rostker
goldberg
argued
march
decided
june
military
selective
service
act
act
authorizes
president
require
registration
possible
military
service
males
females
purpose
registration
facilitate
eventual
conscription
act
registration
draft
discontinued
presidential
proclamation
act
amended
preclude
conscription
result
crisis
southwestern
asia
president
carter
decided
necessary
reactivate
registration
process
sought
congress
allocation
funds
purpose
also
recommended
congress
amend
act
permit
registration
conscription
women
well
men
although
agreeing
necessary
reactivate
registration
process
congress
allocated
funds
necessary
register
males
declined
amend
act
permit
registration
women
thereafter
president
ordered
registration
specified
groups
young
men
lawsuit
brought
several
men
challenging
act
constitutionality
district
ultimately
held
act
discrimination
violated
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
enjoined
registration
act
held
act
registration
provisions
violate
fifth
amendment
congress
acted
well
within
constitutional
authority
raise
regulate
armies
navies
authorized
registration
men
women
pp
customary
deference
accorded
congress
judgments
particularly
appropriate
congress
specifically
considered
question
act
constitutionality
perhaps
area
accorded
congress
greater
deference
area
national
defense
military
affairs
congress
free
disregard
constitution
acts
area
military
affairs
must
particularly
careful
substitute
judgment
desirable
congress
evaluation
evidence
reasonable
evaluation
legislative
branch
congress
carefully
considered
whether
register
males
potential
conscription
whether
register
sexes
broad
constitutional
authority
ignored
considering
constitutionality
studied
choice
one
alternative
preference
pp
question
registering
women
extensively
considered
congress
hearings
held
response
president
request
authorization
register
women
decision
exempt
women
accidental
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
women
since
congress
thoroughly
reconsidered
question
exempting
women
act
act
constitutionality
need
considered
solely
basis
views
expressed
congress
act
first
enacted
modern
form
congress
determination
future
draft
characterized
need
combat
troops
sufficiently
supported
testimony
adduced
hearings
courts
free
make
judgment
question
since
women
excluded
combat
service
statute
military
policy
men
women
simply
similarly
situated
purposes
draft
registration
draft
congress
decision
authorize
registration
men
therefore
violate
due
process
clause
testimony
executive
military
officials
congress
showed
argument
registering
women
based
considerations
equity
congress
entitled
exercise
constitutional
powers
focus
question
military
need
rather
equity
district
undertaking
independent
evaluation
evidence
exceeded
authority
ignoring
congress
conclusions
whatever
need
women
noncombat
roles
mobilization
met
volunteers
staffing
noncombat
positions
women
mobilization
positively
detrimental
important
goal
military
flexibility
pp
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
burger
stewart
blackmun
powell
stevens
joined
white
post
marshall
post
filed
dissenting
opinions
brennan
joined
solicitor
general
mccree
argued
cause
appellant
briefs
assistant
attorney
general
daniel
acting
assistant
attorney
general
martin
deputy
solicitor
general
claiborne
barbara
etkind
william
kanter
mark
gallant
donald
weinberg
argued
cause
appellees
brief
harold
kohn
stuart
savett
isabelle
katz
pinzler
bruce
ennis
laurence
tribe
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
dennis
rapps
david
stern
orthodox
jewish
coalition
draft
nathan
lewin
stacy
acker
et
al
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
daniel
marcus
congressman
robert
kastenmeier
et
al
paul
kenney
men
rights
barbara
brown
thomas
hart
phyllis
segal
judith
avner
national
organization
women
judith
lichtman
women
equity
action
league
educational
legal
defense
fund
et
al
daniel
popeo
paul
kamenar
filed
brief
congressman
lawrence
mcdonald
et
al
amici
curiae
justice
rehnquist
delivered
opinion
question
presented
whether
military
selective
service
act
app
et
seq
ed
supp
iii
violates
fifth
amendment
constitution
authorizing
president
require
registration
males
females
congress
given
power
constitution
raise
support
armies
provide
maintain
navy
make
rules
government
regulation
land
naval
forces
art
cls
pursuant
grant
authority
congress
enacted
military
selective
service
act
app
et
seq
ed
supp
iii
mssa
act
section
act
stat
amended
app
empowers
president
proclamation
require
registration
every
male
citizen
male
resident
aliens
ages
purpose
registration
facilitate
eventual
conscription
pursuant
act
stat
amended
app
persons
required
register
liable
training
service
armed
forces
mssa
registration
provision
serves
purpose
beyond
providing
pool
subsequent
induction
registration
draft
discontinued
presidential
proclamation
cfr
comp
note
following
app
early
president
carter
determined
necessary
reactivate
draft
registration
process
immediate
impetus
decision
soviet
armed
invasion
afghanistan
weekly
comp
pres
doc
state
union
address
according
administration
witnesses
senate
armed
services
committee
resulting
crisis
southwestern
asia
convinced
president
time
come
use
present
authority
require
registration
necessary
step
preserving
enhancing
national
security
interests
department
defense
authorization
appropriations
fiscal
year
hearings
senate
committee
armed
services
hereafter
hearings
joint
statement
john
white
deputy
director
office
management
budget
bernard
rostker
director
selective
service
system
richard
danzig
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
selective
service
system
inactive
however
funds
needed
reactivating
registration
president
therefore
recommended
funds
transferred
department
defense
separate
selective
service
system
doc
also
recommended
congress
take
action
amend
mssa
permit
registration
conscription
women
well
men
see
house
committee
armed
services
presidential
recommendations
selective
service
reform
report
congress
prepared
pursuant
pub
comm
print
hereinafter
presidential
recommendations
app
congress
agreed
necessary
reactivate
registration
process
allocated
funds
purpose
joint
resolution
passed
house
april
senate
june
res
pub
stat
resolution
allocate
funds
originally
requested
president
necessary
register
males
see
cong
rec
nunn
although
congress
considered
question
great
length
see
infra
declined
amend
mssa
permit
registration
women
july
president
proclamation
ordered
registration
specified
groups
young
men
pursuant
authority
conferred
act
registration
commence
july
proclamation
cfr
events
last
year
breathed
new
life
lawsuit
essentially
dormant
lower
courts
nearly
decade
began
several
men
subject
registration
draft
subsequent
induction
armed
services
filed
complaint
district
eastern
district
pennsylvania
challenging
mssa
several
grounds
district
convened
consider
claim
unlawful
discrimination
us
july
declined
dismiss
case
moot
reasoning
although
authority
induct
registrants
lapsed
see
supra
plaintiffs
still
certain
affirmative
obligations
connection
registration
rowland
tarr
supp
nothing
happened
case
five
years
june
clerk
acting
pursuant
local
rule
governing
inactive
cases
proposed
case
dismissed
additional
discovery
thereupon
ensued
defendants
moved
dismiss
various
justiciability
grounds
denied
motion
dismiss
ruling
adequate
record
operation
selective
service
system
action
necessary
reactivate
goldberg
tarr
supp
july
certified
plaintiff
class
male
persons
registered
subject
registration
app
liable
training
service
armed
forces
app
supp
friday
july
three
days
registration
commence
district
issued
opinion
finding
act
violated
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
permanently
enjoined
government
requiring
registration
act
initially
determined
plaintiffs
standing
case
ripe
determinations
challenged
government
turning
merits
rejected
plaintiffs
suggestions
equal
protection
claim
tested
strict
scrutiny
also
rejected
defendants
argument
deference
due
congress
area
military
affairs
required
application
traditional
minimum
scrutiny
test
applying
important
government
interest
test
articulated
craig
boren
struck
mssa
stressed
deciding
whether
extent
women
serve
combat
issue
registration
felt
dispel
concern
injecting
inappropriate
manner
military
affairs
see
also
nn
proceeded
examine
testimony
hearing
evidence
presented
congress
representatives
military
executive
branch
concluded
basis
testimony
military
opinion
backed
extensive
study
availability
women
registrants
materially
increase
flexibility
hamper
rejected
congress
contrary
determination
part
viewed
congress
inconsistent
positions
declining
register
women
yet
spending
funds
recruit
expand
opportunities
military
ibid
director
selective
service
immediately
filed
notice
appeal
next
day
saturday
july
justice
brennan
acting
capacity
circuit
justice
third
circuit
stayed
district
order
enjoining
commencement
registration
registration
began
next
monday
december
noted
probable
jurisdiction
ii
whenever
called
upon
judge
constitutionality
act
congress
gravest
delicate
duty
called
upon
perform
blodgett
holden
holmes
accords
great
weight
decisions
congress
columbia
broadcasting
system
democratic
national
committee
congress
coequal
branch
government
whose
members
take
oath
uphold
constitution
justice
frankfurter
noted
joint
refugee
committee
mcgrath
concurring
opinion
must
due
regard
fact
exercising
primary
judgment
sitting
judgment
upon
also
taken
oath
observe
constitution
responsibility
carrying
government
customary
deference
accorded
judgments
congress
certainly
appropriate
congress
specifically
considered
question
act
constitutionality
see
pp
cong
rec
warner
hatfield
however
merely
case
involving
customary
deference
accorded
congressional
decisions
case
arises
context
congress
authority
national
defense
military
affairs
perhaps
area
accorded
congress
greater
deference
rejecting
registration
women
congress
explicitly
relied
upon
constitutional
powers
art
cls
specific
findings
section
report
senate
armed
services
committee
later
adopted
houses
congress
began
stating
article
section
constitution
commits
exclusively
congress
powers
raise
support
armies
provide
maintain
navy
make
rules
government
regulation
land
naval
forces
pursuant
powers
lies
within
discretion
congress
determine
occasions
expansion
armed
forces
means
best
suited
expansion
prove
necessary
supra
scope
congress
constitutional
power
area
broad
lack
competence
part
courts
marked
gilligan
morgan
noted
difficult
conceive
area
governmental
activity
courts
less
competence
complex
subtle
professional
decisions
composition
training
equipping
control
military
force
essentially
professional
military
judgments
subject
always
civilian
control
legislative
executive
branches
operation
healthy
deference
legislative
executive
judgments
area
military
affairs
evident
several
recent
decisions
parker
levy
rejected
vagueness
overbreadth
challenges
provisions
uniform
code
military
justice
noting
congress
permitted
legislate
greater
breadth
greater
flexibility
statute
governs
military
society
hile
members
military
excluded
protection
granted
first
amendment
different
character
military
community
military
mission
requires
different
application
protections
middendorf
henry
noted
considering
due
process
claims
context
summary
must
give
particular
deference
determination
congress
made
authority
regulate
land
naval
forces
art
concerning
rights
available
see
also
powell
concurring
deference
judgment
branches
area
military
affairs
also
played
major
role
greer
spock
upheld
ban
political
speeches
civilians
military
base
brown
glines
upheld
regulations
imposing
prior
restraint
right
petition
military
personnel
see
also
burns
wilson
macintosh
schlesinger
ballard
supra
considered
due
process
challenge
brought
males
navy
policy
according
females
longer
period
males
attain
promotions
necessary
continued
service
distinguished
previous
discriminations
held
unlawful
reed
reed
frontiero
richardson
cases
classifications
based
overbroad
generalizations
see
case
however
noted
different
treatment
men
women
naval
officers
reflects
archaic
overbroad
generalizations
instead
demonstrable
fact
male
female
line
officers
navy
similarly
situated
respect
opportunities
professional
service
appellee
challenged
current
restrictions
women
officers
participation
combat
sea
duty
none
say
congress
free
disregard
constitution
acts
area
military
affairs
area
congress
remains
subject
limitations
due
process
clause
see
ex
parte
milligan
wall
hamilton
kentucky
distilleries
warehouse
tests
limitations
applied
may
differ
military
context
course
abdicate
ultimate
responsibility
decide
constitutional
question
simply
recognize
constitution
requires
deference
congressional
choice
see
columbia
broadcasting
system
democratic
national
committee
deciding
question
us
must
particularly
careful
substitute
judgment
desirable
congress
evaluation
evidence
reasonable
evaluation
legislative
branch
district
purported
recognize
appropriateness
deference
congress
body
exercising
constitutionally
delegated
authority
military
affairs
stressed
concerned
military
operations
conduct
military
desire
intrude
ibid
appellees
also
stress
case
involves
civilians
military
impact
registration
military
indirect
attenuated
brief
appellees
emphasis
omitted
find
efforts
divorce
registration
military
national
defense
context
deference
called
context
singularly
unpersuasive
recognized
broad
deference
due
congress
selective
service
area
us
case
registration
end
civilian
world
rather
first
step
induction
process
military
one
congress
specifically
linked
consideration
registration
induction
see
pp
congressional
judgments
concerning
registration
draft
based
judgments
concerning
military
operations
needs
see
starting
point
discussion
appropriateness
registering
women
draft
question
proper
role
women
combat
deference
unquestionably
due
latter
judgments
necessarily
required
assessing
former
well
although
district
stressed
intruding
military
questions
opinion
based
assessments
military
need
flexibility
time
mobilization
see
blinking
reality
say
precedents
requiring
deference
congress
military
affairs
implicated
present
case
solicitor
general
argues
largely
basis
foregoing
cases
emphasizing
deference
due
congress
area
military
affairs
national
security
scrutinize
mssa
determine
distinction
drawn
men
women
bears
rational
relation
legitimate
government
purpose
see
railroad
retirement
bd
fritz
examine
act
heightened
scrutiny
approached
discrimination
see
michael
superior
sonoma
county
craig
boren
reed
reed
supra
think
substantive
guarantee
due
process
certainty
law
advanced
refinement
applicable
tests
suggested
government
announced
degrees
deference
legislative
judgments
levels
scrutiny
announces
applies
particular
classifications
made
legislative
body
may
readily
become
facile
abstractions
used
justify
result
case
courts
called
upon
decide
whether
congress
acting
explicit
constitutional
grant
authority
action
transgressed
explicit
guarantee
individual
rights
limits
authority
conferred
simply
labeling
legislative
decision
military
one
hand
automatically
guide
correct
constitutional
result
one
deny
test
craig
boren
supra
government
interest
raising
supporting
armies
important
governmental
interest
congress
committees
carefully
considered
debated
two
alternative
means
furthering
interest
first
register
males
potential
conscription
register
sexes
congress
chose
former
alternative
decision
challenged
equal
protection
grounds
question
must
decide
alternative
chosen
primary
decisionmaker
whether
chosen
congress
denies
equal
protection
laws
denied
imposing
number
cases
previously
cited
suggest
judicial
deference
congressional
exercise
authority
apogee
legislative
action
congressional
authority
raise
support
armies
make
rules
regulations
governance
challenged
previously
noted
supra
deference
mean
abdication
reconciliation
deference
due
congress
constitutional
responsibility
perhaps
best
instanced
schlesinger
ballard
stated
recognized
primary
business
armies
navies
fight
ready
fight
wars
occasion
arise
ex
rel
toth
quarles
see
also
orloff
willoughby
responsibility
determining
best
armed
forces
shall
attend
business
rests
congress
see
art
cls
president
see
art
ii
cl
say
exercising
broad
constitutional
power
congress
violated
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
udges
given
task
running
army
responsibility
setting
channels
grievances
considered
fairly
settled
rests
upon
congress
upon
president
subordinates
military
constitutes
specialized
community
governed
separate
discipline
civilian
orderly
government
requires
judiciary
scrupulous
interfere
legitimate
army
matters
army
must
scrupulous
intervene
judicial
matters
orloff
willoughby
iii
case
quite
different
several
discrimination
cases
considered
despite
appellees
assertions
congress
act
unthinkingly
reflexively
considered
reason
brief
appellees
question
registering
women
draft
received
considerable
national
attention
subject
public
debate
also
extensively
considered
congress
hearings
floor
debate
committee
hearings
held
houses
congress
response
president
request
authorization
register
women
adduced
extensive
testimony
evidence
concerning
issue
see
hearings
hearings
registration
women
subcommittee
military
personnel
house
committee
armed
services
sess
hereafter
house
hearings
hearings
built
hearings
held
previous
year
addressed
question
house
declined
provide
registration
women
passed
joint
resolution
allocating
funds
selective
service
system
see
cong
rec
senate
considered
joint
resolution
defeated
extensive
debate
amendment
effect
authorized
registration
women
noted
earlier
congress
res
authorized
funds
sufficient
cover
registration
males
report
senate
committee
appropriations
res
noted
amount
authorized
president
request
due
committee
decision
provide
register
women
amount
recommended
committee
allow
registration
young
men
see
cong
rec
nunn
proposals
register
women
rejected
course
transferring
funds
register
males
committees
houses
conducted
hearings
issue
also
rejecting
registration
women
house
subcommittee
military
personnel
house
armed
services
committee
tabled
bill
amended
mssa
authorize
registration
women
march
legislative
calendar
house
committee
armed
services
senate
armed
services
committee
rejected
proposal
register
women
one
year
see
pp
adopted
specific
findings
supporting
action
see
pp
findings
stressed
debate
senate
joint
resolution
see
cong
rec
nunn
warner
later
specifically
endorsed
house
senate
conferees
considering
fiscal
year
defense
authorization
bill
see
conf
later
houses
adopted
findings
passing
report
cong
rec
senate
report
therefore
considerably
significant
typical
report
single
house
findings
effect
findings
entire
congress
foregoing
clearly
establishes
decision
exempt
women
registration
byproduct
traditional
way
thinking
females
califano
webster
quoting
califano
goldfarb
stevens
concurring
judgment
michael
plurality
opinion
rejected
similar
argument
action
california
legislature
considering
rejecting
proposals
make
statute
challenged
discrimination
grounds
cause
rejecting
argument
considerably
stronger
issue
considered
great
length
congress
clearly
expressed
purpose
intent
contrast
califano
westcott
gender
qualification
escaped
virtually
unnoticed
hearings
floor
debates
reasons
reject
appellees
argument
must
consider
constitutionality
mssa
solely
basis
views
expressed
congress
mssa
first
enacted
modern
form
contrary
suggestions
appellees
various
amici
reliance
legislative
history
joint
resolution
activity
various
committees
congress
considering
registration
women
violate
sound
principles
appropriations
legislation
considered
modifying
substantive
legislation
congress
change
mssa
thoroughly
reconsider
question
exempting
women
provisions
basis
legislative
history
therefore
highly
relevant
assessing
constitutional
validity
exemption
mssa
established
plan
maintaining
adequate
armed
strength
insure
security
nation
app
registration
first
step
continuous
process
designed
raise
army
speedily
efficiently
falbo
see
nugent
congress
provided
reactivation
registration
order
provid
means
early
delivery
inductees
emergency
supra
although
district
often
tried
sever
consideration
registration
particulars
induction
see
congress
rather
clearly
linked
need
renewed
registration
views
character
subsequent
draft
senate
report
specifically
found
ability
mobilize
rapidly
essential
preservation
national
security
functioning
registration
system
vital
part
mobilization
plan
supra
senator
warner
put
equate
registration
draft
hearings
see
also
jepsen
exon
approach
certainly
logical
since
mssa
induction
interlocked
registration
registered
may
drafted
registration
serves
purpose
beyond
providing
pool
draft
assessment
congressional
purpose
chosen
means
must
therefore
consider
registration
scheme
prelude
draft
time
national
emergency
approach
testing
act
light
purposes
congress
sought
achieve
congress
determined
future
draft
facilitated
registration
scheme
characterized
need
combat
troops
senate
report
explained
specific
finding
later
adopted
houses
mobilization
ordered
wartime
scenario
primary
manpower
need
combat
replacements
see
conclusion
echoed
one
made
year
senate
committee
see
pp
senator
jepsen
put
shortage
combat
arms
drafts
hearings
see
also
jepsen
cong
rec
nelson
congress
determination
need
combat
troops
draft
took
place
sufficiently
supported
testimony
adduced
hearings
courts
free
make
judgment
question
see
hearings
marine
corps
bronars
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
army
clark
yerks
meyer
house
hearings
assistant
secretary
defense
manpower
pirie
see
also
hearing
rogers
purpose
registration
therefore
prepare
draft
combat
troops
women
group
however
unlike
men
group
eligible
combat
restrictions
participation
women
combat
navy
air
force
statutory
supp
iii
women
may
assigned
duty
vessels
aircraft
engaged
combat
missions
female
members
air
force
may
assigned
duty
aircraft
engaged
combat
missions
army
marine
corps
preclude
use
women
combat
matter
established
policy
see
app
congress
specifically
recognized
endorsed
exclusion
women
combat
exempting
women
registration
words
senate
report
principle
women
intentionally
routinely
engage
combat
fundamental
enjoys
wide
support
among
people
universally
supported
military
leaders
testified
committee
current
law
policy
exclude
women
assigned
combat
military
forces
committee
reaffirms
policy
supra
existence
combat
restrictions
clearly
indicates
basis
congress
decision
exempt
women
registration
purpose
registration
prepare
draft
combat
troops
since
women
excluded
combat
congress
concluded
needed
event
draft
therefore
decided
register
turning
senate
report
committee
view
starting
point
discussion
appropriateness
registering
women
draft
question
proper
role
women
combat
policy
precluding
use
women
combat
committee
view
important
reason
including
women
registration
system
supra
congress
decision
authorize
registration
men
therefore
violate
due
process
clause
exemption
women
registration
sufficiently
also
closely
related
congress
purpose
authorizing
registration
see
michael
plurality
opinion
craig
boren
reed
reed
fact
congress
executive
decided
women
serve
combat
fully
justifies
congress
authorizing
registration
since
purpose
registration
develop
pool
potential
combat
troops
case
schlesinger
ballard
supra
gender
classification
individious
rather
realistically
reflects
fact
sexes
similarly
situated
case
michael
supra
plurality
opinion
constitution
requires
congress
treat
similarly
situated
persons
similarly
engage
gestures
superficial
equality
holding
mssa
constitutionally
invalid
district
relied
heavily
president
decision
seek
authority
register
women
testimony
members
executive
branch
military
support
decision
see
stated
administration
witnesses
congress
however
president
decision
ask
authority
register
women
based
equity
house
hearings
statement
assistant
secretary
defense
pirie
director
selective
service
system
rostker
see
also
presidential
recommendations
app
hearings
statements
executive
associate
director
office
management
budget
wellford
director
selective
service
system
rostker
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
also
basis
testimony
military
officials
meyer
allen
senate
report
evaluating
testimony
committee
recognized
argument
registration
induction
women
based
military
necessity
considerations
equity
congress
certainly
entitled
exercise
constitutional
powers
raise
regulate
armies
navies
focus
question
military
need
rather
equity
senator
nunn
senate
armed
services
committee
put
committee
went
great
detail
found
military
necessity
cited
witnesses
registration
females
main
point
favored
registration
females
made
favor
equality
issue
course
legitimate
view
far
military
necessity
primarily
hope
considering
overall
registration
bill
military
necessity
cong
rec
although
military
experts
testified
favor
registering
women
uniformly
opposed
actual
drafting
women
see
hearing
rogers
testimony
event
draft
military
absorb
female
inductees
hearings
used
fill
noncombat
positions
freeing
men
go
front
relying
testimony
striking
mssa
district
palpably
exceeded
authority
ignored
congress
considered
response
line
reasoning
first
place
assuming
small
number
women
drafted
noncombat
roles
congress
simply
consider
worth
added
burdens
including
women
draft
registration
plans
suggested
women
registered
handful
actually
inducted
emergency
committee
finds
confused
ultimately
unsatisfactory
solution
supra
senate
committee
recognized
year
training
needlessly
burdened
women
recruits
used
combat
see
also
supra
administrative
problems
housing
different
treatment
regard
dependency
hardship
physical
standards
also
exist
dismiss
problems
insignificant
context
military
preparedness
exigencies
future
mobilization
congress
also
concluded
whatever
need
women
noncombat
roles
mobilization
whether
less
met
volunteers
see
combat
restrictions
need
primarily
men
women
volunteers
fill
requirements
women
house
hearings
holt
see
also
hearings
rogers
significantly
congress
determined
staffing
noncombat
positions
women
mobilization
positively
detrimental
important
goal
military
flexibility
military
reasons
preclude
large
numbers
women
serving
military
flexibility
requires
commander
able
move
units
ships
quickly
units
ships
located
front
previously
scheduled
front
nevertheless
must
able
move
action
necessary
peace
war
significant
rotation
personnel
necessary
divide
military
two
groups
one
permanent
combat
one
permanent
support
large
numbers
positions
must
available
combat
troops
return
duty
redeployed
supra
light
foregoing
conclude
congress
acted
well
within
constitutional
authority
authorized
registration
men
women
military
selective
service
act
decision
district
holding
otherwise
accordingly
reversed
footnotes
plaintiffs
contended
act
amounted
taking
property
without
due
process
imposed
involuntary
servitude
violated
rights
free
expression
assembly
unlawfully
implemented
advance
unconstitutional
war
impermissibly
discriminated
males
females
district
denied
plaintiffs
application
convene
district
dismissed
suit
rowland
tarr
supp
appeal
appeals
third
circuit
affirmed
dismissal
claims
except
discrimination
claim
remanded
case
district
determine
claim
substantial
enough
warrant
convening
ed
whether
plaintiffs
standing
assert
claim
remand
district
answered
questions
affirmative
resulting
convening
decided
case
act
authorizing
courts
hear
claims
repealed
pub
stat
remains
applicable
suits
filed
repeal
stat
stated
schlesinger
ballard
although
contains
equal
protection
clause
fourteenth
amendment
fifth
amendment
due
process
clause
prohibits
federal
government
engaging
discrimination
unjustifiable
violative
due
process
bolling
sharpe
entering
judgment
july
district
redefined
class
include
male
persons
registered
app
liable
training
service
armed
forces
app
also
either
subject
registration
presidential
proclamation
july
presently
registered
selective
service
system
see
also
simmons
cert
denied
competent
empowered
sit
authority
review
decisions
executive
legislative
branches
government
regard
necessity
method
selection
composition
defense
forces
obvious
needs
discussion
congress
recognized
decision
registration
involved
judgments
military
needs
operations
decisions
entitled
particular
deference
recent
teachings
field
equal
protection
read
isolation
opinions
giving
great
deference
judgment
congress
military
commanders
dealing
management
military
forces
requirements
military
discipline
made
unmistakably
clear
even
fundamental
constitutional
rights
must
circumstances
modified
light
military
needs
congress
judgment
necessary
preserve
national
security
entitled
great
deference
pp
deference
congress
judgment
consistent
dominant
theme
lower
decisions
assessing
present
claim
see
clinton
supp
ed
la
offord
supp
ed
clear
ender
never
rejected
impermissible
classification
instances
kahn
shevin
making
observation
noted
congress
far
drafted
women
armed
services
app
ibid
see
reinstitution
procedures
registration
military
selective
service
act
hearing
manpower
personnel
senate
committee
armed
services
sess
hearing
seven
months
president
call
registration
women
senate
armed
services
committee
rejected
idea
see
pp
amendment
provided
funds
shall
made
available
implementing
system
registration
include
women
cong
rec
findings
conferees
senate
armed
services
committee
added
provision
defense
authorization
bill
authorizing
transfer
funds
register
young
men
stopgap
measure
joint
resolution
fail
see
conf
agree
characterization
mssa
brief
national
organization
women
amicus
curiae
law
coerce
preclude
women
class
performing
tasks
jobs
capable
suggestion
case
involves
exclusion
women
military
nothing
mssa
restricts
way
opportunities
women
volunteer
military
service
major
country
women
combat
jobs
standing
army
see
app
see
brief
appellees
denying
concession
validity
combat
restrictions
submitting
restrictions
irrelevant
present
case
see
also
app
justice
marshall
suggestion
since
congress
focused
need
combat
troops
authorizing
registration
forced
declare
registration
program
unconstitutional
post
event
peacetime
draft
misreads
opinion
perceived
need
combat
troops
event
draft
limited
wartime
draft
see
considering
problems
associated
egistering
women
assignment
combat
assigning
women
combat
positions
emphasis
supplied
need
rotation
combat
noncombat
positions
peace
war
grant
constitutional
authority
congress
executive
military
officials
district
also
focused
termed
congress
inconsistent
positions
encouraging
women
volunteer
military
service
expanding
opportunities
service
one
hand
exempting
registration
draft
reasoning
fails
appreciate
different
purposes
served
encouraging
women
volunteers
registration
draft
women
volunteers
occupy
combat
positions
encouraging
women
volunteer
related
concerns
availability
combat
troops
event
draft
however
need
combat
troops
troops
rotated
combat
see
supra
congress
positions
clearly
inconsistent
treating
district
failed
understand
congress
purpose
behind
registration
distinguished
purpose
encouraging
women
volunteers
general
rogers
testimony
merits
quotation
general
rogers
one
thing
often
lost
sight
senator
emergency
war
army
often
reach
back
support
base
supporting
elements
operating
base
pull
forward
soldiers
fill
ranks
emergency
hand
rifle
give
tanker
suit
put
front
ranks
senator
warner
general
patton
one
time
believe
battle
bulge
general
rogers
absolutely
support
base
operating
base
rear
consists
large
measure
women
opportunity
reach
back
pull
forward
women
placed
forward
fighting
position
tank
opinion
enters
equation
one
considers
subject
utility
women
contingency
conditions
assume
challenged
case
excluding
women
combat
positions
offend
constitution
granting
mobilization
war
noncombat
military
positions
must
filled
personnel
available
moved
combat
positions
occasion
whatsoever
women
army
whether
volunteers
inductees
appears
say
ante
congress
concluded
much
accept
judgment
even
though
serious
view
executive
branch
including
responsible
military
services
contrary
position
regard
unpersuasive
perceive
little
indication
congress
concluded
every
position
military
matter
far
removed
combat
must
filled
men
common
sense
experience
recent
wars
women
volunteers
employed
substantial
numbers
belie
view
reality
ascribed
congress
particularly
face
testimony
military
authorities
hereafter
referred
substantial
number
positions
services
filled
women
peacetime
mobilization
even
though
ineligible
combat
also
little
difficulty
agreeing
reversal
women
serve
wartime
without
adversely
affecting
combat
readiness
predictably
obtained
volunteers
event
equal
protection
component
fifth
amendment
require
go
large
segment
population
burdened
expensive
essentially
useless
procedure
registering
women
agree
see
ante
congress
concluded
legislative
record
indicates
services
rely
women
volunteers
fill
positions
might
eligible
event
mobilization
contrary
record
understand
supports
district
finding
services
conscript
least
persons
fill
positions
men
required
consistent
position
defense
department
representatives
best
estimate
number
women
draftees
used
productively
services
event
major
mobilization
approximately
first
six
months
see
hearings
senate
committee
armed
services
hearings
subcommittee
military
personnel
house
committee
armed
services
number
took
account
estimated
number
women
volunteers
see
deposition
director
selective
service
bernard
rostker
deposition
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
richard
danzig
app
except
single
unsupported
ambiguous
statement
senate
report
effect
women
volunteers
fill
requirements
women
indication
congress
rejected
defense
department
figures
relied
upon
alternative
set
figures
course
division
among
us
indicates
record
respect
means
different
things
different
people
content
vacate
judgment
remand
hearings
findings
crucial
issue
absent
however
agree
record
supports
view
positions
women
eligible
wartime
filled
female
volunteers
also
submits
primary
purpose
registration
conscription
supply
combat
troops
great
majority
noncombat
positions
must
filled
men
ready
rotated
combat
absolute
number
positions
women
eligible
small
de
minimis
moment
equal
protection
purposes
especially
light
administrative
burdens
involved
registering
women
suitable
age
sense
least
record
us
number
women
used
military
without
sacrificing
combat
readiness
small
insubstantial
administrative
convenience
sufficient
justification
kind
outright
discrimination
involved
registering
conscripting
men
women
understand
record
order
secure
personnel
needs
mobilization
government
rely
volunteers
must
register
draft
fill
combat
positions
noncombat
positions
must
filled
men
also
secure
personnel
needed
jobs
performed
persons
ineligible
combat
without
diminishing
military
effectiveness
claim
providing
latter
category
positions
congress
free
register
draft
men
discern
adequate
justification
kind
discrimination
men
women
accordingly
due
respect
dissent
justice
marshall
justice
brennan
joins
dissenting
today
places
imprimatur
one
potent
remaining
public
expressions
ancient
canards
proper
role
women
phillips
martin
marietta
marshall
concurring
upholds
statute
requires
males
females
register
draft
thereby
categorically
excludes
women
fundamental
civic
obligation
believe
decision
inconsistent
constitution
guarantee
equal
protection
laws
dissent
background
litigation
set
opinion
ante
repeat
discussion
bears
emphasis
however
question
presented
case
whether
exclusion
women
registration
military
selective
service
act
app
et
seq
ed
supp
iii
mssa
contravenes
equal
protection
component
due
process
clause
fifth
amendment
although
purpose
registration
assist
preparations
drafting
civilians
military
asked
rule
constitutionality
statute
governing
conscription
advent
armed
forces
mssa
specifically
amended
preclude
conscription
july
pub
stat
app
reactivation
draft
therefore
require
legislative
amendment
see
consequently
called
upon
decide
whether
either
men
women
drafted
whether
must
drafted
equal
numbers
order
drafted
inducted
trained
respective
functions
addition
case
involve
challenge
statutes
policies
prohibit
female
members
armed
forces
serving
combat
understanding
turn
task
hand
clear
statutes
like
mssa
discriminate
basis
gender
must
examined
heightened
scrutiny
mandated
craig
boren
test
classification
withstand
constitutional
challenge
unless
classification
substantially
related
achievement
important
governmental
objective
kirchberg
feenstra
wengler
druggist
mutual
ins
califano
westcott
orr
orr
craig
boren
supra
test
applies
whether
classification
discriminates
males
females
caban
mohammed
orr
orr
supra
craig
boren
supra
party
defending
challenged
classification
carries
burden
demonstrating
importance
governmental
objective
serves
substantial
relationship
discriminatory
means
asserted
end
see
wengler
druggist
mutual
ins
supra
caban
mohammed
supra
craig
boren
supra
consequently
sustain
mssa
government
must
demonstrate
classification
employs
bears
close
substantial
relationship
achievement
important
governmental
objectives
personnel
administrator
massachusetts
feeney
mssa
adequate
armed
strength
must
achieved
maintained
insure
security
nation
app
agree
majority
ante
one
deny
government
interest
raising
supporting
armies
important
governmental
interest
consequently
first
part
craig
boren
test
satisfied
question
remains
whether
discriminatory
means
employed
substantially
serves
statutory
end
concluding
correctly
notes
congress
enacted
reactivated
mssa
pursuant
constitutional
authority
raise
maintain
armies
majority
also
notes
ante
accords
great
weight
decisions
congress
quoting
columbia
broadcasting
system
democratic
national
committee
accorded
particular
deference
decisions
arising
context
congress
authority
military
affairs
particular
quarrel
sentiments
majority
opinion
simply
add
even
area
military
affairs
deference
congressional
judgments
allowed
shade
abdication
ultimate
responsibility
decide
constitutional
questions
pointed
phrase
war
power
invoked
talismanic
incantation
support
exercise
congressional
power
brought
within
ambit
ven
war
power
remove
constitutional
limitations
safeguarding
essential
liberties
robel
quoting
home
bldg
loan
assn
blaisdell
one
safeguar
essential
liberties
fifth
amendment
guarantee
equal
protection
laws
federal
law
classifies
basis
gender
challenged
violating
constitutional
guarantee
ultimately
congress
decide
whether
exists
constitutionally
required
close
substantial
relationship
discriminatory
means
employed
asserted
governmental
objective
see
powell
mccormack
baker
carr
judgment
simply
basis
concluding
case
excluding
women
registration
substantially
related
achievement
concededly
important
governmental
interest
maintaining
effective
defense
reaches
contrary
conclusion
using
nnounced
degre
deference
legislative
judgmen
facile
abstractio
justify
result
ante
ii
government
defend
exclusion
women
registration
ground
preventing
women
serving
military
substantially
related
effectiveness
armed
forces
indeed
successful
experience
women
serving
branches
armed
services
belie
claim
women
volunteers
presently
active
service
military
number
expected
increase
see
department
defense
authorization
appropriations
fiscal
year
hearings
senate
committee
armed
services
senate
hearings
women
military
hearings
military
personnel
subcommittee
house
committee
armed
services
women
military
hearings
congressional
hearings
representatives
department
defense
armed
services
testified
participation
women
armed
forces
contributed
substantially
military
effectiveness
see
senate
hearings
yerks
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
women
military
hearings
assistant
secretary
defense
pirie
congress
never
disagreed
judgment
military
experts
women
made
significant
contributions
effectiveness
military
contrary
congress
repeatedly
praised
performance
female
members
armed
forces
approved
efforts
armed
services
expand
role
last
year
senate
armed
services
committee
declared
women
volunteer
military
service
assigned
military
specialties
volunteers
make
important
contribution
armed
forces
number
women
military
increased
significantly
past
years
expected
continue
increase
authoritative
discussion
congress
reasons
declining
require
registration
women
contained
report
prepared
senate
armed
services
committee
fiscal
year
defense
authorization
bill
supra
report
findings
endorsed
conferees
authorization
bill
see
conf
houses
congress
subsequently
adopted
findings
passing
conference
report
cong
rec
majority
notes
ante
report
findings
effect
findings
entire
congress
senate
report
sets
objectives
congress
sought
accomplish
excluding
women
registration
see
supra
may
appropriately
look
report
evaluating
justification
discrimination
according
senate
report
policy
precluding
use
women
combat
important
reason
including
women
registration
system
supra
see
also
supra
reaffirming
combat
restrictions
report
declared
registering
women
assignment
combat
assigning
women
combat
positions
peacetime
leave
actual
performance
sexually
mixed
units
experiment
conducted
war
unknown
risk
risk
committee
finds
militarily
unwarranted
dangerous
moreover
committee
feels
attempt
assign
women
combat
positions
affect
national
resolve
time
mobilization
time
great
strain
aspects
nation
resources
supra
opinion
offers
different
though
related
explanation
relationship
combat
restrictions
congress
decision
require
registration
women
majority
congress
clearly
linked
need
renewed
registration
views
character
subsequent
draft
ante
also
congress
determined
future
draft
facilitated
registration
scheme
characterized
need
combat
troops
ante
reasons
since
women
eligible
assignment
combat
congress
decision
exclude
registration
unconstitutional
discrimination
inasmuch
en
women
combat
restrictions
women
simply
similarly
situated
purposes
draft
registration
draft
ante
certain
logic
reasoning
approach
fundamentally
flawed
first
place
although
purports
apply
craig
boren
test
similarly
situated
analysis
employs
fact
significantly
different
craig
boren
approach
compare
kirchberg
feenstra
employing
craig
boren
test
stewart
concurring
result
employing
similarly
situated
analysis
essentially
reasons
gender
classification
employed
mssa
constitutionally
permissible
nondiscrimination
necessary
achieve
purpose
registration
prepare
draft
combat
troops
words
majority
concludes
women
may
excluded
registration
needed
event
draft
analysis
however
focuses
wrong
question
relevant
inquiry
craig
boren
test
whether
classification
substantially
advance
important
governmental
interests
rather
question
whether
classification
substantially
related
achievement
asserted
governmental
interest
thus
government
task
case
demonstrate
excluding
women
registration
substantially
furthers
goal
preparing
draft
combat
troops
put
another
way
government
must
show
registering
women
substantially
impede
efforts
prepare
draft
precedents
government
meet
burden
without
showing
statute
less
effective
means
attaining
end
see
wengler
druggists
mutual
ins
explained
orr
orr
emphasis
added
legislative
classifications
distribute
benefits
burdens
basis
gender
carry
inherent
risk
reinforcing
sexual
stereotypes
proper
place
women
need
special
protection
government
purposes
well
served
classification
one
gender
classifies
therefore
carries
baggage
sexual
stereotypes
government
permitted
classify
basis
sex
fact
registering
women
way
obstructs
governmental
interest
preparing
draft
combat
troops
points
second
flaw
analysis
essentially
reduces
question
constitutionality
registration
validity
hypothetical
program
conscripting
men
posits
draft
conscripts
either
assigned
specific
combat
posts
presently
closed
women
must
available
rotation
positions
able
conclude
registering
women
gestur
superficial
equality
ante
since
women
necessarily
ineligible
every
position
filled
hypothetical
draft
indeed
guaranteed
advance
conscription
reimposed
congress
circumstances
form
conscripts
trained
assigned
combat
combat
rotation
positions
women
categorically
excluded
argued
registration
women
pointless
course
guarantee
possible
certainly
nothing
mssa
limits
congress
reinstituting
draft
circumstances
example
congress
may
decide
armed
forces
inadequate
meet
nation
defense
needs
even
times
peace
reinstitute
peacetime
conscription
event
hypothetical
draft
relied
sustain
mssa
classification
presumably
little
relevance
forced
declare
registration
program
unconstitutional
difficulty
comes
congress
lost
sight
important
distinction
registration
conscription
registration
provides
inventory
available
strength
within
military
qualified
pool
country
reinstitution
procedures
registration
military
selective
service
act
hearing
subcommittee
manpower
personnel
senate
armed
services
committee
selective
service
hearings
statement
rogers
conscription
supplies
military
personnel
needed
respond
particular
exigency
fact
registration
first
step
conscription
process
mean
registration
law
expressly
discriminating
men
women
may
justified
valid
conscription
program
retrospect
make
current
discrimination
appear
functionally
related
program
emerged
even
addressing
reasoning
terms
analysis
flawed
entire
argument
rests
premise
demonstrably
false
noted
majority
simply
assumes
registration
prepares
draft
every
draftee
must
available
assignment
combat
majority
draft
scenario
finds
support
either
testimony
congress
importantly
findings
senate
report
indeed
scenario
appears
exist
imagination
even
government
represents
event
mobilization
approximately
demand
induction
system
combat
skills
brief
appellant
emphasis
added
part
rather
join
imagining
hypothetical
drafts
prefer
examine
findings
senate
report
testimony
presented
congress
nothing
senate
report
supports
intimation
women
must
excluded
registration
combat
eligibility
prerequisite
positions
need
filled
event
draft
senate
report
concluded
mobilization
ordered
wartime
scenario
primary
manpower
need
combat
replacements
emphasis
added
conclusion
keeping
testimony
presented
congressional
hearings
department
defense
indicated
event
mobilization
requiring
reinstitution
draft
primary
manpower
requirement
combat
troops
support
personnel
readily
deployed
combat
see
senate
hearings
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
army
clark
yerks
department
indicated
conscripts
also
needed
staff
variety
support
positions
prerequisite
combat
eligibility
therefore
filled
women
assistant
secretary
defense
manpower
reserve
affairs
logistics
pirie
explained
need
expand
combat
arms
said
pressing
need
also
need
expand
support
establishment
time
allow
combat
arms
carry
function
successfully
support
establishment
uses
women
effectively
wartime
think
true
registration
women
hearing
subcommittee
military
personnel
house
committee
armed
services
house
hearings
interest
national
security
emergency
requiring
conscription
military
service
nation
youth
best
qualified
people
wide
variety
tasks
armed
forces
available
performance
women
armed
forces
today
strongly
supports
conclusion
many
best
qualified
people
military
jobs
age
category
women
conclusion
good
reasons
registering
women
conclusion
even
strongly
good
reasons
refusing
register
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
emphasis
added
background
testimony
congressional
hearings
focused
projections
manpower
needs
event
emergency
requiring
reinstitution
draft
particular
role
women
draft
make
discussion
concrete
testimony
examined
draft
scenario
dealing
personnel
requirements
first
six
months
mobilization
response
major
war
europe
defense
department
indicated
three
constraints
maximum
number
women
armed
services
use
event
mobilization
legislative
prohibitions
use
women
certain
military
positions
policy
reserve
certain
assignments
ground
combat
roles
men
need
reserve
substantial
number
noncombat
positions
men
order
provide
pool
ready
replacements
ground
combat
positions
house
hearings
assistant
secretary
pirie
mobilization
present
best
projection
use
women
jobs
inducting
people
reason
jobs
indeed
jobs
support
related
combat
related
think
women
fill
jobs
quite
well
senate
hearings
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
women
subject
draft
department
defense
determine
maximum
number
women
used
armed
forces
subject
existing
constraints
needs
military
services
provide
close
combat
fillers
replacements
quickly
estimate
might
require
least
additional
women
first
six
months
enough
women
volunteers
separate
draft
call
women
issued
review
findings
contained
senate
report
testimony
presented
congressional
hearings
demonstrates
basis
representation
women
ineligible
positions
need
filled
event
draft
testimony
personnel
requirements
event
draft
established
women
fill
least
positions
conscripts
inducted
thus
respect
positions
statutes
policies
barring
women
combat
provide
reason
distinguishing
male
female
potential
conscripts
two
groups
majority
parlance
similarly
situated
combat
restrictions
supply
constitutionally
required
justification
mssa
classification
since
classification
precludes
women
drafted
fill
positions
qualified
useful
government
must
demonstrate
excluding
women
positions
substantially
related
achievement
important
governmental
objective
iii
government
argues
however
consistent
testimony
congress
effect
military
need
draft
women
brief
appellant
emphasis
original
government
points
statement
senate
report
oth
civilian
military
leadership
agreed
military
need
draft
women
argument
registration
induction
women
based
military
necessity
considerations
equity
accepting
government
contention
asserts
president
decision
seek
authority
register
women
based
equity
concludes
congress
certainly
entitled
exercise
constitutional
powers
raise
regulate
armies
navies
focus
question
military
need
rather
equity
ante
view
careful
examination
concepts
equity
military
need
required
previously
noted
defense
department
recommendation
women
included
registration
plans
based
conclusion
drafting
limited
number
women
consistent
contribute
military
effectiveness
see
supra
background
military
experts
concluded
equity
favored
registration
women
assistant
secretary
pirie
explained
since
women
proven
serve
successfully
volunteers
armed
forces
equity
suggests
liable
serve
draftees
conscription
reinstated
house
hearings
report
stated
oth
civilian
military
leadership
agreed
military
need
draft
women
supra
examination
civilian
military
leadership
meant
military
need
therefore
provide
insight
report
use
term
several
witnesses
testified
personnel
requirements
event
mobilization
met
drafting
men
including
women
draft
plans
military
necessity
example
assistant
secretary
defense
pirie
stated
doubtful
female
draft
justified
argument
wartime
personnel
requirements
met
without
pool
draft
eligible
men
sufficiently
large
meet
projected
wartime
requirements
house
hearings
believe
need
draft
women
peacetime
wartime
large
numbers
young
men
available
approximately
million
males
year
group
draft
age
population
military
necessity
draft
females
except
possibly
doctors
health
professionals
insufficient
volunteers
people
skills
may
however
senate
report
allusion
military
need
meant
convey
congress
expectation
women
volunteers
make
unnecessary
draft
women
majority
apparently
accepts
meaning
congress
also
concluded
whatever
need
women
noncombat
roles
mobilization
whether
less
met
volunteers
ante
since
purpose
registration
protect
unanticipated
shortages
volunteers
difficult
see
excluding
women
registration
justified
conjectures
expected
number
female
volunteers
fail
see
exclusion
pool
persons
conscripted
needed
justified
reference
current
supply
volunteers
event
defense
department
best
estimate
event
mobilization
requiring
reinstitution
draft
enough
women
volunteers
fill
positions
women
eligible
department
told
congress
mobilization
present
best
projection
use
women
jobs
inducting
people
senate
hearings
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
emphasis
added
iv
recognizing
need
go
beyond
military
need
argument
asserts
congress
determined
staffing
noncombat
positions
women
mobilization
positively
detrimental
important
goal
military
flexibility
ante
none
deny
preserving
military
flexibility
important
governmental
interest
justify
exclusion
women
registration
draft
ground
must
showing
staffing
even
limited
number
positions
women
impede
military
flexibility
find
nothing
senate
report
provide
basis
representation
congress
believed
case
senate
report
concluded
military
reasons
preclude
large
numbers
women
serving
emphasis
added
report
went
explain
military
flexibility
requires
commander
able
move
units
ships
quickly
units
ships
located
front
previously
scheduled
front
nevertheless
must
able
move
action
necessary
peace
war
significant
rotation
personnel
necessary
divide
military
two
groups
one
permanent
combat
one
permanent
support
large
numbers
positions
must
available
combat
troops
return
duty
redeployed
ibid
women
subject
draft
department
defense
determine
maximum
number
women
used
armed
forces
subject
existing
constraints
needs
military
services
provide
close
combat
fillers
replacements
quickly
estimate
might
require
least
additional
women
first
months
house
hearings
emphasis
added
similarly
reason
induction
limited
number
female
draftees
divide
military
permanent
combat
permanent
support
groups
presently
case
armed
forces
combat
restrictions
prevent
female
draftee
serving
combat
combat
rotation
position
also
apply
women
volunteers
armed
services
presence
increasing
controlled
numbers
female
volunteers
unacceptably
divide
military
two
groups
difficult
see
induction
similarly
limited
additional
number
women
accomplish
result
circumstances
agree
attempt
interpret
senate
report
conclusion
drafting
large
numbers
women
impair
military
flexibility
proof
congress
reached
entirely
different
conclusion
drafting
limited
number
women
adversely
affect
military
flexibility
senate
report
recognized
military
flexibility
objective
speaks
question
whether
large
numbers
women
drafted
report
went
state
suggested
women
registered
handful
actually
inducted
emergency
committee
finds
confused
ultimately
unsatisfactory
solution
first
president
proposal
require
registration
women
include
change
section
mssa
requires
draft
conducted
impartially
among
eligible
administration
witnesses
admitted
current
language
law
probably
precludes
induction
women
men
random
basis
produce
roughly
equal
numbers
men
women
second
conceivable
courts
faced
congressional
decision
register
men
women
equally
equity
considerations
find
insufficient
justification
inducting
token
number
women
services
emergency
emphasis
original
create
monumental
strains
training
system
clog
personnel
administration
support
systems
needlessly
impede
defense
preparations
time
great
national
need
administrative
problems
housing
different
treatment
regard
dependency
hardship
physical
standards
also
exist
specific
finding
senate
report
law
required
women
drafted
equal
numbers
men
mobilization
severely
impaired
strains
training
facilities
administrative
systems
supra
emphasis
added
however
suggestion
congressional
hearings
simultaneous
induction
equal
numbers
males
female
conscripts
either
necessary
desirable
defense
department
recommended
women
included
registration
draft
plans
number
female
draftees
timing
induction
determined
military
personnel
requirements
see
supra
endorsing
plan
department
gave
indication
draft
place
strains
training
administrative
facilities
moreover
director
selective
service
system
testified
registration
induction
process
including
males
females
present
administrative
problems
see
senate
hearings
bernard
rostker
app
deposition
bernard
rostker
senate
report
simply
failed
consider
possibility
limited
number
women
drafted
conclusion
mssa
authorize
drafting
different
numbers
men
women
speculation
judicial
reaction
decision
register
women
since
congress
free
amend
indeed
undertake
new
legislation
authorize
draft
matter
end
furthermore
senate
report
speculation
statute
authorizing
differential
induction
male
female
draftees
vulnerable
constitutional
challenge
unfounded
unchallenged
restrictions
assignment
women
combat
need
preserve
military
flexibility
factors
discussed
senate
report
provide
ample
grounds
concluding
discriminatory
means
employed
statute
substantially
related
achievement
important
governmental
objectives
since
congress
amended
authorize
differential
induction
men
women
based
military
personnel
requirements
senate
report
discussion
added
burdens
result
drafting
equal
numbers
male
female
draftees
provides
basis
concluding
total
exclusion
women
registration
draft
plans
substantially
related
achievement
important
governmental
objectives
sum
neither
senate
report
testimony
presented
congressional
hearings
provides
support
conclusion
seeks
attribute
report
drafting
limited
number
women
number
timing
induction
training
determined
military
personnel
requirements
burden
training
administrative
facilities
vi
reviewing
discussion
findings
contained
senate
report
able
say
report
demonstrates
drafting
large
numbers
women
frustrate
achievement
number
important
governmental
objectives
relate
ultimate
goal
maintaining
adequate
armed
strength
insure
security
nation
app
put
another
way
senate
report
establishes
induction
large
number
men
limited
number
women
determined
military
personnel
requirements
substantially
related
important
governmental
interests
discussion
findings
senate
report
enable
government
carry
burden
demonstrating
completely
excluding
women
draft
excluding
registration
substantially
furthers
important
governmental
objectives
concluding
government
carried
burden
case
adopts
appropriately
deferential
examination
congress
evaluation
evidence
ante
emphasis
original
majority
proceeds
supplement
congress
actual
findings
apparently
believes
congress
made
beyond
substitutes
hollow
shibboleths
deference
legislative
decisions
constitutional
analysis
majority
lost
sight
fact
responsibility
act
ultimate
interpreter
constitution
powell
mccormack
see
baker
carr
congressional
enactments
area
military
affairs
must
like
laws
judged
standards
constitution
constitution
law
land
legislation
must
conform
principles
lays
pointed
phrase
war
power
invoked
talismanic
incantation
support
exercise
congressional
power
brought
within
ambit
robel
furthermore
hen
appears
act
congress
conflicts
constitutional
provisio
choice
enforce
paramount
commands
constitution
sworn
less
push
back
limits
constitution
merely
accommodate
challenged
legislation
trop
dulles
plurality
opinion
instances
since
established
determined
congressional
action
exceeded
bounds
constitution
believe
true
statute
attempt
avoid
constitutional
obligation
today
pushes
back
limits
constitution
accommodate
act
congress
affirm
judgment
district
given
lengthy
discourse
background
litigation
interesting
chooses
bury
sole
reference
fact
see
ante
statute
female
members
air
force
navy
may
assigned
vessels
aircraft
engaged
combat
missions
see
supp
iii
although
statutory
restrictions
assignment
women
combat
army
marine
corps
services
established
policies
preclude
assignment
appellees
concede
constitutional
validity
restrictions
women
combat
taken
position
validity
irrelevant
purposes
case
join
see
ante
rejecting
solicitor
general
suggestion
classification
employed
mssa
scrutinized
rational
relationship
test
used
reviewing
challenges
certain
types
social
economic
legislation
see
schweiker
wilson
railroad
retirement
bd
fritz
consequently
moment
constitutional
challenge
case
pressed
men
claim
mssa
gender
classification
discriminates
constitution
grants
congress
power
raise
support
armies
provide
maintain
navy
make
rules
government
regulation
land
naval
forces
art
cls
although
fifth
amendment
contains
equal
protection
clause
held
fifth
amendment
due
process
clause
prohibits
federal
government
engaging
discrimination
unjustifiable
violative
due
process
schlesinger
ballard
quoting
bolling
sharpe
repeal
statute
limiting
number
female
members
armed
forces
total
enlisted
strength
number
women
military
risen
steadily
absolute
terms
percentage
total
active
military
personnel
percentage
risen
expected
rise
see
dept
defense
use
women
military
ed
reprinted
app
binkin
bach
women
military
summarizing
testimony
presented
congressional
hearings
senator
cohen
stated
asically
evidence
come
committee
participation
women
force
worked
well
praised
every
military
officer
testified
committee
jobs
performed
cases
superior
skill
senate
hearings
noted
see
supra
appellees
elected
challenge
constitutionality
combat
restrictions
thought
logical
conclusion
reasoning
fact
discrimination
women
case
one
must
wonder
feels
compelled
pledge
purported
fealty
craig
boren
test
alternatively
government
employ
classification
related
statutory
objective
based
gender
example
combat
eligibility
current
scheme
large
subgroups
male
population
ineligible
combat
physical
handicaps
conscientious
objector
status
nonetheless
required
register
quotes
senator
warner
comment
equate
registration
draft
ante
whole
senator
warner
statement
merits
quotation
explains
congress
refused
acknowledge
distinction
registration
draft
senator
warner
stated
frankly
equate
registration
draft
way
establish
registration
law
coequal
basis
turn
right
around
establish
draft
law
nonequal
basis
think
knock
right
away
senate
hearings
pirie
explained
reasoning
behind
defense
department
conclusion
terms
large
numbers
military
women
work
occupations
electronics
communications
navigation
radar
repair
jet
engine
mechanics
drafting
surveying
ordnance
transportation
meteorology
effectively
shown
numerous
dod
studies
tests
work
women
armed
forces
today
essential
readiness
capability
forces
case
war
still
true
number
women
similar
work
inevitably
expand
beyond
peacetime
number
women
traditionally
held
vast
majority
jobs
fields
health
advantage
registration
women
pool
trained
personnel
traditionally
female
jobs
exist
event
sufficient
volunteers
available
make
far
greater
sense
include
women
draft
call
thereby
gain
many
skills
draft
males
require
training
fields
drafted
employment
jobs
traditionally
held
females
advantage
release
males
currently
holding
noncombatant
jobs
reassignment
combat
jobs
house
hearings
defense
department
arrived
number
surveyed
military
services
asked
many
women
use
event
mobilization
received
answers
suggesting
use
senate
hearings
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
colloquy
senator
jepsen
principal
deputy
assistant
secretary
defense
danzig
reveals
members
congress
understood
military
need
sense
danzig
surveyed
military
services
asked
many
women
use
among
received
answers
suggesting
use
let
indicate
say
use
mean
imply
use
women
department
defense
view
women
useful
mobilization
scenario
women
available
think
republic
crumble
men
used
instead
senator
jepsen
explicit
military
requirement
involved
danzig
problem
senator
mean
semantic
use
words
explicit
requirement
said
example
military
require
people
brown
eyes
serve
tell
people
blue
eyes
et
cetera
job
hand
deny
job
find
useful
senate
hearings
see
deputy
assistant
attorney
general
simms
explained
much
congress
testimony
hearings
stated
question
military
necessity
drafting
women
irrelevant
constitutional
issue
whether
sufficient
justification
whatever
test
courts
may
apply
registering
women
assign
appellees
burden
prior
scrutiny
equal
protection
decisions
drawn
question
announcing
new
approach
party
challenging
classification
burden
showing
elimination
classification
substantially
furthers
important
governmental
interest
assistant
secretary
defense
pirie
explained
perhaps
sufficient
women
volunteers
come
forward
meet
need
perhaps
young
women
register
advance
put
us
position
call
women
volunteer
sufficient
numbers
quoted
cong
rec
past
wartime
recruitment
experience
bear
sanguine
view
advent
korean
war
unsuccessful
effort
made
recruit
women
meet
rapidly
expanding
manpower
requirements
see
use
women
military
supra
app
colloquy
representative
hillis
assistant
secretary
defense
pirie
house
hearings
makes
clear
number
addition
number
women
serving
armed
forces
pirie
hillis
estimate
need
individuals
inducted
first
six
months
hillis
many
women
pirie
least
individuals
women
hillis
hillis
even
women
active
service
expected
talking
another
projects
pirie
yes
sir
house
hearings
senator
warner
questioned
service
chiefs
impact
service
consequence
draft
based
total
provision
equality
male
female
selective
service
hearings
emphasis
added
two
service
chiefs
answered
senator
warner
question
effect
draft
equal
numbers
men
women
answers
merit
quotation
general
allen
air
force
unfavorable
effect
air
force
objection
draft
ibid
general
wilson
marine
corps
perfectly
happy
women
drafted
percent
goal
believe
handle
marine
corps
ibid
report
explained
congress
mandate
equal
registration
men
women
therefore
might
well
faced
situation
combat
replacements
needed
first
days
say
men
accompanied
women
faced
hypothetical
military
witnesses
stated
situation
intolerable
stated
senate
report
selective
service
plans
provide
drafting
men
first
days
small
number
women
included
total
drafted
first
days