nordic
village
argued
december
decided
february
respondent
nordic
village
filed
petition
relief
chapter
bankruptcy
code
one
officers
withdrew
funds
company
corporate
account
sent
part
money
internal
revenue
service
irs
directing
apply
funds
individual
tax
liability
subsequent
adversary
proceeding
bankruptcy
permitted
nordic
village
trustee
recover
transfer
entered
monetary
judgment
irs
district
affirmed
appeals
rejected
jurisdictional
defense
sovereign
immunity
barred
judgment
held
section
code
waive
sovereign
immunity
action
seeking
monetary
recovery
bankruptcy
pp
hoffman
connecticut
dept
income
maintenance
control
case
since
plurality
dissent
therein
evenly
divided
issue
whether
authorizes
monetary
recovery
state
since
deciding
vote
concurrence
denying
amenability
suit
rested
upon
eleventh
amendment
applicable
however
plurality
reasoning
relevant
relied
pp
section
unequivocally
express
waiver
government
immunity
actions
monetary
relief
necessary
waiver
effective
see
irwin
department
veterans
affairs
contrast
plainly
waive
immunity
regard
monetary
relief
specified
claims
susceptible
least
two
plausible
interpretations
authorize
monetary
relief
legislative
history
bearing
point
unequivocal
expression
waiver
must
expression
statutory
text
hoffman
supra
pp
respondent
several
alternative
grounds
affirming
judgment
broad
jurisdictional
grant
provides
necessary
waiver
bankruptcy
rem
jurisdiction
overrides
sovereign
immunity
waiver
sovereign
immunity
supported
trust
law
principles
unpersuasive
pp
scalia
delivered
opinion
rehnquist
white
kennedy
souter
thomas
joined
stevens
filed
dissenting
opinion
blackmun
joined
richard
seamon
argued
cause
briefs
solicitor
general
starr
assistant
attorney
general
peterson
deputy
solicitor
general
roberts
gary
gray
john
dudeck
marvin
sicherman
argued
cause
filed
brief
respondent
brief
michael
zaverton
justice
scalia
delivered
opinion
respondent
nordic
village
filed
petition
relief
chapter
bankruptcy
code
march
four
months
later
josef
lah
officer
shareholder
nordic
village
drew
check
company
corporate
account
used
obtain
cashier
check
amount
payable
internal
revenue
service
irs
lah
delivered
check
irs
directed
apply
funds
individual
tax
liability
december
trustee
appointed
nordic
village
commenced
adversary
proceeding
bankruptcy
northern
district
ohio
seeking
recover
among
transfers
paid
lah
irs
bankruptcy
permitted
recovery
unauthorized
postpetition
transfer
determined
avoided
recovered
irs
bankruptcy
code
entered
judgment
irs
amount
district
affirmed
divided
panel
appeals
sixth
circuit
affirmed
upheld
reasoning
lower
courts
rejected
jurisdictional
defense
raised
first
time
appeal
sovereign
immunity
barred
judgment
entered
government
granted
certiorari
ii
section
bankruptcy
code
provides
governmental
unit
deemed
waived
sovereign
immunity
respect
claim
governmental
unit
property
estate
arose
transaction
occurrence
governmental
unit
claim
arose
shall
offset
allowed
claim
interest
governmental
unit
claim
governmental
unit
property
estate
except
provided
subsections
section
notwithstanding
assertion
sovereign
immunity
provision
title
contains
creditor
entity
governmental
unit
applies
governmental
units
determination
issue
arising
provision
binds
governmental
units
contrary
government
suggestion
hoffman
control
today
decision
true
sure
congress
made
clear
insofar
within
congress
power
state
federal
sovereigns
treated
immunity
purposes
see
supp
ii
governmental
unit
means
state
since
however
hoffman
evenly
divided
treatment
since
deciding
vote
concurrence
denying
amenability
suit
rested
upon
ground
eleventh
amendment
applicable
federal
government
see
fha
burr
holding
hoffman
binding
force
separate
opinions
dealing
statutory
question
relevant
however
shall
fact
rely
reasoning
plurality
iii
waivers
government
sovereign
immunity
effective
must
unequivocally
expressed
irwin
department
veterans
affairs
quoting
mitchell
king
contrary
respondent
suggestion
moreover
generally
liberally
construed
occasion
narrowly
construed
exceptions
waivers
sovereign
immunity
consistent
congress
clear
intent
context
sweeping
language
federal
tort
claims
act
yellow
cab
see
block
neal
aetna
casualty
surety
context
equally
broad
sue
sued
clauses
see
franchise
tax
board
california
postal
service
fha
burr
supra
cases
however
eradicate
traditional
principle
government
consent
sued
must
construed
strictly
favor
sovereign
mcmahon
enlarge
beyond
language
requires
ruckelshaus
sierra
club
quoting
eastern
transp
rule
construction
occasion
reaffirm
already
term
see
ardestani
ins
subsections
meet
unequivocal
expression
requirement
respect
monetary
liability
addressing
claim
code
defines
right
payment
plainly
waive
sovereign
immunity
regard
monetary
relief
two
settings
compulsory
counterclaims
governmental
claims
permissive
counterclaims
governmental
claims
capped
setoff
limitation
next
models
clarity
stands
subsection
though
waives
sovereign
immunity
fails
establish
unambiguously
waiver
extends
monetary
claims
susceptible
least
two
interpretations
authorize
monetary
relief
one
interpretation
permits
bankruptcy
issue
declaratory
injunctive
though
monetary
relief
government
hoffman
conclusion
reached
reading
two
paragraphs
subsection
complementary
rather
independent
first
paragraph
identifies
subject
matter
disputes
courts
may
entertain
subsection
second
paragraph
describes
relief
courts
may
grant
disputes
say
second
paragraph
specifies
manner
shall
applied
governmental
units
provisions
identified
first
paragraph
manner
permits
declaratory
injunctive
relief
affirmative
monetary
recovery
several
factors
favor
construction
distinction
establishes
suits
monetary
claims
suits
relief
familiar
one
suggested
contrasting
language
used
subsections
claim
subsection
determination
issue
hoffman
also
avoids
eclipsing
carefully
drawn
limitations
placed
waivers
subsections
principal
provision
code
permitting
assertion
claims
persons
estate
provides
entity
owes
debt
property
estate
matured
payable
demand
payable
order
shall
pay
debt
order
trustee
first
paragraph
means
reason
use
entity
provision
applies
respects
governmental
units
government
may
sued
alleged
debts
despite
prior
specification
subsections
claims
government
lie
government
filed
proof
claim
even
setoff
unless
claim
compulsory
counterclaim
earlier
limitations
reduced
trivial
application
paragraph
stands
see
construction
also
attaches
practical
consequences
paragraph
whereas
respondent
interpretation
violates
settled
rule
statute
must
possible
construed
fashion
every
word
operative
effect
see
menasche
respondent
suggested
function
performed
paragraph
paragraph
operates
treat
government
like
entity
creditor
regardless
type
relief
authorized
applicable
code
provision
interpretation
though
authorizing
claims
monetary
relief
nevertheless
perform
significant
function
permit
bankruptcy
determine
amount
dischargeability
estate
liability
government
unpaid
federal
taxes
see
permitting
determine
amount
legality
tax
emphasis
added
whether
government
filed
proof
claim
see
cf
neavear
schweiker
holding
bankruptcy
discharge
debt
owed
social
security
administration
government
repeatedly
objected
grounds
sovereign
immunity
bound
determinations
enacted
see
mckenzie
bostwick
gwilliam
durensky
nd
tex
appeal
dism
subsection
also
susceptible
another
construction
permit
recovery
two
paragraphs
read
independent
rather
second
limiting
first
pursuant
first
paragraph
code
provisions
using
triggering
words
enumerated
paragraph
apply
fully
governmental
units
application
provisions
limited
requirements
subsections
accordance
phrase
introduces
subsection
except
provided
subsections
section
exception
words
read
mean
rules
established
subsections
waiver
government
claim
property
estate
exclusive
preclude
resort
subsection
purpose
reading
bar
present
suit
since
right
recover
postpetition
transfer
clearly
claim
defined
property
estate
defined
dissent
appears
read
paragraphs
independent
provides
explanation
textual
exception
mean
reading
foregoing
assuredly
readings
subsection
plausible
ones
enough
establish
reading
imposing
monetary
liability
government
unambiguous
therefore
adopted
contrary
respondent
suggestion
legislative
history
bearing
ambiguity
point
eleventh
amendment
context
see
hoffman
unequivocal
expression
elimination
sovereign
immunity
insist
upon
expression
statutory
text
clarity
exist
supplied
committee
report
cf
dellmuth
muth
iv
respondent
proposes
several
alternative
grounds
affirming
judgment
unpersuasive
first
claims
necessary
waiver
found
grants
district
bankruptcy
case
initiated
exclusive
jurisdiction
property
wherever
located
debtor
commencement
case
property
estate
respondent
urges
us
construe
language
empowering
bankruptcy
compel
state
return
property
including
money
passes
estate
upon
commencement
bankruptcy
proceeding
theory
sovereign
exposure
suit
governed
specific
language
concealed
broad
jurisdictional
grant
besides
unprecedented
running
afoul
requirement
theory
closely
resembles
argument
rejected
last
term
blatchford
native
village
noatak
argument
made
alaska
eleventh
amendment
immunity
suit
abrogated
jurisdictional
grant
akin
gives
district
courts
jurisdiction
civil
actions
brought
indian
tribe
aris
ing
constitution
laws
treaties
rejecting
contention
observed
fact
congress
grants
jurisdiction
hear
claim
suffice
show
congress
abrogated
defenses
claim
issues
wholly
equally
unpersuasive
respondent
related
argument
bankruptcy
rem
jurisdiction
overrides
sovereign
immunity
initial
matter
premise
argument
missing
since
respondent
invoke
bankruptcy
purport
exercise
rem
jurisdiction
respondent
sought
recover
sum
money
particular
dollars
cf
begier
irs
emphasis
deleted
res
rem
jurisdiction
attached
see
pennsylvania
turnpike
mcginnes
cert
denied
event
never
applied
rem
exception
sovereign
immunity
bar
monetary
recovery
suggested
exception
exists
see
shaw
whiting
pools
establish
exception
otherwise
permit
relief
requested
case
upheld
bankruptcy
order
irs
turn
tangible
property
debtor
seized
debtor
filed
bankruptcy
protection
suit
payment
funds
treasury
quite
different
suit
return
tangible
property
debtor
retained
ownership
opinion
whiting
pools
contains
discussion
nothing
suggests
order
granting
monetary
recovery
proper
resort
principles
trust
law
also
help
respondent
trust
decisions
respondent
cites
irrelevant
since
involve
private
entities
government
one
involve
government
bull
concerns
equitable
recoupment
doctrine
substantially
narrowed
later
cases
see
dalm
application
ordered
justice
stevens
justice
blackmun
joins
dissenting
officer
insolvent
corporation
appropriated
corporate
funds
used
discharge
personal
tax
obligation
federal
government
ultimate
recipient
stolen
property
holds
bankruptcy
trustee
avoid
transfer
interest
rigid
interpretation
doctrine
sovereign
immunity
outweighs
interest
equitable
treatment
general
creditors
shareholders
corporate
debtor
result
neither
necessary
necessary
text
legislative
history
bankruptcy
code
support
contrary
result
nothing
misguided
interest
adherence
obsolete
rules
stake
shall
comment
first
laws
enacted
congress
rules
ordained
text
straightforward
case
involve
either
counterclaim
offset
subsections
applicable
subsection
provides
except
provided
subsections
section
notwithstanding
assertion
sovereign
immunity
provision
title
contains
creditor
entity
governmental
unit
applies
governmental
units
determination
issue
arising
provision
binds
governmental
units
legislative
history
unambiguously
demonstrates
congress
intended
statute
read
literally
immediate
purpose
enable
bankruptcy
determine
amount
dischargeability
debtor
tax
liabilities
sponsors
amendment
clearly
stated
covered
matters
well
specifically
including
avoidance
preferential
transfers
statement
edwards
statement
deconcini
congressional
purpose
waive
sovereign
immunity
pellucidly
clear
evades
conclusion
hypothesizing
plausible
alternative
constructions
statute
refusing
consider
legislative
history
reiterating
view
waivers
sovereign
immunity
must
strictly
construed
shall
comment
plausible
alternatives
except
note
obviously
less
satisfactory
matter
sound
bankruptcy
policy
principled
interpretation
english
language
literal
reading
statute
shall
however
add
words
love
affair
doctrine
sovereign
immunity
ii
despite
ancient
lineage
doctrine
sovereign
immunity
nothing
rule
sometimes
favored
sometimes
disfavored
original
reliance
notion
divinely
ordained
monarch
wrong
course
thoroughly
discredited
moreover
persistent
threat
impartial
administration
justice
repeatedly
acknowledged
recognized
thus
fha
burr
remarked
current
disfavor
doctrine
governmental
immunity
suit
time
time
congress
taken
action
ameliorate
hardship
doctrine
half
century
ago
observed
sense
justice
brought
progressive
relaxation
legislative
enactments
rigor
immunity
rule
representative
governments
attempt
ameliorate
inequalities
necessities
permit
prerogatives
government
yield
needs
citizen
authority
given
liberally
construed
shaw
commission
also
recommends
unpaid
taxes
entitled
priority
reduced
accruing
within
three
years
prior
bankruptcy
accruing
within
one
year
prior
bankruptcy
government
given
priority
taxes
bankruptcy
proceeding
including
secured
tax
lien
data
submitted
commission
treasury
department
establishes
total
amount
collected
federal
government
result
liens
priorities
bankruptcy
proceedings
insignificant
total
federal
budget
view
commission
unseemly
federal
government
insist
upon
collecting
taxes
expense
creditors
taxpayer
possible
justification
plea
necessity
order
keep
government
functioning
indicated
plea
totally
without
foundation
fact
federal
government
enters
business
transactions
prepared
deal
upon
basis
equality
creditors
bankrupt
business
report
commission
bankruptcy
laws
pt
surely
interest
requiring
congress
draft
legislation
greater
clarity
precision
justify
refusal
make
good
faith
effort
ascertain
actual
meaning
message
tried
convey
statutory
provision
already
books
stubborn
insistence
clear
statements
burdens
congress
unnecessary
reenactment
provisions
already
plain
enough
read
literally
cost
litigants
legislature
public
large
sort
judicial
lawmaking
substantial
unfortunate
impact
individual
citizens
engaged
litigation
sovereign
tragic
fact
congress
ample
power
correct
unfortunate
error
justify
refusal
obey
command
respectfully
dissent
footnotes
section
provides
except
otherwise
provided
section
extent
transfer
avoided
section
title
trustee
may
recover
benefit
estate
property
transferred
orders
value
property
initial
transferee
transfer
entity
whose
benefit
transfer
made
immediate
mediate
transferee
initial
transferee
see
also
material
summarized
quoted
dissenting
opinion
hoffman
connecticut
dept
income
maintenance
particularly
note
sponsors
comment
permits
trustee
debtor
possession
assert
avoiding
powers
title
governmental
unit
comment
result
government
subject
avoidance
preferential
transfers
ante
ante
ante
see
library
congress
shaw
consent
necessary
waive
traditional
immunity
must
express
must
strictly
construed
quoting
rayon
importing
ruckelshaus
sierra
club
waivers
immunity
must
construed
strictly
favor
sovereign
enlarge
beyond
language
requires
sherwood
relinquishment
sovereign
immunity
must
strictly
interpreted
construe
statutory
language
conservatism
see
bock
neal
exemption
sovereign
suit
involves
hardship
enough
consent
withheld
add
rigor
refinement
construction
consent
announced
quoting
anderson
hayes
constr
cardozo
indian
towing
frankfurter
guardian
treasury
import
immunity
back
statute
designed
limit
canadian
aviator
thwart
broad
statutory
language
authorizing
suit
unduly
restrictive
interpretation
see
blackstone
commentaries
see
nevada
hall
fiction
king
wrong
rejected
colonists
declared
independence
crown
landord
understand
english
maxim
king
wrong
existence
country
see
davis
sovereign
immunity
must
go
pugh
historical
approach
doctrine
sovereign
immunity
borchard
government
liability
tort
yale
many
legal
scholars
similarly
critical
doctrine
see
comment
sovereign
immunity
anathema
constitutional
tort
santa
clara
law
collecting
authorities
cramton
nonstatutory
review
federal
administrative
action
need
statutory
reform
sovereign
immunity
subject
matter
jurisdiction
parties
defendant
davis
supra
pugh
supra
recognizing
lack
current
justification
inequities
caused
judicially
created
doctrine
several
state
courts
abrogated
limited
immunity
state
local
governments
see
note
rethinking
sovereign
immunity
bivens
collecting
cases
whiting
pools
first
held
reorganization
estate
includes
property
debtor
seized
creditor
prior
filing
petition
reorganization
explained
see
reason
different
result
obtain
irs
creditor
service
bound
extent
secured
creditor
bankruptcy
code
expressly
term
entity
used
includes
governmental
unit
see
tr
oral
arg
moreover
congress
carefully
considered
effect
new
bankruptcy
code
tax
collection
see
generally
report
senate
finance
committee
decided
provide
protection
tax
collectors
irs
grants
enhanced
priorities
unsecured
tax
claims
nondischarge
tax
liabilities
pp
code
cong
pp
tax
collectors
also
enjoy
generally
applicable
right
adequate
protection
property
subject
liens
nothing
bankruptcy
code
legislative
history
indicates
congress
intended
special
exception
tax
collector
form
exclusion
estate
property
seized
satisfy
tax
lien
ibid
one
scholar
comment
countermajoritarian
thrust
fascination
clear
statement
rules
illustrative
dellmuth
muth
held
education
handicapped
act
eha
abrogate
state
immunity
reached
result
even
though
law
imposed
substantive
obligations
directly
included
jurisdictional
grant
included
legislative
discussion
assuming
sued
changed
clear
statement
rule
congress
responded
broad
textual
abrogation
state
immunity
statutes
protecting
disabled
yet
dellmuth
held
eha
meet
stringent
test
abrogation
statute
made
clear
congress
intent
abrogate
state
immunity
lawsuits
filed
congress
overrode
dellmuth
congress
pass
statute
three
times
achieve
original
goal
quite
striking
eskridge
overriding
statutory
interpretation
decisions
yale
footnotes
omitted