miami
herald
publishing
tornillo
argued
april
decided
june
appellant
newspaper
refused
print
appellee
replies
editorials
critical
appellee
candidacy
state
office
appellee
brought
suit
florida
circuit
seeking
injunctive
declaratory
relief
damages
based
florida
right
reply
statute
grants
political
candidate
right
equal
space
answer
criticism
attacks
record
newspaper
making
misdemeanor
newspaper
fail
comply
circuit
held
statute
unconstitutional
infringing
freedom
press
dismissed
action
florida
reversed
holding
statute
violate
constitutional
guarantees
civil
remedies
including
damages
available
remanded
trial
proceedings
held
florida
judgment
final
thus
ripe
review
north
dakota
pharmacy
bd
snyder
stores
pp
statute
violates
first
amendment
guarantee
free
press
pp
governmental
compulsion
newspaper
publish
reason
tells
published
unconstitutional
statute
operates
command
state
sense
statute
regulation
forbidding
appellant
publish
specified
matter
statute
exacts
penalty
basis
content
newspaper
imposing
additional
printing
composing
materials
costs
taking
space
devoted
material
newspaper
may
preferred
print
pp
even
newspaper
face
additional
costs
comply
statute
forced
forgo
publication
news
opinion
inclusion
reply
statute
still
fails
clear
first
amendment
barriers
intrusion
function
editors
choosing
material
goes
newspaper
deciding
size
content
paper
treatment
public
issues
officials
burger
delivered
opinion
unanimous
brennan
filed
concurring
statement
rehnquist
joined
post
white
filed
concurring
opinion
post
daniel
paul
argued
cause
appellant
briefs
james
beasley
richard
schmidt
jerome
barron
argued
cause
appellee
brief
tobias
simon
elizabeth
dufresne
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
joseph
califano
richard
cooper
washington
post
robert
lobdell
robert
warren
times
mirror
james
rodgers
new
york
news
reuben
lawrence
gunnels
chicago
tribune
et
al
harold
wahl
florida
publishing
william
ballard
times
publishing
spessard
lindsey
holland
gannett
florida
et
al
arthur
hanson
frank
stickle
ralph
albright
american
newspaper
publishers
assn
william
mullen
national
newspaper
assn
leonard
marks
american
society
newspaper
editors
et
al
lawrence
walsh
guy
miller
struve
reporters
committee
freedom
press
legal
defense
research
fund
et
al
john
summers
national
association
broadcasters
laurent
scharff
radio
television
news
directors
assn
floyd
abrams
corydon
dunham
howard
monderer
national
broadcasting
harry
inman
robert
owen
dow
jones
et
al
jonathan
alpert
irma
robbins
feder
richard
yale
feder
american
civil
liberties
union
florida
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
albert
kramer
thomas
asher
national
citizens
committee
broadcasting
donald
sessions
pro
se
chief
justice
burger
delivered
opinion
issue
case
whether
state
statute
granting
political
candidate
right
equal
space
reply
criticism
attacks
record
newspaper
violates
guarantees
free
press
fall
appellee
executive
director
classroom
teachers
association
apparently
teachers
agent
candidate
florida
house
representatives
september
september
appellant
printed
editorials
critical
appellee
candidacy
response
editorials
appellee
demanded
appellant
print
verbatim
replies
defending
role
classroom
teachers
association
organization
accomplishments
citizens
dade
county
appellant
declined
print
appellee
replies
appellee
brought
suit
circuit
dade
county
seeking
declaratory
injunctive
relief
actual
punitive
damages
excess
action
premised
florida
statute
right
reply
statute
provides
candidate
nomination
election
assailed
regarding
personal
character
official
record
newspaper
candidate
right
demand
newspaper
print
free
cost
candidate
reply
candidate
may
make
newspaper
charges
reply
must
appear
conspicuous
place
kind
type
charges
prompted
reply
provided
take
space
charges
failure
comply
statute
constitutes
misdemeanor
appellant
sought
declaration
unconstitutional
emergency
hearing
requested
appellee
circuit
denied
injunctive
relief
absent
special
circumstances
injunction
properly
issue
commission
crime
held
unconstitutional
infringement
freedom
press
first
fourteenth
amendments
constitution
supp
circuit
concluded
dictating
newspaper
must
print
different
dictating
must
print
circuit
judge
viewed
statute
vagueness
serving
restrict
stifle
protected
expression
appellee
cause
dismissed
prejudice
direct
appeal
florida
reversed
holding
violate
constitutional
guarantees
held
free
speech
enhanced
abridged
florida
statute
view
furthered
broad
societal
interest
free
flow
information
public
also
held
statute
impermissibly
vague
statute
informs
subject
conduct
part
render
liable
penalties
civil
remedies
including
damages
held
available
statute
case
remanded
trial
proceedings
inconsistent
florida
opinion
postponed
consideration
question
jurisdiction
hearing
case
merits
ii
although
parties
contend
jurisdiction
review
judgment
florida
suggestion
initially
made
judgment
florida
might
final
north
dakota
state
pharmacy
bd
snyder
stores
reviewed
judgment
north
dakota
case
remanded
state
proceedings
conducted
respecting
snyder
application
permit
operate
drug
store
held
final
judgment
purposes
jurisdiction
principles
finality
enunciated
snyder
stores
judgment
florida
case
ripe
review
iii
challenged
statute
creates
right
reply
press
criticism
candidate
nomination
election
statute
enacted
second
recorded
case
decided
provisions
appellant
contends
statute
void
face
purports
regulate
content
newspaper
violation
first
amendment
alternatively
urged
statute
void
vagueness
since
editor
know
exactly
words
call
statute
operation
also
contended
statute
fails
distinguish
critical
comment
defamatory
appellee
supporting
advocates
enforceable
right
access
press
vigorously
argue
government
obligation
ensure
wide
variety
views
reach
public
contentions
access
proponents
set
detail
urged
time
first
amendment
constitution
ratified
part
bill
rights
press
broadly
representative
people
serving
many
newspapers
intensely
partisan
narrow
views
press
collectively
presented
broad
range
opinions
readers
entry
publishing
inexpensive
pamphlets
books
provided
meaningful
alternatives
organized
press
expression
unpopular
ideas
often
treated
events
expressed
views
covered
conventional
newspapers
true
marketplace
ideas
existed
relatively
easy
access
channels
communication
access
advocates
submit
although
newspapers
present
superficially
similar
press
today
reality
different
known
early
years
national
existence
past
half
century
communications
revolution
seen
introduction
radio
television
lives
promise
global
community
use
communications
satellites
specter
wired
nation
means
expanding
cable
television
network
capabilities
printed
press
said
escaped
effects
revolution
newspapers
become
big
business
far
fewer
serve
larger
literate
population
chains
newspapers
national
newspapers
national
wire
news
services
towns
dominant
features
press
become
noncompetitive
enormously
powerful
influential
capacity
manipulate
popular
opinion
change
course
events
major
metropolitan
newspapers
collaborated
establish
news
services
national
scope
national
news
organizations
provide
syndicated
interpretive
reporting
well
syndicated
features
commentary
serve
part
new
school
advocacy
journalism
elimination
competing
newspapers
large
cities
concentration
control
media
results
newspaper
owned
interests
television
station
radio
station
important
components
trend
toward
concentration
control
outlets
inform
public
result
vast
changes
place
hands
power
inform
american
people
shape
public
opinion
much
editorial
opinion
commentary
printed
syndicated
columnists
distributed
nationwide
result
told
national
world
issues
tends
homogeneity
editorial
opinion
commentary
interpretive
analysis
abuses
bias
manipulative
reportage
likewise
said
result
vast
accumulations
unreviewable
power
modern
media
empires
effect
claimed
public
lost
ability
respond
contribute
meaningful
way
debate
issues
monopoly
means
communication
allows
little
critical
analysis
media
except
professional
journals
limited
readership
concentration
nationwide
news
organizations
like
large
institutions
grown
increasingly
remote
unresponsive
popular
constituencies
depend
depend
report
task
force
twentieth
century
fund
task
force
report
national
news
council
free
responsive
press
obvious
solution
available
dissidents
earlier
time
entry
publishing
relatively
inexpensive
today
additional
newspapers
economic
factors
caused
disappearance
vast
numbers
metropolitan
newspapers
made
entry
marketplace
ideas
served
print
media
almost
impossible
urged
claim
newspapers
surrogates
public
carries
concomitant
fiduciary
obligation
account
stewardship
premise
reasoned
effective
way
insure
fairness
accuracy
provide
accountability
government
take
affirmative
action
first
amendment
interest
public
informed
said
peril
marketplace
ideas
today
monopoly
controlled
owners
market
proponents
enforced
access
press
take
comfort
language
several
decisions
suggests
first
amendment
acts
sword
well
shield
imposes
obligations
owners
press
addition
protecting
press
government
regulation
associated
press
rejecting
argument
press
immune
antitrust
laws
virtue
first
amendment
stated
first
amendment
far
providing
argument
application
sherman
act
provides
powerful
reasons
contrary
amendment
rests
assumption
widest
possible
dissemination
information
diverse
antagonistic
sources
essential
welfare
public
free
press
condition
free
society
surely
command
government
shall
impede
free
flow
ideas
afford
combinations
refuge
impose
restraints
upon
constitutionally
guaranteed
freedom
freedom
publish
means
freedom
freedom
publish
guaranteed
constitution
freedom
combine
keep
others
publishing
freedom
press
governmental
interference
first
amendment
sanction
repression
freedom
private
interests
omitted
access
advocates
note
justice
douglas
decade
ago
expressed
deep
concern
regarding
effects
newspaper
monopolies
one
paper
monopoly
area
seldom
presents
two
sides
issue
often
hammers
away
one
ideological
political
line
using
monopoly
position
educate
people
promote
debate
inculcate
readers
one
philosophy
one
attitude
make
money
newspapers
give
variety
views
news
slanted
contrived
indeed
problem
promises
get
worse
great
rights
cahn
ed
iv
however
much
validity
may
found
arguments
point
implementation
remedy
enforceable
right
access
necessarily
calls
mechanism
either
governmental
consensual
governmental
coercion
brings
confrontation
express
provisions
first
amendment
judicial
gloss
amendment
developed
years
foresaw
problems
relating
access
early
decision
associated
press
supra
carefully
contrasted
private
compulsion
print
called
association
bylaws
provisions
district
decree
appellants
compel
ap
members
permit
publication
anything
reason
tells
published
branzburg
hayes
emphasized
cases
us
involve
intrusions
upon
speech
assembly
prior
restraint
restriction
press
may
publish
express
implied
command
press
publish
prefers
withhold
columbia
broadcasting
system
democratic
national
committee
plurality
opinion
part
iii
noted
power
privately
owned
newspaper
advance
political
social
economic
views
bounded
two
factors
first
acceptance
sufficient
number
readers
hence
advertisers
assure
financial
success
second
journalistic
integrity
editors
publishers
fortiori
decision
authorize
restriction
whatever
whether
content
layout
stories
commentary
originated
pittsburgh
press
columnists
contributors
contrary
reaffirm
unequivocally
protection
afforded
editorial
judgment
free
expression
views
issues
however
controversial
see
beginning
associated
press
supra
expressed
sensitivity
whether
restriction
requirement
constituted
compulsion
exerted
government
newspaper
print
otherwise
print
clear
implication
compulsion
publish
reason
tells
published
unconstitutional
responsible
press
undoubtedly
desirable
goal
press
responsibility
mandated
constitution
like
many
virtues
legislated
appellee
argument
florida
statute
amount
restriction
appellant
right
speak
statute
question
prevented
miami
herald
saying
anything
wished
begs
core
question
compelling
editors
publishers
publish
reason
tells
published
issue
case
florida
statute
operates
command
sense
statute
regulation
forbidding
appellant
publish
specified
matter
governmental
restraint
publishing
need
fall
familiar
traditional
patterns
subject
constitutional
limitations
governmental
powers
grosjean
american
press
florida
statute
exacts
penalty
basis
content
newspaper
first
phase
penalty
resulting
compelled
printing
reply
exacted
terms
cost
printing
composing
time
materials
taking
space
devoted
material
newspaper
may
preferred
print
correct
appellee
contends
newspaper
subject
finite
technological
limitations
time
confront
broadcaster
correct
say
economic
reality
newspaper
proceed
infinite
expansion
column
space
accommodate
replies
government
agency
determines
statute
commands
readers
available
faced
penalties
accrue
newspaper
published
news
commentary
arguably
within
reach
statute
editors
might
well
conclude
safe
course
avoid
controversy
therefore
operation
florida
statute
political
electoral
coverage
blunted
reduced
right
access
inescapably
dampens
vigor
limits
variety
public
debate
new
york
times
sullivan
mills
alabama
stated
practically
universal
agreement
major
purpose
first
amendment
protect
free
discussion
governmental
affairs
course
includes
discussions
candidates
ordered
footnotes
state
laws
pat
tornillo
look
upholding
law
pat
tornillo
boss
classroom
teachers
association
candidate
state
legislature
runoff
election
denounced
opponent
lacking
knowledge
legislator
evidenced
failure
file
list
contributions
expenditures
campaign
required
law
czar
tornillo
calls
violation
law
inexcusable
pat
tornillo
led
cta
strike
february
march
school
children
taxpayers
dade
country
call
whatever
illegal
act
public
interest
clearly
prohibited
statutes
say
illegal
certainly
inexcusable
voters
sent
pat
tornillo
tallahassee
occupy
seat
district
house
representatives
people
brought
teacher
strike
come
instructions
vote
responsible
government
crutcher
harrison
ethel
beckham
pat
tornillo
tracts
blurbs
bumper
stickers
pile
daily
teachers
school
mailboxes
amidst
continuing
pouts
school
board
delivering
expense
screeds
say
strike
issue
say
maybe
part
continuation
disregard
laws
cta
might
find
aggravating
whether
defiance
zoning
laws
cta
towers
contracts
laws
strike
recently
state
prohibitions
soliciting
campaign
funds
amongst
teachers
cta
says
fie
try
sue
us
good
cta
good
cta
natural
law
tornillo
law
maybe
years
kicking
public
shin
call
attention
shakedown
statesmanship
whichever
acerbic
prexy
alleged
office
always
felt
private
ventures
public
weal
leap
chance
nab
tab
half
glorious
leader
salary
dues
checkoff
anything
else
except
perhaps
mileage
staff
hydrofoil
give
public
office
says
pat
doubt
live
golden
rule
translation
reads
gold
rule
newspaper
assailing
candidate
election
space
reply
newspaper
columns
assails
personal
character
candidate
nomination
election
election
charges
said
candidate
malfeasance
misfeasance
office
otherwise
attacks
official
record
gives
another
free
space
purpose
newspaper
shall
upon
request
candidate
immediately
publish
free
cost
reply
may
make
thereto
conspicuous
place
kind
type
matter
calls
reply
provided
reply
take
space
matter
replied
person
firm
failing
comply
provisions
section
shall
guilty
misdemeanor
first
degree
punishable
provided
disturb
circuit
holding
injunctive
relief
proper
case
even
statute
constitutional
according
neither
side
took
issue
part
circuit
decision
placed
following
limiting
construction
statute
hold
mandate
statute
refers
reply
wholly
responsive
charge
made
editorial
article
newspaper
replied
reply
neither
libelous
slanderous
publication
anyone
else
vulgar
profane
appellee
response
appellant
jurisdictional
statement
motion
affirm
judgment
alternative
dismiss
appeal
appellant
appellee
claim
uncertainty
constitutional
validity
restricts
present
exercise
first
amendment
rights
brief
appellant
brief
appellee
appellant
finds
urgency
present
consideration
constitutionality
statute
upcoming
elections
whichever
way
decide
merits
intolerable
leave
unanswered
circumstances
important
question
freedom
press
first
amendment
uneasy
unsettled
constitutional
posture
harm
operation
free
press
mills
alabama
douglas
concurring
see
also
organization
better
austin
keefe
first
test
statute
declared
unconstitutional
state
supp
volusia
county
judge
neither
two
suits
instant
action
action
florida
attorney
general
defended
statute
constitutionality
see
generally
barron
access
press
new
first
amendment
right
harv
rev
good
overview
position
access
advocates
see
lange
role
access
doctrine
regulation
mass
media
critical
review
assessment
rev
hereinafter
lange
congress
shall
make
law
respecting
establishment
religion
prohibiting
free
exercise
thereof
abridging
freedom
speech
press
right
people
peaceably
assemble
petition
government
redress
grievances
see
commission
freedom
press
free
responsible
press
hereinafter
sometimes
commission
commission
even
last
years
significant
increase
number
people
likely
read
newspapers
bagdikian
fat
newspapers
slim
coverage
columbia
journalism
review
nearly
half
daily
newspapers
representing
daily
sunday
circulation
owned
newspaper
groups
chains
including
diversified
business
conglomerates
towns
become
rule
effective
competition
operating
percent
large
cities
background
paper
alfred
balk
twentieth
century
fund
task
force
report
national
news
council
free
responsive
press
report
task
force
twentieth
century
fund
task
force
report
national
news
council
free
responsive
press
local
monopoly
printed
news
raises
serious
questions
diversity
information
opinion
local
newspaper
print
local
affairs
see
general
print
power
take
initiative
reporting
enunciation
opinions
extraordinary
power
set
atmosphere
determine
terms
local
consideration
public
issues
bagdikian
information
machines
newspapers
persuaded
congress
grant
immunity
antitrust
laws
case
failing
newspapers
joint
operations
stat
et
seq
freedom
press
right
belonging
like
rights
democracy
people
practical
matter
however
exercised
effective
access
press
financial
economic
technological
conditions
limit
access
small
minority
exercise
right
minority
takes
fiduciary
characteristics
macleish
hocking
freedom
press
italics
omitted
fear
private
citizens
able
respond
adequately
publicity
involving
solution
lies
direction
ensuring
ability
respond
rather
stifling
public
discussion
matters
public
concern
fn
fn
adopted
retraction
statutes
statutes
one
writer
arguing
first
amendment
read
guarantee
right
access
media
limited
right
respond
defamatory
falsehoods
suggested
several
ways
law
might
encourage
public
discussion
barron
access
press
new
first
amendment
right
harv
rev
important
recognize
private
individual
often
desires
press
exposure
either
ideas
causes
constitutional
adjudication
must
take
account
individual
interest
access
press
well
individual
interest
preserving
reputation
even
though
libel
actions
nature
encourage
narrow
view
individual
interest
since
focus
situations
individual
harmed
undesired
press
attention
constitutional
rule
deters
press
covering
ideas
activities
private
individual
thus
conceives
individual
interest
narrowly
national
news
council
independent
voluntary
body
concerned
press
fairness
created
provide
means
neutral
examination
claims
press
inaccuracy
council
created
following
publication
twentieth
century
fund
task
force
report
national
news
council
free
responsive
press
background
paper
attached
report
dealt
detail
british
press
council
seen
author
paper
interest
european
press
councils
hold
violates
first
amendment
guarantee
free
press
occasion
consider
appellant
argument
statute
unconstitutionally
vague
brief
appellee
however
since
amount
space
newspaper
devote
live
news
finite
newspaper
forced
publish
particular
item
must
practical
matter
omit
something
else
number
column
inches
available
news
predetermined
number
financial
physical
factors
including
circulation
amount
advertising
increasingly
availability
newsprint
note
tulane
rev
one
omitted
see
description
likely
effect
florida
statute
publishers
lange
iberty
press
peril
soon
government
tries
compel
go
newspaper
journal
merely
print
observed
facts
way
cow
photographed
plateglass
window
soon
facts
set
context
interpretation
selection
editorial
selection
opens
way
editorial
suppression
state
force
abstention
discrimination
news
without
dictating
selection
chafee
government
mass
communications
justice
brennan
justice
rehnquist
joins
concurring
join
opinion
understand
addresses
right
reply
statutes
implies
view
upon
constitutionality
retraction
statutes
affording
plaintiffs
able
prove
defamatory
falsehoods
statutory
action
require
publication
retraction
see
generally
note
vindication
reputation
public
official
harv
rev
justice
white
concurring
today
holds
first
amendment
bars
state
requiring
newspaper
print
reply
candidate
public
office
whose
personal
character
criticized
newspaper
editorials
according
accepted
jurisprudence
first
amendment
erects
virtually
insurmountable
barrier
government
print
media
far
government
tampering
advance
publication
news
editorial
content
concerned
new
york
times
newspaper
magazine
public
utility
subject
reasonable
governmental
regulation
matters
affecting
exercise
journalistic
judgment
shall
printed
cf
mills
alabama
learned
continue
learn
view
unhappy
experiences
nations
government
allowed
meddle
internal
editorial
affairs
newspapers
regardless
purposes
controlling
press
might
prefer
power
reason
applied
public
discussion
remain
intensely
skeptical
measures
allow
government
insinuate
editorial
rooms
nation
press
whatever
differences
may
exist
interpretations
first
amendment
practically
universal
agreement
major
purpose
amendment
protect
free
discussion
governmental
affairs
course
includes
discussions
candidates
structures
forms
government
manner
government
operated
operated
matters
relating
political
processes
constitution
specifically
selected
press
play
important
role
discussion
public
affairs
thus
press
serves
designed
serve
powerful
antidote
abuses
power
governmental
officials
constitutionally
chosen
means
keeping
officials
elected
people
responsible
people
selected
serve
suppression
right
press
praise
criticize
governmental
agents
clamor
contend
change
muzzles
one
agencies
framers
constitution
thoughtfully
deliberately
selected
improve
society
keep
free
mills
alabama
supra
justify
statute
florida
advances
concededly
important
interest
ensuring
free
fair
elections
means
electorate
informed
issues
prior
compulsion
government
matters
going
nerve
center
newspaper
decision
copy
included
given
edition
collides
first
amendment
woven
fabric
first
amendment
unexceptionable
nonetheless
timeless
sentiment
liberty
press
peril
soon
government
tries
compel
go
newspaper
chafee
government
mass
communications
constitutionally
obnoxious
feature
florida
legislature
may
also
placed
high
premium
protection
individual
reputational
interests
government
certainly
pervasive
strong
interest
preventing
redressing
attacks
upon
reputation
rosenblatt
baer
quite
contrary
law
runs
afoul
elementary
first
amendment
proposition
government
may
force
newspaper
print
copy
journalistic
discretion
chooses
leave
newsroom
floor
whatever
power
may
reside
government
influence
publishing
certain
narrowly
circumscribed
categories
material
see
pittsburgh
press
human
relations
new
york
times
white
concurring
never
thought
first
amendment
permitted
public
officials
dictate
press
contents
news
columns
slant
editorials
though
newspaper
may
publish
without
government
censorship
never
entirely
free
liability
chooses
print
see
ibid
among
things
press
wholly
liberty
publish
falsehoods
damaging
individual
reputation
least
today
cherished
average
citizen
reputation
interest
enough
afford
fair
chance
vindicate
action
libel
characteristically
provided
state
law
unable
force
press
tell
side
story
print
retraction
least
opportunity
win
judgment
able
prove
falsity
damaging
publication
well
fair
chance
recover
reasonable
damages
injury
reaffirming
rule
press
forced
print
answer
personal
attack
made
however
throws
stark
relief
consequences
new
balance
forged
companion
case
also
announced
today
gertz
robert
welch
post
goes
far
toward
eviscerating
effectiveness
ordinary
libel
action
long
potent
response
available
private
citizen
libeled
press
gertz
burden
proving
liability
immeasurably
increased
proving
damages
made
exceedingly
difficult
vindicating
reputation
merely
proving
falsehood
winning
judgment
effect
wholly
foreclosed
needlessly
view
trivializes
denigrates
interest
reputation
removing
virtually
protection
law
always
afforded
course
two
decisions
mean
government
may
dictate
press
print
neither
afford
remedy
libel
form
gertz
leaves
putative
remedy
libel
intact
albeit
severely
emaciated
form
press
certainly
remains
liable
knowing
reckless
falsehoods
new
york
times
sullivan
progeny
however
improper
injunction
publication
might
one
need
think
less
first
amendment
sustain
reasonable
methods
allowing
average
citizen
redeem
falsely
tarnished
reputation
one
doubt
genuine
decency
integrity
good
sense
vast
majority
professional
journalists
support
right
individual
day
falsely
maligned
public
press
press
servant
master
citizenry
freedom
carry
unrestricted
hunting
license
prey
ordinary
citizen
plain
english
freedom
carries
responsibility
even
press
freedom
press
freedom
responsibility
exercise
without
lively
sense
responsibility
free
press
may
readily
become
powerful
instrument
injustice
pennekamp
florida
frankfurter
concurring
omitted
whitney
california
brandeis
concurring
letter
charles
yancey
writings
thomas
jefferson
lipscomb
ed