field
clark
argued
decided
february
bliss
john
wilson
marshall
field
chas
curie
wickham
smith
boyd
et
clarke
smith
sternbach
et
atty
miller
sol
taft
collector
cases
justice
harlan
delivered
opinion
duties
assessed
collected
according
rates
established
known
act
october
woolen
dress
goods
woolen
wearing
apparel
silk
embroideries
imported
marshall
field
silk
cotton
laces
imported
boyd
sutton
colored
cotton
cloths
imported
herman
sternbach
importers
severally
protested
assessment
upon
ground
act
law
upon
appeal
board
general
appraisers
act
june
known
administrative
act
decision
collector
case
approved
chapter
pp
st
judgment
board
affirmed
circuit
courts
respective
districts
matters
arose
cases
brought
review
appellants
question
validity
act
october
upon
three
grounds
separately
examined
seventh
section
article
constitution
provides
bills
raising
revenue
shall
originate
house
representatives
senate
may
propose
concur
amendments
bills
every
bill
shall
passed
house
representatives
senate
shall
becomes
law
presented
president
approve
shall
sign
shall
return
objections
house
shall
originated
shall
enter
objections
large
journal
proceed
reconsider
reconsideration
house
shall
agree
pass
bill
shall
sent
together
objections
house
shall
likewise
reconsidered
approved
house
shall
become
law
cases
votes
houses
shall
determined
yeas
nays
names
persons
voting
bill
shall
entered
journal
house
respectively
bill
shall
returned
president
within
ten
days
sundays
excepted
shall
presented
shall
law
like
manner
signed
unless
congress
adjournment
prevent
return
case
shall
law
order
resolution
vote
concurrence
senate
house
representatives
may
necessary
except
question
adjournment
shall
presented
president
shall
take
effect
shall
approved
disapproved
shall
repassed
senate
house
representatives
according
rules
limitations
prescribed
case
bill
revised
statutes
provide
bill
order
resolution
vote
senate
house
representatives
approved
president
returned
objections
becomes
law
takes
effect
shall
forthwith
received
secretary
state
president
whenever
bill
order
resolution
vote
returned
president
objections
reconsidered
agreed
passed
approved
houses
congress
thereby
becomes
law
takes
effect
shall
received
secretary
state
president
senate
speaker
house
representatives
whichsoever
house
shall
last
approved
shall
carefully
preserve
originals
section
original
enrolled
act
question
designated
face
received
department
state
october
received
attested
signatures
thomas
reed
speaker
house
representatives
levi
morton
president
senate
thereon
indorsements
october
harrison
certify
act
originated
house
representatives
mcpherson
clerk
made
duty
secretary
state
furnish
congressional
printer
correct
copy
every
act
joint
resolution
soon
possible
approval
president
become
law
accordance
constitution
without
approval
duty
performed
secretary
state
respect
act
question
act
appears
volume
statutes
published
distributed
authority
rev
contention
appellants
enrolled
act
custody
sectetary
state
appearing
upon
face
become
law
mode
prescribed
constitution
deemed
absolute
nullity
parts
shown
congressional
records
proceedings
reports
committees
house
reports
committees
conference
papers
printed
authority
congress
reference
house
bill
section
bill
finally
passed
bill
authenticated
signatures
presiding
officers
respective
houses
congress
approved
president
section
alleged
omitted
follows
original
unbroken
factory
packages
smoking
manufactured
tobacco
snuff
held
manufacturers
dealers
time
reduction
herein
provided
shall
go
effect
upon
tax
paid
shall
allowed
drawback
rebate
full
amount
reduction
shall
apply
case
claim
presented
within
sixty
days
following
date
reduction
rebate
manufacturers
may
paid
stamps
reduced
rate
claim
shall
allowed
drawback
paid
less
amount
five
dollars
shall
duty
commissioner
internal
revenue
approval
secretary
treasury
adopt
rules
regulations
prescribe
furnish
blanks
forms
may
necessary
carry
section
effect
payment
rebates
provided
section
hereby
appropriated
money
treasury
otherwise
appropriated
argument
behalf
appellants
bill
signed
speaker
house
representatives
president
senate
presented
approved
president
delivered
latter
secretary
state
act
passed
congress
become
law
fact
passed
congress
view
express
requirements
constitution
correctness
general
principle
doubted
authority
presiding
officers
house
representatives
senate
attest
signatures
president
approve
secretary
state
receive
cause
published
legislative
act
bill
passed
congress
concession
correctness
general
principle
appellants
contend
determine
precise
question
remains
inquire
nature
evidence
upon
may
act
issue
made
whether
bill
originating
house
representatives
senate
asserted
become
law
passed
congress
question
presented
first
time
received
importance
required
receive
deliberate
consideration
recognize
one
hand
duty
performance
may
shrink
give
full
effect
provisions
constitution
relating
enactment
laws
operate
wherever
authority
jurisdiction
extend
hand
unmindful
consequences
must
result
feel
obliged
fidelity
constitution
declare
enrolled
bill
depend
public
private
interests
vast
magnitude
authenticated
signatures
presiding
officers
two
houses
congress
approval
president
deposited
public
archives
act
congress
fact
passed
house
representatives
senate
therefore
become
law
clause
constitution
upon
appellants
rest
contention
act
question
never
passed
congress
one
declaring
house
shall
keep
journal
proceedings
time
time
publish
except
parts
may
judgment
require
secrecy
yeas
nays
members
either
house
question
shall
desire
present
entered
journal
article
assumed
argument
object
clause
make
journal
best
conclusive
evidence
upon
issue
whether
bill
fact
passed
two
houses
congress
words
used
require
interpretation
contrary
justice
story
well
said
object
whole
clause
insure
publicity
proceedings
legislature
correspondent
responsibility
members
respective
constitutents
founded
sound
policy
deep
political
foresight
intrigue
cabal
thus
deprived
main
resources
plotting
devising
measures
secrecy
public
mind
enlightened
attentive
examination
public
measures
patriotism
integrity
wisdom
obtain
due
reward
votes
ascertained
vague
conjecture
positive
facts
long
known
open
responsibility
valuable
check
incentive
among
representatives
free
people
long
journal
proceedings
votes
published
face
world
continue
enjoy
public
favor
demanded
public
opinion
story
const
regard
certain
matters
constitution
expressly
requires
shall
entered
journal
extent
validity
legislative
action
may
affected
failure
matters
entered
journal
need
inquire
question
presented
determination
clear
respect
particular
mode
fullness
shall
kept
proceedings
either
house
relating
matters
expressly
required
entered
journals
whether
bills
orders
resolutions
reports
amendments
shall
entered
large
journal
referred
designated
titles
numbers
like
matters
left
discretion
respective
houses
congress
clause
instrument
either
expressly
necessary
implication
prescribe
mode
fact
original
passage
bill
house
representatives
senate
shall
authenticated
preclude
congress
adopting
mode
end
wisdom
suggests
although
constitution
expressly
require
bills
passed
congress
attested
signatures
presiding
officers
two
houses
usage
orderly
conduct
legislative
proceedings
rules
two
bodies
acted
since
organization
government
require
mode
authentication
signing
speaker
house
representatives
president
senate
open
session
enrolled
bill
official
attestation
two
houses
bill
one
passed
congress
declaration
two
houses
presiding
officers
president
bill
thus
attested
received
due
form
sanction
legislative
branch
government
delivered
obedience
constitutional
requirement
bills
pass
congress
shall
presented
bill
thus
attested
receives
approval
deposited
public
archives
authentication
bill
passed
congress
deemed
complete
unimpeachable
president
authority
approve
bill
passed
congress
enrolled
act
custody
secretary
state
official
attestations
speaker
house
representatives
president
senate
president
carries
face
solemn
assurance
legislative
executive
departments
government
charged
respectively
duty
enacting
executing
laws
passed
congress
respect
due
coequal
independent
departments
requires
judicial
department
act
upon
assurance
accept
passed
congress
bills
authenticated
manner
stated
leaving
courts
determine
question
properly
arises
whether
act
authenticated
conformity
constitution
admitted
enrolled
act
thus
authenticated
sufficient
evidence
contrary
appearing
upon
passed
congress
contention
regarded
law
journal
either
house
fails
show
passed
precise
form
signed
presiding
officers
two
houses
approved
president
said
view
becomes
possible
speaker
house
representatives
president
senate
impose
upon
people
law
bill
never
passed
congress
possibility
remote
seriously
considered
present
inquiry
suggests
deliberate
conspiracy
presiding
officers
committees
enrolled
bills
clerks
two
houses
must
necessarily
parties
acting
common
purpose
defeat
expression
popular
mode
prescribed
constitution
judicial
action
based
upon
suggestion
forbidden
respect
due
ordinate
branch
government
evils
may
result
recognition
principle
enrolled
act
custody
secretary
state
attested
signatures
presiding
officers
two
houses
congress
approval
president
conclusive
evidence
passed
congress
according
forms
constitution
far
less
certainly
result
rule
making
validity
congressional
enactments
depend
upon
manner
journals
respective
houses
kept
subordinate
officers
charged
duty
keeping
views
expressed
supported
numerous
adjudications
country
well
refer
pangborn
young
law
question
arose
relative
value
evidence
passage
bill
journals
respective
houses
legislature
enrolled
act
authenticated
signatures
speakers
two
houses
approval
governor
bill
question
alleged
originated
house
amended
senate
presented
approved
governor
contain
amendments
made
senate
referring
provision
constitution
new
jersey
requiring
house
legislature
keep
journal
proceedings
provision
almost
words
clause
quoted
federal
constitution
speaking
chief
justice
beasley
said
impossible
mind
incline
opinion
framers
constitution
exacting
keeping
journals
design
create
records
ultimate
conclusive
evidence
conformity
legislative
action
constitutional
provisions
relating
enactment
laws
nature
things
observed
journals
must
constructed
loose
hasty
memoranda
made
pressure
business
amid
distractions
numerous
assembly
chief
justice
said
one
deny
laws
state
tested
comparison
journals
imperfect
unauthenticated
stability
written
law
shaken
foundation
certainly
person
venture
say
many
statutes
perhaps
oldest
important
affect
large
classes
persons
great
interests
depend
found
defective
even
constitutional
particulars
judged
criterion
addition
considerations
judging
consequences
remember
danger
prevalence
doctrine
apprehended
intentional
corruption
evidences
character
scarcely
much
say
legal
existence
almost
every
legisaltive
act
mercy
persons
access
journals
obvious
law
invalidated
interpolation
lines
obliteration
one
name
substitution
another
stead
consent
expose
state
legislature
hazards
probable
error
facile
fraud
doctrine
contended
part
evidence
foundation
estimation
considerations
public
policy
conclusion
upon
grounds
public
policy
well
upon
ancient
rules
law
copy
bill
bearing
signatures
presiding
officers
two
houses
legislature
approval
governor
found
custody
secretary
state
conclusive
proof
enactment
contents
statute
constradicted
legislative
journals
mode
principles
affirmed
new
jersey
errors
appeals
freeholders
passaic
stevenson
law
cable
attorney
general
eq
atl
sherman
story
cal
whole
subject
carefully
considered
speaking
justice
sawyer
said
far
better
provision
occasionally
find
way
statute
mistake
even
fraud
every
act
state
national
times
liable
put
issue
impeached
journals
loose
papers
legislature
parol
evidence
state
uncertainty
statute
laws
land
lead
mischiefs
absolutely
intolerable
result
authorities
england
clearly
common
law
whenever
general
statute
misrecited
existence
denied
question
tried
determined
question
law
say
bound
take
notice
inform
best
way
plea
existence
put
issue
tried
question
fact
enrollment
statute
existence
enrollment
record
conclusive
statute
impeached
destroyed
weakened
journals
parliament
less
authentic
less
satisfactory
memorials
departure
principles
except
instances
except
instances
departure
grounded
taken
pursuance
express
constitutional
statutory
provision
requiring
relaxation
rule
order
full
effect
might
given
provisions
instances
rule
relazed
judges
great
caution
hesitation
departure
never
extended
beyond
inspection
journals
branches
legislature
provisions
california
constitution
force
case
decided
relating
journals
legislative
proceedings
substantially
like
clause
upon
subject
constitution
doctrines
case
reaffirmed
people
burt
cal
observed
subsequent
date
new
constitution
adopted
california
journals
examined
impeach
enrolled
bill
county
san
mateo
southern
pac
sawy
fed
case
much
point
ex
parte
wren
miss
validity
certain
act
questioned
ground
although
signed
presiding
officers
two
houses
legislature
approved
governor
law
appeared
journals
bodies
kept
pursuance
constitution
original
bill
passed
house
sent
senate
passed
numerous
amendments
house
concurred
bill
approved
governor
contain
certain
amendments
bore
directly
upon
issues
case
vigorous
opinion
delivered
justice
campbell
held
enrolled
act
signed
president
senate
speaker
house
representatives
governor
sole
exposition
contents
conclusive
evidence
existence
according
purport
allowable
look
discover
history
act
ascertain
provisions
cereful
analysis
adjudged
cases
said
view
subordinates
legislature
disregards
coequal
position
system
three
departments
government
validity
every
act
published
law
tested
examining
history
shown
journals
two
houses
legislature
amount
litigation
difficulty
painful
uncertainty
appalling
contemplation
multiplying
alleged
uncertainty
law
every
suit
every
validity
statute
may
called
question
affecting
right
litigant
nature
appeal
writ
error
bill
review
errors
apparent
face
legislative
records
journals
must
explored
determine
contradiction
exist
journals
bill
signed
presiding
officers
two
houses
law
declared
must
inform
best
law
may
go
beyond
enrolled
signed
bill
try
validity
record
contained
journals
must
perform
task
often
called
every
must
justice
peace
must
much
right
much
bound
preserve
constitution
declare
apply
law
spectacle
examination
journals
justices
peace
statutes
declared
law
result
journalistic
inquiry
circuit
chancery
courts
constantly
engaged
like
manner
appeal
often
try
correctness
determination
conclusion
drawn
legislative
journals
inquiry
validity
statutes
thus
tested
let
courts
accept
statutes
duly
enacted
bills
delivered
legislature
acts
authenticated
prescribed
mode
weeks
smith
atl
said
journals
made
amid
confusion
dispatch
business
therefore
much
likely
contain
errors
certificates
presiding
officers
untrue
moreover
public
policy
requires
enrolled
statures
state
fair
upon
faces
put
question
public
given
faith
validity
man
required
hunt
journals
legislature
determine
whether
statute
properly
certified
spealer
house
president
senate
approved
governor
statute
enrolled
act
public
law
original
private
act
always
held
england
records
highest
order
carry
wounds
absolute
verity
conclusive
general
effect
brodnax
groom
state
nevada
swift
evans
browne
ind
edger
commissioners
ind
pacific
railroad
governor
mo
et
seq
lottery
richoux
la
ann
cases
state
courts
proceed
upon
opposite
grounds
indicated
proper
found
upon
examination
many
rested
upon
constitutional
statutory
provisions
peculiar
character
expressly
necessary
implication
required
authorized
go
behind
enrolled
act
question
whether
act
authenticated
deposited
proper
office
duly
passed
legislature
particularly
case
reference
decisions
illinois
spangler
jacoby
ill
turley
county
logan
prescott
trustees
supervisors
people
ryan
lynch
people
starne
case
said
somewhat
peculiar
provision
constitution
requires
bills
become
laws
shall
read
three
several
times
house
shall
passed
vote
majority
members
elect
bill
thus
signed
approved
conclusive
validity
binding
force
law
according
theory
legislation
bill
become
law
must
record
evidence
every
material
requirement
introduction
becomes
law
evidence
found
upon
journals
two
houses
added
however
prepared
say
different
rule
might
subserved
public
interest
equally
well
leaving
legislature
executive
guard
public
interest
regard
become
responsible
neglect
case
gardner
collector
wall
relied
argument
supporting
contention
appellants
question
time
act
congress
took
effect
doubt
upon
point
arising
fact
month
day
year
approval
act
president
appeared
upon
enrolled
act
custody
department
state
omission
held
supplied
support
act
legislative
journals
said
opinion
therefore
principle
well
authority
whenever
question
arises
law
existence
statute
time
statute
took
effect
precise
terms
statute
judges
called
upon
decide
right
resort
source
information
nature
capable
conveying
judicial
mind
clear
satisfactory
answer
question
always
seeking
first
nature
appropriate
unless
positive
law
enacted
different
rule
question
case
existence
terms
statute
point
judgment
time
admitted
statute
took
effect
appearing
enrolled
act
shown
legislative
journals
scarcely
necessary
say
case
meet
question
presented
cases
south
ottawa
perkins
walnut
wade
post
supervisors
upon
ground
inconsistent
views
expressed
cases
held
question
whether
seeming
act
legislature
became
law
accordance
constitution
judicial
one
decided
courts
judges
question
fact
tried
jury
without
considering
question
principle
held
deference
decisions
illinois
interpreting
constitution
state
competent
determining
validity
enrolled
act
consult
legislative
journals
reliance
also
placed
appellants
upon
section
revised
statutes
providing
journals
senate
house
representatives
executive
journal
senate
injunction
secrecy
removed
certified
secretary
senate
clerk
house
representatives
shall
admitted
evidence
courts
shall
force
effect
originals
produced
authenticated
referring
matters
constitution
require
entered
journals
clear
statutory
declaration
journals
highest
evidence
facts
stated
complete
evidence
occurs
progress
business
respective
houses
much
less
authentication
enrolled
bill
official
signatures
presiding
officers
two
houses
president
act
passed
congress
approved
president
may
overcome
journal
either
house
shows
fails
show
opinion
reasons
stated
competent
appellants
show
journals
either
house
reports
committees
documents
printed
authority
congress
enrolled
bill
designated
finally
passed
contained
section
appear
enrolled
act
custody
state
department
third
section
act
october
chapter
words
view
secure
reciprocal
trade
countries
producing
following
articles
purpose
first
day
january
eighteen
hundred
whenever
often
president
shall
satisfied
government
country
producing
exporting
sugars
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
raw
uncured
articles
imposes
duties
exactions
upon
agricultural
products
view
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
may
deem
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
shall
power
shall
duty
suspend
proclamation
effect
provisions
act
relating
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
production
country
time
shall
deem
case
suspension
duties
shall
belevied
collected
paid
upon
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
product
exported
designated
country
follows
namely
sugars
number
thirteen
dutch
standard
color
shall
pay
duty
polariscopic
tests
follows
namely
sugars
number
thirteen
dutch
standard
color
tank
bottoms
sirups
cane
juice
beet
juice
melada
concentrated
melada
concrete
concentrated
molasses
testing
polariscope
degrees
one
cent
per
pound
every
additional
degree
fraction
degree
shown
polariscopic
test
one
cent
per
pound
additional
sugars
number
thirteen
dutch
standard
color
shall
classified
dutch
standard
color
pay
duty
follows
namely
sugar
number
thirteen
number
sixteen
dutch
standard
color
one
cent
per
pound
sugars
number
sixteen
number
twenty
dutch
standard
color
one
cents
per
pound
sugars
number
twenty
dutch
standard
color
two
cents
per
pound
testing
degrees
four
cents
per
gallon
drainings
sugar
sweepings
shall
subject
duty
either
molasses
sugar
case
may
according
polariscopic
test
coffee
three
cents
per
pound
tea
ten
cents
per
pound
raw
uncured
whether
dry
salted
pickled
angora
skins
raw
without
wool
unmanufactured
asses
skins
raw
unmanufactured
skins
except
wool
one
cents
per
pound
pp
plaintiffs
error
contend
section
far
authorizes
president
suspend
provisions
act
relating
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
unconstitional
delegating
legislative
powers
essential
part
system
established
congress
entire
act
must
declared
null
void
behalf
insisted
legislation
character
sustained
early
decision
practice
ment
nearly
century
even
third
section
unconstitutional
remaining
parts
act
stand
decision
referred
aurora
cranch
case
act
march
forbidding
importation
may
goods
wares
merchandise
port
place
great
britain
france
provided
president
hereby
authorized
case
either
france
great
britain
shall
revoke
modify
edicts
shall
cease
violate
neutral
commerce
declare
proclamation
laying
embargo
renewed
laying
embargo
renewed
nation
act
expired
may
day
congress
passed
another
act
chapter
declaring
case
either
great
britain
france
named
day
revoked
modified
edicts
shall
cease
violate
neutral
commerce
fact
president
shall
declare
proclamation
nation
shall
within
given
time
revoke
modify
edicts
like
manner
certain
sections
act
expiration
three
months
date
proclamation
aforesaid
revived
full
force
effect
far
relates
dominions
colonies
dependencies
articles
growth
produce
manufacture
dominions
colonies
dependencies
nation
thus
refusing
neglecting
revoke
modify
edicts
manner
aforesaid
restrictions
imposed
act
shall
date
proclamation
cease
discontinued
relation
nation
revoking
modifying
decrees
manner
aforesaid
pp
november
president
madison
issued
proclamation
declaring
france
revoked
modified
edicts
ceased
violate
neutral
commerce
argument
case
contended
joseph
ingersoll
congress
transfer
legislative
power
president
make
revival
law
depend
upon
president
proclamation
give
proclamation
force
law
replied
legislature
transfer
power
legislation
president
prescribed
evidence
admitted
fact
upon
law
go
effect
justice
johnson
speaking
whole
said
see
sufficient
reason
legislature
exercise
discretion
reviving
act
march
either
expressly
conditionally
judgment
direct
nineteenth
section
act
declaring
continue
force
certain
time
longer
restrict
power
extending
operation
without
limitation
upon
occurrence
subsequent
combination
events
certainly
decision
competent
congress
make
revival
act
depend
upon
proclamation
president
showing
ascertainment
fact
edicts
certain
nations
revoked
modified
violate
neutral
commerce
principle
apply
case
suspension
act
upon
contingency
ascertained
president
made
known
proclamation
extent
precedents
legislation
sustain
validity
section
consideration
far
makes
suspension
certain
provisions
going
operation
provisions
act
congress
depend
upon
action
president
based
upon
occurrence
subsequent
events
ascertainment
certain
facts
made
known
proclamation
find
congress
frequently
organization
government
present
time
conferred
upon
president
powers
reference
trade
commerce
like
conferred
third
section
act
october
fact
entitled
great
weight
determining
question
us
administration
washington
congress
act
approved
june
authorized
president
congress
session
prescribed
period
opinion
public
sarety
shall
require
lay
embargo
ships
vessels
ports
upon
ships
vessels
ships
vessels
foreign
nation
regulations
circumstances
may
require
continue
revoke
whenever
shall
think
proper
congress
passed
president
adams
approved
act
june
suspending
commercial
intercourse
france
dependencies
providing
government
france
persons
acting
authority
next
session
congress
clearly
disavow
shall
found
refrain
aggressions
depredations
hostilities
encouraged
maintained
vessels
property
citizens
national
rights
sovereignty
violation
faith
treaties
laws
nations
shall
thereby
acknowledge
claims
considered
respects
neutral
unconnected
present
european
war
shall
continued
thereupon
shall
lawful
president
well
ascertained
premises
remit
discontinue
prohibitions
restraints
hereby
enacted
declared
shall
hereby
authorized
make
proclamation
thereof
accordingly
pp
subsequent
act
approved
february
suspending
commercial
intercourse
france
dependencies
contained
section
time
passing
act
shall
lawful
president
shall
deem
expedient
consistent
interest
order
remit
discontinue
time
restraints
prohibitions
aforesaid
either
respect
french
republic
island
port
place
belonging
said
republic
commercial
intercourse
may
safely
renewed
also
revoke
order
whenever
opinion
interest
shall
require
shall
hereby
authorized
make
proclamation
thereof
accordingly
pp
latter
act
president
issued
june
may
proclamations
declaring
lawful
vessels
departing
enter
certain
ports
san
domingo
life
works
john
adams
pp
act
congress
approved
april
made
unlawful
import
november
port
place
great
britain
ireland
colonies
dependencies
great
britain
articles
leather
silk
hemp
flax
tin
brass
material
chief
value
woolen
cloths
whose
invoice
prices
exceeded
five
shillings
sterling
per
square
yard
woolen
hosiery
manufactures
glass
silver
plated
wares
hats
nails
spikes
clothing
millinery
beer
ale
porter
pictures
prints
operation
act
suspended
subsequent
act
december
july
last
act
contained
section
president
hereby
authorized
suspend
operation
aforesaid
act
judgment
public
interest
require
provided
suspension
shall
extend
beyond
second
monday
december
next
acts
received
approval
president
jefferson
act
march
approved
president
madison
provided
much
several
acts
imposing
duties
tonnage
ships
vessels
goods
wares
merchandise
imported
imposed
discriminating
duty
tonnage
foreign
vessels
vessels
goods
imported
foreign
vessels
vessels
repealed
far
respected
produced
manufacture
nation
foreign
ships
vessels
belonged
repeal
take
effect
favor
foreign
nation
president
shall
satisfied
discriminating
countervailing
duties
foreign
nation
far
operate
disadvantage
abolished
satisfactory
proof
received
president
monroe
free
city
bremen
may
discriminating
countervailing
duties
said
city
far
operated
disadvantage
abolished
issued
july
proclamation
stating
acts
congress
upon
subject
repealed
far
related
produce
manufacture
city
similar
proclamations
issued
respect
produce
manufactures
hamburg
lubeck
norway
dukedom
ogdenburg
app
act
approved
march
prohibiting
importation
foreign
vessel
july
year
plaster
paris
production
country
dependencies
vessels
permitted
bring
article
provided
act
continue
force
five
years
january
provided
foreign
nation
dependencies
force
regulations
subject
trade
plaster
paris
prohibiting
exportation
thereof
certain
ports
shall
discontinue
regulations
president
hereby
authorized
declare
fact
proclamation
restrictions
imposed
act
shall
date
proclamation
cease
discontinued
relation
nation
dependencies
discontinuing
regulations
proclamations
execution
act
issued
president
monroe
relating
trade
nova
scotia
new
brunswick
app
act
concerning
discriminating
duties
tonnage
impost
approved
january
provided
satisfactory
evidence
given
president
government
foreign
nation
discriminating
duties
tonnage
impost
imposed
levied
within
ports
said
nation
upon
vessels
wholly
belonging
citizens
upon
merchandise
produce
manufacture
thereof
imported
president
hereby
authorized
issue
proclamation
declaring
foreign
discriminating
duties
tonnage
impost
within
shall
suspended
discontinued
far
respects
vessels
said
nation
merchandise
produce
manufacture
imported
said
suspension
take
effect
time
notification
given
president
continue
long
reciprocal
exemption
vessels
belonging
citizens
merchandise
aforesaid
thereon
laden
shall
continued
longer
similar
section
embodied
act
may
relating
subject
substantially
preserved
section
revised
statutes
execution
acts
proclamations
issued
presidents
follows
adams
july
app
jackson
may
june
september
april
september
app
app
polk
november
app
fillmore
november
app
buchanan
february
app
lincoln
december
app
johnson
december
january
app
grant
june
novemver
february
december
september
october
app
app
hayes
november
st
subsequent
statute
may
repealed
acts
parts
acts
imposed
duties
upon
tonnage
ships
vessels
foreign
nations
provided
president
satisfied
discriminating
countervailing
duties
foreign
nations
far
operate
disadvantage
abolished
provision
preserved
section
revised
statutes
pursuant
act
congress
august
carrying
effect
treaty
great
britain
june
president
pierce
issued
proclamation
december
declaring
grain
flour
breadstuffs
kinds
numerous
specified
articles
admitted
free
duty
newfoundland
received
satisfactory
evidence
province
consented
due
proper
manner
provisions
treaty
extended
allow
full
benefits
stipulations
far
applicable
newfoundland
app
act
congress
approved
march
importation
neat
cattle
hides
neat
cattle
foreign
country
prohibited
operation
act
however
suspended
foreign
country
countries
parts
country
countries
whenever
secretary
treasury
officially
determine
give
public
notice
thereof
importation
tend
introduction
spread
contagious
infectious
diseases
among
cattle
act
provided
president
whenever
judgment
importation
neat
cattle
hides
neat
cattle
may
made
without
danger
introduction
spread
contagious
infectious
disease
among
cattle
may
proclamation
declare
provisions
act
inoperative
shall
afterwards
inoperative
shall
afterwards
inoperative
effect
said
proclamation
provisions
constituted
sections
revised
statutes
passage
act
march
tariff
act
importation
neat
cattle
hides
neat
cattle
foreign
countries
prohibited
authority
given
secretary
treasury
suspend
operation
act
country
whenever
determined
importation
lead
introduction
spread
contagious
infectious
diseases
among
cattle
chapter
st
execution
section
revised
statutes
president
arthur
issued
proclamation
declaring
day
march
long
products
articles
proceeding
imported
islands
cuba
porto
rico
exempt
discrimination
customs
duties
duties
products
articles
proceeding
cuba
porto
rico
spanish
flag
suspended
discontinued
president
cleveland
proclamation
october
revoked
suspension
upon
ground
higher
discriminating
duties
continued
imposed
levied
ports
named
upon
certain
produce
manufactures
merchandise
imported
foreign
countries
vessels
imposed
levied
like
produce
manufactures
merchandise
carried
ports
spanish
vessels
fourteenth
section
act
june
removing
certain
burdens
american
merchant
marine
encouraging
american
foreign
carring
trade
certain
tonnage
duties
imposed
upon
vessels
entering
foreign
port
place
north
america
central
america
west
india
islands
bahama
islands
bermuda
islands
saudwich
islands
newfoundland
president
authorized
suspend
collection
much
duties
vessels
entering
certain
ports
might
excess
tonnage
lighthouse
dues
equivalent
tax
taxes
imposed
american
vessels
government
foreign
country
port
situated
upon
passage
act
time
time
thereafter
often
may
become
necessary
reason
changes
laws
foreign
countries
mentioned
indicate
proclamation
ports
suspension
shall
apply
rate
rates
tonnage
duty
collected
suspension
execution
act
presidents
arthur
cleveland
issued
proclamations
suspending
collection
duties
goods
arriving
certain
designated
ports
seem
unnecessary
make
reference
acts
congress
show
authority
conferred
upon
president
third
section
act
october
entirely
new
feature
legislation
congress
sanction
many
precedents
legislation
precedents
stronger
others
application
case
us
show
judgment
legislative
branch
government
often
desirable
essential
protection
interests
people
unfriendly
discriminating
regulations
established
foreign
governments
interest
people
invest
president
large
discretion
matters
arising
execution
statutes
relating
trade
commerce
nations
decision
case
aurora
never
rendered
practical
construction
constitution
given
many
acts
congress
embracing
almost
entire
period
national
existence
overruled
unless
upon
conviction
legislation
clearly
incompatible
law
land
stuart
laird
cranch
martin
hunter
wheat
cooley
board
wardens
lithographic
sarony
sup
laura
sup
authority
given
president
act
june
lay
embargo
ships
vessels
ports
opinion
public
safety
shall
require
regulations
becontinued
revoked
shall
think
proper
act
february
remit
discontinue
time
restrains
prohibitions
congress
prescribed
respect
commercial
intercourse
french
republic
shall
deem
expedient
consistent
interest
revoke
order
whenever
opinion
interest
shall
require
act
december
suspend
named
time
operation
act
year
judgment
public
interest
require
act
may
revive
former
act
great
britain
france
either
country
named
day
revoked
modified
edicts
violate
neutral
commerce
acts
march
may
declare
repeal
foreign
nation
several
acts
imposing
duties
tonnage
ships
vessels
goods
wares
merchandise
imported
discriminating
duties
foreign
nations
far
operate
disadvantage
abolished
act
march
declare
provisions
act
forbidding
importation
country
neat
cattle
hides
neat
cattle
inoperative
judgment
importation
made
without
danger
introduction
spread
contagious
infectious
disease
among
cattle
regarded
unwarranted
constitution
contention
appellants
respect
third
section
act
october
sustained
congress
delegate
legislative
power
president
principle
universally
recognized
vital
integrity
maintenance
system
government
ordained
constitution
act
october
particular
consideration
inconsistent
principle
real
sense
invest
president
power
legislation
purpose
securing
reciprocal
trade
countries
producing
exporting
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
congress
determined
provisions
act
october
permitting
free
introduction
articles
suspended
country
producing
exporting
imposed
exactions
duties
agricultural
products
president
deemed
found
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
congress
prescribed
advance
duties
levied
collected
paid
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
produced
exported
designated
country
suspension
lasted
nothing
involving
expediency
operation
legislation
left
determination
president
words
may
deem
third
section
course
implied
president
examine
commercial
regulations
countries
producing
exporting
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
form
judgment
whether
reciprocally
equal
reasonable
contrary
effect
upon
american
products
ascertained
fact
duties
exactions
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
imposed
upon
agricultural
products
country
producing
exporting
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
became
duty
issue
proclamation
declaring
suspension
county
congress
determined
occur
discretion
premises
except
respect
duration
suspension
ordered
related
enforcement
policy
established
congress
suspension
absolutely
required
president
ascertained
existence
particular
fact
said
ascertaining
fact
issuing
proclamation
obedience
legislative
exercised
function
making
laws
legislative
power
exercised
congress
declared
suspension
take
effect
upon
named
contingency
president
required
simply
execution
act
congress
making
law
mere
agent
department
ascertain
declare
event
upon
expressed
take
effect
part
law
left
hands
congress
provisions
full
complete
permitting
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
particular
countries
suspended
given
contingency
case
suspension
certain
duties
imposed
true
distinction
judge
ranney
speaking
ohio
well
said
delegation
power
make
law
necessarily
involves
discretion
shall
conferring
authority
discretion
execution
exercised
pursuance
law
first
done
latter
valid
objection
made
railroad
commissioners
ohio
moers
city
reading
language
statutes
books
alternative
depending
discretion
person
persons
confided
duty
determining
whether
proper
occasion
exists
executing
said
exercise
discretion
making
law
locke
appeal
assert
law
less
law
made
depend
future
event
act
rob
legislature
power
act
wisely
public
welfare
whenever
law
passed
relating
state
affairs
yet
developed
things
future
impossible
fully
know
proper
distinction
said
legislature
delegate
power
make
law
make
law
delegate
power
determine
fact
state
things
upon
law
makes
intends
make
action
depend
deny
stop
wheels
government
many
things
upon
wise
useful
legislation
must
depend
known
power
must
therefore
subject
inquiry
determination
outside
halls
legislation
said
equally
applicable
objection
third
section
act
invests
president
power
opinion
third
section
act
october
liable
objection
transfers
legislative
power
president
even
means
follow
parts
act
directly
imposed
duties
upon
articles
imported
inoperative
need
connection
enter
upon
consideration
question
act
october
par
sugar
provides
july
first
eighteen
hundred
july
first
nineteen
hundred
five
shall
paid
moneys
treasury
otherwise
appropriated
provisions
section
three
thousand
six
hundred
revised
statutes
producer
sugar
testing
less
ninety
degrees
polariscope
beets
sorghum
grown
within
maple
sap
produced
within
bounty
two
cents
per
pound
upon
sugar
testing
less
ninety
degrees
polariscope
less
eighty
degrees
bounty
one
fourths
cents
per
pound
rules
regulations
commissioner
internal
revenue
approval
secretary
treasury
shall
prescribe
pp
appellants
contend
congress
power
appropriate
money
treasury
payment
bounties
provisions
connection
system
established
act
entire
act
must
held
inoperative
void
question
constitutional
power
thus
raised
depends
principally
altogether
upon
scope
effect
clause
constitution
giving
congress
power
lay
collect
taxes
duties
imposts
excises
pay
debts
provide
common
defense
general
welfare
article
difficult
suggest
question
larger
importance
one
decision
argument
validity
entire
act
depends
upon
validity
bounty
clause
obviously
founded
error
justified
giving
question
constitutional
power
raised
extended
examination
question
gravity
circumstances
demand
even
position
appellants
respect
power
congress
pay
bounties
sustained
clear
parts
act
interested
namely
laying
duties
upon
articles
imported
remain
force
elementary
principle
said
statute
may
part
constitutional
part
unconstitutional
parts
wholly
independent
constitutional
may
stand
unconstitutional
rejected
allen
louisiana
huntington
worthen
justice
field
speaking
said
different
clauses
act
dependent
upon
evident
legislature
enacted
one
without
two
things
provided
necessary
parts
one
whole
act
fall
invalidity
one
clause
connection
dependency
act
stand
though
different
parts
rejected
said
evident
provisions
imposing
duties
imported
articles
connected
dependent
upon
giving
bounties
upon
production
sugars
country
former
adopted
except
connection
latter
undoubtedly
object
act
raise
revenue
support
government
exert
power
laying
collecting
taxes
duties
encourage
domestic
manufactures
industries
different
kinds
upon
success
promoters
act
claimed
materially
depended
national
prosperity
national
safety
assumed
made
appear
act
provisions
imposing
duties
imported
articles
adopted
except
connection
clause
giving
bounties
production
sugar
country
different
parts
act
respect
operation
legal
connection
whatever
entirely
separable
nature
law
wholly
independent
one
relates
imposition
duties
upon
imported
articles
appropriation
money
treasury
bounties
articles
produced
country
general
sense
may
said
parts
system
neither
words
general
scope
act
justifies
belief
congress
intended
operate
whole
separately
purpose
accomplishing
objects
respectively
designed
unless
impossible
avoid
general
revenue
statute
never
declared
inoperative
parts
particular
part
relating
distinct
subject
may
invalid
different
rule
might
disastrous
financial
operations
government
produce
utmost
confusion
business
entire
country
perceive
error
judgments
affirmed
justice
lamar
concurred
chief
justice
fuller
dissenting
chief
justice
concur
judgment
announced
proposition
maintained
opinion
third
section
known
provision
valid
constitutional
legislation
command
assent
desire
state
briefly
ground
dissent
think
particular
provision
repugnant
first
section
first
article
constitution
provides
legislative
powers
herein
granted
shall
vested
congress
shall
consist
senate
house
representatives
part
legislative
power
delegated
congress
department
government
executive
judicial
axiom
constitutional
law
universally
recognized
principle
essential
integrity
maintenance
system
government
ordained
constitution
legislative
power
must
remain
organ
lodged
instrument
think
section
question
delegate
legislative
power
executive
department
also
commits
department
matters
belonging
power
violation
paragraph
second
section
article
constitution
reads
thus
view
secure
reciprocal
trade
countries
producing
following
articles
purpose
first
day
january
eighteen
hundred
whenever
often
president
shall
satisfied
government
country
producing
exporting
sugars
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
raw
uncured
articles
imposes
duties
exactions
upon
agricultural
products
view
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
may
deem
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
shall
power
shall
duty
suspend
prolamation
effect
provisions
act
relating
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
production
country
time
shall
deem
case
suspension
duties
shall
levied
collected
paid
upon
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
product
exported
designated
country
follows
namely
think
legislation
character
sustained
decision
precedents
congressional
legislation
numerous
enough
properly
considered
practice
government
one
instances
referred
legislation
analogous
section
embodied
acts
congress
known
acts
pronounced
valid
case
aurora
cranch
act
march
forbidding
importation
may
great
britain
france
provided
president
hereby
authorized
case
either
france
great
britain
shall
revoke
modify
edicts
shall
cease
violate
neutral
commerce
declare
proclamation
trade
suspended
act
act
laying
embargo
renewed
nation
act
expired
congress
may
passed
act
enacted
case
either
great
britain
france
shall
day
march
next
revoke
modify
edicts
shall
cease
violate
neutral
commerce
fact
president
shall
declare
proclamation
nation
shall
within
three
months
thereafter
revoke
modify
edicts
like
manner
restrictions
embargo
act
expriation
three
months
date
proclamation
aforesaid
revived
full
force
effect
far
relates
nation
thus
refusing
neglecting
modify
edicts
manner
aforesaid
restrictions
imposed
act
shall
date
proclamation
cease
discontinued
relation
nation
revoking
modifying
decrees
manner
aforesaid
enactments
opinion
transferred
legislative
power
president
legislation
purely
contingent
provided
ascertainment
president
event
future
event
defined
act
directed
evidenced
proclamation
also
prescribed
consequences
follow
upon
proclamation
preclamation
wholly
nature
executive
act
prescribed
mode
ascertainment
involved
exercise
president
belonged
power
congress
enforced
whether
event
provided
happened
either
continuance
restrictions
one
hand
suspension
purpose
effect
section
consideration
radically
different
provided
statutes
intrust
president
ascertainment
fact
therein
defined
upon
law
go
operation
goes
deputes
president
power
suspend
another
section
act
whenever
may
deem
action
foreign
nation
producting
exporting
articles
named
section
unequal
unreasonable
deputes
power
continue
suspension
impose
revenue
duties
articles
named
time
may
deem
certainly
extends
executive
exercise
discretionary
powers
constitution
vested
department
unquestionably
vests
president
power
regulate
commerce
foreign
nations
produce
sugar
tea
coffee
molasses
hides
articles
impose
revenue
duties
upon
length
time
limited
solely
discretion
whenever
deems
revenue
system
policy
nation
articles
produced
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
operation
upon
products
country
features
section
opinion
palpable
violation
constitution
serve
distinguish
legislative
precedents
relied
upon
sustain
practice
government
none
legislative
precedents
save
one
referred
yet
undergone
review
sustained
decision
congressional
legislation
may
construed
delegating
president
power
suspend
law
exempting
importations
duty
reimpose
revenue
duties
upon
judgment
constitutes
policy
countries
fair
reasonable
reciprocity
legislative
precedents
avail
authority
clear
undoubted
principle
constitution
say
policy
phrase
products
comprehensive
embrances
manufacturing
mining
well
agricultural
products
interests
thus
intrusted
discretion
president
adjustment
trade
relations
countries
upon
basis
reciprocity
however
agree
propostition
particular
section
valid
constitutional
regard
essential
part
tariff
act
invalidate
provisions
therefore
concur
judgment
affirming
judgments
several
cases
footnotes
sup