gilbert
california
argued
decided
june
petitioner
convicted
armed
robbery
murder
police
officer
separate
guilt
penalty
stages
trial
jury
rendered
guilty
verdict
imposed
death
penalty
petitioner
alleges
constitutional
errors
admission
testimony
witnesses
also
identified
lineup
occurred
days
indictment
appointment
counsel
notified
identifications
witnesses
present
lineup
admission
handwriting
exemplars
taken
arrest
admission
statements
mentioning
petitioner
part
crimes
statements
held
improperly
admitted
latter
appeal
additionally
alleges
violation
fourth
amendment
rights
police
seizure
photographs
locked
apartment
warrantless
entry
admission
testimony
identifying
photographs
held
taking
handwriting
exemplars
violate
petitioner
constitutional
rights
pp
fifth
amendment
privilege
reaches
compulsory
communications
mere
handwriting
exemplar
contrast
content
written
identifying
physical
characteristic
outside
protection
pp
taking
exemplars
critical
stage
criminal
proceedings
entitling
petitioner
assistance
counsel
minimal
risk
absence
counsel
might
derogate
right
fair
trial
petitioner
request
reconsideration
delli
paoli
held
appropriate
instructions
jury
suffice
prevent
prejudice
defendant
references
statement
connection
statements
need
considered
view
california
holding
rejecting
delli
paoli
rationale
finding
error
petitioner
admission
statements
harmless
pp
closer
examination
record
possible
certiorari
granted
reveals
facts
respect
search
seizure
claim
sufficiently
clear
permit
resolution
question
certiorari
issue
vacated
improvidently
granted
admission
identifications
petitioner
without
first
determining
tainted
illegal
lineup
procedure
independent
origin
constitutional
error
wade
ante
pp
since
record
permit
informed
judgment
whether
identifications
two
stages
trial
independent
source
petitioner
entitled
vacation
conviction
pending
proceedings
california
courts
allowing
state
establish
identifications
independent
source
introduction
evidence
harmless
error
respect
testimony
witnesses
identified
petitioner
lineup
direct
result
illegal
procedure
state
entitled
show
testimony
independent
source
california
courts
must
unless
able
declare
belief
harmless
beyond
reasonable
doubt
grant
petitioner
new
trial
testimony
guilt
stage
grant
appropriate
relief
penalty
stage
pp
luke
mckissack
argued
cause
filed
briefs
petitioner
norman
sokolow
deputy
attorney
general
california
william
james
assistant
attorney
general
argued
cause
respondent
brief
thomas
lynch
attorney
general
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
case
argued
wade
ante
presents
alleged
constitutional
error
admission
evidence
identifications
considered
addition
petitioner
alleges
constitutional
errors
admission
evidence
testimony
witnesses
also
identified
lineup
admission
handwriting
exemplars
taken
arrest
admission
statements
king
mentioning
petitioner
part
crimes
statements
appeal
decided
petitioner
held
improperly
admitted
finally
alleges
fourth
amendment
rights
violated
police
seizure
photographs
locked
apartment
entry
without
search
warrant
admission
testimony
witnesses
identified
photographs
within
hours
crime
petitioner
convicted
superior
california
armed
robbery
mutual
savings
loan
association
alhambra
murder
police
officer
entered
course
robbery
separate
guilt
penalty
stages
trial
jury
rendered
guilty
verdict
imposed
death
penalty
california
affirmed
cal
granted
certiorari
set
case
argument
wade
stovall
denno
post
holding
today
wade
applied
case
issue
whether
admission
lineup
identifications
constitutional
error
requires
new
trial
resolved
record
proceedings
california
courts
must
therefore
first
determine
whether
petitioner
contentions
warrant
greater
relief
petitioner
arrested
philadelphia
fbi
agent
refused
answer
questions
alhambra
robbery
without
advice
counsel
later
answer
questions
another
agent
philadelphia
robberies
robber
used
handwritten
note
demanding
money
handed
interrogation
gave
agent
handwriting
exemplars
admitted
evidence
trial
objection
obtained
violation
petitioner
fifth
sixth
amendment
rights
california
upheld
admission
exemplars
sole
ground
petitioner
waived
rights
might
furnish
agent
tell
gilbert
exemplars
used
investigation
thus
even
gilbert
believed
exemplars
used
california
appear
authorities
improperly
induced
belief
cal
therefore
decide
petitioner
constitutional
claims
pass
question
waiver
since
conclude
taking
exemplars
violated
none
petitioner
constitutional
rights
first
taking
exemplars
violate
petitioner
fifth
amendment
privilege
privilege
reaches
compulsion
accused
communications
whatever
form
might
take
compulsion
responses
also
communications
example
compliance
subpoena
produce
one
papers
compulsion
makes
suspect
accused
source
real
physical
evidence
schmerber
california
one
voice
handwriting
course
means
communication
means
follows
however
every
compulsion
accused
use
voice
write
compels
communication
within
cover
privilege
mere
handwriting
exemplar
contrast
content
written
like
voice
body
identifying
physical
characteristic
outside
protection
wade
supra
claim
made
content
exemplars
testimonial
communicative
matter
cf
boyd
second
taking
exemplars
critical
stage
criminal
proceedings
entitling
petitioner
assistance
counsel
putting
aside
fact
exemplars
taken
indictment
appointment
counsel
minimal
risk
absence
counsel
might
derogate
right
fair
trial
cf
wade
supra
reason
unrepresentative
exemplar
taken
brought
corrected
adversary
process
trial
since
accused
make
unlimited
number
additional
exemplars
analysis
comparison
government
defense
handwriting
experts
thus
accused
opportunity
meaningful
confrontation
state
case
trial
ordinary
processes
state
expert
handwriting
witnesses
presentation
evidence
handwriting
experts
wade
supra
ii
petitioner
contends
denied
due
process
law
admission
guilt
stage
trial
accomplice
pretrial
statements
police
referred
petitioner
times
course
reciting
petitioner
role
robbery
murder
statements
inadmissible
hearsay
petitioner
held
king
aspect
appeal
improperly
obtained
therefore
inadmissible
california
law
cal
petitioner
us
reconsider
delli
paoli
held
appropriate
instructions
jury
suffice
prevent
prejudice
defendant
references
statement
least
applied
case
gained
reversal
improper
admission
statements
occasion
pass
upon
contention
california
rejected
delli
paoli
rationale
relying
least
part
reasoning
delli
paoli
dissent
regards
cautionary
instructions
inadequate
cure
prejudice
people
aranda
cal
california
applied
aranda
case
held
error
gilbert
admission
king
statements
harmless
standard
applied
reasonable
possibility
error
admitting
king
statements
testimony
might
contributed
gilbert
conviction
standard
derived
decision
fahy
connecticut
fahy
basis
holding
chapman
california
standard
applied
california
satisfies
standard
defined
chapman
may
california
review
application
standard
king
statements
remand
state
presses
harmless
error
also
introduction
lineup
identifications
however
best
implies
ultimate
application
aranda
confirms
petitioner
argument
reconsideration
delli
paoli
need
considered
time
iii
california
rejected
gilbert
challenge
admission
certain
photographs
taken
apartment
pursuant
warrantless
search
justified
entry
apartment
circumstances
basis
hot
pursuit
exigent
circumstances
exceptions
warrant
requirement
granted
certiorari
consider
important
question
extent
exceptions
may
permit
warrantless
searches
without
violation
fourth
amendment
closer
examination
record
possible
certiorari
granted
reveals
facts
appear
sufficient
clarity
enable
us
decide
question
see
appendix
opinion
compare
warden
hayden
therefore
vacate
certiorari
issue
improvidently
granted
monrosa
carbon
black
export
iv
since
none
petitioner
contentions
warrants
relief
issue
becomes
relief
required
application
case
principles
today
announced
wade
supra
three
eyewitnesses
alhambra
crimes
identified
gilbert
guilt
stage
trial
observed
lineup
conducted
without
notice
counsel
los
angeles
auditorium
days
indictment
appointment
counsel
manager
apartment
house
incriminating
evidence
found
gilbert
allegedly
resided
identified
gilbert
courtroom
also
testified
substance
prior
lineup
identification
examination
state
eight
witnesses
identified
courtroom
penalty
stage
eyewitnesses
alhambra
crimes
robberies
allegedly
committed
addition
identifications
witnesses
also
testified
identified
gilbert
lineup
lineup
stage
behind
bright
lights
prevented
line
seeing
audience
upwards
persons
audience
eyewitness
one
several
robberies
charged
gilbert
record
otherwise
virtually
silent
occurred
lineup
guilt
stage
first
witness
cashier
savings
loan
association
identified
gilbert
courtroom
defense
counsel
moved
presence
jury
strike
testimony
ground
identified
gilbert
pretrial
lineup
conducted
absence
counsel
violation
sixth
amendment
made
applicable
fourteenth
amendment
gideon
wainwright
requested
hearing
outside
presence
jury
present
evidence
supporting
claim
identification
others
elicited
state
eyewitnesses
predicated
least
large
part
upon
identification
purported
identification
gilbert
showup
trial
judge
denied
motion
premature
defense
counsel
elicited
fact
cashier
lineup
identification
moved
strike
identification
testimony
without
passing
merits
sixth
amendment
claim
trial
judge
denied
motion
ground
assuming
violation
event
entitle
gilbert
suppression
identification
defense
counsel
thereafter
elicited
fact
lineup
identifications
two
eyewitnesses
direct
examination
identified
gilbert
courtroom
defense
counsel
unsuccessfully
objected
penalty
stage
testimony
eight
witnesses
robberies
identified
gilbert
lineup
admission
identifications
without
first
determining
tainted
illegal
lineup
independent
origin
constitutional
error
wade
supra
held
pretrial
lineup
accused
exhibited
identifying
witnesses
critical
stage
criminal
prosecution
police
conduct
lineup
without
notice
absence
counsel
denies
accused
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
calls
question
admissibility
trial
identifications
accused
witnesses
attended
lineup
however
wade
record
permit
informed
judgment
whether
identifications
two
stages
trial
independent
source
gilbert
therefore
entitled
vacation
conviction
pending
holding
proceedings
california
may
deem
appropriate
afford
state
opportunity
establish
identifications
independent
source
introduction
evidence
event
harmless
error
quite
different
considerations
involved
admission
testimony
manager
apartment
house
guilt
phase
eight
witnesses
penalty
stage
identified
gilbert
lineup
testimony
direct
result
illegal
lineup
come
exploitation
primary
illegality
wong
sun
state
therefore
entitled
opportunity
show
testimony
independent
source
per
se
exclusionary
rule
testimony
effective
sanction
assure
law
enforcement
authorities
respect
accused
constitutional
right
presence
counsel
critical
lineup
absence
legislative
regulations
adequate
avoid
hazards
fair
trial
lineups
presently
conducted
desirability
deterring
constitutionally
objectionable
practice
must
prevail
undesirability
excluding
relevant
evidence
cf
mapp
ohio
conclusion
buttressed
consideration
witness
testimony
lineup
identification
enhance
impact
identification
jury
seriously
aggravate
whatever
derogation
exists
accused
right
fair
trial
therefore
unless
california
able
declare
belief
harmless
beyond
reasonable
doubt
chapman
california
gilbert
entitled
remand
new
trial
prejudicial
error
found
guilt
stage
penalty
stage
whatever
relief
california
law
affords
penalty
stage
must
set
aside
judgment
california
conviction
vacated
case
remanded
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
ordered
appendix
opinion
agent
schlatter
testified
immediately
upon
entering
apartment
put
approximately
officers
made
quick
search
occupant
took
minute
continued
presence
officers
became
matter
assumption
person
persons
involved
come
back
testified
officer
found
photographs
agent
crowley
entered
apartment
agent
schlatter
testimony
might
support
california
view
scope
search
agent
crowley
testified
arrived
within
five
minutes
agent
schlatter
around
give
take
minutes
either
way
apartment
already
searched
suspects
instructed
look
apartment
anything
find
use
identify
continue
pursuit
person
without
conducting
detailed
search
crowley
testimony
search
pursuant
photos
found
limited
manner
merely
inspected
objects
plain
sight
aid
identification
stated
detailed
search
guns
money
conducted
warrant
issued
three
hours
later
agent
townsend
said
arrived
apartment
sometime
perhaps
well
within
hour
agent
crowley
another
agent
local
officer
conducted
detailed
search
bedroom
stated
looked
bedroom
closet
dresser
think
headstand
substantial
sum
money
found
dresser
townsend
specifically
say
whether
crowley
bedroom
time
money
found
testimony
might
support
finding
officers
engaged
general
search
bedroom
time
photos
found
testimony
agents
concerning
time
arrival
apartment
inconsistent
three
possible
conclusions
scope
search
taking
townsend
testimony
together
crowley
concluded
two
arrived
time
agent
schlatter
testimony
crowley
arrived
however
supports
conclusion
crowley
begun
activities
townsend
arrived
testimony
agent
kiel
enter
apartment
obtained
photos
talking
landlady
approximately
time
crowley
townsend
testified
arrived
sum
testimony
concerning
timing
events
surrounding
search
approximate
contradictory
footnotes
record
gilbert
involving
federal
prosecutions
gilbert
apparently
contains
many
details
occurred
lineup
opinion
appeals
ninth
circuit
lineup
occurred
march
gilbert
indicted
obtained
counsel
held
auditorium
used
purpose
los
angeles
police
ten
thirteen
prisoners
placed
lighted
stage
witnesses
assembled
darkened
portion
room
facing
stage
separated
screen
see
prisoners
seen
state
federal
officers
also
present
one
acted
moderator
proceedings
man
lineup
identified
number
name
man
required
step
forward
marked
circle
turn
presenting
profiles
well
face
back
view
walk
put
take
certain
articles
clothing
man
number
called
directed
step
circle
asked
certain
questions
picked
whether
owned
car
whether
arrested
armed
lived
also
asked
repeat
certain
phrases
loud
soft
voice
phrases
witnesses
crimes
heard
robbers
use
freeze
stickup
holdup
empty
cash
drawer
heist
anybody
move
either
men
stage
taken
clear
assembled
witnesses
asked
like
see
told
doubts
time
resolve
several
gave
numbers
men
wanted
see
including
gilbert
prisoners
longer
present
gilbert
others
put
similar
procedure
witnesses
asked
particular
prisoner
say
particular
phrase
walk
particular
way
lineup
witnesses
talked
clear
lineup
however
presence
call
numbers
men
identify
split
among
concerning
admissibility
prior
extrajudicial
identifications
independent
evidence
identity
witness
third
parties
present
prior
identification
see
alr
held
prior
identification
hearsay
admitted
testimony
identifier
merely
prior
consistent
statement
recent
trend
however
admit
prior
identification
exception
admits
substantive
evidence
prior
communication
witness
available
trial
see
alr
later
case
service
california
rule
people
gould
cal
said
evidence
extrajudicial
identification
admissible
corroborate
identification
made
trial
people
slobodion
cal
independent
evidence
identity
unlike
testimony
corroborated
proof
prior
consistent
statements
unless
first
impeached
evidence
extrajudicial
identification
admitted
regardless
whether
testimonial
identification
impeached
earlier
identification
greater
probative
value
identification
made
courtroom
suggestions
others
circumstances
trial
may
intervened
create
fancied
recognition
witness
mind
failure
witness
repeat
extrajudicial
identification
destroy
probative
value
failure
may
explained
loss
memory
circumstances
extrajudicial
identification
tends
connect
defendant
crime
principal
danger
admitting
hearsay
evidence
present
since
witness
available
trial
justice
black
concurring
part
dissenting
part
petitioner
convicted
robbery
murder
partially
basis
handwriting
samples
given
police
custody
without
counsel
partially
evidence
identified
eyewitnesses
lineup
identification
ceremony
held
california
officers
los
angeles
auditorium
without
notice
counsel
opinion
shows
officers
took
gilbert
auditorium
prisoner
formed
lineup
gilbert
persons
required
one
step
forward
asked
certain
questions
required
repeat
certain
phrases
eyewitnesses
crimes
looked
efforts
identify
criminals
trial
gilbert
objected
handwriting
samples
identification
testimony
given
witnesses
saw
auditorium
lineup
ground
admission
evidence
violate
fifth
amendment
privilege
sixth
amendment
right
counsel
fourteenth
amendment
makes
self
incrimination
clause
fifth
amendment
right
counsel
clause
sixth
amendment
obligatory
see
malloy
hogan
gideon
wainwright
rejects
gilbert
contention
connection
handwriting
exemplars
ground
taking
exemplars
critical
stage
criminal
proceedings
entitling
petitioner
assistance
counsel
reality
however
one
critical
stages
government
proceedings
ended
gilbert
conviction
state
case
gilbert
defense
handwriting
exemplars
important
lineup
perhaps
handwriting
analysis
notes
scientific
systematized
wade
ante
may
carry
much
weight
jury
kind
lineup
identification
however
suggests
absence
counsel
handwriting
exemplars
obtained
impair
right
trial
nothing
said
previous
opinions
links
right
counsel
protection
fifth
amendment
rights
wade
ante
nothing
said
justifies
linking
right
counsel
protection
sixth
amendment
rights
nothing
constitution
justify
considering
right
counsel
subsidiary
right
attaches
deems
specific
rights
jeopardy
real
basis
holding
stage
obtaining
handwriting
exemplars
critical
statement
minimal
risk
absence
counsel
might
derogate
right
fair
trial
considers
right
fair
trial
overriding
aim
right
counsel
wade
ante
somehow
believes
power
balance
away
constitutional
guarantee
right
counsel
believes
unnecessary
provide
considers
fair
trial
think
lacks
constitutional
power
thus
balance
away
defendant
absolute
right
counsel
sixth
fourteenth
amendments
guarantee
framers
declare
sixth
amendment
defendant
entitled
fair
trial
entitled
counsel
condition
thinks
minimal
risk
without
lawyer
trial
unfair
sixth
amendment
settled
trial
without
lawyer
constitutionally
unfair
unless
balancing
formula
somehow
changed
johnson
zerbst
gideon
wainwright
thought
finally
established
right
accused
counsel
without
balancing
kind
holding
illustrates
danger
bill
rights
guarantees
use
words
like
fair
trial
take
place
clearly
specified
safeguards
constitution
think
far
safer
constitutional
rights
adhere
constitutional
language
like
accused
shall
assistance
counsel
defence
instead
substituting
words
mentioned
accused
shall
assistance
counsel
thinks
necessary
assure
fair
trial
judgment
guarantees
constitution
bill
rights
provide
kind
fair
trial
framers
sought
protect
gilbert
entitled
assistance
counsel
forced
supply
evidence
government
use
trial
reverse
case
reason
also
ii
think
clearly
indicate
neither
delli
paoli
chapman
relevance
delli
paoli
rested
admissibility
evidence
federal
state
courts
introduction
evidence
state
courts
exclusively
governed
state
law
unless
introduction
violate
federal
constitutional
provision
federal
provision
see
spencer
texas
error
admitting
accomplice
pretrial
statements
error
state
law
chapman
providing
federal
constitutional
rule
absolutely
relevance
instead
looking
test
applied
california
order
ascertain
whether
comports
chapman
make
clear
leaving
unbridled
power
control
state
courts
absence
conflicting
federal
constitutional
provisions
iii
reasons
stated
vacate
judgment
california
remand
consideration
whether
admission
handwriting
exemplars
lineup
identification
harmless
error
dismisses
improvidently
granted
fourth
amendment
question
raised
gilbert
case
dissent
decide
question
gilbert
however
since
refuses
decide
question
see
reason
expressing
views
length
justice
douglas
concurring
part
dissenting
part
agree
opinion
except
part
reverse
remand
new
trial
search
seizure
point
search
petitioner
home
sought
justified
doctrine
hot
pursuit
even
though
officers
conducting
search
knew
petitioner
suspected
criminal
home
january
california
bank
robbed
two
armed
men
police
officer
killed
one
robbers
another
officer
shot
one
robbers
weaver
captured
blocks
scene
crime
weaver
told
police
participated
robbery
person
known
skinny
gilbert
accomplice
told
officers
gilbert
lived
apartment
hawaiian
sounding
named
apartment
house
los
feliz
boulevard
information
given
federal
bureau
investigation
broadcast
field
agent
kiel
instructed
find
apartment
kiel
located
lanai
apartment
los
feliz
boulevard
informed
radio
control
engaged
apartment
manager
conversation
talking
man
gave
key
manager
told
going
san
francisco
days
agent
kiel
learned
manager
flood
one
two
men
rented
apartment
previous
day
man
turned
key
left
rear
exit
agent
ran
alleyway
saw
one
meantime
federal
officers
learned
weaver
gilbert
registered
name
flood
also
learned
three
men
may
involved
robbery
two
entered
bank
third
driving
getaway
car
additional
federal
agents
arrived
apartment
response
agent
kiel
radio
summons
kiel
told
resident
apartment
robert
flood
left
agents
obtained
key
manager
entered
apartment
searched
person
hiding
place
person
found
one
find
envelope
containing
pictures
petitioner
pictures
seized
shown
bank
employees
identification
agents
also
found
notebook
containing
diagram
area
surrounding
bank
clip
automatic
pistol
bag
containing
rolls
coins
bearing
marking
robbed
bank
basis
information
search
warrant
issued
automatic
clip
notebook
coin
rolls
seized
petitioner
arrested
pennsylvania
february
items
seized
search
apartment
introduced
evidence
trial
murder
california
justified
search
ground
police
hot
pursuit
suspected
bank
robbers
entry
apartment
lawful
subsequent
search
seizure
lawful
since
officers
trying
identify
suspects
facilitate
continued
pursuit
cal
set
forth
testimony
relating
search
fully
appendix
opinion
reasons
stated
agree
facts
appear
sufficient
clarity
enable
us
decide
serious
question
presented
since
search
seizure
took
place
without
warrant
stand
comes
within
one
narrowly
defined
exceptions
rule
search
seizure
must
rest
upon
validly
executed
search
warrant
see
jeffers
jones
rios
stoner
california
one
exceptions
officers
probable
cause
arrest
may
enter
dwelling
make
arrest
conduct
contemporaneous
search
place
arrest
order
find
seize
things
connected
crime
fruits
means
committed
well
weapons
things
effect
escape
custody
agnello
course
assumes
arrest
made
search
substantially
contemporaneous
arrest
confined
immediate
vicinity
arrest
stoner
california
supra
case
exemption
applicable
since
arrest
made
many
days
search
location
far
removed
search
officers
entered
apartment
searched
petitioner
find
nevertheless
continued
searching
apartment
seized
pictures
inescapable
conclusion
searching
evidence
linking
petitioner
bank
robbery
suspected
robbers
said
legally
entered
apartment
officers
properly
look
apartment
anything
used
identify
suspects
expedite
pursuit
cal
prior
case
police
enter
search
house
without
warrant
incidental
valid
arrest
judgment
stands
police
search
house
evidence
even
though
suspect
arrested
purpose
search
words
california
limited
incident
purpose
officers
entry
apprehend
suspected
criminal
doctrine
police
given
license
search
evidence
linking
crime
certainly
evidence
well
calculated
identify
suspects
expedite
pursuit
since
police
concentrate
person
whose
home
ransacked
ibid
search
seizure
case
violates
another
limitation
concededly
decision
harris
flouted
general
search
evidence
even
police
hot
pursuit
warrant
arrest
make
constitutional
general
search
room
house
lefkowitz
police
acting
without
search
warrant
search
extensively
warrant
warrant
must
prescribed
fourth
amendment
particularly
describe
things
seized
stated
lefkowitz
supra
authority
officers
search
one
house
place
business
contemporaneously
lawful
arrest
therein
upon
valid
warrant
arrest
certainly
greater
conferred
search
warrant
issued
upon
adequate
proof
sufficiently
describing
premises
things
sought
obtained
indeed
informed
deliberate
determinations
magistrates
empowered
issue
warrants
searches
seizures
permissible
constitution
preferred
hurried
action
officers
others
may
happen
make
arrests
security
unlawful
searches
likely
attained
resort
search
warrants
reliance
upon
caution
sagacity
petty
officers
acting
excitement
attends
capture
persons
accused
crime
modern
police
technique
ransacking
houses
even
point
seizing
entire
contents
done
kremen
shocking
departure
philosophy
fourth
amendment
kind
search
conducted
indeed
general
search
fourth
amendment
aimed
particular
target
aimed
take
step
resurrect
one
complaints
gave
rise
revolution
stated
boyd
practice
obtained
colonies
issuing
writs
assistance
revenue
officers
empowering
discretion
search
suspected
places
smuggled
goods
james
otis
pronounced
worst
instrument
arbitrary
power
destructive
english
liberty
fundamental
principles
law
ever
found
english
law
book
since
placed
liberty
every
man
hands
every
petty
officer
february
boston
famous
debate
occurred
perhaps
prominent
event
inaugurated
resistance
colonies
oppressions
mother
country
said
john
adams
first
scene
first
act
opposition
arbitrary
claims
great
britain
child
independence
born
appendix
opinion
justice
douglas
agent
kiel
testified
agents
schlatter
onsgaard
arrived
apartment
entered
apartment
minute
two
arrival
kiel
received
photographs
agent
schlatter
agent
schlatter
testified
agent
onsgaard
local
police
arrived
apartment
agent
crowley
one
two
local
police
officers
arrived
another
car
time
schlatter
briefly
talked
kiel
apartment
manager
entered
apartment
upon
entering
saw
one
made
fast
search
apartment
person
hiding
place
person
found
none
search
took
matter
seconds
minute
outside
fter
searched
person
persons
one
became
matter
assumption
person
persons
involved
come
back
seemed
schlatter
agent
photograph
hand
first
saw
hands
agent
officer
schlatter
vague
recollection
agent
officer
told
found
bedroom
number
photographs
schlatter
took
photographs
kiel
instructed
take
one
savings
loan
association
see
anyone
recognize
photograph
schlatter
testified
apartment
minutes
making
search
left
agents
behind
left
agent
crowley
testified
entered
apartment
around
give
take
minutes
either
way
say
officers
apartment
less
five
minutes
entered
believed
officers
agent
rear
building
first
entry
made
entered
crowley
entered
apartment
already
searched
people
received
instructions
look
apartment
anything
find
use
identify
continue
pursuit
person
without
conducting
detailed
search
bedroom
dresser
crowley
saw
envelope
bearing
name
marlboro
photo
studio
appeared
envelope
containing
photos
see
something
inside
crowley
opened
envelope
saw
several
copies
photographs
discussed
matter
onsgaard
charge
building
instructed
crowley
give
another
agent
utilize
pursuing
investigation
reasonably
certain
agent
mr
schlatter
according
crowley
course
search
turned
photographs
crowley
turned
items
see
reverse
business
cards
sales
slips
local
stores
sort
item
might
folded
appear
possibly
contain
information
value
pursuit
relayed
information
obtained
manner
man
coordinating
operation
crowley
remained
apartment
next
morning
agent
townsend
testified
arrived
apartment
ometime
perhaps
within
hour
arrival
began
search
townsend
testified
agent
crowley
another
agent
local
officer
looked
bedroom
closet
dresser
think
headstand
known
one
agents
police
officers
apartment
townsend
stated
agents
officers
bedroom
found
money
bedroom
dresser
hour
arrived
apartment
say
specifically
whether
crowley
time
thus
conflict
regarding
times
events
took
place
respect
nature
searches
conducted
various
officers
way
read
record
however
state
facts
appear
sufficient
clarity
enable
us
decide
question
presented
crowley
testimony
came
upon
photographs
searching
anything
use
identify
continue
pursuit
stands
uncontradicted
testimony
apartment
already
searched
person
prior
search
uncovering
photographs
schlatter
testimony
operation
became
matter
unsuccessful
search
person
contradict
crowley
testimony
search
identifying
evidence
certainly
compatible
crowley
best
knew
discovered
photographs
townsend
testimony
others
perhaps
including
crowley
conducted
detailed
search
conflict
crowley
testimony
first
record
indicates
detailed
search
conducted
photographs
found
according
testimony
kiel
schlatter
schlatter
gave
photographs
kiel
according
townsend
arrived
sometime
second
even
detailed
search
took
place
crowley
found
photographs
crowley
participated
search
indicate
crowley
search
turned
photographs
limited
crowley
claimed
anything
indicate
search
general
stated
finally
townsend
testimony
general
search
conflict
schlatter
testimony
operation
became
suspect
found
said
preclude
detailed
search
evidence
record
indicates
schlatter
apartment
townsend
others
conducted
detailed
search
way
read
record
photographs
discovered
course
general
search
evidence
even
crowley
believed
testimony
relating
nature
search
thrown
simply
assumed
came
upon
envelope
course
search
suspect
reason
pry
envelope
seize
pictures
obtain
evidence
envelope
contain
neither
suspect
weapon
phase
case
agree
justice
black
justice
fortas
justice
white
justice
harlan
justice
stewart
join
concurring
part
dissenting
part
concur
parts
ii
iii
opinion
reasons
stated
separate
opinion
wade
ante
dissent
part
iv
opinion
therefore
affirm
judgment
california
justice
fortas
chief
justice
joins
concurring
part
dissenting
part
concur
result
vacation
judgment
california
remand
case
believe
adequate
reverse
remand
new
trial
additional
ground
petitioner
entitled
sixth
fourteenth
amendments
advised
right
counsel
connection
response
prosecutor
demand
handwriting
exemplar
giving
handwriting
exemplar
critical
stage
proceeding
brother
black
critical
stage
much
lineup
see
wade
ante
depending
upon
circumstances
may
inoffensive
constitution
totally
fair
accused
entirely
reliable
administration
justice
hand
may
constitutionally
offensive
totally
unfair
accused
prejudicial
ascertainment
truth
accused
whose
handwriting
exemplar
sought
needs
counsel
write
money
life
emulate
holdup
note
using
red
ink
brown
paper
large
letters
demanded
handwriting
exemplar
effect
inculpation
confession
cf
eloquent
arguments
need
counsel
opinion
wade
supra
today
appears
hold
accused
may
compelled
give
handwriting
exemplar
cf
schmerber
california
presumably
may
punished
adamantly
refuses
unlike
blood
handwriting
extracted
doctor
accused
veins
accused
subjected
physical
restraint
schmerber
permits
presumably
basis
decision
trial
courts
may
hold
accused
contempt
keep
jail
indefinitely
gives
handwriting
exemplar
decision
goes
beyond
schmerber
accused
absence
warning
right
counsel
compelled
cooperate
merely
submit
engage
volitional
act
merely
suffer
inevitable
consequences
arrest
state
custody
take
affirmative
action
may
merely
identify
tie
directly
crime
dissented
schmerber
reasons
stated
separate
opinion
wade
supra
regard
extension
schmerber
impermissible
wade
accused
compelled
utter
words
used
criminal
heat
act
least
comfort
counsel
even
denies
accused
may
refuse
speak
words
compelled
utterance
occurs
course
lineup
present
case
deprives
even
source
comfort
whatever
protection
counsel
ingenuity
provide
face
opinion
utterly
insupportable
respectful
opinion
like
fingerprinting
measuring
photographing
even
process
involving
use
discretion
capable
abuse
stream
inculpation
play
limited
role
offsetting
false
inference
misleading
coincidence
stacked
handwriting
exemplar
reference
efficacy
situation
much
comfort
appellate
source
solace
defendant
counsel
agree
condemnation
lineup
identifications
consequent
identifications
join
part
opinion
also
reverse
remand
new
trial
use
handwriting
exemplars
unconstitutionally
obtained
absence
advice
accused
availability
counsel
conclude
violation
privilege
implicit
facts
relating
exemplars
waived
absence
advice
counsel
gault
miranda
arizona