jarecki
searle
argued
march
decided
june
together
polaroid
corporation
commissioner
internal
revenue
certiorari
appeals
first
circuit
argued
march
development
new
products
discovery
within
meaning
internal
revenue
code
amended
income
resulting
manufacture
sale
certain
patented
drugs
cameras
camera
equipment
stereo
products
resulting
inventions
included
within
statutory
definition
abnormal
income
qualify
korean
war
excess
profits
tax
relief
excess
profits
tax
act
pp
income
made
eligible
korean
war
excess
profits
tax
relief
concluding
sentence
paragraph
provides
classification
income
class
described
subparagraphs
inclusive
shall
subject
regulations
prescribed
secretary
pp
reversed
affirmed
wayne
barnett
argued
cause
petitioners
respondent
briefs
former
solicitor
general
rankin
solicitor
general
cox
assistant
attorneys
general
rice
oberdorfer
acting
assistant
attorneys
general
sellers
heffron
harry
marselli
norman
wolfe
isaac
barnett
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
david
saperstein
walter
cummings
argued
cause
respondent
brief
edwin
austin
chief
justice
warren
delivered
opinion
cases
present
problems
interpretation
internal
revenue
code
section
excess
profits
tax
act
stat
act
intended
tax
high
rates
unusually
high
profits
earned
korean
war
imposes
tax
profits
excess
amount
deemed
represent
taxpayer
normal
profits
recognizing
however
profits
otherwise
subject
tax
scheme
might
stem
causes
inflated
wartime
economy
congress
enacted
section
grants
relief
certain
cases
abnormal
income
defined
allocating
income
years
received
purposes
computing
tax
dispute
cases
whether
income
sales
certain
new
products
falls
within
statutory
definition
abnormal
income
taxpayers
claim
income
sales
products
income
resulting
discovery
claim
therefore
abnormal
income
within
class
defined
income
resulting
exploration
discovery
prospecting
combination
foregoing
extending
period
months
taxpayer
inventor
producer
polaroid
land
process
camera
film
produce
photograph
seconds
polaroid
synthetic
polarizer
device
incorporated
viewers
audiences
watched
three
dimensional
motion
pictures
vogue
years
ago
inventions
product
months
research
novel
according
taxpayer
patented
polaroid
land
equipment
subject
patents
end
taxpayer
characterizes
invention
revolutionary
production
new
departure
business
taxpayer
hitherto
engaged
primarily
manufacturing
selling
optical
products
polarizing
sunglasses
visors
camera
filters
returns
taxpayer
utilized
provisions
computing
tax
income
sales
photographic
equipment
polarizers
commissioner
determined
applicable
tax
upheld
determination
deficiency
appeals
first
circuit
affirmed
holding
taxpayer
inventions
discoveries
income
sale
abnormal
income
granted
certiorari
case
resolve
conflict
decisions
first
seventh
circuits
present
purposes
accept
first
circuit
taxpayers
assertions
novelty
products
also
agree
taxpayers
inventions
discoveries
word
used
income
sales
new
products
may
receive
special
treatment
provided
look
first
face
statute
discovery
word
usable
many
contexts
various
shades
meaning
however
stand
alone
gathers
meaning
words
around
words
strongly
suggest
precise
narrow
application
intended
three
words
conjunction
exploration
discovery
prospecting
describe
activity
oil
gas
mining
industries
difficult
conceive
industry
apply
certainly
development
manufacture
drugs
cameras
industries
maxim
noscitur
sociis
word
known
company
keeps
inescapable
rule
often
wisely
applied
word
capable
many
meanings
order
avoid
giving
unintended
breadth
acts
congress
see
neal
clark
application
maxim
leads
conclusion
discovery
means
discovery
mineral
resources
examine
construction
compare
subparagraphs
becomes
unmistakably
clear
discovery
meant
include
development
patentable
products
discovery
wide
scope
need
provision
subparagraph
income
sale
patents
formulae
processes
income
taxpayers
reading
discovery
also
income
resulting
discovery
within
subparagraph
borrow
homely
metaphor
judge
aldrich
first
circuit
big
hole
fence
big
cat
need
small
hole
small
one
statute
admits
reasonable
construction
gives
effect
provisions
circumstances
adopt
strained
reading
renders
one
part
mere
redundancy
see
menasche
taxpayers
assert
ordinary
meaning
discovery
must
govern
find
ample
evidence
face
statute
shall
show
legislative
history
technical
usage
intended
even
without
evidence
find
difficult
believe
congress
intended
apply
layman
meaning
discovery
describe
products
research
lead
necessity
drawing
line
things
found
things
made
ordinary
usage
things
revealed
discoveries
new
fabrications
inventions
appear
senseless
congress
adopt
usage
provide
relief
income
discoveries
yet
make
provision
income
inventions
perhaps
patent
law
discovery
uncommonly
wide
meaning
taxpayers
suggest
fields
patents
taxation
lores
unto
usage
patent
law
means
entirely
taxpayers
favor
unpersuasive
evidence
effect
congress
intend
introduce
difficult
distinction
inventions
discoveries
excess
profits
tax
law
relevant
legislative
history
fortifies
conclusions
words
statute
lead
us
word
discovery
used
many
years
tax
laws
always
used
limited
meaning
finding
mineral
deposits
revenue
act
enacting
one
earliest
excess
profits
tax
laws
limit
placed
excess
profits
tax
income
bona
fide
sale
mines
oil
gas
wells
interest
therein
principal
value
property
demonstrated
prospecting
exploration
discovery
work
done
taxpayer
revenue
act
stat
identical
limitation
imposed
income
tax
levied
act
usage
discovery
obtained
allowance
depletion
deductions
limitation
income
tax
proceeds
sale
mineral
deposits
without
significant
change
revenue
acts
remains
income
tax
provisions
internal
revenue
code
carried
forward
code
discovery
linked
exploration
prospecting
word
restrictively
applied
extractive
industries
correspondingly
narrow
use
discovery
continued
since
depletion
allowance
sections
appears
code
years
preceding
enactment
section
issue
time
discovery
used
successive
taxing
statutes
word
developed
term
art
precise
limited
meaning
excess
profits
tax
act
stat
made
specific
mention
types
abnormal
income
qualifying
relief
earlier
excess
profits
tax
statutes
indication
worked
transformation
meaning
discovery
section
stat
amended
stat
classified
six
types
abnormal
income
among
following
income
resulting
exploration
discovery
prospecting
research
development
tangible
property
patents
formulae
processes
combination
foregoing
extending
period
months
relief
provisions
excess
profits
tax
act
construe
modeled
part
world
war
ii
act
different
significant
respects
classifications
income
new
congress
gave
separate
treatment
income
discovery
minerals
income
invention
provided
relief
subparagraph
income
resulting
exploration
discovery
prospecting
provided
subparagraph
income
sale
patents
formulae
processes
emphasis
added
subparagraph
encompass
income
inventions
cover
income
sale
products
made
new
patent
sort
income
issue
taxpayers
assert
income
inventions
realistically
speaking
abnormal
businesses
discovery
new
mine
business
prospector
income
within
spirit
say
held
within
letter
subparagraph
clear
however
congress
may
recognized
abnormal
nature
sort
income
chose
deliberately
deny
relief
limit
relief
cases
research
development
provided
subparagraph
relief
provisions
world
war
ii
act
intended
provide
flexible
rules
application
often
uncertain
affair
administering
commissioner
often
faced
difficult
task
separating
income
product
research
development
resulting
merely
improved
management
sales
efforts
difficulty
distinction
led
tax
hold
distinction
must
made
exercising
common
sense
judgment
entirely
possible
allocation
made
one
person
never
match
made
another
ramsey
accessories
mfg
commissioner
congress
recognized
delay
uncertainty
caused
element
administrative
discretion
sections
set
drafting
excess
profits
tax
law
principle
subjective
judgments
avoided
new
law
sess
principle
expressly
followed
drafting
senate
committee
reported
follows
equivalent
provision
world
war
ii
law
sec
also
permitted
adjustments
reference
certain
types
income
particularly
resulting
sale
tangible
property
arising
research
development
extended
period
months
provision
old
law
potential
loophole
major
dimensions
appeared
means
restricting
adjustment
truly
meritorious
cases
introduction
large
degree
administrative
discretion
type
required
general
relief
clause
world
war
ii
law
sec
need
reallocation
income
seemed
materially
less
classes
income
described
bill
omits
item
list
abnormal
types
income
reallocation
made
sess
taxpayers
recognize
must
congress
intended
change
language
limit
kinds
income
eligible
relief
say
however
income
research
development
excluded
comes
inventions
merely
patentable
also
sufficiently
revolutionary
called
genuine
discoveries
still
within
protection
find
impossible
believe
amendment
designed
eliminate
uncertainly
administrative
discretion
introduce
law
without
congressional
word
warning
explanation
distinction
vague
dependent
upon
nuances
scientific
opinion
unprecedented
urged
taxpayers
ii
taxpayers
another
argument
first
circuit
rejected
seventh
circuit
reach
paragraph
defines
abnormal
income
income
class
described
paragraph
meets
certain
requirements
paragraph
lists
four
classes
income
provides
concluding
sentence
classification
income
class
described
subparagraphs
inclusive
shall
subject
regulations
prescribed
secretary
need
decide
precise
effect
sentence
relied
light
clear
purpose
congress
enacting
cut
amount
administrative
discretion
prevailed
predecessor
section
also
scope
available
relief
power
secretary
extend
relief
far
beyond
four
corners
statute
may
doubted
sufficient
note
unlike
predecessor
made
relief
available
abnormal
income
whether
specified
particular
class
applies
classes
specified
section
apply
terms
abnormal
income
contains
indication
secretary
create
administrative
classifications
embracing
income
even
sentence
relied
gives
secretary
power
expand
classes
abnormal
income
somewhat
beyond
four
enumerated
statute
clearly
done
regulations
specifically
provide
income
sale
tangible
property
arising
research
development
extended
period
months
included
list
abnormal
types
income
section
applicable
income
may
constitute
class
income
purposes
section
specific
exclusion
clearly
furtherance
purpose
congress
deleting
research
development
income
classification
abnormal
income
commissioner
effecting
congress
barred
relief
type
income
issue
last
sentence
regulation
taxpayers
also
rely
aid
provides
merely
research
development
income
eligible
relief
properly
includible
class
income
otherwise
applies
held
however
taxpayers
income
fall
within
class
therefore
judgment
appeals
seventh
circuit
must
reversed
judgment
appeals
first
circuit
affirmed
ordered
footnotes
section
provides
part
definitions
purposes
section
abnormal
income
term
abnormal
income
means
income
class
described
paragraph
includible
gross
income
taxpayer
taxable
year
subchapter
abnormal
taxpayer
derive
income
class
taxpayer
normally
derives
income
class
amount
income
class
includible
gross
income
taxable
year
excess
per
centum
average
amount
gross
income
class
four
previous
taxable
years
taxpayer
existence
four
previous
taxable
years
taxable
years
taxpayer
existence
separate
classes
income
following
subparagraphs
shall
held
describe
separate
class
income
income
arising
claim
award
judgment
decree
interest
foregoing
income
resulting
exploration
discovery
prospecting
combination
foregoing
extending
period
months
income
sale
patents
formulae
processes
combination
foregoing
developed
period
months
income
includible
gross
income
taxable
year
rather
different
taxable
year
reason
change
taxpayer
method
accounting
income
classifiable
one
subparagraphs
shall
classified
one
taxpayer
irrevocably
elects
classification
income
class
described
subparagraphs
inclusive
shall
subject
regulations
prescribed
secretary
lay
terms
polaroid
photographic
equipment
searle
drugs
probably
better
called
inventions
discoveries
webster
new
international
dictionary
unabridged
ed
makes
distinction
one
discovers
existed
remained
unknown
one
invents
forming
combinations
either
entirely
new
attain
end
means
unknown
columbus
discovered
america
newton
discovered
law
gravitation
edison
invented
phonograph
constitution
art
cl
gives
congress
power
secure
inventors
exclusive
right
discoveries
terms
discover
discovery
used
throughout
patent
statutes
seem
generally
appear
invent
invention
terms
separate
meanings
see
whoever
invents
discovers
new
useful
process
machine
manufacture
composition
matter
may
obtain
patent
therefor
see
dolbear
american
bell
telephone
telephone
cases
section
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
providing
case
mines
oil
gas
wells
discovered
taxpayer
fair
market
value
property
materially
disproportionate
cost
depletion
allowance
shall
based
upon
fair
market
value
property
date
discovery
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
revenue
act
stat
section
revenue
act
stat
gave
commissioner
power
grant
relief
case
tax
owing
abnormal
conditions
affecting
capital
income
corporation
work
upon
corporation
exceptional
hardship
section
world
war
ii
law
classified
specific
types
abnormal
income
purposes
computing
tax
provided
relief
abnormal
income
whatever
class
considered
general
relief
section
expressly
provided
world
war
ii
excess
profits
tax
statute
stat
words
used
statute
meaning
used
income
tax
chapter
code
sess
general
relief
section
world
war
ii
act
stat
amended
stat
stat
stat
stat
provided
adjustments
computation
base
period
income
taxpayer
established
among
things
fair
amount
representing
normal
earnings
base
period
fact
committee
reports
state
adjustments
limited
income
arising
four
classes
specified
subparagraphs
sess
sess
excess
profits
tax
act
stat
amended
stat
section
defines
abnormal
income
income
class
includible
gross
income
taxpayer
treas
reg
amended
cum
bull
income
within
class
described
subparagraphs
section
section
applicable
may
grouped
taxpayer
subject
approval
commissioner
examination
taxpayer
return
classes
similar
specified
subparagraphs
section
reasonable
business
type
taxpayer
conducts
appropriate
light
taxpayer
business
experience
accounting
practice
income
sale
tangible
property
arising
research
development
extended
period
months
included
list
abnormal
types
income
section
applicable
income
may
constitute
class
income
purposes
section
however
section
applicable
income
income
otherwise
properly
includible
within
class
income
section
applicable
example
class
described
section