ernst
ernst
hochfelder
argued
december
decided
march
petitioner
accounting
firm
retained
audit
periodically
brokerage
firm
books
records
respondents
customers
brokerage
firm
invested
securities
scheme
ultimately
revealed
fraudulent
perpetrated
firm
president
principal
stockholder
fraud
came
light
respondents
filed
action
damages
petitioner
securities
exchange
act
act
makes
unlawful
use
employ
manipulative
deceptive
device
contrivance
contravention
securities
exchange
commission
sec
rules
alleged
brokerage
firm
president
scheme
violated
sec
rule
petitioner
aided
abetted
violations
failure
conduct
proper
audits
firm
thereby
failing
discover
internal
practices
prevented
effective
audit
district
granted
petitioner
motion
summary
judgment
dismissed
action
holding
whether
cause
action
based
merely
allegations
negligence
genuine
issue
material
fact
whether
petitioner
conducted
audits
accordance
generally
accepted
standards
appeals
reversed
remanded
holding
one
breaches
duty
inquiry
disclosure
owed
another
liable
damages
aiding
abetting
third
party
violation
rule
fraud
discovered
prevented
breach
genuine
issues
fact
whether
petitioner
committed
breach
whether
inquiry
disclosure
led
discovery
prevention
president
fraud
held
private
cause
action
damages
lie
rule
absence
allegation
scienter
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
defendant
part
pp
use
words
manipulative
device
contrivance
clearly
shows
intended
proscribe
type
conduct
quite
different
negligence
particularly
use
word
manipulative
virtually
term
art
used
connection
securities
markets
connotes
intentional
willful
conduct
designed
deceive
defraud
investors
controlling
artificially
affecting
price
securities
pp
act
legislative
history
also
indicates
addressed
practices
involving
element
scienter
read
impose
liability
negligent
conduct
alone
pp
structure
act
interrelated
securities
act
act
support
contention
since
contrast
certain
sections
acts
terms
explicitly
restricted
willful
knowing
purposeful
conduct
construed
require
negligent
action
inaction
precondition
civil
liability
instance
congress
acts
created
express
civil
liability
favor
purchasers
sellers
securities
clearly
specified
whether
recovery
premised
knowing
intentional
conduct
negligence
entirely
innocent
mistake
express
recognition
cause
action
premised
negligent
behavior
example
stands
sharp
contrast
language
moreover
express
civil
remedies
act
allowing
recovery
negligent
conduct
subject
significant
procedural
restrictions
indicating
judicially
created
private
damages
remedy
comparable
restrictions
extended
consistently
congress
intent
actions
premised
negligence
since
allow
causes
action
express
act
remedies
brought
instead
thereby
nullifying
effectiveness
restrictions
remedies
pp
language
rule
arguably
read
proscribing
type
material
misstatement
omission
course
conduct
effect
defrauding
investors
whether
wrongdoing
intentional
reading
comport
rule
administrative
history
makes
clear
intended
apply
activities
involving
scienter
importantly
scope
rule
exceed
power
granted
sec
whose
language
history
compel
interpreting
rule
apply
intentional
wrongdoing
pp
case
remanded
proceedings
require
proof
negligent
misfeasance
petitioner
since
throughout
history
case
respondents
proceeded
theory
liability
premised
negligence
fact
specifically
disclaiming
petitioner
engaged
fraud
intentional
misconduct
powell
delivered
opinion
burger
stewart
white
marshall
rehnquist
joined
blackmun
filed
dissenting
opinion
brennan
joined
post
stevens
took
part
consideration
decision
case
robert
berner
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
francis
morrissey
michael
madda
kenneth
lang
willard
king
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondents
hochfelder
et
al
willard
lassers
argued
cause
respondents
allison
et
al
brief
donald
vetter
leon
despres
alex
elson
paul
gonson
argued
cause
securities
exchange
commission
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
brief
solicitor
general
bork
deputy
solicitor
general
friedman
lawrence
nerheim
charles
luedde
kenneth
bialkin
louis
craco
filed
brief
american
institute
certified
public
accountants
amicus
curiae
urging
reversal
justice
powell
delivered
opinion
issue
case
whether
action
civil
damages
may
lie
securities
exchange
act
act
stat
securities
exchange
commission
rule
cfr
absence
allegation
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
part
defendant
petitioner
ernst
ernst
accounting
firm
retained
first
securities
company
chicago
first
securities
small
brokerage
firm
member
midwest
stock
exchange
national
association
securities
dealers
perform
periodic
audits
firm
books
records
connection
audits
ernst
ernst
prepared
filing
securities
exchange
commission
commission
annual
reports
required
first
securities
act
also
prepared
first
securities
responses
financial
questionnaires
midwest
stock
exchange
exchange
respondents
customers
first
securities
invested
fraudulent
securities
scheme
perpetrated
leston
nay
president
firm
owner
stock
nay
induced
respondents
invest
funds
escrow
accounts
represented
yield
high
rate
return
respondents
majority
transactions
occurring
fact
escrow
accounts
nay
converted
respondents
funds
use
immediately
upon
receipt
transactions
customary
form
dealings
first
securities
customers
respondents
drew
personal
checks
payable
nay
designated
bank
account
escrow
accounts
reflected
books
records
first
securities
none
shown
periodic
accounting
respondents
connection
investments
included
first
securities
filings
commission
exchange
fraud
came
light
nay
committed
suicide
leaving
note
described
first
securities
bankrupt
escrow
accounts
spurious
respondents
subsequently
filed
action
damages
ernst
ernst
district
northern
district
illinois
act
complaint
charged
nay
escrow
scheme
violated
commission
rule
ernst
ernst
aided
abetted
nay
violations
failure
conduct
proper
audits
first
securities
revealed
discovery
respondents
cause
action
rested
theory
negligent
nonfeasance
premise
ernst
ernst
failed
utilize
appropriate
auditing
procedures
audits
first
securities
thereby
failing
discover
internal
practices
firm
said
prevent
effective
audit
practice
principally
relied
nay
rule
open
mail
addressed
first
securities
addressed
first
securities
attention
even
arrived
absence
respondents
contended
ernst
ernst
conducted
proper
audit
discovered
mail
rule
existence
rule
disclosed
reports
exchange
commission
ernst
ernst
irregular
procedure
prevented
effective
audit
led
investigation
nay
revealed
fraudulent
scheme
respondents
specifically
disclaimed
existence
fraud
intentional
misconduct
part
ernst
ernst
extensive
discovery
district
granted
ernst
ernst
motion
summary
judgment
dismissed
action
rejected
ernst
ernst
contention
cause
action
aiding
abetting
securities
fraud
maintained
rule
merely
allegations
negligence
concluded
however
genuine
issue
material
fact
respect
whether
ernst
ernst
conducted
audits
accordance
generally
accepted
auditing
standards
appeals
seventh
circuit
reversed
remanded
holding
one
breaches
duty
inquiry
disclosure
owed
another
liable
damages
aiding
abetting
third
party
violation
rule
fraud
discovered
prevented
breach
reasoned
ernst
ernst
statutory
duty
inquiry
adequacy
first
securities
internal
control
system
contracted
audit
first
securities
prepare
filing
commission
annual
report
first
securities
financial
condition
required
act
rule
reasoned
respondents
beneficiaries
statutory
duty
inquire
related
duty
disclose
material
irregularities
discovered
concluded
genuine
issues
fact
whether
ernst
ernst
failure
discover
comment
upon
nay
mail
rule
constituted
breach
duties
inquiry
disclosure
whether
inquiry
disclosure
led
discovery
prevention
nay
fraud
granted
certiorari
resolve
question
whether
private
cause
action
damages
lie
rule
absence
allegation
scienter
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
conclude
therefore
reverse
ii
federal
regulation
transactions
securities
emerged
part
aftermath
market
crash
securities
act
act
stat
amended
et
designed
provide
investors
full
disclosure
material
information
concerning
public
offerings
securities
commerce
protect
investors
fraud
imposition
specified
civil
liabilities
promote
ethical
standards
honesty
fair
dealing
see
act
intended
principally
protect
investors
manipulation
stock
prices
regulation
transactions
upon
securities
exchanges
markets
impose
regular
reporting
requirements
companies
whose
stock
listed
national
securities
exchanges
see
although
acts
contain
numerous
carefully
drawn
express
civil
remedies
criminal
penalties
congress
recognized
efficient
regulation
securities
trading
accomplished
rigid
statutory
program
part
act
congress
created
commission
provided
arsenal
flexible
enforcement
powers
see
act
act
section
act
makes
unlawful
person
use
employ
connection
purchase
sale
security
manipulative
deceptive
device
contrivance
contravention
rules
regulations
commission
may
prescribe
necessary
appropriate
public
interest
protection
investors
acting
pursuant
power
conferred
commission
promulgated
rule
provides
employment
manipulative
deceptive
devices
shall
unlawful
person
directly
indirectly
use
means
instrumentality
interstate
commerce
mails
facility
national
securities
exchange
employ
device
scheme
artifice
defraud
make
untrue
statement
material
fact
omit
state
material
fact
necessary
order
make
statements
made
light
circumstances
made
misleading
engage
act
practice
course
business
operates
operate
fraud
deceit
upon
person
connection
purchase
sale
security
section
makes
unlawful
use
employment
manipulative
deceptive
device
contrivance
contravention
commission
rules
words
manipulative
deceptive
used
conjunction
device
contrivance
strongly
suggest
intended
proscribe
knowing
intentional
misconduct
see
sec
texas
gulf
sulphur
friendly
concurring
cert
denied
sub
nom
coates
sec
loss
summary
remarks
bus
law
special
issue
see
also
kohn
american
metal
climax
adams
concurring
dissenting
amicus
curiae
brief
however
commission
contends
nothing
language
manipulative
deceptive
device
contrivance
limits
operation
knowing
intentional
practices
support
view
commission
cites
overall
congressional
purpose
acts
protect
investors
false
deceptive
practices
might
injure
see
affiliated
ute
citizens
supra
superintendent
insurance
bankers
life
cas
supra
case
borak
see
also
sec
capital
gains
res
commission
reasons
since
effect
upon
investors
given
conduct
regardless
whether
conduct
negligent
intentional
congress
must
intended
bar
practices
done
knowingly
intentionally
logic
approach
impose
liability
wholly
faultless
conduct
conduct
results
harm
investors
result
commission
unlikely
support
apart
logic
might
lead
commission
add
gloss
operative
language
statute
quite
different
commonly
accepted
meaning
see
addison
holly
hill
fruit
products
argument
simply
ignores
use
words
manipulative
device
contrivance
terms
make
unmistakable
congressional
intent
proscribe
type
conduct
quite
different
negligence
use
word
manipulative
especially
significant
virtually
term
art
used
connection
securities
markets
connotes
intentional
willful
conduct
designed
deceive
defraud
investors
controlling
artificially
affecting
price
securities
addition
relying
upon
commission
argument
respect
operative
language
statute
respondents
contend
since
dealing
remedial
legislation
tcherepnin
knight
must
construed
technically
restrictively
flexibly
effectuate
remedial
purposes
affiliated
ute
citizens
quoting
sec
capital
gains
research
bureau
supra
argue
remedial
purposes
acts
demand
construction
embraces
negligence
standard
liability
seeking
accomplish
broad
remedial
goals
congress
adopt
uniformly
negligence
standard
even
express
civil
remedies
circumstances
respect
certain
classes
defendants
congress
create
express
liability
predicated
upon
failure
exercise
reasonable
care
act
stat
amended
liability
experts
accountants
misleading
statements
portions
registration
statements
responsible
situations
good
faith
absolute
defense
act
stat
amended
misleading
statements
document
filed
pursuant
act
still
circumstances
congress
created
express
liability
regardless
defendant
fault
act
issuer
liability
misleading
statements
registration
statement
thus
evident
congress
fashioned
standards
fault
express
civil
remedies
acts
particularized
basis
ascertainment
congressional
intent
respect
standard
liability
created
particular
section
acts
must
therefore
rest
primarily
language
section
deal
judicially
implied
liability
statutory
language
certainly
less
important
view
language
clearly
connotes
intentional
misconduct
mindful
language
statute
controls
sufficiently
clear
context
oregon
packard
motor
car
nlrb
inquiry
may
unnecessary
turn
nevertheless
legislative
history
act
ascertain
whether
support
meaning
attributed
commission
respondents
although
extensive
legislative
history
act
bereft
explicit
explanation
congress
intent
think
relevant
portions
history
support
conclusion
addressed
practices
involve
element
scienter
read
impose
liability
negligent
conduct
alone
original
version
develop
act
contained
identical
bills
introduced
senator
fletcher
representative
rayburn
sess
sess
section
bills
present
evolved
proscribed
unlawful
use
device
contrivance
device
contrivance
way
manner
commission
may
rules
regulations
find
detrimental
public
interest
proper
protection
investors
subsections
proposed
listed
specific
practices
congress
empowered
commission
regulate
rulemaking
power
see
short
sale
order
soon
hearings
house
bill
held
substitute
bill
introduced
houses
abbreviated
modified
operative
language
read
manipulative
device
contrivance
see
still
third
bill
retaining
commission
power
regulate
specific
practices
enumerated
prior
bills
omitting
reference
commission
authority
prescribe
rules
concerning
manipulative
deceptive
devices
general
introduced
passed
house
final
language
modified
version
senate
amendment
last
house
bill
see
conf
neither
intended
scope
reasons
changes
operative
language
revealed
explicitly
legislative
history
act
deals
primarily
aspects
legislation
indication
however
intended
proscribe
conduct
involving
scienter
extensive
hearings
preceded
passage
act
touched
briefly
discussion
devoted
enumerated
devices
commission
empowered
proscribe
relevant
exposition
provision
become
thomas
corcoran
spokesman
drafters
corcoran
indicated
subsection
later
says
thou
shalt
devise
cunning
devices
course
subsection
clause
prevent
manipulative
devices
think
objection
kind
clause
commission
authority
deal
new
manipulative
devices
hearings
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
legislative
reports
address
scope
catchall
function
directly
considering
specific
manipulative
practices
left
commission
regulation
however
reports
indicate
liability
attach
absent
scienter
supporting
conclusion
congress
intended
lesser
standard
senate
report
discusses
generally
various
abuses
precipitated
need
legislation
inadequacy
stock
exchanges
report
analyzes
component
provisions
statute
parse
specific
reference
following
addition
discretionary
elastic
powers
conferred
administrative
authority
effective
regulation
must
include
several
clear
statutory
provisions
reinforced
penal
civil
sanctions
aimed
manipulative
deceptive
practices
demonstrated
fulfill
useful
function
sanctions
found
sections
investor
suffered
loss
reason
illicit
practices
equitable
allowed
recover
damages
guilty
party
bill
provides
person
unlawfully
manipulates
price
security
induces
transactions
security
means
false
misleading
statements
makes
false
misleading
statement
report
corporation
shall
liable
damages
bought
sold
security
prices
affected
violation
statement
case
burden
plaintiff
show
violation
fact
statement
false
misleading
relied
thereon
damage
defendant
may
escape
liability
showing
statement
made
good
faith
supra
emphasis
supplied
acts
constitute
interrelated
components
federal
regulatory
scheme
governing
transactions
securities
see
blue
chip
stamps
indicated
sec
national
securities
interdependence
various
sections
securities
laws
certainly
relevant
factor
interpretation
language
congress
chosen
recognizing
respondents
commission
contrast
sections
acts
support
contention
civil
liability
may
imposed
upon
proof
negligent
conduct
think
misconceive
significance
provisions
acts
commission
argues
congress
explicit
requiring
willful
conduct
standard
fault
intended
citing
act
stat
generally
proscribes
manipulation
securities
prices
sections
example
respectively
prohibit
manipulation
security
prices
purpose
creating
false
misleading
appearance
active
trading
security
respect
market
security
purpose
inducing
purchase
sale
security
others
see
also
section
imposes
upon
ny
person
willfully
participates
act
transaction
violation
provisions
civil
liability
anyone
purchased
sold
security
price
affected
manipulative
activities
commission
concludes
since
terms
explicitly
restricted
willful
knowing
purposeful
conduct
construed
cases
require
negligent
action
inaction
precondition
civil
liability
structure
acts
support
commission
argument
instance
congress
created
express
civil
liability
favor
purchasers
sellers
securities
clearly
specified
whether
recovery
premised
knowing
intentional
conduct
negligence
entirely
innocent
mistake
see
act
stat
amended
act
stat
amended
example
act
unambiguously
creates
private
action
damages
registration
statement
includes
untrue
statements
material
facts
fails
state
material
facts
necessary
make
statements
therein
misleading
within
limits
specified
issuer
securities
held
absolutely
liable
damages
resulting
misstatement
omission
experts
accountants
prepared
portions
registration
statement
accorded
due
diligence
defense
effect
negligence
standard
expert
may
avoid
civil
liability
respect
portions
registration
statement
responsible
showing
reasonable
investigation
reasonable
ground
believe
statements
responsible
true
omission
material
fact
see
escott
barchris
constr
supp
sdny
express
recognition
cause
action
premised
negligent
behavior
stands
sharp
contrast
language
significantly
undercuts
commission
argument
also
consider
significant
express
civil
remedies
act
allowing
recovery
negligent
conduct
see
subject
significant
procedural
restrictions
applicable
section
act
example
authorizes
require
plaintiff
bringing
suit
thereof
post
bond
costs
including
attorney
fees
specified
circumstances
assess
costs
conclusion
litigation
section
specifies
statute
limitations
one
year
time
violation
discovered
event
exceed
three
years
time
offer
sale
applicable
actions
brought
restrictions
significantly
imposed
amendments
act
adopted
part
act
prior
amendment
contained
provision
payment
costs
act
may
stat
see
act
june
stat
amendments
also
substantially
shortened
statute
limitations
provided
compare
stat
see
act
stat
think
procedural
limitations
indicate
judicially
created
private
damages
remedy
comparable
restrictions
extended
consistently
intent
congress
actions
premised
negligent
wrongdoing
extension
allow
causes
action
covered
brought
instead
thereby
nullify
effectiveness
carefully
drawn
procedural
restrictions
express
actions
see
fischman
raytheon
mfg
sec
texas
gulf
sulphur
friendly
concurring
rosenberg
globe
aircraft
supp
ed
loss
supra
jennings
marsh
securities
regulation
ed
unwilling
bring
result
absent
substantial
support
legislative
history
none
addressed
point
primarily
language
history
commission
contends
however
subsections
rule
cast
language
standing
alone
encompass
intentional
negligent
behavior
subsections
respectively
provide
unlawful
make
untrue
statement
material
fact
omit
state
material
fact
necessary
order
make
statements
made
light
circumstances
made
misleading
engage
act
practice
course
business
operates
operate
fraud
deceit
upon
person
viewed
isolation
language
subsection
arguably
subsection
read
proscribing
respectively
type
material
misstatement
omission
course
conduct
effect
defrauding
investors
whether
wrongdoing
intentional
note
first
reading
harmonized
administrative
history
rule
history
making
clear
commission
adopted
rule
intended
apply
activities
involved
scienter
importantly
rule
adopted
pursuant
authority
granted
commission
rulemaking
power
granted
administrative
agency
charged
administration
federal
statute
power
make
law
rather
power
adopt
regulations
carry
effect
congress
expressed
statute
dixon
quoting
manhattan
general
equipment
commissioner
thus
despite
broad
view
rule
advanced
commission
case
scope
exceed
power
granted
commission
congress
reasons
stated
think
commission
original
interpretation
rule
compelled
language
history
related
sections
acts
see
gerstle
lanza
drexel
sec
texas
gulf
sulphur
friendly
concurring
loss
supra
statute
speaks
specifically
terms
manipulation
deception
implementing
devices
contrivances
commonly
understood
terminology
intentional
wrongdoing
history
reflects
expansive
intent
quite
unwilling
extend
scope
statute
negligent
conduct
iii
recognizing
rule
might
held
require
proof
negligent
nonfeasance
ernst
ernst
precondition
imposition
civil
liability
respondents
contend
case
remanded
trial
whatever
standard
adopted
throughout
lengthy
history
case
respondents
proceeded
theory
liability
premised
negligence
specifically
disclaiming
ernst
ernst
engaged
fraud
intentional
misconduct
circumstances
think
inappropriate
remand
action
proceedings
judgment
appeals
reversed
footnotes
two
separate
substantially
identical
complaints
initially
filed
different
members
present
group
respondents
subsequently
respondents
jointly
filed
first
amended
complaint
two
cases
treated
district
consolidated
consolidated
formally
appeal
first
count
complaint
directed
exchange
charging
acts
omissions
aided
abetted
nay
fraud
summary
judgment
favor
exchange
affirmed
appeal
hochfelder
midwest
stock
exchange
cert
denied
immediately
nay
suicide
commission
commenced
receivership
proceedings
first
securities
proceedings
respondents
except
two
asserted
claims
based
fraudulent
escrow
accounts
claims
ultimately
allowed
sec
first
securities
cert
denied
held
nay
conduct
violated
rule
first
securities
liable
nay
fraud
aider
abettor
question
ernst
ernst
liability
considered
case
response
interrogatories
district
respondents
conceded
accuse
ernst
ernst
deliberate
intentional
fraud
merely
inexcusable
negligence
app
district
also
held
respondents
action
barred
doctrine
equitable
estoppel
applicable
illinois
statute
limitations
three
years
see
infra
customers
first
securities
respondents
sent
confirmation
forms
required
rule
requesting
verify
accuracy
statements
notify
ernst
ernst
exceptions
although
confirmation
forms
contained
reference
escrow
accounts
ernst
ernst
notified
fact
last
audit
first
securities
ernst
ernst
completed
december
first
complaint
action
filed
february
support
holding
appeals
cited
decision
hochfelder
midwest
stock
exchange
supra
detailed
elements
necessary
establish
claim
rule
based
defendant
aiding
abetting
securities
fraud
solely
inaction
see
supra
case
plaintiff
must
show
party
charged
aiding
abetting
knowledge
breach
duty
inquiry
knowledge
fraud
possessing
knowledge
party
failed
act
due
improper
motive
breach
duty
disclosure
explained
instant
case
elements
comprise
flexible
standard
liability
amplified
according
peculiarities
case
view
holding
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
required
civil
liability
rule
need
consider
whether
civil
liability
aiding
abetting
appropriate
section
rule
elements
necessary
establish
cause
action
see
brennan
midwestern
life
ins
supp
supp
nd
ind
aff
cert
denied
defendant
held
liable
giving
active
knowing
assistance
third
party
engaged
violations
securities
laws
see
generally
ruder
multiple
defendants
securities
law
fraud
cases
aiding
abetting
conspiracy
pari
delicto
indemnification
contribution
rev
see
supra
concluded
duty
inquiry
imposed
ernst
ernst
grounded
concern
protection
investors
respondents
without
reaching
question
whether
statute
imposed
direct
duty
respondents
held
ernst
ernst
owed
duty
inquiry
respondents
arising
contract
first
securities
since
ernst
ernst
specifically
foresee
respondents
limited
class
might
suffer
negligent
audit
compare
glanzer
shepard
ultramares
touche
see
rhode
island
hospital
trust
nat
bank
swartz
moreover
respondents
conceded
rely
financial
statements
reports
prepared
ernst
ernst
certificate
opinion
briefs
respondents
allude
several
alleged
failings
ernst
ernst
audit
first
securities
principally
failure
inquire
collectibility
certain
loans
first
securities
nay
failure
follow
memorandum
characterized
first
securities
overall
system
internal
control
weak
centralization
functions
cashier
appeals
mentioned
none
alleged
deficiencies
opinion
case
although
discuss
loans
nay
certain
related
matters
opinion
hochfelder
midwest
stock
exchange
holding
existence
facts
insufficient
put
exchange
notice
inquiry
first
securities
financial
affairs
required
appeals
also
reversed
district
holding
respect
equitable
estoppel
statute
limitations
see
supra
view
disposition
case
need
address
issues
although
verbal
formulations
standard
applied
varied
several
courts
appeals
held
substance
negligence
alone
sufficient
civil
liability
rule
see
white
abrams
flexible
duty
standard
myzel
fields
cert
denied
negligence
sufficient
kohler
kohler
knowledge
required
courts
appeals
held
type
scienter
intent
defraud
reckless
disregard
truth
knowing
use
practice
defraud
necessary
action
see
clegg
conk
cert
denied
element
scienter
conscious
fault
lanza
drexel
willful
reckless
disregard
truth
decisions
announcing
form
negligence
suffices
civil
liability
rule
actually
involved
negligent
conduct
smallwood
pearl
brewing
cert
denied
kohn
american
metal
climax
adams
concurring
dissenting
bucklo
scienter
rule
nw
rev
opinion
term
scienter
refers
mental
state
embracing
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
certain
areas
law
recklessness
considered
form
intentional
conduct
purposes
imposing
liability
act
need
address
question
whether
circumstances
reckless
behavior
sufficient
civil
liability
rule
since
case
concerns
action
damages
also
need
consider
question
whether
scienter
necessary
element
action
injunctive
relief
rule
cf
sec
capital
gains
research
bureau
respondents
contend
ernst
ernst
owed
direct
duty
act
rule
conduct
proper
audit
first
securities
may
base
private
cause
action
ernst
ernst
violation
duty
respondents
cause
action
however
premised
solely
alleged
violation
rule
lengthy
history
litigation
amended
original
complaint
aver
cause
action
rule
therefore
consider
claim
liability
properly
us
even
assuming
respondents
assert
claim
independently
see
note
implied
liability
securities
exchange
act
harv
rev
sec
release
may
birnbaum
newport
steel
cert
denied
kardon
national
gypsum
supp
ed
see
cases
cited
supra
compare
comment
scienter
rule
rev
note
negligent
misrepresentations
rule
chi
rev
note
securities
acts
harv
rev
note
civil
liability
section
rule
suggestion
replacing
doctrine
privity
yale
loss
securities
regulation
ed
commission
permit
recovery
upon
proof
negligence
cases
order
harmonize
civil
liability
express
civil
remedies
contained
acts
commission
limit
circumstances
civil
liability
imposed
negligent
violation
rule
situations
defendant
knew
reasonably
foresee
plaintiff
rely
conduct
ii
plaintiff
fact
rely
iii
amount
plaintiff
damages
caused
defendant
conduct
definite
ascertainable
brief
sec
amicus
curiae
commission
concludes
present
record
establish
conditions
since
ernst
ernst
reasonably
foreseen
financial
statements
first
securities
induce
respondents
invest
escrow
accounts
respondents
fact
rely
ernst
ernst
audits
amount
respondents
damages
unascertainable
respondents
accept
commission
basic
analysis
operative
language
statute
rule
reject
additional
requirements
recovery
negligent
violations
let
general
words
draw
nourishment
purpose
one
thing
draw
unexpressed
spirit
outside
bounds
normal
meaning
words
quite
another
legislation
expressed
technical
terms
addressed
common
run
men
therefore
understood
according
sense
thing
ordinary
man
right
rely
ordinary
words
addressed
addison
holly
hill
fruit
products
see
frankfurter
reflections
reading
statutes
rev
webster
international
dictionary
ed
defines
device
hat
devised
formed
design
contrivance
invention
project
scheme
often
scheme
deceive
stratagem
artifice
contrivance
pertinent
part
thing
contrived
used
contriving
scheme
plan
artifice
turn
contrive
pertinent
part
defined
devise
plan
plot
fabricate
design
invent
scheme
commission
also
ignores
use
terms
use
employ
language
supportive
view
congress
intend
embrace
negligent
conduct
webster
international
dictionary
supra
defines
manipulate
manage
treat
artfully
fraudulently
manipulate
accounts
exchanges
force
prices
matched
orders
wash
sales
fictitious
reports
rig
see
infra
see
supra
support
position
commission
cites
statements
corcoran
senate
hearings
modern
society
many
things
make
crimes
sheer
matters
negligence
intent
necessary
every
crime
hearings
subcommittee
stock
exchange
practices
senate
committee
banking
currency
comments
taken
context
shed
light
meaning
corcoran
remarks
made
discussion
whether
criminal
violations
arise
material
part
incorporated
act
absence
specific
intent
influence
security
prices
personal
gain
remarks
moreover
addressed
scope
general
observations
concerning
activity
society
might
proscribe
criminal
law
ferdinand
pecora
counsel
committee
draftsman
provident
securities
described
language
xcluding
scope
act
done
ulterior
motives
purposes
set
forth
act
hearings
subcommittee
stock
exchange
practices
supra
prior
passage
act
proposed
amended
require
willful
behavior
prerequisite
civil
liability
violations
compare
act
see
commission
also
relies
objections
draft
version
see
supra
raised
representatives
securities
industry
house
senate
hearings
warned
language
vague
commission
might
outlaw
anything
hearings
subcommittee
stock
exchange
practices
supra
hearings
house
committee
interstate
foreign
commerce
remarks
kind
made
course
legislative
debate
hearings
persons
responsible
preparation
drafting
bill
entitled
little
weight
see
mine
workers
wrightwood
dairy
especially
regard
statements
legislative
opponents
zeal
defeat
bill
understandably
tend
overstate
reach
nlrb
fruit
packers
see
schwegmann
calvert
distillers
wash
sales
transactions
involving
change
beneficial
ownership
matched
orders
orders
security
entered
knowledge
orders
substantially
size
substantially
time
price
entered
different
persons
security
section
act
proscribes
wash
sales
matched
orders
effectuated
purpose
creating
false
misleading
appearance
active
trading
security
registered
national
securities
exchange
respect
market
security
see
latimer
thornton
individuals
sign
registration
statement
directors
issuer
underwriter
securities
similarly
accorded
complete
defense
civil
liability
based
exercise
reasonable
investigation
reasonable
belief
registration
statement
misleading
see
feit
leasco
data
processing
equipment
supp
edny
underwriters
established
defense
see
generally
jennings
marsh
securities
regulation
ed
sources
cited
therein
folk
civil
liabilities
federal
securities
acts
barchris
case
rev
section
creates
potential
civil
liability
seller
securities
favor
purchaser
misleading
statements
omissions
connection
transaction
seller
exculpated
proves
know
exercise
reasonable
care
known
untruth
omission
section
act
amended
title
ii
act
makes
persons
control
person
liable
liable
jointly
severally
extent
controlled
person
unless
knowledge
reasonable
ground
believe
existence
facts
reason
liability
controlled
person
alleged
exist
see
act
june
stat
provisions
act
expressly
create
civil
liability
except
directed
specific
classes
individuals
directors
officers
beneficial
holders
securities
see
provident
securities
kern
county
land
occidental
petroleum
contains
condition
requiring
something
negligence
section
creates
potential
civil
liability
person
willfully
participates
manipulation
securities
national
exchange
section
creates
potential
civil
liability
misleading
statements
filed
commission
provides
defendant
defense
acted
good
faith
knowledge
statement
false
misleading
imposes
liability
upon
controlling
person
violations
act
control
exculpates
defendant
acted
good
faith
induce
act
constituting
violation
emphasizing
important
difference
operative
language
purpose
act
contrasted
however
courts
concluded
proof
scienter
unnecessary
action
damages
shareholder
recipients
materially
misleading
proxy
statement
issuer
corporation
gerstle
see
also
kohn
american
metal
climax
adams
concurring
dissenting
since
statute
limitations
provided
civil
actions
law
limitations
forum
state
followed
cases
judicially
implied
remedies
see
holmberg
armbrecht
cases
cited
therein
although
always
certain
state
statute
limitations
followed
statutes
limitations
usually
longer
period
provided
loss
supra
costs
see
infra
congress
regarded
restrictions
private
damages
actions
significant
introducing
title
ii
act
senator
fletcher
indicated
amendment
act
providing
potential
payment
costs
including
attorneys
fees
important
amendment
cong
rec
one
purposes
deter
actions
brought
solely
potential
settlement
value
see
ibid
conf
blue
chip
stamps
manor
drug
stores
deterrent
lacking
context
district
power
award
attorneys
fees
sharply
circumscribed
see
alyeska
pipeline
service
wilderness
society
bad
faith
requirement
rich
ex
rel
industrial
lumber
section
act
creates
private
cause
action
persons
accountants
make
cause
made
materially
misleading
statements
reports
documents
filed
commission
need
consider
question
whether
cause
action
may
maintained
basis
actions
constitute
violation
liability
extends
persons
reliance
statements
purchased
sold
security
whose
price
affected
statements
liability
limited
however
important
respect
defendant
accorded
defense
acted
good
faith
knowledge
statement
false
misleading
consistent
language
legislative
history
section
suggests
something
negligence
part
defendant
required
recovery
original
version
see
supra
provided
defendant
liable
acted
good
faith
exercise
reasonable
care
ground
believe
statement
false
misleading
accounting
profession
objected
provision
ground
liability
created
honest
errors
judgment
see
senate
hearings
stock
exchange
practices
supra
house
hearings
supra
subsequent
drafts
current
formulation
adopted
also
significant
actions
limited
relatively
short
statute
limitations
similar
provided
act
moreover
act
district
authorized
require
plaintiff
post
bond
costs
including
attorneys
fees
assess
costs
conclusion
litigation
apparently
rule
hastily
drafted
response
situation
clearly
involving
intentional
misconduct
commission
regional
administrator
boston
reported
director
trading
exchange
division
president
corporation
telling
shareholders
corporation
poorly
purchasing
shares
resultant
depressed
prices
fact
business
exceptionally
well
rule
drafted
approved
day
report
received
see
conference
codification
federal
securities
laws
bus
law
remarks
milton
freeman
one
rule
codrafters
blue
chip
stamps
supra
blackmun
dissenting
although
adopted
pursuant
language
rule
appears
derived
significant
part
act
blue
chip
stamps
supra
blackmun
dissenting
sec
texas
gulf
sulphur
friendly
concurring
cert
denied
sub
nom
coates
sec
indication
administrative
history
rule
subsections
intended
proscribe
conduct
involving
scienter
indeed
commission
release
issued
contemporaneously
rule
explained
securities
exchange
commission
today
announced
adoption
rule
prohibiting
fraud
person
connection
purchase
securities
previously
existing
rules
fraud
purchase
securities
applied
brokers
dealers
new
rule
closes
loophole
protections
fraud
administered
commission
prohibiting
individuals
companies
buying
securities
engage
fraud
purchase
sec
release
may
fiscal
year
commission
adopted
rule
additional
protection
investors
new
rule
prohibits
fraud
person
connection
purchase
securities
previously
existing
rules
fraud
purchase
securities
applied
brokers
dealers
annual
report
securities
exchange
commission
find
language
history
dispositive
appropriate
standard
liability
occasion
examine
additional
considerations
policy
set
forth
parties
may
influenced
lawmakers
formulation
statute
note
standard
urged
respondents
significantly
broaden
class
plaintiffs
may
seek
impose
liability
upon
accountants
experts
perform
services
express
opinions
respect
matters
acts
last
term
blue
chip
stamps
pertinently
observed
much
development
law
deceit
elimination
artificial
barriers
recovery
claims
first
express
concern
inexorable
broadening
class
plaintiff
may
sue
area
law
ultimately
result
harm
good
ultramares
touche
chief
judge
cardozo
observed
respect
liability
indeterminate
amount
indeterminate
time
indeterminate
class
hazards
business
conducted
terms
extreme
enkindle
doubt
whether
flaw
may
exist
implication
duty
exposes
consequences
see
supra
justice
blackmun
justice
brennan
joins
dissenting
see
blue
chip
stamps
manor
drug
stores
interprets
securities
exchange
act
securities
exchange
commission
rule
cfr
restrictively
narrowly
thereby
stultifies
recovery
victim
time
confining
statute
rule
situations
defendant
scienter
intent
deceive
manipulate
defraud
sheer
negligence
says
within
reach
statute
rule
contemplated
great
reforms
effectuated
congress
commission
perhaps
right
doubt
government
commission
doubt
evidenced
thrust
brief
filed
solicitor
general
behalf
commission
amicus
curiae
opinion
sure
certain
technical
consistency
seems
however
investor
victimized
much
negligent
conduct
positive
deception
logical
drive
wedge
two
saying
congress
clearly
intended
one
certainly
one
questions
fact
respondents
victims
intentional
securities
fraud
practiced
leston
nay
issue
course
petitioner
accountant
firm
involvement
firm
responsibility
rule
language
rule
making
unlawful
person
connection
purchase
sale
security
make
untrue
statement
material
fact
omit
state
material
fact
necessary
order
make
statements
made
light
circumstances
made
misleading
engage
act
practice
course
business
operates
operate
fraud
deceit
upon
person
motion
summary
judgment
therefore
respondents
allegations
view
sufficient
district
dismissal
action
improper
extent
dismissal
rested
proposition
suit
maintained
rule
mere
negligence
opposite
appears
true
least
second
circuit
respect
suits
sec
enjoin
violation
rule
sec
management
dynamics
sec
spectrum
sec
texas
gulf
sulphur
cert
denied
sub
nom
coates
sec
see
real
distinction
situation
one
surely
question
whether
negligent
conduct
violates
rule
depend
upon
plaintiff
identity
negligence
violation
factor
sec
sues
must
violation
factor
private
party
sues
present
posture
case
concerned
issue
violation
secondary
issue
private
party
judicially
created
entitlement
damages
specific
relief
see
rondeau
mosinee
paper
critical
importance
auditing
accountant
role
insuring
full
disclosure
overestimated
sec
emphasized
certifying
statements
accountant
duty
safeguard
public
interest
client
touche
niven
bailey
smart
complex
society
accountant
certificate
lawyer
opinion
instruments
inflicting
pecuniary
loss
potent
chisel
crowbar
benjamin
cert
denied
sub
nom
howard
light
initial
inquiry
whether
ernst
ernst
preparation
certification
financial
statements
first
securities
company
chicago
negligent
failure
perceive
nay
extraordinary
mail
rule
alleged
respects
thus
whether
rule
violated
thwarted
today
decides
thwarted
rests
congress
rephrase
investor
victims
ever
relief
federal
securities
laws
thought
enacted
broad
needed
deserving
benefit
understandably
resolve
number
issues
suggested
briefs
see
ante
view
result
reached
purpose
served
considering
issues
dissent