cruz
beto
argued
decided
march
petitioner
prisoner
alleged
buddhist
complained
allowed
use
prison
chapel
prohibited
writing
religious
advisor
placed
solitary
confinement
sharing
religious
material
prisoners
federal
district
denied
relief
without
hearing
findings
holding
complaint
area
left
sound
discretion
prison
administration
appeals
affirmed
held
basis
allegations
texas
discriminated
petitioner
denying
reasonable
opportunity
pursue
buddhist
faith
comparable
offered
prisoners
adhering
conventional
religious
precepts
cause
remanded
hearing
appropriate
findings
certiorari
granted
vacated
remanded
per
curiam
complaint
alleging
cause
action
cruz
buddhist
texas
prison
prisoners
members
religious
sects
allowed
use
prison
chapel
cruz
shared
buddhist
religious
material
prisoners
according
allegations
retaliation
placed
solitary
confinement
diet
bread
water
two
weeks
without
access
newspapers
magazines
sources
news
also
alleged
prohibited
corresponding
religious
advisor
buddhist
sect
isolation
unit
spend
hours
day
total
idleness
according
allegations
texas
encourages
inmates
participate
religious
programs
providing
state
expense
chaplains
catholic
jewish
protestant
faiths
providing
also
state
expense
copies
jewish
christian
bibles
conducting
weekly
sunday
school
classes
religious
services
according
allegations
points
good
merit
given
prisoners
reward
attending
orthodox
religious
services
points
enhancing
prisoner
eligibility
desirable
job
assignments
early
parole
consideration
respondent
answered
denying
allegations
moving
dismiss
federal
district
denied
relief
without
hearing
findings
saying
complaint
area
left
sound
discretion
prison
administration
went
say
valid
disciplinary
security
reasons
known
may
prevent
equality
exercise
religious
practices
prison
appeals
affirmed
federal
courts
sit
supervise
prisons
enforce
constitutional
rights
persons
including
prisoners
unmindful
prison
officials
must
accorded
latitude
administration
prison
affairs
prisoners
necessarily
subject
appropriate
rules
regulations
persons
prison
like
individuals
right
petition
government
redress
grievances
course
includes
access
prisoners
courts
purpose
presenting
complaints
johnson
avery
ex
parte
hull
see
also
younger
gilmore
gilmore
lynch
supp
nd
moreover
racial
segregation
unconstitutional
outside
prisons
unconstitutional
within
prisons
save
necessities
prison
security
discipline
lee
washington
even
closely
point
cooper
pate
reversed
dismissal
complaint
brought
said
taking
true
allegations
complaint
must
motion
dismiss
complaint
stated
cause
action
ibid
allegation
made
petitioner
solely
religious
beliefs
denied
permission
purchase
certain
religious
publications
denied
privileges
enjoyed
prisoners
said
conley
gibson
complaint
dismissed
failure
state
claim
unless
appears
beyond
doubt
plaintiff
prove
set
facts
support
claim
entitle
relief
cruz
buddhist
denied
reasonable
opportunity
pursuing
faith
comparable
opportunity
afforded
fellow
prisoners
adhere
conventional
religious
precepts
palpable
discrimination
state
buddhist
religion
established
long
christian
era
first
amendment
applicable
reason
fourteenth
amendment
torcaso
watkins
prohibits
government
making
law
prohibiting
free
exercise
religion
allegations
complaint
assumed
true
must
motion
dismiss
texas
violated
first
fourteenth
amendments
motion
leave
proceed
forma
pauperis
granted
petition
certiorari
granted
judgment
vacated
cause
remanded
hearing
appropriate
findings
ordered
footnotes
plaintiff
inmate
texas
department
corrections
member
buddhist
churches
america
time
filing
suit
incarcerated
eastham
unit
since
transferred
ellis
unit
substantial
number
prisoners
texas
department
corrections
either
adherents
buddhist
faith
wish
explore
gospel
buddhism
however
defendants
refused
past
continue
refuse
buddhists
right
hold
religious
services
disseminate
teachings
buddha
plaintiff
prevented
defendants
borrowing
lending
buddhist
religious
books
materials
punished
said
defendants
placed
solitary
confinement
diet
bread
water
two
weeks
sharing
buddhist
religious
material
prisoners
despite
repeated
requests
defendants
use
prison
chapel
facilities
purpose
holding
buddhist
religious
services
denials
thereof
defendants
promulgated
customs
regulations
maintain
religious
program
within
penal
system
consecrated
chaplains
protestant
jewish
roman
catholic
religions
state
expense
assigned
various
units
copies
holy
bible
jewish
christian
distributed
state
expense
free
prisoners
religious
services
religious
classes
protestant
jewish
roman
catholic
adherents
held
regularly
chapel
facilities
erected
state
expense
purposes
records
maintained
defendants
religious
participation
inmates
religious
participation
encouraged
inmates
defendants
necessary
steps
toward
true
rehabilitation
points
good
merit
given
inmates
defendants
reward
religious
participation
protestant
jewish
roman
catholic
faiths
enhance
inmates
eligibility
promotions
class
job
assignment
parole
inmates
buddhist
faith
denied
right
participate
religious
program
made
available
protestant
jewish
roman
catholic
faiths
defendants
plaintiff
members
class
represents
subjected
arbitrary
unreasonable
exclusion
without
lawful
justification
invidiously
discriminates
violation
constitutional
right
religious
freedom
denies
equal
protection
laws
suggest
course
every
religious
sect
group
within
prison
however
number
must
identical
facilities
personnel
special
chapel
place
worship
need
provided
every
faith
regardless
size
must
chaplain
priest
minister
provided
without
regard
extent
demand
reasonable
opportunities
must
afforded
prisoners
exercise
religious
freedom
guaranteed
first
fourteenth
amendments
without
fear
penalty
chief
justice
burger
concurring
result
concur
result
reached
even
though
allegations
complaint
borderline
necessary
compel
evidentiary
hearing
claims
alleged
frivolous
others
present
justiciable
issues
possibly
constitutional
legal
requirement
government
provide
materials
every
religion
sect
practiced
diverse
country
buddhist
materials
denied
prisoners
someone
offers
supply
justice
rehnquist
dissenting
unlike
persuaded
petitioner
complaint
claim
first
amendment
opinion
appeals
vacated
trial
must
necessarily
conduct
trial
upon
complaint
first
amendment
course
texas
may
neither
establish
religion
may
impair
free
exercise
thereof
petitioner
alleges
voluntary
services
made
available
prison
facilities
protestants
catholics
jews
may
attend
church
services
choice
none
prior
holdings
indicates
program
part
prison
officials
amounts
establishment
religion
petitioner
prisoner
serving
years
robbery
texas
penitentiary
understandably
free
practice
religion
outside
prison
walls
intimation
pleadings
punished
religious
views
case
cooper
pate
prisoner
denied
receipt
mail
religion
cooper
presented
question
interference
prison
administration
type
involved
retaining
chaplains
scheduling
use
prison
facilities
timing
activities
various
prisoners
none
holdings
first
amendment
requires
addition
allowed
freedom
religious
belief
prisoners
allowed
freely
evangelize
views
among
prisoners
indication
petitioner
complaint
prison
officials
dealt
strictly
efforts
convert
convicts
buddhism
efforts
communicants
faiths
make
similar
conversions
reason
status
petitioner
obviously
limited
extent
may
practice
religion
assuredly
free
attend
church
choice
outside
prison
walls
fact
texas
prison
system
offers
buddhist
services
particular
prison
circumstances
pleaded
complaint
demonstrate
religious
freedom
impaired
presumably
prison
officials
obligated
provide
facilities
particular
denominational
services
within
prison
although
undertake
provide
must
make
reasonable
distinctions
may
survive
analysis
equal
protection
clause
petitioner
basic
claim
amounts
prison
facilities
provided
denominational
services
religions
numerous
followers
failure
provide
prison
facilities
buddhist
services
amounts
denial
equal
protection
laws
indication
petitioner
complaint
many
practicing
buddhists
particular
prison
facility
incarcerated
indication
demand
upon
available
facilities
prisoner
activities
neither
decisions
full
argument
summarily
reversing
dismissal
prisoner
civil
rights
complaint
ever
given
full
consideration
proper
balance
struck
prisoners
rights
extensive
administrative
discretion
must
rest
correction
officials
apply
rule
deference
administrative
discretion
overwhelmingly
accepted
courts
appeals
failing
least
hear
argument
rule
govern
long
line
decisions
recognized
equal
protection
laws
guaranteed
fourteenth
amendment
applied
precisely
equivalent
way
multitudinous
fact
situations
may
confront
courts
one
hand
held
racial
classifications
invidious
suspect
think
quite
consistent
intent
framers
fourteenth
amendment
many
doubtless
surprised
know
convicts
came
within
ambit
treat
prisoner
claims
end
spectrum
claims
racial
discrimination
absent
complaint
alleging
facts
showing
difference
treatment
petitioner
fellow
buddhists
practitioners
denominations
numerous
adherents
reasonably
justified
rational
hypothesis
leave
matter
hands
prison
officials
assumed
dismissal
trial
must
treated
proper
standard
conley
gibson
permit
grant
motion
fed
rule
civ
proc
require
district
inflexibly
apply
general
principle
complaint
every
inmate
many
respects
different
litigating
posture
persons
unconfined
inmate
stands
gain
something
lose
nothing
complaint
stating
facts
ultimately
unable
prove
though
may
denied
legal
relief
nonetheless
obtained
short
sabbatical
nearest
federal
courthouse
expand
availability
courtroom
appearances
requiring
district
construe
every
inmate
complaint
liberal
rule
conley
gibson
deprives
courts
latitude
necessary
process
species
complaint
finally
factual
hearing
imperative
remand
dismissal
appropriate
grounds
failure
state
claim
relief
evident
record
us
forma
pauperis
complaint
might
well
dismissed
frivolous
malicious
discretion
vested
trial
power
limited
impaired
strictures
rule
fletcher
young
although
trial
based
dismissal
grounds
record
support
dismissal
frivolous
state
answer
complaint
showed
identical
issues
religious
freedoms
litigated
another
prisoner
institution
claiming
impairment
practice
buddhist
religion
brought
attorney
employed
prison
provide
legal
services
inmates
clear
whether
petitioner
party
suit
many
suits
filed
fellow
prisoners
instant
claim
may
barred
doctrine
res
judicata
event
prior
adjudication
claim
another
prisoner
identical
circumstances
substantial
factor
decision
dismiss
claim
frivolous
addition
trial
dismissal
another
petitioner
cases
filed
shortly
instant
action
trial
judge
exposed
myriad
previous
actions
found
voluminous
repetitious
duplicitous
many
instances
deceitful
whether
petitioner
might
raised
claim
several
actions
joined
prisoner
plaintiffs
also
proper
foundation
finding
complaint
frivolous
malicious
whatever
might
posture
constitutional
claim
petitioner
never
flooded
courts
repetitive
duplicitous
claims
recently
adjudicated
identical
proceeding
believe
dismissed
frivolous
case
us
remand
hearing
appropriate
findings
ante
page
course
procedural
vehicle
making
findings
civil
litigation
trial
civil
litigant
entitled
inasmuch
never
dealt
special
procedural
problems
presented
prisoners
civil
suits
see
fed
rules
civ
proc
haines
kerner
younger
gilmore
houghton
shafer
lee
washington
cooper
pate
douglas
sigler
carey
settle
carswell
wainwright
walker
pate
read
johnson
avery
concerned
prisoners
traditional
remedy
habeas
corpus
reach
issue
statutory
civil
cause
action
see
generally
mcgowan
maryland
dandridge
williams
royster
guano
virginia
levy
louisiana
carrington
rash
examples
spectrum
fourteenth
amendment
review
standards
loving
virginia
korematsu
petitioner
represented
lawyer
drafted
complaint
alleged
excluded
participation
religious
programs
exclusion
arbitrary
unreasonable
without
lawful
justification
holding
counsel
standards
pleading
applied
prisoners
claims
relief
conclusions
arbitrariness
insufficient
williams
dunbar
ex
rel
hoge
bolsinger
last
type
discussed
writes
writs
economic
gain
group
comprised
unscrupulous
manipulators
interested
acquiring
prisoners
money
cigarettes
merchandise
purchased
inmate
canteen
client
interest
aroused
determine
ability
pay
must
keep
hook
commonly
done
deliberately
misstating
facts
case
appears
least
surface
inmate
entitled
relief
documents
drafted
client
cast
role
sympathetic
protagonist
reading
inmate
elated
found
someone
able
present
case
favorably
willing
pay
maintain
lie
created
larsen
prisoner
looks
rev
decisions
help
may
employ
handful
tricks
damage
image
state
courts
subtle
subterfuges
used
small
minority
tax
credulity
lawyer
one
simply
made
legal
citations
ran
short
actual
ones
one
action
california
adult
authority
involving
application
administrative
law
one
used
following
citations
aesop
fables
first
baptist
church
sally
stanford
doda
one
inch
chest
dogood
planet
earth
references
volumes
page
numbers
nonexistent
publications
equally
fantastic
penal
review
page
accompany
case
composed
eloquent
decision
good
law
make
selected
acts
adult
authority
unconstitutional
time
decisions
freely
circulated
among
several
gullible
ones
began
citing
also
emporary
relief
prison
confinement
always
alluring
prospect
hardened
criminal
possibility
escape
lurks
every
excursion
beyond
prison
walls
price
johnston
cf
price
johnston
giving
courts
appeals
necessary
discretion
determine
prisoners
allowed
argue
habeas
corpus
appeals
person
apparent
request
prisoner
argue
personally
reflects
something
mere
desire
freed
temporarily
confines
prison
capable
conducting
intelligent
responsible
argument
presence
courtroom
may
secured
without
undue
inconvenience
danger
justified
issuing
writ
reece
washington
conway
oliver