providence
journal
argued
january
decided
may
respondents
newspaper
executive
editor
violated
temporary
restraining
order
issued
district
civil
suit
brought
enjoin
dissemination
surveillance
logs
memoranda
concerning
plaintiff
deceased
father
although
subsequently
vacated
order
nevertheless
appointed
private
attorney
prosecute
respondents
criminal
contempt
order
declining
ask
attorney
pursue
matter
representation
federal
defendants
underlying
civil
action
ultimately
found
respondents
criminal
contempt
appeals
reversed
ground
order
transparently
invalid
first
amendment
although
solicitor
general
denied
special
prosecutor
authority
represent
seeking
reinstatement
contempt
judgment
prosecutor
nevertheless
filed
petition
writ
certiorari
granted
briefed
argued
case
held
since
special
prosecutor
lacks
authority
represent
writ
certiorari
dismissed
want
jurisdiction
pp
title
regulations
issued
attorney
general
empower
solicitor
general
designee
conduct
argue
suits
interested
pp
case
one
interested
within
plain
meaning
action
initiated
continues
litigated
order
unique
sovereign
interest
vindicating
authority
judiciary
rationale
underlying
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
affirmed
inherent
authority
federal
courts
appoint
private
attorneys
prosecute
disobedience
orders
order
assure
judiciary
independent
means
vindicating
authority
necessitate
special
prosecutor
appearance
young
create
exception
therefore
similar
provisions
unlike
give
attorney
general
exclusive
control
litigation
involving
except
otherwise
provided
authorized
law
young
simply
acknowledges
excepted
provision
authorization
within
meaning
statutory
provisos
pp
judicially
initiated
contempt
citation
case
interested
policies
underlying
speak
one
voice
voice
reflect
common
interest
government
people
development
law
rather
variety
parochial
inconsistent
interests
shaped
immediate
demands
case
sub
judice
undermined
anomalous
consequences
result
deluge
unauthorized
certiorari
petitions
filed
attorneys
special
prosecutors
behest
district
judges
pp
blackmun
delivered
opinion
brennan
white
marshall
scalia
joined
scalia
filed
concurring
opinion
post
stevens
filed
dissenting
opinion
rehnquist
joined
post
kennedy
took
part
consideration
decision
case
robert
parrillo
argued
cause
briefs
william
curran
floyd
abrams
argued
cause
respondents
brief
edward
hindle
joseph
cavanagh
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
solicitor
general
fried
assistant
attorney
general
willard
deputy
solicitor
general
bryson
edwin
kneedler
douglas
letter
washington
legal
foundation
et
al
daniel
popeo
michael
mcdonald
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
american
civil
liberties
union
et
al
john
powell
steven
shapiro
lynette
labinger
martha
minow
kathleen
sullivan
marjorie
heins
american
newspaper
publishers
association
et
al
james
goodale
john
koeltl
justice
blackmun
delivered
opinion
seeks
reinstatement
judgment
contempt
newspaper
executive
editor
violating
invalid
temporary
restraining
order
publication
concluded
prosecutor
sought
certiorari
briefed
argued
case
without
authorization
solicitor
general
may
represent
dismiss
writ
certiorari
november
raymond
patriarca
son
raymond
patriarca
deceased
filed
suit
federal
bureau
investigation
fbi
director
department
justice
attorney
general
providence
journal
company
journal
wjar
television
ten
wjar
seeking
enjoin
dissemination
logs
memoranda
compiled
course
illegal
electronic
surveillance
see
providence
journal
fbi
cert
denied
plaintiff
father
complaint
amended
based
freedom
information
act
foia
supp
iv
title
iii
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
title
iii
et
seq
supp
iv
fourth
amendment
alleged
fbi
improperly
released
logs
memoranda
journal
wjar
pursuant
foia
request
following
death
senior
patriarca
summons
complaint
motion
temporary
restraining
order
served
journal
november
next
day
counsel
various
parties
gathered
conference
chief
judge
district
district
rhode
island
conference
apparently
transcript
chief
judge
entered
temporary
restraining
order
barring
publication
logs
memoranda
set
hearing
friday
november
counsel
journal
federal
defendants
objected
order
evening
november
respondent
charles
hauser
executive
editor
journal
first
advised
restraining
order
discussing
journal
executives
perils
noncompliance
hauser
decided
publish
story
based
logs
memoranda
following
day
november
journal
published
one
article
patriarcas
another
clash
district
journal
see
app
patriarca
forthwith
filed
motion
journal
hauser
adjudged
criminal
contempt
patriarca
however
declined
prosecute
contempt
motion
district
decided
ask
attorney
pursue
matter
representation
federal
defendants
underlying
civil
action
invoking
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
district
appointed
william
curran
rhode
island
bar
prosecuting
attorney
full
authority
prosecute
pending
contempt
motion
app
curran
application
district
ordered
respondents
show
cause
adjudged
criminal
contempt
following
hearing
february
district
found
respondents
criminal
contempt
order
entered
november
concluded
jurisdiction
consider
whether
patriarca
statutory
fourth
amendment
claims
merit
whether
privacy
interest
outweighed
journal
first
amendment
interest
publication
thus
temporary
restraining
order
entered
preserve
status
quo
pending
consideration
significant
legal
issues
valid
even
though
subsequently
vacated
district
fined
journal
suspended
jail
sentence
hauser
placing
probation
months
ordering
perform
hours
public
service
respondents
appealed
appeals
first
circuit
reversed
judgment
contempt
providence
journal
found
temporary
restraining
order
transparently
invalid
first
amendment
thus
constitutionality
collaterally
challenged
contempt
proceedings
according
none
grounds
asserted
support
order
including
foia
title
iii
fourth
amendment
provided
even
colorable
basis
prior
restraint
ordered
district
appeals
sitting
en
banc
summarily
modified
panel
opinion
holding
even
subject
transparently
invalid
order
must
make
effort
seek
emergency
appellate
relief
ruled
however
publisher
may
proceed
publish
challenge
constitutionality
order
contempt
proceeding
timely
access
appellate
available
timely
decision
forthcoming
convinced
respondents
obtained
emergency
relief
publisher
make
final
decision
whether
run
story
following
day
found
unfair
subject
respondents
substantial
sanctions
failing
follow
newly
announced
procedures
providence
journal
importance
issues
granted
certiorari
ii
decide
whether
respondents
properly
held
contempt
violating
district
subsequently
invalidated
restraining
order
must
consider
respondents
motion
dismiss
writ
certiorari
appears
manner
unusual
case
reached
us
departed
significantly
established
practice
appeals
reversed
judgment
contempt
sitting
en
banc
modified
panel
opinion
special
prosecutor
sought
authorization
solicitor
general
file
petition
writ
certiorari
letter
dated
july
solicitor
general
denied
authorization
see
app
brief
amicus
curiae
response
respondents
motion
dismiss
sg
letter
respondents
argue
without
permission
special
prosecutor
proceed
denying
authorization
special
prosecutor
file
appear
behalf
solicitor
general
questioned
whether
recent
decision
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
rendered
authorization
unnecessary
case
concerning
criminal
contempt
charge
prosecuted
private
counsel
appointed
pursuant
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
see
sg
letter
see
also
brief
amicus
curiae
find
implication
decision
young
conclude
special
prosecutor
lacks
authority
represent
party
entitled
petition
certiorari
must
dismiss
writ
certiorari
want
jurisdiction
title
provides
relevant
part
except
attorney
general
particular
case
directs
otherwise
attorney
general
solicitor
general
shall
conduct
argue
suits
appeals
interested
matters
assigned
shall
conducted
handled
supervised
solicitor
general
consultation
agency
official
concerned
conducting
assigning
supervising
cases
including
appeals
petitions
opposition
certiorari
briefs
arguments
settlement
thereof
cfr
present
case
clearly
one
interested
action
initiated
vindication
judicial
power
art
iii
emphasis
added
interest
unique
sovereign
continues
litigated
special
prosecutor
seeks
reinstate
judgment
criminal
contempt
federal
including
possible
prison
sentence
individual
defendant
substantial
fine
newspaper
defendant
fact
allegedly
criminal
conduct
concerns
violation
order
instead
common
law
statutory
prohibition
render
prosecution
less
exercise
sovereign
power
indeed
last
term
case
much
like
present
one
involving
prosecution
criminal
contempt
flatly
stated
private
attorneys
appointed
prosecute
criminal
contempt
action
represent
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
emphasis
added
see
also
gompers
bucks
stove
range
roceedings
law
criminal
contempt
public
defendant
special
prosecutor
solicitor
general
argue
case
one
interested
phrase
used
refers
solely
cases
interests
executive
branch
issue
litigation
argument
goes
special
prosecutor
acted
support
power
judicial
branch
rather
furtherance
executive
constitutional
responsibility
art
ii
take
care
laws
faithfully
executed
suggested
interpretation
however
presumes
one
may
appear
something
sovereign
composed
three
branches
nixon
find
proposition
somewhat
startling
particularly
supported
office
whose
authority
substantially
diminished
adoption
reject
construction
inconsistent
plain
meaning
seems
elementary
even
exercising
distinct
jealously
separated
powers
three
branches
parts
one
government
hampton
congress
familiar
enough
language
separation
powers
shall
assume
intended
without
saying
exclude
judicial
branch
referred
interest
moreover
may
well
matters
uniquely
executive
branch
concerns
think
fairly
described
broad
statutory
language
young
reaffirmed
inherent
authority
federal
initiate
criminal
contempt
proceeding
disobedience
order
ability
appoint
private
attorney
prosecute
contempt
action
power
considered
part
judicial
function
grounded
first
foremost
upon
necessity
ability
punish
disobedience
judicial
orders
regarded
essential
ensuring
judiciary
means
vindicate
authority
without
complete
dependence
branches
special
prosecutor
claims
appearance
necessary
vindication
district
authority
district
mercy
another
branch
deciding
whether
proceedings
initiated
lacked
power
appoint
private
attorney
prosecute
contempt
charge
judgment
vindicating
district
authority
vulnerable
attorney
general
withholding
authorization
defend
argument
however
overlooks
circumstances
special
prosecutor
actually
came
position
seek
review
district
judgment
contempt
reversed
appeal
special
prosecutor
may
decide
seek
writ
certiorari
basis
professional
judgment
appeals
decision
merits
review
see
generally
rule
sometimes
apparently
occurred
special
prosecutor
solicitor
general
disagree
respect
whether
case
presents
issues
worthy
review
kind
disagreement
actually
arises
regular
basis
solicitor
general
attorneys
representing
various
agencies
disagreement
interfere
judiciary
power
protect
case
consent
solicitor
general
ever
became
relevant
members
judiciary
decided
district
judge
erred
adjudging
defendants
contempt
majority
panel
appeals
perhaps
majority
en
banc
decided
favor
alleged
contemner
necessity
required
appointment
independent
prosecutor
faded
indeed
longer
present
hand
district
adjudged
party
contempt
appellate
affirmed
special
prosecutor
little
need
services
fulfill
duties
contemner
petitions
writ
certiorari
solicitor
general
need
consulted
authorization
participation
obtained
oppose
petition
defend
judgment
circumstances
solicitor
general
declines
authorize
defense
judgment
prevented
special
prosecutor
proceeding
independent
ability
judiciary
vindicate
authority
might
appear
threatened
courts
agreed
contemner
disobeyed
order
executive
judgment
contrary
threaten
undermine
judicial
decisions
threat
however
inconsequential
part
judicial
branch
must
decide
whether
exercise
discretion
review
judgment
well
within
authority
appoint
amicus
curiae
file
briefs
present
oral
argument
support
judgment
see
bob
jones
university
order
appointing
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
fausto
solicitor
general
argues
apply
contempt
proceeding
initiated
unilaterally
federal
young
sustained
power
appoint
private
attorney
prosecute
criminal
contempt
charge
despite
fact
language
certainly
somewhat
similar
requires
litigation
conducted
government
attorney
except
otherwise
authorized
law
conduct
litigation
agency
officer
thereof
party
interested
reserved
officers
department
justice
direction
attorney
general
young
neither
expressed
implied
special
consideration
judicially
initiated
contempt
proceeding
statutes
implicated
discussed
young
provide
attorney
general
exclusive
control
specified
litigation
except
otherwise
provided
authorized
law
fair
reading
young
indicates
federal
inherent
authority
punish
disobedience
vindicate
authority
excepted
provision
authorization
within
meaning
power
punish
contempts
inherent
courts
first
recognized
young
rather
many
times
decided
may
regarded
settled
law
young
quoting
michaelson
ex
rel
chicago
thus
contrary
solicitor
general
intimation
young
read
exception
instead
young
consistent
plain
language
provisos
sections
section
way
vivid
contrast
contains
proviso
plain
statutory
language
reason
enough
persuade
us
accept
respondents
objections
dismiss
writ
certiorari
observe
salutory
policies
support
undermined
anomalous
consequences
result
approach
urged
upon
special
prosecutor
solicitor
general
among
reasons
reserving
litigation
attorney
general
solicitor
general
concern
usually
speak
one
voice
voice
reflects
parochial
interests
particular
agency
common
interests
government
therefore
people
without
centralization
decision
whether
seek
certiorari
might
well
deluged
petitions
every
federal
prosecutor
agency
instrumentality
urging
position
variety
inconsistent
positions
shaped
immediate
demands
case
sub
judice
rather
longer
term
interests
development
law
procedures
set
young
seems
evident
majority
contempt
cases
prosecuted
attorney
see
special
prosecutor
interpretation
whereby
contempt
citation
initiated
district
case
interested
attorney
free
file
petition
writ
certiorari
without
authorization
solicitor
general
need
speculate
attorney
resolve
conflict
duty
preservation
respect
judicial
authority
attorneys
manual
duty
superiors
department
justice
reject
hand
interpretation
creates
potential
conflict
similarly
attorney
concluded
appeals
decision
reversing
judgment
contempt
merit
review
declined
file
petition
seem
follow
solicitor
general
interpretation
district
judge
appoint
another
special
prosecutor
solely
purposes
seeking
certiorari
writ
granted
litigating
case
see
brief
amicus
curiae
response
respondents
motion
dismiss
surely
neither
force
historical
practice
necessity
protecting
dignity
district
whose
judgment
contempt
reversed
appeal
warrants
attributing
power
district
judge
iii
conclude
criminal
contempt
prosecution
brought
vindicate
authority
judiciary
punish
disobedience
order
suit
interested
within
meaning
regardless
appointed
district
prosecute
action
case
special
prosecutor
filed
petition
writ
certiorari
without
authorization
solicitor
general
thus
without
authorization
appear
behalf
absent
proper
representative
government
petitioner
criminal
prosecution
jurisdiction
lacking
writ
certiorari
heretofore
granted
dismissed
ordered
footnotes
november
previously
scheduled
district
held
hearing
argument
counsel
set
preliminary
injunction
hearing
tuesday
november
extending
restraining
order
date
app
following
preliminary
injunction
hearing
vacated
temporary
restraining
order
denied
preliminary
injunctive
relief
journal
wjar
granted
preliminary
injunction
dissemination
logs
memoranda
federal
defendants
decision
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
event
prohibited
patriarca
taking
action
young
instructed
courts
request
attorney
prosecute
criminal
contempt
charge
attorney
declined
appoint
special
prosecutor
private
attorney
attorney
interested
party
amicus
curiae
argues
district
reasons
legally
insufficient
support
decision
ask
government
attorney
undertake
contempt
prosecution
prosecution
journal
order
vindicate
district
authority
pose
conflict
government
attorneys
brief
amicus
curiae
disposition
case
need
address
circumstances
procedures
prescribed
young
requesting
appropriate
prosecuting
authority
pursue
contempt
action
may
bypassed
hold
today
federal
statute
deprives
special
prosecutor
authority
pursue
litigation
behalf
solicitor
general
declines
petition
certiorari
authorize
filing
petition
dismiss
writ
even
though
eventually
expressed
interest
litigation
solicitor
general
filed
brief
amicus
curiae
support
position
taken
special
prosecutor
see
karcher
may
diamond
charles
section
reads
shall
power
punish
fine
imprisonment
discretion
contempt
authority
none
disobedience
resistance
lawful
writ
process
order
rule
decree
command
fact
relies
solicitor
general
exercise
independent
judgment
decline
authorize
petitions
review
majority
cases
government
lost
courts
appeals
see
andres
frankfurter
concurring
mccree
solicitor
general
client
see
also
griswold
office
solicitor
general
representing
interests
mo
rev
solicitor
general
special
obligation
aid
well
serve
client
providing
solicitor
general
subject
direction
attorney
general
attend
interests
litigation
statutes
always
understood
mean
longrange
interests
simply
terms
fisc
success
particular
litigation
government
people
omitted
young
emphasized
principle
restraint
contempt
counsels
caution
exercise
power
appoint
private
prosecutor
repeat
rationale
appointment
authority
necessity
judiciary
completely
dependent
executive
branch
redress
direct
affronts
authority
powerless
protect
branch
declined
prosecution
exercise
inherent
power
last
resort
plain
language
resolves
conflict
express
reservations
authority
litigation
therein
provided
provision
law
vests
litigation
authority
elsewhere
statute
begins
except
otherwise
provided
law
creates
general
rule
applies
unless
contradicted
provision
young
reason
address
application
provisions
apply
contempt
proceeding
initiated
reaffirmed
inherent
authority
federal
appoint
private
attorney
prosecute
contempt
charge
conflict
statutory
requirements
fact
admits
exception
course
mean
congress
chooses
exempt
litigation
otherwise
blanket
coverage
statute
mean
however
alleged
exception
must
scrutinized
subjected
ordinary
tools
statutory
construction
determine
whether
congress
intended
supersede
indeed
congress
enacted
provisions
suggest
exceptions
blanket
coverage
see
federal
courts
improvement
act
stat
preserving
existing
authority
tennessee
valley
authority
represent
attorneys
choosing
adding
see
stat
claims
appeals
federal
circuit
courts
named
ethics
government
act
amended
authorizing
independent
counsel
initiate
conduct
prosecutions
competent
jurisdiction
name
see
last
cited
act
sealed
case
app
prob
juris
noted
sub
nom
morrison
olson
see
also
stern
inconsistency
government
litigation
harv
rev
discussing
independent
litigating
authority
interstate
commerce
commission
without
pausing
construe
effect
enactments
note
similar
indication
congress
intended
exception
special
prosecutor
appointed
prosecute
contempt
charge
despite
fact
federal
rule
criminal
procedure
reflects
longstanding
practice
assume
congress
aware
private
prosecutions
contempt
actions
see
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
similarly
nothing
precludes
members
congress
judiciary
adding
views
litigation
intervenors
amici
curiae
practice
long
recognized
see
bowsher
synar
instances
directly
authorized
statute
see
may
well
solicitor
general
contends
even
pursuing
judicially
initiated
contempt
prosecution
attorney
remains
practical
purposes
officer
representative
executive
branch
direction
attorney
general
see
brief
amicus
curiae
response
respondents
motion
dismiss
standpoint
solicitor
special
prosecutor
interpretation
seem
permit
attorney
appear
behalf
interests
stake
contempt
prosecution
case
captioned
significance
holding
previously
observed
courts
must
look
behind
names
symbolize
parties
determine
whether
justiciable
case
controversy
presented
icc
thus
even
case
recaptioned
special
prosecutor
upon
filing
petition
reflect
adversary
nature
proceeding
see
petitioner
objections
respondents
motion
dismiss
required
determine
whether
case
interested
criminal
contempt
prosecution
federal
however
styled
case
justice
scalia
concurring
join
opinion
ably
demonstrates
according
plain
meaning
fully
consistent
opinion
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
continue
believe
however
district
courts
possess
power
inherent
otherwise
prosecute
contemners
disobedience
judgments
derivative
power
appoint
attorney
conduct
contempt
prosecutions
see
scalia
concurring
judgment
justice
stevens
chief
justice
joins
dissenting
statute
enacted
first
congress
created
office
attorney
general
described
responsibilities
office
statute
provided
shall
also
appointed
meet
person
learned
law
act
shall
sworn
affirmed
faithful
execution
office
whose
duty
shall
prosecute
conduct
suits
shall
concerned
give
advice
opinion
upon
questions
law
required
president
requested
heads
departments
touching
matters
may
concern
departments
shall
receive
compensation
services
shall
law
provided
judiciary
act
ch
stat
emphasis
supplied
litigation
interested
course
conducted
executive
branch
government
orderly
administration
requires
litigation
conducted
supervision
direction
single
office
congress
therefore
wisely
granted
attorney
general
broad
enough
authority
accomplish
mission
unlikely
however
statute
enacted
congress
foresaw
possibility
matters
judicial
contempts
see
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
legislative
contempts
see
anderson
dunn
wheat
mcgrain
daugherty
need
defend
legislative
veto
see
ins
chadha
present
justiciable
controversies
congress
judiciary
might
interests
diverge
executive
branch
government
nevertheless
cases
shall
concerned
equally
unlikely
congress
amendment
recent
consideration
provision
perceived
much
less
endorsed
view
read
place
control
litigation
exclusively
hands
executive
branch
although
texts
statutes
congress
enacted
read
foreclose
either
congress
judiciary
appointing
counsel
participate
litigation
long
held
construing
statute
bound
follow
literal
language
statute
however
clear
words
may
appear
superficial
examination
leads
absurd
even
unreasonable
results
american
trucking
citation
omitted
see
also
offshore
logistics
tallentire
california
federal
savings
loan
assn
guerra
wells
fargo
bank
history
common
sense
make
clear
congress
never
intended
grant
executive
branch
exclusive
authority
control
litigation
coequal
branch
government
maintains
substantial
justiciable
interest
early
house
representatives
adopted
resolution
directing
speaker
house
employ
counsel
may
think
proper
defend
suit
brought
john
anderson
said
thomas
dunn
expenses
defrayed
contingent
fund
house
annals
cong
speaker
retained
william
wirt
defend
suit
established
congressional
power
legislative
contempt
see
anderson
dunn
supra
although
wirt
serving
attorney
general
congress
nonetheless
deemed
necessary
retain
wirt
private
capacity
pay
defend
suit
see
american
state
papers
misc
vol
statement
sums
paid
william
wirt
attorney
general
beyond
salary
services
required
law
congress
read
shall
concerned
extend
beyond
interests
executive
branch
attorney
general
already
obliged
prosecute
conduct
suit
separate
retainer
agreement
necessary
indeed
house
committee
judiciary
later
explained
payment
beyond
attorney
general
salary
proper
provided
services
rendered
belong
office
manner
bound
perform
therefore
perform
entitled
paid
professional
man
numerous
occasions
since
anderson
dunn
congress
seen
fit
retain
private
counsel
represent
interests
see
kilbourn
thompson
pocket
veto
case
powell
mccormack
gravel
ins
chadha
bowsher
synar
similarly
interests
federal
judiciary
certainly
interests
well
represented
litigation
private
counsel
several
occasions
see
chandler
judicial
council
tenth
circuit
calvert
fire
ins
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
yet
time
anderson
dunn
today
heard
argument
cases
without
bothering
determine
whether
solicitor
general
approved
participation
litigation
addition
frequently
appointed
counsel
sometimes
designated
amicus
curiae
nevertheless
fully
authorized
argue
cases
interested
see
myers
bob
jones
university
appointing
counsel
without
asking
approval
solicitor
general
taking
action
moreover
despite
fact
contains
language
similar
found
confirmed
power
judiciary
appoint
counsel
conduct
litigation
interested
see
young
ex
rel
vuitton
et
fils
supra
long
previously
unquestioned
practice
comports
well
common
sense
section
directs
xcept
attorney
general
particular
case
directs
otherwise
attorney
general
solicitor
general
shall
conduct
argue
suits
appeals
interested
language
mandatory
case
interested
solicitor
general
shall
argue
appeal
course
quite
properly
solicitor
general
seek
certiorari
every
case
adversely
affecting
interest
instead
solicitor
general
acts
strategically
choosing
important
cases
cases
likely
prevail
thus
separating
wheat
chaff
solicitor
general
makes
series
judgments
interest
executive
officer
solicitor
general
may
reasonably
weigh
consider
interests
executive
agencies
faced
difference
view
executive
branch
coordinate
branch
government
however
solicitor
general
faces
conflict
interest
undeniably
intolerable
encountered
private
sector
essence
asked
resolve
conflicting
interests
clients
common
sense
dictates
congress
intend
create
conflict
office
solicitor
general
moreover
even
compellingly
unreasonable
conclude
congress
intended
abdicate
solicitor
general
department
justice
function
determining
interest
congress
judiciary
certainly
congress
intend
executive
offices
charged
weighing
competing
executive
congressional
judicial
interests
authority
absent
legislation
deny
congress
judiciary
access
prior
practice
consistent
commonsense
reading
also
significant
officer
interested
correct
interpretation
provision
solicitor
general
places
interpretation
text
brief
case
submits
title
like
statutes
vest
attorney
general
exclusive
control
litigation
applies
cases
interested
virtue
constitutional
statutory
responsibilities
executive
branch
branch
attorney
general
serves
cf
icc
southern
cir
section
centralizes
responsibility
conduct
public
litigation
enables
president
attorney
general
supervise
various
policies
executive
branch
brief
amicus
curiae
response
respondents
motion
dismiss
request
house
representatives
president
monroe
transmitted
congress
information
relating
amount
public
money
paid
attorney
general
salary
fixed
law
information
accompanied
presidential
message
sheds
light
early
understanding
act
providing
part
act
september
instituting
office
attorney
general
made
duty
prosecute
conduct
suits
concerned
seen
therefore
statement
communicated
money
whatever
paid
attorney
general
services
character
duty
belonging
office
beyond
salary
fixed
law
american
state
papers
misc
vol
office
attorney
general
established
act
september
duty
defined
prosecute
conduct
suits
shall
concerned
appointments
heretofore
made
compensation
heretofore
allowed
reference
existing
constitution
office
duties
belonging
already
stated
follows
clearly
department
government
right
ever
right
call
upon
attorney
general
perform
duties
difficult
show
officer
greater
obligation
private
citizen
render
gratuitous
services
government
particularly
nature
estimated
paid
extensive
interesting
concerns
nation
nevertheless
happen
frequently
happened
government
occasion
legal
aid
officers
bound
cases
able
afford
occasional
aid
afforded
attorney
general
without
interference
proper
duties
objection
employed
upon
ordinary
professional
footing
receiving
compensation
service
required
design
office
already
appeared
render
stated
duties
stated
compensation
salary
never
understood
intended
office
deprive
officer
right
employ
professional
talents
learning
benefit
done
without
prejudice
faithful
performance
stated
duties
reviewing
past
committee
finds
nothing
disapprove
additional
professional
aid
employed
seems
necessary
proper
compensated
beyond
fair
reasonable
amount
compensation
allowed
attorney
general
services
rendered
belong
office
manner
bound
perform
therefore
perform
entitled
paid
professional
man
title
provides
except
otherwise
authorized
law
conduct
litigation
agency
officer
thereof
party
interested
reserved
officers
department
justice
direction
attorney
general
title
provides
department
justice
executive
department
section
turn
provides
president
shall
appoint
department
justice
advice
consent
senate
solicitor
general
learned
law
assist
attorney
general
performance
duties
although
conflict
avoided
solicitor
general
authorize
certiorari
delegate
control
litigation
every
case
coordinate
branch
asserts
interest
doubt
congress
intended
mandatory
language
apply
congress
judiciary
merely
solicitor
general
simply
reallocate
control
litigation
back
whenever
requested
legislation
enacted
creating
office
senate
legal
counsel
see
stat
et
seq
ed
supp
iii
title
provides
directed
counsel
shall
intervene
appear
amicus
curiae
name
senate
legal
action
proceeding
pending
powers
responsibilities
congress
constitution
placed
issue
section
provides
ermission
intervene
party
appear
amicus
curiae
section
shall
right
relieves
attorney
general
certain
representational
responsibilities
notified
senate
counsel
handling
matter
also
requires
attorney
general
notify
counsel
respect
proceeding
party
determination
attorney
general
solicitor
general
appeal
decision
affecting
constitutionality
act
within
time
enable
senate
direct
counsel
intervene
party
proceeding
similar
statute
provides
representation
house
representatives
declined
coverage
see
conf
moreover
appear
enacting
congress
intended
create
exception
appear
congress
saw
need
rather
senate
determined
interests
congress
institution
make
present
reliance
ad
hoc
services
justice
department
private
counsel
wholly
unsatisfactory
representation
department
justice
deemed
unsatisfactory
department
justice
part
executive
branch
first
foremost
responsibility
represent
interests
president
executive
branch
thus
creating
unacceptable
conflict
interest
continued
reliance
private
representation
cases
involving
conflict
department
justice
also
rejected
high
cost
retaining
private
counsel
basis
need
maintain
consistency
among
legal
positions
taken
senate
often
insufficient
time
need
representation
arises
locate
retain
private
counsel
see
essence
senate
saw
need
hire
counsel
need
create
exception
permitting
form
legal
representation
congress
engaged
years