sillasse
bryan
argued
march
decided
june
held
term
willfully
requires
proof
defendant
knew
conduct
unlawful
also
knew
federal
licensing
requirement
pp
used
criminal
context
willful
act
generally
one
undertaken
bad
purpose
see
heikkinen
words
establish
willful
violation
statute
government
must
prove
defendant
acted
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
ratzlaf
rejects
petitioner
argument
two
principal
reasons
particularized
showing
required
first
knowingly
requirement
three
categories
acts
made
unlawful
demonstrates
government
must
prove
knowledge
persuasive
knowingly
refers
knowledge
facts
constituting
offense
distinguished
knowledge
law
see
bailey
respect
three
knowingly
categories
background
presumption
every
citizen
knows
law
makes
unnecessary
adduce
specific
evidence
prove
mind
regards
willfully
category
issue
however
jury
must
find
defendant
acted
mind
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
also
rejected
petitioner
second
argument
must
read
require
knowledge
law
light
adoption
similar
interpretation
cases
concerned
willful
violations
tax
laws
see
cheek
willful
structuring
cash
transactions
avoid
bank
reporting
requirement
see
ratzlaf
cases
readily
distinguishable
involved
highly
technical
statutes
threatened
ensnare
individuals
engaged
apparently
innocent
conduct
danger
present
jury
found
petitioner
knew
conduct
unlawful
pp
petitioner
additional
arguments
based
reading
congressional
intent
rejected
fopa
legislative
history
ambiguous
offer
much
assistance
since
main
support
lies
statements
made
opponents
bill
see
schwegmann
brothers
calvert
distillers
next
time
fopa
passed
willfulness
requirements
uniformly
interpreted
require
knowledge
inaccurate
number
courts
reached
different
conclusions
moreover
cases
adopting
petitioner
view
support
notion
disregard
known
legal
obligation
sufficient
establish
willful
violation
way
make
necessary
petitioner
final
governed
indicates
congress
intended
willfully
include
knowledge
similar
reason
pp
trial
misstatement
law
jury
instruction
given
correct
instructions
sentence
asserting
government
need
prove
petitioner
knowledge
breaking
law
provide
basis
reversal
petitioner
effectively
object
sentence
context
entire
instructions
seems
unlikely
jury
misled
petitioner
failed
raise
argument
second
circuit
grant
certiorari
limited
narrow
legal
question
hereinbefore
decided
pp
affirmed
tevens
delivered
opinion
onnor
ennedy
outer
homas
reyer
joined
outer
filed
concurring
opinion
calia
filed
dissenting
opinion
ehnquist
insburg
joined
notice
opinion
subject
formal
revision
publication
preliminary
print
reports
readers
requested
notify
reporter
decisions
washington
typographical
formal
errors
order
corrections
may
made
preliminary
print
goes
press
sillasse
bryan
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
second
circuit
june
justice
stevens
delivered
opinion
petitioner
convicted
willfully
dealing
firearms
without
federal
license
question
presented
whether
term
willfully
requires
proof
defendant
knew
conduct
unlawful
whether
also
requires
proof
knew
federal
licensing
requirement
congress
enacted
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
stat
title
iv
act
congress
made
findings
concerning
impact
traffic
firearms
prevalence
lawlessness
violent
crime
amended
criminal
code
include
detailed
provisions
regulating
use
sale
firearms
amended
defined
number
unlawful
acts
subsection
made
unlawful
person
except
licensed
dealer
engage
business
dealing
firearms
section
established
federal
licensing
program
repeated
prohibition
dealing
firearms
without
license
specified
penalties
violating
provision
chapter
read
literally
authorized
imposition
fine
prison
sentence
five
years
person
dealt
firearms
without
license
even
person
believed
acting
lawfully
enacted
omitted
express
scienter
requirement
therefore
arguably
imposed
strict
criminal
liability
every
unlicensed
dealer
firearms
act
also
omitted
definition
term
engaged
business
even
though
conduct
element
unlawful
act
prohibited
congress
enacted
firearms
owners
protection
act
fopa
part
cure
omissions
findings
statute
explained
additional
legislation
necessary
protect
citizens
respect
acquisition
possession
use
firearms
lawful
purposes
fopa
therefore
amended
include
definition
term
engaged
business
amended
add
scienter
requirement
condition
imposition
penalties
unlaw
ful
acts
defined
three
categories
offenses
intent
required
defendant
acted
knowingly
fourth
category
includes
provision
chapter
required
intent
defendant
acted
willfully
offense
issue
case
provision
willfully
category
ii
jury
found
petitioner
guilty
accept
government
version
evidence
evidence
proved
petitioner
federal
license
deal
firearms
used
straw
purchasers
ohio
acquire
pistols
purchased
straw
purchasers
made
false
statements
purchasing
guns
petitioner
assured
straw
purchasers
file
serial
numbers
guns
resold
guns
brooklyn
street
corners
known
drug
dealing
evidence
unquestionably
adequate
prove
petitioner
dealing
firearms
knew
conduct
unlawful
however
evidence
aware
federal
law
prohibits
dealing
firearms
without
federal
license
petitioner
charged
conspiracy
violate
willfully
engaging
business
dealing
firearms
substantive
violation
provision
close
evidence
petitioner
requested
trial
judge
instruct
jury
petitioner
convicted
knew
federal
licensing
requirement
judge
rejected
request
instead
trial
judge
gave
explanation
term
willfully
person
acts
willfully
acts
intentionally
purposely
intent
something
law
forbids
bad
purpose
disobey
disregard
law
person
need
aware
specific
law
rule
conduct
may
violating
must
act
intent
petitioner
found
guilty
counts
appeal
argued
evidence
insufficient
proof
knowledge
federal
licensing
requirement
trial
judge
erred
failing
instruct
jury
knowledge
essential
element
offense
appeals
affirmed
concluded
instructions
proper
government
elicited
ample
proof
petitioner
acted
willfully
app
eleventh
circuit
held
necessary
government
prove
defendant
acted
knowledge
licensing
requirement
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
iii
word
willfully
sometimes
said
word
many
meanings
whose
construction
often
dependent
context
appears
see
spies
obviously
differentiates
deliberate
unwitting
conduct
criminal
law
also
typically
refers
culpable
state
mind
explained
murdock
variety
phrases
used
describe
concept
general
matter
used
criminal
context
willful
act
one
undertaken
bad
purpose
words
order
establish
willful
violation
statute
government
must
prove
defendant
acted
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
ratzlaf
petitioner
argues
particularized
showing
required
case
two
principal
reasons
first
argues
fact
congress
used
adverb
knowingly
authorize
punishment
three
categories
acts
made
unlawful
word
willfully
referred
unlicensed
dealing
firearms
demonstrates
government
must
shoulder
special
burden
cases
like
argument
persuasive
term
knowingly
necessarily
reference
culpable
state
mind
knowledge
law
justice
jackson
correctly
observed
knowledge
requisite
knowing
violation
statute
factual
knowledge
distinguished
knowledge
law
thus
bailey
held
prosecution
fulfills
burden
proving
knowing
violation
escape
statute
demonstrates
escapee
knew
actions
result
leaving
physical
confinement
without
permission
staples
held
charge
defendant
possession
unregistered
machinegun
unlawful
required
proof
knew
weapon
possessed
characteristics
brought
within
statutory
definition
machinegun
however
necessary
prove
defendant
knew
possession
unlawful
see
rogers
plurality
opinion
slip
thus
unless
text
statute
dictates
different
result
term
knowingly
merely
requires
proof
knowledge
facts
constitute
offense
respect
three
categories
conduct
made
punishable
performed
knowingly
background
presumption
every
citizen
knows
law
makes
unnecessary
adduce
specific
evidence
prove
mind
directed
hand
required
however
respect
conduct
fourth
category
criminal
done
willfully
jury
must
find
defendant
acted
mind
say
acted
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
petitioner
next
argues
must
read
require
knowledge
law
interpretation
willfully
two
contexts
certain
cases
involving
willful
violations
tax
laws
concluded
jury
must
find
defendant
aware
specific
provision
tax
code
charged
violating
see
cheek
similarly
order
satisfy
willful
violation
ratzlaf
concluded
jury
find
defendant
knew
structuring
cash
transactions
avoid
reporting
requirement
unlawful
see
cases
however
readily
distinguishable
tax
cases
ratzlaf
involved
highly
technical
statutes
presented
danger
ensnaring
individuals
engaged
apparently
innocent
conduct
result
held
statutes
carv
exception
traditional
rule
rance
law
excuse
require
defendant
knowledge
law
danger
convicting
individuals
engaged
apparently
innocent
activity
motivated
decisions
tax
cases
ratzlaf
present
jury
found
petitioner
knew
conduct
unlawful
thus
willfulness
requirement
carve
exception
traditional
rule
ignorance
law
excuse
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
required
iv
petitioner
advances
number
additional
arguments
based
reading
congressional
intent
petitioner
first
points
legislative
history
fopa
history
ambiguous
offer
petitioner
much
assistance
petitioner
main
support
lies
statements
made
opponents
bill
stated
however
fears
doubts
opposition
authoritative
guide
construction
legislation
schwegmann
brothers
calvert
distillers
zeal
defeat
bill
understandably
tend
overstate
reach
nlrb
fruit
packers
petitioner
next
argues
time
fopa
passed
willfulness
requirements
subsections
uniformly
interpreted
lower
courts
require
knowledge
law
petitioner
argues
congress
intended
willfully
meaning
initial
matter
lower
courts
come
agreement
courts
stated
willfulness
satisfied
disregard
known
legal
obligation
willful
also
interpreted
variously
refer
purposeful
intentional
conduct
indifferen
ce
requirements
law
moreover
cases
disregard
known
legal
obligation
held
sufficient
establish
willfulness
perfectly
clear
record
licensee
knowledge
law
thus
cases
support
notion
disregard
known
legal
obligation
cient
establish
willful
violation
way
stand
proposition
required
finally
petitioner
argues
governed
willfulness
standard
indicates
congress
intended
willfully
include
knowledge
law
subsection
prohibits
licensees
selling
firearms
person
licensee
knows
reasonable
cause
believe
reside
licensee
state
except
inter
alia
transaction
fully
complies
laws
seller
buyer
state
subsection
licensee
shall
presumed
absence
evidence
contrary
actual
knowledge
state
laws
published
ordinances
although
petitioner
argues
presumption
indicates
congress
intended
willfulness
require
knowledge
law
offenses
covered
petitioner
mistaken
noted
disregard
known
legal
obligation
certainly
sufficient
establish
willful
violation
nothing
contradicts
basic
distinction
one
sentence
trial
instructions
jury
read
contained
misstatement
law
portion
instructions
given
correct
statement
already
quoted
judge
stated
case
government
required
prove
defendant
knew
license
required
government
required
prove
knowledge
breaking
app
emphasis
added
judge
added
words
required
license
sentence
accurate
given
nevertheless
error
provide
basis
reversal
four
reasons
first
petitioner
object
sentence
except
insofar
argued
jury
instructed
government
burden
proving
knowledge
federal
licensing
requirement
second
context
entire
instructions
seems
unlikely
jury
misled
see
park
third
petitioner
failed
raise
argument
appeals
finally
grant
certiorari
limited
narrow
legal
question
whether
knowledge
licensing
requirement
essential
element
offense
accordingly
judgment
appeals
affirmed
ordered
notes
sec
congress
hereby
finds
declares
widespread
traffic
firearms
moving
otherwise
affecting
interstate
foreign
commerce
existing
federal
controls
traffic
adequately
enable
control
traffic
within
borders
exercise
police
power
ease
person
acquire
firearms
rifle
shotgun
including
criminals
juveniles
without
knowledge
consent
parents
guardians
narcotics
addicts
mental
defectives
armed
groups
supplant
functions
duly
constituted
public
authorities
others
whose
possession
weapons
similarly
contrary
public
interest
significant
factor
prevalence
lawlessness
violent
crime
adequate
federal
control
interstate
foreign
commerce
weapons
persons
engaging
businesses
importing
manufacturing
dealing
grave
problem
properly
dealt
effective
state
local
regulation
traffic
made
possible
stat
stat
current
version
provision
substantially
version
codified
shall
unlawful
person
except
licensed
importer
licensed
manufacturer
licensed
dealer
engage
business
importing
manufacturing
dealing
firearms
course
business
ship
transport
receive
firearm
interstate
foreign
commerce
penalties
whoever
violates
provision
chapter
shall
fined
imprisoned
five
years
stat
congress
finds
additional
legislation
required
reaffirm
intent
congress
expressed
section
gun
control
act
purpose
title
place
undue
unnecessary
federal
restrictions
burdens
citizens
respect
acquisition
possession
use
firearms
appropriate
purpose
hunting
trapshooting
target
shooting
personal
protection
lawful
activity
title
intended
discourage
eliminate
private
ownership
use
firearms
citizens
lawful
purposes
stat
title
currently
provides
except
otherwise
provided
subsection
subsection
section
section
whoever
knowingly
makes
false
statement
representation
respect
information
required
chapter
kept
records
person
licensed
chapter
applying
license
exemption
relief
disability
provisions
chapter
knowingly
violates
subsection
section
knowingly
imports
brings
possession
thereof
firearm
ammunition
violation
section
willfully
violates
provision
chapter
shall
fined
title
imprisoned
five
years
see
supra
else
make
use
straw
purchasers
assure
shave
serial
numbers
guns
moreover
street
corner
sales
consistent
belief
legality
enterprise
although
prohibition
unlicensed
dealing
firearms
set
forth
see
supra
criminal
sanction
set
forth
see
supra
knowledge
law
federal
firearms
statute
defendant
charged
conspiracy
violate
allegedly
violated
sic
specific
intent
statute
must
accordingly
find
beyond
reasonable
doubt
defendant
relevant
times
charged
acted
knowledge
unlawful
engage
business
firearms
distribution
lawfully
purchased
legally
permissible
transferee
gun
purchaser
ou
must
persuaded
actual
knowledge
federal
firearms
licensing
laws
defendant
acted
knowing
intentional
violation
app
citing
ratzlaf
app
word
often
denotes
act
intentional
knowing
voluntary
distinguished
accidental
used
criminal
statute
generally
means
act
done
bad
purpose
felton
potter
spurr
without
justifiable
excuse
felton
supra
williams
people
pac
people
jewell
mich
louis
ry
batesville
tel
ark
clay
state
tex
cr
stubbornly
obstinately
perversely
wales
miner
ind
lynch
commonwealth
claus
chicago
gt
ry
iowa
state
harwell
word
also
employed
characterize
thing
done
without
ground
believing
lawful
roby
newton
conduct
marked
careless
disregard
whether
one
right
act
philadelphia
ry
fed
state
savre
iowa
state
morgan
see
heikkinen
willful
failure
deportee
sense
apply
identify
country
willing
receive
absence
evidence
purpose
justifiable
excuse
like
said
acted
purpose
without
excuse
murdock
hen
used
criminal
statue
willfully
generally
means
act
done
bad
purpose
felton
omitting
thing
knowingly
wilfully
implies
knowledge
thing
determination
bad
intent
omit
word
wilfully
says
chief
justice
shaw
ordinary
sense
used
statutes
means
merely
voluntarily
bad
purpose
pick
mass
frequently
understood
says
bishop
signifying
evil
intent
without
justifiable
excuse
crim
law
vol
sect
sand
siffert
loughlin
reiss
modern
federal
jury
instructions
means
act
knowledge
one
conduct
unlawful
intent
something
law
forbids
say
bad
purpose
disobey
disregard
law
opinion
dissenting
decision
upholding
constitutionality
statute
authorizing
punishment
knowing
violation
interstate
commerce
regulation
justice
jackson
wrote
suggested
defendant
protected
indefiniteness
conviction
authorized
knowing
violations
argument
seems
jury
find
defendant
knowingly
violated
regulation
finds
knew
meaning
regulation
accused
violating
exception
screws
rests
particularized
basis
knowledge
requisite
knowing
violation
statute
factual
knowledge
distinguished
knowledge
law
suppose
intends
suggest
petitioner
knew
nothing
existence
regulation
ignorance
constitute
defense
boyce
motor
lines
dissenting
opinion
liparota
case
concluded
term
knowing
term
knowingly
title
literally
referred
knowledge
law
well
knowledge
relevant
facts
see
justice
jackson
translation
terms
mens
rea
actus
reus
found
opinion
morissette
even
tax
cases
always
required
heightened
mens
rea
pomponio
per
curiam
example
jury
instructed
willful
act
one
done
bad
purpose
either
disobey
disregard
law
approved
instruction
concluding
trial
judge
adequately
instructed
jury
willfulness
stated
cheek
proliferation
statutes
regulations
sometimes
made
difficult
average
citizen
know
comprehend
extent
duties
obligations
imposed
tax
laws
congress
accordingly
softened
impact
presumption
making
specific
intent
violate
law
element
certain
federal
criminal
tax
offenses
thus
almost
years
ago
interpreted
statutory
term
used
federal
criminal
tax
statutes
carving
exception
traditional
rule
every
person
presumed
know
law
special
treatment
criminal
tax
offenses
largely
due
complexity
tax
laws
see
bates
slip
noting
ratzlaf
holding
based
particular
statutory
context
currency
structuring
ratzlaf
holding
based
particular
contex
currency
structuring
statute
urrency
structuring
inevitably
nefarious
person
structures
currency
transaction
invariably
motivated
desire
keep
government
dark
government
construction
statute
criminalize
apparently
innocent
activity
cheek
complex
tax
system
uncertainty
often
arises
even
among
taxpayers
earnestly
wish
follow
law
purpose
law
penalize
frank
difference
opinion
innocent
errors
made
despite
exercise
reasonable
care
bishop
quoting
spies
murdock
congress
intend
person
reason
bona
fide
misunderstanding
liability
tax
duty
make
return
adequacy
records
maintained
become
criminal
mere
failure
measure
prescribed
standard
conduct
cheek
see
also
ratzlaf
noting
venerable
principle
ignorance
law
generally
defense
criminal
charge
concluding
congress
intended
otherwise
particular
contex
currency
structuring
statute
even
ratzlaf
decided
chief
judge
breyer
explained
need
specificity
statutes
inapplicable
danger
conviction
defendant
innocent
state
mind
wrote
believe
criminal
prosecutions
law
violations
sort
issue
much
resemble
criminal
prosecutions
tax
law
violations
compare
sets
laws
technical
sets
laws
sometimes
criminalize
conduct
strike
ordinary
citizen
immoral
likely
unlawful
thus
sets
laws
may
lead
unfair
result
criminally
prosecuting
individuals
subjectively
honestly
believe
acted
criminally
cheek
sets
forth
legal
standard
requiring
proof
defendant
subjectively
aware
duty
issue
avoid
unfair
results
aversa
concurring
opinion
therefore
concluded
standards
apply
tax
cases
cases
ratzlaf
moreover
requiring
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
fully
consistent
purpose
fopa
fopa
enacted
protect
citizens
might
inadvertently
violate
law
see
supra
see
also
andrade
example
representative
hughes
staunch
opponent
bill
stated
willfulness
requirement
make
next
impossible
convict
dealers
particularly
engage
business
without
acquiring
license
prosecution
show
dealer
personally
aware
every
detail
law
made
conscious
decision
violate
law
cong
rec
even
petitioner
amicus
acknowledges
statement
undoubtedly
exaggeration
brief
national
association
criminal
defense
lawyers
amicus
curiae
see
also
andrade
see
perri
department
treasury
stein
blumenthal
rich
supp
sd
ohio
lewin
blumenthal
fin
feather
sport
shop
treasury
department
supp
neb
prino
simon
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
see
also
stein
person
intentionally
act
prohibited
evil
motive
reliance
erroneous
advice
acts
careless
disregard
statutory
requirements
violation
willful
internal
quotation
marks
omitted
perri
district
found
perri
knew
strawman
transaction
violate
act
stein
record
shows
plaintiff
agents
instructed
requirements
law
acknowledged
understanding
secretary
regulations
nevertheless
despite
repeated
warnings
secretary
violations
continued
occur
omitted
powers
bureau
alcohol
tobacco
firearms
supp
nd
bureau
representatives
inspected
powers
august
pointed
many
violations
gave
copy
regulations
thoroughly
explained
obligations
gave
pamphlet
explaining
obligations
date
powers
knew
obligations
shyda
director
bureau
alcohol
tobacco
firearms
supp
md
formal
administrative
hearing
petitioner
admitted
stand
oath
aware
specific
legal
obligation
issue
mayesh
schultz
sd
uncontroverted
evidence
shows
clearly
plaintiff
aware
holding
period
requirements
mayesh
previously
advised
requirements
illinois
law
clearly
acknowledged
aware
mclemore
treasury
department
supp
nd
finding
owner
pawnshop
well
employees
knowledge
law
mayesh
example
stated
uncontroverted
evidence
shows
clearly
plaintiff
aware
holding
period
requirements
mayesh
previously
advised
requirements
illinois
law
clearly
acknowledged
aware
since
material
facts
undisputed
matter
law
plaintiff
clearly
knowingly
violated
illinois
holding
provisions
hence
consider
action
matter
law
basis
trial
disputed
facts
connection
sufficient
justify
refusal
license
renewal
see
also
perri
stating
dealer
understands
requirements
law
knowingly
fails
follow
indifferent
willfulness
established
satisfied
stein
evidence
repeated
violations
knowledge
law
requirements
held
sufficient
establish
willfulness
emphasis
added
mclemore
petitioner
also
argues
statutory
willfully
violates
provision
chapter
congressional
intent
attach
liability
defendant
possesses
specific
knowledge
provision
chapter
rejected
similar
argument
international
minerals
chemical
although
case
involved
word
knowingly
phrase
knowingly
violates
regulation
response
see
reason
word
phrase
provision
chapter
construed
shorthand
designation
specific
acts
omissions
violate
act
act
viewed
signal
exception
rule
ignorance
law
excuse
sillasse
bryan
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
second
circuit
june
justice
souter
concurring
join
opinion
caveat
petitioner
raised
preserved
specific
objection
erroneous
statement
jury
instructions
see
part
ante
vote
vacate
conviction
sillasse
bryan
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
second
circuit
june
justice
scalia
chief
justice
justice
ginsburg
join
dissenting
petitioner
sillasse
bryan
convicted
willfully
violating
federal
licensing
requirement
firearms
dealers
jury
apparently
found
evidence
clearly
shows
bryan
aware
general
way
aspect
conduct
unlawful
see
ante
issue
whether
general
knowledge
illegality
enough
sustain
conviction
whether
willful
violation
licensing
provision
requires
proof
defendant
knew
conduct
unlawful
specifically
lacked
necessary
license
point
statute
view
genuinely
ambiguous
opinion
devoted
confirming
half
ambiguity
refuting
bryan
various
arguments
statute
clearly
requires
specific
knowledge
licensing
requirement
ante
offers
real
justification
implicit
conclusion
either
statute
unambiguously
requires
general
knowledge
illegality
ambiguously
requiring
general
knowledge
enough
instead
curiously
falls
back
traditional
rule
ignorance
law
excuse
conclude
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
required
ante
view
case
calls
application
different
familiar
rule
ambiguity
criminal
statute
doubts
resolved
favor
defendant
adamo
wrecking
quoting
bass
section
title
makes
unlawful
person
engage
business
dealing
firearms
without
federal
license
provision
enforced
criminally
imposes
criminal
penalties
whoever
willfully
violates
provision
chapter
word
willfully
wide
range
meanings
construction
often
influenced
context
ratzlaf
quoting
spies
contexts
connotes
nothing
act
intentional
knowing
voluntary
distinguished
accidental
murdock
present
context
however
inasmuch
preceding
three
subparagraphs
specify
mens
rea
knowingly
firearms
offenses
see
willful
violation
must
require
mental
state
culpable
mere
intent
perform
forbidden
act
concedes
apparently
agrees
violation
willful
unless
defendant
knows
general
way
conduct
unlawful
brief
ante
jury
must
find
defendant
acted
mind
say
acted
knowledge
conduct
unlawful
concession
takes
case
beyond
useful
application
maxim
ignorance
law
excuse
everyone
agrees
requires
knowledge
law
real
question
law
answer
knowledge
law
enoughor
put
another
way
defendant
must
ignorant
every
law
violated
course
conduct
innocent
willfully
violating
licensing
requirement
points
textual
basis
conclusion
notoriously
malleable
word
willfully
instead
seems
fall
back
presumption
apparently
derived
rule
ignorance
law
excuse
even
ignorance
law
excuse
excuse
construed
narrowly
statutory
language
permits
believe
approach
makes
sense
statute
congress
enacted
quarrel
assertion
willfully
requires
general
knowledge
sense
defendant
need
able
recite
chapter
verse
title
code
enough
view
defendant
generally
aware
actus
reus
punished
firearms
without
illegal
willing
accept
mens
rea
general
entirely
divorced
actus
reus
statute
enacted
punish
approach
turns
strange
unlikely
creature
bryan
guilty
willfully
dealing
firearms
without
federal
license
even
example
never
heard
licensing
requirement
aware
violated
law
using
straw
purchasers
filing
serial
numbers
pistols
ante
even
limit
rational
basis
limit
universe
relevant
laws
federal
firearms
statutes
bryan
also
act
ing
mind
hence
presumably
guilty
willfully
dealing
firearms
without
license
knew
transactions
violated
new
york
city
business
licensing
sales
tax
ordinances
matter
suffice
bryan
knew
car
sold
guns
illegally
doubleparked
order
meet
appointed
time
sale
intentionally
violated
pennsylvania
speed
limit
drive
back
gun
purchase
ohio
stop
focusing
conduct
defendant
actually
charged
selling
guns
without
license
see
principled
way
determine
law
defendant
must
conscious
violating
see
lewis
slip
scalia
concurring
judgment
pointing
similar
interpretive
problem
potentially
raised
assimilative
crimes
act
congress
free
course
make
criminal
liability
one
statute
turn
knowledge
another
use
firearms
dealer
statutes
encourage
compliance
new
york
city
tax
collection
efforts
put
judges
juries
kind
mental
gymnastics
described
strange
results
lightly
assume
congress
intended
make
liability
federal
criminal
statute
depend
heavily
upon
vagaries
local
local
law
dealing
completely
unrelated
subjects
must
presumption
cases
like
one
think
reasonable
presume
congress
makes
ignorance
law
defense
criminal
prohibition
ordinarily
means
ignorance
unlawfulness
specific
conduct
punished
criminal
prohibition
meaning
given
word
willfully
contexts
concluded
requires
knowledge
law
see
ratzlaf
convict
ratzlaf
crime
charged
jury
find
knew
structuring
engaged
unlawful
cheek
standard
statutory
willfullness
requirement
intentional
violation
known
legal
duty
issue
whether
defendant
knew
duty
purportedly
imposed
provision
statute
regulation
accused
violating
explains
cases
ground
involved
highly
technical
statutes
presented
danger
ensnaring
individuals
engaged
apparently
innocent
conduct
ante
explanation
complexity
tax
currency
laws
may
explain
interpreted
willful
require
awareness
illegality
opposed
merely
act
intentional
knowing
voluntary
distinguished
accidental
murdock
way
justifies
distinction
seeks
draw
today
knowledge
law
defendant
actually
charged
violating
knowledge
law
defendant
conceivably
charged
violating
protect
pure
heart
necessary
forgive
someone
whose
surreptitious
laundering
drug
money
violates
unbeknownst
technical
currency
statute
regardless
complex
violated
statute
may
defendant
acted
mind
seems
likely
congress
presumption
knowledge
illegality
mind
enacted
provision
issue
another
section
firearms
owners
protection
act
pub
stat
prohibits
licensed
dealers
selling
firearms
residents
unless
fully
comply
laws
provision
goes
state
licensed
dealers
shall
presumed
purposes
subparagraph
absence
evidence
contrary
actual
knowledge
state
laws
published
ordinances
ibid
like
provision
issue
violation
criminal
offense
committed
willfully
within
meaning
quite
correct
provision
establish
beyond
doubt
willfully
requires
knowledge
particular
prohibitions
violated
fact
knowledge
attributed
knowledge
prohibitions
sufficient
demonstrate
conclusively
knowledge
prohibitions
sufficient
ante
though
demonstrate
certainly
suggests
say
willful
violation
certain
law
criminal
knowledge
existence
law
presumed
fairly
reflects
think
presumption
willful
violation
requires
knowledge
law
violated
one
choose
therefore
think
presumption
statutory
intent
opposite
one
applies
reasonable
however
decide
case
basis
presumption
common
ground
statutory
context
requires
awareness
law
conviction
statute
simply
ambiguous
silent
precise
contours
mens
rea
requirement
face
ambiguity
invoke
rule
concerning
ambit
criminal
statutes
resolved
favor
lenity
bass
quoting
rewis
rule
penal
laws
construed
strictly
perhaps
much
less
old
construction
founded
tenderness
law
rights
individuals
plain
principle
power
punishment
vested
legislative
judicial
department
era
multiplying
new
federal
crimes
reason
ever
give
ancient
canon
construction
consistent
application
fostering
uniformity
interpretation
criminal
statutes
reduce
occasions
produce
judicial
havoc
resolving
defendants
favor
circuit
conflict
regarding
substantive
elements
federal
crime
see
bousley
respectfully
dissent