argersinger
hamlin
argued
december
decided
june
right
indigent
defendant
criminal
trial
assistance
counsel
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
made
applicable
fourteenth
gideon
wainwright
governed
classification
offense
whether
jury
trial
required
accused
may
deprived
liberty
result
criminal
prosecution
whether
felony
misdemeanor
denied
assistance
counsel
case
florida
erred
holding
petitioner
indigent
tried
offense
punishable
imprisonment
six
months
fine
given
jail
sentence
right
counsel
ground
right
extends
trials
offenses
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
pp
reversed
douglas
delivered
opinion
brennan
stewart
white
marshall
blackmun
joined
brennan
filed
concurring
opinion
douglas
stewart
joined
post
burger
filed
opinion
concurring
result
post
powell
filed
opinion
concurring
result
rehnquist
joined
post
bruce
rogow
argued
cause
petitioner
reargument
michael
shea
argued
cause
pro
hac
vice
original
argument
brief
hubbart
george
georgieff
assistant
attorney
general
florida
reargued
cause
respondent
brief
robert
shevin
attorney
general
raymond
marky
assistant
attorney
general
joined
attorneys
general
respective
follows
gary
nelson
arizona
arthur
bolton
georgia
anthony
park
idaho
jack
gremillion
louisiana
james
erwin
maine
robert
woodahl
montana
robert
list
nevada
robert
morgan
north
carolina
helgi
johanneson
north
dakota
daniel
mcleod
south
carolina
solicitor
general
griswold
argued
cause
amicus
curiae
reargument
urging
reversal
brief
assistant
attorney
general
petersen
deputy
solicitor
general
greenawalt
harry
sachse
beatrice
rosenberg
sidney
glazer
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
william
hellerstein
legal
aid
society
new
york
marshall
hartman
national
legal
aid
defender
association
lauren
beasley
chief
assistant
attorney
general
utah
filed
brief
attorney
general
utah
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
briefs
amici
curiae
filed
john
havelock
attorney
general
state
alaska
andrew
miller
attorney
general
vann
lefcoe
assistant
attorney
general
commonwealth
virginia
justice
douglas
delivered
opinion
petitioner
indigent
charged
florida
carrying
concealed
weapon
offense
punishable
imprisonment
six
months
fine
trial
judge
petitioner
unrepresented
counsel
sentenced
serve
days
jail
brought
habeas
corpus
action
florida
alleging
deprived
right
counsel
unable
indigent
layman
properly
raise
present
trial
good
sufficient
defenses
charge
stands
convicted
florida
decision
ruling
right
counsel
followed
line
marked
duncan
louisiana
respects
right
trial
jury
held
right
counsel
extends
trials
offenses
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
case
petition
certiorari
granted
reverse
sixth
amendment
enumerated
situations
made
applicable
reason
fourteenth
amendment
see
duncan
louisiana
supra
washington
texas
klopfer
north
carolina
pointer
texas
gideon
wainwright
oliver
provides
specified
standards
criminal
prosecutions
one
requirement
public
trial
oliver
supra
held
right
public
trial
applicable
state
proceeding
even
though
sentence
involved
another
guarantee
right
informed
nature
cause
accusation
still
another
right
confrontation
pointer
texas
supra
another
compulsory
process
obtaining
witnesses
one
favor
washington
texas
supra
never
limited
rights
felonies
lesser
serious
offenses
washington
texas
supra
said
held
due
process
requires
accused
assistance
counsel
defense
confronted
witnesses
right
speedy
public
trial
respecting
right
speedy
public
trial
right
informed
nature
cause
accusation
right
confront
witnesses
right
compulsory
process
obtaining
witnesses
recently
stated
simply
arguable
ever
held
trial
petty
offense
may
held
secret
without
notice
accused
charges
cases
defendant
right
confront
accusers
compel
attendance
witnesses
behalf
junker
right
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
rev
district
columbia
clawans
illustrates
point
offense
engaging
without
license
business
dealing
property
offense
punishable
fine
imprisonment
days
held
offense
petty
one
tried
without
jury
conviction
reversed
new
trial
ordered
trial
prejudicially
restricted
right
right
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
right
trial
jury
also
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
reason
fourteenth
limited
duncan
louisiana
supra
trials
potential
punishment
imprisonment
six
months
various
opinions
baldwin
new
york
make
plain
right
trial
jury
different
genealogy
brigaded
system
trial
judge
alone
stated
duncan
providing
accused
right
tried
jury
peers
gave
inestimable
safeguard
corrupt
overzealous
prosecutor
complaint
biased
eccentric
judge
defendant
preferred
judgment
jury
tutored
perhaps
less
sympathetic
reaction
single
judge
beyond
jury
trial
provisions
federal
state
constitutions
reflect
fundamental
decision
exercise
official
power
reluctance
entrust
plenary
powers
life
liberty
citizen
one
judge
group
judges
fear
unchecked
power
typical
state
federal
governments
respects
found
expression
criminal
law
insistence
upon
community
participation
determination
guilt
innocence
deep
commitment
nation
right
jury
trial
serious
criminal
cases
defense
arbitrary
law
enforcement
qualifies
protection
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
must
therefore
respected
originally
england
person
charged
treason
felony
denied
aid
counsel
except
respect
legal
questions
accused
might
suggest
time
parties
civil
cases
persons
accused
misdemeanors
entitled
full
assistance
counsel
appears
least
twelve
thirteen
colonies
rule
english
common
law
respect
consideration
definitely
rejected
right
counsel
fully
recognized
criminal
prosecutions
save
one
two
instances
right
limited
capital
offenses
serious
crimes
powell
alabama
reject
therefore
premise
since
prosecutions
crimes
punishable
imprisonment
less
six
months
may
tried
without
jury
may
also
tried
without
lawyer
assistance
counsel
often
requisite
existence
fair
trial
powell
alabama
supra
capital
case
said
right
heard
many
cases
little
avail
comprehend
right
heard
counsel
even
intelligent
educated
layman
small
sometimes
skill
science
law
charged
crime
incapable
generally
determining
whether
indictment
good
bad
unfamiliar
rules
evidence
left
without
aid
counsel
may
put
trial
without
proper
charge
convicted
upon
incompetent
evidence
evidence
irrelevant
issue
otherwise
inadmissible
lacks
skill
knowledge
adequately
prepare
defense
even
though
perfect
one
requires
guiding
hand
counsel
every
step
proceedings
without
though
guilty
faces
danger
conviction
know
establish
innocence
true
men
intelligence
much
true
ignorant
illiterate
feeble
intellect
adversary
system
criminal
justice
person
haled
poor
hire
lawyer
assured
fair
trial
unless
counsel
provided
seems
us
obvious
truth
governments
state
federal
quite
properly
spend
vast
sums
money
establish
machinery
try
defendants
accused
crime
lawyers
prosecute
everywhere
deemed
essential
protect
public
interest
orderly
society
similarly
defendants
charged
crime
indeed
fail
hire
best
lawyers
get
prepare
present
defenses
government
hires
lawyers
prosecute
defendants
money
hire
lawyers
defend
strongest
indications
widespread
belief
lawyers
criminal
courts
necessities
luxuries
right
one
charged
crime
counsel
may
deemed
fundamental
essential
fair
trials
countries
beginning
state
national
constitutions
laws
laid
great
emphasis
procedural
substantive
safeguards
designed
assure
fair
trials
impartial
tribunals
every
defendant
stands
equal
law
noble
ideal
realized
poor
man
charged
crime
face
accusers
without
lawyer
assist
person
right
reasonable
notice
charge
opportunity
heard
defense
right
day
basic
system
jurisprudence
rights
include
minimum
right
examine
witnesses
offer
testimony
represented
counsel
emphasis
supplied
trial
vagrancy
cases
illustrative
brief
sentences
imprisonment
may
imposed
cases
often
bristle
thorny
constitutional
questions
see
papachristou
jacksonville
gault
dealt
juvenile
delinquency
offense
committed
adult
carried
fine
imprisonment
jail
two
months
committed
juvenile
might
lead
detention
state
institution
reached
age
said
juvenile
needs
assistance
counsel
cope
problems
law
make
skilled
inquiry
facts
insist
upon
regularity
proceedings
ascertain
whether
defense
prepare
submit
child
requires
guiding
hand
counsel
every
step
proceedings
citing
powell
alabama
premise
gault
even
prosecutions
offenses
less
serious
felonies
fair
trial
may
require
presence
lawyer
beyond
problem
trials
appeals
guilty
plea
problem
looms
large
misdemeanor
well
felony
cases
counsel
needed
accused
may
know
precisely
fully
aware
prospect
going
jail
prison
treated
fairly
prosecution
addition
volume
misdemeanor
cases
far
greater
number
felony
prosecutions
may
create
obsession
speedy
dispositions
regardless
fairness
result
report
president
commission
law
enforcement
administration
justice
challenge
crime
free
society
example
legislation
last
year
increased
number
judges
district
columbia
general
sessions
four
judges
process
preliminary
stages
felony
cases
serious
misdemeanor
cases
petty
offenses
equal
number
traffic
offenses
per
year
inevitable
consequence
volume
large
almost
total
preoccupation
movement
cases
calendar
long
speed
often
substituted
care
casually
arranged
compromise
often
substituted
adjudication
inadequate
attention
tends
given
individual
defendant
whether
protecting
rights
sifting
facts
trial
deciding
social
risk
presents
determining
deal
conviction
frequent
result
futility
failure
dean
edward
barrett
recently
observed
wherever
visitor
looks
system
finds
great
numbers
defendants
processed
harassed
overworked
officials
police
cases
investigate
prosecutors
walk
courtrooms
try
simple
cases
take
initial
looks
files
defense
lawyers
appear
time
hasty
conversations
clients
judges
face
long
calendars
certain
knowledge
calendars
tomorrow
next
day
anything
longer
choice
dispose
cases
suddenly
becomes
clear
defendants
criminal
process
scant
regard
individuals
numbers
dockets
faceless
ones
processed
sent
way
gap
theory
reality
enormous
little
observation
administration
criminal
justice
operation
required
reach
conclusion
suffers
basic
ills
evidence
prejudice
results
misdemeanor
defendants
justice
one
study
concluded
isdemeanants
represented
attorneys
five
times
likely
emerge
police
charges
dismissed
defendants
face
similar
charges
without
counsel
american
civil
liberties
union
legal
counsel
misdemeanants
preliminary
report
must
conclude
therefore
problems
associated
misdemeanor
petty
offenses
often
require
presence
counsel
insure
accused
fair
trial
justice
powell
suggests
problems
raised
even
situations
prospect
imprisonment
post
need
consider
requirements
sixth
amendment
regards
right
counsel
loss
liberty
involved
however
petitioner
fact
sentenced
jail
said
baldwin
new
york
prospect
imprisonment
however
short
time
seldom
viewed
accused
trivial
petty
matter
may
well
result
quite
serious
repercussions
affecting
career
reputation
hold
therefore
absent
knowing
intelligent
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
offense
whether
classified
petty
misdemeanor
felony
unless
represented
counsel
trial
view
oregon
agree
said
stevenson
holzman
hold
person
may
deprived
liberty
denied
assistance
counsel
guaranteed
sixth
amendment
holding
applicable
criminal
prosecutions
including
prosecutions
violations
municipal
ordinances
denial
assistance
counsel
preclude
imposition
jail
sentence
american
bar
association
project
standards
criminal
justice
matter
sound
judicial
administration
preferable
disregard
characterization
offense
felony
misdemeanor
traffic
offense
adequate
require
provision
defense
services
offenses
carry
sentence
jail
prison
often
practical
matter
sentences
rarely
ever
imposed
certain
types
offenses
intents
purposes
punishment
carry
fine
thus
standard
seeks
distinguish
classes
cases
real
likelihood
incarceration
may
follow
conviction
types
likelihood
noted
standard
recommend
determination
need
counsel
terms
facts
particular
case
draws
categorical
line
types
offenses
incarceration
punishment
practical
possibility
providing
defense
services
approved
draft
run
misdemeanors
affected
today
ruling
end
actual
deprivation
person
liberty
accused
receive
benefit
guiding
hand
counsel
necessary
one
liberty
jeopardy
reversed
footnotes
review
federal
state
decisions
following
gideon
contained
comment
right
counsel
impact
gideon
wainwright
fifty
creighton
rev
twelve
provide
counsel
indigents
accused
serious
crime
misdemeanor
category
nineteen
provide
appointment
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
one
oregon
whose
said
stevenson
holzman
objective
insure
fair
trial
every
criminal
prosecution
need
counsel
determined
seriousness
crime
assistance
counsel
best
avoid
conviction
innocent
objective
important
municipal
general
jurisdiction
california
requirement
extends
traffic
violations
blake
municipal
cal
app
cal
rptr
overall
extended
right
defendants
charged
crimes
less
serious
felonies
comment
right
counsel
supra
see
frankfurter
corcoran
petty
federal
offenses
constitutional
guaranty
trial
jury
harv
rev
james
headley
cf
kaye
petty
offenders
peers
chi
rev
see
also
johnson
zerbst
sixth
amendment
embodies
realistic
recognition
obvious
truth
average
defendant
professional
legal
skill
protect
brought
tribunal
power
take
life
liberty
wherein
prosecution
presented
experienced
learned
counsel
simple
orderly
necessary
lawyer
untrained
layman
may
appear
intricate
complex
mysterious
defendants
charged
felonies
state
courts
charged
felonies
federal
courts
president
commission
law
enforcement
administration
justice
task
force
report
courts
exclusive
traffic
offenses
however
estimated
annually
four
five
million
cases
involving
misdemeanors
ibid
authoritative
figures
extrapolations
indicate
probably
million
traffic
offenses
year
note
dollars
sense
expanded
right
counsel
iowa
rev
title
defines
petty
offense
one
penalty
exceed
imprisonment
six
months
fine
title
provides
appointment
counsel
indigents
cases
petty
offense
appeals
fifth
circuit
noted
james
headley
enacted
criminal
justice
act
contains
congressional
plan
furnishing
legal
representation
federal
expense
certain
indigents
purport
cover
full
range
constitutional
rights
counsel
indeed
conference
report
criminal
justice
act
made
clear
conferees
belief
right
counsel
extends
offenses
petty
serious
alike
conf
sess
connection
federal
rules
criminal
procedure
amended
provide
rule
every
defendant
unable
obtain
counsel
shall
entitled
counsel
assigned
represent
every
stage
proceedings
initial
appearance
commissioner
appeal
unless
waives
appointment
advisory
committee
note
rule
says
like
original
rule
amended
rule
provides
right
counsel
broader
two
respects
compensation
provided
criminal
justice
act
right
extends
petty
offenses
tried
district
courts
right
extends
defendants
unable
obtain
counsel
reasons
financial
see
marston
oliver
supp
ed
incarceration
thirty
days
less
usually
result
loss
employment
consequent
substantial
detriment
defendant
family
share
justice
powell
doubt
nation
legal
resources
sufficient
implement
rule
announce
today
estimated
counsel
required
represent
indigent
misdemeanants
excluding
traffic
offenders
note
dollars
sense
expanded
right
counsel
iowa
rev
figures
relatively
insignificant
compared
estimated
attorneys
statistical
abstract
number
projected
double
year
see
ruud
burgeoning
law
school
enrollment
indeed
new
admissions
bar
year
lawyers
required
fill
estimated
average
annual
openings
article
proposed
revised
constitution
oregon
provides
every
person
right
assistance
counsel
official
proceedings
dealings
public
officers
may
materially
affect
afford
counsel
right
counsel
appointed
case
may
lose
liberty
one
partial
solution
problem
minor
offenses
may
well
remove
system
american
bar
association
special
committee
crime
prevention
control
recently
recommended
inter
alia
regulation
various
types
conduct
harm
one
involved
public
drunkenness
narcotics
addiction
vagrancy
deviant
sexual
behavior
taken
courts
handling
matters
transferred
nonjudicial
entities
detoxification
centers
narcotics
treatment
centers
social
service
agencies
handling
offenses
housing
code
traffic
violations
transferred
specialized
administrative
bodies
aba
report
new
perspectives
urban
crime
iv
solution
course
peculiarly
within
province
state
local
legislatures
forty
thousand
traffic
charges
arising
nonparking
traffic
citations
disposed
action
seattle
study
showed
however
cases
possibility
imprisonment
result
traffic
conviction
three
kinds
cases
accused
exposed
danger
imprisonment
offense
charged
reckless
drunken
driving
additional
traffic
violation
charged
individual
subject
suspended
sentence
previous
violation
whatever
offense
charged
convicted
individual
unable
pay
fine
imposed
junker
right
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
rev
people
convicted
city
new
york
traffic
infractions
jaywalking
speeding
fined
imprisoned
given
suspended
sentences
jailed
criminal
city
new
york
annual
report
convicted
serious
traffic
offenses
driving
influence
reckless
driving
leaving
scene
accident
subject
form
imprisonment
ibid
justice
brennan
justice
douglas
justice
stewart
join
concurring
join
opinion
add
observation
upon
discussion
legal
resources
ante
law
students
well
practicing
attorneys
may
provide
important
source
legal
representation
indigent
council
legal
education
professional
responsibility
clepr
informs
us
country
accredited
law
schools
established
clinical
programs
students
aid
clients
variety
civil
criminal
matters
clepr
newsletter
may
programs
supplement
practice
rules
enacted
authorizing
students
practice
law
prescribed
conditions
ibid
like
american
bar
association
model
student
practice
rule
regulations
permit
students
make
supervised
appearances
defense
counsel
criminal
cases
clepr
state
rules
permitting
student
practice
law
comparisons
comments
given
huge
increase
law
school
enrollments
past
years
see
ruud
burgeoning
law
school
enrollment
think
plain
law
students
expected
make
significant
contribution
quantitatively
qualitatively
representation
poor
many
areas
including
cases
reached
today
decision
total
law
schools
also
established
clinical
programs
corrections
law
students
faculty
supervision
aid
prisoners
preparation
petitions
relief
clepr
newsletter
may
see
simpson
app
chief
justice
burger
concurring
result
agree
much
analysis
opinion
justice
powell
appraisal
problems
able
confine
focus
solely
burden
bear
providing
counsel
inclined
stage
development
constitutional
right
counsel
conclude
much
commend
drawing
line
penalties
excess
six
months
confinement
yet
several
cogent
factors
suggest
infirmities
approach
allows
confinement
period
without
aid
counsel
trial
deprivation
liberty
serious
matter
issues
must
dealt
trial
petty
offense
misdemeanor
may
often
simpler
involved
felony
trial
yet
beyond
capability
layman
especially
opposed
prosecutor
little
ground
therefore
assume
defendant
unaided
counsel
able
adequately
defend
lesser
charges
may
involve
confinement
serious
charges
appeal
conviction
uncounselled
trial
likely
much
help
defendant
since
die
usually
cast
judgment
entered
uncounselled
trial
record
trial
judges
sitting
petty
misdemeanor
cases
prosecutors
recognize
exactly
required
today
decision
individual
imprisoned
unless
represented
counsel
trial
judge
prosecutor
engage
predictive
evaluation
case
determine
whether
significant
likelihood
defendant
convicted
trial
judge
sentence
jail
term
judge
preserve
option
jail
sentence
offering
counsel
defendant
unable
retain
counsel
need
predict
place
new
load
courts
already
overburdened
already
compelled
deal
far
cases
one
day
reasonable
proper
yet
prediction
one
beyond
capacity
experienced
judge
aided
prosecuting
officer
jury
cases
latter
prepared
inform
judge
prior
record
accused
general
nature
case
accused
including
use
violence
severity
harm
victim
impact
community
factors
relevant
sentencing
process
since
judge
degree
information
judgment
guilt
determined
ways
found
serious
misdemeanor
cases
jury
trial
waived
make
available
judge
trial
mean
full
presentence
report
every
defendant
every
case
jury
passes
guilt
prosecutor
know
trial
whether
intends
urge
jail
sentence
prepared
aid
factual
legal
basis
view
score
mean
defense
counsel
must
provided
also
additional
prosecutors
better
facilities
securing
information
accused
bears
probability
decision
confine
step
take
today
cause
surprise
legal
profession
five
years
ago
profession
speaking
american
bar
association
report
standards
relating
providing
defense
services
determined
society
goal
system
providing
counsel
facilities
defense
good
system
society
provides
prosecution
american
bar
association
project
standards
criminal
justice
providing
defense
services
approved
draft
aba
addressing
must
case
constitutional
requirement
broad
policy
issue
elsewhere
report
aba
stated
fundamental
premise
standards
representation
counsel
desirable
criminal
cases
viewpoint
defendant
society
counsel
provided
criminal
proceedings
offenses
punishable
loss
liberty
except
types
offenses
punishment
likely
imposed
regardless
denomination
felonies
misdemeanors
otherwise
pp
counsel
accused
essential
component
administration
criminal
justice
properly
constituted
hear
criminal
case
must
viewed
tripartite
entity
consisting
judge
jury
appropriate
counsel
prosecution
counsel
accused
approved
draft
nonjury
case
prior
record
accused
made
known
trier
fact
except
way
traditional
impeachment
justice
powell
justice
rehnquist
joins
concurring
result
gideon
wainwright
held
required
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
furnish
counsel
indigent
defendants
charged
felonies
question
us
today
whether
indigent
defendant
convicted
offense
carrying
maximum
punishment
six
months
imprisonment
fine
sentenced
days
jail
entitled
matter
constitutional
right
assistance
appointed
counsel
broader
question
whether
due
process
clause
requires
indigent
charged
state
petty
offense
afforded
right
appointed
counsel
case
review
florida
agreed
indigents
charged
serious
misdemeanors
entitled
appointed
counsel
vote
four
three
limited
right
offenses
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
state
drawing
line
followed
lead
duncan
louisiana
subsequent
case
baldwin
new
york
decided
shortly
opinion
held
due
process
right
trial
jury
state
criminal
cases
limited
cases
offense
charged
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
clear
wherever
line
drawn
must
drawn
indigent
right
appointed
counsel
cases
due
process
right
jury
trial
unskilled
layman
may
able
defend
nonjury
trial
judge
experienced
piecing
together
unassembled
facts
jury
guiding
hand
counsel
needed
marshal
evidence
coherent
whole
consistent
best
case
behalf
defendant
accompanying
right
counsel
right
trial
jury
becomes
meaningless
limiting
right
jury
trial
cases
offense
charged
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
compel
conclusion
indigent
right
appointed
counsel
must
similarly
restricted
opinions
duncan
baldwin
district
columbia
clawans
reveal
limitation
historic
origins
common
law
history
exists
support
similar
limitation
right
counsel
contrary
common
law
right
counsel
available
misdemeanor
felony
cases
recently
gideon
indigent
state
trial
right
appointed
counsel
felony
cases
moreover
interest
protected
right
guilt
innocence
determined
jury
tempering
possibly
arbitrary
harsh
exercise
prosecutorial
judicial
power
important
fundamental
guarantee
fair
trial
right
counsel
unable
agree
florida
indigent
defendant
charged
petty
offense
may
every
case
afforded
fair
trial
without
assistance
counsel
agree
new
rule
due
process
today
enunciated
absent
knowing
intelligent
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
unless
represented
counsel
trial
ante
seems
line
drawn
rigidity
middle
course
extremes
florida
rule
rule
comports
requirements
fourteenth
amendment
adhere
principle
due
process
requires
fundamental
fairness
criminal
trials
principle
believe
encompasses
right
counsel
petty
cases
whenever
assistance
counsel
necessary
assure
fair
trial
accord
indigent
accused
need
assistance
counsel
mysteriously
evaporate
charged
offense
punishable
six
months
less
powell
alabama
gideon
involved
felony
prosecutions
noted
laymen
present
adequately
cases
much
less
identify
argue
relevant
legal
questions
many
petty
offenses
also
present
complex
legal
factual
issues
may
fairly
tried
defendant
assisted
counsel
even
relatively
simple
cases
defendants
ignorance
handicap
incapable
defending
consequences
misdemeanor
conviction
whether
brief
period
served
sometimes
deplorable
conditions
found
local
jails
effect
criminal
record
employability
frequently
sufficient
magnitude
casually
dismissed
label
petty
serious
consequences
also
may
result
convictions
punishable
imprisonment
stigma
may
attach
conviction
escapade
losing
one
driver
license
serious
individuals
brief
stay
jail
bell
burson
said
licenses
issued
petitioner
case
continued
possession
may
become
essential
pursuit
livelihood
suspension
issued
licenses
thus
involves
state
action
adjudicates
important
interests
licensees
cases
licenses
taken
away
without
procedural
due
process
required
fourteenth
amendment
say
due
process
requires
appointment
counsel
petty
cases
assessment
possible
consequences
conviction
sole
test
need
assistance
counsel
flat
rule
florida
equally
inflexible
rule
majority
opinion
apply
cases
within
defined
areas
regardless
circumstances
precisely
mechanistic
application
find
alternatives
unsatisfactory
due
process
perhaps
fundamental
concept
law
embodies
principles
fairness
rather
immutable
line
drawing
every
aspect
criminal
trial
counsel
often
essential
fair
trial
means
universal
fact
petty
offense
cases
complex
others
exceedingly
simple
justification
furnishing
counsel
indigents
accused
felonies
noted
government
hires
lawyers
prosecute
defendants
money
hire
lawyers
defend
strongest
indications
widespread
belief
lawyers
criminal
courts
necessities
luxuries
yet
government
often
hire
lawyers
prosecute
petty
offenses
instead
arresting
police
officer
presents
case
every
defendant
afford
hire
lawyers
defend
petty
charges
possibility
jail
sentence
remote
probable
fine
seems
small
evidence
guilt
overwhelming
costs
assistance
counsel
may
exceed
benefits
anomalous
opinion
today
extend
right
appointed
counsel
indigent
defendants
cases
right
counsel
rarely
exercised
nonindigent
defendants
indeed
one
effects
ruling
favor
defendants
classified
indigents
classified
yet
groups
engaging
counsel
minor
case
luxury
family
afford
line
indigency
assumed
capacity
pay
counsel
necessarily
somewhat
arbitrary
drawn
differently
state
state
often
resulting
serious
inequities
accused
persons
new
rule
accent
disadvantage
barely
economically
survey
state
courts
misdemeanors
tried
showed
procedures
often
informal
presided
lay
judges
jury
trials
rare
prosecution
vigorous
inaccurate
say
defendant
obtain
fair
trial
without
assistance
counsel
courts
say
defendant
needs
assistance
counsel
offense
charged
petty
one
despite
overbreadth
easiest
solution
prophylactic
rule
require
appointment
counsel
indigents
criminal
cases
simplicity
rule
appealing
applied
automatically
every
case
price
pursuing
easy
course
high
indeed
terms
adverse
impact
administration
criminal
justice
systems
apparent
one
reflects
wide
variety
petty
misdemeanor
offenses
varying
definitions
thereof
diversity
penalties
prescribed
potential
impact
state
systems
also
apparent
view
variations
types
courts
jurisdictions
ranging
justices
peace
judges
small
communities
elaborately
staffed
police
courts
operate
hours
day
great
metropolitan
centers
rule
adopted
today
go
way
limited
cases
sentence
imprisonment
thrust
position
indicates
however
decision
must
made
rule
extended
cases
except
perhaps
minor
traffic
violations
rejects
constitutional
grounds
today
exercise
judicial
discretion
need
counsel
jail
sentence
imposed
one
must
assume
similar
rejection
discretion
cases
illogical
without
discernible
support
constitution
hold
discretion
may
ever
exercised
nominal
jail
sentence
contemplated
time
endorse
legitimacy
discretion
cases
may
result
far
serious
consequences
hours
days
incarceration
fifth
fourteenth
amendments
guarantee
property
well
life
liberty
may
taken
person
without
affording
due
process
law
majority
opinion
suggests
constitutional
basis
distinguishing
deprivations
liberty
property
fact
majority
suggests
reason
drawing
distinction
logic
advances
extending
right
counsel
cases
penalty
imprisonment
imposed
applies
equally
well
cases
penalties
may
imposed
majority
deny
penalties
serious
brief
jail
sentences
thus
although
new
rule
extended
today
imprisonment
category
cases
opinion
foreshadows
adoption
broad
prophylactic
rule
applicable
petty
offenses
one
foresee
consequences
drastic
enlargement
constitutional
right
free
counsel
even
today
decision
seriously
adverse
impact
upon
functioning
criminal
justice
system
slow
fashion
new
constitutional
rule
consequences
unknown
dimensions
especially
since
supported
neither
history
precedent
ii
majority
opinion
concludes
absent
valid
waiver
person
may
imprisoned
even
lesser
offenses
unless
represented
counsel
trial
simplest
terms
means
circumstances
land
may
anyone
imprisoned
however
briefly
unless
represented
waived
right
counsel
opinion
disquietingly
barren
details
rule
implemented
thousands
statutes
ordinances
authorize
imprisonment
six
months
less
usually
alternative
fine
offenses
include
trivial
misdemeanors
ranging
spitting
sidewalk
certain
traffic
offenses
also
include
variety
serious
misdemeanors
broad
spectrum
cases
daily
floods
lower
criminal
courts
rule
laid
today
confront
judges
courts
awkward
dilemma
counsel
appointed
knowingly
waived
sentence
imprisonment
duration
may
imposed
judge
therefore
forced
decide
advance
trial
without
hearing
evidence
whether
forgo
entirely
judicial
discretion
impose
sentence
imprisonment
abandon
responsibility
consider
full
range
punishments
established
legislature
alternatives
assuming
availability
counsel
appoint
counsel
retain
discretion
vested
law
abandon
discretion
advance
proceed
without
counsel
latter
course
followed
first
victim
new
rule
likely
concept
justice
requires
personalized
decision
guilt
sentence
notion
sentencing
tailored
fit
crime
individual
abandoned
many
categories
offenses
resolving
dilemma
administer
new
rule
judges
tempted
arbitrarily
divide
petty
offenses
two
categories
sentences
imprisonment
may
imposed
sentence
given
regardless
statutory
authorization
creating
categories
offenses
law
imprisonable
impose
jail
sentences
judge
overruling
de
facto
legislative
determination
appropriate
range
punishment
particular
offense
true
majority
notes
classes
imprisonable
offenses
imprisonment
rarely
imposed
even
occasional
imposition
sentence
may
serve
valuable
deterrent
purpose
least
legislatures
today
courts
viewed
threat
imprisonment
even
rarely
carried
serving
legitimate
social
function
brief
amicus
curiae
solicitor
general
suggested
flexibility
preserved
technique
trial
de
novo
evidence
contrary
pretrial
assumptions
justified
jail
sentence
presumably
mistrial
declared
counsel
appointed
new
trial
ordered
solicitor
general
also
recognized
second
trial
even
counsel
might
unfair
prosecutor
make
use
evidence
came
first
trial
accused
uncounselled
second
trial
held
judge
might
longer
finally
second
trial
held
reason
afford
judge
opportunity
impose
harsher
sentence
might
run
afoul
guarantee
twice
placed
jeopardy
offense
likelihood
second
trial
certain
offenses
classified
legislatures
imprisonable
treated
judges
unimprisonable
new
rule
announced
today
also
result
equal
protection
problems
may
well
unfair
unequal
treatment
individual
defendants
depending
whether
individual
judge
determined
advance
leave
open
option
imprisonment
thus
accused
indigent
entitled
courts
counsel
courts
jurisdiction
indigent
accused
offense
counsel
since
services
counsel
may
essential
fair
trial
even
cases
jail
sentence
imposed
results
type
pretrial
judgment
arbitrary
discriminatory
different
type
discrimination
result
typical
case
judgment
alternative
prescribed
example
five
days
jail
fine
judge
predetermined
imprisonment
imposed
respect
particular
category
cases
indigent
convicted
often
receive
meaningful
sentence
defendant
pay
fine
responded
sentence
accordance
law
whereas
indigent
commits
identical
offense
may
pay
penalty
deterrent
repetition
similar
offenses
indigents
avoid
equal
protection
problems
preserve
range
sentencing
options
prescribed
law
judges
likely
appoint
counsel
indigents
minor
offenses
jail
sentences
extremely
rare
doubtful
possess
necessary
resources
meet
sudden
expansion
right
counsel
solicitor
general
suggested
behalf
rule
today
adopts
recognized
consequences
far
reaching
addition
expense
compensating
counsel
noted
mandatory
requirement
defense
counsel
require
time
prosecutors
courtroom
time
lead
bigger
backlogs
present
personnel
reporters
needed
well
counsel
one
worst
bottlenecks
emphasizing
new
constitutional
rule
made
retroactive
solicitor
general
commented
chaos
result
mandatory
requirement
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
decision
become
fully
applicable
day
announced
massive
pileup
state
courts
meet
standard
involve
delays
frustrations
real
contribution
administration
justice
majority
treatment
consequences
new
rule
concerned
solicitor
general
reassuring
said
presently
attorneys
number
increase
rapidly
doubling
asserted
sufficient
provide
number
counsel
estimated
one
source
represent
indigent
misdemeanants
excluding
traffic
offenders
totally
unrealistic
imply
lawyers
potentially
available
thousands
practice
many
practice
work
governments
corporate
legal
departments
armed
services
unavailable
criminal
representation
general
practice
indication
many
qualified
defend
criminal
cases
willing
accept
assignments
may
prove
less
lucrative
similarly
unrealistic
suggest
implementation
new
rule
require
lawyers
communities
public
defenders
available
private
lawyers
specializing
petty
cases
thus
possible
necessary
coordinate
schedules
lawyers
willing
take
occasional
misdemeanor
appointment
crowded
calendars
lower
courts
cases
scheduled
weeks
advance
instead
frequently
tried
day
arrest
finally
majority
focus
aggregate
figures
ignores
heart
problem
distribution
availability
lawyers
especially
hundreds
small
localities
across
country
perhaps
serious
potential
impact
today
holding
already
overburdened
local
courts
primary
cause
assembly
line
justice
volume
cases
far
excess
capacity
system
handle
efficiently
fairly
rule
may
well
exacerbate
delay
congestion
courts
familiar
common
tactic
counsel
exhausting
every
possible
legal
avenue
often
without
due
regard
probable
payoff
cases
may
lawyer
duty
cases
done
purposes
delay
absence
direct
economic
impact
client
plus
omnipresent
claim
frequently
produces
decision
litigate
every
issue
likely
young
lawyers
fresh
law
school
receive
appointments
cases
admirable
zeal
lawyers
eagerness
make
reputation
time
yet
crowded
schedules
permit
devote
relatively
minor
legal
problems
desire
courtroom
exposure
availability
cases
hourly
fees
lucrative
novice
recent
constitutional
explosion
procedural
rights
accused
factors
likely
result
stretching
process
consequent
increased
costs
public
added
delay
congestion
courts
additional
problem
ability
various
localities
furnish
counsel
varies
widely
even
adequate
resources
national
basis
uneven
distribution
resources
lawyers
facilities
available
funding
presents
acute
problem
number
state
courts
considered
question
case
compelled
confront
realities
many
concluded
indigent
right
appointed
counsel
extend
misdemeanor
cases
reaching
conclusion
state
courts
drawn
line
different
places
acknowledged
moved
least
part
impracticality
going
legislatures
courts
enactment
laws
rules
drawn
line
short
adopted
majority
cases
statutes
reflect
judgment
courts
legislatures
many
understand
problems
local
judicial
systems
better
rule
announced
today
may
seriously
overtax
capabilities
papers
filed
recent
petition
writ
certiorari
serve
example
today
ruling
mean
localities
november
petition
wright
town
wood
filed
case
arising
south
dakota
police
magistrate
conviction
municipal
offense
public
intoxication
raises
issues
us
case
requested
town
wood
file
response
march
lawyer
occasionally
employed
town
filed
clerk
affidavit
explaining
town
responded
explained
wood
south
dakota
population
sewer
water
system
quite
poor
office
nearest
lawyer
town
miles
away
town
decided
contesting
case
unwise
allocation
limited
resources
though
undoubtedly
smaller
wood
dissimilar
hundreds
communities
lawyers
meager
financial
resources
need
sort
local
system
deal
minor
offenses
quite
common
numerous
petty
offenses
towns
tried
local
courts
magistrates
serious
offenses
tried
countywide
located
county
seat
undoubtedly
true
injustices
result
informal
procedures
local
courts
counsel
furnished
certainly
counsel
furnished
indigents
cases
require
counsel
furnished
virtually
every
indigent
charged
imprisonable
offense
practical
impossibility
many
small
town
courts
community
simply
enforce
laws
perhaps
said
give
undue
weight
likelihood
chaos
possibility
adverse
effects
system
answer
may
given
constitution
requires
rule
announced
majority
consequences
immaterial
satisfied
guarantee
due
process
required
assistance
counsel
every
case
jail
sentence
imposed
workable
method
insuring
justice
adopt
majority
rule
hesitate
join
opinion
despite
misgivings
effect
upon
administration
justice
addition
resulting
problems
availability
counsel
costs
especially
intolerable
delay
already
overburdened
system
majority
drawing
new
inflexible
rule
may
raise
fourteenth
amendment
problems
resolves
although
opinion
deal
explicitly
sentence
deprivation
liberty
however
brief
according
special
constitutional
status
cases
sentence
imposed
may
derogate
need
counsel
types
cases
unless
embraces
even
broader
prophylactic
rule
due
process
requires
fair
trial
cases
neither
rule
approved
rule
today
enunciated
likely
achieve
result
iii
hold
right
counsel
cases
absolute
one
determined
trial
courts
exercising
judicial
discretion
basis
determination
made
accused
formally
pleads
many
petty
cases
resolved
guilty
pleas
assistance
counsel
may
required
trial
conclude
assistance
counsel
required
case
state
reasons
issue
preserved
review
trial
become
obligated
scrutinize
carefully
subsequent
proceedings
protection
defendant
unrepresented
defendant
sought
enter
plea
guilty
examine
case
insure
admissible
evidence
tending
support
elements
offense
case
went
trial
without
defense
counsel
intervene
necessary
insure
defendant
adequately
brings
facts
favor
prevent
legal
issues
overlooked
formal
trial
rules
applied
strictly
unrepresented
defendants
finally
appellate
courts
carefully
scrutinize
decisions
appoint
counsel
proceedings
follow
impossible
well
unwise
create
precise
detailed
set
guidelines
judges
follow
determining
whether
appointment
counsel
necessary
assure
fair
trial
certainly
three
general
factors
weighed
first
consider
complexity
offense
charged
example
charges
traffic
law
infractions
rarely
present
complex
legal
factual
questions
charges
contain
difficult
intent
elements
raise
collateral
legal
questions
problems
usually
complex
unassisted
layman
offense
one
state
represented
counsel
defendants
afford
obtain
counsel
strong
indication
indigent
also
needs
assistance
counsel
second
consider
probable
sentence
follow
conviction
obtained
serious
likely
consequences
greater
probability
lawyer
appointed
noted
part
imprisonment
serious
consequence
consider
third
consider
individual
factors
peculiar
case
course
difficult
anticipate
one
relevant
factor
competency
individual
defendant
present
case
attitude
community
toward
particular
defendant
particular
incident
another
consideration
might
reasons
defendant
peculiar
need
lawyer
compel
appointment
counsel
case
normally
think
unnecessary
obviously
sensitivity
diligence
individual
judges
crucial
operation
rule
fundamental
fairness
requiring
consideration
varying
factors
case
rule
similar
certain
respects
rule
applied
felony
cases
betts
brady
bute
illinois
overruled
gideon
one
reasons
seeking
definitive
standard
felony
cases
failure
many
state
courts
live
responsibilities
determining
basis
whether
counsel
appointed
see
concurring
opinion
justice
harlan
gideon
assume
past
insensitivity
state
courts
rights
defendants
continue
certainly
follows
course
reading
rigid
rules
constitution
state
courts
unable
exercise
judicial
discretion
within
limits
fundamental
fairness
little
reason
think
insensitivity
abate
concluding
emphasize
conviction
adversary
system
functions
best
fairly
parties
represented
competent
counsel
becoming
member
participated
efforts
enlarge
extend
availability
counsel
correct
disposition
case
therefore
matter
considerable
concern
members
strongly
drawn
ideal
extending
right
counsel
differ
two
fundamentals
constitution
requires
ii
effect
upon
criminal
justice
system
especially
smaller
cities
thousands
police
municipal
justice
peace
courts
across
country
view
expressed
opinion
accord
considerable
discretion
courts
allow
flexibility
opportunity
adjustment
seems
necessary
imposing
new
doctrine
lowest
level
courts
although
view
precipitate
chaos
predicted
solicitor
general
probable
result
absolutist
rule
still
remain
serious
practical
problems
resulting
expansion
indigents
rights
counsel
cases
according
reviewable
discretion
courts
determining
counsel
necessary
fair
trial
rather
mandating
completely
inflexible
rule
facilitate
orderly
transition
far
wider
availability
use
defense
counsel
process
courts
first
instance
decide
cases
recognize
duty
consider
need
counsel
every
case
defendant
faces
significant
penalty
factors
mentioned
standards
guidelines
assure
fairness
might
prescribed
jurisdiction
legislation
rule
considered
relevant
goal
accord
essence
adversary
system
expand
rapidly
practicable
availability
counsel
person
accused
crime
must
stand
alone
counsel
needed
proceedings
courts
accord
views
expressed
concur
result
decision
case
true
justice
black
opinion
gideon
narrowly
written
justice
harlan
quick
suggest
concurring
opinion
facts
gideon
require
decide
whether
indigent
right
appointed
counsel
extend
criminal
cases
opinions
announced
recently
assumed
holding
gideon
yet
extended
misdemeanor
cases
see
gault
mempa
rhay
burgett
texas
loper
beto
used
herein
term
petty
offense
means
offense
authorized
imprisonment
exceed
six
months
baldwin
new
york
also
includes
offenses
punishable
imprisonment
regardless
amount
fine
might
authorized
extent
definition
used
herein
differs
federal
statutory
definition
petty
offense
includes
offense
punishable
six
months
imprisonment
fine
exceeding
see
powell
alabama
duncan
louisiana
although
given
retroactive
effect
ruling
gideon
pickelsimer
wainwright
said
values
implemented
right
jury
trial
measurably
served
requiring
retrial
persons
convicted
past
procedures
consistent
sixth
amendment
right
jury
trial
destefano
woods
supra
see
silverstein
defense
poor
criminal
cases
american
state
courts
see
james
headley
wide
range
civil
disabilities
may
result
misdemeanor
convictions
forfeiture
public
office
state
ex
rel
stinger
kruger
mo
disqualification
licensed
profession
cal
bus
code
optometrists
stat
real
estate
brokers
loss
pension
rights
stat
ann
police
disability
pension
denied
injury
result
participation
fights
riots
civil
insurrections
committing
crime
ind
ann
stat
teacher
convicted
misdemeanor
resulting
imprisonment
stat
tit
supp
conviction
crime
misdemeanor
see
generally
project
collateral
consequences
criminal
conviction
vand
rev
gideon
wainwright
petty
offenses
much
less
plea
negotiation
serious
offenses
see
report
president
commission
law
enforcement
administration
justice
challenge
crime
free
society
hereinafter
challenge
thus
cases
evidence
guilt
overwhelming
assistance
counsel
less
essential
obtain
lighter
sentence
silverstein
supra
neither
report
president
commission
law
enforcement
administration
justice
american
bar
association
went
route
takes
today
president
commission
recommended
counsel
provided
criminal
defendants
face
significant
penalty
least
danger
substantial
loss
liberty
challenge
supra
american
bar
association
standard
extend
right
counsel
cases
loss
liberty
likely
imposed
american
bar
association
project
standards
criminal
justice
providing
defense
services
approved
draft
neither
supports
new
inflexible
constitutional
rule
see
callan
wilson
north
carolina
pearce
type
penalty
discussed
involving
discretionary
alternative
jail
fine
presents
serious
problems
fairness
indigents
nonindigents
administration
justice
cf
tate
short
adequate
resolution
inherently
difficult
problems
yet
found
rule
adopted
today
depriving
lower
courts
discretion
cases
unless
counsel
available
appointed
aggravate
problem
tr
oral
arg
custom
many
localities
appoint
counsel
basis
compensation
generally
inadequate
even
federal
courts
criminal
justice
act
provides
one
generous
compensation
plans
rates
appointed
counsel
per
hour
spent
per
hour
time
subject
maximum
total
fee
misdemeanor
case
felony
low
american
standards
consequently
majority
persons
willing
accept
appointments
young
inexperienced
see
cappelletti
part
one
emergence
modern
theme
cappelletti
gordley
legal
aid
modern
themes
variations
stan
rev
justice
brennan
suggests
concurring
opinion
law
students
might
provide
important
source
legal
representation
presents
figures
however
many
students
qualified
willing
undertake
responsibilities
defending
indigent
misdemeanants
although
welcome
progress
made
programs
supported
american
bar
association
enlist
involvement
law
students
indigent
representation
problems
meeting
state
requirements
assuring
requisite
control
supervision
far
insubstantial
moreover
impact
student
participation
limited
primarily
less
communities
law
schools
located
see
generally
james
crisis
courts
challenge
supra
see
james
supra
schrag
majesty
secret
service
protecting
consumer
new
york
city
yale
cook
county
illinois
recent
study
revealed
members
chicago
bar
association
committee
defense
prisoners
appointed
represent
indigent
defendants
elect
jury
trial
trial
cases
appointed
counsel
retained
counsel
public
defender
one
possible
explanation
contrast
committee
counsel
sometimes
serving
part
gain
experience
willing
undertake
jury
trial
assistant
public
defender
busy
conscious
probable
extra
penalty
accruing
defendant
loses
case
jury
oaks
lehman
criminal
justice
system
indigent
omitted
see
irvin
state
app
burrage
superior
cableton
state
ark
state
ex
rel
argersinger
hamlin
people
dupree
people
mallory
hendrix
city
seattle
cert
denied
state
ex
rel
plutschack
department
health
social
services
see
hawaii
art
idaho
code
supp
stat
ann
supp
rule
crim
proc
la
rev
stat
rule
crim
proc
md
rule
neb
rev
stat
rev
stat
mex
stat
ann
supp
utah
code
ann
supp
stat
tit
supp
code
ann
supp
see
kamisar
choper
right
counsel
minnesota
field
findings
observations
rev
local
judges
interviewed
authors
concluded
right
counsel
extended
petty
cases
dividing
line
drawn
question
assigned
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
resolves
nothing
proposition
thrust
views
limited
funds
need
judicial
economy
dictate
nothing
omitted
see
state
borst
see
cableton
state
justices
peace
arkansas
resident
practicing
lawyers
counties
practicing
lawyers
impact
right
counsel
misdemeanor
cases
seriously
impair
administration
justice
arkansas
impose
intolerable
burden
upon
legal
profession
omitted
see
silverstein
supra
successful
implementation
majority
rule
require
state
local
governments
appropriate
considerable
funds
something
willing
three
nation
population
provide
state
appropriations
indigent
defense
note
dollars
sense
expanded
right
counsel
iowa
rev
example
state
kansas
spent
defending
indigents
felony
cases
although
budgetary
request
legislature
appropriated
brief
appellant
james
strange
decided
today
post
view
american
resources
funds
spent
legal
services
program
regarded
trivial
cappelletti
supra
although
american
economy
times
size
british
american
population
almost
times
great
american
legal
aid
expenditures
less
times
high
seems
individualized
rule
unlike
rule
majority
rule
present
equal
protection
problems
decisions
griffin
illinois
douglas
california
mayer
city
chicago
see
katz
municipal
courts
another
urban
ill
case
western
reserve
rev
cf
hamilton
alabama
white
maryland
harvey
mississippi
although
less
plea
negotiating
petty
cases
see
supra
assistance
counsel
may
still
needed
defendant
faced
overwhelming
evidence
guilt
make
intelligent
decision
whether
go
trial
disagree
overruling
betts
complete
accord
gideon
betts
like
gideon
concerned
right
counsel
felony
case
see
supra
neither
case
controls
today
result
indeed
recognized
many
problems
identified
opinion
result
raising
standards
requirement
counsel
view
relying
upon
judicial
discretion
assure
fair
trial
petty
offenses
comports
constitution
minimize
problems
otherwise
affect
adversely
administration
criminal
justice
courts
already
severe
strain