great
lakes
dredge
dock
huffman
argued
decided
may
emmett
kerrigan
new
orleans
petitioners
perrault
baton
rouge
respondents
chief
justice
stone
delivered
opinion
petitioners
brought
suit
district
respondent
state
officer
charged
administration
enforcement
louisiana
unemployment
compensation
law
act
amended
act
act
first
extraordinary
session
acts
complaint
alleges
petitioners
numerous
classes
employees
engaged
navigation
operation
dredges
pile
drivers
operation
quarter
boats
tugs
launches
barges
vessels
used
deepening
dredging
extending
otherwise
improving
channels
underlying
navigable
waters
state
tax
contribution
state
unemployment
insurance
fund
state
law
exact
petitioners
exceeded
suit
brought
sum
relief
prayed
declaratory
judgment
state
law
applied
petitioners
employees
unconstitutional
void
trial
district
held
statute
applicable
petitioners
employees
applied
valid
exercise
state
power
formal
judgment
ordered
dismissal
suit
interpreted
light
opinion
findings
conclusions
law
metropolitan
water
kaw
valley
drainage
gulf
refining
clark
williard
american
propeller
mfg
interpreted
rests
wholly
declaration
statute
applied
petitioners
constitutional
thus
effect
declaratory
judgment
appeals
fifth
circuit
affirmed
holding
statute
exacting
employers
contributions
state
unemployment
compensation
fund
valid
exercise
state
taxing
power
see
steward
mach
davis
carmichael
southern
coal
coke
application
act
petitioners
interfere
characteristic
feature
general
maritime
law
interstate
international
aspects
fall
ban
southern
pac
jensen
ann
cases
following
federal
social
security
act
exempting
operation
officers
crews
vessels
field
otherwise
precluded
state
applying
law
respect
employees
question
public
importance
questions
decided
granted
certiorari
set
case
argument
standard
dredging
corporation
murphy
international
elevating
murphy
appeal
order
granting
writ
requested
counsel
discuss
briefs
oral
argument
question
whether
declaratory
judgment
procedure
appropriately
used
case
complaint
seeks
judgment
state
officer
prevent
enforcement
state
statute
state
act
held
exacts
employers
payments
state
unemployment
insurance
fund
nature
excise
tax
upon
exercise
right
privilege
employing
individuals
measured
percentage
wages
paid
see
carmichael
southern
coal
coke
supra
petitioners
challenged
state
right
collect
tax
interposed
barrier
collection
present
suit
federal
declaratory
judgment
district
indicated
substance
given
declaratory
judgment
circuit
appeals
sustained
save
purpose
courts
occasion
entertain
suit
pronounce
judgment
neither
parties
questioned
sufficiency
pleadings
present
case
declaratory
judgment
without
raising
issue
pass
question
submitted
counsel
whether
declaratory
judgment
procedure
may
appropriately
resorted
circumstances
case
answering
nature
remedy
afforded
taxpayers
state
law
illegal
exaction
tax
importance
section
article
constitution
louisiana
directs
legislature
shall
provide
issuance
process
restrain
collection
tax
complete
adequate
remedy
prompt
recovery
every
taxpayer
illegal
tax
paid
act
sets
complete
statutory
scheme
carry
effect
constitutional
provision
courts
state
forbidden
restrain
collection
state
tax
person
aggrieved
payment
amount
found
due
enforcement
provision
laws
relation
thereto
shall
pay
tax
appropriate
state
officer
file
suit
recovery
either
state
federal
courts
pending
suit
amount
collected
required
segregated
held
subject
judgment
rendered
suit
taxpayer
prevails
suit
interest
two
per
cent
per
annum
added
amount
taxes
refunded
recognized
federal
courts
exercise
sound
discretion
traditionally
guided
courts
equity
granting
withholding
extraordinary
relief
may
afford
ordinarily
restrain
state
officers
collecting
state
taxes
state
law
affords
adequate
remedy
taxpayer
matthews
rodgers
withholding
extraordinary
relief
courts
authority
give
denial
jurisdiction
congress
conferred
federal
courts
settled
rule
measure
inadequacy
plaintiff
legal
remedy
legal
remedy
afforded
federal
state
courts
stratton
louis
di
giovanni
camden
fire
ins
contrary
recognition
jurisdiction
conferred
federal
courts
embraces
suits
equity
well
law
federal
equity
may
appropriate
case
refuse
give
special
protection
private
rights
exercise
jurisdiction
prejudicial
public
interest
dern
virginian
ry
system
federation
stay
hand
public
interest
reasonably
appears
private
interests
suffer
see
commonwealth
pennsylvania
williams
cases
cited
public
interest
federal
courts
equity
exercise
discretionary
power
grant
withhold
relief
avoid
needless
obstruction
domestic
policy
scrupulous
regard
rightful
independence
state
governments
times
actuate
federal
courts
proper
reluctance
interfere
injunction
fiscal
operations
require
relief
denied
every
case
asserted
federal
right
may
preserved
without
whenever
question
presented
uniformly
held
mere
illegality
unconstitutionality
state
municipal
tax
ground
equitable
relief
courts
remedy
law
plain
adequate
complete
aggrieved
party
left
remedy
state
courts
cause
may
brought
review
federal
question
involved
matthews
rodgers
supra
pages
pages
interference
state
internal
economy
administration
inseparable
assaults
federal
courts
validity
state
taxation
necessarily
attends
injunctions
interlocutory
final
restraining
collection
state
taxes
considerations
moment
persuaded
federal
courts
equity
deny
relief
state
acting
within
constitutional
authority
set
adequate
procedure
securing
taxpayer
recovery
illegally
exacted
tax
congress
recognized
gave
sanction
practice
federal
equity
courts
act
august
stat
enacted
amendment
section
judicial
code
provides
district
shall
jurisdiction
suit
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
tax
imposed
pursuant
laws
state
plain
speedy
efficient
remedy
may
law
equity
courts
state
earlier
refusal
federal
courts
equity
interfere
collection
state
taxes
unless
threatened
injury
taxpayer
one
state
courts
afford
adequate
remedy
confirmation
practice
congress
important
bearing
upon
appropriate
use
declaratory
judgment
procedure
federal
courts
means
adjudicating
validity
state
taxes
true
act
congress
speaks
suits
enjoin
suspend
restrain
assessment
levy
collection
tax
imposed
state
law
declaratory
judgment
procedure
may
case
used
procure
determination
rights
parties
without
injunction
coercive
relief
also
true
procedure
may
every
practical
sense
operate
suspend
collection
state
taxes
litigation
ended
find
unnecessary
inquire
whether
words
statute
may
construed
prohibit
declaration
federal
courts
concerning
invalidity
state
tax
opinion
considerations
led
federal
courts
equity
refuse
enjoin
collection
state
taxes
save
exceptional
cases
require
like
restraint
use
declaratory
judgment
procedure
statutory
authority
render
declaratory
judgments
permits
federal
courts
new
form
procedure
exercise
jurisdiction
decide
cases
controversies
law
equity
judiciary
acts
already
conferred
aetna
life
ins
haworth
thus
federal
declaratory
judgments
act
act
june
stat
amended
provides
subdivision
declaration
rights
may
awarded
although
relief
asked
subdivision
relief
based
declaratory
judgment
decree
may
granted
whenever
necessary
proper
jurisdiction
district
present
suit
praying
adjudication
rights
anticipation
threatened
infringement
analogous
equity
jurisdiction
suits
quia
timet
decree
quieting
title
see
nashville
ry
wallace
called
upon
adjudicate
essentially
equitable
cause
action
district
free
suit
equity
grant
withhold
relief
prayed
upon
equitable
grounds
declaratory
judgments
act
devised
deprive
courts
equity
powers
freedom
withhold
relief
upon
established
equitable
principles
provided
new
form
procedure
adjudication
rights
conformity
principles
senate
committee
report
bill
pointed
exercise
equity
power
make
rules
governing
declaratory
judgment
procedure
house
report
declared
discretion
conferred
upon
courts
whether
administer
justice
procedure
see
brillhart
excess
ins
borchard
declaratory
judgments
ed
considerations
persuaded
federal
courts
equity
grant
relief
allegedly
unlawful
state
tax
led
enactment
act
august
persuasive
relief
way
declaratory
judgment
may
likewise
withheld
sound
discretion
due
regard
considerations
duty
withhold
relief
present
case
appears
state
legislature
provided
payment
challenged
tax
appropriate
state
officer
taxpayer
may
maintain
suit
recover
back
suit
may
assert
federal
rights
secure
review
affords
adequate
remedy
taxpayer
time
leaves
undisturbed
state
administration
taxes
act
august
predicated
upon
desirability
freeing
interference
federal
courts
state
procedures
authorize
litigation
challenging
tax
tax
paid
see
sess
sess
even
though
statutory
command
deemed
restricted
prohibition
injunctions
restraining
collection
state
taxes
enactment
hardly
indication
disapproval
policy
federal
equity
courts
mandatory
withdrawal
traditional
power
decline
jurisdiction
exercise
discretion
like
reasons
think
plain
also
enactment
act
august
stat
excluded
operation
declaratory
judgments
act
cases
involving
federal
taxes
taken
deprive
courts
discretionary
authority
withhold
declaratory
relief
appropriate
cases
amendment
passed
merely
purpose
clear
declaratory
judgments
act
permit
radical
departure
policy
congress
require
prompt
payment
federal
taxes
see
sess
judgment
dismissal
must
therefore
affirmed
solely
ground
appropriate
exercise
discretion
relief
way
atory
judgment
denied
without
consideration
merits
affirmed