cases
argued
decided
october
first
two
cases
brought
certificates
division
opinion
judges
circuit
southern
district
new
york
last
brought
certificate
division
opinion
judges
circuit
southern
district
ohio
steffens
indicted
fourth
fifth
sections
act
congress
entitled
act
punish
counterfeiting
sale
dealing
counterfeit
goods
approved
stat
first
count
indictment
charges
knowingly
wilfully
possession
counterfeits
colorable
imitations
mumm
rheims
france
manufacturers
sellers
champagne
wine
second
count
charges
knowingly
wilfully
selling
counterfeited
representations
colorable
imitations
said
mumm
wittemann
indicted
fifth
section
act
indictment
consists
six
counts
charge
counterfeiting
forging
possession
colorable
imitations
buying
selling
offering
sale
dealing
colorable
imitations
private
mark
belonging
used
firm
kunkleman
rheims
france
manufacturers
dealers
wine
known
heidsick
brand
champagne
wine
johnson
mcnamara
reeder
prosecuted
act
criminal
information
containing
seven
counts
first
fourth
sixth
founded
upon
consisting
letters
registered
patent
office
charles
april
use
upon
packages
whiskey
respectively
charge
defendants
counterfeiting
affixing
colorable
imitation
dealing
selling
packages
whiskey
attached
colorable
imitation
said
second
third
fifth
seventh
counts
founded
upon
another
consisting
seal
ribbon
latter
secured
seal
package
containing
whiskey
registered
charles
may
respectively
charge
defendants
counterfeiting
making
colorable
imitation
affixing
colorable
imitation
dealing
packages
whiskey
attached
colorable
imitation
said
sects
act
follows
person
persons
shall
intent
defraud
person
persons
knowingly
wilfully
cast
engrave
manufacture
possession
buy
sell
offer
sale
deal
die
dies
plate
plates
brand
brands
engraving
engravings
wood
stone
metal
substance
moulds
false
representation
likeness
copy
colorable
imitation
die
plate
brand
engraving
mould
private
label
brand
stamp
wrapper
engraving
paper
substance
registered
pursuant
statutes
shall
upon
conviction
thereof
punished
prescribed
first
section
act
person
persons
shall
intent
defraud
person
persons
knowingly
wilfully
make
forge
counterfeit
possession
buy
sell
offer
sale
deal
representation
likeness
similitude
copy
colorable
imitation
private
label
brand
stamp
wrapper
engraving
mould
registered
pursuant
statutes
shall
upon
conviction
thereof
punished
prescribed
first
section
act
sect
rev
follows
person
firm
domiciled
corporation
created
authority
state
territory
thereof
person
firm
corporation
resident
located
foreign
country
treaty
convention
affords
similar
privileges
citizens
entitled
exclusive
use
lawful
intend
adopt
use
exclusive
use
within
may
obtain
protection
lawful
complying
following
requirements
causing
recorded
patent
office
statement
specifying
names
parties
residences
places
business
desire
protection
class
merchandise
particular
description
goods
comprised
class
intended
appropriated
description
thereof
showing
mode
intended
applied
used
length
time
use
making
payment
fee
dollars
manner
purpose
fee
required
patents
complying
regulations
may
pre
scribed
commissioner
patents
indictment
general
demurrer
judges
circuit
opposed
opinion
upon
following
question
act
congress
approved
entitled
act
punish
counterfeiting
goods
sale
dealing
counterfeit
goods
indictment
found
upheld
wholly
part
law
necessary
proper
carrying
execution
powers
vested
congress
constitution
information
johnson
mcnamara
reeder
general
demurrer
thereupon
question
arose
decision
whether
said
act
congress
within
constitutional
power
congress
whether
unconstitutional
null
void
opinions
judges
circuit
opposed
validity
act
july
provides
registration
gives
remedies
civil
actions
infringing
recognized
justice
clifford
delivered
opinion
mclean
fleming
first
sentence
opinion
follows
lawful
may
obtained
individuals
firms
corporations
entitled
comply
requirements
prescribed
act
congress
provision
duly
registered
required
shall
remain
force
thirty
years
date
registration
subject
exception
necessary
noticed
stat
rev
sects
clearly
intimated
protection
rightfully
provided
act
invalid
protection
mode
obtained
protection
civil
remedies
within
power
congress
also
statutes
punishing
crime
pirating
upon
property
case
several
others
cited
margin
page
revised
statutes
constitutionality
act
discussed
others
smith
reynolds
blatch
smith
reynolds
id
osgood
rockwood
id
moorman
hodge
saw
assumed
rather
directly
affirmed
sixth
circuit
judge
swing
pronounced
law
constitutional
seventh
circuit
contrary
decision
made
case
question
argued
decided
upon
clause
section
article
constitution
opinion
advanced
provision
authority
congress
subject
conferred
argument
drawn
likeness
property
use
bears
partents
copyrights
fact
congress
legislating
upon
three
matters
original
act
revised
statutes
classed
together
demands
careful
consideration
undoubtedly
legislative
mind
kindred
subjects
thought
power
congress
might
derived
source
shall
however
dwell
upon
view
question
maintain
constitutionality
statute
upon
indictments
information
found
upon
ground
regulates
commerce
within
power
given
congress
clause
section
article
constitution
provides
congress
shall
power
regulate
commerce
foreign
nations
among
several
indian
tribes
term
largest
import
comprehends
intercourse
purposes
trade
forms
including
transportation
purchase
sale
exchange
commodities
citizens
country
citizens
subjects
countries
citizens
different
power
regulate
embraces
instruments
commerce
may
conducted
far
instruments
concerned
subjects
local
operation
held
may
provide
regulations
congress
acts
reference
subject
power
applies
national
character
nature
admit
uniformity
regulation
power
exclusive
state
authority
welton
state
missouri
full
clear
statement
meant
extent
power
congress
purchase
sale
commodities
included
term
power
congress
embraces
instruments
aids
appliances
prosecuted
true
trade
intercourse
must
foreign
among
citizens
different
indian
tribes
instrumentalities
employed
aids
trade
commerce
local
operation
nature
admit
uniformity
regulation
power
congress
applies
exclusive
important
instrumentalities
aids
appliances
trade
especially
modern
times
conducted
means
manufacturers
merchants
identify
manufactures
merchandise
symbols
men
engaged
trade
manufactures
become
known
marts
commerce
reputation
goods
extended
published
become
better
known
profits
business
enhanced
hence
use
become
universal
trade
business
extent
necessary
auxiliaries
among
commercial
nations
growing
tendency
universal
recognition
emblems
commerce
browne
sect
use
aids
exchange
commodities
great
markets
world
generally
recognized
considered
vitally
important
protection
commerce
made
subject
treaties
france
german
empire
belgium
austria
russia
powers
english
merchandise
marks
act
affords
protection
foreigners
subjects
great
britain
browne
subject
one
local
common
interest
commercial
nations
operation
benefits
derived
use
confined
particular
localities
countries
admit
order
efficiency
require
uniformity
regulation
congress
endeavored
effect
uniformity
first
providing
registration
remedies
violation
owners
rights
action
case
damages
bill
equity
enjoin
offending
party
sects
rev
stat
civil
remedies
proved
inadequate
effectually
prevent
pirating
upon
materially
differ
previously
existed
congress
following
examples
prussia
france
england
browne
pp
passed
act
stat
offences
therein
defined
charged
indictments
information
specification
unnecessary
demurrers
general
ground
entire
act
unconstitutional
constitutionality
application
subjects
foreign
countries
question
presented
indictments
purpose
natural
reasonable
effect
acts
protect
producer
importer
foreign
goods
right
selling
thus
carry
good
faith
enforce
treaty
stipulations
subject
act
regulation
foreign
commerce
convention
france
april
stat
forbids
reproduction
either
two
countries
marks
affixed
merchandise
gives
injured
party
action
damages
citizen
subject
country
act
counterfeiting
committed
provides
second
article
owners
residing
either
two
countries
order
secure
rights
must
deposit
duplicate
copies
marks
patent
office
washington
clerk
office
tribunal
commerce
seine
paris
mutual
covenant
concerning
whatever
protection
laws
either
country
give
citizens
subjects
extended
citizens
subjects
intent
treaty
law
france
june
provides
civil
action
also
criminal
proceeding
prescribes
severe
penalties
counterfeit
way
fraudulently
deal
false
representations
declares
foreigners
shall
equally
enjoy
benefits
products
countries
diplomatic
conventions
established
reciprocity
french
marks
browne
congress
order
afford
effective
remedy
evil
extend
protection
french
importers
france
gives
producers
merchants
markets
enacted
forger
dealer
forged
shall
answer
bar
criminal
justice
courts
end
lawful
within
power
congress
means
appropriate
said
passing
statutes
july
congress
exceeded
power
application
cover
cases
arising
wholly
within
several
make
acts
committed
within
directed
operations
general
regulate
foreign
commerce
affect
domestic
concerns
several
fraudulent
dealing
plainly
interferes
thwarts
power
duty
protect
foreign
trade
moreover
impossible
limit
effect
within
confines
state
extends
places
market
goods
simulated
false
device
answer
objection
subject
statutes
general
interest
commerce
upon
congress
power
legislate
operation
coextensive
trade
objection
law
regulating
touches
internal
concerns
state
wheeling
bridge
case
observed
say
exercise
admitted
power
congress
conferred
constitution
withheld
appears
shown
effect
operation
law
may
incidentally
extend
beyond
limitation
power
upon
interpretation
principal
object
framers
instrument
conferring
power
sacrificed
subordinate
consequences
resulting
exercise
power
congress
tax
imports
exclusive
yet
constitutional
provision
seriously
limits
power
internal
affairs
held
brown
maryland
wheat
way
manner
tax
sale
imported
goods
incorporated
mixed
mass
property
country
justice
strong
delivering
opinion
state
tax
railway
gross
receipts
wall
construes
ruling
brown
maryland
applying
persons
importers
sell
foreign
goods
unbroken
bale
package
see
also
welton
state
missouri
plain
authoritative
exposition
constitution
power
state
internal
commerce
right
tax
property
within
jurisdiction
interfered
limited
exercise
power
legislate
concerning
police
morals
health
community
endeavored
regulate
sale
particular
articles
spirituous
liquors
laws
invalid
far
affect
sale
imported
goods
importer
original
package
mixed
general
mass
salable
commodities
license
cases
commonwealth
kimball
pick
mass
license
cases
decided
state
might
regulate
sale
liquors
original
packages
imported
another
state
absence
legislation
congress
upon
subject
congress
exercised
power
regulate
commerce
state
laws
far
conflict
action
congress
must
yield
power
internal
concerns
materially
diminished
also
regard
regulation
pilotage
within
power
congress
cooley
board
wardens
general
law
regulating
pilotage
upon
navigable
waters
materially
affects
internal
commerce
many
yet
parties
indicted
convicted
violation
provisions
farnham
blatch
warren
mclean
taylor
id
regulation
trade
indian
tribes
action
law
especially
constitution
adopted
chiefly
within
state
asserted
power
congress
comprehends
navigation
within
limits
every
state
union
far
navigation
may
manner
connected
commerce
foreign
nations
among
several
indian
tribes
gibbins
ogden
wheat
connection
refer
holliday
wall
gallons
whiskey
congress
power
legislate
upon
subject
general
interest
commerce
submitted
legislation
congress
purpose
give
uniform
protection
throughout
country
constitutional
however
may
affect
internal
affairs
insisted
defendants
act
terms
also
applied
goods
intended
foreign
commerce
reply
excluding
operation
provisions
regard
objectionable
valid
enactment
susceptible
enforced
proper
cases
may
remain
law
constitutional
certain
limitations
exceeds
may
still
operative
within
legitimate
sphere
void
excess
george
hoadly
contra
justice
miller
delivered
opinion
three
cases
whose
titles
stand
head
opinion
criminal
prosecutions
violations
known
legislation
congress
first
two
indictments
southern
district
new
york
last
information
southern
district
ohio
judges
circuit
courts
pending
certified
difference
opinion
substantially
question
namely
acts
congress
subject
founded
rightful
authority
constitution
entire
legislation
congress
regard
recent
origin
first
seen
sects
inclusive
act
july
entitled
act
revise
consolidate
amend
statutes
relating
patents
copyrights
stat
part
act
relating
embodied
chap
tit
sects
revised
statutes
sufficient
present
say
provide
registration
patent
office
device
nature
mark
person
usage
established
exclusive
right
person
registering
intends
appropriate
act
exclusive
use
make
wrongful
use
registered
person
without
owner
permission
cause
action
civil
suit
damages
six
years
later
act
stat
punishing
fine
imprisonment
fraudulent
use
sale
counterfeiting
registered
pursuance
statutes
informations
indictments
founded
cases
us
right
adopt
use
symbol
device
distinguish
goods
property
made
sold
person
whose
mark
exclusion
use
persons
long
recognized
common
law
chancery
courts
england
country
statutes
property
right
violation
damages
may
recovered
action
law
continued
violation
enjoined
equity
compensation
past
infringement
exclusive
right
created
act
congress
depend
upon
enforcement
whole
system
property
civil
remedies
protection
existed
long
anterior
act
remained
full
force
since
passage
propositions
well
understood
require
neither
citation
authorities
elaborate
argument
prove
property
right
exclusive
use
rest
laws
like
great
body
rights
person
property
depend
security
protection
power
congress
legislate
subject
establish
conditions
rights
shall
enjoyed
exercised
period
duration
legal
remedies
enforcement
power
exist
must
found
constitution
source
powers
congress
lawfully
exercise
argument
cases
seems
conceded
advocates
validity
acts
congress
subject
point
two
clauses
constitution
one
assert
sufficient
warrant
may
found
legislation
first
eighth
clause
sect
first
article
section
manifestly
intended
enumeration
powers
expressly
granted
congress
closing
declaration
rule
ascertainment
powers
necessary
way
implication
carry
efficient
operation
expressly
given
authorizes
congress
clause
referred
promote
progress
science
useful
arts
securing
limited
times
authors
inventors
exclusive
right
respective
writings
discoveries
first
attempt
congress
regulate
right
found
act
july
referred
entitled
act
revise
consolidate
amend
statutes
relating
patents
copyrights
terms
long
since
become
technical
referring
one
inventions
writings
authors
reasonable
inference
part
statute
also
opinion
congress
exercise
power
found
clause
constitution
may
also
safely
assumed
critical
examination
subject
courts
became
necessary
mainly
wholly
clause
advocates
law
looked
support
attempt
however
identify
essential
characteristics
inventions
discoveries
arts
sciences
writings
authors
show
effort
surrounded
insurmountable
difficulties
ordinary
necessary
relation
invention
discovery
recognized
common
law
generally
growth
considerable
period
use
rather
sudden
invention
often
result
accident
rather
design
act
congress
sought
establish
registration
neither
originality
invention
discovery
science
art
way
essential
right
conferred
act
endeavor
classify
head
writings
authors
objections
equally
strong
regard
inventions
originality
required
word
writings
may
liberally
construed
include
original
designs
engravings
prints
original
founded
creative
powers
mind
writings
protected
fruits
intellectual
labor
embodied
form
books
prints
engravings
like
may
generally
adoption
something
already
existence
distinctive
symbol
party
using
common
law
exclusive
right
grows
use
mere
adoption
act
congress
exclusive
right
attaches
upon
registration
neither
case
depend
upon
novelty
invention
discovery
work
brain
requires
fancy
imagination
genius
laborious
thought
simply
founded
priority
appropriation
look
vain
statute
qualification
condition
symbol
however
plain
simple
old
first
appropriated
claimant
distinctive
may
registration
secure
right
exclusive
use
legislation
may
judicious
aid
common
law
subject
may
within
competency
legislatures
whose
general
powers
embrace
class
subjects
unable
see
power
constitutional
provision
concerning
authors
inventors
writings
discoveries
clause
constitution
supposed
confer
requisite
authority
congress
third
section
read
connection
granting
clause
follows
congress
shall
power
regulate
commerce
foreign
nations
among
several
indian
tribes
argument
use
alone
gives
identify
particular
class
quality
goods
manufacture
produce
property
person
puts
general
market
sale
sale
article
distinguished
commerce
therefore
useful
valuable
aid
instrument
commerce
regulation
virtue
clause
belongs
congress
act
question
lawful
exercise
power
every
species
property
subject
commerce
used
even
essential
commerce
brought
clause
within
control
congress
barrels
casks
bottles
boxes
alone
certain
articles
commerce
kept
safety
contents
transferred
seller
buyer
thereby
become
subjects
congressional
legislation
property
nathan
louisiana
paul
virginia
wall
held
policy
insurance
made
corporation
one
state
property
situated
another
article
commerce
come
within
purview
clause
considering
says
shipped
forwarded
one
state
another
put
sale
hand
almy
state
california
held
stamp
duty
imposed
legislature
california
bills
lading
gold
silver
transported
place
state
another
state
forbidden
constitution
instruments
necessity
transaction
commerce
duty
tax
upon
exports
question
therefore
whether
bears
relation
commerce
general
terms
bring
within
congressional
control
used
applied
classes
commerce
fall
within
control
one
present
case
propose
leave
undecided
adopt
course
called
course
administration
law
consider
whether
act
congress
department
government
within
constitutional
authority
department
due
respect
branch
government
requires
shall
decide
transcended
powers
plain
avoid
duty
cases
manifestly
dictate
wisdom
judicial
propriety
decide
necessary
case
hand
uniform
course
regard
statutes
passed
congress
readily
appear
one
consider
vast
amount
argument
presented
us
assailing
unconstitutional
count
may
fingers
instances
declared
act
congress
void
want
constitutional
power
governed
view
duty
proceed
remark
glance
commerce
clause
constitution
discloses
often
subject
comment
power
regulation
conferred
congress
limited
commerce
foreign
nations
commerce
among
commerce
indian
tribes
bearing
mind
liberal
construction
commerce
foreign
nations
means
commerce
citizens
citizens
subjects
foreign
nations
commerce
among
means
commerce
individual
citizens
different
still
remains
large
amount
commerce
perhaps
largest
trade
traffic
citizens
state
beyond
control
congress
therefore
congress
undertakes
enact
law
valid
regulation
commerce
reasonable
expect
find
face
law
essential
nature
regulation
commerce
foreign
nations
among
several
indian
tribes
limited
excess
power
congress
main
purpose
establish
regulation
applicable
trade
commerce
points
especially
apparent
designed
govern
commerce
wholly
citizens
state
obviously
exercise
power
confided
congress
find
recognition
principle
chapter
marks
revised
statutes
naturally
look
description
class
persons
entitled
register
mark
reference
goods
applied
instance
statute
described
persons
engaged
commerce
different
related
use
commerce
evident
congress
believed
acting
clause
constitution
authorizes
regulate
commerce
among
registered
congress
protected
use
goods
sold
citizen
one
state
another
citizen
foreign
state
citizen
seen
congress
least
intending
exercise
power
regulation
conferred
clause
constitution
idea
found
suggested
statute
language
person
firm
domiciled
corporation
created
state
territory
thereof
person
residing
foreign
country
treaty
convention
affords
similar
privileges
citizens
may
registration
obtain
protection
requirement
person
shall
engaged
kind
commerce
congress
authorized
regulate
general
declaration
anybody
anybody
country
permits
us
like
may
registering
fully
protected
person
registering
required
furnish
statement
class
merchandise
particular
description
goods
comprised
class
intended
appropriated
hint
goods
transported
one
state
another
foreign
countries
sect
intended
impose
restriction
upon
commissioner
patents
matter
registration
limitation
suggested
regard
persons
property
engaged
different
classes
commerce
mentioned
constitution
remedies
provided
act
right
owner
registered
infringed
confined
case
used
foreign
commerce
therefore
manifest
distinction
found
act
broad
purpose
establish
universal
system
mark
registration
benefit
already
used
mark
wished
adopt
one
future
without
regard
character
trade
applied
residence
owner
solitary
exception
resided
foreign
countries
extended
privileges
us
excluded
suggested
congress
power
regulate
marks
used
commerce
foreign
nations
among
several
statutes
shall
held
valid
class
cases
two
objections
first
indictments
cases
show
wrongfully
used
used
kind
commerce
secondly
may
true
one
part
statute
valid
constitutional
another
part
unconstitutional
void
may
enforce
valid
part
distinctly
separable
stand
alone
within
judicial
province
give
words
used
congress
narrower
meaning
manifestly
intended
bear
order
crimes
may
punished
described
language
brings
within
constitutional
power
body
precise
point
decided
reese
case
congress
passed
statute
punishing
election
officers
refuse
person
lawfully
entitled
right
cast
vote
election
opinion
regarded
section
statute
consideration
congress
punish
denial
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
urged
however
general
description
offence
included
limited
one
section
valid
fact
cause
denial
said
chief
justice
able
reject
part
unconstitutional
retain
remainder
possible
separate
constitutional
proposed
effect
attained
striking
disregarding
words
section
inserting
sections
must
stand
whole
fall
altogether
language
plain
room
construction
unless
effect
constitution
question
determined
whether
introduce
words
limitation
penal
statute
make
specific
expressed
general
limit
statute
manner
asked
make
new
law
enforce
old
one
part
duty
case
us
undertake
make
judicial
construction
law
congress
make
quite
probable
matter
body
unwilling
namely
make
law
partial
operation
complicate
rights
parties
hold
instances
act
congress
others
state
law
cooley
const
lim
commonwealth
hitchings
gray
mass
said
wish
understood
leaving
untouched
whole
question
power
duty
congress
pass
laws
necessary
carry
treaties
effect
references
opinion
legislation
congress
mainly
view
act
civil
remedy
act
provides
criminal
offences
described
act
express
terms
solely
referable
frauds
counterfeits
unlawful
use
registered
provisions
former
act
act
unconstitutional
registration
confers
lawful
right
criminal
enactment
intended
protect
right
falls
questions
cases
inquiry
whether
statutes
upheld
whole
part
valid
constitutional
must
answered
negative
certified
proper
circuit
courts