com
pennsylvania
state
west
virginia
argued
april
decided
june
john
davis
new
york
city
john
price
freeman
eagleson
columbus
ohio
altizer
charleston
edward
corn
ironton
ohio
state
ohio
hoffheimer
clarksburg
england
fred
blue
charleston
philip
steptoe
clarksburg
john
morgantown
state
west
virginia
geo
alter
pittsburgh
schaffer
chester
leo
weil
pittsburgh
commonwealth
wealth
pennsylvania
justice
van
devanter
delivered
opinion
suits
one
commonwealth
pennsylvania
state
ohio
enjoin
state
west
virginia
enforcing
act
passed
legislature
acts
complainants
believe
largely
curtail
cut
supply
natural
gas
heretofore
carried
pipe
lines
west
virginia
territory
sold
used
fuel
lighting
purposes
although
distinct
suits
much
alike
presented
bar
substantially
single
case
dealt
accordingly
opinion
west
virginia
act
set
forth
length
margin
complainants
challenge
validity
ground
directly
interferes
interstate
commerce
therefore
contravenes
commerce
clause
constitution
article
cl
rest
right
relief
grounds
enforce
act
subject
irreparable
injury
respect
many
public
institutions
governmental
agencies
long
using
gas
subject
incalculable
injury
imperil
health
comfort
thousands
people
use
gas
homes
largely
dependent
thereon
halt
curtail
many
industries
seasonally
use
great
quantities
gas
wherein
thousands
persons
employed
millions
taxable
wealth
invested
conditions
suits
arisen
facts
material
disposal
follows
natural
gas
found
pronounced
depths
porous
sand
natural
reservoir
brought
surface
reduced
possession
wells
drilled
containing
strata
surface
owner
thus
reduces
possession
becomes
owner
becomes
subject
commerce
like
product
forest
field
mine
inclosing
strata
great
pressure
called
rock
pressure
causes
flow
rapidly
strata
penetrated
one
surface
owner
drills
wells
begins
draw
gas
others
desiring
exercise
common
right
must
take
course
otherwise
lands
may
drained
wells
gas
drawn
inclosing
strata
practicable
mode
storing
holding
must
used
promptly
chief
use
consists
producing
heat
light
burning
points
use
generally
centers
population
industry
less
remote
places
production
intervening
transmission
effected
pipe
lines
normal
rock
pressure
carry
gas
considerable
distances
pressure
wanes
inadequate
supplemented
using
compressors
west
virginia
production
natural
gas
began
much
years
ago
last
years
greater
state
producing
fields
include
counties
first
gas
produced
course
oil
operations
regarded
nuisance
permitted
waste
air
soon
came
regarded
valuable
heating
lighting
economy
convenience
attending
use
made
preferred
fuel
use
within
state
became
relatively
general
far
less
production
producers
turned
neighboring
notably
pennsylvania
ohio
market
west
virginia
sanctioned
effort
permitted
formation
laws
corporations
purpose
constructing
pipe
lines
gas
fields
carrying
gas
latter
selling
also
permitted
corporations
come
territory
purpose
extended
companies
use
power
eminent
domain
acquiring
rights
way
pipe
lines
way
require
assert
power
require
consumers
within
limits
preferred
consumers
elsewhere
effort
find
market
succeeded
gas
came
extensively
carried
pennsylvania
far
pittsburgh
ohio
far
cleveland
toledo
cincinnati
way
entire
production
made
value
producers
landowners
lessees
gas
fields
greatly
benefited
taxable
wealth
state
largely
increased
approximately
invested
west
virginia
miles
pipe
lines
miles
trunk
lines
pipe
lines
reach
producing
fields
areas
consumption
pennsylvania
ohio
connect
near
state
line
others
leading
consuming
areas
operated
continuous
flow
gas
points
production
points
use
branch
lines
divert
gas
intervening
points
without
changing
general
flow
several
lines
cross
recross
state
boundary
repeatedly
pipe
lines
operated
public
utilities
supplying
gas
public
true
pennsylvania
ohio
well
west
virginia
lines
long
supplying
gas
three
use
charitable
educational
penal
institutions
counties
municipalities
use
county
city
school
buildings
local
utilities
serving
particular
communities
people
generally
many
cities
towns
use
homes
places
business
offices
seasons
adequate
supply
industrial
plants
use
operation
predominant
use
fuel
purposes
lighting
relatively
small
gas
going
pennsylvania
ohio
carried
supplied
prior
engagements
respecting
long
time
contracts
exacted
preferred
purchasers
consumers
experience
gas
fields
shown
multiplied
prolonged
drafts
natural
supply
exhaust
since
apparent
older
portions
west
virginia
fields
approaching
exhaustion
produc
ion
fields
reached
passed
maximum
newer
portions
however
judgment
informed
operators
make
fields
commercially
productive
several
years
latterly
colder
november
may
combined
needs
domestic
industrial
consumers
largely
excess
production
pipe
line
companies
generally
adopted
pursuing
policy
preferring
domestic
consumers
months
contracts
contain
provisions
admitting
preference
months
little
occasion
heating
homes
offices
needs
domestic
consumers
drop
materially
much
gas
may
supplied
industrial
use
without
affecting
domestic
use
increased
population
enlarged
west
advantages
inhering
gas
fuel
finally
resulted
gross
demand
satisfied
even
summer
months
present
actual
consumption
production
sustain
pipe
line
companies
supply
gas
west
virginia
without
cutting
carry
pennsylvania
ohio
carry
pennsylvania
ohio
without
cutting
supply
west
virginia
short
situation
constrain
companies
supply
gas
one
three
necessarily
constrain
supply
less
two
billion
cubic
feet
gas
produced
west
virginia
billion
consumed
within
state
without
becoming
available
public
billion
became
available
hands
pipe
line
companies
companies
supplied
billion
consumers
state
carried
billion
consumers
outside
also
brought
billion
state
gas
fields
outside
extent
enlarged
amount
supplied
local
consumers
amount
billion
went
domestic
use
billion
industrial
use
major
part
gas
carried
pennsylvania
went
industrial
consumers
major
part
carried
ohio
went
domestic
consumers
gas
carried
outside
state
sold
used
therein
naturally
considering
additional
pipe
lines
compressors
labor
employed
longer
transmission
proportion
marketed
beyond
state
varied
much
practically
years
ago
discrimination
consumers
inside
state
dealt
plane
others
companies
declined
quit
existing
service
communities
consumers
outside
serve
inside
nothing
invidious
line
fair
treatment
rather
discrimination
gas
carried
pennsylvania
ohio
respectively
supplied
state
municipal
agencies
strictly
public
use
negligible
amounts
billions
cubic
feet
per
year
fuel
food
cooked
water
heated
thousands
dependents
charitable
penal
institutions
hundreds
schoolhouses
heated
made
comfortable
thousands
children
municipal
waterworks
operated
several
cities
notably
cincinnati
toledo
heating
appliances
adjusted
use
make
changes
incident
substituting
fuel
involve
expenditure
state
large
sum
public
money
pennsylvania
gas
used
domestic
consumers
caring
people
ohio
domestic
consumers
caring
people
natural
gas
service
available
change
fuel
require
adjustment
heating
cooking
appliances
average
cost
domestic
consumer
aggregate
cost
exceeding
pennsylvania
nd
ohio
act
whose
enforcement
sought
enjoined
passed
legislature
west
virginia
february
went
effect
may
following
suits
brought
eight
days
thereafter
direction
legislatures
complainant
leave
interlocutory
injunctions
prayed
granted
outset
still
force
three
questions
bearing
propriety
entertaining
suits
raised
soon
suits
begun
consideration
postponed
final
hearing
first
question
whether
suits
involve
justiciable
controversy
sense
judiciary
article
constitution
opinion
every
element
controversy
present
suit
presents
direct
issue
two
whether
one
may
withdraw
natural
product
common
subject
commercial
dealings
established
current
commerce
moving
territory
complainant
state
asserts
defendant
state
denies
withdrawal
interference
interstate
commerce
forbidden
constitution
essentially
judicial
question
concededly
suits
private
parties
course
character
different
suit
sought
abstract
ruling
question
injunction
withdrawal
presently
threatened
likely
productive
great
injury
purpose
withdraw
shown
enactment
defendant
state
set
forth
carried
effect
officers
acting
name
command
state
principal
action
officers
rightly
may
imputed
even
though
suit
injunction
might
lie
attitude
complainant
mere
volunteers
attempting
vindicate
freedom
interstate
commerce
redress
purely
private
grievances
sues
protect
twofold
proprietor
various
public
institutions
schools
whose
supply
gas
largely
curtailed
cut
threatened
interference
interstate
current
representative
consuming
public
whose
supply
similarly
affected
interests
substantial
threatened
serious
injury
state
uses
large
amounts
gas
several
institutions
greater
part
discharge
duties
relatively
imperative
break
cessation
supply
embarrass
greatly
discharge
duties
expose
thousands
dependents
school
children
serous
discomfort
substitute
another
form
fuel
involve
large
public
expenditures
private
consumers
state
include
inhabitants
many
urban
communities
constitute
substantial
portion
state
population
health
comfort
welfare
seriously
jeopardized
threatened
withdrawal
gas
interstate
stream
matter
grave
public
concern
state
representative
public
interest
apart
individuals
affected
merely
remote
ethical
interest
one
immediate
recognized
law
principle
views
full
support
prior
decisions
missouri
illinois
sup
sup
kansas
colorado
sup
sup
georgia
tennessee
copper
sup
ann
cas
new
york
new
jersey
sup
wyoming
colorado
sup
defendant
state
relies
cases
new
hampshire
louisiana
sup
louisiana
texas
sup
kansas
sup
oklahoma
atchison
topeka
santa
fe
ry
sup
texas
interstate
commerce
commission
sup
facts
turned
opinions
show
widely
different
point
second
question
whether
suits
brought
prematurely
brought
days
west
virginia
act
went
force
order
made
public
service
commission
tested
actual
practice
prove
suits
premature
course
otherwise
appeared
act
certainly
operate
complainant
apprehended
one
await
consummation
threatened
injury
obtain
preventive
relief
injury
certainly
impending
enough
turning
act
find
first
section
lays
every
pipe
line
company
positive
extent
supply
gas
produced
state
whether
produced
satisfy
needs
whether
domestic
industrial
use
intending
consumers
whether
old
new
willing
pay
gas
want
use
within
section
state
produced
transported
wherein
supplied
others
substantive
provision
whose
terms
direct
certain
immediate
obedience
commanded
order
commission
required
give
precision
make
obligatory
leaves
nothing
discretion
enforce
contrary
prescribes
definite
rule
conduct
puts
rule
force
imposes
unconditional
mandatory
duty
counsel
state
admit
obviously
intended
enforce
preferred
recognition
satisfaction
needs
consumers
within
state
present
prospective
regardless
effect
interstate
stream
consumers
outside
state
second
section
invests
commission
finding
notice
hearing
company
supplying
gas
local
needs
probably
without
adequate
supply
order
another
company
gas
excess
required
within
state
furnish
company
whose
supply
inadequate
gas
make
deficiency
alternative
undertake
supply
local
needs
extent
excess
provision
like
first
shows
purpose
give
local
consumers
present
prospective
preferred
status
permit
surplus
gas
carried
fourth
section
empowers
commission
entertain
complaints
persons
aggrieved
affected
act
require
violation
discontinued
act
obeyed
subject
right
review
courts
also
provides
means
compelling
obedience
act
pending
proceedings
commission
decision
review
sections
contain
penal
remedial
provisions
designed
make
described
effective
one
fifth
section
declares
day
company
officers
agents
employees
fail
observe
comply
order
direction
commission
perform
duty
enjoined
act
shall
constitute
separate
disti
ct
violation
another
sixth
section
subjects
company
violating
act
action
damages
one
claiming
wronged
violation
regard
entirely
clear
act
intended
compel
retention
within
state
whatever
gas
may
required
meet
local
needs
purposes
procedural
penal
remedial
provisions
amply
adequate
accomplish
result
think
equally
clear
allegations
bills
established
evidence
situation
suits
brought
act
directly
immediately
work
large
curtailment
volume
gas
moving
complainant
indeed
conclusion
unavoidable
increasing
demand
west
virginia
decreasing
production
act
years
work
practical
cessation
interstate
stream
must
held
therefore
suits
brought
prematurely
third
question
whether
requisite
parties
brought
suits
objected
pipe
line
companies
brought
nothing
makes
presence
essential
complainant
make
complaint
seek
relief
supplying
gas
evidently
continue
restrained
prevented
defendant
state
complainant
controversy
also
objected
consumers
defendant
state
benefited
act
enforced
representation
suits
misconception
represented
state
nothing
situation
requiring
specially
represented
brought
equal
basis
objected
suit
prevent
enforcement
statute
reducing
railroad
freight
rates
one
prevent
enforcement
municipal
ordinance
reducing
telephone
electric
light
rates
shippers
users
benefited
reduction
must
specially
represented
brought
objection
course
untenable
objection
turn
principal
issue
whether
state
wherein
natural
gas
produced
recognized
subject
commercial
dealings
may
require
sale
disposal
consumers
state
shall
accorded
preferred
right
purchase
consumers
requirement
necessarily
operate
withdraw
large
volume
gas
established
interstate
current
whereby
supplied
consumers
course
last
analysis
question
whether
enforced
withdrawal
bene
fit
local
consumers
interference
interstate
commerce
forbidden
state
constitution
question
important
one
one
state
may
others
may
natural
gas
exported
consumption
besides
may
done
one
natural
product
may
done
others
several
earth
yields
products
great
value
carried
used
notwithstanding
importance
question
solution
difficult
controlling
principles
settled
many
closely
point
discussion
may
relatively
brief
constitution
article
cl
power
regulate
interstate
commerce
expressly
committed
congress
therefore
impliedly
forbidden
purpose
protect
commercial
intercourse
invidious
restraints
prevent
interference
conflicting
hostile
state
laws
insure
uniformity
regulation
means
matter
interstate
commerce
single
people
assented
alike
bound
equally
protected
even
th
ir
power
lay
collect
taxes
comprehensive
necessary
power
exerted
way
involves
discrimination
commerce
ward
maryland
wall
welton
missouri
webber
virginia
coe
errol
sup
guy
baltimore
robbins
shelby
taxing
district
sup
natural
gas
lawful
article
commerce
transmission
one
state
another
sale
consumption
latter
interstate
commerce
state
law
whether
state
gas
produced
sold
necessary
operation
prevents
obstructs
burdens
transmission
regulation
interstate
prohibited
interference
west
kansas
natural
gas
sup
public
utilities
landon
sup
fuel
gas
hallanan
sup
milling
bondurant
sup
lemke
farmers
grain
sup
western
union
telegraph
foster
sup
minnesota
barber
sup
brimmer
rebman
sup
west
virginia
act
law
provisions
conditions
must
surround
operation
necessarily
directly
compel
diversion
local
consumers
large
increasing
part
gas
heretofore
going
consumers
complainant
therefore
work
serious
interference
commerce
urged
special
considerations
take
act
general
rule
sustain
validity
even
though
interference
one
pipe
line
companies
engaged
supplying
gas
public
west
virginia
quasi
public
business
act
require
companies
furnish
reasonably
adequate
service
within
reasonable
territorial
limits
true
business
quasi
public
character
pennsylvania
ohio
well
west
virginia
obligations
inhering
power
insist
adequate
service
three
supply
gas
necessarily
marks
extent
service
rendered
much
business
interstate
grown
course
years
west
virginia
encouraged
sanctioned
development
part
business
profited
greatly
present
effort
rightly
understood
subordinate
part
local
business
within
borders
words
effect
attempt
regulate
interstate
business
advantage
local
consumers
may
direction
one
railroads
short
facilities
moving
coal
haul
intrastate
coal
exclusion
interstate
coal
different
kind
force
another
consideration
advanced
end
gas
natural
product
state
become
necessity
therein
supply
waning
longer
sufficient
satisfy
local
needs
used
abroad
act
therefore
legitimate
measure
conservation
interest
people
state
situation
stated
affords
ground
assumption
state
power
regulate
interstate
commerce
act
attempts
power
lodged
elsewhere
contention
essence
presented
considered
west
kansas
natural
gas
sup
case
involving
validity
oklahoma
statute
designed
accomplish
retention
natural
gas
within
state
district
case
heard
bill
answer
proceeding
allegations
fact
answer
taken
true
hearing
resulted
decree
adjudging
statute
invalid
enjoining
enforcement
decree
affirmed
answer
opinion
shows
alleged
physical
conditions
made
apparent
gas
field
relatively
short
duration
cities
near
field
people
needed
gas
state
embodied
prairie
land
devoid
timber
local
fuel
supply
excepting
coal
natural
gas
production
coal
growing
rapidly
costly
natural
practical
usable
fuel
domestic
industrial
use
natural
gas
pipe
lines
plaintiffs
intending
construct
put
operation
permitted
carry
gas
supply
speedily
exhausted
referring
allegations
contention
ruling
principle
statute
conservation
needed
natural
resource
said
sup
results
contention
repel
acceptance
gas
reduced
possession
commodity
belongs
owner
land
reduced
possession
individual
property
subject
sale
may
subject
intrastate
commerce
interstate
commerce
statute
oklahoma
recognizes
subject
intrastate
commerce
seeks
prohibit
subject
interstate
commerce
purpose
conservation
words
purpose
conservation
sense
business
welfare
state
coal
might
timber
products
may
limited
amount
consideration
public
welfare
confine
gas
use
inhabitants
state
confine
inhabitants
state
power
singular
situation
might
result
pennsylvania
might
keep
coal
northwest
timber
mining
minerals
may
products
field
brought
within
principle
thus
enlarged
without
enlargement
influence
interstate
commerce
need
pointed
consequences
power
tend
one
state
embargo
may
retaliated
embargo
commerce
halted
state
lines
yet
said
matters
foreign
interstate
commerce
state
lines
commerce
instead
new
power
appears
new
welfare
welfare
transcends
state
rather
let
us
say
constituted
welfare
state
made
greater
division
resources
natural
created
every
state
every
state
purpose
result
interstate
commerce
clause
constitution
turning
backward
must
done
authority
another
instrumentality
finally
urged
prescribe
execute
regulations
respecting
apportionment
use
gas
among
three
therefore
bills
dismissed
conclusion
follow
premise
object
suits
obtain
decretal
regulations
enjoin
enforcement
west
virginia
act
ground
unconstitutional
enactment
intended
enforcement
subject
complainant
injury
serious
magnitude
full
consideration
reach
conclusion
act
unconstitutional
apprehensions
complainant
respecting
injur
ensue
enforcement
well
founded
obviously
operate
inequitably
situation
appropriate
decree
one
declaring
act
invalid
enjoining
enforcement
dismiss
bills
leave
act
enforced
quite
inadmissible
need
regulating
interstate
commerce
involved
regulation
sought
body
power
resides
decrees
complainants
justice
holmes
dissenting
statute
seeks
reach
natural
gas
begun
move
commerce
kind
addresses
gas
hereafter
collected
uses
first
must
applied
gas
collected
subject
law
valid
moment
yet
matter
commerce
among
think
products
state
actually
started
point
outside
may
regulated
state
notwithstanding
commerce
clause
oliver
iron
mining
lord
sup
ed
may
held
state
might
levy
occupation
tax
upon
mining
iron
ore
equal
six
per
cent
value
ore
produced
previous
year
although
substantially
ore
left
state
put
upon
cars
purpose
single
movement
severed
bed
case
state
product
certainly
destined
interstate
commerce
put
upon
cars
act
produced
yet
interstate
commerce
tax
sustained
know
relevant
distinction
taxing
regulating
ways
mcculloch
maryland
wheat
held
authorized
regulate
ways
closely
resembling
present
sligh
kirkwood
sup
state
law
sustained
made
criminal
sell
offer
shipment
citrus
fruits
immature
otherwise
unfit
consumption
upon
grounds
local
policy
intercepted
got
stream
object
interstate
commerce
local
interest
present
case
greater
obvious
green
oranges
power
state
preserve
food
supply
people
game
laws
notwithstanding
indirect
interference
interstate
commerce
established
geer
connecticut
sup
silz
hesterberg
sup
difference
property
rights
state
game
gas
still
ground
concern
plaintiffs
plain
decisions
cited
depend
upon
speculative
view
title
see
missouri
holland
sup
right
state
regulate
use
natural
gas
prevent
waste
sustained
fourteenth
amendment
walls
midland
carbon
sup
suppose
plaintiffs
fared
better
invoked
commerce
clause
need
refer
prohibition
manufacture
articles
intended
export
colored
oleomargarine
capital
city
dairy
ohio
sup
spirits
result
cases
expressed
form
general
recognition
right
state
make
provision
local
needs
minnesota
rate
cases
sup
ann
cas
right
recognized
even
interference
interstate
commerce
direct
interstate
train
required
stop
accommodate
passengers
leave
state
lake
shore
michigan
southern
ry
ohio
sup
gulf
colorado
santa
fe
ry
texas
sup
see
nothing
commerce
clause
prevent
state
giving
preference
inhabitants
enjoyment
natural
advantages
gas
used
private
perons
purposes
know
power
congress
require
devote
public
use
transport
across
state
lines
law
west
virginia
west
virginia
alone
makes
west
virginian
gas
called
public
utility
far
shall
matter
law
alone
decides
aware
general
language
oklahoma
kansas
natural
gas
sup
decision
though
wrong
implying
pennsylvania
might
keep
coal
northwest
timber
etc
confess
see
hinder
certainly
owners
mines
forests
saw
fit
export
products
constitution
make
see
nothing
instrument
produce
different
result
state
gave
owners
motives
conduct
effering
bonus
however
decision
case
referred
goes
outweigh
consensus
decisions
referred
seem
confirm
think
plain
without
constitution
prohibit
state
securing
reasonable
preference
inhabitants
enjoyment
products
even
effect
law
keep
property
within
boundaries
otherwise
passed
outside
hudson
county
water
mccarter
sup
ann
cas
agree
substantially
brothers
mcreynolds
brandeis
think
jurisdiction
sense
justify
statement
opinion
upon
meris
case
think
bill
dismissed
justice
mcreynolds
dissenting
seems
quite
clear
record
presents
justiciable
controversy
certainly
none
within
original
jurisdiction
manifest
purpose
protecting
local
consumers
west
virginia
commanded
public
service
corporations
transport
natural
gas
beyond
borders
state
satisfied
reasonable
requirements
people
therein
thereupon
complainants
came
original
bills
alleged
statute
enforced
inhabitants
obtain
enough
gas
imperative
demands
divers
pipe
lines
theretofore
accustomed
supply
ask
us
declare
enactment
invalid
conflict
commerce
clause
federal
constitution
restrain
enforcement
pipe
lines
hereafter
fail
comply
contracts
course
may
proceeded
proper
forum
say
probably
fail
statute
demand
power
enjoined
set
real
controversy
cognizable
west
virginia
prohibit
drilling
new
gas
wells
hardly
suppose
complainants
demand
injunction
even
admitted
supplies
cut
doctrine
announced
production
permitted
years
appealing
hardships
follow
cessation
suppose
west
virginia
repeal
charters
public
service
corporations
transporting
gas
thereby
disable
interfere
upon
demand
another
state
claimed
suffer
originally
adopted
constitution
provided
cases
affecting
ambassadors
public
ministers
consuls
state
shall
party
shall
original
jurisdiction
chisholm
georgia
dall
declared
citizen
one
state
proceed
another
state
original
action
louisiana
texas
sup
chief
justice
fuller
pointed
character
controversies
original
jurisdiction
emphasis
declared
vindication
freedom
interstate
commerce
committed
state
parens
patriae
unless
ruling
pass
discard
follows
neither
complainants
higher
standing
one
citizens
contract
gas
eleventh
amendment
unnecessary
argue
framers
constitution
never
intended
empower
suit
individual
enjoin
state
enforcing
regulations
prescribed
public
service
corporations
yet
possibility
must
affirmed
doctrine
announced
concluding
opinion
chisholm
georgia
justice
iredell
exclaimed
pray
god
attorney
general
doctrine
law
established
judgment
good
predicts
may
take
place
none
evils
concern
say
appears
pregnant
like
prayer
seems
inappropriate
justice
brandeis
dissenting
statement
made
justice
holmes
seems
unanswerable
like
justice
mcreynolds
think
reasons
bills
dismissed
without
passing
upon
constitutional
question
presented
natural
gas
quantity
produced
counties
west
virginia
inhabitants
state
years
dependent
upon
domestic
uses
supplied
nearly
industrial
establishments
concerns
engaged
business
distributing
natural
gas
public
corporations
organized
laws
west
virginia
organized
laws
state
unincorporated
prior
act
february
hereinafter
referred
declared
statute
public
service
endowed
power
eminent
domain
duty
furnishing
public
throughout
west
virginia
territory
business
adequate
service
carnegie
natural
gas
swiger
clarksburg
light
heat
public
service
commission
duty
confirmed
legislation
state
prior
world
war
production
natural
gas
west
virginia
demand
large
quantities
exported
public
service
corporations
without
thereby
lessening
ability
concerns
give
adequate
service
west
virginia
customers
war
demand
within
without
state
increased
greatly
thereafter
supply
became
smaller
net
supply
west
virginia
natural
gas
available
distribution
public
service
corporations
per
cent
exported
year
per
cent
per
cent
west
virginia
consumers
complained
amount
furnished
inadequate
discriminated
west
virginia
gas
companies
interest
residents
companies
exported
gas
sought
justify
ina
equacy
service
west
virginia
customers
asserting
contract
duty
supply
west
virginia
gas
distributing
companies
consumers
aggregate
demand
customers
several
exceeded
available
supply
west
virginia
public
service
corporations
took
part
export
business
remaining
engaged
solely
distribution
within
state
many
dependent
largely
upon
gas
supply
companies
sought
justify
inadequate
service
fact
demands
gas
exported
corporations
dependent
denied
full
supply
west
virginia
consumers
insisted
common
law
forbade
public
service
companies
disable
performaning
duty
give
adequate
service
within
state
contended
exporting
public
service
corporations
habitually
supplied
local
distributing
companies
justify
furnishing
reduced
supply
setting
contracts
furnish
supplies
concerns
contentions
denied
exporting
companies
asserted
legally
controlled
respect
public
service
commission
west
virginia
remove
doubt
concerning
statutory
powers
commission
insure
adequate
service
west
virginia
consumers
legislature
state
enacted
chapter
acts
approved
february
year
take
effect
days
passage
statute
declared
rules
substantive
law
public
service
corporation
engaged
distributing
natural
gas
produced
within
state
shall
exporting
supply
disable
performing
duty
give
adequate
service
within
west
virginia
public
service
corporation
whose
gas
supply
insufficient
afford
service
customers
may
prescribed
conditions
call
upon
public
service
corporation
within
territory
surplus
supply
furnish
part
surplus
may
required
enable
give
adequate
service
effective
date
act
state
pennsylvania
state
ohio
filed
bill
equity
state
west
virginia
prayed
act
declared
void
obnoxious
federal
constitution
west
virginia
officials
enjoined
attempting
way
enforce
statute
basis
relief
bill
set
forth
extensive
use
natural
gas
state
institutions
several
municipalities
millions
residents
alleged
serious
injury
result
consumers
deprived
west
virginia
supply
ohio
bill
alleged
lso
cutting
west
virginia
supply
natural
gas
greatly
reduce
value
public
service
properties
reduce
taxable
values
properties
thereby
deprive
state
important
revenues
prayed
specifically
plaintiff
state
residents
declared
adequate
remedy
law
west
virginia
officials
enjoined
interfering
transportation
natural
gas
use
ohio
pending
suit
injunction
granted
instituting
state
west
virginia
suit
statute
company
corporation
engaged
production
transportation
natural
gas
state
west
virginia
state
ohio
public
official
producer
exporter
distributor
gas
consumer
made
party
plaintiff
defendant
either
bill
temporary
injunction
issued
case
upon
filing
bill
motion
dismiss
answer
replication
filed
without
disposing
motions
dismiss
parties
proceeded
take
evidence
thereafter
submitted
cases
final
hearing
several
objections
made
maintenance
suits
may
passed
without
discussion
assumed
constitutional
question
submitted
deemed
merely
political
one
georgia
stanton
wall
massachusetts
mellon
sup
ed
decided
june
assumed
alleged
right
acquire
purchase
bring
state
natural
gas
produced
elsewhere
fundamental
treated
similar
legally
right
asserted
kansas
colorado
sup
sup
water
interstate
stream
continue
flow
state
right
recognized
missouri
illinois
sup
new
york
new
jersey
sup
georgia
tennessee
copper
sup
ann
cas
waters
air
within
one
state
kept
reasonably
free
pollution
originating
another
assumed
use
natural
gas
pennsylvania
ohio
shown
general
bring
suits
within
rule
acted
upon
cases
cited
render
inapplicable
rule
declared
kansas
sup
oklahoma
atchison
topeka
santa
fe
railway
sup
suits
dismissed
brought
aid
interests
deemed
provate
finally
still
state
permitted
one
natural
resources
freely
dealt
article
interstate
commerce
may
thereafter
prohibit
export
thereof
although
appears
whole
remaining
supply
required
satisfy
needs
citizens
objections
raised
defendant
considered
objections
opinion
present
insuperable
obstacles
maintenance
suits
first
without
jurisdiction
bills
present
neither
within
meaning
federal
constitution
marbury
madison
cranch
muskrat
sup
texas
interstate
commerce
commission
sup
proceedings
according
regular
course
judicial
procedure
protect
right
property
personal
right
like
mcchord
louisville
nashville
railroad
sup
attempt
enjoin
executive
action
legislation
instituted
frankly
secure
general
declaration
west
virginia
act
february
unconstitutional
compare
giles
harris
sup
rule
without
power
entertain
proceeding
applies
equally
whether
party
invoking
aid
state
private
person
rule
overcome
giving
pleadings
form
institutions
consumers
west
fairchild
hughes
sup
atherton
mills
johnston
sup
texas
interstate
commerce
commission
supra
moreover
shown
legal
sense
danger
invasion
alleged
rights
shown
pennsylvania
ohio
public
institutions
consumers
west
virginia
suggested
georgia
tennessee
copper
sup
ann
cas
shown
many
consumers
within
plaintiff
suffer
serious
injury
west
virginia
supply
cut
primarily
least
acts
omissions
threatened
legal
sense
danger
supply
stopped
mere
enactment
statute
obviously
constitute
threat
interrupt
flow
gas
plaintiff
importation
ohio
pennsylvania
conducted
state
west
virginia
wholly
privately
owned
public
service
corporations
importation
ceases
irimarily
least
acts
omissions
corporations
yet
even
allegation
corporations
threaten
intend
discontinue
importation
compelled
unless
state
west
virginia
enjoined
enforcing
statute
hand
clearly
appears
laws
west
virginia
present
danger
corporations
summarily
prevented
state
continuing
full
volume
export
gas
compelled
reduce
restriction
imposed
act
upon
exportation
gas
may
result
requirement
west
virginia
public
service
corporations
shall
means
export
disable
performing
duties
consumers
dis
tributing
companies
within
state
legal
sense
danger
restriction
result
must
appear
one
exporting
companies
disabling
exportation
also
state
official
take
effective
action
prevent
exportation
legislation
west
virginia
many
things
happen
much
time
must
elapse
exporting
corporations
legal
duty
discontinue
essen
exports
still
time
actually
prevented
exporting
gas
west
virginia
legislation
executive
officer
power
jurisdiction
declare
enforce
performance
alleged
duty
public
service
corporation
primary
resort
public
service
commission
application
acted
upon
either
granting
denying
relief
fuel
gas
public
service
commission
state
bluefield
water
works
co
kelly
axe
manufacturing
fuel
gas
act
establishing
commission
prescribes
methods
remedies
pursued
order
enforce
duty
give
adequate
service
chapter
acts
chapter
acts
chapter
acts
chapter
acts
manufacturers
light
heat
ott
fed
claimed
failure
give
adequate
service
petition
may
filed
commission
secure
notice
hearing
corporation
commission
order
may
made
commission
issues
order
purports
restrict
way
discretion
theretofore
exercised
corporation
respect
exports
every
concern
act
legally
free
continue
transportation
gas
pennsylvania
ohio
statute
passed
possible
commission
never
called
upon
act
possible
called
upon
commission
refuse
make
order
possible
commission
made
order
order
character
affect
seriously
interests
plaintiff
seeks
protect
possible
order
made
state
suspend
operation
eventually
annul
act
makes
careful
provision
judicial
review
orders
commission
postponing
incidence
penalties
liabilities
review
never
occasion
invoking
respect
statute
doctrine
ex
parte
young
sup
ann
cas
commission
without
power
enforce
order
impose
penalty
overcome
disobedience
disregard
order
resort
must
west
virginia
statutes
courts
end
original
proceeding
must
instituted
whether
suit
enforce
obedience
brought
commission
others
corporation
given
opportunity
defend
ground
order
reason
invalid
may
inaugurate
proceeding
bringing
suit
order
annulled
randall
gas
star
glass
fuel
gas
public
service
commission
moreover
final
order
commission
enforceable
even
days
entry
elapsed
period
allowed
within
party
feeling
aggrieved
may
apply
suspension
order
application
made
speedy
hearing
must
given
section
time
suits
begun
action
kind
taken
relation
matters
dealt
act
february
either
commission
board
official
state
corporation
person
ever
affected
provision
statute
action
taken
act
yet
effect
said
legal
sense
pennsylvania
ohio
consumers
present
danger
irreparable
injury
plaintiffs
fears
best
premature
held
oregon
hitchcock
sup
even
instance
state
take
upon
decision
questions
committed
another
department
government
thus
anticipate
action
federal
executive
reasons
equally
strong
interfering
advance
decision
executive
state
matter
committed
determination
private
suits
relief
necessarily
denied
compare
first
national
bank
albuquerque
albright
sup
south
carolina
georgia
suit
one
state
another
even
greater
caution
exercised
assuming
act
missouri
illinois
sup
kansas
colorado
sup
new
york
new
jersey
sup
objection
georgia
tennessee
copper
sup
ann
cas
interested
left
action
law
redress
injuries
may
suffered
stage
controversy
reached
suits
begun
indeed
since
see
prentis
atlantic
coast
line
sup
bacon
rutland
sup
second
fatal
lack
necessary
parties
failure
exporting
companies
continue
exportation
gas
plaintiffs
consumers
distributing
companies
pennsylvania
ohio
injured
primarily
least
rights
corporations
one
invaded
enforcing
statute
rights
consumers
distributing
corporations
pennsylvania
ohio
derivative
merely
whether
west
virginia
corporations
may
furnish
gas
plaintiff
whether
corporations
may
regulated
statute
attempts
controversies
west
virginia
corporations
submitted
rights
adjudication
suits
intimated
corporations
wish
act
declared
void
may
assume
wish
conceivably
decision
holding
act
valid
might
benefit
since
might
relieve
improvident
contracts
distributing
companies
pennsylvania
ohio
may
corporations
benefited
others
injured
decision
made
question
presented
unless
corporations
legally
represented
either
plaintiff
defendant
bound
decree
either
suits
new
orleans
water
works
new
orleans
sup
neither
plaintiff
defendant
legally
represents
clear
since
found
entertain
suit
decide
question
presented
held
california
southern
pacific
sup
minnesota
northern
securities
sup
comport
gravity
finality
characterize
adjudication
exercise
original
jurisdiction
proceed
instance
state
absence
parties
whose
rights
actually
passed
upon
effect
determined
even
though
might
technically
bound
subsequent
litigation
tribunal
compare
texas
interstate
commerce
commission
sup
remaining
west
virginia
gas
corporations
expo
gas
also
vitally
interested
question
submitted
far
interest
general
one
qua
consumer
might
represented
public
service
commission
end
commission
state
perhaps
made
party
defendant
many
gas
corporations
appear
specific
interests
decision
might
affect
directly
contracts
exporting
companies
supply
gas
obligations
contracts
different
act
held
valid
held
void
decision
effect
prohibition
exports
declared
act
void
might
seriously
impair
contract
rights
moreover
section
act
provides
sections
provisions
clauses
act
shall
deemed
separable
also
respect
persons
firms
corporations
consumers
mentioned
therein
affected
thereby
separable
part
act
held
unconstitutional
reason
invalid
unenforceable
remaining
parts
thereof
shall
remain
full
force
effect
surely
statute
may
valid
exporting
companies
action
exporting
may
ultra
vires
certain
west
virginia
distributing
companies
may
acquired
preferential
rights
supply
gas
determine
view
provision
act
void
toto
parties
affected
thereby
facts
litigants
able
present
therefore
even
appeared
rights
legally
present
danger
irreparable
injury
resulting
wrongful
acts
defendant
suits
maintained
third
obstacles
overcome
sitting
equity
dismiss
bills
unable
grant
relief
appropriate
sitting
equity
clearly
lend
aid
enable
west
virgina
public
service
corporations
discriminate
west
virginia
consumers
interest
ohio
pennsylvania
consumers
therefore
appropriate
decree
framed
require
west
virginia
corporations
treat
west
virginia
customers
least
well
outside
state
decree
leave
west
virginia
public
service
corporation
free
export
gas
disregard
duty
discriminate
public
state
natural
gas
produced
also
pennsylvania
ohio
equitably
dependent
supplies
cansumed
furthermore
west
virginia
gas
exported
also
maryland
indiana
kentucky
two
natural
gas
produced
quantity
clearly
event
go
compel
west
virginia
share
production
equitable
state
dependent
upon
part
gas
supply
order
determine
equitable
part
west
virginia
production
state
might
require
public
service
corporations
retain
part
free
export
obviously
necessary
marshall
resources
demands
needs
six
consider
respect
conduct
business
therein
circumstances
attending
development
factors
necessary
considered
determining
division
west
virginia
production
fair
conditions
determination
made
character
questions
decided
obliged
refuse
undertake
task
reason
bills
dismissed
even
held
rights
legally
represented
plaintiffs
present
danger
irreparable
injury
wrongful
acts
defendant
fatal
lack
necessary
parties
justice
several
following
inquiries
essential
potential
well
actual
production
state
ascertained
actual
production
earlier
years
approximately
current
production
ascertained
data
regularly
collected
geological
survey
public
utility
commissions
several
ascertain
potential
production
searching
inquiry
made
methods
production
pursued
among
things
extent
recent
production
secured
forcing
wells
likelihood
production
lessened
forcing
wells
restored
allowing
periods
rest
extent
recent
reduced
outputs
may
atributable
failure
sink
enough
wells
open
additional
territory
necessary
inquire
also
extent
character
existing
gas
reserves
situated
whomsoever
owned
ascertaining
extent
gas
territory
yet
developed
necessary
inquire
extent
reserve
controlled
otherwise
available
several
public
service
corporations
several
cost
developing
particular
fields
marketing
supply
therefrom
relation
undeveloped
territory
worked
already
exhausted
extent
rapidly
development
new
areas
new
sources
supply
properly
proceed
demand
actual
potential
state
determined
determining
demand
confine
inquiry
ascer
taining
amount
used
called
rates
charged
several
communities
must
also
considered
upon
well
upon
relative
cost
kinds
fuel
depend
large
part
extent
demand
particularly
industries
character
use
circumstances
developed
likewise
important
factors
deciding
distribution
equitable
among
things
necessary
determine
extent
ohio
high
percentage
waste
investment
made
distributing
mains
customers
appliances
circumstances
investments
made
local
distributing
company
might
reasonably
required
restrict
business
existing
customers
even
existing
needs
like
restriction
great
hardship
applied
new
companies
yet
brought
business
paying
basis
determination
concerning
production
none
concerning
demand
afford
stable
basis
future
action
factor
entering
determination
constant
investigations
supply
demand
pursued
continuously
recurrent
decisions
distribution
required
thus
estimate
undeveloped
gas
territory
must
ever
changing
new
discovery
may
open
territory
theretogore
unknown
sinking
test
wells
may
establish
act
territory
previously
deemed
valuable
wholly
unproductive
field
public
service
regulation
controlling
body
confronted
factors
baffling
natural
gas
industry
none
continuous
supervision
control
required
high
degree
decisions
made
character
calls
informed
judgment
board
experts
tribunal
determine
among
things
whether
inadequate
service
due
several
inadequate
supply
improvident
use
consumers
whether
overcome
inadequacy
supply
new
territory
developed
wells
sunk
old
territory
whether
view
prospective
needs
several
communities
better
reserves
husbanded
uses
gas
may
put
curtailed
thus
called
upon
perhaps
business
judgment
managing
companies
pro
rata
distribution
among
users
gas
time
time
available
obviously
result
equitable
distribution
domestic
users
also
many
industrial
ones
gas
supply
uncertain
find
necessary
assure
adequate
supply
heating
cooking
power
either
oil
kind
fuel
expense
producing
necessary
alternative
appliances
large
tribunal
decide
also
many
serious
questions
character
usually
committed
determination
public
utility
commissions
difficulties
involved
decisions
much
enhanced
differences
laws
rules
practices
several
regarding
duties
natural
gas
companies
furnish
adequate
service
cearly
undertake
determinations
equitable
distribution
task
complexity
difficulty
even
interstate
public
service
commission
broad
powers
perfected
administrative
machinery
ample
resources
practical
experience
duties
might
fail
perform
satisfactorily
powerless
frame
decree
provide
machinery
means
equitable
distribution
available
supply
effected
according
settled
practice
refuse
entertain
suits
compare
marble
ripley
wall
taxas
pacific
railway
marshall
sup
giles
harris
sup
per
curiam
suits
havi
heretofore
submitted
pleadings
evidence
fully
advised
premises
considered
ordered
decreed
follows
act
passed
legislature
defendant
state
february
set
forth
bills
complaint
suits
known
chapter
west
virginia
acts
void
inoperative
enactment
contravenes
limitations
constitution
places
upon
state
action
respect
commerce
among
several
defendant
state
several
officers
agents
servants
hereby
severally
enjoined
enforcing
atttempting
enforce
act
aggregate
costs
suits
apportioned
among
paid
parties
thereto
follows
state
west
virginia
half
commonwealth
pennsylvania
state
ohio
levi
cooke
commissioner
evidence
suits
taken
reported
shall
receive
paid
sum
full
compensation
services
rendered
expenses
incurred
connection
sum
taxed
part
aggregate
costs
two
suits
paid
parties
proportions
named
clerk
transmit
chief
magistrates
commonwealth
pennsylvania
ohio
west
virginia
copies
decree
duly
authenticated
seal
footnotes
rehearing
granted
sup
ed
com
pennsylvania
state
west
virginia
act
passed
february
went
effect
may
reads
follows
every
person
engaged
furnishing
required
law
whether
statutory
common
law
furnish
natural
gas
public
use
use
public
part
public
whether
domestic
industrial
consumption
within
state
shall
extent
supply
said
gas
produced
state
whether
produced
person
person
furnish
public
use
within
territory
state
use
public
every
part
public
within
territory
state
gas
produced
said
gas
transported
served
person
supply
natural
gas
reasonably
adequate
purposes
whether
domestic
industrial
otherwise
natural
gas
consumed
desired
consumed
public
part
public
within
said
territory
state
said
consumer
consumers
therein
shall
apply
ready
willing
make
payment
lawful
rates
case
person
engaged
furnishing
required
law
whether
statutory
common
law
furnish
natural
gas
public
use
within
state
use
public
part
public
within
state
shall
production
supply
natural
gas
probably
insufficient
furnish
use
purposes
whether
domestic
industrial
otherwise
natural
gas
consumed
public
part
public
within
territory
state
served
person
event
public
service
commission
shall
authority
hereby
conferred
upon
application
person
consumers
within
state
due
hearing
upon
notice
proof
satisfaction
commission
public
convenience
necessity
requir
order
person
engaged
furnishing
required
law
whether
statutory
common
law
furnish
natural
gas
public
use
within
state
producing
furnishing
natural
gas
public
use
said
territory
transporting
said
territory
furnish
person
sufficient
production
supply
natural
gas
purpose
supplying
deficiency
times
upon
reasonable
terms
conditions
rates
amounts
commission
shall
prescribe
whenever
hearing
upon
notice
proof
commission
shall
determine
public
convenience
necessity
require
commission
shall
authority
provide
compel
establishment
reasonable
physical
connection
connections
lines
pipes
conduits
person
excess
supply
gas
lines
pipes
conduits
person
deficiency
supply
require
laying
construction
reasonable
extensions
lines
pipes
conduits
may
necessary
establishment
physical
connection
connections
ascertain
determine
fix
reasonable
terms
conditions
connection
connections
including
reasonable
rules
regulations
provisions
payment
costs
expense
making
apportionment
cost
expense
may
appear
reasonable
provided
however
person
shall
virtue
section
ordered
furnish
natural
gas
person
engaged
furnishing
required
law
furnish
natural
gas
public
use
except
extent
person
ordered
furnish
natural
gas
shall
time
production
supply
natural
gas
excess
quantity
sufficient
furnish
reasonably
adequate
supply
consumers
within
state
shall
person
virtue
section
ordered
furnish
natural
gas
person
engaged
furnishing
required
law
furnish
natural
gas
public
use
territory
within
state
said
person
said
excess
shall
extent
excess
ready
willing
furnish
within
time
commission
shall
prescribe
shall
actually
furnish
consumers
within
said
territory
reasonably
adequate
supply
natural
gas
far
shall
conflict
act
authority
powers
jurisdiction
duties
conferred
imposed
public
service
commission
act
entitled
act
create
public
service
commission
prescribe
powers
duties
prescribe
penalties
violations
provisions
act
passed
february
one
thousand
nine
hundred
thirteen
amended
act
entitled
act
amend
sections
one
two
three
four
five
nine
ten
fourteen
fifteen
chapter
nine
acts
one
thousand
nine
hundred
thirteen
creating
public
service
commission
prescribing
powers
duties
penalties
violation
provisions
said
chapter
add
thereto
six
sections
known
sections
eight
enlarging
powers
duties
said
public
service
commission
prescribing
additional
penalties
giving
commission
power
punish
contempt
passed
february
tenth
one
thousand
nine
hundred
fifteen
hereby
conferred
imposed
public
service
commission
resepect
act
part
thereof
case
violation
provision
act
person
aggrieved
affected
thereby
may
complain
thereof
public
service
commission
like
manner
thereupon
procedure
shall
provided
respect
complaints
said
commission
proceedings
remedies
may
taken
enforcement
review
order
orders
said
commission
punishment
violation
order
orders
provided
law
respect
orders
said
commission
case
violation
provision
act
public
service
commission
person
aggrieved
affected
violation
name
may
apply
competent
jurisdiction
bill
injunction
petition
writ
mandamus
appropriate
action
suit
proceeding
compel
obedience
compliance
act
prevent
violation
act
provision
thereof
pending
proceedings
said
commission
thereafter
final
determination
action
suit
proceeing
enforcement
review
final
order
said
commission
shall
jurisdiction
grant
appropriate
order
judgment
decree
premises
person
subject
provisions
act
shall
fail
refuse
comply
requirement
sion
hereunder
person
shall
subject
fine
less
one
hundred
dollars
five
hundred
dollars
offense
person
officers
corporation
person
corporation
may
indicted
failure
comply
requirement
commission
provisions
act
upon
conviction
thereof
may
fined
exceed
five
hundred
dollars
discretion
confined
jail
exceed
thirty
days
every
day
person
officer
agent
employee
person
shall
fail
observe
comply
order
direction
commission
perform
duty
enjoined
act
shall
constitute
separate
distinct
violation
order
direction
act
case
may
person
claiming
damaged
violation
act
may
bring
suit
behalf
recovery
damage
person
persons
violating
circuit
jurisdiction
action
may
compel
attendance
person
persons
said
action
brought
officer
director
agent
employee
person
persons
witness
also
require
production
books
papers
documents
may
useful
evidence
trial
thereof
witness
may
compelled
testify
witness
shall
prosecuted
offense
concerning
compelled
hereunder
testify
word
within
meaning
act
shall
construed
meanan
include
persons
firms
corporations
sections
provisions
clauses
act
shall
deemed
separable
also
respect
persons
firms
corporations
consumers
mentioned
therein
affected
thereby
separable
part
act
held
unconstitutional
reason
invalid
unenforceable
remaining
parts
thereof
shall
remain
full
force
effect
acts
parts
acts
conflict
act
hereby
repealed
state
constitution
act
went
effect
expiration
days
legislature
distinguished
approval
governor
state
mounts
words
service
corporation
used
act
shall
include
persons
associations
persons
firms
corporations
municipalities
agencies
engaged
employed
business
herein
enumerated
public
service
business
whether
enumerated
whether
incorporated
acts
acts
acts
see
acts
large
part
gas
produced
available
distribution
public
much
consumed
within
state
field
drilling
cleaning
wells
operation
compressor
pump
stations
transport
gas
producer
must
also
reservations
leases
ordinarily
deliver
landowner
free
gas
service
temptation
discriminate
may
great
pennsylvania
ohio
communities
formerly
supplied
local
production
natural
gas
longer
possible
afford
pay
vary
high
price
gas
rather
discard
existing
gas
appliances
install
new
ones
required
oil
coal
substituted
fuel
average
price
per
cubic
feet
domestic
consumption
cents
west
virginia
cents
pennsylvania
cents
ohio
industrial
consumption
cents
west
virginia
cents
pennsylvania
cents
ohio
geological
survey
gas
published
may
state
property
interest
running
water
naturally
flowing
public
waters
air
within
boundaries
georgia
tennessee
copper
sup
ann
cas
running
water
withheld
property
taken
public
waters
air
polluted
territorial
integrity
invaded
alleged
right
purchase
interstate
commerce
import
natural
resource
sense
right
state
described
appropriately
privilege
citizens
compare
louisiana
texas
sup
privileges
state
charged
federal
constitution
duty
enforce
fact
institution
suits
specially
authorized
legistures
pennsylvania
ohio
legal
significance
attorney
general
ohio
brief
supply
gas
adequate
consumption
inside
state
west
virginia
transportation
time
world
war
record
pp
reason
vast
demand
gas
industrial
consumption
occurred
result
war
drew
upon
lines
gas
companies
summer
heavily
heavily
winter
gas
companies
opportunity
rest
wells
accumulate
surplus
gas
normal
conditions
federal
government
unde
normal
conditions
federal
governent
fuel
administration
gave
orders
gas
companies
supply
essential
industrial
plants
gas
possible
wells
drilled
turned
lines
normal
conditions
held
reserve
assure
future
supply
record
pp
supply
gas
never
adequate
purposes
periods
maximum
demand
since
time
may
production
increase
war
closed
excessive
activities
early
ceased
followed
period
industrial
depression
may
opportunity
periodic
rest
gas
wells
well
human
beings
appear
need
thus
seemingly
exhausted
wells
may
restored
furthermore
hitherto
undeveloped
gas
areas
may
worked
wells
may
drilled
areas
already
developed
new
areas
may
opened
acres
gas
territory
held
public
service
corporations
state
large
part
still
undeveloped
moreover
demand
may
lessen
except
times
emergency
use
natural
gas
industries
determined
largely
relative
cost
compared
coal
oil
demands
economy
manufacture
may
alone
compel
reduction
use
industry
thus
time
leave
supply
ample
domestic
purposes
pennsylvania
used
manufacturing
purposes
three
times
much
natural
gas
imported
west
virginia
geological
survey
gas
published
may
pp
domestic
consumption
amounts
per
cent
total
consumption
geological
survey
gas
supra
moreover
present
large
waste
may
stopped
waste
ohio
per
cent
per
cent
per
cent
hand
west
virginia
waste
per
cent
per
cent
gas
supra
situation
wholly
unlike
pressented
savage
jones
sup
relied
upon
plaintiffs
suit
state
chemist
executive
official
vested
power
act
complainant
default
compliance
cause
arrest
prosecution
every
person
dealing
article
within
state
distributed
broadcast
throughout
state
warning
circulars
moreover
even
west
virginia
statute
construed
imposing
penalties
disobedience
severe
menacing
require
interposition
federal
public
service
corporations
west
pennsylvania
thereby
denied
due
process
law
doctrine
ex
parte
young
corporations
sue
oklahoma
operating
love
sup
relied
upon
plaintiff
sufficient
say
attorney
general
governor
even
legislature
state
conclusively
deemed
represent
public
interests
controversy
presented
bill
even
state
voluntarily
becomes
complainant
equity
claim
represent
sides
controversy
minnesota
northern
securities
sup
production
pennsylvania
cubic
feet
consumption
ohio
production
cubic
feet
consumption
geological
survey
gas
published
may
production
kentucky
cubic
feet
consumption
indiana
production
consumption
maryland
production
negligible
geological
survey
bulletin
gas
supra
idea
may
formed
scope
inquiry
examining
data
concerning
natural
gas
operations
collected
geological
survey
instance
appear
potential
supply
pennsylvania
ample
present
needs
concerns
prefer
husband
resources
remoter
future
unjust
discrimination
part
west
virginia
companies
deny
customers
within
state
adequate
supply
supplying
pennsylvania
distributing
companies
amount
gas
might
produced
reserves
within
pennsylvania
kentucky
ample
supplies
undeveloped
fields
sought
gas
west
virginia
kentucky
companies
funds
inclination
make
time
large
investment
required
secure
supply
within
state
circumstances
west
virginia
companies
justified
supplying
kentucky
demand
leaving
west
virginia
customers
unsatisfied
distributing
companies
pennsylvania
ohio
kentucky
indiana
permitted
extend
mains
add
new
customers
west
virginia
recognized
insufficiency
supply
satisfy
needs
consumers
within
state
shall
deemed
existing
demand
state
existing
demand
limited
customers
already
connected
mean
amount
theretofore
taken
customers
may
wish
take
existing
appliances