watson
buck
argued
decided
may
thomas
haight
jersey
city
frank
wideman
washington
louis
frohlich
herman
finkelstein
new
york
city
manley
caldwell
west
palm
beach
buck
others
tom
watson
atty
florida
lucien
boggs
jacksonville
tyrus
norwood
asst
atty
florida
andrew
bennett
washington
george
gibbs
jacksonville
fla
watson
others
justice
black
delivered
opinion
broad
outline
cases
involve
constitutionality
florida
statutes
regulating
business
persons
hol
ing
music
copyrights
declaring
combinations
composers
publishers
owners
copyrights
illegal
restraint
trade
american
society
composers
authors
publishers
ascap
one
appellants
one
appellees
combination
controls
performance
rights
major
part
available
supply
copyrighted
popular
music
appellants
appellees
individual
composers
authors
publishers
music
controlled
ascap
appellees
appellants
attorney
general
state
prosecuting
attorneys
florida
charged
duty
enforcing
certain
parts
statutes
question
cases
originally
single
action
ascap
sought
enjoin
state
officials
enforcing
florida
statute
federal
district
composed
three
judges
judicial
code
granted
temporary
injunction
affirmed
without
passing
upon
merits
constitutional
questions
involved
gibbs
buck
supplemental
bill
complaint
filed
asking
three
judge
enjoin
florida
statute
relating
subject
final
hearing
three
judge
enjoined
state
officials
enforcing
part
statute
granted
injunction
certain
sections
act
buck
gibbs
supp
appeal
ascap
refusal
enjoin
state
officials
enforcing
remainder
act
appeal
state
officials
order
granting
injunction
act
certain
sections
act
without
passing
upon
validity
thirteen
sections
subsections
act
held
remaining
eight
sections
deprived
copyright
owners
rights
granted
federal
copyright
laws
statute
must
fall
entirety
upon
premise
sections
held
invalid
parts
bill
intended
florida
legislature
form
harmonious
whole
fall
together
ultimate
questions
involved
must
first
determine
whether
ruling
correct
hold
following
reasons
florida
legislature
expressed
purpose
directly
contrary
district
finding
legislature
intended
regard
spelled
section
act
clear
emphatic
language
legislature
section
reads
section
sentence
clause
part
act
reason
held
declared
unconstitutional
imperative
sic
void
holding
invalidity
shall
affect
remaining
portions
act
shall
construed
legislative
intent
pass
act
without
unconstitutional
inoperative
invalid
part
therein
remainder
act
exclusion
part
parts
shall
held
deemed
valid
excluded
parts
included
herein
flat
statement
florida
legislature
intended
act
stand
enforced
exclusion
part
parts
might
held
invalid
unless
controlling
decision
florida
courts
compels
different
course
federal
courts
justified
speculating
state
legislature
meant
exactly
opposite
declared
legislative
intent
florida
recognizes
seeks
carry
legislative
intent
thus
expressed
speaking
similar
severabi
ity
clause
another
statute
said
act
whole
evinces
purpose
part
legislature
impose
license
tax
chain
stores
section
provides
section
provision
clause
thereof
act
applied
circumstances
shall
declared
invalid
unconstitutional
invalidity
shall
affect
portions
act
held
valid
shall
extend
circumstances
held
invalid
liberal
terms
section
may
reasonably
discerned
legislature
intended
act
review
held
good
eventuality
produce
unreasonable
unconstitutional
absurd
result
test
determine
severance
whether
remainder
act
upheld
rests
fact
whether
invalid
portion
import
valid
part
incomplete
cause
results
contemplated
ture
louis
liggett
lee
measured
test
error
doubt
section
sections
upon
failed
pass
complete
consistent
statute
purpose
reality
heart
act
comprising
distinct
legislative
plan
suppression
combinations
declared
unlawful
pointed
sections
passed
outlaw
combinations
fix
fees
prescribe
means
whereby
legislative
proscription
made
effective
since
therefore
phase
act
aimed
unlawful
combinations
complete
capable
standing
alone
must
consider
separable
phase
statute
determining
whether
injunction
properly
issued
state
officials
matter
fact
record
stands
right
ascap
injunction
depends
upon
phase
statute
determined
validity
invalidity
particular
sections
thought
inconsistent
federal
constitution
copyright
laws
passed
pursuant
ultimate
determinative
question
therefore
whether
florida
power
exercised
outlaw
activities
within
state
price
fixing
combinations
composed
copyright
owners
considering
question
necessary
explain
discuss
injunction
rest
upon
phase
florida
statutory
plan
defendants
injunction
proceedings
state
attorney
general
charged
responsibility
enforcing
state
criminal
laws
state
prosecuting
attorneys
subject
attorney
general
authority
performance
official
duties
statutes
us
made
duty
state
prosecuting
attorneys
acting
attorney
general
direction
institute
state
courts
criminal
civil
proceedings
original
bill
alleged
defendants
threatened
unless
statute
terms
hole
thereof
particularly
complainants
others
similarly
situated
consequence
complainants
suffer
irreparable
injury
damages
supplemental
bill
contained
similar
allegations
act
bills
drawn
upon
premise
complainants
entitled
injunction
restraining
state
prosecuting
officers
ing
single
part
either
lengthy
statutes
circumstances
arise
respect
every
one
multitudinous
regulations
prohibitions
contained
laws
answers
state
representatives
specifically
denied
made
threats
whatever
enforce
acts
complainants
one
else
answer
supplemental
bill
however
said
perform
duties
imposed
upon
act
findings
subject
general
effect
threatened
enforce
state
statutes
complainants
others
similarly
situated
event
complainants
others
similarly
situated
refuse
comply
said
state
statutes
acts
made
unlawful
said
state
statutes
noted
find
threat
enforce
specific
provision
either
law
complete
lack
record
evidence
information
sort
show
threat
prosecute
complainants
one
else
connection
specific
clause
paragraph
numerous
prohibitions
acts
subject
possible
exception
discussed
later
possibly
gathered
meager
record
references
vital
allegation
complainants
bill
though
suits
threatened
criminal
civil
proceedings
instituted
particular
proceedings
contemplated
state
officials
stood
ready
perform
duties
oath
office
acquire
knowledge
violations
act
state
attorney
general
took
position
beginning
construction
earlier
act
duties
kind
imposed
upon
subordinates
except
relationship
prohibited
combinations
type
defined
section
federal
injunctions
state
criminal
statutes
either
entirety
respect
separate
distinct
prohibitions
granted
matter
course
even
statutes
unconstitutional
citizen
member
community
immune
prosecution
good
faith
alleged
criminal
acts
imminence
prosecution
even
though
alleged
unauthorized
hence
unlawful
alone
ground
relief
equity
exerts
extraordinary
powers
prevent
irreparable
injury
plaintiff
seeks
aid
beal
missouri
pacific
railroad
general
statement
officer
stands
ready
perform
duty
falls
far
short
threat
warrant
intervention
equity
especially
true
complete
absence
showin
definite
expressed
intent
enforce
particular
clauses
broad
comprehensive
provisioned
statute
general
statement
equivalent
threat
prosecutions
gegun
immediately
numbers
manner
indicate
virtual
certainty
extraordinary
injury
alone
justifies
equitable
suspension
proceedings
criminal
courts
imminence
immediacy
proposed
enforcement
nature
threats
actually
made
exceptional
irreparable
injury
complainants
sustain
threats
carried
among
vital
allegations
must
shown
exist
restraint
criminal
proceedings
justified
yet
lack
consideration
accorded
aspect
complaint
complainants
presenting
case
reaching
decision
clearly
apparent
failure
give
proper
weight
eyes
essential
prerequisite
exercise
equitable
power
clear
import
record
thought
federal
finds
state
criminal
statute
unconstitutional
mere
statement
prosecuting
officer
intends
perform
duty
sufficient
justification
warrant
federal
enjoining
state
prosecuting
officers
way
enforcing
statute
question
however
rule
general
rule
equity
interfere
prevent
enforcement
criminal
statute
even
though
unconstitutional
justify
interference
must
exceptional
circumstances
clear
showing
injunction
necessary
order
afford
adequate
protection
constitutional
rights
said
must
appear
danger
irreparable
loss
great
immediate
otherwise
accused
first
set
defense
state
even
though
validity
statute
challenged
ample
opportunity
ultimate
review
federal
questions
spielman
motor
sales
dodge
circumstances
immediate
danger
irreparable
loss
shown
tested
rule
therefore
possible
exception
phase
statute
outlawing
florida
activities
combinations
declared
unlawful
section
act
shall
later
consider
separately
neither
findings
record
based
justified
injunction
state
prosecuting
officers
addition
fact
situation
meet
tests
laid
decided
cases
scope
two
statutes
illustrates
wisdom
policy
judicial
self
restraint
part
federal
courts
suspending
state
statutes
entirety
upon
ground
complainant
might
eventually
prosecuted
violating
part
florida
dual
system
government
last
word
construction
meaning
statutes
state
never
yet
passed
upon
statutes
us
highly
desirable
opportunity
separate
sections
two
acts
sections
repetitious
sections
unimportant
present
purposes
embraced
within
two
acts
many
separate
distinct
regulations
commands
prohibitions
one
foresee
varying
applications
separate
provisions
conceivably
might
made
law
constitutional
applied
one
manner
may
still
contravene
constitution
applied
another
since
contingencies
attempted
enforcement
envisioned
advance
applications
courts
main
found
wiser
delay
passing
upon
constitutionality
separate
phases
comprehensive
statute
faced
cases
involving
particular
provisions
specifically
applied
persons
claim
injured
passing
upon
possible
significance
manifold
provisions
broad
statute
advance
efforts
apply
separate
provisions
analogous
rendering
advisory
opinion
upon
statute
declaratory
judgment
upon
hypothetical
case
course
conceivable
statute
might
flagrantly
patently
violative
express
constitutional
prohibitions
every
clause
sentence
paragraph
whatever
manner
whomever
effort
might
made
apply
sufficient
say
statutes
us
type
cases
separate
sections
paragraphs
acts
tried
state
courts
federal
questions
properly
presented
brought
time
record
justify
passing
upon
part
statute
except
possibly
phase
prohibits
activities
florida
combinations
declared
unlawful
proof
findings
regard
clear
specific
might
nevertheless
circumstances
case
proceed
ultimate
decisive
question
consideration
case
much
confusion
brought
discussing
statutes
though
power
state
prohibit
regulate
combinations
restraint
trade
identical
went
power
exercised
congress
sherman
act
note
argument
rests
upon
mistaken
premise
within
province
determining
whether
phase
state
statute
comes
collision
federal
constitution
laws
passed
pursuant
thereto
scrutinize
act
order
determine
whether
believe
fair
unfair
conducive
good
evil
people
florida
capable
protecting
defeating
public
interest
state
questions
legislature
florida
decided
unless
constitutionally
valid
federal
legislation
granted
individual
copyright
owners
right
combine
state
power
validly
prohibit
proscribed
combinations
held
merely
individuals
serve
property
rights
better
combination
individuals
find
nothing
copyright
laws
purports
grant
copyright
owners
privilege
combining
violation
otherwise
valid
state
federal
laws
fact
determined
contrary
relation
copyright
privileges
complainants
urge
distinction
previous
holdings
question
contention
based
idea
congress
granted
copyright
privilege
relation
public
performances
music
reference
protection
particular
privilege
combination
essential
therefore
asked
conclude
asserted
necessities
situation
congress
intended
grant
extraordinary
privilege
combination
pointed
nothing
either
language
copyright
laws
history
enactment
indicate
congressional
purpose
deprive
either
whole
part
power
regulate
combinations
restraint
trade
compare
pierce
oil
texas
findings
fact
ascap
comes
squarely
within
definition
combinations
prohibited
section
act
section
defines
unlawful
combination
aggregation
authors
composers
publishers
owners
copyrighted
vocal
instrumental
musical
compositions
form
society
association
like
members
constitute
substantial
number
persons
firms
corporations
within
control
musical
compositions
one
objects
combination
determination
ation
license
fees
exactions
required
combination
members
interested
parties
section
act
makes
offense
combinations
act
within
state
violation
terms
act
found
composers
authors
members
ascap
principal
music
publishers
country
members
society
controls
right
performance
members
similar
societies
foreign
countries
board
directors
ascap
control
fixing
prices
charged
performance
licenses
since
record
findings
ascap
association
within
meaning
section
act
called
upon
instance
pass
upon
validity
provisions
contained
numerous
clauses
sentences
phases
act
might
cover
combinations
us
enough
us
say
case
phase
florida
law
prohibiting
activities
unlawful
combinations
described
section
act
contravene
copyright
laws
federal
constitution
particular
attacks
upon
specified
provisions
statutes
involved
appropriate
determination
proceeding
erred
granting
injunction
bill
dismissed
questions
remain
open
consideration
disposition
appropriate
proceedings
reasons
given
judgment
reversed
cause
remanded
lower
instructions
dismiss
bill
judgment
affirmed
ordered
reversed
remanded
part
affirmed
part
justice
murphy
took
part
consideration
decision
case
footnotes
ch
ch
said
remain
sections
effect
declaring
ascap
similar
societies
illegal
associations
outlawing
arrangements
license
fees
proscribing
making
offense
attempts
collect
section
making
persons
acting
combination
agents
liable
penalties
act
section
fixing
penalties
section
giving
state
courts
jurisdiction
enforce
act
civilly
criminally
sections
prescribing
procedure
possible
exception
section
nowhere
course
opinion
sections
held
invalid
secretary
state
state
comptroller
added
parties
defendant
supplemental
bill
complaint
filed
october
ground
given
compolainants
adding
parties
certain
duties
imposed
officials
act
duties
however
required
certain
fees
collected
actions
brought
enforce
law
course
litigation
florida
three
attorneys
general
present
attorney
general
took
office
january
parties
joined
motion
substitute
defendant
place
predecessor
office
objection
substitution
motion
granted
arkansas
corporation
commission
thompson
railroad
commission
texas
pullman
co
railroad
commission
texas
rowan
nichols
oil
thompson
magnolia
petroleum
ex
parte
baldwin
gilchrist
interborough
rapid
transit
referred
recent
consent
decree
ascap
federal
district
southern
district
new
york
theory
decree
might
bearing
upon
state
power
pass
legislation
attack
matters
relating
purely
intrastate
transactions
state
might
pass
valid
regulations
prohibit
restraint
trade
even
federal
government
law
whatever
reference
similar
matters
involving
interstate
transactions
concluded
matter
law
said
statute
necessary
protect
serve
public
interest
state
florida
interstate
circuit
cf
fashion
originators
guild
america
federal
trade
commission
ethyl
gasoline