porter
warner
holding
argued
decided
june
milton
klein
washington
petitioner
townsend
minneapolis
respondent
justice
murphy
delivered
opinion
case
concerned
power
federal
enforcement
proceeding
emergency
price
control
act
order
restitution
rents
collected
landlord
excess
permissible
maximums
warner
holding
company
respondent
owns
eight
apartment
houses
minneapolis
minnesota
containing
approximately
dwelling
units
june
demanded
received
rents
excess
permitted
applicable
maximum
rent
regulations
issued
act
administrator
office
price
administration
brought
action
district
restrain
respondent
continuing
exceed
rent
ceilings
complaint
later
amended
seek
addition
decree
requiring
respondent
tender
persons
entitled
thereto
refund
amounts
collected
defendant
tenants
rent
use
occupancy
housing
accommodations
excess
maximum
rents
established
said
regulation
provided
however
defendant
shall
required
make
tender
person
commenced
action
defendant
section
emergency
price
control
act
alleging
collection
defendant
rent
excess
maximum
rents
established
said
regulation
district
enjoined
respondent
continuing
collect
rents
excess
legal
maximums
declined
order
restitution
bowles
warner
holding
eighth
circuit
appeals
affirmed
judgment
courts
held
jurisdiction
statute
order
restitution
granted
certiorari
result
conflict
reached
sixth
circuit
appeals
bowles
skaggs
obvious
importance
issue
administration
enforcement
emergency
price
control
act
proceeding
instituted
administrator
act
provides
judgment
administrator
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
constitute
constitute
violation
provision
section
act
may
make
application
appropriate
order
enjoining
acts
practices
order
enforcing
compliance
provision
upon
showing
administrator
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
permanent
temporary
injunction
restraining
order
order
shall
granted
without
bond
thus
administrator
invoked
jurisdiction
district
enjoin
acts
practices
made
illegal
act
enforce
compliance
act
jurisdiction
equitable
one
unless
otherwise
provided
statute
inherent
equitable
powers
district
available
proper
complete
exercise
jurisdiction
since
public
interest
involved
proceeding
nature
equitable
powers
assume
even
broader
flexible
character
private
controversy
stake
virginian
ry
system
federation
power
thereby
resident
district
exercising
jurisdiction
equity
mould
decree
necessities
particular
case
hecht
bowles
may
act
adjust
reconcile
competing
claims
accord
full
justice
real
parties
interest
necessary
persons
originally
connected
litigation
may
brought
rights
subject
matter
may
determined
enforced
addition
may
go
beyond
matters
immediately
underlying
equitable
jurisdiction
decide
whatever
issues
give
whatever
relief
may
necessary
circumstances
way
equity
complete
rather
truncated
justice
camp
boyd
moreover
comprehensiveness
equitable
jurisdiction
denied
limited
absence
clear
valid
legislative
command
unless
statute
many
words
necessary
inescapable
inference
restricts
jurisdiction
equity
full
scope
jurisdiction
recognized
applied
great
principles
equity
securing
complete
justice
yielded
light
inferences
doubtful
construction
brown
swann
pet
see
also
hecht
bowles
supra
readily
apparent
foregoing
decree
compelling
one
disgorge
profits
rents
property
quired
violation
emergency
price
control
act
may
properly
entered
district
equity
jurisdiction
invoked
indeed
language
admits
conclusion
expressly
envisages
applications
administrator
orders
enjoining
violations
act
orders
enforcing
compliance
act
expressly
authorizes
district
upon
proper
showing
grant
permanent
temporary
injunction
restraining
order
order
recognized
hecht
bowles
supra
term
order
contemplates
remedy
injunction
restraining
order
remedy
entered
exercise
district
equitable
discretion
order
recovery
restitution
illegal
rents
may
considered
proper
order
either
two
theories
may
considered
equitable
adjunct
injunction
decree
nothing
clearly
part
subject
matter
suit
injunction
recovery
illegally
acquired
given
rise
necessity
injunctive
relief
sure
recovery
obtained
independent
suit
equity
adequate
legal
remedy
available
white
sparkill
realty
lacassagne
chapuis
equitable
jurisdiction
properly
invoked
injunctive
purposes
power
decide
relevant
matters
dispute
award
complete
relief
even
though
decree
includes
might
conferred
law
alexander
hillman
may
considered
order
appropriate
necessary
enforce
compliance
act
section
anticipates
orders
character
although
makes
attempt
catalogue
infinite
forms
variations
orders
might
take
problem
formulating
orders
left
judicial
process
adapting
appropriate
equitable
remedies
specific
situations
cf
phelps
dodge
national
labor
relations
board
framing
remedies
courts
must
act
primarily
effectuate
policy
emergency
price
control
act
protect
public
interest
giving
necessary
respect
private
interests
involved
inherent
equitable
jurisdiction
thus
called
play
clearly
authorizes
discretion
decree
restitution
excessive
charges
order
give
effect
policy
congress
clark
smith
pet
unreasonable
conclude
restitution
order
appropriate
necessary
enforce
compliance
act
give
effect
purposes
future
compliance
may
definitely
assured
one
compelled
restore
one
illegal
gains
statutory
policy
eventing
inflation
plainly
advanced
prices
rents
collected
past
reduced
legal
maximums
legislative
background
confirms
conclusion
traditional
equity
powers
remain
unimpaired
proceeding
section
order
restitution
may
made
senate
committee
banking
currency
reporting
upon
bill
became
emergency
price
control
act
stated
regard
common
substantially
regulatory
statutes
bill
authorizes
official
charged
duty
administering
act
apply
appropriate
state
federal
order
enjoining
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
constitute
constitute
violation
provision
bill
courts
given
jurisdiction
issue
whatever
order
enforce
compliance
proper
circumstances
particular
case
last
sentence
unmistakable
acknowledgement
courts
equity
free
act
way
responsive
statutory
policy
preventing
inflation
true
authorizes
aggrieved
purchaser
tenant
sue
damages
behalf
person
sued
within
statutory
period
reason
entitled
sue
administrator
may
institute
action
damages
behalf
extent
damages
might
properly
awarded
equity
exercise
jurisdiction
see
veazie
williams
supersedes
possibility
provides
exclusive
remedy
relative
damages
establishes
sole
means
whereby
individuals
may
assert
private
right
damages
whereby
administrator
behalf
may
seek
damages
ture
penalties
moreover
giving
relief
acts
law
rather
equity
exception
damages
way
conflicts
jurisdiction
equity
courts
issue
whatever
orders
may
necessary
vindicate
public
interest
compel
compliance
act
prevent
undo
inflationary
tendencies
restitution
lies
within
equitable
jurisdiction
consistent
differs
greatly
damages
penalties
may
awarded
bowles
skaggs
supra
administrator
seeks
restitution
request
award
statutory
damages
purchaser
tenant
pay
person
part
penalties
go
treasury
suit
administrator
rather
asks
act
public
interest
restoring
status
quo
ordering
return
rightfully
belongs
purchaser
tenant
action
within
recognized
power
within
highest
tradition
equity
thus
plainly
unaffected
provisions
find
provision
act
expressly
impliedly
precludes
ordering
restitution
exercise
equity
jurisdiction
situation
statute
created
right
provided
special
exclusive
remedy
thereby
negativing
jurisdiction
might
otherwise
asserted
babcock
clearly
instance
equity
jurisdiction
lacking
failure
exhaust
prescribed
administrative
remedies
myers
bethlehem
shipbuilding
rather
occasion
congress
utilized
save
one
aspect
broad
equitable
jurisdiction
inheres
courts
proposed
exercise
jurisdiction
consistent
statutory
language
policy
legislative
background
public
interest
follows
district
erred
declining
jurisdictional
reasons
consider
whether
restitution
order
necessary
proper
circumstances
present
case
must
therefore
remanded
may
exercise
discretion
belongs
decide
issue
restitution
order
appear
conflicting
claims
counterclaims
tenants
landlord
amounts
due
inherent
power
bring
interested
parties
settle
controversies
retain
case
matters
otherwise
litigated
mallow
hinde
wheat
reversed
justice
jackson
took
part
consideration
decision
case
justice
rutledge
dissenting
emergency
price
control
legislation
congress
much
concerned
remedies
substantive
prohibitions
knew
effectiveness
latter
depended
altogether
upon
scheme
enforcement
accordingly
original
later
covered
matter
remedies
greatest
detail
precision
provisions
jurisdictional
procedural
general
scheme
confine
narrowly
constitution
allows
rights
regulated
persons
challenge
provisions
act
regulations
time
create
broad
powers
enforcement
various
civil
criminal
sanctions
yakus
dissenting
opinion
congress
take
chances
either
respect
inference
construction
excessive
say
perhaps
legislation
history
equalled
price
control
acts
wealth
detail
precision
completeness
jurisdictional
procedural
remedial
provisions
yakus
supra
scheme
enforcement
highly
integrated
parts
precisely
tooled
minutely
geared
legal
equitable
criminal
sanctions
included
injured
persons
remedies
dovetailed
guarded
overlapping
given
administrator
sue
damages
penalties
injured
party
failed
time
allowed
enjoin
tion
secure
order
compliance
temporary
permanent
relief
cause
institution
criminal
proceedings
require
licensing
dealers
power
suspend
license
thus
drive
business
powerful
battery
weapons
call
reinforcement
armor
provided
act
equal
tasks
enforcement
conceivably
arise
congress
ignorant
remedy
restitution
knew
give
remedies
wished
confer
need
add
one
think
give
expressly
think
order
context
includes
conferred
put
statutory
scheme
joint
section
gives
overcharged
person
remedy
damages
penalty
limited
time
thereafter
exclusive
right
sue
administrator
recovers
goes
federal
treasury
overcharged
person
includes
amount
overcharge
sued
provisions
taken
together
statute
limitations
private
right
recovery
time
goes
cut
government
right
takes
place
vindication
public
interest
restitution
sought
inconsistent
rights
contemplates
return
unjustly
taken
enrichment
taken
right
administrator
seeks
assert
think
teeth
statute
recovers
act
makes
part
sum
says
shall
paid
treasury
whenever
recovered
administrator
overcharged
person
pocket
recovered
mutually
exclusive
alternative
rights
recovery
administrator
pays
tenants
recovers
suit
paying
money
act
says
shall
go
treasury
time
suit
passed
right
recover
amounts
whether
administrator
sue
amounts
behalf
government
foregoing
penalties
asked
decide
asked
effect
decide
take
money
act
says
shall
go
treasury
give
persons
whose
right
recover
act
cut
think
remedy
sought
inconsistent
remedies
expressly
given
statute
contrary
substantive
rights
creates
think
congress
failed
provide
restitution
indeed
cut
remedy
imply
restriction
upon
creative
resources
equity
congress
silent
formulating
remedies
rights
created
courts
equity
free
use
creative
resources
congress
explicit
remedies
affords
especially
congress
given
limited
remedies
enlarges
scope
remedies
particularizes
far
remedies
overcharges
afforded
even
courts
equity
may
grant
relief
disregard
remedies
specifically
defined
congress
justice
reed
justice
frankfurter
join
opinion
footnotes
stat
defendant
notice
pending
injunction
proceeding
completes
acts
sought
enjoined
equity
may
restore
status
quo
means
mandatory
injunction
texas
northside
ry
porter
lee
report
also
authorizes
administrator
enforce
compliance
provisions
section
bill
whenever
judgment
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
constitute
constitute
violation
provision
section
making
application
appropriate
order
enjoining
acts
practices
order
enforcing
compliance
provision
upon
showing
administrator
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
temporary
permanent
injunction
restraining
order
order
granted
without
bond
section
amended
stabilization
extension
act
stat
congress
recognized
provision
damage
actions
affords
remedy
law
persons
damaged
pay
unlawfully
high
prices
also
stated
action
people
remedy
inflation
written
statute
congress
recognized
practical
need
aid
enforcement
amendment
whereby
administrator
allowed
sue
damages
prescribed
conditions
said
important
gap
present
system
enforcement
sanctions
id
nowhere
however
indication
intended
whittle
equitable
jurisdiction
recg
nized
preclude
suit
restitution
see
control
made
effective
least
bad
price
control
stop
inflation
enables
defy
regulation
profit
expense
buyers
sellers
unselfishly
cooperate
interests
emergency
supra
section
stat
stat
amending
subsections
original
act
adding
subsection
section
see
note
section
judgment
administrator
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
constitute
constitute
violation
provision
section
act
may
make
application
appropriate
order
enjoining
acts
practices
order
enforcing
compliance
provision
upon
showing
administrator
person
engaged
engage
acts
practices
permanent
temporary
injunction
restraining
roder
order
shall
granted
without
bond
section
person
willfully
violates
provision
section
act
person
makes
statement
entry
false
material
respect
document
report
required
kept
filed
section
section
shall
upon
conviction
thereof
subject
fine
imprisonment
two
years
case
violation
section
one
year
cases
fine
imprisonment
whenever
administrator
reason
believe
person
liable
punishment
subsection
may
certify
facts
attorney
general
may
discretion
cause
appropriate
proceedings
brought
section
see
kraus
note
section
original
act
stat
administrator
entitled
bring
suit
damages
penalties
buyer
entitled
bring
action
see
eg
bowles
glick
lumber
act
subsequently
amended
provide
set
text
administrator
bring
suit
damages
penalties
also
injured
party
brought
action
within
thirty
days
date
occurrence
violation
stat
see
note
suit
bar
brought
passage
amendment
fact
significance
since
whether
taken
original
amended
form
inconsistent
remedy
restitution
sought
government
section
person
selling
commodity
violates
regulation
order
price
schedule
prescribing
maximum
price
maximum
prices
person
buys
commodity
use
consumption
course
trade
business
may
within
one
year
date
occurrence
violation
except
hereinafter
provided
bring
action
seller
account
overcharge
action
seller
shall
liable
reasonable
attorney
fees
costs
determined
plus
whichever
following
sums
greater
amount
three
times
amount
overcharge
overcharges
upon
action
based
discretion
may
determine
amount
less
discretion
may
determine
provided
however
amount
shall
amount
overcharge
overcharges
whichever
greater
defendant
proves
violation
regulation
order
price
schedule
question
neither
wilfull
sic
result
failure
take
practicable
precautions
occurrence
violation
purposes
section
payment
receipt
rent
housing
accommodations
shall
deemed
buying
selling
commodity
case
may
word
shall
mean
amount
consideration
exceeds
applicable
maximum
price
person
selling
commodity
violates
regulation
order
price
schedule
prescribing
maximum
price
maximum
prices
buyer
either
fails
institute
action
subsection
within
thirty
days
date
occurrence
violation
entitled
reason
bring
action
administrator
may
institute
action
behalf
within
period
action
instituted
administrator
buyer
shall
thereafter
barred
bringing
action
violation
violations
action
subsection
either
buyer
administrator
case
may
may
brought
competent
jurisdiction
judgment
action
damages
subsection
shall
bar
recovery
subsection
damages
action
thes
ame
seller
account
sales
made
purchaser
prior
institution
action
judgment
rendered
emphasis
added