corley
argued
january
decided
april
mcnabb
mallory
generally
rende
inadmissible
confessions
made
periods
detention
violat
prompt
presentment
requirement
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
rule
turn
provides
person
making
arrest
must
take
defendant
without
unnecessary
delay
magistrate
judge
congress
enacted
response
miranda
arizona
applications
rule
attempt
eliminate
miranda
provides
confession
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
lists
several
considerations
courts
address
assessing
voluntariness
subsection
focuses
provides
confession
made
defendant
arrest
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
bringing
person
magistrate
judge
confession
found
trial
judge
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
extends
time
limit
delay
reasonable
considering
means
transportation
distance
nearest
available
magistrate
petitioner
corley
arrested
assaulting
federal
officer
around
fbi
agents
took
philadelphia
hospital
treat
minor
injury
taken
hospital
local
fbi
office
told
suspect
bank
robbery
though
office
building
nearest
magistrate
judges
agents
bring
magistrate
judge
questioned
hoping
confession
hours
arrest
corley
began
oral
confession
robbed
bank
asked
break
held
overnight
interrogation
resumed
next
morning
ending
signed
written
confession
finally
presented
magistrate
judge
hours
arrest
charged
armed
bank
robbery
related
charges
district
denied
motion
suppress
confessions
rule
reasoned
oral
confession
occurred
within
window
time
corley
medical
treatment
excluded
delay
also
found
written
confession
admissible
explaining
unreasonable
delay
rule
corley
requested
break
convicted
conspiracy
bank
robbery
third
circuit
affirmed
relying
circuit
precedent
effect
abrogated
replaced
pure
voluntariness
test
concluded
district
found
confession
voluntary
considering
points
listed
admissible
even
presentment
delay
unreasonable
held
section
modified
supplant
pp
government
claims
makes
confession
admissible
voluntarily
given
entirely
eliminates
bar
admitting
even
voluntary
confession
given
unreasonable
presentment
delay
corley
argues
meant
overrule
miranda
notes
touches
making
rule
inapplicable
confessions
given
within
six
hours
arrest
better
argument
pp
government
reading
renders
nonsensical
superfluous
subsection
really
meant
voluntary
confession
admissible
subsection
add
nothing
confession
made
voluntarily
admissible
period
never
inadmissible
solely
delay
even
delay
beyond
six
hours
government
reading
thus
odds
basic
interpretive
canon
statute
construed
give
effect
provisions
part
inoperative
superfluous
void
insignificant
hibbs
winn
government
claims
providing
confession
shall
admissible
congress
meant
confession
shall
involuntary
thus
read
specify
rule
applying
cases
delay
tell
courts
delay
alone
make
confession
involuntary
unless
delay
exceeds
six
hours
write
statute
way
russello
terms
inadmissible
involuntary
synonymous
congress
used
presume
ascribe
difference
simple
mistake
draftsmanship
ibid
also
every
reason
believe
congress
used
distinct
terms
deliberately
specifying
two
criteria
must
satisfied
prevent
confession
inadmissible
solely
delay
confession
must
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
moreover
rule
inadmissible
involuntary
mean
different
things
corley
position
contrast
gives
effect
reading
overruling
miranda
qualifying
government
counterargument
corley
reading
also
create
conflict
since
makes
voluntary
confessions
admissible
leave
voluntary
confessions
inadmissible
falls
short
first
broad
directive
aims
specific
statute
given
precedence
general
one
busic
second
reading
create
conflict
make
superfluous
also
create
conflicts
many
rules
evidence
subsection
possibly
given
literal
scope
pp
legislative
history
strongly
favors
corley
reading
government
points
nothing
history
supporting
contrary
view
pp
government
position
leave
rule
presentment
requirement
without
teeth
apparent
remedy
presentment
delay
prompt
presentment
requirement
administrative
nicety
dates
back
common
law
rule
presentment
point
judge
must
take
several
key
steps
foreclose
government
overreaching
informing
defendant
charges
giving
defendant
chance
consult
counsel
without
federal
agents
free
question
suspects
extended
periods
bringing
open
even
though
custodial
police
interrogation
nature
isolates
pressures
individual
dickerson
inducing
people
confess
crimes
never
committed
pp
merit
government
fallback
claim
even
preserved
limited
version
congress
cut
enacting
federal
rule
evidence
provides
relevant
evidence
admissible
except
otherwise
provided
constitution
act
congress
rules
rules
prescribed
advisory
committee
notes
expressly
identified
statutorily
authorized
rule
survive
rule
government
previously
conceded
rule
preserved
pp
vacated
remanded
souter
delivered
opinion
stevens
kennedy
ginsburg
breyer
joined
alito
filed
dissenting
opinion
roberts
scalia
thomas
joined
johnnie
corley
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
third
circuit
april
justice
souter
delivered
opinion
question
whether
congress
intended
discard
merely
narrow
rule
mcnabb
mallory
arrested
person
confession
inadmissible
given
unreasonable
delay
bringing
judge
hold
congress
meant
limit
eliminate
common
law
obliged
arresting
officer
bring
prisoner
magistrate
soon
reasonably
see
county
riverside
mclaughlin
scalia
dissenting
presentment
requirement
tended
prevent
secret
detention
served
inform
suspect
charges
law
nearly
every
american
state
national
government
see
mcnabb
supra
mcnabb
raised
question
enforce
number
federal
statutes
codifying
presentment
rule
citing
among
others
ed
provided
shall
duty
marshal
may
arrest
person
take
defendant
nearest
judicial
officer
federal
agents
flouted
requirement
interrogating
several
murder
suspects
days
bringing
magistrate
given
confessions
convicted
defendants
motions
exclude
confessions
evidence
saw
need
reach
constitutional
issue
instead
invoked
supervisory
power
establish
maintain
civilized
standards
procedure
evidence
federal
courts
exercised
sake
making
good
traditional
obligation
embodied
federal
presentment
legislation
saw
statutes
traditional
rule
aimed
checking
likelihood
resort
third
degree
meant
generally
avoid
evil
implications
secret
interrogation
persons
accused
crime
acknowledged
congress
ha
explicitly
forbidden
use
evidence
procured
derogation
presentment
obligation
realized
permit
ting
evidence
made
basis
conviction
federal
courts
stultify
policy
congress
ha
enacted
law
exercise
supervisory
authority
held
confessions
inadmissible
obtained
unreasonable
presentment
delay
shortly
mcnabb
combined
action
judicial
conference
congress
produced
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
pulled
several
statutory
presentment
provisions
together
one
place
see
mallory
supra
describing
rule
compendious
restatement
without
substantive
change
several
prior
specific
federal
statutory
provisions
first
enacted
rule
told
officer
making
arrest
warrant
issued
upon
complaint
person
making
arrest
without
warrant
take
arrested
person
without
unnecessary
delay
nearest
available
commissioner
nearby
officer
empowered
commit
persons
charged
offenses
laws
fed
rule
crim
proc
rule
remains
much
today
person
making
arrest
within
must
take
defendant
without
unnecessary
delay
magistrate
judge
fed
rule
crim
proc
case
applying
mcnabb
rule
together
soon
arose
upshaw
despite
government
confession
error
circuit
thought
mcnabb
exclusionary
rule
applied
involuntary
confessions
obtained
coercion
period
delay
held
defendant
voluntary
confession
admissible
evidence
error
reiterated
reasoning
years
earlier
mcnabb
case
held
plain
purpose
requirement
prisoners
promptly
taken
committing
magistrates
check
resort
officers
interrogation
persons
accused
crime
quoting
mcnabb
supra
upshaw
consequently
emphasized
even
voluntary
confessions
inadmissible
given
unreasonable
delay
presentment
applied
rule
mallory
holding
confession
given
seven
hours
arrest
inadmissible
unnecessary
delay
presenting
suspect
magistrate
police
questioned
suspect
hours
within
vicinity
numerous
committing
magistrates
repeated
reasons
rule
explained
since
delay
purpose
interrogation
epitome
unnecessary
delay
see
also
mclaughlin
scalia
dissenting
clear
common
law
element
bearing
upon
reasonableness
delay
circumstances
pressing
need
conduct
investigation
arresting
officer
ability
prisoner
secured
reach
magistrate
upshaw
supra
thus
rule
known
simply
generally
render
inadmissible
confessions
made
periods
detention
violat
prompt
presentment
requirement
rule
law
remained
congress
enacted
response
miranda
arizona
application
federal
courts
subsections
meant
eliminate
see
dickerson
infra
subsection
provides
criminal
prosecution
brought
confession
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
subsection
lists
several
considerations
courts
address
assessing
subsection
focused
see
infra
provides
federal
prosecution
confession
made
defendant
therein
person
arrest
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
bringing
person
magistrate
judge
confession
found
trial
judge
made
voluntarily
confession
made
within
six
hours
arrest
time
limit
extended
delay
reasonable
considering
means
transportation
distance
traveled
nearest
available
magistrate
issue
case
whether
congress
intended
sweep
exclusionary
rule
aside
entirely
merely
meant
provide
immunization
voluntary
confessions
given
within
six
hours
suspect
arrest
petitioner
johnnie
corley
suspected
robbing
bank
norristown
pennsylvania
federal
agents
learned
corley
subject
arrest
unrelated
local
matter
federal
state
officers
went
together
execute
state
warrant
september
found
pulling
driveway
car
corley
nearly
ran
one
officer
jumped
car
pushed
officer
ran
agents
gave
chase
caught
arrested
assaulting
federal
officer
arrest
occurred
fbi
agents
first
kept
corley
local
police
station
questioned
residents
near
place
captured
around
took
philadelphia
hospital
treat
minor
cut
hand
got
chase
agents
took
hospital
philadelphia
fbi
office
told
suspect
norristown
bank
robbery
though
office
building
chambers
nearest
magistrate
judges
agents
bring
corley
magistrate
questioned
instead
hopes
getting
confession
app
agents
repeated
arguments
sold
corley
benefits
cooperating
government
signed
form
waiving
miranda
rights
hours
arrest
corley
began
oral
confession
robbed
bank
spoke
vein
agents
asked
put
writing
corley
said
tired
wanted
break
agents
decided
hold
overnight
take
written
statement
next
morning
september
began
interrogation
ended
corley
signed
written
confession
finally
presented
magistrate
day
hours
arrest
corley
charged
armed
bank
robbery
conspiracy
commit
armed
bank
robbery
using
firearm
furtherance
crime
violence
moved
suppress
oral
written
confessions
rule
district
denied
motion
explanation
time
corley
receiving
medical
treatment
excluded
delay
oral
confession
thus
given
within
window
crim
ed
may
app
district
also
held
corley
written
confession
admissible
reasoning
break
interrogation
requested
arrestee
already
begun
confession
constitute
unreasonable
delay
rule
corley
convicted
conspiracy
armed
robbery
acquitted
using
firearm
crime
violence
divided
panel
appeals
third
circuit
affirmed
conviction
though
rationale
rejecting
corley
rule
argument
different
district
panel
majority
considered
bound
circuit
precedent
effect
entirely
abrogated
rule
replaced
pure
voluntariness
test
see
citing
government
virgin
islands
gereau
majority
saw
district
found
confession
voluntary
considering
points
listed
admissible
regardless
whether
delay
presentment
unnecessary
unreasonable
judge
sloviter
read
gereau
differently
dissented
opinion
displace
rule
abrogate
presentment
delays
beyond
six
hours
granted
certiorari
resolve
division
circuit
courts
reach
compare
glover
entirely
supplanted
christopher
mansoori
limited
rule
periods
six
hours
arrest
perez
vacate
remand
ii
government
argument
focuses
provides
confession
shall
admissible
evidence
federal
voluntarily
given
government
subsection
means
district
looks
considerations
finds
confession
voluntary
comes
entirely
eliminates
bar
admitting
even
voluntary
confession
given
unreasonable
delay
presentment
corley
argues
meant
overrule
miranda
nothing
effect
touches
subsection
providing
confession
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
presentment
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
subsection
leaves
inapplicable
confessions
given
within
six
hours
confession
comes
even
later
exclusionary
rule
applies
courts
see
whether
delay
unnecessary
unreasonable
corley
better
argument
fundamental
problem
government
reading
renders
nonsensical
superfluous
subsection
provides
confession
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
presentment
confession
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
really
meant
voluntary
confession
admissible
government
contends
add
nothing
confession
made
voluntarily
admissible
period
never
inadmissible
solely
delay
matter
whether
delay
went
beyond
six
hours
way
government
concedes
tr
oral
arg
congress
never
needed
overnment
view
always
superfluous
government
reading
thus
odds
one
basic
interpretive
canons
statute
construed
effect
given
provisions
part
inoperative
superfluous
void
insignificant
hibbs
winn
quoting
singer
statutes
statutory
construction
rev
ed
government
attempts
mitigate
problem
rewriting
clarifying
strictly
necessary
provision
although
congress
wrote
confession
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
confession
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
government
tells
us
congress
actually
meant
confession
shall
involuntary
solely
delay
confession
otherwise
voluntary
made
within
six
hours
arrest
thus
rewritten
coexist
peacefully
albeit
inelegantly
simply
specifying
rule
applying
cases
delay
tell
courts
delay
alone
make
confession
involuntary
unless
delay
exceeds
six
hours
proposal
short
answer
congress
write
statute
way
russello
quoting
naftalin
government
may
say
sensibly
read
inadmissible
involuntary
words
virtually
synonymous
statutory
context
brief
simply
begin
congress
used
terms
presume
ascribe
difference
simple
mistake
draftsmanship
russello
supra
fact
every
reason
believe
congress
used
distinct
terms
deliberately
subsection
specifies
two
criteria
must
satisfied
prevent
confession
inadmissible
solely
delay
confession
must
made
voluntarily
within
six
hours
arrest
voluntariness
thus
one
several
criteria
admissibility
involuntary
inadmissible
plainly
synonymous
government
argument
ignores
fact
rule
presume
congress
aware
cannon
university
chicago
inadmissible
involuntary
mean
different
things
explained
government
concedes
makes
even
voluntary
confessions
inadmissible
given
unreasonable
delay
presentment
upshaw
tr
oral
arg
well
understood
excluded
totally
voluntary
confessions
accept
government
attempt
confuse
critically
distinct
terms
involuntary
inadmissible
rewriting
rule
nothing
applying
corley
position
contrast
gives
effect
reading
overruling
miranda
qualifying
government
answers
however
accepting
corley
argument
result
different
problem
create
conflict
since
provides
voluntary
confessions
admissible
corley
reading
leaves
voluntary
confessions
inadmissible
government
counterargument
falls
short
two
reasons
first
even
read
odds
conflict
resolved
recognizing
broad
directive
aims
specific
statute
given
precedence
general
one
busic
second
fundamentally
prudently
read
create
conflict
make
superfluous
explained
simply
reading
way
create
conflicts
many
rules
subsection
possibly
given
literal
scope
subsection
provides
criminal
prosecution
brought
confession
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
defines
confession
confession
guilt
criminal
offense
statement
made
given
orally
writing
thus
government
seriously
urged
literal
reading
mean
criminal
prosecution
brought
statement
respect
criminal
offense
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
thus
many
rule
evidence
overridden
case
case
defendant
statement
lawyer
admissible
despite
insistence
privilege
hearsay
statement
defendant
allegedly
made
come
defendant
confession
entirely
unrelated
crime
committed
years
earlier
admissible
without
absurdities
literalism
show
congress
writing
literalistic
frame
turns
reductio
ad
absurdum
antisuperfluousness
canon
confirm
subsection
leaves
alone
legislative
history
says
fact
government
concedes
subsections
aimed
miranda
subsection
meant
modify
presentment
exclusionary
rule
tr
oral
arg
concede
section
considered
overrule
miranda
subsection
addressed
concession
unavoidable
senate
originated
split
provision
two
parts
division
contained
subsections
division
contained
subsection
cong
rec
debate
senate
floor
immediately
voting
proposals
several
senators
including
section
prime
sponsor
senator
mcclellan
explained
division
miranda
decision
division
related
mallory
cong
rec
distinct
intent
confirmed
separate
senate
votes
adopting
two
measures
division
division
abrogate
government
claims
voting
division
entirely
superfluous
division
vote
already
done
job
aside
sponsor
statement
full
senate
carries
considerable
weight
senator
mcclellan
explanation
division
specifically
addressed
miranda
confirms
never
meant
reach
far
enough
abrogate
background
evidentiary
rules
including
legislative
history
drives
point
home
conclusively
shows
intent
subsection
limit
replace
original
draft
subsection
indeed
done
away
completely
bill
first
written
provided
criminal
prosecution
confession
made
given
person
defendant
therein
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
bringing
person
magistrate
confession
made
voluntarily
reported
senate
committee
judiciary
cong
rec
provision
conceived
resisted
however
number
senators
worried
allowing
indefinite
presentment
delays
see
tydings
provision
permit
federal
criminal
suspects
questioned
indefinitely
presented
committing
magistrate
fong
provision
open
doors
practices
holding
suspects
incommunicado
indefinite
period
senator
tydings
proposed
striking
bill
altogether
amendment
senator
scott
introduced
compromise
qualifying
words
confession
made
given
person
within
six
hours
following
arrest
detention
amendment
amendment
intended
confine
excluding
confessions
given
six
hours
delay
see
cong
rec
remarks
scott
amendment
provides
period
confessions
may
received
shall
case
exceed
hours
explicitly
modeled
provision
congress
passed
months
earlier
govern
presentment
practice
district
columbia
title
iii
act
relating
crime
criminal
procedure
district
columbia
crime
act
stat
see
cong
rec
remarks
scott
amendment
attempt
conform
nearly
practicable
title
iii
crime
act
terms
act
ny
statement
admission
confession
made
arrested
person
within
three
hours
immediately
following
arrest
shall
excluded
evidence
courts
district
columbia
solely
delay
presentment
stat
given
clear
intent
title
iii
modify
eliminate
district
columbia
see
using
model
plainly
shows
congress
meant
much
sum
legislative
history
strongly
favors
corley
reading
government
points
nothing
history
supporting
view
created
rule
applying
cases
presentment
issue
also
counts
heavily
position
leave
rule
presentment
requirement
without
teeth
government
forced
admit
apparent
remedy
delay
presentment
tr
oral
arg
one
might
care
prompt
presentment
requirement
administrative
nicety
fact
rule
always
mattered
practical
ways
still
said
stretches
back
common
law
one
important
protections
unlawful
arrest
mclaughlin
scalia
dissenting
today
presentment
point
judge
required
take
several
key
steps
foreclose
government
overreaching
informing
defendant
charges
right
remain
silent
right
counsel
availability
bail
right
preliminary
hearing
giving
defendant
chance
consult
counsel
deciding
detention
release
fed
rule
crim
proc
see
also
rule
world
without
federal
agents
free
question
suspects
extended
periods
bringing
open
always
known
custodial
secrecy
leads
see
mcnabb
one
smattering
history
dictatorships
needs
lecture
subject
understand
need
even
within
system
take
care
going
far
ustodial
police
interrogation
nature
isolates
pressures
individual
dickerson
mounting
empirical
evidence
pressures
induce
frighteningly
high
percentage
people
confess
crimes
never
committed
see
drizin
leo
problem
false
confessions
world
rev
justice
frankfurter
point
mcnabb
fresh
ever
history
liberty
largely
history
observance
procedural
safeguards
one
neither
text
history
makes
case
congress
meant
away
iii
government
fallback
claim
even
preserved
limited
version
congress
cut
rule
altogether
enacting
federal
rule
evidence
act
pub
stat
far
might
matter
rule
provides
relevant
evidence
admissible
except
otherwise
provided
constitution
act
congress
rules
rules
prescribed
pursuant
statutory
authority
government
says
excludes
relevant
evidence
way
otherwise
provided
four
authorities
fallen
scythe
government
never
raised
argument
third
circuit
district
justify
refusing
consider
event
merit
advisory
committee
notes
rule
congress
enacted
rules
evidence
relied
past
interpret
rules
tome
plurality
opinion
expressly
identified
statutorily
authorized
rule
survive
rule
rules
civil
criminal
procedure
instances
require
exclusion
relevant
evidence
example
effective
enforcement
rule
held
require
exclusion
statements
elicited
detention
violation
thereof
pp
citing
mallory
see
also
mallory
supra
th
case
calls
proper
application
rule
federal
rules
criminal
procedure
indeed
government
previously
conceded
rule
preserved
brief
payner
saying
rule
left
courts
questions
concerning
propriety
excluding
relevant
evidence
method
implementing
constitution
federal
statute
statutorily
authorized
rule
citing
example
government
right
first
time
bizarre
hold
congress
adopted
rule
purpose
exactly
opposite
advisory
committee
notes
said
rule
iv
hold
modified
without
supplanting
rule
revised
district
suppression
claim
must
find
whether
defendant
confessed
within
six
hours
arrest
unless
longer
delay
reasonable
considering
means
transportation
distance
traveled
nearest
available
magistrate
confession
came
within
period
admissible
subject
rules
evidence
long
made
voluntarily
weight
given
left
jury
ibid
confession
occurred
presentment
beyond
six
hours
however
must
decide
whether
delaying
long
unreasonable
unnecessary
cases
confession
suppressed
case
third
circuit
apply
rule
consequence
never
conclusively
determined
whether
corley
oral
confession
treated
made
within
six
hours
arrest
district
held
circuit
consider
justifiability
delay
beyond
six
hours
oral
confession
treated
given
outside
window
make
enquiry
respect
corley
written
confession
therefore
vacate
judgment
appeals
remand
case
consideration
issues
first
instance
consistent
opinion
ordered
johnnie
corley
petitioner
writ
certiorari
appeals
third
circuit
april
justice
alito
chief
justice
justice
scalia
justice
thomas
join
dissenting
section
title
code
directly
unequivocally
answers
question
presented
case
petitioner
arrested
federal
agents
twice
waived
rights
voluntarily
confessed
first
orally
later
writing
participated
armed
bank
robbery
taken
magistrate
judge
initial
appearance
question
must
decide
whether
voluntary
confession
may
suppressed
ground
unnecessary
delay
bringing
petitioner
magistrate
judge
unless
unambiguous
language
ignored
petitioner
confession
may
suppressed
section
criminal
prosecution
brought
confession
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
applying
settled
principles
statutory
construction
must
first
determine
whether
statutory
text
plain
unambiguous
must
apply
statute
according
terms
carcieri
salazar
slip
nothing
ambiguous
language
claim
otherwise
although
normally
presume
congress
means
statute
says
connecticut
nat
bank
germain
today
concludes
mean
says
voluntary
confession
may
suppressed
supervisory
rule
requires
suppression
confession
unnecessary
delay
bringing
federal
criminal
defendant
judicial
officer
arrest
announced
long
adopted
according
rule
survived
enactment
congress
adopted
provision
sole
purpose
abrogating
miranda
apparently
never
realized
provision
broad
language
also
away
rule
disagree
analysis
therefore
respectfully
dissent
ii
first
substantial
argument
invokes
antisuperfluousness
canon
ante
statute
read
possible
provisions
given
effect
none
superfluous
ante
section
provides
voluntary
confession
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
bringing
defendant
judicial
officer
defendant
brought
judicial
officer
within
six
hours
arrest
means
voluntary
confession
may
never
excluded
due
delay
bringing
defendant
judicial
officer
reasons
provides
safe
harbor
subset
voluntary
confessions
made
cases
initial
appearance
occurs
within
six
hours
arrest
superfluous
canons
interpretation
quite
often
useful
close
cases
statutory
language
ambiguous
observed
canon
license
judiciary
rewrite
language
enacted
legislature
monsanto
quoting
albertini
like
canons
antisuperfluousness
canon
merely
interpretive
aid
absolute
rule
see
connecticut
nat
bank
words
statute
unambiguous
first
canon
also
last
inquiry
times
congress
enacts
provisions
superfluous
may
instance
cf
noting
edundancies
across
statutes
unusual
events
drafting
gutierrez
de
martinez
lamagno
souter
dissenting
noting
although
congress
indulged
little
redundancy
inelegance
may
forgiven
congress
sensibly
seen
practical
value
redundancy
moreover
superfluity
created
giving
subsection
plain
meaning
may
minimized
interpreting
subsection
apply
confessions
otherwise
voluntary
government
contends
though
inartfully
drafted
superfluous
provision
means
confession
admissible
given
within
six
hours
arrest
otherwise
voluntary
basis
prepresentment
delay
concluding
confession
coerced
read
way
superfluous
rejects
argument
ground
write
statute
way
ante
thus
order
adhere
narrow
reading
entirely
disregards
unambiguous
language
although
says
confession
admissible
voluntarily
given
reads
provision
mean
voluntary
confession
may
excluded
ground
confession
obtained
violation
miranda
reading
short
answer
congress
really
write
statute
way
true
statutory
interpretation
questions
come
question
case
like
jigsaw
puzzle
simply
perfect
solution
problem
us
instead
must
choose
two
imperfect
solutions
first
one
adopted
entirely
disregards
clear
simple
language
rests
proposition
congress
understand
plain
import
language
used
subsection
adheres
strictly
literal
interpretation
second
option
respects
clear
language
subsection
either
accepts
statutory
surplusage
interprets
reference
voluntary
confession
mean
otherwise
voluntary
confession
mind
latter
choice
far
preferable
addition
antisuperfluousness
canon
relies
canon
favors
specific
statutory
provision
conflicting
provision
cast
general
terms
ante
canon
inapplicable
one
thing
quite
specific
specifically
provides
confession
voluntary
admissible
important
provision
specific
general
conflicts
see
national
cable
telecommunications
gulf
power
true
specific
statutory
language
control
general
language
conflict
two
however
conflict
emphasis
added
subsection
conflicting
authorize
suppression
voluntary
confession
identifies
conflict
two
statutory
provisions
conflict
express
language
one
provision
negative
implication
draws
another
precludes
suppression
voluntary
confession
based
solely
delay
less
six
hours
infers
congress
must
contemplated
voluntary
confession
suppressed
based
solely
delay
six
hours
cites
authority
canon
interpretation
favors
negative
implication
sort
clear
express
statutory
language
contends
literal
interpretation
leave
prompt
presentment
requirement
set
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
without
teeth
apparent
remedy
delay
presentment
ante
nothing
strange
however
prompt
presentment
requirement
enforced
rule
excluding
voluntary
confessions
made
period
excessive
prepresentment
delay
notes
common
law
obliged
arresting
officer
bring
prisoner
magistrate
soon
reasonably
ante
supervisory
rule
adopted
middle
century
day
required
fourth
amendment
bring
arrestee
promptly
judicial
officer
see
county
riverside
mclaughlin
never
held
constitutional
requirement
backed
automatic
exclusionary
sanction
see
hudson
michigan
although
prompt
presentment
requirement
serves
interests
addition
prevention
coerced
confessions
rule
provides
sanction
excessive
prepresentment
delay
instances
confession
sought
obtained
moreover
need
exclusionary
rule
longer
clear
rule
adopted
long
miranda
originally
served
purpose
addressed
giving
miranda
warnings
upon
arrest
miranda
recognized
mcnabb
mallory
responsive
considerations
fifth
amendment
policy
miranda
rule
devised
address
miranda
arizona
era
requirement
prompt
presentment
ensured
persons
taken
custody
within
relatively
short
period
receive
advice
rights
see
mcnabb
however
miranda
ensures
arrestees
receive
advice
even
earlier
point
within
moments
taken
custody
course
arrestees
receiving
miranda
warnings
may
waive
rights
submit
questioning
law
enforcement
officers
see
davis
arrestees
may
likewise
waive
prompt
presentment
requirement
see
new
york
hill
context
broad
array
constitutional
statutory
provisions
articulated
general
rule
presumes
availability
waiver
recognized
basic
rights
criminal
defendants
subject
seems
unlikely
many
arrestees
willing
waive
right
remain
silent
right
assistance
counsel
questioning
balk
waiving
right
prompt
presentment
courts
appeals
gone
far
hold
waiver
miranda
rights
also
constitutes
waiver
see
salamanca
cadc
cert
denied
barlow
cert
denied
indian
boy
cert
denied
duvall
cert
denied
howell
pettyjohn
cadc
cert
denied
cert
denied
whether
decisions
correct
certainly
clear
rule
adds
much
protection
beyond
provided
miranda
contends
legislative
history
supports
interpretation
legislative
history
proves
nothing
evident
terms
statute
respect
legislative
history
certainly
shows
provision
chief
backers
meant
away
cites
evidence
intended
accomplish
contrary
senate
report
clearly
says
meant
reinstate
traditional
rule
confession
excluded
involuntary
see
senate
report
step
obviously
consequences
beyond
elimination
miranda
senate
report
repeatedly
cited
escobedo
illinois
example
unsound
limitation
admission
voluntary
confessions
see
senate
report
thus
illustrating
understood
simply
provision
whether
majority
members
house
senate
rule
specifically
mind
voted
immaterial
statutory
provisions
may
often
reach
broader
specific
targets
lawmakers
might
mind
time
enactment
legislative
history
relating
suggests
nothing
members
congress
may
mistakenly
thought
version
finally
adopted
displace
rule
relates
version
emerged
senate
judiciary
committee
completely
eliminated
rule
see
ante
senators
opposed
version
provision
eventually
passed
simply
trimmed
rule
possible
identify
senators
spoke
opposition
earlier
version
subsection
voted
favor
version
eventually
passed
fair
infer
senators
likely
thought
amendment
subsection
saved
rule
see
cong
rec
evidence
majority
house
senate
shared
view
member
took
moments
read
subsections
must
readily
understood
subsection
wipe
away
based
rules
barring
admission
voluntary
confessions
miranda
subsection
authorize
suppression
voluntary
confessions
unjustifiably
attributes
majority
house
senate
mistake
legislative
history
suggests
may
made
finally
argues
literal
reading
many
rule
evidence
overridden
case
case
ante
order
avoid
absurd
result
says
necessary
read
merely
abrogating
miranda
rule
merit
language
congress
used
confession
admissible
voluntarily
given
virtually
verbatim
quotation
language
used
describing
traditional
rule
regarding
admission
confessions
see
haynes
washington
short
true
test
admissibility
confession
made
freely
voluntarily
without
compulsion
inducement
sort
quoting
wilson
lyons
oklahoma
ziang
sung
wan
bram
making
statements
certainly
mean
suggest
voluntary
confession
must
admitted
instances
standard
rule
evidence
preclude
admission
reason
suppose
congress
meant
thing
either
event
federal
rules
evidence
make
clear
supersede
ordinary
evidence
rules
including
rules
regarding
privilege
rule
hearsay
rule
restrictions
use
character
evidence
rule
thus
necessary
disregard
plain
language
order
avoid
sort
absurd
results
refers
reasons
affirm
decision
appeals
therefore
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
rejected
attempt
overrule
miranda
dickerson
full
subsections
provide
criminal
prosecution
brought
district
columbia
confession
defined
subsection
hereof
shall
admissible
evidence
voluntarily
given
confession
received
evidence
trial
judge
shall
presence
jury
determine
issue
voluntariness
trial
judge
determines
confession
voluntarily
made
shall
admitted
evidence
trial
judge
shall
permit
jury
hear
relevant
evidence
issue
voluntariness
shall
instruct
jury
give
weight
confession
jury
feels
deserves
circumstances
trial
judge
determining
issue
voluntariness
shall
take
consideration
circumstances
surrounding
giving
confession
including
time
elapsing
arrest
arraignment
defendant
making
confession
made
arrest
arraignment
whether
defendant
knew
nature
offense
charged
suspected
time
making
confession
whether
defendant
advised
knew
required
make
statement
statement
used
whether
defendant
advised
prior
questioning
right
assistance
counsel
whether
defendant
without
assistance
counsel
questioned
giving
confession
presence
absence
factors
taken
consideration
judge
need
conclusive
issue
voluntariness
confession
full
subsection
provides
criminal
prosecution
district
columbia
confession
made
given
person
defendant
therein
person
arrest
detention
custody
officer
agency
shall
inadmissible
solely
delay
bringing
person
magistrate
judge
officer
empowered
commit
persons
charged
offenses
laws
district
columbia
confession
found
trial
judge
made
voluntarily
weight
given
confession
left
jury
confession
made
given
person
within
six
hours
immediately
following
arrest
detention
provided
time
limitation
contained
subsection
shall
apply
case
delay
bringing
person
magistrate
judge
officer
beyond
period
found
trial
judge
reasonable
considering
means
transportation
distance
traveled
nearest
available
magistrate
judge
officer
granted
certiorari
resolve
question
ultimately
resolved
case
different
ground
dissent
says
antisuperfluousness
canon
place
nothing
ambiguous
language
post
opinion
alito
response
violates
cardinal
rule
statute
read
whole
king
vincent
hospital
subsection
seems
clear
one
ignores
absurd
results
literal
reading
infra
one
reads
recognizes
means
literally
says
serves
purpose
even
dissent
concedes
read
together
simply
perfect
solution
problem
us
post
thus
dissent
point
subsection
seems
clear
read
isolation
proves
nothing
meaning
ambiguity
certain
words
phrases
may
become
evident
placed
context
fda
brown
williamson
tobacco
subsection
read
context
avoiding
question
congress
getting
better
answer
congress
meant
members
explicitly
said
legislative
record
see
infra
dissent
seeks
avoid
absurd
results
claiming
supersede
ordinary
evidence
rules
post
argument
conclusion
reason
suppose
congress
meant
thing
post
dissent
certainly
correct
reason
suppose
congress
meant
thing
reductio
ad
absurdum
shows
leaves
dissent
saying
must
read
literally
rendering
superfluous
literally
override
rules
evidence
dissent
ways
means
profess
literalism
take
absurdity
literalism
brings
credo
quia
absurdum
tertullian
may
said
take
absurd
literalism
alternative
reading
statute
proviso
end
relating
reasonable
delays
caused
means
transportation
distance
traveled
came
later
separate
amendment
cong
rec
footnotes
see
miranda
arizona
see
mcnabb
mallory
argument
government
conceded
section
considered
overrule
miranda
subsection
addressed
see
tr
oral
arg
apparent
attorney
government
chose
words
carefully
concede
seems
suggest
subsection
intended
overrule
miranda
subsection
part
affected
rule
contrary
suggestion
cases
one
standard
rules
evidence
might
block
admission
voluntary
confession
seem
quite
rare
cites
examples
thus
justifies
reading
totally
disregards
clear
language
subsection
based
essentially
fanciful
hypothetical
cases
event
covered
since
federal
rules
evidence