harriss
argued
october
decided
june
construed
federal
regulation
lobbying
act
vague
indefinite
meet
requirements
due
process
pp
general
class
offenses
statute
directed
plainly
within
terms
statute
struck
vague
even
though
marginal
cases
put
doubts
might
arise
general
class
offenses
made
constitutionally
definite
reasonable
construction
statute
duty
give
statute
construction
section
limits
coverage
act
persons
except
specified
political
committees
solicit
collect
receive
contributions
money
thing
value
one
main
purposes
either
persons
contributions
aid
accomplishment
aims
set
forth
pp
purposes
set
forth
construed
refer
lobbying
commonly
accepted
sense
direct
communication
members
congress
pending
proposed
legislation
pp
principal
purpose
requirement
adopted
merely
exclude
scope
contributions
persons
incidental
purpose
influencing
legislation
exclude
contribution
substantial
part
used
influence
legislation
direct
communication
congress
person
whose
activities
substantial
part
directed
influencing
legislation
direct
communication
congress
pp
three
prerequisites
coverage
person
must
solicited
collected
received
contributions
one
main
purposes
person
one
main
purposes
contributions
must
influence
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
intended
method
accomplishing
purpose
must
direct
communication
members
congress
case
unnecessary
pass
contention
penalty
provision
violates
first
amendment
pp
section
yet
applied
appellees
never
applied
appellees
found
innocent
charges
elimination
still
leave
statute
defining
specific
duties
providing
specific
penalty
violation
duty
separability
provision
act
given
effect
ultimately
found
invalid
oscar
davis
argued
cause
brief
robert
stern
acting
solicitor
general
assistant
attorney
general
olney
beatrice
rosenberg
john
wilkins
walter
cummings
solicitor
general
filed
statement
jurisdiction
burton
wheeler
argued
cause
harriss
appellee
brief
edward
wheeler
hugh
howell
argued
cause
linder
commissioner
agriculture
georgia
appellee
brief
victor
davidson
ralph
moore
appellee
submitted
brief
pro
se
chief
justice
warren
delivered
opinion
appellees
charged
information
violation
federal
regulation
lobbying
act
stat
relying
previous
decision
national
association
manufacturers
mcgrath
supp
vacated
moot
district
dismissed
information
ground
act
unconstitutional
supp
case
direct
appeal
criminal
appeals
act
seven
counts
information
laid
requires
designated
reports
congress
every
person
receiving
contributions
expending
money
purpose
influencing
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
one
count
charges
national
farm
committee
texas
corporation
failure
report
solicitation
receipt
contributions
influence
passage
legislation
cause
rise
price
agricultural
commodities
commodity
futures
defeat
legislation
cause
decline
prices
remaining
six
counts
charge
defendants
moore
harriss
failure
report
expenditures
single
purpose
alleged
expenditures
consist
payment
compensation
others
communicate
members
congress
public
functions
committee
hearings
concerning
legislation
affecting
agricultural
prices
alleged
expenditures
relate
largely
costs
campaign
induce
various
interested
groups
individuals
communicate
letter
members
congress
legislation
two
counts
information
laid
requires
person
shall
engage
pay
consideration
purpose
attempting
influence
passage
defeat
legislation
register
congress
make
specified
disclosures
two
counts
allege
considerable
detail
defendants
moore
linder
hired
express
certain
views
congress
agricultural
prices
cause
others
purpose
attempting
influence
passage
legislation
cause
rise
price
agricultural
commodities
commodity
futures
defeat
legislation
cause
decline
prices
pursuant
undertaking
without
registered
required
arranged
members
congress
contacted
behalf
views
either
directly
emissaries
artificially
stimulated
letter
campaign
concerned
sufficiency
information
criminal
pleading
review
criminal
appeals
act
limited
decision
alleged
invalidity
statute
information
based
making
decision
judge
statute
face
see
petrillo
invalidity
lobbying
act
asserted
three
grounds
vague
indefinite
meet
requirements
due
process
violate
first
amendment
guarantees
freedom
speech
freedom
press
right
petition
government
penalty
provision
violates
right
people
first
amendment
petition
government
constitutional
requirement
definiteness
violated
criminal
statute
fails
give
person
ordinary
intelligence
fair
notice
contemplated
conduct
forbidden
statute
underlying
principle
man
shall
held
criminally
responsible
conduct
reasonably
understand
proscribed
hand
general
class
offenses
statute
directed
plainly
within
terms
statute
struck
vague
even
though
marginal
cases
put
doubts
might
arise
petrillo
cf
jordan
de
george
general
class
offenses
made
constitutionally
definite
reasonable
construction
statute
duty
give
statute
construction
course
adopted
screws
upholding
definiteness
civil
rights
act
course
appropriate
key
section
lobbying
act
entitled
persons
applicable
section
provides
provisions
title
shall
apply
person
except
political
committee
defined
federal
corrupt
practices
act
duly
organized
state
local
committees
political
party
agent
employee
persons
manner
whatsoever
directly
indirectly
solicits
collects
receives
money
thing
value
used
principally
aid
principal
purpose
person
aid
accomplishment
following
purposes
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
influence
directly
indirectly
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
government
urges
much
broader
construction
namely
person
must
report
expenditures
influence
legislation
even
though
solicit
collect
receive
contributions
provided
construction
believe
violence
title
language
well
legislative
history
construction
urged
government
become
law
congress
accomplish
legislation
turn
alleged
vagueness
purposes
set
forth
rumely
involved
interpretation
similar
language
believe
language
construed
refer
lobbying
commonly
accepted
sense
direct
communication
members
congress
pending
proposed
federal
legislation
legislative
history
act
makes
clear
least
congress
sought
disclosure
direct
pressures
exerted
lobbyists
hirelings
artificially
stimulated
letter
campaign
likewise
clear
congress
intended
act
operate
narrower
basis
even
broader
application
organizations
seeking
propagandize
general
public
permissible
remains
consideration
meaning
principal
purpose
used
principally
aid
legislative
history
act
indicates
term
principal
adopted
merely
exclude
scope
contributions
persons
incidental
purpose
influencing
legislation
conversely
principal
purpose
requirement
exclude
contribution
substantial
part
used
influence
legislation
direct
communication
congress
person
whose
activities
substantial
part
directed
influencing
legislation
direct
communication
congress
otherwise
organization
example
exempted
lobbying
one
main
activities
act
large
measure
reduced
mere
exhortation
abuse
legislative
process
construing
act
narrowly
avoid
constitutional
doubts
must
also
avoid
construction
seriously
impair
effectiveness
act
coping
problem
designed
alleviate
summarize
therefore
three
prerequisites
coverage
person
must
solicited
collected
received
contributions
one
main
purposes
person
one
main
purposes
contributions
must
influence
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
intended
method
accomplishing
purpose
must
direct
communication
members
congress
since
modifies
substantive
provisions
act
construction
necessity
also
narrow
scope
substantive
provisions
underlying
information
case
thus
limited
persons
covered
covered
must
report
contributions
expenditures
purpose
attempting
influence
legislation
direct
communication
congress
similarly
limited
persons
stated
exceptions
covered
addition
engage
pay
valuable
consideration
purpose
attempting
influence
legislation
direct
communication
congress
construed
way
lobbying
act
meets
constitutional
requirement
definiteness
ii
thus
construed
also
violate
freedoms
guaranteed
first
amendment
freedom
speak
publish
petition
government
legislative
complexities
individual
members
congress
expected
explore
myriad
pressures
regularly
subjected
yet
full
realization
american
ideal
government
elected
representatives
depends
small
extent
ability
properly
evaluate
pressures
otherwise
voice
people
may
easily
drowned
voice
special
interest
groups
seeking
favored
treatment
masquerading
proponents
public
weal
evil
lobbying
act
designed
help
prevent
toward
end
congress
sought
prohibit
pressures
merely
provided
modicum
information
hire
attempt
influence
legislation
collect
spend
funds
purpose
wants
know
hired
putting
money
much
acted
spirit
similar
purpose
passing
federal
corrupt
practices
act
maintain
integrity
basic
governmental
process
see
burroughs
cannon
circumstances
believe
congress
least
within
bounds
act
construed
constitutionally
forbidden
require
disclosure
lobbying
activities
deny
congress
large
measure
power
congress
used
power
manner
restricted
appropriate
end
conclude
applied
persons
defined
offend
first
amendment
suggested
however
lobbying
act
respect
persons
defined
may
practical
matter
act
deterrent
exercise
first
amendment
rights
hypothetical
borderline
situations
conjured
persons
choose
remain
silent
fear
possible
prosecution
failure
comply
act
narrow
construction
act
precluding
reasonable
fears
calculated
avoid
restraint
even
assuming
deterrent
effect
restraint
indirect
one
resulting
comparable
many
ways
restraint
resulting
criminal
libel
laws
hazard
restraint
remote
require
striking
statute
face
otherwise
plainly
within
area
congressional
power
designed
safeguard
vital
national
interest
iii
appellees
attack
statute
ground
penalty
provided
unconstitutional
section
provides
addition
penalties
provided
subsection
person
convicted
misdemeanor
specified
therein
prohibited
period
three
years
date
conviction
attempting
influence
directly
indirectly
passage
defeat
proposed
legislation
appearing
committee
congress
support
opposition
proposed
legislation
person
violates
provision
subsection
shall
upon
conviction
thereof
guilty
felony
shall
punished
fine
imprisonment
five
years
fine
imprisonment
find
unnecessary
pass
contention
unlike
judged
face
yet
applied
appellees
never
applied
appellees
found
innocent
charges
see
wurzbach
petrillo
moreover
act
provides
separability
provision
found
invalid
ultimately
declared
unconstitutional
elimination
still
leave
statute
defining
specific
duties
providing
specific
penalty
violation
duty
prohibition
expressly
stated
addition
penalties
provided
subsection
subsection
makes
violation
misdemeanor
punishable
fine
imprisonment
consequently
seem
obstacle
giving
effect
separability
clause
ever
prove
necessary
compare
electric
bond
share
securities
exchange
commission
judgment
reversed
cause
remanded
district
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
reversed
footnotes
section
provides
person
shall
engage
pay
consideration
purpose
attempting
influence
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
shall
anything
furtherance
object
register
clerk
house
representatives
secretary
senate
shall
give
officers
writing
oath
name
business
address
name
address
person
employed
whose
interest
appears
works
duration
employment
much
paid
receive
paid
paid
much
paid
expenses
expenses
included
person
registering
shall
first
tenth
day
calendar
quarter
long
activity
continues
file
clerk
secretary
detailed
report
oath
money
received
expended
preceding
calendar
quarter
carrying
work
paid
purposes
names
papers
periodicals
magazines
publications
caused
published
articles
editorials
proposed
legislation
employed
support
oppose
provisions
section
shall
apply
person
merely
appears
committee
congress
support
opposition
legislation
public
official
acting
official
capacity
case
newspaper
regularly
published
periodical
including
individual
owns
publishes
employed
newspaper
periodical
ordinary
course
business
publishes
news
items
editorials
comments
paid
advertisements
directly
indirectly
urge
passage
defeat
legislation
newspaper
periodical
individual
engages
activities
connection
passage
defeat
legislation
appear
committee
congress
support
opposition
legislation
information
required
filed
provisions
section
clerk
house
representatives
secretary
senate
shall
compiled
said
clerk
secretary
acting
jointly
soon
practicable
close
calendar
quarter
respect
information
filed
shall
printed
congressional
record
third
count
abated
death
defendant
charge
made
see
petrillo
government
appeal
open
whole
case
borden
see
jordan
de
george
quarles
statutory
construction
problems
approaches
criminal
law
vand
rev
note
harv
rev
cf
fox
washington
musser
utah
winters
new
york
rule
statutes
charged
vagueness
one
aspect
broader
principle
fairly
possible
must
construe
congressional
enactments
avoid
danger
unconstitutionality
delaware
hudson
congress
industrial
organizations
rumely
thus
case
supra
held
expenditures
labor
organization
publication
weekly
periodical
urging
support
certain
candidate
forthcoming
congressional
election
forbidden
federal
corrupt
practices
act
makes
unlawful
labor
organization
make
contribution
expenditure
connection
congressional
election
similarly
rumely
case
supra
construed
house
resolution
authorizing
investigation
lobbying
activities
intended
influence
encourage
promote
retard
legislation
cover
lobbying
commonly
accepted
sense
representations
made
directly
congress
members
committees
section
defines
term
person
including
individual
partnership
committee
association
corporation
organization
group
persons
government
view
based
variance
language
language
section
refers
person
solicits
collects
receives
contributions
however
refers
receiving
contributions
also
expending
money
apparently
government
contention
since
makes
reference
expenditures
inapplicable
expenditure
provisions
section
however
limits
application
whole
merely
part
senate
house
reports
bill
state
section
defines
application
title
committee
print
july
statement
representative
monroney
legislative
reorganization
act
see
also
remarks
representative
dirksen
presenting
bill
house
gist
antilobbying
provision
contained
section
cong
rec
lobbying
act
enacted
title
iii
legislative
reorganization
act
reported
congress
joint
committee
organization
congress
senate
house
reports
accompanying
bill
identical
respect
title
iii
declared
lobbying
act
applies
chiefly
three
distinct
classes
lobbyists
first
visit
capitol
initiate
propaganda
country
form
letters
telegrams
many
based
entirely
upon
misinformation
facts
class
persons
organizations
required
title
cease
curtail
activities
respect
merely
disclose
sources
collections
methods
disbursed
second
second
class
lobbyists
employed
come
capitol
false
impression
exert
powerful
influence
members
congress
individuals
spend
time
washington
presumably
exerting
mysterious
influence
respect
legislation
employers
interested
carefully
conceal
members
congress
happen
contact
purpose
presence
title
wise
prohibits
curtails
activities
merely
requires
shall
register
disclose
sources
purposes
employment
amount
compensation
third
third
class
entirely
honest
respectable
representatives
business
professional
philanthropic
organizations
come
washington
openly
frankly
express
views
legislation
many
serve
useful
perfectly
legitimate
purpose
expressing
views
interpretations
employers
respect
legislation
concerns
likewise
required
register
state
compensation
sources
employment
committee
print
july
statement
representative
monroney
legislative
reorganization
act
pp
see
also
statement
senate
senator
la
follette
chairman
joint
committee
cong
rec
see
act
separability
clause
note
infra
providing
invalidity
application
act
affect
validity
application
persons
circumstances
senate
house
reports
accompanying
bill
state
act
apply
organizations
formed
purposes
whose
efforts
influence
legislation
merely
incidental
purposes
formed
committee
print
july
statement
representative
monroney
legislative
reorganization
act
senate
discussion
preceding
enactment
senator
hawkes
asked
senator
la
follette
chairman
joint
committee
charge
bill
explanation
principal
purpose
requirement
particular
senator
hawkes
sought
assurance
organizations
like
chamber
commerce
subject
act
senator
la
follette
refused
give
assurance
stating
far
organizations
individuals
concerned
say
senator
new
jersey
depend
type
character
activity
undertake
tell
senator
whether
come
act
depend
type
activity
engage
far
legislation
concerned
act
affects
individuals
organizations
alike
engage
covered
activity
italics
added
cong
rec
see
also
representative
dirksen
remarks
house
cong
rec
criterion
novel
federal
law
see
int
rev
code
income
tax
estate
tax
gift
tax
providing
tax
exemption
contributions
charitable
educational
organizations
substantial
part
activities
carrying
propaganda
otherwise
attempting
influence
legislation
illustrative
cases
applying
criterion
see
sharpe
estate
commissioner
cir
marshall
commissioner
cir
faulkner
commissioner
cir
huntington
national
bank
commissioner
cf
girard
trust
commissioner
cir
leubuscher
commissioner
cir
weyl
commissioner
cir
slee
commissioner
see
also
annotation
three
exceptions
see
note
supra
construction
act
least
definite
many
criminal
statutes
upheld
charge
vagueness
boyce
motor
lines
regulation
providing
drivers
motor
vehicles
carrying
explosives
shall
avoid
far
practicable
feasible
prearrangement
routes
driving
congested
thoroughfares
places
crowds
assembled
street
car
tracks
tunnels
viaducts
dangerous
crossings
dennis
smith
act
making
unlawful
person
conspire
knowingly
willfully
advocate
abet
advise
teach
duty
necessity
desirability
propriety
overthrowing
destroying
government
force
violence
petrillo
statute
forbidding
coercion
radio
stations
employ
persons
excess
number
employees
needed
perform
actual
services
screws
williams
statute
forbidding
acts
deprive
person
rights
privileges
immunities
secured
protected
constitution
laws
wurzbach
statute
forbidding
candidate
congress
officer
employee
solicit
receive
contribution
political
purpose
whatever
officer
employee
omaechevarria
idaho
statute
forbidding
pasturing
sheep
cattle
range
previously
occupied
cattle
upon
range
usually
occupied
cattle
grower
fox
washington
state
statute
imposing
criminal
sanctions
every
person
shall
wilfully
print
publish
edit
issue
knowingly
circulate
sell
distribute
display
book
paper
document
written
printed
matter
form
advocating
encouraging
inciting
tendency
encourage
incite
commission
crime
breach
peace
act
violence
shall
tend
encourage
advocate
disrespect
law
courts
justice
nash
sherman
act
forbidding
every
contract
combination
form
trust
otherwise
conspiracy
restraint
trade
commerce
among
several
foreign
nations
cf
jordan
de
george
statute
providing
deportation
persons
committed
crimes
involving
moral
turpitude
similar
legislation
enacted
twenty
see
notes
yale
rev
similarly
hatch
act
probably
deters
federal
employees
political
activity
permitted
statute
yet
sustained
national
interest
nonpolitical
civil
service
public
workers
mitchell
stat
provision
act
application
thereof
person
circumstances
held
invalid
validity
remainder
act
application
provision
persons
circumstances
shall
affected
thereby
justice
douglas
justice
black
concurs
dissenting
sympathy
effort
save
statute
charge
vague
indefinite
unconstitutional
inclinations
way
end
oral
argument
study
changed
mind
convinced
formula
adopted
save
act
dangerous
use
easily
ensnare
people
done
exercise
constitutional
rights
speech
assembly
press
deal
validity
criminal
statute
use
test
connally
general
construction
question
whether
statute
either
forbids
requires
act
terms
vague
men
common
intelligence
must
necessarily
guess
meaning
differ
application
vague
think
one
fails
meet
standards
required
due
process
law
see
petrillo
determining
question
consider
statute
face
stated
lanzetta
new
jersey
face
challenged
provision
repugnant
due
process
clause
specification
details
offense
intended
charged
serve
validate
statute
accusation
prescribes
rule
govern
conduct
warns
transgression
one
may
required
peril
life
liberty
property
speculate
meaning
penal
statutes
entitled
informed
state
commands
forbids
question
therefore
information
charges
proof
might
whether
statute
sufficiently
narrow
precise
give
fair
warning
contended
act
plainly
applies
persons
pay
others
present
views
congress
either
committee
hearings
letters
communications
congress
congressmen
persons
spend
money
induce
others
communicate
congress
difficulty
act
rewritten
words
actually
added
subtracted
produce
result
section
makes
act
applicable
anyone
directly
indirectly
solicits
collects
receives
contributions
used
principally
aid
principal
purpose
person
aid
either
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
influence
directly
indirectly
passage
defeat
legislation
congress
contributions
might
used
principally
aid
influencing
directly
indirectly
passage
defeat
measure
congress
one
retained
purpose
influencing
passage
defeat
legislation
one
addresses
trade
union
repeal
labor
law
certainly
hopes
influence
legislation
manufacturers
association
runs
ads
newspapers
sales
tax
farm
group
undertakes
raise
money
educational
program
conducted
newspapers
magazines
radio
television
showing
need
revision
attitude
world
trade
group
oil
companies
puts
agents
nation
capital
sound
alarm
hostile
legislation
exert
influence
congressmen
defeat
work
hill
passage
laws
favorable
oil
interests
business
labor
farm
religious
social
racial
group
raises
money
contact
people
request
write
congressman
get
law
repealed
modified
get
proposed
law
passed
propose
law
activities
covered
act
one
included
others
apparently
excludes
kind
activities
listed
categories
includes
part
activities
entail
contacts
congress
however
difficulty
course
difficulty
seems
insuperable
find
warrant
act
drawing
line
direct
communication
congress
pressures
congress
act
much
concerned
one
words
direct
communication
congress
act
congress
concerned
raising
money
aid
passage
defeat
legislation
whatever
tactics
used
strikes
one
whole
group
activities
influence
indirectly
substitutes
new
concept
remaining
group
influence
directly
influence
directly
passage
defeat
legislation
includes
number
methods
example
nationwide
radio
television
advertising
programs
promoting
particular
measure
well
buttonholing
congressmen
include
latter
excluding
former
rewrite
act
case
one
distinct
types
lobbying
specifically
proscribed
another
different
group
defined
loose
broad
terms
make
definition
vague
uncertain
give
words
act
ordinary
meaning
know
terminal
points
judging
words
congress
used
one
type
activity
enumerated
much
proscribed
another
importance
problem
emphasized
reason
fact
legislation
domain
first
amendment
amendment
provides
congress
shall
make
law
abridging
freedom
speech
press
right
people
petition
government
redress
grievances
congress
require
one
register
writes
article
makes
speech
files
advertisement
appears
radio
television
writes
letter
seeking
influence
existing
pending
proposed
legislation
pose
considerable
question
first
amendment
thomas
collins
indicates
mean
intimate
congress
without
power
require
disclosure
real
principals
behind
come
congress
get
others
speak
though
represent
public
interest
fact
undisclosed
agents
special
groups
mention
first
amendment
emphasize
statutes
touching
field
narrowly
drawn
prevent
supposed
evil
see
cantwell
connecticut
cast
vague
indefinite
terms
cast
cloud
exercise
constitutional
rights
cf
stromberg
california
thornhill
alabama
winters
new
york
joseph
burstyn
wilson
rule
relaxed
congress
impose
registration
requirements
exercise
first
amendment
rights
saving
courts
salvage
good
bad
meanwhile
causing
might
possibly
covered
act
peril
law
practical
effect
deterrent
exercise
first
amendment
rights
seeks
avoid
consequence
construing
law
narrowly
applying
paid
buttonhole
congressmen
collect
expend
moneys
get
others
may
appropriate
cases
read
statute
gloss
placed
order
save
charge
vagueness
see
fox
washington
think
course
appropriate
language
act
broad
one
writes
letter
makes
speech
publishes
article
distributes
literature
many
things
appellees
charged
fair
notice
close
prohibited
line
construction
give
today
make
clear
retroactively
vague
standards
confronted
appellees
acts
charged
criminal
cf
pierce
since
act
touches
exercise
first
amendment
rights
narrowly
drawn
meet
precise
evils
vagueness
evils
continuous
effective
restraint
justice
jackson
dissenting
several
reasons
lead
withhold
assent
decision
clearest
feature
case
begins
act
mischievously
vague
government
charged
enforcement
understand
important
assumptions
rejected
interpretation
clearest
feature
decision
leaves
country
act
much
like
act
passed
congress
course
question
us
easy
differ
whether
appropriate
strike
strike
recall
cases
gone
far
rewriting
act
act
passed
congress
appear
apply
persons
solicit
receive
funds
purpose
lobbying
receive
expend
funds
purpose
lobbying
merely
expend
funds
purpose
lobbying
least
eliminates
last
category
coverage
act
though
suppose
serious
evils
affecting
public
interest
found
way
lobbyists
spend
money
ways
obtain
present
indictments
six
counts
relate
exclusively
failures
report
expenditures
one
appears
rest
exclusively
failure
report
receipts
also
congress
enacted
statute
reach
raising
spending
funds
purpose
influencing
congressional
action
directly
indirectly
entirely
deletes
indirectly
narrows
directly
mean
direct
communication
members
congress
two
constructions
leave
act
touching
part
practices
congress
deemed
sinister
finally
compensate
deletions
act
expands
phrase
principal
purpose
refers
contribution
substantial
part
used
influence
legislation
agree
course
make
liberal
interpretations
save
legislative
acts
including
penal
statutes
punish
conduct
traditionally
recognized
morally
wrong
whoever
kidnaps
steals
kills
commits
similar
acts
violence
upon
another
bound
know
inviting
retribution
society
many
statutes
define
crimes
traditionally
perhaps
necessarily
vague
dealing
novel
offense
established
bounds
moral
basis
criminality
conduct
dealt
depends
entirely
upon
purpose
influence
legislation
though
may
many
abuses
pursuit
purpose
act
deal
corruption
defendants
example
indicted
failing
report
activities
raising
spending
money
influence
legislation
support
farm
prices
charge
corruption
bribery
deception
improper
action
may
selfish
business
best
interests
nation
whole
area
legal
penalties
applied
formulae
precise
clear
language
permit
first
amendment
forbids
congress
abridge
right
people
petition
government
redress
grievances
right
interpretation
consistent
given
first
amendment
rights
confers
large
immunity
upon
activities
persons
organizations
groups
classes
obtain
think
due
government
course
conflicting
claims
propaganda
confusing
annoying
times
doubt
deceiving
corrupting
may
forget
constitutional
system
allow
greatest
freedom
access
congress
people
may
press
selfish
interests
congress
acting
arbiter
demands
conflicts
matters
nature
seem
wise
leave
scope
criminal
act
close
impinging
right
petition
dependent
upon
judicial
construction
limitations
judicial
construction
constitutional
statutory
always
subject
hazards
judicial
reconstruction
one
may
rely
today
narrow
interpretation
peril
later
may
expand
act
include
accordance
terms
today
excludes
recently
happened
antitrust
laws
cites
similarly
vague
criminal
case
sustained
indictment
admittedly
changing
repeated
constitutional
statutory
interpretations
underwriters
ex
post
facto
provision
constitution
held
protect
citizen
retroactive
change
decisional
law
prejudicial
change
legislation
long
statute
stands
books
vagueness
contingent
threat
activities
today
rules
contingency
change
views
hereafter
constituted
opinion
presupposes
disagree
congress
power
regulate
lobbying
hire
business
profession
require
agents
disclose
principals
activities
receipts
however
reach
real
evils
lobbying
without
cutting
constitutional
right
petition
difficult
delicate
task
action
today
gives
little
guidance
doubt
whether
act
construed
permit
applications
abridge
right
petition
clear
safe
workable
channels
must
maintained
think
point
defects
limitations
condemn
act
clearly
sustain
written
leave
rewriting
congress
congress
know
experience
good
right
petition
evils
professional
lobbying