humphrey
argued
may
decided
may
william
donovan
washington
henry
bond
ralstone
irvine
washington
counsel
plaintiff
attorney
general
stanley
reed
sol
washington
justice
sutherland
delivered
opinion
plaintiff
brought
suit
claims
recover
sum
money
alleged
due
deceased
salary
federal
trade
commissioner
october
president
undertook
remove
office
time
death
february
certified
two
questions
act
february
stat
usca
respect
power
president
make
removal
material
facts
give
rise
questions
follows
william
humphrey
decedent
december
nominated
president
hoover
succeed
member
federal
trade
commission
confirmed
senate
duly
commissioned
term
seven
years
expiring
september
taking
required
oath
office
entered
upon
duties
july
president
roosevelt
addressed
letter
commissioner
asking
resignation
ground
aims
purposes
administration
respect
work
commission
carried
effectively
personnel
selection
disclaiming
reflection
upon
commissioner
personally
upon
services
commissioner
replied
asking
time
sult
friends
correspondence
upon
subject
president
august
wrote
commissioner
expressing
hope
resignation
forthcoming
saying
know
realize
feel
mind
mind
go
along
together
either
policies
administering
federal
trade
commission
frankly
think
best
people
country
full
confidence
commissioner
declined
resign
october
president
wrote
date
hereby
removed
office
commissioner
federal
trade
commission
humphrey
never
acquiesced
action
continued
thereafter
insist
still
member
commission
entitled
perform
duties
receive
compensation
provided
law
rate
per
annum
upon
facts
set
forth
certificate
deem
unnecessary
recite
following
questions
certified
provisions
section
federal
trade
commission
act
stating
commissioner
may
removed
president
inefficiency
neglect
duty
malfeasance
office
restrict
limit
power
president
remove
commissioner
except
upon
one
causes
named
foregoing
question
answered
affirmative
power
president
remove
commissioner
restricted
limited
shown
foregoing
interrogatory
answer
made
thereto
restriction
limitation
valid
constitution
federal
trade
commission
act
stat
usca
creates
commission
five
members
appointed
president
advice
consent
senate
section
provides
three
commissioners
shall
members
political
party
first
commissioners
appointed
shall
continue
office
terms
three
four
five
six
seven
years
respectively
date
taking
effect
act
september
term
designated
president
successors
shall
appointed
terms
seven
years
except
person
chosen
fill
vacancy
shall
appointed
unexpired
term
commissioner
shall
succeed
commission
shall
choose
chairman
membership
commissioner
shall
engage
business
vocation
employment
commissioner
may
removed
president
inefficiency
neglect
duty
malfeasance
office
section
act
usca
part
provides
methods
competition
commerce
declared
unlawful
commission
empowered
directed
prevent
persons
partnerships
corporations
except
banks
common
carriers
subject
acts
regulate
commerce
using
unfair
methods
competition
commerce
exercising
power
commission
must
issue
complaint
stating
charges
giving
notice
hearing
upon
day
fixed
person
partnership
corporation
proceeded
given
right
appear
time
place
fixed
show
cause
order
cease
desist
issued
provision
intervention
others
interested
commission
finds
method
competition
one
prohibited
act
directed
make
report
writing
stating
findings
facts
issue
cause
served
cease
desist
order
order
disobeyed
commission
may
apply
appropriate
circuit
appeals
enforcement
party
subject
order
may
seek
obtain
review
circuit
appeals
manner
provided
act
section
usca
among
things
gives
commission
wide
powers
investigation
respect
certain
corporations
subject
act
respect
matters
upon
must
report
congress
recommendations
many
investigations
made
served
basis
congressional
legislation
section
usca
provides
suit
equity
brought
direction
attorney
general
provided
antitrust
acts
may
upon
conclusion
testimony
therein
shall
opinion
complainant
entitled
relief
refer
said
suit
commission
master
chancery
ascertain
report
appropriate
form
decree
therein
commission
shall
proceed
upon
notice
parties
rules
procedure
may
prescribe
upon
coming
report
exceptions
may
filed
proceedings
relation
thereto
upon
report
master
equity
causes
may
adopt
reject
report
whole
part
enter
decree
nature
case
may
judgment
require
first
question
first
considered
whether
provisions
section
federal
trade
commission
act
already
quoted
president
power
limited
removal
specific
causes
enumerated
therein
negative
contention
government
based
principally
upon
decision
shurtleff
case
involved
power
president
remove
general
appraiser
merchandise
appointed
act
june
stat
section
act
provided
appointment
president
advice
sent
senate
nine
general
appraisers
merchandise
removed
office
time
president
inefficiency
neglect
duty
malfeasance
office
president
removed
shurtleff
without
assigning
cause
therefor
claims
dismissed
plaintiff
petition
recover
salary
upholding
president
power
remove
causes
stated
shurtleff
relied
upon
maxim
expressio
unius
est
exclusio
alterius
held
rule
expressed
maxim
proper
one
founded
upon
justifiable
reasoning
many
instances
accorded
controlling
weight
involve
alteration
universal
practice
government
century
consequent
curtailment
powers
executive
unusual
manner
meant
expression
appears
reading
opinion
opinion
saying
term
office
fixed
act
exception
judicial
officers
provided
constitution
civil
officer
ever
held
office
life
tenure
since
foundation
government
points
construe
statute
contended
shurtleff
give
appraiser
right
hold
office
life
found
guilty
act
specified
statute
result
complete
revolution
respect
general
tenure
office
effected
implication
regard
particular
office
think
quite
inadmissible
said
pages
attribute
intention
part
congress
make
extraordinary
change
usual
rule
governing
tenure
office
one
applied
particular
office
without
stating
intention
plain
explicit
language
instead
leaving
implied
doubtful
inferences
bring
belief
congress
ever
intended
result
omitting
use
language
put
intention
beyond
doubt
circumstances
led
reject
maxim
inapplicable
exceptional
face
unbroken
precedent
life
tenure
except
case
judiciary
conclusion
congress
intended
among
civil
officers
appraisers
alone
selected
hold
office
life
extreme
forbid
opinion
ruling
produce
result
reasonably
avoided
situation
presented
plainly
wholly
different
statute
fixes
term
office
accordance
many
precedents
first
commissioners
appointed
continue
office
terms
three
four
five
six
seven
years
respectively
successors
appointed
terms
seven
commissioner
subject
removal
president
inefficiency
neglect
duty
malfeasance
office
words
act
definite
unambiguous
government
says
phrase
office
legal
significance
moreover
applies
first
commissioners
think
significance
may
literally
application
restricted
suggested
nevertheless
lends
support
view
contrary
government
meaning
entire
requirement
respect
tenure
easy
suppose
congress
intended
secure
first
commissioners
removal
except
causes
specified
deny
like
security
successors
putting
phrase
aside
however
fixing
definite
term
subject
removal
cause
unless
countervailing
provision
circumstance
indicating
contrary
unable
find
enough
establish
legislative
intent
term
curtailed
absence
cause
intention
congress
removal
made
specified
term
except
one
enumerated
causes
clear
upon
face
statute
think
made
clear
consideration
character
commission
legislative
history
accompanied
preceded
passage
act
commission
nonpartisan
must
nature
duties
act
entire
impartiality
charged
enforcement
policy
except
policy
law
duties
neither
political
executive
predominantly
quasi
judicial
quasi
legislative
like
interstate
commerce
commission
members
called
upon
exercise
trained
judgment
body
experts
law
informed
experience
illinois
cent
inter
com
standard
oil
legislative
reports
houses
congress
clearly
reflect
view
fixed
term
necessary
effective
fair
administration
law
report
senate
pp
senate
committee
interstate
commerce
support
bill
afterwards
became
act
question
referring
provision
fixing
term
office
seven
years
arranged
membership
subject
complete
change
one
time
said
work
commission
exacting
difficult
character
demanding
persons
experience
problems
proper
knowledge
public
requirements
practical
affairs
industry
manifestly
desirable
terms
commissioners
shall
long
enough
give
opportunity
acquire
expertness
dealing
special
questions
concerning
industry
comes
experience
report
declares
one
advantage
commission
possessed
bureau
corporations
executive
subdivision
department
commerce
abolished
act
lay
fact
independence
essential
commission
open
suspicion
partisan
direction
report
quotes
statement
committee
senator
newlands
reported
bill
tribunal
high
character
department
government
board
commission
dignity
permanence
ability
independent
executive
authority
except
selection
independent
character
debates
houses
demonstrate
prevailing
view
commission
anybody
government
people
free
domination
control
possibility
thing
apart
existing
department
subject
orders
president
effect
appears
debates
long
thorough
contain
nothing
contrary
general
rule
precludes
use
debates
explain
meaning
words
statute
may
considered
reflecting
light
upon
general
purposes
evils
sought
remedy
federal
trade
commission
raladam
thus
language
act
legislative
reports
general
purposes
legislation
reflected
debates
combine
demonstrate
congressional
intent
create
body
experts
shall
gain
experience
length
service
body
shall
independent
executive
authority
except
selection
free
exercise
judgment
without
leave
hindrance
official
department
government
accomplishment
purposes
clear
congress
opinion
length
certainty
tenure
vitally
contribute
hold
nevertheless
members
commission
continue
office
mere
president
might
thwart
large
measure
ends
congress
sought
realize
definitely
fixing
term
office
conclude
intent
act
limit
executive
power
removal
causes
enumerated
existence
none
claimed
pass
second
question
second
support
contention
removal
provision
section
construed
unconstitutional
interference
executive
power
president
government
chief
reliance
myers
case
recently
decided
prevailing
dissenting
opinions
fully
review
general
subject
power
executive
removal
discussion
add
little
value
wealth
material
collected
opinions
examine
length
historical
legislative
judicial
data
bearing
upon
question
beginning
called
decision
first
congress
coming
almost
day
opinions
delivered
occupy
pages
volume
printed
nevertheless
narrow
point
actually
decided
president
power
remove
postmaster
first
class
without
advice
consent
senate
required
act
congress
course
opinion
expressions
occur
tend
sustain
government
contention
beyond
point
involved
therefore
come
within
rule
stare
decisis
far
harmony
views
set
forth
expressions
disapproved
like
situation
presented
case
cohens
virginia
wheat
respect
certain
general
expressions
opinion
marbury
madison
cranch
chief
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
marbury
case
speaking
cohens
case
said
maxim
disregarded
general
expressions
every
opinion
taken
connection
case
expressions
used
go
beyond
case
may
respected
control
judgment
subsequent
suit
point
presented
decision
reason
maxim
obvious
question
actually
investigated
care
considered
full
extent
principles
may
serve
illustrate
considered
relation
case
decided
possible
bearing
cases
seldom
completely
investigated
added
general
expressions
case
marbury
madison
understood
limitations
put
upon
opinion
cohens
case
see
also
carroll
lessee
carroll
et
office
postmaster
essentially
unlike
office
involved
decision
myers
case
accepted
controlling
decision
postmaster
executive
officer
restricted
performance
executive
functions
charged
duty
related
either
legislative
judicial
power
actual
decision
myers
case
finds
support
theory
officer
merely
one
units
executive
department
hence
inherently
subject
exclusive
illimitable
power
removal
chief
executive
whose
subordinate
aid
putting
aside
dicta
may
followed
sufficiently
persuasive
controlling
necessary
reach
decision
goes
far
enough
include
purely
executive
officers
goes
farther
much
less
include
officer
occupies
place
executive
department
exercises
part
executive
power
vested
constitution
president
federal
trade
commission
administrative
body
created
congress
carry
effect
legislative
policies
embodied
statute
accordance
legislative
standard
therein
prescribed
perform
specified
duties
legislative
judicial
aid
body
proper
sense
characterized
arm
eye
executive
duties
performed
without
executive
leave
contemplation
statute
must
free
executive
control
administering
provisions
statute
respect
methods
competition
say
filling
administering
details
embodied
general
standard
commission
acts
part
quasi
legislatively
part
quasi
judicially
making
investigations
reports
thereon
information
congress
section
aid
legislative
power
acts
legislative
agency
section
authorizes
commission
act
master
chancery
rules
prescribed
acts
agency
judiciary
extent
exercises
executive
function
distinguished
executive
power
constitutional
sense
discharge
effectuation
quasi
legislative
quasi
judicial
powers
agency
legislative
judicial
departments
government
congress
without
authority
prescribe
causes
removal
members
trade
commission
limit
executive
power
removal
accordingly
power
becomes
practically
respect
civil
officers
exception
judiciary
provided
constitution
solicitor
general
bar
apparently
recognizing
true
commendable
candor
agreed
view
respect
removability
members
federal
trade
commission
necessitated
like
view
respect
interstate
commerce
commission
claims
thus
confronted
serious
question
whether
members
quasi
legislative
quasi
judicial
bodies
judges
legislative
claims
exercising
judicial
power
williams
continue
office
pleasure
president
think
plain
constitution
illimitable
power
removal
possessed
president
respect
officers
character
named
authority
congress
creating
quasi
legislative
quasi
judicial
agencies
require
act
discharge
duties
independently
executive
control
well
doubted
authority
includes
appropriate
incident
power
fix
period
shall
continue
forbid
removal
except
cause
meantime
quite
evident
one
holds
office
pleasure
another
depended
upon
maintain
attitude
independence
latter
fundamental
necessity
maintaining
three
general
departments
government
entirely
free
control
coercive
influence
direct
indirect
either
others
often
stressed
hardly
open
serious
question
much
implied
fact
separation
powers
departments
constitution
rule
recognizes
essential
coequality
sound
application
principle
makes
one
master
house
precludes
imposing
control
house
another
master
james
wilson
one
framers
constitution
former
justice
said
independence
department
required
proceedings
free
remotest
influence
direct
indirect
either
two
powers
andrews
works
james
wilson
vol
justice
story
first
volume
work
constitution
ed
citing
federalist
said
neither
departments
reference
possess
directly
indirectly
overruling
influence
administration
respective
powers
see
supra
pages
power
removal
claimed
president
falls
within
principle
since
coercive
influence
threatens
independence
commission
wholly
disconnected
executive
department
already
fully
appears
created
congress
means
carrying
operation
legislative
judicial
powers
agency
legislative
judicial
departments
light
question
consideration
examined
precedents
referred
myers
case
find
nothing
justify
conclusion
contrary
reached
relation
bill
proposed
madison
establish
executive
department
foreign
affairs
bill
provided
principal
officer
removable
office
president
clause
changed
read
principal
officer
shall
removed
office
president
certain
things
follow
thereby
connection
debates
recognizing
confirming
thought
myers
case
sole
power
president
matter
shall
discuss
subject
since
fully
covered
opinions
myers
case
except
say
office
consideration
congress
purely
executive
officer
one
responsible
president
alone
definite
sense
reading
debates
shows
president
illimitable
power
removal
considered
respect
executive
officers
pertinent
observe
later
time
tenure
office
comptroller
treasury
consideration
madison
quite
evidently
thought
since
duties
office
purely
executive
nature
partook
judiciary
quality
well
different
rule
respect
executive
removal
might
well
apply
annals
congress
cols
marbury
madison
supra
cranch
pages
made
clear
chief
justice
marshall
opinion
justice
peace
district
columbia
removable
president
distinction
officer
officers
appointed
aid
president
performance
constitutional
duties
latter
case
distinction
saw
acts
acts
therefore
controls
way
illustration
adverted
act
establishing
department
foreign
affairs
subject
result
said
whether
power
president
remove
officer
shall
prevail
authority
congress
condition
power
fixing
definite
term
precluding
removal
except
cause
depend
upon
character
office
myers
decision
affirming
power
president
alone
make
removal
confined
purely
executive
officers
officers
kind
consideration
hold
removal
made
prescribed
term
officer
appointed
except
one
causes
named
applicable
statute
extent
decision
myers
case
sustains
unrestrictable
power
president
remove
purely
executive
officers
present
decision
power
extend
office
involved
shall
remain
field
doubt
leave
cases
may
fall
within
future
consideration
determination
may
arise
accordance
foregoing
questions
submitted
answered
question
yes
question
yes
justice
mcreynolds
agrees
questions
answered
affirmative
separate
opinion
myers
page
page
views
concerning
power
president
remove
appointees
footnotes
provision
section
act
usca
authorizes
president
direct
investigation
report
commission
relation
alleged
violations
acts
obviously
collateral
main
design
act
detract
force
general
statement
character
body