bank
germain
argued
january
decided
march
suit
respondent
germain
trustee
bankrupt
debtor
estate
seeking
hold
petitioner
connecticut
national
bank
cnb
liable
various
torts
breaches
contract
bankruptcy
denied
cnb
motion
strike
germain
demand
jury
trial
district
affirmed
appeals
dismissed
cnb
attempted
appeal
lack
jurisdiction
holding
appeals
may
exercise
jurisdiction
interlocutory
order
bankruptcy
district
issues
order
withdrawn
case
bankruptcy
district
acts
capacity
bankruptcy
appeals
held
interlocutory
order
issued
district
sitting
appeals
bankruptcy
appealable
unambiguous
language
section
provides
review
courts
appeals
certain
circumstances
nterlocutory
orders
district
courts
limit
review
orders
issued
district
courts
sitting
bankruptcy
trial
courts
rather
appellate
courts
title
gives
courts
appeals
jurisdiction
inter
alia
appeals
final
orders
district
courts
sitting
appellate
courts
bankruptcy
silent
review
interlocutory
orders
limit
unadorned
words
negative
implication
contrary
germain
contention
giving
effect
companion
provision
confers
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
acting
capacity
render
wholly
superfluous
although
overlap
also
confers
jurisdiction
final
decisions
bankruptcy
appellate
panels
section
reaches
cases
redundancies
across
statutes
unusual
events
drafting
positive
repugnancy
two
laws
must
give
effect
pp
reversed
remanded
thomas
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
scalia
kennedy
souter
joined
stevens
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
filed
opinion
concurring
judgment
white
blackmun
joined
janet
hall
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
eric
brunstad
linda
morkan
thomas
germain
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
justice
thomas
delivered
opinion
case
determine
appealability
interlocutory
order
issued
district
sitting
appeals
bankruptcy
fuel
oil
filed
bankruptcy
petition
bankruptcy
district
connecticut
although
case
began
reorganization
chapter
bankruptcy
code
bankruptcy
converted
liquidation
chapter
petitioner
connecticut
national
bank
cnb
successor
interest
one
creditors
respondent
thomas
germain
trustee
estate
june
germain
sued
cnb
connecticut
state
seeking
hold
bank
liable
various
torts
breaches
contract
cnb
removed
suit
district
district
connecticut
pursuant
local
rule
automatically
referred
proceeding
bankruptcy
overseeing
liquidation
germain
filed
demand
jury
trial
cnb
moved
strike
germain
demand
bankruptcy
denied
cnb
motion
fuel
oil
district
affirmed
germain
connecticut
nat
bank
cnb
tried
appeal
appeals
second
circuit
dismissed
lack
jurisdiction
second
circuit
held
appeals
may
exercise
jurisdiction
interlocutory
orders
bankruptcy
district
issues
order
withdrawn
proceeding
case
bankruptcy
district
acts
capacity
bankruptcy
appeals
granted
certiorari
reverse
remand
ii
courts
appeals
jurisdiction
nterlocutory
orders
district
courts
cnb
contends
applies
terms
case
second
circuit
therefore
exercised
discretionary
jurisdiction
appeal
germain
argues
apply
case
congress
limited
deals
bankruptcy
jurisdiction
cnb
responds
nothing
limits
agree
cnb
bankruptcy
appeals
governed
part
section
comprises
four
subsections
three
concern
us
subsection
gives
district
courts
authority
hear
appeals
final
interlocutory
orders
bankruptcy
courts
district
noted
jurisdiction
provision
hear
cnb
appeal
bankruptcy
subsection
permits
judicial
council
circuit
establish
bankruptcy
appellate
panel
fill
role
district
courts
subsection
subsection
pivotal
case
provides
courts
appeals
shall
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
judgments
orders
decrees
entered
subsections
sec
tion
germain
contends
appeals
jurisdiction
either
view
precludes
jurisdiction
negative
implication
germain
reasons
follows
although
appear
cover
universe
decisions
issued
district
courts
conferring
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
conferring
jurisdiction
certain
interlocutory
ones
fact
cover
final
decisions
district
argues
section
render
superfluous
since
final
decision
issued
district
sitting
bankruptcy
appellate
still
final
decision
district
effect
germain
contends
section
must
exclusive
within
domain
defines
universe
orders
issued
district
courts
sitting
pursuant
courts
appeals
bankruptcy
district
enters
order
capacity
germain
concludes
confer
jurisdiction
nothing
else
germain
claims
find
support
view
reading
legislative
history
contrary
germain
contention
need
choose
giving
effect
one
hand
statutes
pose
proposition
section
confers
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
acting
capacity
section
contrast
confers
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
act
bankruptcy
appellate
courts
also
confers
jurisdiction
final
decisions
appellate
panels
bankruptcy
acting
sections
overlap
therefore
section
confers
jurisdiction
cases
section
reach
redundancies
across
statutes
unusual
events
drafting
long
positive
repugnancy
two
laws
wood
pet
must
give
effect
giving
effect
render
one
wholly
superfluous
read
precluding
courts
appeals
negative
implication
exercising
jurisdiction
district
courts
sitting
bankruptcy
similarly
read
precluding
jurisdiction
courts
disfavor
interpretations
statutes
render
language
superfluous
case
canon
apply
event
canons
construction
rules
thumb
help
courts
determine
meaning
legislation
interpreting
statute
always
turn
first
one
cardinal
canon
others
stated
time
courts
must
presume
legislature
says
statute
means
means
statute
says
see
ron
pair
enterprises
goldenberg
oneale
thornton
cranch
words
statute
unambiguous
first
canon
also
last
judicial
inquiry
complete
rubin
see
also
ron
pair
enterprises
supra
germain
says
legislative
history
points
different
result
think
judicial
inquiry
applicability
begins
ends
say
section
provides
review
courts
appeals
certain
circumstances
nterlocutory
orders
district
courts
section
silent
review
interlocutory
orders
nowhere
limit
review
orders
issued
district
courts
sitting
trial
courts
bankruptcy
rather
appellate
courts
nowhere
else
whether
statute
congress
indicated
unadorned
words
way
limited
implication
dangerous
extreme
infer
case
words
instrument
expressly
provide
shall
exempted
operation
sturges
crowninshield
wheat
see
also
regents
univ
cal
public
employment
relations
reason
infer
either
congress
meant
limit
appellate
review
interlocutory
orders
bankruptcy
proceedings
long
party
proceeding
case
bankruptcy
meets
conditions
imposed
appeals
may
rely
statute
basis
jurisdiction
judgment
appeals
second
circuit
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
ordered
section
provides
relevant
part
courts
appeals
shall
jurisdiction
appeals
interlocutory
orders
district
courts
judges
thereof
granting
continuing
modifying
refusing
dissolving
injunctions
refusing
dissolve
modify
injunctions
except
direct
review
may
interlocutory
orders
appointing
receivers
refusing
orders
wind
receiverships
take
steps
accomplish
purposes
thereof
interlocutory
decrees
district
courts
judges
thereof
determining
rights
liabilities
parties
admiralty
cases
appeals
final
decrees
allowed
district
judge
making
civil
action
order
otherwise
appealable
section
shall
opinion
order
involves
controlling
question
law
substantial
ground
difference
opinion
immediate
appeal
order
may
materially
advance
ultimate
termination
litigation
shall
state
writing
order
appeals
jurisdiction
appeal
action
may
thereupon
discretion
permit
appeal
taken
order
application
made
within
ten
days
entry
order
whenever
uncertainty
meaning
statute
prudent
examine
legislative
history
case
examination
appropriate
petitioner
interpretation
creates
unusual
overlap
rejecting
petitioner
position
appeals
concluded
enacting
current
system
bankruptcy
appeals
congress
limited
scope
excluding
review
courts
appeals
certain
interlocutory
bankruptcy
orders
congress
intended
significant
change
scheme
appellate
jurisdiction
indication
purpose
almost
certainly
found
way
legislative
history
legislative
record
however
contains
mention
intent
limit
scope
silence
tends
support
conclusion
change
intended
accordingly
notwithstanding
inferences
drawn
appeals
legislative
history
consistent
petitioner
interpretation
statute
also
actually
supports
reason
agree
textual
analysis
concur
judgment
footnotes
see
american
hospital
assn
nlrb
edmonds
compagnie
generale
transatlantique
see
also
harrison
ppg
industries
rehnquist
dissenting
case
construction
legislative
language
makes
sweeping
relatively
unorthodox
change
made
think
judges
well
detectives
may
take
consideration
fact
watchdog
bark
night
similarly
justice
frankfurter
scholarly
observation
concerning
interpretation
statutory
text
also
applies
analysis
legislative
history
one
must
listen
attentively
say
frankfurter
reflections
reading
statutes
justice
justice
white
justice
blackmun
join
concurring
judgment
agree
congress
enacted
part
bankruptcy
amendments
federal
judgeship
act
congress
probably
intend
deprive
courts
appeals
longstanding
jurisdiction
interlocutory
appeals
bankruptcy
cases
think
admit
construction
statutes
render
largely
superfluous
strive
interpret
statutes
avoid
redundancy
cf
ante
case
think
far
likely
congress
inadvertently
created
redundancy
congress
intended
withdraw
appellate
jurisdiction
interlocutory
bankruptcy
appeals
roundabout
method
reconferring
jurisdiction
appeals
final
bankruptcy
orders
reverse
judgment
reason