claflin
houseman
argued
decided
october
error
state
new
york
action
brought
may
new
york
county
kings
julius
houseman
claflin
houseman
assignee
bankruptcy
comstock
young
horace
claflin
section
bankrupt
act
recover
sum
interest
amount
collected
claflin
judgment
bankrupts
recovered
within
four
months
commencement
proceedings
bankruptcy
ground
action
stated
complaint
bankrupts
suffered
judgment
taken
default
intent
give
claflin
preference
creditors
time
insolvent
knew
reasonable
cause
believe
insolvent
judgment
obtained
fraud
bankrupt
law
defendant
demurred
complaint
assigning
cause
first
jurisdiction
subject
action
secondly
complaint
state
facts
sufficient
constitute
cause
action
judgment
rendered
plaintiff
thirteenth
day
january
subsequently
affirmed
general
term
appeals
judgment
brought
writ
error
second
section
act
stat
argued
william
henry
arnoux
plaintiff
error
congress
exclusive
right
legislate
federal
courts
exclusive
power
adjudicate
ames
bailey
pet
cornell
mason
osborn
bank
wheat
state
legislate
courts
adjudicate
lathrop
johns
martin
hunter
lessee
wheat
rose
hinely
cranch
mclean
lafayette
bank
mclean
stearns
paine
shearman
bingham
jurisdiction
courts
exclusive
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
const
art
sects
story
sect
martin
hunter
lessee
supra
ex
parte
cabrera
griffin
domingues
duer
mannhardt
joderstron
binn
commonwealth
kostaff
serg
davis
packard
pet
houston
moore
wheat
bankrupt
act
march
construction
terms
confers
exclusive
jurisdiction
upon
district
circuit
courts
goodall
tuttle
alexander
id
shearman
bingham
id
ex
parte
christy
mitchell
great
milling
works
story
peck
jenness
mclean
lafayette
bank
mclean
moore
jones
right
assignee
bring
suits
collection
assets
bankrupt
new
right
conferred
upon
act
congress
cook
whipple
therefore
remedy
afforded
statute
exclusive
dudley
mayhew
jordan
plank
road
morley
id
thurber
blanck
id
hollister
hollister
bank
keyes
almy
harris
johns
rex
robinson
burr
fact
assignee
bankruptcy
dependent
upon
national
tribunals
independent
conclusive
jurisdiction
latter
statutory
actions
brought
officer
appointed
laws
state
courts
neither
interfere
interrupt
exercise
authority
clothed
aid
enforcing
mckim
voorhies
cranch
slocum
mayberry
wheat
mcclung
silliman
id
barney
hall
peters
cranch
mcnutt
bland
hopkins
stockton
watts
distinct
independent
autonomies
sovereign
capacity
laws
foreign
except
surrendered
powers
ohio
debolt
buckner
finley
pet
bank
augusta
earle
id
therefore
state
courts
jurisdiction
action
brought
person
acting
representative
capacity
barb
parsons
lyman
williams
storrs
johns
ch
doolittle
lewis
id
vroom
van
horn
paige
morrell
dickey
johns
ch
brown
brown
barb
ch
petersen
chemical
bank
matter
estate
butler
id
mosselman
caen
barb
abraham
plestero
wend
willetts
waite
harrison
sterry
cranch
johnson
hunt
wend
hoyt
thompson
peale
phipps
orr
amory
mass
booth
clark
submitted
printed
arguments
lee
defendant
error
justice
bradley
delivered
opinion
point
principally
relied
plaintiff
error
assignee
bankruptcy
sue
state
courts
argued
cause
action
arises
purely
solely
provisions
act
congress
prosecuted
courts
state
courts
jurisdiction
subject
recently
settled
several
district
circuit
courts
jurisdiction
bankrupt
law
causes
arising
proceedings
bankruptcy
pending
districts
much
doubt
subject
finally
settled
last
term
favor
jurisdiction
lathrop
assignee
drake
et
decision
otherwise
long
period
generally
supposed
law
assignees
bankruptcy
position
plaintiff
error
correct
utterly
without
remedy
collect
assets
bankrupt
districts
bankruptcy
proceedings
pending
neither
state
courts
federal
courts
entertained
jurisdiction
revised
statutes
whether
inadvertently
made
jurisdiction
courts
exclusive
matters
proceedings
bankruptcy
sect
whether
regulation
affect
cognizance
plenary
actions
suits
necessary
determine
events
question
cognizance
must
met
case
important
principles
involved
require
much
deliberate
consideration
already
effect
decided
opinion
lathrop
assignee
drake
et
taken
granted
stated
state
courts
jurisdiction
question
directly
involved
case
fully
considered
eyster
gaff
et
decided
state
deprived
jurisdiction
case
bankruptcy
defendant
may
proceed
judgment
without
noticing
bankruptcy
proceedings
assignee
cause
appearance
entered
proceed
appear
thing
constitution
incapacitate
state
courts
taking
cognizance
causes
bankruptcy
parties
constitutional
argument
plaintiff
error
supposes
proceedings
bankruptcy
ipso
facto
determine
subject
eyster
gaff
et
say
mistake
suppose
bankrupt
law
avoids
force
judicial
proceedings
state
courts
instant
one
parties
adjudged
bankrupt
nothing
act
sanctions
proposition
debtor
bankrupt
man
contests
right
real
personal
property
loses
none
rights
bankruptcy
adversary
courts
remain
open
contests
statute
divested
courts
jurisdiction
actions
certain
classes
actions
conferred
jurisdiction
benefit
assignee
circuit
district
courts
concurrent
divest
state
courts
pp
conclusion
reached
courts
federal
state
hold
state
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
courts
actions
suits
bankrupt
assignee
party
see
samson
burton
bank
reg
payson
dietz
id
gilbert
priest
id
stevens
mechanics
savings
bank
mass
cook
whipple
brown
hall
bush
mays
man
nat
bank
penn
contrary
cases
true
brigham
claflin
voorhees
frisbie
others
think
former
cases
founded
better
reason
assignee
fourteenth
section
bankrupt
act
rev
stat
sect
becomes
invested
bankrupt
rights
action
property
actions
arising
contract
unlawful
taking
detention
injury
property
right
sue
actions
lie
cases
actions
ejectment
trespass
trover
assumpsit
debt
suits
equity
actions
suits
state
courts
cognizance
assignee
power
bring
courts
well
persons
aliens
foreign
corporations
may
bring
assignee
simply
derives
title
law
title
respected
state
courts
case
exactly
bank
first
bank
chartered
capacity
given
sue
sued
courts
record
place
whatsoever
held
bank
deveaux
cranch
authorize
bank
sue
courts
without
showing
proper
citizenship
parties
different
bank
obliged
sue
state
courts
yet
right
arising
law
much
affirmed
case
assignee
bankruptcy
second
bank
express
capacity
sue
sued
state
courts
competent
jurisdiction
circuit
case
osborn
bank
wheat
objected
congress
authority
enable
bank
sue
federal
courts
merely
created
act
congress
held
otherwise
sustained
right
sue
therein
question
made
right
sue
state
courts
bankrupt
law
substantially
provisions
subject
present
law
held
assignee
sue
state
courts
ex
parte
christie
nugent
boyd
id
wood
jenkins
met
analogous
cases
occurred
result
reached
general
principle
jurisdiction
may
conferred
courts
may
made
exclusive
constitution
exclusive
jurisdiction
neither
express
implied
state
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
whenever
constitution
competent
take
thus
may
sue
state
courts
often
may
done
surely
principle
greater
includes
less
officer
corporation
created
authority
may
enabled
sue
courts
nothing
constitution
fairly
considered
forbids
general
question
whether
state
courts
exercise
concurrent
jurisdiction
federal
courts
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
elaborately
discussed
bench
published
treatises
sometimes
leaning
one
direction
sometimes
result
discussions
judgment
seen
cases
affirm
jurisdiction
excluded
express
provision
incompatibility
exercise
arising
nature
particular
case
consider
structure
true
relations
federal
state
governments
really
foundation
excluding
state
courts
jurisdiction
laws
laws
several
much
binding
citizens
courts
thereof
state
laws
foreign
sovereignty
regards
several
concurrent
within
jurisdiction
paramount
sovereignty
every
citizen
state
subject
two
distinct
sovereignties
concurrent
jurisdiction
state
place
persons
though
distinct
legal
equitable
rights
acquired
either
system
laws
may
enforced
either
sovereignty
competent
hear
determine
kind
rights
restrained
constitution
exercise
jurisdiction
thus
legal
equitable
right
acquired
state
laws
may
prosecuted
state
courts
also
parties
reside
different
federal
courts
rights
whether
legal
equitable
acquired
laws
may
prosecuted
courts
state
courts
competent
decide
rights
like
character
class
subject
however
qualification
right
arises
law
congress
may
see
fit
give
federal
courts
exclusive
jurisdiction
see
remarks
justice
field
moses
taylor
wall
story
martin
hunter
lessee
wheat
justice
swayne
ex
parte
mcneil
wall
jurisdiction
sometimes
exclusive
express
enactment
sometimes
implication
act
congress
gives
penalty
party
aggrieved
without
specifying
remedy
enforcement
reason
enforced
provided
otherwise
act
congress
proper
action
state
fact
state
derives
existence
functions
state
laws
reason
afford
relief
subject
also
laws
much
bound
recognize
operative
within
state
recognize
state
laws
two
together
form
one
system
jurisprudence
constitute
law
land
state
courts
two
jurisdictions
foreign
treated
courts
country
jurisdiction
partly
different
partly
concurrent
disposition
regard
laws
emanating
foreign
jurisdiction
founded
erroneous
views
nature
relations
state
federal
governments
often
cause
consequence
unjustifiable
jealousy
government
occasion
disastrous
evils
country
true
sovereignties
distinct
neither
interfere
proper
jurisdiction
clearly
shown
chief
justice
taney
case
ableman
booth
hence
state
courts
power
revise
action
federal
courts
federal
state
except
federal
constitution
laws
involved
reason
state
courts
open
prosecution
rights
growing
laws
jurisdiction
competent
denied
reference
discussions
subject
consideration
given
rise
may
place
occasion
fully
examined
number
federalist
alexander
hamilton
usual
analytical
power
genius
hardly
argument
suggestion
made
since
anticipate
showing
exclusive
delegation
authority
federal
government
arise
one
three
ways
either
express
grant
exclusive
authority
particular
subject
simple
grant
authority
subsequent
prohibition
thereof
lastly
authority
granted
union
utterly
incompatible
similar
authority
says
principles
may
also
apply
judiciary
well
legislative
power
hence
infers
state
courts
retain
jurisdiction
unless
taken
away
one
enumerated
modes
previous
jurisdiction
possibility
extend
cases
might
grow
peculiar
new
constitution
considered
cases
congress
might
give
federal
courts
sole
jurisdiction
hold
says
state
courts
divested
part
primitive
jurisdiction
may
relate
appeal
even
opinion
every
case
expressly
excluded
future
acts
national
legislature
course
take
cognizance
causes
acts
may
give
birth
infer
nature
judiciary
power
general
genius
system
judiciary
power
every
government
looks
beyond
local
municipal
laws
civil
cases
lays
hold
subjects
litigation
parties
within
jurisdiction
though
causes
dispute
relative
laws
distant
part
globe
addition
consider
state
governments
national
government
truly
light
kindred
systems
parts
one
whole
inference
seems
conclusive
state
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
cases
arising
laws
union
expressly
prohibited
views
seem
shared
first
congress
drawing
judiciary
act
distributing
jurisdiction
among
various
courts
created
act
constant
exercise
authority
include
exclude
state
courts
therefrom
direction
given
subject
assumed
early
judicial
history
state
courts
retained
usual
jurisdiction
concurrently
federal
courts
invested
jurisdiction
like
cases
thus
judiciary
act
exclusive
cognizance
given
circuit
district
courts
crimes
offences
cognizable
authority
district
courts
civil
causes
admiralty
maritime
jurisdiction
seizures
water
laws
impost
navigation
trade
seizures
land
penalties
forfeitures
incurred
said
laws
concurrent
jurisdiction
state
courts
given
district
circuit
courts
causes
alien
sues
tort
violation
law
nations
treaty
writs
common
law
plaintiffs
circuit
courts
suit
citizen
state
suit
brought
citizen
another
state
alien
party
distinction
made
branches
jurisdiction
respect
constitution
uses
expression
cases
respect
term
omitted
supposed
wherever
constitution
declares
judicial
power
shall
extend
cases
cases
law
equity
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
cases
affecting
ambassadors
jurisdiction
federal
courts
necessarily
exclusive
power
simply
extended
controversies
certain
class
party
jurisdiction
federal
courts
necessarily
exclusive
distinction
seems
recognized
congress
already
seen
judiciary
act
subsequent
acts
show
thing
thus
first
patent
law
securing
inventors
discoveries
inventions
passed
gave
treble
damages
infringement
recovered
action
case
founded
statute
circuit
competent
jurisdiction
course
state
courts
subsequent
acts
subject
couched
terms
regard
jurisdiction
circuit
courts
imply
exclusive
state
courts
expressly
made
see
patent
acts
rev
stat
sect
parsons
barnard
johns
dudley
mayhew
comst
elmer
pennel
regard
naturalization
subject
necessarily
within
exclusive
regulation
congress
first
act
subject
passed
subsequent
acts
give
plenary
jurisdiction
state
courts
language
act
record
one
stat
act
designates
superior
district
circuit
one
territorial
districts
circuit
district
stat
acts
passed
jurisdiction
given
county
courts
along
northern
frontier
suits
fines
penalties
forfeitures
revenue
laws
stat
act
march
cognizance
given
state
county
courts
generally
suits
taxes
duties
fines
penalties
forfeitures
arising
laws
imposing
direct
taxes
internal
duties
stat
instances
show
prevalent
opinion
existed
state
courts
competent
jurisdiction
cases
arising
wholly
laws
whether
possessed
particular
case
matter
construction
acts
relating
thereto
true
state
courts
certain
instances
declined
exercise
jurisdiction
conferred
upon
militate
weight
general
argument
see
lathrop
johns
see
especially
able
dissenting
opinion
justice
platt
id
indeed
intimated
justice
story
obiter
dictum
delivering
opinion
martin
hunter
lessee
wheat
state
courts
take
direct
cognizance
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
jurisdiction
existed
constitution
adopted
true
jurisdiction
depending
authority
jurisdiction
existed
least
certain
extent
authority
inventors
grants
exclusive
right
inventions
constitution
adopted
state
courts
jurisdiction
thereof
change
authority
creating
right
change
nature
right
assertion
therefore
jurisdiction
previously
existed
must
taken
important
limitations
much
influence
proper
case
arose
adjudication
houston
moore
decided
wheat
case
congress
passed
act
organizing
calling
forth
militia
prescribed
punishment
inflicted
delinquents
making
liable
pay
certain
fine
determined
adjudged
without
specifying
legislature
pennsylvania
also
passed
militia
law
providing
organization
training
calling
militia
establishing
trial
delinquents
law
many
respects
exactly
corresponded
far
covered
ground
reason
held
inoperative
void
houston
delinquent
law
tried
state
decided
jurisdiction
offence
constituted
fact
enforce
laws
state
legislature
reenacted
decision
delivered
justice
washington
based
upon
general
principle
state
jurisdiction
offence
irrespective
authority
state
federal
created
congress
confer
jurisdiction
upon
state
courts
courts
might
exercise
jurisdiction
cases
authorized
laws
state
prohibited
exclusive
jurisdiction
federal
courts
justices
story
johnson
dissented
perhaps
went
case
act
congress
instituted
well
provided
complete
code
organization
calling
forth
militia
entire
law
pennsylvania
subject
might
well
regarded
void
may
question
construction
conceded
congress
power
make
jurisdiction
courts
exclusive
cohens
virginia
wheat
chief
justice
marshall
demonstrates
necessity
appellate
power
federal
judiciary
revise
decisions
state
courts
cases
arising
constitution
laws
order
constitutional
grant
judicial
power
extending
cases
may
full
effect
says
propriety
intrusting
construction
constitution
laws
made
pursuance
thereof
judiciary
union
believe
yet
drawn
question
seems
corollary
political
axiom
federal
courts
either
possess
exclusive
jurisdiction
cases
power
revise
judgment
rendered
state
tribunals
federal
state
courts
concurrent
jurisdiction
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
case
description
brought
state
removed
judgment
revised
judgment
construction
constitution
laws
treaties
confided
particularly
judicial
department
confided
equally
department
state
courts
however
may
constituted
see
subject
discussed
kent
com
sergeant
const
story
sect
curtis
sects
case
teal
felton
suit
brought
state
new
york
postmaster
neglect
duty
deliver
newspaper
postal
laws
action
sustained
appeals
new
york
decision
affirmed
comst
see
case
decisive
question
consideration
without
discussing
subject
sufficient
say
hold
assignee
bankruptcy
bankrupt
act
stood
revision
authority
bring
suit
state
courts
wherever
courts
invested
appropriate
jurisdiction
suited
nature
case
judgment
affirmed