enacted
regulation
cfr
published
april
fed
reg
enacted
september
stat
statutory
reference
discretion
respecting
motions
reopen
appears
iv
iii
gives
attorney
general
discretion
waive
one
statute
time
limitations
extraordinary
circumstances
amicus
urges
statutory
language
governing
motions
reopen
anticipates
exercise
attorney
general
discretion
motion
reopen
shall
state
new
facts
proven
hearing
held
motion
granted
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
quoting
one
demur
argument
congress
anticipated
decisions
reopening
motions
discretionary
even
statutory
proscription
congress
enacted
ii
speaks
authority
specified
merely
assumed
contemplated
attorney
general
discretion
specified
synonymous
implied
anticipated
see
webster
new
collegiate
dictionary
specify
means
name
state
explicitly
detail
see
also
soltane
dept
justice
alito
think
use
marginally
ambiguous
statutory
language
without
adequate
particular
action
within
attorney
general
discretion
purposes
ii
defining
used
ii
mean
pursuant
subordinate
attorney
general
observes
give
rise
fatal
anomaly
section
ii
apply
regulations
promulgated
authority
relevant
subchapter
specifications
discretion
subchapter
reply
brief
respondent
appendix
brief
amicus
lists
hundreds
statutory
provisions
regulations
described
issued
statute
see
app
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
every
one
examples
congress
expressly
used
word
regulations
oral
argument
amicus
called
attention
three
instances
congress
used
words
specified
title
without
reference
regulations
encompass
agency
matters
tr
oral
arg
citing
three
provisions
point
parts
act
turn
rely
administrative
determinations
amicus
research
underscores
point
context
defines
congress
excepted
ii
granting
relief
section
concerns
applications
asylum
absent
exception
asylum
applicants
might
fall
within
ii
jurisdictional
bar
statutory
provision
specifies
attorney
general
may
grant
asylum
emphasis
added
see
zadvydas
davis
suggests
discretion
amicus
suggests
word
ii
read
expansively
draw
decisions
made
discretionary
regulation
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
ii
say
decision
says
decision
explained
decisions
falling
within
ii
compass
sensibly
understood
include
decisions
made
discretionary
congress
see
brief
respondent
noting
thirty
provisions
relevant
subchapter
ina
explicitly
grant
attorney
general
make
certain
decision
counsel
offered
explanation
response
question
congress
want
exclude
review
discretionary
judgments
attorney
general
recited
explicitly
discretionary
statute
provide
judicial
review
judgments
lawfully
discretionary
attorney
general
given
authority
make
discretionary
done
tr
oral
arg
see
statement
house
conference
report
iirira
amicus
suggests
supports
argument
congress
intended
broadly
foreclose
judicial
review
reopening
denials
brief
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
report
bars
judicial
review
decision
action
attorney
general
specified
discretion
attorney
general
conf
statement
read
simply
summarizes
statutory
text
general
level
home
question
whether
decisions
made
discretionary
regulation
judicially
reviewable
reach
question
whether
review
reopening
denial
precluded
lack
jurisdiction
alien
underlying
claim
relief
courts
confronting
question
refused
consider
petitions
review
reopening
denial
seeks
revisit
denial
underlying
claim
reasoned
hearing
petition
bar
review
petitioner
core
claim
see
assaad
ashcroft
per
curiam
express
opinion
whether
federal
courts
may
review
board
decision
reopen
removal
proceedings
sua
sponte
courts
appeals
held
decisions
unreviewable
sua
sponte
reopening
committed
agency
discretion
law
see
see
tamenut
mukasey
en
banc
per
curiam
agreeing
ten
courts
appeals
footnotes
two
provisions
subchapter
ii
refer
motions
reopen
enacted
implementation
cfr
therefore
regulation
said
implement
provisions
see
ante
title
addresses
procedural
requirements
filing
motion
requires
consolidation
motion
reopen
underlying
removal
order
enacted
part
illegal
immigration
reform
immigrant
responsibility
act
iirira
september
made
effective
april
see
stat
prior
time
consolidation
provision
found
subchapter
see
provision
conferred
authority
rescind
deportation
order
upon
motion
reopen
filed
within
days
date
order
deportation
alien
demonstrates
failure
appear
exceptional
circumstances
upon
motion
reopen
filed
time
alien
demonstrates
alien
receive
notice
alien
demonstrates
alien
federal
state
custody
appear
fault
alien
similar
provision
enacted
part
iirira
contained
government
notes
provision
apply
case
petitioner
challenges
denial
second
motion
reopen
parties
agree
governed
brief
respondent