iowa
tovar
argued
january
decided
march
respondent
tovar
november
arraignment
operating
motor
vehicle
influence
alcohol
owi
response
trial
questions
tovar
affirmed
wanted
represent
plead
guilty
conducting
guilty
plea
colloquy
required
iowa
rules
criminal
procedure
explained
tovar
pleaded
guilty
entitled
speedy
public
jury
trial
right
counsel
help
select
jury
question
witnesses
present
evidence
make
arguments
behalf
pleading
guilty
cautioned
tovar
give
right
trial
rights
trial
represented
counsel
remain
silent
presumption
innocence
subpoena
witnesses
compel
testimony
informed
tovar
maximum
minimum
penalties
owi
conviction
explained
accepting
guilty
plea
assure
tovar
fact
guilty
charged
offense
end
informed
tovar
two
elements
owi
charge
defendant
must
operated
motor
vehicle
iowa
intoxicated
tovar
confirmed
first
date
question
operating
motor
vehicle
iowa
second
dispute
result
intoxilyzer
test
showing
blood
alcohol
level
exceeded
legal
limit
nearly
twice
accepted
guilty
plea
hearing
next
month
imposed
minimum
sentence
two
days
jail
fine
tovar
charged
owi
time
second
offense
aggravated
misdemeanor
iowa
law
represented
counsel
proceeding
pleaded
guilty
tovar
charged
owi
class
felony
iowa
law
represented
counsel
tovar
pleaded
guilty
felony
charge
counsel
moved
preclude
use
tovar
first
owi
conviction
enhance
offense
aggravated
misdemeanor
felony
tovar
maintained
waiver
counsel
invalid
fully
knowing
intelligent
voluntary
never
made
aware
dangers
disadvantages
trial
denied
motion
found
tovar
guilty
sentenced
owi
charge
iowa
appeals
affirmed
iowa
reversed
remanded
entry
judgment
without
consideration
tovar
first
owi
conviction
holding
colloquy
preceding
acceptance
tovar
guilty
plea
constitutionally
inadequate
iowa
high
ruled
issue
two
warnings
given
tovar
essential
knowing
intelligent
waiver
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
plea
stage
defendant
must
advised
specifically
waiving
counsel
assistance
deciding
whether
plead
guilty
entails
risk
viable
defense
overlooked
deprives
opportunity
obtain
independent
opinion
whether
facts
applicable
law
wise
plead
guilty
held
neither
warning
ordered
iowa
mandated
sixth
amendment
constitutional
requirement
satisfied
trial
informs
accused
nature
charges
right
counseled
regarding
plea
range
allowable
punishments
attendant
upon
entry
guilty
plea
pp
sixth
amendment
secures
defendant
facing
incarceration
right
counsel
critical
stages
criminal
process
see
maine
moulton
including
plea
hearing
white
maryland
per
curiam
tovar
received
prison
term
first
owi
conviction
right
counsel
plea
stage
trial
elected
contest
charge
argersinger
hamlin
although
accused
may
choose
forgo
representation
waiver
right
counsel
must
knowing
voluntary
intelligent
see
johnson
zerbst
information
defendant
must
possess
order
make
intelligent
election
depends
range
factors
including
education
sophistication
complex
easily
grasped
nature
charge
stage
proceeding
see
johnson
see
faretta
california
less
searching
formal
colloquy
may
suffice
earlier
stages
criminal
process
patterson
described
pragmatic
approach
waivers
one
asks
purposes
lawyer
serve
particular
stage
proceedings
question
assistance
counsel
provide
accused
stage
less
rigorous
warnings
required
pretrial
stage
full
dangers
disadvantages
less
substantial
obvious
accused
trial
pp
sixth
amendment
compel
two
admonitions
ordered
iowa
law
ordinarily
considers
waiver
knowing
intelligent
sufficiently
aware
defendant
fully
understands
nature
right
likely
apply
general
circumstances
ruiz
even
defendant
lacked
full
complete
appreciation
consequences
flowing
waiver
state
may
nevertheless
prevail
shows
information
provided
defendant
satisfied
constitutional
minimum
patterson
iowa
high
gave
insufficient
consideration
guiding
decisions
prescribing
scripted
admonitions
holding
necessary
every
guilty
plea
instance
overlooked
observations
information
defendant
must
waive
counsel
intelligently
depend
upon
particular
facts
circumstances
case
johnson
moreover
tovar
acknowledges
collateral
attack
uncounseled
conviction
defendant
burden
prove
competently
intelligently
waive
right
counsel
tovar
never
claimed
fully
understand
owi
charge
range
punishment
crime
prior
pleading
guilty
never
articulate
precision
additional
information
counsel
provided
given
simplicity
charge
see
patterson
assert
unaware
right
counseled
prior
arraignment
suggests
may
mistaken
belief
right
counsel
trial
instead
going
plead
guilty
given
particular
facts
circumstances
surrounding
case
johnson
far
clear
warnings
kind
required
iowa
enlightened
tovar
decision
whether
seek
counsel
represent
case
straightforward
two
admonitions
issue
might
confuse
mislead
defendant
inform
warnings
might
misconstrued
convey
meritorious
defense
exists
defendant
plead
lesser
charge
neither
prospect
realistic
one
defendant
delays
plea
vain
hope
counsel
uncover
tenable
basis
contesting
reducing
criminal
charge
prompt
disposition
case
impeded
resources
either
state
defendant
indigent
defendant
financially
ineligible
appointed
counsel
wasted
free
adopt
statute
rule
decision
guides
acceptance
uncounseled
plea
deem
useful
federal
constitution
require
two
admonitions
controversy
pp
reversed
remanded
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
unanimous
iowa
petitioner
felipe
edgardo
tovar
writ
certiorari
iowa
march
justice
ginsburg
delivered
opinion
sixth
amendment
safeguards
accused
faces
incarceration
right
counsel
critical
stages
criminal
process
maine
moulton
wade
entry
guilty
plea
whether
misdemeanor
felony
charge
ranks
critical
stage
right
counsel
adheres
argersinger
hamlin
white
maryland
per
curiam
waiver
right
counsel
constitutional
rights
criminal
process
generally
must
knowing
intelligent
ac
done
sufficient
awareness
relevant
circumstances
brady
case
concerns
extent
trial
judge
accepting
guilty
plea
uncounseled
defendant
must
elaborate
right
representation
beyond
affording
defendant
opportunity
consult
counsel
prior
entry
plea
assisted
counsel
plea
hearing
must
specifically
advise
defendant
waiving
assistance
counsel
deciding
whether
plead
guilty
entails
risk
viable
defense
overlooked
admonis
defendant
waiving
right
attorney
lose
opportunity
obtain
independent
opinion
whether
facts
applicable
law
wise
plead
guilty
iowa
iowa
held
warnings
essential
knowing
intelligent
waiver
sixth
amendment
right
assistance
counsel
ibid
hold
neither
warning
mandated
sixth
amendment
constitutional
requirement
satisfied
trial
informs
accused
nature
charges
right
counseled
regarding
plea
range
allowable
punishments
attendant
upon
entry
guilty
plea
november
respondent
felipe
edgardo
tovar
college
student
arrested
ames
iowa
operating
motor
vehicle
influence
alcohol
owi
see
iowa
code
intoxilyzer
test
administered
night
tovar
arrest
showed
blood
alcohol
level
app
arresting
officer
informed
tovar
rights
miranda
arizona
tovar
signed
form
stating
waived
rights
agreed
answer
questions
iowa
state
univ
dept
public
safety
owi
supplemental
report
lodging
petitioner
iowa
state
univ
dept
public
safety
rights
warnings
lodging
petitioner
hours
arrest
tovar
appeared
judge
iowa
district
story
county
judge
indicated
initial
appearance
form
tovar
appeared
without
counsel
waived
application
counsel
initial
appearance
owcr
lodging
petitioner
judge
also
marked
form
checklist
tovar
informed
charge
rights
receive
copy
complaint
ibid
arraignment
set
november
interim
tovar
released
jail
november
inquiries
tovar
began
tovar
appears
without
counsel
see
tovar
waived
application
appointed
attorney
want
represent
today
hearing
app
tovar
replied
yes
sir
soon
asked
ow
wish
plead
tovar
answered
guilty
ibid
tovar
affirmed
promised
anything
threatened
way
induce
plead
guilty
conducting
guilty
plea
colloquy
required
iowa
rules
criminal
procedure
see
iowa
rule
crim
proc
explained
tovar
pleaded
guilty
entitled
speedy
public
trial
jury
app
right
represented
trial
attorney
help
tovar
select
jury
question
state
witnesses
present
evidence
behalf
make
arguments
judge
jury
behalf
pleading
guilty
cautioned
tovar
give
right
trial
kind
charge
give
right
represented
attorney
trial
ibid
advised
tovar
entered
guilty
plea
relinquish
right
remain
silent
trial
right
presumption
innocence
right
subpoena
witnesses
compel
testimony
turning
particular
offense
tovar
charged
informed
owi
conviction
carried
maximum
penalty
year
jail
fine
minimum
penalty
two
days
jail
fine
tovar
affirmed
understood
exposure
penalties
ibid
next
explained
accepting
guilty
plea
assure
tovar
fact
guilty
charged
offense
end
informed
tovar
owi
charge
two
elements
first
date
question
tovar
operating
motor
vehicle
state
iowa
second
intoxicated
tovar
confirmed
driving
ames
iowa
night
apprehended
dispute
results
intoxilyzer
test
administered
police
night
showed
blood
alcohol
level
exceeded
legal
limit
nearly
twice
plea
colloquy
asked
tovar
still
wished
plead
guilty
tovar
affirmed
accepted
tovar
plea
observing
factual
basis
tovar
made
plea
voluntarily
full
understanding
rights
consequences
pleading
guilty
december
tovar
appeared
sentencing
owi
simultaneously
arraignment
subsequent
charge
driving
suspended
license
see
iowa
code
noting
tovar
attendance
without
counsel
inquired
tovar
want
represent
today
hearing
want
take
time
hire
attorney
represent
app
tovar
replied
represent
ibid
engaged
essentially
plea
colloquy
suspension
charge
owi
charge
previous
month
accepting
tovar
guilty
plea
suspension
charge
sentenced
counts
owi
conviction
imposed
minimum
sentence
two
days
jail
fine
plus
surcharge
costs
suspension
conviction
imposed
fine
plus
surcharge
costs
march
tovar
convicted
owi
second
time
represented
counsel
proceeding
pleaded
guilty
record
see
app
pet
cert
december
tovar
charged
owi
time
third
offense
see
iowa
code
additionally
driving
license
barred
see
iowa
law
classifies
owi
serious
misdemeanor
owi
aggravated
misdemeanor
owi
owi
offenses
thereafter
rank
class
felonies
represented
attorney
tovar
pleaded
guilty
december
charges
record
march
counsel
tovar
filed
motion
adjudication
law
points
motion
urged
tovar
first
owi
conviction
used
enhance
december
owi
charge
aggravated
misdemeanor
felony
app
significantly
tovar
allege
unaware
november
arraignment
right
counsel
prior
pleading
guilty
plea
hearing
instead
maintained
waiver
counsel
invalid
full
knowing
intelligent
voluntary
never
made
aware
dangers
disadvantages
denied
tovar
motion
may
explaining
offense
readily
understood
laypersons
penalty
unduly
severe
duty
inquiry
imposed
upon
required
assure
awareness
right
counsel
willingness
proceed
without
counsel
face
awareness
app
pet
cert
brackets
original
tovar
waived
right
jury
trial
found
guilty
owi
charge
driving
license
barred
four
months
adjudication
tovar
sentenced
owi
charge
received
jail
term
days
suspended
three
years
probation
fine
plus
surcharges
costs
app
driving
license
barred
tovar
received
jail
term
run
concurrently
owi
sentence
suspended
fine
iowa
appeals
affirmed
app
pet
cert
iowa
vote
reversed
remanded
entry
judgment
without
consideration
tovar
first
owi
conviction
iowa
highest
acknowledged
dangers
proceeding
pro
se
guilty
plea
proceeding
different
dangers
proceeding
pro
se
jury
trial
therefore
inquiries
made
proceedings
also
different
nonetheless
held
colloquy
preceding
acceptance
tovar
guilty
plea
constitutionally
inadequate
instructed
dispositively
defendant
tovar
chooses
plead
guilty
without
assistance
attorney
must
advised
usefulness
attorney
dangers
order
make
knowing
intelligent
waiver
right
counsel
trial
judge
must
advise
defendant
generally
defenses
criminal
charges
may
known
laypersons
danger
waiving
assistance
counsel
deciding
whether
plead
guilty
risk
viable
defense
overlooked
defendant
admonished
waiving
right
attorney
lose
opportunity
obtain
independent
opinion
whether
facts
applicable
law
wise
plead
guilty
addition
must
ensure
defendant
understands
nature
charges
range
allowable
punishments
granted
certiorari
view
division
opinion
requirements
sixth
amendment
imposes
waiver
counsel
plea
hearing
compare
akins
state
cashman
reverse
judgment
iowa
ii
sixth
amendment
secures
defendant
faces
incarceration
right
counsel
critical
stages
criminal
process
see
maine
moulton
wade
plea
hearing
qualifies
critical
stage
white
maryland
tovar
received
prison
term
owi
conviction
right
counsel
plea
stage
trial
elected
contest
charge
argersinger
hamlin
person
accused
crime
however
may
choose
forgo
representation
constitution
force
lawyer
upon
defendant
adams
ex
rel
mccann
require
waiver
right
counsel
knowing
voluntary
intelligent
see
johnson
zerbst
tovar
contends
waiver
counsel
november
first
owi
plea
hearing
insufficiently
informed
therefore
constitutionally
invalid
particular
asserts
trial
judge
elaborate
value
stage
case
attorney
advice
dangers
entering
plea
brief
respondent
described
waiver
counsel
intelligent
defendant
knows
choice
made
eyes
open
adams
however
prescribed
formula
script
read
defendant
elects
proceed
without
counsel
information
defendant
must
possess
order
make
intelligent
election
decisions
indicate
depend
range
factors
including
defendant
education
sophistication
complex
easily
grasped
nature
charge
stage
proceeding
see
johnson
waiver
trial
counsel
said
defendant
may
allowed
proceed
pro
se
must
warned
specifically
hazards
ahead
faretta
california
instructive
defendant
faretta
resisted
counsel
aid
preferring
represent
held
constitutional
right
recognizing
right
however
cautioned
although
defendant
need
skill
experience
lawyer
order
competently
intelligently
choose
made
aware
dangers
disadvantages
record
establish
knows
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
later
patterson
illinois
elaborated
dangers
disadvantages
faretta
referred
trial
observed
counsel
required
help
even
gifted
layman
adhere
rules
procedure
evidence
comprehend
subtleties
voir
dire
examine
witnesses
effectively
object
improper
prosecution
questions
much
warnings
pitfalls
proceeding
trial
without
counsel
therefore
said
must
rigorous
ly
conveyed
clarified
however
earlier
stages
criminal
process
less
searching
formal
colloquy
may
suffice
patterson
concerned
postindictment
questioning
police
prosecutor
stage
case
held
warnings
required
miranda
arizona
adequately
informed
defendant
fifth
amendment
rights
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
well
miranda
warnings
said
effectively
convey
defendant
right
counsel
present
questioning
addition
inform
ultimate
adverse
consequence
making
uncounseled
admissions
statements
may
used
ensuing
criminal
proceeding
miranda
warnings
added
also
sufficed
let
defendant
know
lawyer
namely
advise
refrain
making
statements
prove
damaging
defense
patterson
describes
pragmatic
approach
waiver
question
one
asks
purposes
lawyer
serve
particular
stage
proceedings
question
assistance
provide
accused
stage
order
determine
scope
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
type
warnings
procedures
required
waiver
right
recognized
require
less
rigorous
warnings
pretrial
patterson
explained
pretrial
proceedings
less
important
trial
stage
full
dangers
disadvantages
less
substantial
obvious
accused
trial
citation
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
tovar
case
state
maintains
like
miranda
warnings
found
adequate
patterson
iowa
plea
colloquy
suffices
advise
defendant
right
counsel
assure
guilty
plea
informed
voluntary
brief
petitioner
tr
oral
arg
plea
colloquy
according
state
makes
plain
attorney
role
challenge
charge
sentence
therefore
adequately
conveys
defendant
utility
counsel
dangers
brief
petitioner
tovar
hand
defends
precise
instructions
required
iowa
see
supra
essential
knowing
voluntary
intelligent
plea
stage
waiver
counsel
brief
respondent
resolve
case
need
endorse
state
position
nothing
plea
colloquy
needed
safeguard
tovar
right
counsel
preliminarily
note
things
case
tovar
first
indicated
waived
counsel
initial
appearance
see
supra
affirmed
wanted
represent
plea
hearing
see
supra
declined
offer
time
hire
attorney
sentencing
still
open
request
withdrawal
plea
see
supra
state
contest
defendant
must
alerted
right
assistance
counsel
entering
plea
see
brief
petitioner
acknowledging
defendant
need
know
retained
appointed
counsel
assist
plea
stage
work
ing
issues
guilt
sentencing
indeed
iowa
appeared
assume
tovar
informed
entitlement
counsel
aid
least
pretermitted
issue
see
accordingly
state
presents
narrower
question
sixth
amendment
require
give
rigid
detailed
admonishment
pro
se
defendant
pleading
guilty
usefulness
attorney
attorney
may
provide
independent
opinion
whether
wise
plead
guilty
without
attorney
defendant
risks
overlooking
defense
pet
cert
training
question
turn
reiterate
particular
language
iowa
employed
announcing
warnings
thought
sixth
amendment
required
trial
judge
must
advise
defendant
generally
defenses
criminal
charges
may
known
laypersons
danger
waiving
assistance
counsel
deciding
whether
plead
guilty
risk
viable
defense
overlooked
addition
defendant
admonished
waiving
right
attorney
lose
opportunity
obtain
independent
opinion
whether
facts
applicable
law
wise
plead
guilty
ibid
tovar
receive
advice
sole
question
us
whether
sixth
amendment
compels
two
admonitions
hold
recently
explained
reversing
lower
determination
guilty
plea
voluntary
law
ordinarily
considers
waiver
knowing
intelligent
sufficiently
aware
defendant
fully
understands
nature
right
likely
apply
general
circumstances
even
though
defendant
may
know
specific
detailed
consequences
invoking
ruiz
emphasis
original
similarly
observed
patterson
defendant
lacked
full
complete
appreciation
consequences
flowing
waiver
defeat
state
showing
information
provided
satisfied
constitutional
minimum
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
iowa
gave
insufficient
consideration
guiding
decisions
prescribing
scripted
admonitions
holding
necessary
every
guilty
plea
instance
note
iowa
high
overlooked
observations
information
defendant
must
waive
counsel
intelligently
depend
case
upon
particular
facts
circumstances
surrounding
case
johnson
supra
moreover
tovar
acknowledges
collateral
attack
uncounseled
conviction
defendant
burden
prove
competently
intelligently
waive
right
assistance
counsel
see
watts
state
iowa
brief
respondent
light
note
tovar
never
claimed
fully
understand
charge
range
punishment
crime
prior
pleading
guilty
never
articulate
precision
additional
information
counsel
provided
given
simplicity
charge
see
patterson
supra
assert
unaware
right
counseled
prior
arraignment
suggests
may
mistaken
belief
right
counsel
trial
merely
going
plead
guilty
brief
respondent
emphasis
added
given
particular
facts
circumstances
surrounding
case
see
johnson
far
clear
warnings
kind
required
iowa
enlightened
tovar
decision
whether
seek
counsel
represent
case
straightforward
amicus
curiae
suggests
admonitions
issue
might
confuse
mislead
defendant
inform
warnings
iowa
declared
mandatory
might
misconstrued
veiled
suggestion
meritorious
defense
exists
defendant
plead
lesser
charge
neither
prospect
realistic
one
defendant
delays
plea
vain
hope
counsel
uncover
tenable
basis
contesting
reducing
criminal
charge
prompt
disposition
case
impeded
resources
either
state
defendant
indigent
defendant
financially
ineligible
appointed
counsel
wasted
brief
amicus
curiae
tr
oral
arg
note
finally
free
adopt
statute
rule
decision
guides
acceptance
uncounseled
plea
deem
useful
see
alaska
rule
crim
proc
rule
crim
proc
md
rule
rule
crim
proc
rule
crim
proc
comment
hold
two
admonitions
iowa
ordered
required
federal
constitution
reasons
stated
judgment
iowa
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
ordered
footnotes
person
commits
offense
operating
intoxicated
person
operates
motor
vehicle
state
either
following
conditions
influence
alcoholic
beverage
alcohol
concentration
iowa
code
tovar
appeared
along
four
individuals
charged
misdemeanor
offenses
app
presiding
judge
proposed
conduct
plea
proceeding
five
cases
jointly
individuals
indicated
object
course
action
rule
since
renumbered
stage
still
open
tovar
request
withdrawal
guilty
plea
owi
charge
substitute
plea
guilty
see
iowa
rule
crim
proc
order
appear
owi
arraignment
tovar
drove
courthouse
despite
suspension
license
apprehended
en
route
home
app
prior
asking
tovar
whether
wished
hire
counsel
noted
tovar
applied
attorney
application
denied
financially
dependent
upon
parents
tovar
challenge
absence
counsel
sentencing
see
iowa
rule
crim
proc
defense
objection
request
capable
determination
without
trial
general
issue
may
raised
trial
motion
state
wilt
iowa
approving
use
motions
adjudication
law
points
iowa
rule
criminal
procedure
material
facts
undisputed
tovar
conceded
owi
conviction
used
enhancement
purposes
record
dissenting
justices
criticized
majority
approach
rigid
line
pragmatic
approach
described
patterson
illinois
noted
addition
advice
concerning
constitutional
rights
guilty
plea
relinquishes
tovar
made
fully
aware
penal
consequences
might
befall
went
forward
without
counsel
pleaded
guilty
ibid
amicus
curiae
reads
decision
scott
illinois
hold
constitutionally
defective
waiver
counsel
misdemeanor
prosecution
although
warranting
vacation
term
imprisonment
affords
ground
disturbing
underlying
conviction
amicus
accordingly
contends
constitution
preclude
use
uncounseled
misdemeanor
conviction
enhance
penalty
subsequent
offense
regardless
validity
prior
waiver
see
brief
amicus
curiae
state
however
contest
iowa
determination
conviction
obtained
without
effective
waiver
counsel
used
enhance
subsequent
charge
see
ibid
therefore
address
arguments
amicus
advances
questioning
premise
see
also
iowa
also
held
must
ensure
defendant
understands
nature
charges
range
allowable
punishments
parties
dispute
tovar
informed
trial
comment
tovar
appeared
without
counsel
arraignment
inquiry
whether
tovar
wanted
represent
hearing
see
app
hardly
lend
support
tovar
suggestion
may
believed
see
also
inquiry
sentencing
whether
tovar
want
ed
take
time
hire
attorney
iowa
rule
crim
proc
time
judgment
defendant
may
request
withdrawal
guilty
plea
substitution
guilty
plea