verlinden
central
bank
nigeria
argued
january
decided
may
contract
federal
republic
nigeria
petitioner
dutch
corporation
purchase
cement
nigeria
provided
nigeria
establish
confirmed
letter
credit
purchase
price
subsequently
petitioner
sued
respondent
bank
instrumentality
nigeria
federal
district
alleging
certain
actions
respondent
constituted
anticipatory
breach
letter
credit
petitioner
alleged
jurisdiction
provision
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
act
granting
federal
district
courts
jurisdiction
without
regard
amount
controversy
nonjury
civil
action
foreign
state
claim
relief
personam
respect
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
either
sections
title
applicable
international
agreement
district
holding
act
permitted
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
dismissed
action
ground
none
exceptions
sovereign
immunity
specified
act
applied
appeals
affirmed
ground
act
exceeded
scope
art
iii
constitution
provides
part
judicial
power
shall
extend
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
made
authority
controversies
state
citizens
thereof
foreign
citizens
subjects
held
neither
diversity
clause
arising
clause
art
iii
broad
enough
support
jurisdiction
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereigns
held
part
act
codifies
matter
federal
law
restrictive
theory
foreign
sovereign
immunity
immunity
confined
suits
involving
foreign
sovereign
public
acts
extend
cases
arising
strictly
commercial
acts
one
specified
exceptions
sovereign
immunity
applies
federal
district
may
exercise
jurisdiction
claim
fall
within
one
exceptions
lacks
jurisdiction
pp
face
allows
foreign
plaintiff
sue
foreign
sovereign
federal
provided
substantive
requirements
act
satisfied
act
contains
indication
limitation
based
plaintiff
citizenship
considered
whole
legislative
history
reveals
intent
limit
jurisdiction
act
actions
brought
american
citizens
pp
congress
exceed
scope
art
iii
granting
federal
district
courts
jurisdiction
certain
civil
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereigns
rule
decision
may
provided
state
law
diversity
clause
art
iii
broad
enough
support
jurisdiction
arising
clause
appropriate
basis
statutory
grant
jurisdiction
enacting
act
congress
expressly
exercised
power
regulate
foreign
commerce
along
specified
art
powers
act
merely
concern
access
federal
courts
rather
governs
types
actions
foreign
sovereigns
may
held
liable
federal
codifies
standards
governing
foreign
sovereign
immunity
aspect
substantive
federal
law
thus
suit
foreign
state
act
necessarily
involves
application
comprehensive
body
substantive
federal
law
hence
arises
federal
law
within
meaning
art
iii
pp
since
appeals
affirming
district
find
necessary
address
statutory
question
whether
present
action
fell
within
specified
exception
foreign
sovereign
immunity
remand
must
consider
whether
jurisdiction
exists
act
pp
burger
delivered
opinion
unanimous
abram
chayes
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
berthold
hoeniger
mitchell
bailey
deputy
solicitor
general
bator
argued
cause
amicus
curiae
urging
reversal
brief
solicitor
general
lee
assistant
attorney
general
mcgrath
kenneth
geller
stephen
shapiro
deputy
solicitors
general
william
kanter
eloise
davies
stephen
shulman
invitation
argued
cause
amicus
curiae
support
judgment
briefs
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
filed
lori
fisler
damrosch
joseph
mclaughlin
committee
international
law
association
bar
city
new
york
monroe
leigh
timothy
atkeson
cecil
olmstead
stewart
baker
rule
law
committee
et
al
brief
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
filed
stephen
shulman
mark
ellenberg
republic
guinea
chief
justice
burger
delivered
opinion
granted
certiorari
consider
whether
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
authorizing
foreign
plaintiff
sue
foreign
state
district
nonfederal
cause
action
violates
article
iii
constitution
april
federal
republic
nigeria
petitioner
verlinden
dutch
corporation
principal
offices
amsterdam
netherlands
entered
contract
providing
purchase
metric
tons
cement
nigeria
parties
agreed
contract
governed
laws
netherlands
disputes
resolved
arbitration
international
chamber
commerce
paris
france
contract
provided
nigerian
government
establish
irrevocable
confirmed
letter
credit
total
purchase
price
slavenburg
bank
amsterdam
according
petitioner
amended
complaint
however
respondent
central
bank
nigeria
instrumentality
nigeria
improperly
established
unconfirmed
letter
credit
payable
morgan
guaranty
trust
new
york
august
verlinden
subcontracted
liechtenstein
corporation
interbuco
purchase
cement
needed
fulfill
contract
meanwhile
ports
nigeria
become
clogged
hundreds
ships
carrying
cement
sent
numerous
cement
suppliers
nigeria
also
entered
contracts
central
bank
unilaterally
directed
correspondent
banks
including
morgan
guaranty
adopt
series
amendments
letters
credit
issued
connection
cement
contracts
central
bank
also
directly
notified
suppliers
payment
made
shipments
approved
central
bank
two
months
arrival
nigerian
waters
verlinden
sued
central
bank
district
southern
district
new
york
alleging
central
bank
actions
constituted
anticipatory
breach
letter
credit
verlinden
alleged
jurisdiction
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
respondent
moved
dismiss
among
reasons
lack
personal
jurisdiction
district
first
held
federal
may
exercise
jurisdiction
suit
brought
foreign
corporation
foreign
sovereign
although
legislative
history
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
clearly
reveal
whether
congress
intended
act
extend
actions
brought
foreign
plaintiffs
judge
weinfeld
reasoned
language
act
broad
embracing
confers
jurisdiction
nonjury
civil
action
foreign
state
supp
sdny
moreover
district
view
allowing
actions
foreign
sovereigns
including
initiated
foreign
plaintiffs
brought
federal
necessary
effectuate
congressional
purpose
concentrating
litigation
sovereign
federal
courts
order
aid
development
uniform
body
federal
law
governing
assertions
sovereign
immunity
ibid
district
also
held
art
iii
jurisdiction
extends
suits
foreign
corporations
foreign
sovereigns
stating
act
imposes
single
federal
standard
applied
uniformly
state
federal
courts
hearing
claims
brought
foreign
consequence
even
though
plaintiff
claim
one
grounded
upon
common
law
case
one
arises
federal
law
complaint
compels
application
uniform
federal
standard
governing
assertions
sovereign
immunity
short
immunities
act
injects
essential
federal
element
suits
brought
foreign
ibid
appeals
second
circuit
affirmed
different
grounds
agreed
district
act
properly
construed
permit
actions
brought
foreign
plaintiffs
held
however
act
exceeded
scope
art
iii
constitution
view
appeals
neither
diversity
clause
arising
clause
art
iii
broad
enough
support
jurisdiction
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereigns
accordingly
concluded
congress
without
power
grant
federal
courts
jurisdiction
case
affirmed
district
dismissal
action
granted
certiorari
reverse
remand
ii
century
half
generally
granted
foreign
sovereigns
complete
immunity
suit
courts
country
schooner
exchange
cranch
chief
justice
marshall
concluded
jurisdiction
nation
within
territory
susceptible
limitation
imposed
impliedly
waived
jurisdiction
certain
activities
foreign
sovereigns
although
narrow
holding
schooner
exchange
courts
lack
jurisdiction
armed
ship
foreign
state
found
port
opinion
came
regarded
extending
virtually
absolute
immunity
foreign
sovereigns
see
berizzi
brothers
pesaro
von
mehren
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
colum
schooner
exchange
made
clear
however
foreign
sovereign
immunity
matter
grace
comity
part
restriction
imposed
constitution
accordingly
consistently
deferred
decisions
political
branches
particular
executive
branch
whether
take
jurisdiction
actions
foreign
sovereigns
instrumentalities
see
ex
parte
peru
mexico
hoffman
state
department
ordinarily
requested
immunity
actions
friendly
foreign
sovereigns
tate
letter
state
department
announced
adoption
restrictive
theory
foreign
sovereign
immunity
theory
immunity
confined
suits
involving
foreign
sovereign
public
acts
extend
cases
arising
foreign
state
strictly
commercial
acts
restrictive
theory
initially
enacted
law
however
application
proved
troublesome
past
initial
responsibility
deciding
questions
sovereign
immunity
fell
primarily
upon
executive
acting
state
department
courts
abided
suggestions
immunity
state
department
consequence
foreign
nations
often
placed
diplomatic
pressure
state
department
seeking
immunity
occasion
political
considerations
led
suggestions
immunity
cases
immunity
available
restrictive
theory
additional
complication
posed
fact
foreign
nations
always
make
requests
state
department
cases
responsibility
fell
courts
determine
whether
sovereign
immunity
existed
generally
reference
prior
state
department
decisions
see
generally
lowenfeld
claims
foreign
proposal
reform
law
rev
thus
sovereign
immunity
determinations
made
two
different
branches
subject
variety
factors
sometimes
including
diplomatic
considerations
surprisingly
governing
standards
neither
clear
uniformly
applied
see
weber
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
origin
meaning
effect
yale
studies
world
public
order
congress
passed
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
order
free
government
diplomatic
pressures
clarify
governing
standards
assur
litigants
decisions
made
purely
legal
grounds
procedures
insure
due
process
accomplish
objectives
act
contains
comprehensive
set
legal
standards
governing
claims
immunity
every
civil
action
foreign
state
political
subdivisions
agencies
instrumentalities
part
act
codifies
matter
federal
law
restrictive
theory
sovereign
immunity
foreign
state
normally
immune
jurisdiction
federal
state
courts
subject
set
exceptions
specified
exceptions
include
actions
foreign
state
explicitly
impliedly
waived
immunity
actions
based
upon
commercial
activities
foreign
sovereign
carried
causing
direct
effect
one
specified
exceptions
applies
foreign
state
shall
liable
manner
extent
private
individual
like
circumstances
act
expressly
provides
standards
control
courts
thus
clearly
contemplates
suits
may
brought
either
federal
state
courts
however
view
potential
sensitivity
actions
foreign
importance
developing
uniform
body
law
area
supra
act
guarantees
foreign
right
remove
civil
action
state
federal
act
also
provides
claim
permitted
act
may
brought
outset
federal
one
specified
exceptions
sovereign
immunity
applies
federal
district
may
exercise
jurisdiction
claim
fall
within
one
exceptions
federal
courts
lack
jurisdiction
case
foreign
state
also
ensured
immunity
jurisdiction
state
courts
iii
district
appeals
held
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
purports
allow
foreign
plaintiff
sue
foreign
sovereign
courts
provided
substantive
requirements
act
satisfied
agree
face
language
statute
unambiguous
statute
grants
jurisdiction
nonjury
civil
action
foreign
state
respect
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
act
contains
indication
limitation
based
citizenship
plaintiff
legislative
history
less
clear
regard
house
report
recites
act
provide
jurisdiction
claim
respect
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
sections
supra
emphasis
added
also
purpose
provide
parties
maintain
lawsuit
foreign
state
entities
emphasis
added
another
point
however
report
refers
growing
number
disputes
american
citizens
foreign
expresses
desire
ensure
citizens
access
courts
emphasis
added
notwithstanding
reference
citizens
conclude
considered
whole
legislative
history
reveals
intent
limit
jurisdiction
act
actions
brought
american
citizens
congress
aware
concern
courts
might
turned
small
international
courts
claims
open
comers
litigate
dispute
private
party
may
foreign
state
anywhere
world
testimony
bruno
ristau
hearings
language
statute
reveals
congress
protected
danger
restricting
class
potential
plaintiffs
rather
enacting
substantive
provisions
requiring
form
substantial
contact
see
action
satisfies
substantive
standards
act
may
brought
federal
regardless
citizenship
plaintiff
iv
turn
core
question
presented
case
whether
congress
exceeded
scope
art
iii
constitution
granting
federal
courts
jurisdiction
certain
civil
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereigns
rule
decision
may
provided
state
law
cases
firmly
establish
congress
may
expand
jurisdiction
federal
courts
beyond
bounds
established
constitution
see
hodgson
bowerbank
cranch
kline
burke
construction
within
art
iii
constitution
find
two
sources
authorizing
grant
jurisdiction
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
diversity
clause
arising
clause
diversity
clause
provides
judicial
power
extends
controversies
state
citizens
thereof
foreign
covers
actions
citizens
yet
diversity
jurisdiction
sufficiently
broad
support
grant
jurisdiction
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
since
foreign
plaintiff
state
citize
thereof
see
mossman
higginson
dall
conclude
however
arising
clause
art
iii
provides
appropriate
basis
statutory
grant
jurisdiction
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
act
controlling
decision
scope
art
iii
arising
jurisdiction
chief
justice
marshall
opinion
osborn
bank
wheat
osborn
upheld
constitutionality
statute
granted
bank
right
sue
federal
causes
action
based
upon
state
law
concluded
judicial
department
may
receive
power
construing
every
law
legislature
may
constitutionally
make
rule
laid
sufficient
foundation
jurisdiction
title
right
set
party
may
defeated
one
construction
constitution
law
sustained
opposite
construction
reason
authority
foreign
commerce
foreign
relations
congress
undisputed
power
decide
matter
federal
law
whether
circumstances
foreign
nations
amenable
suit
actions
foreign
sovereigns
courts
raise
sensitive
issues
concerning
foreign
relations
primacy
federal
concerns
evident
see
banco
nacional
de
cuba
sabbatino
zschernig
miller
promote
federal
interests
congress
exercised
art
powers
enacting
statute
comprehensively
regulating
amenability
foreign
nations
suit
statute
must
applied
district
courts
every
action
foreign
sovereign
since
jurisdiction
action
depends
existence
one
specified
exceptions
foreign
sovereign
immunity
threshold
every
action
district
foreign
state
therefore
must
satisfy
one
exceptions
applies
must
apply
detailed
federal
law
standards
set
forth
act
accordingly
action
foreign
sovereign
arises
federal
law
purposes
art
iii
jurisdiction
reaching
contrary
conclusion
appeals
relied
heavily
upon
decisions
construing
statute
grants
district
courts
general
jurisdiction
case
arises
laws
placed
particular
emphasis
complaint
rule
provides
purposes
statutory
arising
jurisdiction
federal
question
must
appear
face
complaint
may
enter
anticipation
defense
see
louisville
nashville
mottley
gully
first
national
bank
wright
miller
cooper
federal
practice
procedure
hereinafter
wright
miller
cooper
view
appeals
question
foreign
sovereign
immunity
case
arose
solely
defense
face
verlinden
complaint
although
language
parallels
arising
clause
art
iii
never
held
statutory
arising
jurisdiction
identical
art
iii
arising
jurisdiction
quite
contrary
true
section
general
statute
although
broadly
phrased
continuously
construed
limited
light
history
produced
demands
reason
coherence
dictates
sound
judicial
policy
emerged
statute
function
provision
mosaic
federal
judiciary
legislation
statute
constitution
expounding
romero
international
terminal
operating
emphasis
added
rejecting
arising
jurisdiction
appeals
also
noted
jurisdictional
provision
felt
conclusion
compelled
prior
cases
rejected
congressional
attempts
confer
jurisdiction
federal
courts
simply
enacting
jurisdictional
statutes
mossman
higginson
dall
example
found
statute
purporting
confer
jurisdiction
actions
alien
party
exceed
scope
art
iii
construed
allow
action
solely
two
aliens
propeller
genesee
chief
fitzhugh
upholding
statute
granting
jurisdiction
vessels
great
lakes
exercise
maritime
jurisdiction
rejected
view
jurisdictional
statute
constituted
federal
regulation
commerce
upon
arising
jurisdiction
based
cases
appeals
apparently
concluded
jurisdictional
statute
never
constitute
federal
law
action
arises
art
iii
purposes
yet
statutes
issue
prior
cases
sought
nothing
grant
jurisdiction
particular
class
cases
stated
propeller
genesee
chief
law
contains
regulations
commerce
merely
confers
new
jurisdiction
district
courts
object
purpose
evident
congress
passing
law
intend
exercise
power
regulate
commerce
emphasis
added
contrast
enacting
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
congress
expressly
exercised
power
regulate
foreign
commerce
along
specified
art
powers
see
supra
house
report
clearly
indicates
primary
purpose
act
se
forth
comprehensive
rules
governing
sovereign
immunity
jurisdictional
provisions
act
simply
one
part
comprehensive
scheme
act
thus
merely
concern
access
federal
courts
rather
governs
types
actions
foreign
sovereigns
may
held
liable
federal
state
act
codifies
standards
governing
foreign
sovereign
immunity
aspect
substantive
federal
law
see
ex
parte
peru
mexico
hoffman
applying
standards
generally
require
interpretation
numerous
points
federal
law
finally
determines
none
exceptions
sovereign
immunity
applies
plaintiff
barred
raising
claim
manifestly
title
right
set
party
may
defeated
one
construction
laws
sustained
opposite
construction
osborn
bank
inquiry
foreign
sovereign
immunity
labeled
act
matter
jurisdiction
affect
constitutionality
congress
action
granting
federal
courts
jurisdiction
cases
calling
application
comprehensive
regulatory
statute
congress
pursuant
unquestioned
art
powers
enacted
broad
statutory
framework
governing
assertions
foreign
sovereign
immunity
congress
deliberately
sought
channel
cases
foreign
sovereigns
away
state
courts
federal
courts
thereby
reducing
potential
multiplicity
conflicting
results
among
courts
resulting
jurisdictional
grant
within
bounds
art
iii
since
every
action
foreign
sovereign
necessarily
involves
application
body
substantive
federal
law
accordingly
arises
federal
law
within
meaning
art
iii
conclusion
grant
jurisdiction
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
consistent
constitution
end
case
action
must
satisfy
art
iii
must
also
supported
statutory
grant
jurisdiction
made
clear
deciding
whether
statutory
jurisdiction
exists
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
entails
application
substantive
terms
act
determine
whether
one
specified
exceptions
immunity
applies
present
case
district
satisfying
constitutionality
act
held
present
action
fall
within
specified
exception
appeals
reaching
contrary
conclusion
jurisdiction
constitution
find
necessary
address
statutory
question
accordingly
remand
appeals
must
consider
whether
jurisdiction
exists
act
appeals
agrees
district
issue
case
end
hand
appeals
concludes
jurisdiction
exist
statute
action
may
remanded
district
proceedings
ordered
footnotes
nigeria
entered
cement
contracts
suppliers
description
general
background
events
see
texas
trading
milling
federal
republic
nigeria
cert
denied
see
also
trendtex
trading
central
bank
nigeria
parties
seriously
dispute
fact
unilateral
amendments
constituted
violations
article
uniform
customs
practice
documentary
credits
chamber
commerce
brochure
revision
stipulation
parties
applicable
see
supp
sdny
title
provides
district
courts
shall
original
jurisdiction
without
regard
amount
controversy
nonjury
civil
action
foreign
state
defined
section
title
claim
relief
personam
respect
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
either
sections
title
applicable
international
agreement
personal
jurisdiction
foreign
state
shall
exist
every
claim
relief
district
courts
jurisdiction
subsection
service
made
section
title
district
dismissed
lack
personal
jurisdiction
act
however
statutory
jurisdiction
otherwise
known
competence
personal
jurisdiction
turn
application
substantive
provisions
act
federal
district
courts
provided
jurisdiction
foreign
state
entitled
immunity
either
sections
applicable
international
agreement
provides
personal
jurisdiction
wherever
jurisdiction
exists
subsection
service
process
made
thus
none
exceptions
sovereign
immunity
set
forth
act
applies
district
lacks
statutory
jurisdiction
personal
jurisdiction
district
conclusion
none
exceptions
act
applied
therefore
signified
absence
competence
personal
jurisdiction
foreign
diversity
clause
provides
judicial
power
extends
controversies
state
citizens
thereof
foreign
citizens
subjects
art
iii
cl
arising
clause
provides
judicial
power
shall
extend
cases
arising
constitution
laws
treaties
made
shall
made
authority
ibid
decision
announced
moved
leave
intervene
rehearing
ground
appeals
complied
requires
action
constitutionality
act
congress
affecting
public
interest
drawn
question
shall
certify
fact
attorney
general
appeals
denied
motion
without
explanation
see
app
pet
cert
letter
jack
tate
acting
legal
adviser
department
state
acting
attorney
general
philip
perlman
may
reprinted
dept
state
bull
alfred
dunhill
london
cuba
appendix
opinion
white
see
testimony
monroe
leigh
legal
adviser
department
state
hearings
subcommittee
administrative
law
governmental
relations
house
committee
judiciary
hereafter
hearings
leigh
sovereign
immunity
case
imias
note
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
giving
plaintiff
day
ford
rev
act
also
contains
exceptions
certain
actions
rights
property
taken
violation
international
law
issue
actions
involving
rights
real
estate
inherited
gift
property
located
actions
certain
noncommercial
torts
within
certain
actions
involving
maritime
liens
certain
counterclaims
section
somewhat
modifies
standard
liability
respect
punitive
damages
actions
encourage
bringing
actions
foreign
federal
courts
act
specifies
federal
district
courts
shall
original
jurisdiction
without
regard
amount
controversy
situation
federal
also
lack
personal
jurisdiction
see
supra
section
provides
sovereign
immunity
shall
apply
waived
may
seen
exception
normal
pattern
act
generally
requires
form
contact
need
decide
whether
waiving
immunity
foreign
state
consent
suit
based
activities
wholly
unrelated
act
appear
affect
traditional
doctrine
forum
non
conveniens
see
generally
kane
suing
foreign
sovereigns
procedural
compass
stanford
rev
note
suits
foreigners
foreign
courts
selective
expansion
jurisdiction
yale
prior
passage
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
congress
clearly
intended
govern
actions
foreign
sovereigns
state
courts
occasion
exercised
jurisdiction
suits
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereigns
see
zeevi
sons
grindlays
bank
cert
denied
congress
prohibit
actions
enacted
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
sought
ensure
action
might
brought
foreign
sovereign
state
also
brought
removed
federal
see
supra
view
conclusion
proper
actions
foreign
plaintiffs
foreign
sovereign
immunities
act
within
art
iii
arising
jurisdiction
need
consider
petitioner
alternative
argument
act
constitutional
aspect
protective
jurisdiction
see
generally
note
theory
protective
jurisdiction
rev
since
art
iii
requires
minimal
diversity
see
state
farm
fire
casualty
tashire
diversity
jurisdiction
sufficient
basis
jurisdiction
least
one
plaintiffs
citizen
state
enacting
legislation
congress
relied
specifically
powers
prescribe
jurisdiction
federal
courts
art
cl
define
offenses
law
nations
art
cl
regulate
commerce
foreign
nations
art
cl
make
laws
necessary
proper
execute
government
powers
art
cl
house
report
act
sovereign
immunity
affirmative
defense
must
specially
pleaded
act
however
jurisdiction
turns
existence
exception
foreign
sovereign
immunity
accordingly
even
foreign
state
enter
appearance
assert
immunity
defense
district
still
must
determine
immunity
unavailable
act
citing
shoshone
mining
rutter
appeals
recognized
implied
art
iii
jurisdiction
broader
nevertheless
placed
substantial
reliance
decisions
construing
although
major
function
foreign
service
immunities
act
whole
regulate
jurisdiction
federal
courts
cases
involving
foreign
act
purpose
set
forth
comprehensive
rules
governing
sovereign
immunity
supra
act
also
prescribes
procedures
commencing
lawsuits
foreign
federal
state
courts
specifies
circumstances
attachment
execution
may
obtained
property
foreign
ibid
addition
act
defines
extent
liability
setting
general
rule
foreign
sovereign
liable
manner
extent
private
individual
subject
certain
specified
exceptions
view
resolution
case
need
consider
petitioner
claim
renders
every
claim
foreign
sovereign
federal
cause
action
see
generally
wright
miller
cooper
several
related
cases
involving
contracts
nigeria
cement
suppliers
appeals
held
statutory
jurisdiction
existed
act
cases
held
nigeria
acts
commercial
nature
cause
direct
effect
within
meaning
texas
trading
milling
federal
republic
nigeria
actions
involved
contract
american
supplier
operating
within
however
present
case
district
found
exception
inapplicable
concluding
repudiation
letter
credit
caused
direct
substantial
injurious
effect