reese
argued
decided
october
reese
error
circuit
district
kentucky
case
argued
october
term
general
williams
phillips
henry
stanbery
buckner
defendants
chief
justice
waite
delivered
opinion
case
comes
hare
reason
division
opinion
judges
circuit
district
kentucky
presents
indictment
containing
four
counts
sects
act
may
stat
two
inspectors
municipal
election
state
kentucky
refusing
receive
count
election
vote
william
garner
citizen
african
descent
questions
presented
certificate
division
arose
upon
general
demurrers
several
counts
indictment
abandon
first
third
counts
expressly
waive
consideration
claims
arising
enforcement
fifteenth
amendment
constitution
concession
principal
question
left
consideration
whether
act
indictment
found
made
effective
punishment
inspectors
elections
refuse
receive
count
votes
citizens
qualifications
voters
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
congress
declared
act
done
within
state
crime
courts
power
treat
hudson
cranch
claimed
statute
reach
case
unless
one
question
looking
statute
find
first
section
provides
citizens
shall
otherwise
qualified
law
vote
election
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
thereat
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
constitution
state
contrary
notwithstanding
simply
declares
right
without
providing
punishment
violation
second
section
provides
punishment
officer
charged
duty
furnishing
citizens
opportunity
perform
act
constitution
laws
state
made
prerequisite
qualification
voting
shall
omit
give
citizens
equal
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
become
qualified
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
applicant
apply
include
inspectors
election
whose
duty
receive
count
votes
citizens
designated
law
voters
already
become
qualified
vote
election
third
section
effect
whenever
constitution
laws
state
act
shall
required
done
citizen
prerequisite
qualify
entitle
vote
offer
citizen
perform
act
required
done
aforesaid
shall
fail
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
offer
perform
acting
thereon
deemed
held
performance
law
act
person
offering
failing
aforesaid
otherwise
qualified
shall
entitled
vote
manner
extent
fact
performed
act
judge
inspector
officer
election
whose
duty
receive
count
give
effect
vote
citizen
shall
wrongfully
refuse
omit
receive
count
vote
citizen
upon
presentation
affidavit
stating
offer
time
place
thereof
name
person
officer
whose
duty
act
thereon
wrongfully
prevented
person
officer
performing
act
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
fourth
section
provides
punishment
person
shall
force
bribery
threats
intimidation
unlawful
means
hinder
delay
shall
combine
others
hinder
delay
prevent
obstruct
citizen
act
required
done
qualify
vote
voting
election
second
count
indictment
based
upon
fourth
section
act
fourth
upon
third
section
rights
immunities
created
dependant
upon
constitution
protected
congress
form
manner
protection
may
congress
legitimate
exercise
legislative
discretion
shall
provide
may
varied
meet
necessities
particular
right
protected
fifteenth
amendment
confer
right
suffrage
upon
one
prevents
however
giving
preference
particular
one
citizen
another
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
adoption
done
much
within
power
state
exclude
citizens
voting
account
race
account
age
property
education
citizens
one
race
certain
qualifications
permitted
law
vote
another
qualifications
must
previous
amendment
constitutional
guaranty
discrimination
follows
amendment
invested
citizens
new
constitutional
right
within
protecting
power
congress
right
exemption
discrimination
exercise
elective
franchise
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
express
provisions
second
section
amendment
congress
may
enforce
legislation
leads
us
inquire
whether
act
consideration
legislation
purpose
power
congress
legislate
upon
subject
voting
state
elections
rests
upon
amendment
effect
art
sect
constitution
respect
elections
senators
representatives
consideration
contended
amendment
confers
authority
impose
penalties
every
wrongful
refusal
receive
vote
qualified
elector
state
elections
wrongful
refusal
election
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
congress
interfere
provide
punishment
therefore
third
fourth
sections
act
beyond
limit
unauthorized
third
section
express
terms
limit
offence
inspector
elections
punishment
provided
wrongful
discrimination
account
race
conceded
urged
section
construed
precede
claimed
refers
limited
argument
wrongful
act
part
officer
whose
duty
receive
permit
requisite
qualification
dispense
actual
qualification
state
laws
substitute
prescribed
affidavit
therefor
mentioned
prohibited
sect
wit
discrimination
account
race
consequently
sect
confined
operation
wrongful
discrimination
penal
statute
must
construed
strictly
strictly
indeed
defeat
clear
intention
congress
words
employed
must
understood
sense
obviously
used
wiltberger
wheat
taking
whole
statute
together
apparent
intention
congress
thus
limit
operation
act
give
effect
statute
contemplates
important
change
election
laws
previous
adoption
general
rule
regulated
way
details
elections
prescribed
qualifications
voters
manner
offering
vote
election
make
known
qualifications
officers
charge
act
interferes
practice
prescribes
rules
provided
laws
substitutes
certain
circumstances
performance
wrongfully
prevented
performance
elector
makes
presents
affidavit
form
effect
prescribed
inspectors
treat
equivalent
specified
requirement
state
law
radical
change
practice
statute
creates
explicit
terms
nothing
left
construction
avoided
law
condition
elector
may
act
upon
one
idea
meaning
inspector
upon
another
elector
provisions
statute
required
state
affidavit
wrongfully
prevented
officer
qualifying
words
limitation
part
section
case
like
affidavit
language
statute
sufficient
voter
inspector
laws
prohibit
things
provide
punishment
violation
double
meaning
citizen
unnecessarily
placed
honest
error
construction
penal
statute
may
subjected
prosecution
false
oath
inspector
elections
put
jeopardy
equal
honesty
entertains
opposite
opinion
statute
limits
wrongful
act
justify
affidavit
discrimination
account
race
citizen
makes
affidavit
wrongfully
prevented
officer
true
ordinary
sense
term
subjects
indictment
trial
conviction
true
prevented
wrongful
act
statute
contemplated
limitation
wrongful
act
exclusion
justify
affidavit
give
right
vote
without
actual
performance
prerequisite
inspector
rejects
vote
reads
law
limited
sense
thinks
confined
wrongful
discrimination
account
race
subjects
prosecution
punishment
misconstrued
law
penal
statutes
expressed
language
uncertain
legislature
undertakes
define
statute
new
offence
provide
punishment
express
language
need
deceive
common
mind
every
man
able
know
certainty
committing
crime
go
beyond
third
section
read
fourth
find
words
limitation
reference
even
construed
manifesting
intention
confine
provisions
terms
fifteenth
amendment
section
object
punishment
persons
force
bribery
hinder
delay
person
qualifying
voting
view
facts
feel
compelled
say
opinion
language
third
fourth
sections
confine
operation
unlawful
discriminations
account
race
congress
power
provide
generally
punishment
unlawfully
interfere
prevent
exercise
elective
franchise
without
regard
discrimination
language
sections
broad
enough
purpose
remains
consider
whether
statute
general
provisions
made
available
punishment
may
guilty
unlawful
discrimination
citizens
exercising
elective
franchise
account
race
attempt
sections
consideration
provide
specifically
offence
case
provided
comes
general
prohibition
wrongful
act
unlawful
obstruction
particular
therefore
directly
called
upon
decide
whether
penal
statute
enacted
congress
limited
powers
general
language
broad
enough
cover
wrongful
acts
without
well
within
constitutional
jurisdiction
limited
judicial
construction
make
operate
congress
may
rightfully
prohibit
punish
purpose
must
take
sections
statute
able
reject
part
unconstitutional
retain
remainder
possible
separate
unconstitutional
proposed
effect
attained
striking
disregarding
words
section
inserting
sections
must
stand
whole
fall
altogether
language
plain
room
construction
unless
effect
constitution
question
determined
whether
introduce
words
limitation
penal
statute
make
specific
expressed
general
certainly
dangerous
legislature
set
net
large
enough
catch
possible
offenders
leave
courts
step
inside
say
rightfully
detained
set
large
extent
substitute
judicial
legislative
department
government
courts
enforce
legislative
ascertained
within
constitutional
grant
power
within
legitimate
sphere
congress
beyond
control
courts
steps
outside
constitutional
limitations
attempts
beyond
reach
courts
authorized
called
upon
due
course
legal
proceedings
must
annul
encroachments
upon
reserved
power
people
limit
statute
manner
asked
make
new
law
enforce
old
one
part
duty
must
therefore
decide
congress
yet
provided
legislation
punishment
offence
charged
indictment
circuit
properly
sustained
demurrers
gave
judgment
defendants
makes
unnecessary
answer
questions
certified
since
law
gives
presiding
judge
casting
vote
cases
division
authorizes
judgment
accordance
opinion
rev
sect
find
judgment
rendered
correct
need
bo
affirm
however
reverse
questions
certified
may
considered
final
determination
case
according
opinion
express
answered
judgment
affirmed
justice
clifford
justice
hunt
dissenting
justice
clifford
concur
indictment
bad
reasons
widely
different
assigned
well
prohibited
fifteenth
amendment
constitution
denying
abridging
right
citizens
vote
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
power
vested
congress
second
article
amendment
enforce
prohibition
appropriate
legislation
since
adoption
amendment
congress
legislated
upon
subject
first
section
enforcement
act
provided
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
shall
otherwise
qualified
vote
state
territorial
municipal
elections
entitled
allowed
vote
elections
constitution
law
custom
usage
regulalation
state
territory
authority
contrary
notwithstanding
beyond
doubt
section
forbids
discrimination
white
citizens
citizens
color
respect
right
vote
section
provide
person
officer
making
discrimination
shall
guilty
offence
prescribe
person
officer
guilty
making
discrimination
shall
subject
fine
penalty
punishment
whatever
none
counts
indictment
case
however
framed
section
necessary
give
consideration
except
far
may
aid
construction
sections
act
stat
sect
act
deserve
examination
assumes
certain
acts
may
required
done
authority
constitution
laws
certain
laws
certain
territories
prerequisite
qualification
voting
certain
persons
officers
may
constitution
laws
charged
performance
duties
furnishing
citizens
oopportunity
perform
prerequisites
become
qualified
vote
provides
shall
duty
every
person
officer
give
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
equal
opportunity
perform
prerequisites
become
qualified
vote
equal
opportunity
required
section
given
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
perform
described
prerequisite
provision
section
person
officer
charged
performance
described
duties
shall
refuse
knowingly
omit
give
full
effect
requirements
section
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
person
aggrieved
also
deemed
guilty
misdemeanor
punished
therein
provided
sections
applicable
subject
contained
enforcement
act
reference
hereafter
made
id
four
counts
exhibited
indictment
defendants
record
shows
defendants
filed
demurrer
counts
joined
behalf
two
wit
first
abandoned
argument
examination
confined
second
fourth
record
also
appears
defendants
together
one
william
farnaugh
january
lawful
inspectors
municipal
election
held
day
city
lexington
state
kentucky
pursuant
constitution
laws
state
inspectors
charged
law
duty
receiving
counting
certifying
registering
reporting
giving
effect
vote
citizens
qualified
vote
said
election
ward
city
accusation
set
forth
second
count
indictment
one
william
garner
said
municipal
election
offered
said
inspectors
polls
said
election
said
ward
vote
members
said
city
council
said
poll
lawful
proper
voting
place
precinct
said
william
garner
free
male
citizen
state
african
descent
resided
said
state
two
years
said
city
one
year
next
preceding
said
election
resident
said
voting
precinct
ward
offered
vote
sixty
days
immediately
prior
said
election
time
offer
vote
qualified
entitled
alleged
laws
state
vote
said
election
offer
due
form
vote
said
election
made
alleged
said
william
garner
charge
said
william
farnaugh
consented
receive
count
register
give
effect
vote
party
offering
defendants
constituting
majority
inspectors
election
power
receive
reject
votes
offered
said
poll
said
party
offered
vote
unlawfully
agree
confer
inspectors
take
receive
certify
register
report
give
effect
vote
voters
african
descent
offered
said
election
unless
voter
offering
vote
besides
otherwise
qualified
vote
paid
said
city
one
dollar
fifty
cents
preceding
year
january
prior
day
election
said
agreement
pleader
alleges
made
intent
thereby
hinder
prevent
obstruct
voters
african
descent
account
race
color
though
lawfully
entitled
vote
said
election
voting
taken
separately
allegation
afford
support
theory
must
considered
connection
allegation
immediately
follows
count
alleged
follows
defendants
pursuance
said
unlawful
agreement
election
aforesaid
wrongfully
illegally
require
demand
said
party
offered
vote
aforesaid
prerequisite
qualification
voting
said
election
produce
evidence
paid
said
city
proper
officers
said
one
dollar
fifty
cents
year
preceding
january
preceding
day
said
election
averment
effect
party
offering
vote
refused
comply
illegal
requirement
demand
produce
evidence
demanded
required
offences
created
statute
well
offences
created
common
law
rare
exceptions
consist
one
ingredient
cases
many
rule
universal
every
ingredient
offence
composed
must
accurately
clearly
alleged
indictment
indictment
bad
demurrer
may
quashed
motion
judgment
may
arrested
sentence
reversed
writ
error
cook
wall
matters
well
pleaded
true
admitted
demurrer
equally
true
every
ingredient
offence
must
accurately
clearly
described
indictment
sufficient
accurately
clearly
describe
ingredients
offence
composed
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
otherwise
qualified
vote
state
territorial
municipal
election
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
election
even
though
constitution
laws
customs
usages
regulations
state
territory
allow
even
prohibit
voter
exercising
right
stat
sect
evidently
purpose
section
place
male
citizen
color
elector
footing
white
male
citizen
nothing
else
intended
provision
evident
fact
profess
enlarge
vary
prior
existing
right
white
male
citizens
respect
whatever
conclusive
support
theory
also
derived
second
section
act
obviously
passed
enforce
obedience
rule
forbidding
discrimination
colored
male
citizens
white
male
citizens
respect
right
vote
elections
charter
city
lexington
provided
tax
shall
levied
free
male
inhabitant
years
age
upwards
except
paupers
inhabiting
said
city
ratio
exceeding
one
dollar
fifty
cents
sess
laws
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
order
may
entitled
vote
election
must
free
male
citizens
years
age
resident
city
least
six
months
ward
resides
least
sixty
days
prior
day
election
paid
assessed
city
january
preceding
day
election
sess
laws
white
male
citizens
possessing
qualifications
vote
required
law
find
guaranty
right
exercise
privilege
first
section
enforcement
act
mandate
section
explicit
imperative
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
otherwise
qualified
vote
state
territorial
municipal
election
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
elections
even
though
forbidden
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
constitution
state
laws
custom
usage
regulation
state
territory
election
held
disability
vote
every
kind
arising
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
declared
first
section
act
removed
colored
male
citizen
unless
otherwise
qualified
law
vote
election
entitled
enjoy
privilege
white
male
citizen
possess
qualifications
required
law
constitute
legal
voter
election
legal
disability
vote
election
arising
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
removed
fifteenth
amendment
affirmed
first
section
enforcement
act
congress
knew
full
well
cases
arise
want
qualifications
removed
might
prevent
colored
citizen
exercising
right
suffrage
election
intent
purpose
second
section
act
furnish
citizens
opportunity
remove
every
disability
enable
become
qualified
exercise
right
punish
persons
officers
charged
duty
regard
unlawfully
wrongfully
refuse
wilfully
omit
end
hence
provided
act
shall
required
done
prerequisite
qualification
voting
persons
officers
charged
manner
stated
performance
duties
furnishing
citizens
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
become
qualified
vote
shall
duty
every
person
officer
give
citizens
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
equal
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
become
qualified
vote
persons
officers
wrongfully
refuse
knowingly
omit
perform
duty
charged
clause
second
section
enforcement
act
commit
offence
defined
section
incur
penalty
subject
punishment
prescribed
offence
enough
appears
second
indictment
show
beyond
question
sustained
second
section
enforcement
act
count
expressly
alleges
defendants
inspectors
time
complaining
party
offered
vote
refused
receive
count
produce
evidence
paid
city
one
dollar
fifty
cents
assessed
preceding
year
payment
appears
law
state
prerequisite
necessary
qualification
enable
citizen
vote
election
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
express
allegation
count
party
offering
vote
refused
comply
prerequisite
demanded
vote
received
counted
without
complying
prerequisite
argument
show
allegations
insufficient
constitute
offence
defined
second
section
enforcement
act
section
act
quite
unnecessary
appears
terms
allegations
party
offering
vote
irrespective
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
qualified
voter
election
law
state
election
held
persons
within
category
described
first
section
enforcement
act
enacted
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
election
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
citizens
otherwise
qualified
vote
election
pending
inasmuch
alleged
count
party
offering
vote
case
otherwise
qualified
law
vote
time
offered
vote
inasmuch
excuse
pleaded
producing
evidence
establish
prerequisite
qualification
clear
supposed
offence
set
forth
sufficient
certainty
justify
conviction
sentence
accused
defects
also
exist
fourth
count
becomes
necessary
considering
questions
defects
present
examine
care
third
section
enforcement
act
sect
act
differs
respects
second
section
example
sect
provides
whenever
constitution
laws
state
laws
territory
act
shall
required
done
citizen
prerequisite
qualify
entitle
vote
offer
citizen
perform
act
required
done
aforesaid
shall
fail
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
aforesaid
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
offer
perform
deemed
held
performance
law
act
person
offering
failing
aforesaid
otherwise
qualified
shall
entitled
vote
manner
extent
fact
performed
said
act
clause
section
enacted
offer
party
interested
perform
prerequisite
act
qualify
entitle
vote
shall
fail
reason
specified
effect
actual
performance
prerequisite
act
provision
judge
inspector
officer
election
whose
duty
shall
receive
count
certify
register
report
give
effect
vote
citizen
upon
presentation
affidavit
stating
offer
time
place
thereof
name
officer
person
whose
duty
act
thereon
wrongfully
prevented
person
officer
performing
act
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
sum
dollars
person
aggrieved
also
guilty
misdemeanor
payment
january
preceding
day
election
beyond
doubt
one
prerequisite
acts
one
referred
part
section
equally
clear
introductory
clause
section
wholly
inapplicable
case
citizen
claiming
right
vote
election
actually
paid
required
election
law
state
voters
seasonably
paid
tax
need
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
qualify
vote
third
section
act
passed
provide
class
citizens
paid
tax
offered
pay
offer
failed
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
prerequisite
qualified
voters
law
state
male
citizens
years
age
residents
city
least
six
months
ward
reside
least
sixty
days
immediately
prior
day
election
paid
assessed
city
fifteenth
day
january
preceding
day
election
obviously
payment
time
mentioned
prerequisite
qualify
citizen
vote
purpose
second
section
secure
citizen
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
punish
persons
officers
charged
duty
furnishing
citizen
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
case
person
officer
refuses
knowingly
omits
duty
regard
grant
still
clear
punishment
offender
retroact
give
effect
right
citizen
vote
secure
public
right
vote
received
counted
registered
reported
made
effectural
election
injustice
kind
foreseen
might
done
remedy
difficulty
third
section
passed
purpose
provide
offer
citizen
perform
prerequisite
offer
fails
carried
exection
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
shall
deemed
held
performance
law
act
prerequisite
person
offering
perform
prerequisite
failing
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
otherwise
qualified
shall
entitled
vote
manner
extent
fact
performed
prerequisite
act
nothing
short
performance
prerequisite
act
entitle
citizen
vote
election
state
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
furnished
required
act
congress
whose
duty
furnish
opportunity
perform
act
refuse
omit
offer
perform
prerequisite
act
offer
fails
carried
execution
wrongful
act
omission
whose
duty
receive
permit
performance
prerequisite
act
shall
effect
law
actual
performance
offer
perform
effect
law
actual
performance
case
fails
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
follows
offer
must
made
terms
circumstances
received
carried
execution
constitute
legal
complete
performance
prerequisite
act
law
state
requires
regared
citizen
offering
vote
election
paid
assessed
city
case
one
dollar
fifty
cents
january
preceding
day
election
unless
offer
made
terms
circumstances
accepted
carried
execution
constitute
legal
complete
performance
prerequisite
act
person
officer
refused
omitted
carry
offer
execution
incur
penalty
guilty
offence
defined
section
act
properly
alleged
failed
carried
effect
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
viewed
light
suggestions
must
offer
contemplated
third
section
act
offer
made
terms
circumstances
accepted
carried
execution
person
officer
made
constitute
complete
performance
prerequisite
show
party
making
offer
otherwise
qualified
entitled
vote
election
evidence
entirely
wanting
show
authors
enforcement
act
ever
intended
abrogate
state
election
law
except
far
denies
abridges
right
citizen
vote
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
every
discrimination
account
forbidden
fifteenth
amendment
first
section
act
consideration
provides
remarked
citizens
otherwise
qualified
vote
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
constitution
law
contrary
notwithstanding
state
election
laws
creating
discriminations
superseded
regard
fifteenth
amendment
enforcement
act
furnishes
ground
infer
intended
annul
state
election
laws
respect
whatever
congress
intended
third
section
act
abrogate
election
law
state
creating
prerequisite
question
quite
clear
second
section
wholly
unnecessary
useless
regulation
provide
means
enable
citizens
comply
prerequisite
abrogated
treated
null
succeeding
section
statutes
interpreted
practicable
avoid
repugnancy
different
parts
give
sensible
intelligent
effect
every
one
provisions
ever
presumed
part
statute
supererogatory
without
meaning
potter
dwarris
difficulties
kind
avoided
held
second
section
enacted
afford
citizens
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
act
qualify
vote
punish
person
officer
refuses
knowingly
omits
perform
duty
furnishing
opportunity
intent
purpose
third
section
protect
citizens
consequences
wrongful
refusal
wilful
omission
person
officer
receive
give
effect
actuall
offer
citizen
perform
prerequisite
made
terms
circumstances
offer
accepted
carried
execution
whould
constitute
actual
complete
performance
act
made
prerequisite
right
voting
state
law
apply
suggestions
fourth
count
indictment
clear
allegations
regard
insufficent
describe
offence
defined
third
section
enforcement
act
beyond
doubt
general
rule
indictment
offence
created
statute
sufficient
describe
offence
words
statute
safe
admit
general
rule
supported
many
decided
cases
highest
authority
equally
certain
exceptions
exist
rule
well
established
rule
result
another
rule
criminal
pleading
framing
indictments
founded
upon
statutes
paramount
others
one
universal
application
every
ingredient
offence
must
accurately
clearly
expressed
words
indictment
must
contain
allegation
every
fact
legally
essential
punishment
inflicted
cook
wall
speaking
principle
bishop
says
pervades
entire
system
adjudged
law
criminal
procedure
appears
cases
wherever
move
department
jurisprudence
come
contact
escape
atmosphere
surrounds
us
bishop
cr
sect
archbold
crim
stark
crim
cr
law
rev
sect
steel
smith
barn
ald
examples
kind
held
exceptions
exist
rule
sufficient
indictment
founded
upon
statute
follow
words
statute
numerous
show
many
exceptions
become
extensively
recognized
firmly
settled
rule
pleading
criminal
law
moreover
says
bishop
must
averment
facts
shows
prima
facie
guilt
defendant
supposing
facts
set
true
possible
nonexistence
fact
mentioned
room
escape
prima
facie
conclusion
guilt
indictment
insufficient
exact
case
bishop
cr
sect
plain
says
learned
author
full
expression
given
statutory
terms
rules
relating
indictment
left
uncomplied
indictment
still
insufficient
must
added
conform
also
rules
consequently
general
doctrine
indictment
sufficient
follows
words
statute
creating
defining
offence
subject
exceptions
requiring
allegation
expanded
beyond
prohibiting
terms
sect
general
says
marshall
sufficient
libel
libel
information
charge
offence
words
direct
forfeiture
proposition
think
universally
true
words
describe
subject
law
general
think
charge
libel
conform
true
sense
meaning
words
used
legislature
mary
ann
wheat
similar
views
expressed
gooding
wheat
opinion
given
justice
story
first
stated
general
rule
sufficient
certainty
indictment
allege
offence
terms
statute
proceeds
remark
say
general
doubtless
cases
particularity
required
either
obvious
intention
legislature
application
known
principles
law
known
principles
law
require
particularity
case
order
ingredients
offence
may
accurately
clearly
alleged
equally
clear
intention
legislature
also
requires
thing
obvious
mere
statement
party
offered
perform
prerequisite
never
intended
made
equivalent
performance
unless
statement
accompanied
offer
pay
tax
circumstances
shown
ready
able
make
payment
authorities
necessary
prove
indictment
upon
statute
must
state
facts
circumstances
constitute
statute
offence
bring
party
indicted
precisely
within
provisions
statute
defining
offence
statutes
often
framed
says
colby
meet
relations
parties
prevent
frauds
one
upon
framing
statutes
language
used
often
elliptical
leaving
circumstances
expressive
relations
parties
supplied
intendment
construction
cases
facts
circumstances
constituting
relation
must
alleged
indictment
though
expressed
words
statute
colby
cr
law
people
wibur
park
cr
cas
com
cook
monr
pearce
state
sneed
people
stone
wend
whiting
state
anthony
state
cr
law
rev
sect
note
cases
cited
like
preceding
counts
preliminary
allegations
fourth
count
without
objection
jury
proceed
present
party
offering
vote
qualifications
age
citizenship
residence
required
state
law
thirtieth
day
january
order
might
become
qualified
vote
said
election
offer
collector
office
said
city
pay
tax
due
said
city
theretofore
assessed
said
city
assessed
said
city
said
city
said
collector
claimed
due
said
city
said
collector
wrongfully
refused
account
race
color
give
said
party
opportunity
pay
said
preceding
year
wrongfully
refused
receive
said
tax
said
party
order
might
become
qualified
vote
said
election
said
collector
given
citizens
white
race
opportunity
pay
taxes
due
said
city
order
might
become
qualified
purpose
alleged
may
admitted
yet
may
true
complaining
party
never
made
offer
time
place
mentioned
pay
one
dollar
fifty
cents
due
city
time
place
mentioned
terms
circumstances
offer
made
accepted
person
officer
offer
made
person
officer
done
every
thing
duty
every
thing
power
carry
effect
offer
constituted
performance
prerequisite
act
actual
payment
january
preceding
day
election
prerequisite
act
performed
qualify
citizen
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
vote
said
election
offer
therefore
order
may
deemed
held
performance
law
prerequisite
must
offer
pay
amount
party
making
offer
must
possess
ability
means
pay
amount
person
officer
offer
made
unless
payment
amount
tax
made
said
person
officer
authorized
discharge
tax
carry
offer
execution
without
violating
duty
city
readiness
pay
therefore
necessarily
implied
language
third
section
case
offer
fails
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
offer
deemed
held
performance
law
prerequisite
act
party
making
offer
ready
pay
tax
person
officer
offer
made
means
make
payment
held
offer
fails
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
offer
made
perversion
law
good
sense
hold
duty
person
officer
carry
offer
execution
discharging
tax
without
receiving
amount
tax
party
making
offer
performance
giving
full
effect
several
allegations
count
nothing
approximating
requirement
therein
alleged
thing
kind
implied
word
used
part
indictment
performance
prerequisite
citizens
otherwise
qualified
entitles
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
vote
election
offer
perform
offer
made
terms
circumstances
accepted
carried
execution
constitute
performance
also
entitle
citizens
vote
manner
extent
performed
prerequisite
provided
offer
fails
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
judges
inspectors
officers
elections
must
take
notice
provisions
constitute
essential
element
ingredient
offence
defined
third
section
act
officers
elections
whether
judges
inspectors
required
carry
regulations
full
effect
provision
judge
inspector
officer
election
whose
duty
shall
receive
count
certify
register
report
give
effect
vote
citizens
shall
wrongfully
refuse
omit
receive
count
certify
register
give
effect
vote
citizen
upon
presentation
affidavit
stating
offer
time
place
thereof
name
officer
person
whose
duty
act
offer
citizen
wrongfully
prevented
person
officer
performing
prerequisite
act
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
sum
person
aggrieved
also
guilty
misdemeanor
fined
imprisoned
therein
provided
course
must
assumed
terms
affidavit
exactly
set
forth
third
count
indictment
follows
word
used
affidavit
must
receive
construction
already
given
word
part
section
provides
offer
fail
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
shall
deemed
held
performance
law
prerequisite
act
decisive
confirmation
view
derived
fact
complaining
party
required
state
affidavit
offer
time
place
thereof
name
person
officer
whose
duty
act
thereon
affiant
wrongfully
prevented
person
officer
performing
prerequisite
act
none
deny
presumed
word
affidavit
means
thing
word
used
declaratory
part
section
must
held
offer
described
affidavit
must
one
made
terms
circumstances
offer
accepted
might
carried
execution
person
officer
made
words
must
offer
whatever
necessary
perform
prerequisite
act
follows
word
used
act
congress
necessarily
includes
readiness
pay
tax
equally
clear
affidavit
contain
statement
plainly
must
unless
offer
scope
failed
carried
execution
held
failure
wrongful
act
omission
person
officer
offer
made
construction
must
erroneous
adopted
lead
consequences
shock
publice
sense
require
collector
discharge
tax
without
payment
manifest
violation
duty
taken
point
view
clear
third
count
indictment
vague
uncertain
indefinite
allegations
constitute
proper
foundation
conviction
sentence
defendants
even
suppose
signification
word
sufficiently
comprehensive
include
readiness
perform
explicitly
denied
still
clear
offer
pleaded
fourth
count
season
constitute
compliance
prerequisite
qualification
reason
state
statute
requires
shall
paid
fifteenth
day
january
preceding
day
election
come
conclusions
necessary
examine
fourth
section
enforcement
act
reason
obvious
without
much
examination
one
counts
indictment
sufficient
warrant
conviction
sentence
defendants
offence
defined
section
justice
hunt
compelled
dissent
judgment
case
defendants
indicted
circuit
district
kentucky
upon
trial
defendants
judgment
discharged
indictment
account
alleged
insufficiency
fourth
count
indictment
contains
allegations
concerning
election
city
lexington
statute
kentucky
entitle
one
vote
election
state
voter
must
possess
certain
qualifications
recited
paid
tax
assessed
city
lexington
james
robinson
collector
said
city
entitled
collect
said
tax
garner
order
might
entitled
vote
offer
said
robinson
office
pay
assessed
claimed
robinson
refused
receive
tax
account
race
color
garner
time
election
necessary
qualifications
garner
offered
vote
time
presented
affidavit
inspector
stating
offer
aforesaid
made
robinson
particulars
required
statute
refusal
robinson
receive
tax
farnaugh
consented
receive
vote
defendants
constituting
majority
inspectors
wrongfully
refused
receive
refusal
account
race
color
said
garner
indictment
based
upon
act
congress
may
stat
first
four
sections
act
follows
citizens
shall
otherwise
qualified
law
vote
election
people
state
territory
district
county
city
parish
township
school
district
municipality
territorial
subdivision
shall
entitled
allowed
vote
elections
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
constitution
law
custom
usage
regulation
state
territory
authority
contrary
notwithstanding
authority
constitution
laws
state
laws
territory
act
shall
required
done
prerequisite
qualification
voting
constitution
laws
persons
officers
shall
charged
performance
duties
furnishing
citizens
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
become
qualified
vote
shall
duty
every
person
officer
give
citizens
equal
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
become
qualified
vote
without
distinction
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
person
officer
shall
refuse
knowingly
omit
give
full
effect
section
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
sum
person
aggrieved
thereby
recovered
action
case
full
costs
allowance
shall
deem
shall
also
every
offence
deemed
guilty
misdemeanor
shall
conviction
thereof
fined
less
five
hundred
dollars
imprisoned
less
one
month
one
year
discretion
whenever
authority
constitution
laws
state
laws
territory
act
shall
required
done
citizen
prerequisite
qualify
entitle
vote
offer
citizen
perform
act
required
done
aforesaid
shall
fail
carried
execution
reason
wrongful
act
omission
aforesaid
person
officer
charged
duty
receiving
permitting
performance
offer
perform
acting
thereon
deemed
held
performance
law
act
person
offering
failing
aforesaid
otherwise
qualified
shall
entitled
vote
manner
extent
fact
performed
act
judge
inspector
officer
election
whose
duty
shall
receive
count
certify
register
report
give
effect
vote
citizen
shall
wrongfully
refuse
omit
receive
count
certify
register
report
give
effect
vote
citizen
upon
presentation
affidavit
stating
offer
time
place
thereof
name
officer
person
whose
duty
act
thereon
wrongfully
prevented
person
officer
performing
act
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
sum
person
aggrieved
thereby
recovered
action
case
full
costs
allowance
shall
deem
shall
also
every
offence
guilty
misdemeanor
shall
conviction
thereof
fined
less
imprisoned
less
one
month
one
year
discretion
person
force
bribery
threats
intimidation
unlawful
means
shall
hinder
delay
prevent
obstruct
shall
combine
confederate
others
hinder
delay
prevent
obstruct
citizen
act
required
done
qualify
vote
voting
election
aforesaid
person
shall
every
offence
forfeit
pay
sum
person
aggrieved
thereby
recovered
action
case
full
costs
allowance
shall
deem
shall
also
every
offence
deemed
guilty
misdemeanor
shall
conviction
thereof
fined
less
imprisoned
less
one
month
one
year
discretion
said
opposition
indictment
hostility
statute
drawn
second
section
makes
penal
offence
officer
refuse
opportunity
perform
prerequisite
therein
referred
account
race
color
party
therefore
indictment
officer
may
good
violation
fifteenth
amendment
third
section
relates
inspectors
elections
omits
reference
race
color
therefore
indictment
sustained
officers
said
congress
power
punish
violation
rights
elector
generally
violation
attributable
race
color
condition
said
also
prohibition
act
congress
general
language
prohibition
act
account
race
color
hence
insisted
statute
indictment
insufficient
understand
basis
opinion
majority
observe
intention
congress
subject
plain
discussed
fifteenth
amendment
adopted
object
secure
lately
enslaved
population
protection
violations
right
vote
account
color
previous
condition
act
entitled
act
enforce
right
citizens
vote
several
union
purposes
first
section
contains
general
announcement
right
embarrassed
fact
race
color
previous
condition
second
section
requires
equal
opportunity
shall
given
races
providing
every
prerequisite
voting
officer
violates
provision
shall
subject
civil
damages
extent
fine
imprisonment
suppose
congress
making
provisions
intended
impose
duty
upon
subject
penalty
officers
perfect
exercise
right
vote
wit
inspectors
receive
reject
votes
quite
absurd
garner
citizen
african
descent
offered
collector
taxes
pay
existing
claimed
exist
prerequisite
voting
election
held
city
lexington
thirtieth
day
january
collector
illegally
refused
allow
garner
account
race
color
make
payment
brought
garner
case
within
terms
third
section
statute
person
offering
failing
made
offer
illegally
rejected
account
race
entitled
vote
fact
performed
act
made
affidavit
setting
forth
facts
stating
particularity
required
statute
wrongfully
prevented
paying
tax
presented
inspector
wrongfully
refused
receive
permit
vote
account
race
color
wrongful
refusal
receive
vote
fact
incompetent
reason
act
account
race
color
inspector
within
statutory
provisions
respecting
race
color
words
aforesaid
provisions
respecting
race
color
first
second
sections
statute
incorporated
made
part
third
fourth
sections
illustrate
sect
enacts
person
unlawful
means
shall
hinder
prevent
citizen
voting
election
aforesaid
shall
subject
fine
imprisonment
words
aforesaid
mean
mean
causes
pretences
upon
grounds
first
second
sections
mentioned
account
race
color
person
prevented
necessary
words
expression
incorporated
fourth
section
true
words
wrongful
act
omission
aforesaid
person
offering
failing
aforesaid
third
section
application
words
aforesaid
become
pertinent
pointed
unless
construed
wholly
absolutely
without
meaning
meaning
possibly
given
person
garner
offering
failing
aforesaid
shall
entitled
vote
performed
act
failed
aforesaid
account
race
inspectors
thereupon
refused
receive
vote
paid
race
color
prevented
payment
words
prevented
voting
aforesaid
fourth
section
third
section
words
refuse
aforesaid
sufficiently
accomplish
purpose
statute
amount
enactment
refusal
receive
vote
account
race
color
shall
punished
third
fourth
sections
declared
better
satisfied
construction
statute
looking
senate
debates
time
passage
find
attention
called
point
whether
act
make
offence
dependent
race
color
previous
condition
conceded
charge
bill
language
must
embrace
class
cases
satisfied
bill
stood
appears
act
considering
particularity
required
indictment
statutory
description
offences
times
extreme
distinctions
almost
ridiculous
think
cases
good
sense
sacrificed
technical
nicety
sound
principle
carried
extravagant
extent
object
indictment
apprise
accused
charged
object
statute
declare
define
offence
intended
made
punishable
laid
charge
absolute
perpetration
offence
primary
characteristic
lies
intent
instigation
motives
party
towards
perpetration
acts
accused
important
developing
mala
mens
constituting
crime
need
spread
upon
record
almeida
whart
prec
note
whart
note
case
us
acts
constituting
offence
spread
indictment
alleged
defects
facts
constituting
mala
mens
refusal
receive
affidavit
evidence
tax
paid
garner
rejection
vote
essential
acts
defendants
constitute
guilt
rest
matter
motive
instigation
extreme
particularity
strict
construction
expected
indictments
penal
statutes
seem
necessary
sickles
sharp
johns
said
rule
penal
statutes
strictly
construed
admits
qualification
plain
manifest
intention
legislature
regarded
hartwell
wall
said
object
construing
penal
well
statutes
ascertain
legislative
intent
words
must
narrowed
exclusion
legislature
intended
embrace
intention
must
gathered
words
words
general
embrace
various
classes
persons
authority
restrict
one
class
purpose
alike
applicable
ogden
strong
paine
said
must
construed
make
parts
harmonize
give
sensible
effect
presumed
legislature
meant
part
statute
without
meaning
effect
morris
pet
statute
made
unlawful
person
serve
vessel
employed
made
use
transportation
slaves
one
foreign
country
another
slaves
actually
received
transported
board
defendant
vessel
held
words
statute
embraced
case
vessel
sailing
intent
employed
say
penal
statute
extended
beyond
plain
meaning
words
yet
evident
intention
legislature
defeated
forced
overstrict
construction
case
donna
mariana
dods
vessel
condemned
sir
william
scott
english
statute
condemning
vessels
slaves
exported
transported
carried
although
outward
voyage
never
taken
slave
board
result
general
intent
statute
prevent
certain
acts
subordinate
proceedings
necessarily
connected
coming
within
intent
embraced
provisions
id
hodgman
people
den
id
act
subjecting
offender
penalties
prior
act
held
subject
indictment
well
pecuniary
penalties
prior
statute
provided
especially
liberal
rule
construction
prevail
though
form
statute
penal
fact
protect
freedom
examination
surrounding
circumstances
knowledge
evil
intended
prevented
clear
statement
statute
acts
prohibited
made
punishable
certain
knowledge
legislative
intention
furnish
rule
language
statute
us
construed
motives
instigating
acts
forbidden
acts
brought
within
jurisdiction
federal
authority
need
set
forth
technical
minuteness
reference
made
intent
fully
set
forth
second
section
held
references
third
fourth
sections
motives
instigations
declared
second
section
incorporated
became
part
third
fourth
sections
sufficient
offence
authority
therein
stated
hold
therefore
third
fourth
sections
statute
considering
provide
punishment
inspectors
elections
refuse
votes
qualified
electors
account
race
color
indictment
sufficient
statute
sufficiently
describes
offence
opinion
majority
discusses
subjects
except
sufficiency
indictment
validity
act
may
holding
valid
law
upon
crime
charged
predicated
became
unnecessary
opinion
discuss
points
held
indictment
good
statute
created
offence
charged
question
arisen
whether
statute
constitutional
question
much
larger
part
argument
counsel
cause
directed
conclusions
reached
correct
question
directly
presents
trust
unbecoming
views
upon
constitutional
points
thus
arising
set
forth
warrant
say
views
entertained
associates
opinions
arguments
writer
question
constitutionality
act
may
arises
mainly
upon
fifteenth
amendment
constitution
follows
right
citizens
vote
shall
denied
abridged
state
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
congress
shall
power
enforce
article
appropriate
legislation
observe
first
place
right
protected
behalf
particular
class
persons
wit
citizens
limitation
persons
concerned
class
cases
question
shall
arise
right
citizens
vote
right
vote
election
officers
subject
provision
person
protected
must
citizen
whenever
right
vote
exists
person
case
within
amendment
literal
grammatical
construction
language
intention
congress
appear
many
considerations
originally
introduced
mr
senator
henderson
read
state
shall
deny
abridge
right
citizens
vote
hold
office
account
race
color
previous
condition
globe
pt
judiciary
committee
reported
back
resolution
right
citizens
vote
hold
office
shall
denied
abridged
state
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
congress
appropriate
legislation
may
enforce
provisions
article
id
omitting
words
hold
office
form
adopted
class
persons
indicated
original
resolution
protected
described
citizens
state
resolution
reported
committee
citizens
neither
resolution
limitations
character
elections
vote
given
right
vote
person
offering
vote
citizen
clause
attached
illiberal
illogical
say
protection
intended
limited
election
particular
officers
wit
take
part
affairs
federal
government
congress
completing
third
series
amendments
intended
protect
rights
newly
emancipated
freedmen
south
adoption
thirteenth
amendment
slavery
involuntary
servitude
exist
within
place
subject
jurisdiction
took
first
great
step
protection
confirmation
political
rights
class
persons
adoption
fourteenth
amendment
persons
born
naturalized
subject
jurisdiction
thereof
citizens
reside
state
shall
make
enforce
law
shall
abridge
privileges
immunities
citizens
shall
state
deprive
person
life
liberty
property
without
due
process
law
deny
person
within
jurisdiction
equal
protection
laws
strong
measure
direction
taken
higher
privilege
yet
untouched
security
vastly
greater
thus
far
given
colored
race
provided
contrary
exclusion
permitted
elective
franchise
right
vote
elections
country
officers
country
governed
second
section
fourteenth
amendment
state
power
refuse
right
voting
elections
class
persons
consequence
reduction
representation
congress
proportion
excluded
class
bear
whole
number
male
citizens
age
years
understood
mean
mean
one
late
slaveholding
desire
exclude
colored
population
right
voting
expense
reducing
representation
congress
existence
large
colored
population
southern
lately
slaves
necessarily
ignorant
disturbing
element
affairs
overlooked
confronted
us
always
everywhere
congress
determined
meet
emergency
creating
political
equality
conferring
upon
freedmen
political
rights
possessed
white
inhabitants
state
believed
newly
enfranchised
people
effectually
secured
protection
rights
life
liberty
pursuit
happiness
giving
greatest
rights
among
freemen
ballot
hence
fifteenth
amendment
passed
congress
adopted
power
state
deprive
citizen
right
vote
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
impede
obstruct
right
account
expressly
negatived
declared
right
citizen
thus
denied
abridged
persons
affected
citizens
subject
right
persons
vote
specified
elections
specified
officers
federal
officers
state
officers
right
vote
broadest
terms
citizen
country
nearly
every
thing
submitted
popular
test
office
eagerly
sought
possesses
right
vote
holds
powerful
instrument
advantage
political
personal
importance
large
bodies
emigrants
among
us
intrusted
early
period
right
vote
well
known
every
man
observation
far
ballot
freedman
abridged
degree
importance
security
diminished
state
rights
municipal
rights
touch
numerous
affairs
life
federal
government
less
numerous
men
less
important
congress
possessing
making
constitutional
amendment
unlimited
power
propose
intended
confine
great
guaranty
single
class
elections
wit
elections
officers
scarcely
credited
hold
therefore
fifteenth
amendment
embraces
case
elections
held
state
municipal
well
federal
officers
first
section
act
may
wherein
right
vote
freed
restriction
reason
race
color
condition
elections
people
county
town
municipal
subdivision
justified
constitution
contended
also
case
us
denial
abridgment
state
kentucky
right
garner
vote
election
question
state
said
statute
authorized
vote
illegally
prevented
voting
unauthorized
illegal
act
inspectors
word
sometimes
people
community
individuals
less
closely
political
relations
inhabiting
temporarily
permanently
country
often
denotes
country
territorial
region
inhabited
community
unfrequently
applied
government
people
live
times
represents
combined
idea
people
territory
government
difficult
see
senses
primary
conception
people
community
people
whatever
territory
dwelling
either
temporarily
permanently
whether
organized
regular
government
looser
less
definite
relations
constitute
state
constitution
term
frequently
expresses
combined
idea
noticed
people
territory
government
state
ordinary
sense
constitution
political
community
free
citizens
occupying
territory
defined
boundaries
organized
government
sanctioned
limited
written
constitution
established
consent
governed
union
common
constitution
forms
distinct
greater
political
unit
constitution
designates
makes
people
compose
one
people
one
country
texas
white
wall
word
confined
meaning
legislative
power
community
evident
authority
cited
reference
various
places
used
constitution
referred
power
congress
commerce
among
several
sect
subd
refers
commerce
inhabitants
different
transactions
political
organizations
called
people
state
intended
word
numerous
cases
provision
considered
cases
questions
arose
upon
individual
transactions
citizens
different
rights
upon
territory
different
bound
one
state
shall
obliged
enter
clear
pay
duties
another
sect
subd
refers
region
locality
electors
president
shall
meet
respective
vote
art
sect
subd
ordained
judicial
power
shall
extend
controversies
two
state
citizens
another
state
citizens
different
citizens
state
claiming
lands
grants
different
state
citizens
thereof
foreign
citizens
subjects
art
sect
subd
find
different
meaning
attached
word
different
parts
sentence
controversy
two
spoken
refers
political
organizations
known
controversy
state
citizens
another
state
refers
political
organization
party
persons
living
within
locality
citizens
composing
second
party
may
reside
controversy
citizens
different
citizens
state
claiming
lands
grants
different
refers
local
region
territory
described
first
branch
sentence
political
organization
grantor
second
branch
faith
credit
shall
given
state
public
acts
records
judicial
proceedings
every
state
art
sect
full
faith
shall
given
throughout
territory
state
sovereign
state
agencies
authorities
faith
credit
given
acts
political
organization
known
state
agencies
acts
executive
acts
courts
record
expression
connection
refers
includes
agencies
agencies
legislation
congress
authority
directed
question
arising
upon
agencies
courts
questions
judicially
presented
hampton
mcconnell
wheat
green
sacramento
bank
alabama
dalton
judicial
proceedings
state
mean
proceedings
courts
state
never
doubted
constitutional
authority
provide
credit
given
records
lawful
provide
credit
given
records
courts
state
purpose
state
provision
shall
guarantee
every
state
republican
form
government
guaranty
people
state
may
exercised
favor
political
power
called
seems
plain
constitution
speaks
state
prescribes
may
may
includes
cases
agencies
instrumentalities
state
acts
intended
prohibition
shall
upon
legislative
action
expressed
thus
art
sect
subd
provided
state
shall
pass
bill
attainder
ex
post
facto
law
law
impairing
obligation
contracts
provision
state
shall
impair
obligation
contracts
state
shall
pass
law
impairing
obligation
contracts
word
fifteenth
amendment
construed
paragraph
heretofore
quoted
respecting
commerce
among
declares
acts
state
shall
receive
full
faith
credit
every
state
include
acts
proceed
authority
state
political
organization
called
act
agents
may
act
convention
legislature
governor
magistrates
officers
lower
degree
whoever
authorized
wield
power
state
state
whether
acts
within
powers
exceeds
convention
state
kentucky
ordain
legislature
enact
person
african
descent
formerly
slave
entitled
vote
elections
ordinance
law
void
excess
power
body
enacting
possess
validity
whatever
doubted
however
afford
ground
jurisdiction
courts
fifteenth
amendment
state
speaks
acts
agents
although
agents
exercise
powers
possess
state
possess
although
action
illegal
inspectors
elections
represent
state
exercise
whole
power
state
creating
actual
government
reception
votes
declaration
results
votes
wilfully
corruptly
receive
illegal
votes
reject
legal
votes
make
false
certificates
usurper
obtains
office
act
case
act
state
result
must
abided
corrected
action
courts
matter
erroneous
illegal
corrupt
may
action
upon
subject
appointed
manage
binds
parties
action
state
legal
measures
taken
annul
authorized
state
act
premises
act
contrary
instructions
duty
nevertheless
officers
state
acting
upon
subject
committed
state
acts
state
legislature
speaks
officers
act
voice
act
equally
state
opinion
therefore
refusal
defendants
inspectors
elections
receive
vote
garner
refusal
state
kentucky
denial
state
within
meaning
fifteenth
amendment
right
vote
contended
congress
power
enforce
provisions
amendment
enactment
penal
laws
power
enforcement
provided
limited
correcting
erroneous
decisions
state
presented
federal
courts
appeal
writ
error
example
said
declared
state
shall
deprive
person
life
liberty
property
without
due
process
law
declaration
intended
guaranty
commission
murder
false
imprisonment
robbery
crimes
committed
individual
malefactors
give
congress
power
pass
laws
punishment
crimes
several
generally
far
act
may
shall
held
include
cases
dependent
upon
race
color
previous
condition
far
power
impose
pains
penalties
offences
may
arise
called
upon
discuss
subject
far
argument
applied
legislation
offences
committed
account
race
color
hold
entirely
unsound
sound
brings
impotent
conclusion
vigorous
amendments
subject
slavery
protection
ignorant
freedman
hostile
legislation
personal
prejudice
tedious
expensive
uncertain
course
litigation
state
courts
thence
appeal
writ
error
federal
courts
practically
remedy
well
amendments
passed
rights
infringed
one
thousand
remedied
protected
process
adopting
fifteenth
amendment
ordained
second
section
thereof
congress
shall
power
enforce
article
appropriate
legislation
done
remove
doubts
existed
former
power
add
least
weight
repetition
existing
power
held
bank
cases
cases
mccullough
maryland
wheat
gibbons
ogden
id
new
york
miln
pet
knox
lee
wall
dooley
smith
id
congress
determine
whether
necessity
arisen
called
action
congress
adjudges
necessities
country
require
establishment
bank
issue
notes
judgment
conclusive
upon
within
power
review
congress
authorized
desires
protect
freedman
rights
citizen
voter
may
prejudiced
unscrupulous
hostility
newly
conferred
rights
manifest
course
enact
possess
right
provide
facilities
exercise
appointing
proper
superintendents
special
officers
examine
alleged
abuses
giving
jurisdiction
federal
courts
providing
punishment
interfere
right
countries
abound
laws
punishment
violate
rights
others
either
property
person
much
trespassers
may
punished
peaceable
citizen
may
protected
punishment
means
protection
end
arrest
conviction
sentence
imprisonment
one
inspector
refused
vote
person
african
descent
account
race
effectually
secure
right
voter
number
civil
suits
state
courts
prosecuted
timid
ignorant
penniless
parties
possessing
wealth
influence
sentiment
community
certain
fact
legislation
taken
congress
considering
appropriate
effectual
means
enforcing
amendment
legislation
respect
constitutional
also
proved
previous
action
congress
art
sect
subd
constitution
provides
follows
person
held
service
labor
one
state
laws
thereof
escaping
another
shall
consequence
law
regulation
therein
discharged
service
labor
shall
delivered
claim
party
service
labor
may
due
time
adoption
constitution
containing
provision
slavery
recognized
legal
many
rights
slaveholder
slave
intended
protected
clause
enforce
protection
congress
time
time
passed
laws
providing
means
restoring
escaped
slave
master
inflicting
punishment
upon
violated
master
rights
thus
early
congress
enacted
master
agent
might
seize
arrest
fugitive
slave
upon
obtaining
certificate
judge
magistrate
carry
back
state
whence
escaped
return
slavery
every
person
hindered
obstructed
master
agent
harbored
concealed
fugitive
notice
subject
damages
penalty
recovered
benefit
claimant
proper
try
stat
act
stat
circuit
courts
ordered
enlarge
number
commissioners
view
afford
reasonable
facilities
reclaim
fugitives
labor
ninth
section
act
provided
person
wilfully
obstruct
hinder
removal
fugitive
either
without
process
rescue
aid
abet
attempt
escape
harbor
conceal
fugitive
notice
either
said
offences
subject
fine
exceeding
imprisonment
exceeding
six
months
indictment
conviction
shall
pay
forfeit
way
civil
damages
party
injured
illegal
conduct
sum
fugitive
lost
aforesaid
recovered
action
debt
prigg
pennsylvania
pet
legislation
held
valid
held
sims
case
cush
act
constitutional
state
tribunals
writ
habeas
corpus
interfere
federal
authorities
acting
upon
cases
arising
act
ableman
booth
held
act
constitutional
provisions
habeas
corpus
state
laws
must
obeyed
authority
must
executed
case
prigg
decided
act
booth
act
pertinent
present
question
former
case
held
act
far
authorized
owner
seize
recapture
slave
state
union
requiring
aid
legislation
either
state
national
clause
relating
fugitive
slaves
said
found
national
state
constitution
said
necessary
conclusion
absence
positive
provision
contrary
national
government
bound
departments
legislative
judicial
executive
carry
effect
rights
duties
imposed
upon
constitution
doctrine
useful
present
time
pertinent
point
considering
clause
protecting
freedmen
like
sustaining
rights
slaveholders
found
federal
constitution
like
former
provides
means
enforcing
authority
fines
imprisonments
federal
courts
national
government
bound
departments
carry
effect
rights
duties
imposed
upon
constitution
connection
clause
constitution
quoted
found
express
authority
congress
enforce
appropriate
legislation
yet
decide
congress
power
enforce
provisions
fine
imprisonment
right
legislate
subject
belongs
congress
exclusively
courts
ready
apply
sound
principles
constitution
provision
contitution
decisions
seem
furnish
rule
deciding
constitutionality
law
question
rather
provides
life
liberty
property
shall
interfered
except
due
process
law
necessary
consider
far
congress
may
legislate
upon
individual
crimes
provision
right
view
legislation
wit
enforcement
fifteenth
amendment
means
penalties
legal
principle
indictment
contain
good
counts
bad
counts
judgment
guilty
upon
whole
indictment
sustained
record
shows
considered
every
count
indictment
insufficient
judgment
entered
discharging
defendants
without
day
whole
indictment
upon
view
taken
validity
fourth
count
judgment
erroneous
reversed
trial
ordered
upon
indictment