wade
hunter
argued
march
decided
april
rehearing
denied
may
see
wade
hunter
brewster
kansas
city
snyder
kansas
city
petitioner
oscar
davis
washington
respondent
justice
black
delivered
opinion
fifth
amendment
constitution
provides
person
shall
twice
put
jeopardy
life
limb
offense
petitioner
prison
conviction
serious
offense
contends
entitled
freedom
another
martial
previously
put
jeopardy
offense
first
dissolved
convening
authority
reached
decision
government
contends
fifth
amendment
provision
applicable
military
courts
bar
second
conviction
government
views
record
dissolution
first
dictated
pressing
military
tactical
situation
circumstances
contentions
arise
follows
march
american
troops
infantry
division
entered
krov
germany
next
afternoon
two
german
women
raped
two
men
american
uniforms
several
days
later
petitioner
another
american
soldier
arrested
upon
charges
committed
offenses
two
weeks
later
march
troops
advanced
miles
farther
germany
place
called
pfalzfeld
date
pfalzfeld
petitioner
soldier
put
trial
general
convened
order
commanding
general
infantry
division
division
two
soldiers
attached
hearing
evidence
arguments
counsel
closed
consider
case
later
day
reopened
announced
continued
later
date
fixed
judge
advocate
reason
continuance
desire
hear
witnesses
available
deciding
guilt
innocence
accused
week
later
commanding
general
division
withdrew
charges
directing
take
proceedings
general
transmitted
charges
commanding
general
third
army
recommendations
trial
new
reason
transferring
charges
explained
communication
commanding
general
third
army
case
previously
referred
trial
general
trial
commenced
two
witnesses
mother
father
victim
alleged
rape
unable
present
due
sickness
continued
case
testimony
obtained
due
tactical
situation
distance
residence
witnesses
become
great
case
compl
ted
within
reasonable
time
commanding
general
third
army
concluded
situation
command
distance
krov
made
impracticable
third
army
conduct
accordingly
turn
transmitted
charges
fifteenth
army
stating
action
necessary
carry
policy
american
army
europe
accelerate
prompt
trials
immediate
vicinity
alleged
offenses
pursuant
transmittal
fifteenth
army
commanding
general
convened
point
forty
miles
krov
petitioner
represented
counsel
filed
plea
bar
alleging
put
jeopardy
first
martial
proceedings
tried
plea
overruled
case
tried
conviction
followed
sentenced
dishonorable
discharge
forfeiture
pay
allowances
life
imprisonment
imprisonment
later
reduced
twenty
years
exhausting
right
military
review
petitioner
brought
habeas
corpus
proceeding
federal
district
ordered
release
holding
plea
former
jeopardy
sustained
appeals
reversed
one
judge
dissenting
hold
circumstances
shown
fifth
amendment
provision
bar
petitioner
trial
second
interpretation
application
fifth
amendment
jeopardy
provision
bene
considered
chiefly
civil
rather
military
proceedings
past
cases
decided
defendant
put
trial
jury
may
subjected
kind
bars
second
trial
offense
even
though
trial
discontinued
without
verdict
see
kepner
cf
palko
connecticut
may
true
judge
trying
case
without
jury
fails
reason
enter
judgment
mccarthy
zerbst
provision
fifth
amendment
however
mean
every
time
defendant
put
trial
competent
tribunal
entitled
go
free
trial
fails
end
final
judgment
rule
create
insuperable
obstacle
administration
justice
many
cases
semblance
type
oppressive
practices
prohibition
aimed
may
unforeseeable
circumstances
arise
trial
making
completion
impossible
failure
jury
agree
verdict
event
purpose
law
protect
society
guilty
crimes
frequently
frustrated
denying
courts
power
put
defendant
trial
instances
trial
judge
discovered
facts
trial
indicated
one
members
jury
might
biased
government
defendant
settled
duty
judge
event
discharge
jury
direct
retrial
said
enough
show
defendant
valued
right
trial
completed
particular
tribunal
must
instances
subordinated
public
interest
fair
trials
designed
end
judgments
justice
requires
particular
trial
discontinued
question
decided
persons
conversant
factors
relevant
determination
guiding
rule
federal
courts
determining
trials
discontinued
outlined
perez
wheat
case
trial
judge
without
consent
defendant
government
discharged
jury
members
unable
agree
defendant
claimed
tried
prayed
discharge
matter
right
answering
claim
said
wheat
page
think
cases
nature
law
invested
courts
justice
authority
discharge
jury
giving
verdict
whenever
opinion
taking
circumstances
consideration
manifest
necessity
act
ends
public
justice
otherwise
defeated
exercise
sound
discretion
subject
impossible
define
circumstances
render
proper
interfere
sure
power
used
greatest
caution
urgent
circumstances
plain
obvious
causes
capital
cases
especially
courts
extremely
careful
interfere
chances
life
favour
prisoner
right
order
discharge
security
public
faithful
sound
conscientious
exercise
discretion
rests
cases
upon
responsibility
judges
oaths
office
rule
announced
perez
case
basis
later
decisions
double
jeopardy
attempts
lay
rigid
formula
rule
trial
discontinued
particular
circumstances
manifest
necessity
failure
discontinue
defeat
ends
justice
see
reason
broad
test
applied
deciding
whether
action
runs
counter
fifth
amendment
provision
double
jeopardy
measured
perez
rule
adhere
petitioner
second
trial
kind
double
jeopardy
within
intent
fifth
amendment
claim
went
beyond
powers
temporarily
continuing
trial
obtain
benefit
witnesses
district
viewed
record
showing
purpose
dissolving
get
witnesses
purpose
district
held
kind
necessity
came
within
recognized
exception
provision
see
cornero
urged
apply
cornero
interpretation
necessity
rule
asked
adopt
cornero
rule
petitioner
contends
absence
witnesses
never
justify
discontinuance
trial
rigid
formula
inconsistent
guiding
principles
perez
decision
adhere
principles
command
courts
considering
whether
trial
terminated
without
judgment
take
circumstances
account
thereby
forbid
mechanical
application
abstract
formula
value
perez
principles
thus
lies
capacity
informed
application
widely
different
circumstances
without
injury
defendants
public
interest
furthermore
record
sufficient
show
tactical
situation
brought
rapidly
advancing
army
responsible
withdrawal
charges
first
appears
first
order
transmittal
charges
order
made
commanding
general
division
responsible
convening
also
responsible
effective
military
employment
division
carrying
plan
invasion
germany
intimation
record
tactical
situation
require
transfer
order
composed
officers
invading
army
division
momentous
issues
hung
invasion
assume
officers
needed
perform
military
functions
perez
case
said
sound
discretion
presiding
judge
accepted
necessity
discontinuing
trial
case
presents
extraordinary
reasons
judgment
commanding
general
accepted
courts
least
absence
charges
bad
faith
part
commanding
general
courts
attempt
review
decision
tactical
situation
required
transfer
charges
affirmed
justice
murphy
justice
douglas
justice
rutledge
agree
dissenting
agree
military
courts
civil
jeopardy
within
meaning
fifth
amendment
attaches
begins
hearing
evidence
agree
also
valid
charge
pending
first
concerned
jurisdiction
person
petitioner
first
evidence
introduced
fact
sides
completed
presentation
cases
submitted
oral
argument
closed
consider
decision
later
opened
motion
purpose
hearing
testimony
three
named
witnesses
expected
shed
light
question
identification
commanding
general
unit
comprising
petitioner
trying
withdrew
charges
dissolved
transmitted
papers
commanding
general
third
army
recommendation
trial
eneral
subsequently
transferred
commanding
general
fifteenth
army
referred
case
trial
general
petitioner
tried
convicted
overruled
plea
former
jeopardy
based
prior
proceeding
commanding
general
fifteenth
army
recommendation
staff
judge
advocate
approved
finding
guilty
reduced
period
confinement
life
twenty
years
case
assigned
review
board
review
consisting
three
judge
advocates
branch
office
judge
advocate
general
european
theater
board
sitting
paris
close
scene
military
operations
filed
unanimous
opinion
effect
plea
bar
consequently
record
trial
legally
insufficient
support
findings
sentence
assistant
judge
advocate
general
filed
dissenting
opinion
sentence
confirmed
commanding
general
european
theater
habeas
corpus
proceedings
district
agreed
board
review
plea
double
jeopardy
sustained
appeals
reversed
one
judge
dissenting
doubt
wade
placed
jeopardy
first
trial
holds
decision
commanding
officer
assessing
tactical
military
situation
sufficient
deprive
right
constitution
free
twice
subjected
trial
offense
reading
constitution
agree
harassment
defendant
repeatedly
tried
less
army
advancing
guarantee
constitution
double
jeopardy
eroded
away
tide
appearing
exceptions
command
fifth
amendment
allow
temporizing
basic
rights
declares
adaptations
military
justice
exigencies
tactical
situations
prerogative
commander
field
price
expediency
compliance
constitution
reverse
judgment
footnotes
charges
article
war
member
desires
witnesses
called
case
allow
time
secure
witnesses
case
continued
like
witnesses
brought
parents
person
making
accusation
rosa
glowsky
also
room
assist
identification
identity
accused
continued
later
date
set
rial
udge
dvocate
soldier
acquitted
acting
army
judge
advocate
reviewing
petitioner
conviction
said
witnesses
german
positively
identified
accused
wade
witnesses
failed
identify
soldier
holding
circumstances
fifth
amendment
bar
trial
second
makes
unnecessary
consider
following
questions
discussed
government
brief
extent
overruling
plea
former
jeopardy
subject
collateral
attack
habeas
corpus
proceedings
see
carter
mcclaughry
cf
grafton
sunal
large
cases
collected
page
validity
fortieth
article
war
stat
article
provides
part
follows
person
shall
without
consent
tried
second
time
offense
proeeding
accused
found
guilty
upon
charge
specification
shall
held
trial
sense
article
reviewing
one
confirming
authority
shall
taken
final
action
upon
case
simmons
thompson
see
simmons
logan
keerl
montana
lovato
new
mexico
manual
par
recommends
evidence
appears
insufficient
proper
determination
issue
matter
may
ordinarily
take
appropriate
action
view
obtaining
available
additional
evidence
necessary
advisable
determination
may
instance
require
trial
judge
advocate
recall
witness
summon
new
witnesses
make
investigation
inquiry
along
certain
lines
view
discovering
producing
additional
evidence
opinion
board
review
reads
part
follows
see
nothing
renders
absence
witnesses
shown
record
trial
case
emergent
situation
exception
rule
federal
courts
witnesses
may
lie
beyond
reach
process
process
issues
witnesses
may
respond
oral
promises
appear
may
kept
may
become
ill
trial
difficulties
proof
grounds
termination
trial
second
prosecution
imperious
necessity
means
sudden
overwhelming
emergency
uncontrollable
unforeseeable
infecting
judicial
process
rendering
fair
impartial
trial
impossible
mean
expediency
transcript
record