wilder
virginia
hospital
argued
january
decided
june
qualify
federal
financial
assistance
help
defray
cost
furnishing
medical
care
needy
medicaid
act
must
submit
secretary
health
human
services
approval
plan
inter
alia
establishes
scheme
reimbursing
health
care
providers
congress
passed
boren
amendment
act
requires
provider
reimbursement
according
rates
state
finds
makes
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
state
must
also
assure
secretary
individuals
reasonable
access
facilities
adequate
quality
virginia
plan
providers
reimbursed
according
prospective
formula
approved
secretary
amendment
respondent
nonprofit
corporation
composed
public
private
hospitals
operating
virginia
filed
suit
petitioner
state
officials
declaratory
injunctive
relief
alleging
state
plan
violates
act
reimbursement
rates
reasonable
adequate
district
denied
petitioners
motion
dismiss
summary
judgment
based
claim
afford
respondent
cause
action
appeals
affirmed
concluding
providers
may
sue
state
officials
declaratory
injunctive
relief
assure
compliance
boren
amendment
held
boren
amendment
enforceable
action
declaratory
injunctive
relief
brought
health
care
providers
pp
section
provides
cause
action
deprivation
rights
secured
federal
laws
inapplicable
statute
question
create
enforceable
rights
within
meaning
congress
foreclosed
enforcement
statute
enactment
wright
roanoke
redevelopment
housing
authority
boren
amendment
creates
substantive
federal
right
enforceable
providers
adoption
reasonable
adequate
reimbursement
rates
little
doubt
providers
intended
beneficiaries
amendment
see
golden
state
transit
los
angeles
since
amendment
establishes
system
reimbursing
providers
phrased
terms
benefiting
moreover
amendment
imposes
binding
obligation
gives
rise
enforceable
rights
see
pennhurst
state
school
hospital
halderman
since
cast
mandatory
rather
predatory
terms
since
provision
federal
funds
expressly
conditioned
compliance
amendment
petitioners
contention
congress
intend
require
adopt
rates
actually
reasonable
adequate
contrary
statutory
language
requires
state
find
rates
satisfy
requirements
entitles
secretary
reject
state
plan
upon
concluding
assurances
given
unsatisfactory
render
requirements
thus
entire
reimbursement
provision
essentially
meaningless
petitioners
contention
quickly
dispelled
review
amendment
background
legislative
history
demonstrate
amendment
passed
free
restrictive
reimbursement
requirements
previously
imposed
secretary
relieve
fundamental
obligation
pay
reasonable
rates
congress
intended
retain
providers
right
challenge
rates
unreasonable
injunctive
suits
furthermore
state
flexibility
adopt
rates
finds
reasonable
adequate
petitioners
contend
render
obligation
imposed
amendment
vague
amorphous
judicially
enforceable
see
golden
state
supra
statute
secretary
regulations
set
factors
state
must
consider
adopting
rates
statute
requires
state
making
findings
judge
rates
reasonableness
objective
benchmark
efficiently
economically
operated
facility
ensuring
reasonable
access
eligible
participants
although
knowledge
hospital
industry
might
required
evaluate
state
findings
inquiry
well
within
competence
judiciary
pp
congress
foreclosed
private
judicial
remedy
enforcement
boren
amendment
since
express
provision
effect
act
see
wright
supra
since
statute
create
remedial
scheme
sufficiently
comprehensive
demonstrate
intent
preclude
remedy
suits
see
middlesex
county
sewerage
authority
national
sea
clammers
primary
purpose
amendment
reduce
secretary
role
determining
rate
payment
calculation
methods
secretary
limited
oversight
function
act
authorizes
withhold
approval
plans
curtail
federal
funds
cases
noncompliance
insufficient
demonstrate
intent
foreclose
relief
cf
wright
supra
moreover
although
regulation
requires
adopt
appeals
procedure
individual
providers
may
obtain
administrative
review
reimbursement
rates
also
allows
limit
issues
may
raised
review
including
virginia
allow
providers
challenge
overall
method
rates
determined
limited
state
procedures
considered
comprehensive
scheme
precludes
reliance
see
pp
brennan
delivered
opinion
white
marshall
blackmun
stevens
joined
rehnquist
filed
dissenting
opinion
scalia
kennedy
joined
post
claire
guthrie
deputy
attorney
general
virginia
argued
cause
petitioners
briefs
mary
sue
terry
attorney
general
roger
chaffe
senior
assistant
attorney
general
pamela
reed
virginia
manhard
assistant
attorneys
general
deputy
solicitor
general
roberts
argued
cause
amicus
curiae
urging
reversal
brief
solicitor
general
starr
assistant
attorney
general
gerson
lawrence
robbins
anthony
steinmeyer
irene
solet
walter
dellinger
argued
cause
respondent
brief
martin
donlan
judith
henry
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
state
connecticut
et
al
clarine
nardi
riddle
attorney
general
connecticut
richard
lynch
arnold
menchel
kenneth
graham
assistant
attorneys
general
attorneys
general
respective
follows
siegelman
alabama
douglas
baily
alaska
robert
corbin
arizona
john
van
de
kamp
california
duane
woodard
colorado
charles
oberly
iii
delaware
robert
butterworth
florida
michael
bowers
georgia
warren
price
iii
hawaii
jim
jones
idaho
neil
hartigan
illinois
linley
pearson
indiana
thomas
miller
iowa
robert
stephan
kansas
frederic
cowan
kentucky
william
guste
louisiana
james
tierney
maine
joseph
curran
maryland
james
shannon
massachusetts
frank
kelley
michigan
hubert
humphrey
iii
minnesota
mike
moore
mississippi
william
webster
missouri
marc
racicot
montana
brian
mckay
nevada
john
arnold
new
hampshire
peter
perretti
new
jersey
hal
stratton
new
mexico
robert
abrams
new
york
lacy
thornburg
north
carolina
nicholas
spaeth
north
dakota
anthony
celebrezze
ohio
robert
henry
oklahoma
david
frohnmayer
oregon
ernest
preate
pennsylvania
james
rhode
island
travis
medlock
south
carolina
roger
tellinghuisen
south
dakota
charles
burson
tennessee
jim
mattox
texas
paul
van
dam
utah
jeffrey
amestoy
vermont
kenneth
eikenberry
washington
charles
brown
west
virginia
joseph
meyer
wyoming
national
governors
association
et
al
benna
ruth
solomon
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
american
health
care
association
et
al
thomas
fox
joel
hamme
eugene
tillman
thomas
mcgough
rex
lee
carter
phillips
california
association
hospitals
et
al
robert
klein
mark
windisch
darryl
cordero
temple
university
matthew
strickler
robert
newman
filed
brief
gray
panthers
advocacy
committee
et
al
amici
curiae
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
case
requires
us
determine
whether
health
care
provider
may
bring
action
ed
challenge
method
state
reimburses
health
care
providers
medicaid
act
act
stat
amended
et
seq
ed
supp
specifically
question
presented
whether
boren
amendment
act
requires
reimbursement
according
rates
state
finds
makes
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
supp
enforceable
action
pursuant
medicaid
cooperative
program
federal
government
provides
financial
assistance
may
furnish
medical
care
needy
individuals
although
participation
program
voluntary
participating
must
comply
certain
requirements
imposed
act
regulations
promulgated
secretary
health
human
services
secretary
qualify
federal
assistance
state
must
submit
secretary
approved
plan
medical
assistance
contains
comprehensive
statement
describing
nature
scope
state
medicaid
program
cfr
state
plan
required
establish
among
things
scheme
reimbursing
health
care
providers
medical
services
provided
needy
individuals
section
act
sets
requirements
reimbursement
health
care
providers
amended
boren
amendment
section
provides
state
plan
medical
assistance
must
provide
payment
hospital
services
nursing
facility
services
services
intermediate
care
facility
mentally
retarded
provided
plan
use
rates
determined
accordance
methods
standards
developed
state
state
finds
makes
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
order
provide
care
services
conformity
applicable
state
federal
laws
regulations
quality
safety
standards
assure
individuals
eligible
medical
assistance
reasonable
access
inpatient
hospital
services
adequate
quality
supp
emphasis
added
respondent
virginia
hospital
association
vha
nonprofit
corporation
composed
public
private
hospitals
operating
virginia
app
filed
suit
district
eastern
district
virginia
several
state
officials
including
governor
secretary
human
resources
members
state
department
medical
assistance
services
state
agency
administers
virginia
medicaid
system
respondent
contends
virginia
plan
reimbursement
violates
act
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
economically
efficiently
incurred
cost
providing
care
medicaid
patients
hospitals
assure
access
inpatient
care
app
see
also
app
per
diem
reimbursement
rates
reasonably
adequately
met
costs
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
hospitals
providing
care
services
conformity
applicable
state
federal
laws
regulations
quality
safety
standards
respondent
seeks
declaratory
injunctive
relief
including
order
requiring
petitioners
promulgate
new
state
plan
providing
new
rates
interim
reimburse
medicaid
providers
rates
commensurate
payments
medicare
program
app
petitioners
filed
motion
dismiss
alternative
motion
summary
judgment
ground
ed
afford
respondent
cause
action
challenge
commonwealth
compliance
medicaid
act
record
exh
district
denied
motion
app
pet
cert
appeals
fourth
circuit
affirmed
concluding
health
care
providers
may
sue
state
officials
declaratory
injunctive
relief
ensure
compliance
act
specifically
held
language
legislative
history
boren
amendment
demonstrate
creates
enforceable
rights
congress
intend
foreclose
private
remedy
enforcement
rights
virginia
hospital
assn
baliles
granted
certiorari
order
determine
whether
boren
amendment
enforceable
useful
first
consider
history
reimbursement
provision
enacted
act
required
provide
reimbursement
reasonable
cost
hospital
services
actually
provided
measured
according
standards
adopted
secretary
pub
stat
congress
became
concerned
however
secretary
wielded
much
control
reimbursement
rates
see
congress
therefore
amended
act
give
flexibility
develop
methods
standards
reimbursement
congress
retained
ultimate
requirement
rates
reimburse
reasonable
cost
services
provided
new
law
required
pay
reasonable
cost
inpatient
hospital
services
determined
accordance
methods
standards
shall
developed
state
reviewed
approved
secretary
pub
stat
response
rapidly
rising
medicaid
costs
congress
extended
boren
amendment
hospitals
part
omnibus
budget
reconciliation
act
pub
stat
congress
blamed
mounting
medicaid
costs
complexity
rigidity
secretary
reimbursement
regulations
see
vol
pp
pp
although
previous
version
act
theory
afforded
degree
flexibility
adopt
methods
determining
reimbursement
rates
congress
found
fact
regulations
promulgated
secretary
essentially
forced
adopt
medicaid
rates
based
medicare
reasonable
cost
principles
congress
recognize
inflationary
nature
current
cost
reimbursement
system
intend
ed
give
greater
latitude
developing
implementing
alternative
reimbursement
methodologies
promote
efficient
economical
delivery
services
vol
supra
amendment
delete
current
provision
requiring
reimburse
hospitals
reasonable
cost
basis
substitute
provision
requiring
reimburse
hospitals
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
cost
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
order
meet
applicable
laws
quality
safety
standards
thus
congress
affirmed
desire
state
reimbursement
rates
reasonable
afforded
greater
flexibility
calculating
reasonable
rates
example
congress
explained
free
establish
statewide
classwide
rates
establish
rates
based
prospective
cost
include
incentive
provisions
encourage
efficient
operation
see
vol
supra
supra
flexibility
ensured
limiting
oversight
role
secretary
see
supra
thus
boren
amendment
provides
state
must
reimburse
providers
according
rates
finds
makes
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
state
must
also
assure
secretary
individuals
reasonable
access
facilities
adequate
quality
act
define
terms
secretary
declined
adopt
national
definition
concluding
determine
factors
considered
determining
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
efficiently
economically
operated
facilit
ies
see
fed
reg
regulations
require
state
make
finding
least
annually
rates
reasonable
adequate
see
cfr
though
state
required
submit
assurances
effect
secretary
makes
change
reimbursement
rates
see
fed
reg
according
secretary
boren
amendment
places
responsibility
development
reasonable
adequate
payment
rates
thus
reviews
reasonableness
assurances
provided
state
state
findings
see
cfr
secretary
review
focuses
assurances
attest
fact
findings
indeed
indicate
payment
rates
reasonable
judges
whether
assurances
satisfactory
fed
reg
therefore
secretary
require
submit
findings
underlying
data
ii
section
provides
cause
action
deprivation
rights
privileges
immunities
secured
constitution
laws
maine
thiboutot
held
provides
cause
action
violations
federal
statutes
well
constitution
recognized
two
exceptions
rule
plaintiff
alleging
violation
federal
statutes
well
permitted
sue
unless
statute
create
enforceable
rights
privileges
immunities
within
meaning
congress
foreclosed
enforcement
statute
enactment
wright
roanoke
redevelopment
housing
authority
petitioners
argue
first
boren
amendment
create
enforceable
rights
second
congress
foreclosed
enforcement
act
address
contentions
turn
section
speaks
terms
rights
privileges
immunities
violations
federal
law
golden
state
transit
los
angeles
emphasis
added
must
therefore
determine
whether
boren
amendment
creates
federal
right
enforceable
inquiry
turns
whether
provision
question
intend
ed
benefit
putative
plaintiff
ibid
citations
internal
quotations
omitted
provision
creates
enforceable
right
unless
reflects
merely
congressional
preference
certain
kind
conduct
rather
binding
obligation
governmental
unit
pennhurst
state
school
hospital
halderman
unless
interest
plaintiff
asserts
vague
amorphous
beyond
competence
judiciary
enforce
golden
state
supra
quoting
wright
supra
test
conclude
act
creates
right
enforceable
health
care
providers
adoption
reimbursement
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
efficiently
economically
operated
facility
provides
care
medicaid
patients
right
merely
procedural
one
rates
accompanied
findings
assurances
however
perfunctory
reasonableness
adequacy
rather
act
provides
substantive
right
reasonable
adequate
rates
well
pennhurst
supra
held
developmentally
disabled
assistance
bill
rights
act
ed
supp
iii
create
rights
enforceable
section
bill
rights
provision
declared
congress
made
certain
findings
respecting
rights
persons
developmental
disabilities
namely
persons
right
appropriate
treatment
least
restrictive
environment
federal
state
governments
obligation
ensure
institutions
failing
provide
appropriate
treatment
receive
federal
funds
concluded
context
entire
statute
legislative
history
revealed
congress
intended
neither
create
new
substantive
rights
require
recognize
rights
instead
congress
intended
indicate
preference
appropriate
treatment
examined
language
provision
determined
general
statement
findings
thin
reed
support
creation
rights
obligations
moreover
since
neither
statute
corresponding
regulations
made
compliance
provision
condition
receipt
federal
funding
reasoned
provisions
intended
hortatory
mandatory
refused
infer
congressional
intent
condition
federal
funding
compliance
congress
must
express
clearly
intent
impose
conditions
grant
federal
funds
knowingly
decide
whether
accept
funds
ibid
recently
wright
however
found
brooke
amendment
housing
act
ed
supp
iii
implementing
regulations
create
rights
enforceable
brooke
amendment
limits
amount
rent
public
housing
tenant
charged
regulations
adopted
pursuant
statute
require
inclusion
reasonable
allowance
utilities
rent
reasoned
statute
regulations
mandatory
limitation
focusing
individual
family
income
addition
rejected
argument
provision
reasonable
utility
allotment
vague
create
enforceable
right
regulations
set
guidelines
housing
authorities
follow
determining
utility
allowance
right
sufficiently
specific
definite
qualify
enforceable
righ
pennhurst
beyond
competence
judiciary
enforce
light
pennhurst
wright
conclude
boren
amendment
imposes
binding
obligation
participating
medicaid
program
adopt
reasonable
adequate
rates
obligation
enforceable
health
care
providers
boren
amendment
cast
mandatory
rather
predatory
terms
state
plan
must
provide
payment
hospital
according
rates
state
finds
reasonable
adequate
supp
emphasis
added
moreover
provision
federal
funds
expressly
conditioned
compliance
amendment
secretary
authorized
withhold
funds
noncompliance
provision
secretary
expressed
intention
withhold
funds
state
plan
comply
statute
noncompliance
practice
see
cfr
question
noncompliance
practice
may
arise
state
failure
actually
comply
federal
requirement
regardless
whether
plan
complies
requirement
boren
amendment
language
succinctly
sets
forth
congressional
command
wholly
uncharacteristic
mere
suggestion
nudge
west
virginia
university
hospitals
casey
quoting
pennhurst
cert
granted
petitioners
concede
boren
amendment
requires
state
provide
level
reimbursement
health
care
providers
cause
action
lie
state
failed
adopt
reimbursement
provision
whatsoever
tr
oral
arg
petitioners
also
concede
must
state
required
find
rates
reasonable
adequate
make
assurances
effect
secretary
reply
brief
petitioners
dissent
although
acknowledging
state
obligations
apparently
hold
right
enforceable
right
compel
compliance
bare
procedural
requirements
see
post
think
amendment
limited
argument
requirements
findings
assurances
procedural
requirements
require
state
adopt
rates
actually
reasonable
adequate
nothing
argument
state
findings
assurances
need
correct
reject
argument
render
statutory
requirements
findings
assurances
thus
entire
reimbursement
provision
essentially
meaningless
make
little
sense
congress
require
state
make
findings
without
requiring
findings
correct
addition
reason
require
state
submit
assurances
secretary
statute
require
state
findings
reviewable
manner
secretary
decline
adopt
interpretation
boren
amendment
render
dead
letter
see
rosado
wyman
see
also
sands
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
petitioners
acknowledge
state
may
make
submit
assurances
based
patently
false
finding
see
tr
oral
arg
insist
congress
left
secretary
federal
courts
ensure
state
rates
based
false
findings
extent
argument
bears
question
whether
boren
amendment
creates
enforceable
rights
opposed
whether
congress
intended
foreclose
private
enforcement
statute
pursuant
see
infra
supports
conclusion
provision
create
enforceable
rights
secretary
entitled
reject
state
plan
upon
concluding
state
assurances
compliance
unsatisfactory
see
supra
state
notice
adopt
rates
chooses
requirement
make
findings
mere
formality
cf
pennhurst
supra
rather
plausible
interpretation
amendment
requiring
state
find
rates
reasonable
adequate
statute
imposes
concomitant
obligation
adopt
reasonable
adequate
rates
doubt
congress
intended
require
adopt
rates
actually
reasonable
adequate
quickly
dispelled
review
legislative
history
boren
amendment
primary
objective
amendment
free
reimbursement
according
medicare
reasonable
cost
principles
required
prior
regulation
amendment
delete
provision
requiring
reimburse
hospitals
reasonable
cost
basis
substitute
provision
requiring
reimburse
hospitals
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
cost
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
order
meet
applicable
laws
quality
safety
standards
emphasis
added
passing
boren
amendment
congress
sought
decentralize
method
determining
rates
eliminate
state
fundamental
obligation
pay
reasonable
rates
see
flexibility
given
intended
encourage
arbitrary
reductions
payment
adversely
affect
quality
care
words
congress
gave
leeway
adopting
method
computing
rates
choose
retrospective
prospective
methodologies
example
congress
retained
underlying
requirement
reasonable
adequate
rates
reducing
secretary
role
establishing
rates
congress
intended
primary
responsibility
developing
rates
transferred
secretary
still
ensure
compliance
provision
see
committee
expects
secretary
keep
regulatory
requirements
minimum
necessary
assure
proper
accountability
overburden
facilities
unnecessary
burdensome
paperwork
requirements
emphasis
added
conf
secretary
retains
final
authority
review
rates
disapprove
meet
requirements
statute
petitioners
right
state
findings
required
correct
little
point
requiring
secretary
review
state
assurances
moreover
clear
prior
passage
boren
amendment
congress
intended
health
care
providers
able
sue
federal
injunctive
relief
ensure
reimbursed
according
reasonable
rates
provider
suits
federal
courts
commonplace
addition
response
several
freezing
medicaid
payments
health
care
providers
congress
amended
act
require
waive
eleventh
amendment
immunity
suit
violations
act
see
see
also
cong
rec
remarks
taft
congress
believed
waiver
necessary
existing
means
enforcement
noncompliance
procedures
instituted
secretary
suits
injunctive
relief
health
care
providers
insufficient
deal
problem
outright
noncompliance
included
compensation
past
underpayments
see
supra
amendment
required
secretary
withhold
federal
medicaid
funds
state
executed
waiver
immunity
march
pub
stat
provision
generated
great
deal
opposition
repealed
next
session
congress
pub
stat
see
supra
pp
cong
rec
remarks
rogers
congress
explained
intend
repeal
construed
way
contravening
constraining
rights
providers
medicaid
services
state
medicaid
agencies
department
seek
prospective
injunctive
relief
federal
state
judicial
forum
neither
repeal
waiver
section
interpreted
placing
constraints
rights
parties
involved
seek
prospective
injunctive
relief
experience
demonstrates
clearly
congress
understood
act
grant
health
care
providers
enforceable
rights
repeal
waiver
requirement
given
background
implausible
conclude
substituting
requirements
findings
assurances
congress
intended
deprive
health
care
providers
right
challenge
rates
instead
legislative
history
shows
requirements
findings
assurances
prescribe
respective
roles
state
secretary
petitioners
suggest
eliminate
state
obligation
adopt
reasonable
rates
nevertheless
petitioners
argue
boren
amendment
gives
state
flexibility
adopt
rates
finds
reasonable
adequate
obligation
imposed
amendment
vague
amorphous
judicially
enforceable
reject
argument
wright
statute
regulation
set
factors
state
must
consider
adopting
rates
addition
statute
requires
state
making
findings
judge
reasonableness
rates
objective
benchmark
efficiently
economically
operated
facilit
providing
care
compliance
federal
state
standards
time
ensuring
reasonable
access
eligible
participants
amendment
gives
substantial
discretion
choosing
among
reasonable
methods
calculating
rates
may
affect
standard
reviews
whether
rates
comply
amendment
render
amendment
unenforceable
may
range
reasonable
rates
certainly
rates
outside
range
state
ever
find
reasonable
adequate
act
although
knowledge
hospital
industry
might
required
evaluate
state
findings
respect
reasonableness
rates
inquiry
well
within
competence
judiciary
petitioners
also
argue
congress
foreclosed
enforcement
medicaid
act
find
little
merit
argument
lightly
conclude
congress
intended
preclude
reliance
remedy
deprivation
federally
secured
right
wright
quoting
smith
robinson
burden
state
show
express
provision
specific
evidence
statute
congress
intended
foreclose
private
enforcement
wright
supra
petitioners
concede
act
expressly
preclude
resort
absence
express
provision
found
private
enforcement
foreclosed
statute
creates
remedial
scheme
sufficiently
comprehensive
demonstrate
congressional
intent
preclude
remedy
suits
middlesex
county
sewerage
authority
national
sea
clammers
two
occasions
found
remedial
scheme
established
congress
sufficient
displace
remedy
provided
sea
clammers
supra
held
comprehensive
enforcement
scheme
found
federal
water
pollution
control
act
et
seq
granted
environmental
protection
agency
considerable
enforcement
power
use
noncompliance
orders
civil
suits
criminal
penalties
included
two
provisions
evidenced
congressional
intent
foreclose
reliance
see
similarly
smith
robinson
supra
held
elaborate
administrative
scheme
set
forth
education
handicapped
act
eha
et
manifested
congress
desire
foreclose
private
reliance
remedy
eha
contained
carefully
tailored
administrative
judicial
mechanism
included
local
administrative
review
culminated
right
judicial
review
citing
medicaid
act
contains
comparable
provision
private
judicial
administrative
enforcement
instead
act
authorizes
secretary
withhold
approval
plans
ed
supp
curtail
federal
funds
whose
plans
compliance
act
addition
act
requires
adopt
procedure
postpayment
claims
review
ensure
proper
efficient
payment
claims
management
program
regulation
required
adopt
appeals
procedure
individual
providers
may
obtain
administrative
review
reimbursement
rates
cfr
commonwealth
virginia
adopted
administrative
scheme
within
state
medicaid
agency
comply
regulations
app
administrative
scheme
considered
sufficiently
comprehensive
demonstrate
congressional
intent
withdraw
private
remedy
wright
concluded
generalized
powers
department
housing
urban
development
hud
audit
cut
federal
funds
insufficient
foreclose
reliance
vindicate
federal
rights
noted
hud
exercise
auditing
power
frequently
statute
require
hud
provide
mechanism
individuals
bring
problems
attention
hud
ibid
see
also
rosado
conclusion
even
appropriate
context
medicaid
act
since
explained
see
supra
primary
purpose
boren
amendment
reduce
role
secretary
determining
methods
calculating
payment
rates
follows
secretary
limited
oversight
insufficient
demonstrate
intent
foreclose
relief
altogether
courts
also
reject
petitioners
argument
existence
administrative
procedures
whereby
health
care
providers
obtain
review
individual
claims
payment
evidences
intent
foreclose
private
remedy
federal
courts
availability
state
administrative
procedures
ordinarily
foreclose
resort
see
patsy
board
regents
find
indication
congress
specifically
intended
administrative
procedure
replace
private
remedies
available
regulations
allow
limit
issues
may
raised
administrative
proceeding
cfr
including
virginia
allow
health
care
providers
challenge
overall
method
rates
determined
see
brief
american
health
care
association
et
al
amici
curiae
app
limited
state
administrative
procedures
considered
comprehensive
scheme
manifests
congressional
intent
foreclose
reliance
see
wright
availability
grievance
procedure
prevent
resort
thus
conclude
congress
foreclose
private
judicial
remedy
iii
boren
amendment
act
creates
right
enforceable
private
cause
action
pursuant
state
adopt
rates
finds
reasonable
adequate
rates
meet
costs
efficient
economical
health
care
provider
judgment
appeals
accordingly
affirmed
footnotes
every
person
color
statute
ordinance
regulation
custom
usage
state
territory
district
columbia
subjects
causes
subjected
citizen
person
within
jurisdiction
thereof
deprivation
rights
privileges
immunities
secured
constitution
laws
shall
liable
party
injured
action
law
suit
equity
proper
proceeding
redress
congress
enacted
boren
amendment
changed
standard
reimbursement
nursing
intermediate
care
facilities
pub
stat
following
year
congress
extended
boren
amendment
standard
reimbursement
hospitals
pub
stat
since
reimbursement
standard
applied
payments
made
intermediate
care
facilities
mentally
retarded
pub
stat
virginia
current
formula
reimbursement
rates
takes
median
cost
care
peer
group
computed
adjusts
costs
annually
account
inflation
figures
median
cost
care
calculated
determining
per
diem
median
cost
care
medicaid
patient
year
adjusting
inflation
use
consumer
price
index
cpi
determine
annual
reimbursement
rates
baseline
figures
adjusted
cpi
however
plan
amended
baseline
figures
adjusted
inflation
index
tied
medical
care
costs
app
respondent
argues
method
calculating
payment
rates
tied
costs
incurred
efficient
economical
hospital
specifically
respondent
challenges
method
computing
baseline
median
costs
use
cpi
rather
index
tied
medical
care
costs
adjust
rates
years
way
medical
care
cost
index
used
complaint
app
addition
respondent
contends
appeals
procedure
established
state
plan
inadequate
act
part
excludes
challenges
principles
reimbursement
app
district
initially
granted
petitioners
motion
dismiss
grounds
collateral
estoppel
record
exhs
appeals
reversed
virginia
hospital
assn
baliles
remand
petitioners
raised
numerous
challenges
justiciability
lawsuit
including
argument
based
eleventh
amendment
appeals
rejected
argument
ground
suit
seeks
prospective
injunctive
relief
state
officials
virginia
hospital
assn
baliles
previously
granted
certiorari
decide
issue
coos
bay
care
center
oregon
dept
human
resources
vacated
moot
see
supra
passage
boren
amendment
state
plans
provided
reimbursement
retrospective
basis
health
care
providers
reimbursed
according
reasonable
cost
services
actually
provided
since
passage
boren
amendment
however
adopted
plans
prospective
nature
whereby
providers
paid
advance
payments
calculated
according
state
formula
care
cost
virginia
plan
typical
prospective
plan
state
medicaid
agency
must
submit
following
information
assurances
amount
estimated
average
proposed
payment
rate
type
provider
amount
rate
increased
decreased
relation
preceding
year
estimate
extent
feasible
effect
new
rate
availability
services
type
care
furnished
extent
provider
participation
degree
costs
covered
hospitals
serve
disproportionate
number
patients
cfr
secretary
may
however
request
state
provide
additional
background
information
believes
necessary
complete
review
state
assurances
fed
reg
different
inquiry
involved
determining
whether
private
right
action
implied
particular
statute
see
cort
ash
implied
right
action
cases
employ
cort
test
determine
whether
congress
intended
create
private
remedy
asserted
violation
statutory
rights
see
transamerica
mortgage
advisors
lewis
touche
ross
redington
test
reflects
concern
grounded
separation
powers
congress
rather
courts
controls
availability
remedies
violations
statutes
see
thompson
thompson
scalia
concurring
judgment
cannon
university
chicago
powell
dissenting
provides
alternative
source
express
congressional
authorization
private
suits
middlesex
county
sewerage
authority
national
sea
clammers
concerns
present
case
consistent
view
recognize
exception
general
rule
provides
remedy
violation
federal
statutory
rights
congress
affirmatively
withdrawn
remedy
see
golden
state
transit
los
angeles
wright
roanoke
redevelopment
housing
authority
congress
granted
million
sum
woefully
inadequate
meet
enormous
financial
burden
providing
appropriate
treatment
least
restrictive
alternative
also
supported
conclusion
congress
limited
purpose
mind
enacted
contrast
medicaid
program
federal
government
provides
funds
cover
cost
patient
care
see
supp
federal
contribution
medicaid
program
totaled
approximately
billion
brief
amicus
curiae
amicus
curiae
argues
statute
requires
state
provide
assurances
secretary
rates
comply
statute
assurances
give
rise
enforceable
rights
brief
amicus
curiae
terms
therefore
boren
amendment
vests
rate
making
discretion
subject
condition
make
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
interpretation
ignores
language
statute
requires
state
find
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
assure
eligible
individuals
reasonable
access
services
see
also
cfr
fed
reg
statute
requires
make
finding
payment
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
requirement
state
make
finding
necessary
prerequisite
subsequent
requirement
state
provide
assurances
secretary
requirements
separate
obligations
apparent
secretary
regulations
state
must
make
findings
least
annually
need
make
assurances
unless
state
plan
amended
cfr
moreover
secretary
interpretation
role
statute
review
reasonableness
assurances
presented
state
rather
findings
based
entirely
understanding
state
responsibility
find
rates
adequate
making
assurances
secretary
see
fed
reg
explicit
statutory
responsibility
state
agency
make
findings
method
standards
result
reasonable
adequate
payment
rates
doubt
requiring
detailed
reporting
add
substantially
evaluation
assurances
petitioners
suggest
health
care
providers
might
able
bring
challenge
secretary
decision
approve
plan
judicial
review
provisions
administrative
procedure
act
apa
however
argues
remedy
apa
decision
accept
assurances
entrusted
agency
discretion
see
tr
oral
arg
need
address
dispute
however
irrelevant
question
whether
boren
amendment
creates
rights
enforceable
house
senate
reports
replete
indications
congress
intended
actually
adopt
rates
reasonable
adequate
conference
committee
report
explains
conferees
intend
state
hospital
reimbursement
policies
meet
costs
must
incurred
hospitals
providing
covered
care
services
medicaid
eligible
well
costs
required
provide
care
conformity
state
federal
requirements
conf
see
amendment
requires
reimburse
hospitals
rates
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
vol
pp
permitting
greater
flexibility
reimbursement
system
design
committee
intends
ensure
alternative
systems
provide
fair
adequate
compensation
services
medicaid
beneficiaries
committee
believes
hospitals
paid
cost
care
medicaid
patients
economical
manner
see
also
medicaid
medicare
amendments
hearings
subcommittee
health
environment
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
statement
boren
amendment
places
responsibility
squarely
establish
adequate
payments
cong
rec
amendment
achieves
present
law
objective
assuring
care
differs
present
law
respect
methods
may
employ
determining
reasonable
adequate
rates
colloquy
pryor
boren
see
alabama
nursing
home
assn
harris
california
hospital
assn
obledo
minnesota
assn
health
care
facilities
minnesota
dept
public
welfare
hospital
assn
new
york
state
toia
massachusetts
general
hospital
weiner
mary
hospital
east
louis
ogilvie
catholic
medical
center
brooklyn
queens
div
mary
hospital
rockefeller
app
dism
cf
national
union
hospital
health
care
employees
rwdsu
carey
although
providers
may
sue
union
representing
employees
provider
may
sue
see
roviders
continue
course
institute
suit
injunctive
relief
state
federal
courts
necessary
letter
department
health
education
welfare
state
compliance
federal
medicaid
requirements
hearings
subcommittee
health
senate
committee
finance
providers
recourse
without
amendment
includes
injunctive
relief
state
officials
remarks
assistant
secretary
kurzman
cong
rec
although
provider
sue
state
enjoin
action
sic
sue
recover
lost
funds
immunity
suit
afforded
amendment
remarks
rogers
indeed
federal
courts
continued
entertain
challenges
since
passage
boren
amendment
circuits
explicitly
addressed
issue
concluded
amendment
enforceable
health
care
providers
see
amisub
psl
colorado
dept
social
services
west
virginia
university
hospitals
casey
cert
granted
coos
bay
care
center
nebraska
health
care
dunning
cert
denied
courts
entertained
claims
without
separately
considering
whether
providers
cause
action
see
hoodkroft
convalescent
center
new
hampshire
division
human
services
cert
denied
colorado
health
care
assn
colorado
dept
social
services
hillhaven
wisconsin
dept
health
social
services
alabama
hospital
assn
beasley
mississippi
hospital
heckler
charleston
memorial
hospital
conrad
washington
health
facilities
assn
washington
dept
social
health
services
example
determining
methods
calculating
rates
reasonably
related
costs
efficient
hospital
state
must
consider
unique
situation
financial
otherwise
hospital
serves
disproportionate
number
low
income
patients
statutory
requirements
adequate
care
nursing
home
special
situation
hospitals
providing
inpatient
care
care
nursing
home
sufficient
unavailable
supp
boren
amendment
provides
anything
guidance
provision
issue
wright
vested
housing
authority
substantial
discretion
setting
utility
allowances
see
wright
roanoke
redevelopment
housing
authority
dissenting
citing
cfr
example
amisub
supra
invalidated
colorado
plan
state
made
findings
rates
reasonable
adequate
state
conceded
adoption
budget
adjustment
factor
divided
median
cost
care
half
absolutely
relevance
costs
efficient
hospital
see
also
casey
supra
invalidating
pennsylvania
plan
provided
justification
treating
hospitals
differently
hospitals
cert
granted
state
errs
finding
rates
reasonable
adequate
supplying
assurances
effect
secretary
provider
entitled
invalidate
current
state
plan
order
state
promulgate
new
plan
complies
act
note
courts
appeals
generally
agree
state
complied
procedural
requirements
imposed
amendment
regulations
federal
employs
deferential
standard
review
evaluate
whether
rates
comply
substantive
requirements
amendment
see
amisub
supra
casey
supra
dunning
supra
wisconsin
hospital
assn
reivitz
mississippi
hospital
supra
express
opinion
cases
contains
correct
articulation
appropriate
standard
review
indeed
conclusion
even
apt
given
congress
believed
private
judicial
remedy
existed
passage
boren
amendment
see
supra
administrative
oversight
scheme
elaborate
today
reasons
reject
argument
availability
action
secretary
apa
forecloses
remedy
putting
aside
question
whether
apa
remedy
available
see
supra
absolutely
indication
congress
intended
action
sole
method
health
care
providers
enforce
reimbursement
provision
moreover
given
congress
believed
private
cause
action
existed
prior
passage
boren
amendment
amendment
reduced
secretary
oversight
role
implausible
infer
congress
intended
replace
private
judicial
remedy
proceeding
judicial
review
apa
virginia
procedure
allows
providers
dispute
individual
payments
excludes
appeal
following
issues
organization
peer
groups
use
reimbursement
rates
established
plan
calculation
initial
group
ceilings
use
consumer
price
index
time
limits
set
forth
state
plan
ibid
finally
reject
petitioners
argument
availability
judicial
review
virginia
administrative
procedure
act
relevant
question
whether
relief
available
see
wright
see
generally
monroe
pape
chief
justice
rehnquist
justice
justice
scalia
justice
kennedy
join
dissenting
relevant
portion
boren
amendment
requires
reimburse
medicaid
services
providers
using
rates
determined
accordance
methods
standards
developed
state
state
finds
makes
assurances
satisfactory
secretary
reasonable
adequate
meet
costs
must
incurred
efficiently
economically
operated
facilities
supp
reasons
policy
underlying
boren
amendment
thwarted
judicial
review
unavailable
challenge
reasonableness
adequacy
rates
established
reimbursing
medicaid
services
providers
sort
reasoning
however
hitherto
thought
adequate
basis
deciding
congress
conferred
enforceable
right
party
maine
thiboutot
plaintiff
seeking
judicially
enforce
provision
federal
statute
required
demonstrate
statute
contained
implied
cause
action
satisfaction
familiar
standards
cort
ash
means
making
requisite
showing
general
practice
imply
cause
action
language
statute
explicitly
conferred
right
directly
class
persons
included
plaintiff
case
cannon
university
chicago
thus
crucial
demonstration
existence
implied
action
statute
contain
right
favor
particular
plaintiff
see
cort
first
statute
create
federal
right
favor
plaintiff
plaintiff
satisfy
three
additional
standards
establish
statute
contained
implied
judicial
remedy
vindicating
right
see
ibid
maine
thiboutot
essentially
removed
burden
making
latter
three
showings
holding
generally
exception
subsequently
developed
middlesex
county
sewerage
authority
national
sea
clammers
supplies
remedy
vindication
rights
arising
federal
statutes
holding
thiboutot
rendered
obsolete
case
law
pertaining
implied
rights
action
significant
area
overlap
remained
relief
either
implication
cort
ash
supra
language
used
congress
must
confer
identifiable
enforceable
rights
see
wright
roanoke
redevelopment
housing
authority
dissenting
whether
federal
statute
confers
substantive
rights
issue
unique
actions
implied
right
action
cases
also
asked
since
cort
ash
whether
statute
create
federal
right
favor
plaintiff
regard
wright
said
action
lie
congress
intend
statutory
provision
rise
level
enforceable
right
citing
pennhurst
state
school
hospital
halderman
cannon
supra
said
language
statute
generally
accurate
indicator
propriety
implication
cause
action
statement
suggestive
traditional
rule
first
step
exposition
statute
always
look
statute
text
stop
text
fully
reveals
meaning
see
american
tobacco
patterson
ur
starting
point
must
language
employed
congress
assume
legislative
purpose
expressed
ordinary
meaning
words
used
internal
citations
omitted
apparent
reason
deviate
sound
rule
question
whether
federal
statute
confers
substantive
rights
plaintiff
yet
virtually
ignores
relevant
text
medicaid
statute
case
medicaid
statute
provides
appropriations
federal
funds
submit
approved
secretary
health
human
services
state
plans
medical
assistance
supp
next
provision
statute
specifies
requirements
contents
state
medical
assistance
plans
provision
issue
simply
part
thirteenth
listed
requirement
plans
light
placement
within
structure
statute
see
pennhurst
supra
emphasizing
statutory
context
provision
review
one
reasonably
conclude
addressed
merely
establishes
one
many
conditions
receiving
federal
medicaid
funds
text
clearly
confer
substantive
rights
medicaid
services
providers
structural
evidence
buttressed
absence
statute
express
focus
providers
beneficiary
class
provision
see
wright
supra
finding
provision
statute
focusing
plaintiff
class
dispositive
evidence
congress
intent
brooke
amendment
create
rights
favor
plaintiff
class
even
one
assume
terms
confer
substantive
right
providers
nature
guarantee
reasonable
adequate
rates
statute
places
limitation
right
plain
language
section
establishes
procedure
establishing
rates
reimbursement
first
step
requires
make
certain
findings
second
step
requires
make
certain
assurances
secretary
secretary
courts
review
assurances
logic
case
law
respondent
arguably
may
bring
action
require
rates
set
according
process
indeed
establishment
rates
accordance
process
discernible
right
accruing
anyone
case
illustrates
medicaid
providers
bring
actions
avoid
process
rather
seek
implementation
approves
challenges
despite
fact
plaintiff
success
suit
results
displacement
rates
created
accordance
statutory
process
rates
established
pursuant
order
support
decision
looks
beyond
unambiguous
terms
statute
relies
policy
considerations
purportedly
derived
legislative
history
superseded
versions
statute
see
ante
concludes
ante
contrary
position
equates
proposition
obligated
adopt
reasonable
rates
indeed
theme
much
argument
without
judicial
enforceability
trusted
implement
command
creating
rate
systems
reasonable
adequate
one
point
make
little
sense
congress
require
state
make
findings
without
requiring
findings
correct
decline
adopt
interpretation
boren
amendment
render
dead
letter
ante
interpretation
refers
however
scarcely
render
boren
amendment
dead
letter
instead
reading
nullifies
letter
amendment
apart
displacement
statutory
ratesetting
process
noted
previously
suggestion
deliberately
disregard
requirements
statute
ignores
secretary
oversight
incorporated
statute
less
justice
recognizes
basic
purpose
boren
amendment
allow
latitude
establishing
medicaid
reimbursement
rates
light
fact
interpretation
takes
far
liberties
statutory
language
position
advanced
petitioners
reverse
judgment
appeals