johnson
avery
argued
november
decided
february
petitioner
tennessee
prisoner
disciplined
violating
prison
regulation
prohibited
inmates
assisting
prisoners
preparing
writs
district
held
regulation
void
effect
barring
illiterate
prisoners
access
federal
habeas
corpus
conflicted
appeals
reversed
finding
state
interest
preserving
prison
discipline
limiting
practice
law
attorneys
justified
burden
regulation
might
place
access
federal
habeas
corpus
held
absence
provision
state
tennessee
reasonable
alternative
assist
illiterate
poorly
educated
inmates
preparing
petitions
relief
state
may
validly
enforce
regulation
absolutely
bars
inmates
furnishing
assistance
prisoners
pp
reversed
remanded
karl
warden
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
pierce
winningham
thomas
fox
deputy
attorney
general
tennessee
argued
cause
respondents
brief
george
mccanless
attorney
general
david
mcmackin
assistant
attorney
general
melvin
wulf
filed
brief
american
civil
liberties
union
et
amici
curiae
urging
reversal
thomas
lynch
attorney
general
california
albert
harris
assistant
attorney
general
robert
granucci
george
nock
deputy
attorneys
general
filed
brief
state
california
amicus
curiae
urging
affirmance
justice
fortas
delivered
opinion
inmate
advise
assist
otherwise
contract
aid
another
either
without
fee
prepare
writs
legal
matters
intended
innocent
man
punished
man
believes
unlawfully
held
illegally
convicted
prepare
brief
state
complaint
letter
form
address
lawyer
judge
formal
writ
necessary
receive
hearing
false
charges
untrue
complaints
may
punished
inmates
forbidden
set
practitioners
purpose
promoting
business
writing
writs
time
district
order
entered
petitioner
transferred
maximum
security
building
put
disciplinary
cell
block
entitled
fewer
privileges
given
ordinary
prisoners
promised
refrain
assistance
inmates
restored
regular
prison
conditions
privileges
second
hearing
held
march
district
explored
issues
concerning
compliance
prison
officials
initial
order
hearing
reaffirmed
earlier
order
state
appealed
appeals
sixth
circuit
reversed
concluding
regulation
unlawfully
conflict
federal
right
habeas
corpus
according
sixth
circuit
interest
state
preserving
prison
discipline
limiting
practice
law
licensed
attorneys
justified
whatever
burden
regulation
might
place
access
federal
habeas
corpus
ii
since
basic
purpose
writ
enable
unlawfully
incarcerated
obtain
freedom
fundamental
access
prisoners
courts
purpose
presenting
complaints
may
denied
obstructed
example
held
state
may
validly
make
writ
available
prisoners
pay
filing
fee
smith
bennett
insisted
indigent
well
affluent
prisoner
proceedings
must
formality
instance
state
obligated
furnish
prisoners
otherwise
able
obtain
transcript
equivalent
recordation
prior
habeas
corpus
hearings
use
proceedings
long
district
cf
griffin
illinois
tennessee
urges
however
contested
regulation
case
justified
part
state
disciplinary
administration
prisons
doubt
discipline
administration
state
detention
facilities
state
functions
subject
federal
authority
paramount
federal
constitutional
statutory
rights
supervene
clear
however
instances
state
regulations
applicable
inmates
prison
facilities
conflict
rights
regulations
may
invalidated
example
lee
washington
practice
racial
segregation
prisoners
justified
state
necessary
maintain
good
order
discipline
held
however
practice
constitutionally
prohibited
although
careful
point
order
district
affirmed
made
allowance
necessities
prison
security
discipline
ex
parte
hull
invalidated
state
regulation
required
habeas
corpus
petitions
first
submitted
prison
authorities
approved
legal
investigator
parole
board
properly
drawn
transmitted
state
urged
requirement
necessary
maintain
prison
discipline
held
regulation
violated
principle
state
officers
may
abridge
impair
petitioner
right
apply
federal
writ
habeas
corpus
cf
cochran
kansas
doubt
tennessee
constitutionally
adopt
enforce
rule
forbidding
illiterate
poorly
educated
prisoners
file
habeas
corpus
petitions
tennessee
adopted
rule
absence
source
assistance
prisoners
effectively
district
concluded
practical
purposes
prisoners
assistance
lawyer
possibly
valid
constitutional
claims
never
heard
record
supports
conclusion
jails
penitentiaries
include
among
inmates
high
percentage
persons
totally
functionally
illiterate
whose
educational
attainments
slight
whose
intelligence
limited
appears
equally
true
tennessee
prison
facilities
federal
courts
practice
appoint
counsel
proceedings
petition
relief
passes
initial
judicial
evaluation
determined
issues
presented
calling
evidentiary
hearing
taylor
pegelow
cir
ex
rel
marshall
wilkins
cir
see
sokol
handbook
federal
habeas
corpus
held
general
obligation
courts
state
federal
appoint
counsel
prisoners
indicate
without
wish
seek
relief
see
barker
ohio
cir
accordingly
initial
burden
presenting
claim
relief
usually
rests
upon
indigent
prisoner
help
obtain
within
prison
walls
prison
system
case
except
able
help
usually
old
hands
exceptionally
gifted
prisoners
prisoner
effect
denied
access
courts
unless
help
available
indisputable
prison
writ
writers
like
petitioner
sometimes
menace
prison
discipline
petitions
often
unskillful
burden
courts
receive
held
ex
parte
hull
supra
declaring
invalid
state
prison
regulation
required
prisoners
legal
pleadings
screened
state
officials
considerations
prompted
regulation
formulation
without
merit
state
officers
may
abridge
impair
petitioner
right
apply
federal
writ
habeas
corpus
obviously
far
short
showing
required
demonstrate
depriving
prisoners
assistance
fellow
inmates
tennessee
substance
deprived
unable
reasonable
adequacy
prepare
petitions
access
constitutionally
statutorily
protected
availability
writ
habeas
corpus
contrast
several
public
defender
system
supplies
trained
attorneys
paid
public
funds
available
consult
prisoners
regarding
habeas
corpus
petitions
least
one
state
employs
senior
law
students
interview
advise
inmates
state
prisons
another
state
voluntary
program
whereby
members
local
bar
association
make
periodic
visits
prison
consult
prisoners
concerning
cases
express
judgment
concerning
plans
existence
indicates
techniques
available
provide
alternatives
state
elects
prohibit
mutual
assistance
among
inmates
even
absence
alternatives
state
may
impose
reasonable
restrictions
restraints
upon
acknowledged
propensity
prisoners
abuse
giving
seeking
assistance
preparation
applications
relief
example
limitations
time
location
activities
imposition
punishment
giving
receipt
consideration
connection
activities
cf
hatfield
bailleaux
cir
sustaining
reasonable
regulations
time
location
prisoner
work
petitions
unless
state
provides
reasonable
alternative
assist
inmates
preparation
petitions
relief
may
validly
enforce
regulation
issue
barring
inmates
furnishing
assistance
prisoners
judgment
appeals
reversed
case
remanded
proceedings
consistent
opinion
reversed
remanded
footnotes
fay
noia
see
note
constitutional
law
prison
regulations
jailhouse
lawyer
duke
tennessee
department
correction
departmental
report
fiscal
years
tennessee
procedure
provides
appointment
counsel
necessary
code
ann
supp
see
spector
prison
librarian
looks
rev
note
supra
see
also
rossmoore
koenigsberg
habeas
corpus
indigent
prisoner
rutgers
rev
time
second
hearing
petitioner
case
warden
testified
state
considering
setting
program
senior
law
students
vanderbilt
law
school
assist
prisoners
preparation
relief
applications
whatever
may
worth
petitioner
testified
stop
helping
inmates
system
existence
one
state
designated
inmate
official
prison
see
note
supra
reversing
district
appeals
relied
power
state
restrict
practice
law
licensed
attorneys
source
authority
prison
regulation
power
control
practice
law
exercised
abrogate
federally
protected
rights
naacp
button
sperry
florida
event
type
activity
involved
preparation
petitions
relief
though
historically
traditionally
one
may
benefit
services
trained
dedicated
lawyer
function
often
perhaps
generally
performed
laymen
title
apparently
contemplates
many
situations
petitions
federal
habeas
corpus
relief
prepared
laymen
justice
douglas
concurring
join
opinion
add
words
emphasis
important
thesis
case
increasing
complexities
governmental
apparatus
local
federal
levels
made
difficult
person
process
claim
even
make
complaint
social
security
virtual
maze
hierarchy
governs
urban
housing
often
intricate
takes
expert
know
agency
jurisdiction
particular
complaint
office
call
official
see
noise
abatement
broken
sewer
line
fallen
tree
mystery
many
metropolitan
areas
person
claim
assertable
faraway
washington
even
helpless
evidenced
increasing
tendency
constituents
rely
congressional
delegation
identify
press
process
claims
think
claims
grist
mill
lawyers
becoming
abundantly
clear
effort
ferreting
basis
claims
agencies
responsible
preparing
almost
endless
paperwork
prosecution
work
laymen
enough
lawyers
manage
supervise
affairs
much
basic
work
done
requires
special
legal
talent
yet
philosophy
legal
profession
cuts
drastically
active
roles
laymen
expressed
new
york
denying
application
neighborhood
legal
services
permission
offer
broad
type
service
indigents
legal
assistance
corporation
supported
federal
antipoverty
funds
executive
staff
responsibility
hire
discharge
staff
top
lowest
lay
echelon
must
lawyers
matter
action
legal
services
app
div
poverty
lawyers
overworked
work
delegated
new
york
law
permits
senior
law
students
practice
law
certain
supervised
conditions
approval
must
first
granted
appellate
division
rung
two
lower
legal
profession
ladder
laymen
legal
technicians
comparable
nurses
lab
assistants
medical
profession
large
law
firms
employ
seems
reason
used
legal
services
programs
relieve
attorneys
professional
tasks
samore
legal
services
poor
albany
rev
plight
man
prison
may
respects
even
acute
plight
person
outside
may
need
collateral
proceedings
test
legality
detention
relief
management
parole
system
defective
detainers
lodged
create
burdens
nature
incarcerated
status
may
grievances
civil
nature
outside
prison
imprisonment
may
give
wife
grounds
divorce
factor
determining
custody
children
may
pressing
social
security
workmen
compensation
veterans
claims
demand
legal
counsel
prison
heavy
supply
light
private
matters
civil
nature
legal
counsel
indigent
prison
almost
even
criminal
proceedings
sparse
statutes
providing
counsel
like
california
appoint
counsel
represent
indigent
prisoner
collateral
hearings
succeeds
making
prima
facie
case
result
counsel
hand
preparation
papers
initial
decision
prisoner
claim
substance
many
think
prisoner
needs
help
early
stage
weed
frivolous
claims
legal
aid
societies
sponsored
part
national
legal
aid
defender
association
provide
counsel
prisoners
legal
aid
offices
however
many
pressing
obligations
civil
criminal
nature
communities
among
freemen
able
provide
satisfactory
assistance
prisoners
thing
true
neighborhood
legal
services
offices
see
function
providing
legal
counsel
particular
community
member
leaves
soon
taken
prison
cases
state
public
defenders
represent
man
even
passes
beyond
prison
walls
often
public
defender
general
authorization
process
matters
experimented
programs
designed
especially
prison
community
bureau
prisons
led
way
program
allowing
senior
law
students
service
federal
penitentiary
leavenworth
kansas
since
encouraged
similar
programs
lewisburg
university
pennsylvania
law
school
elsewhere
emory
university
school
law
provides
free
legal
assistance
inmates
atlanta
federal
penitentiary
program
law
school
university
california
los
angeles
reach
inside
federal
prisons
describing
university
kansas
law
school
program
leavenworth
legal
counsel
bureau
prisons
said
experience
leavenworth
shown
attacks
upon
prison
administration
prospective
frivolous
litigation
screened
law
school
felt
prisoner
good
cause
action
relief
granted
great
percentage
cases
large
part
activity
disposing
long
outstanding
detainers
lodged
inmates
addition
program
handles
civil
matters
domestic
relations
problems
compensation
claims
even
tangible
success
fact
inmate
someone
outside
listen
analyze
problems
beneficial
effect
think
programs
beneficial
inmates
students
staff
courts
government
fails
provide
prison
legal
counsel
demands
prison
generates
community
illiteracy
mental
deficiency
notoriously
high
enough
ask
prisoner
lawyer
without
assistance
fellow
prisoners
meritorious
claims
never
see
light
courtroom
cases
assistance
succeeds
speaks
even
cases
fails
may
provide
necessary
medium
expression
unusual
subculture
created
criminal
law
wherein
prisoners
exist
creatures
law
use
law
try
reclaim
previously
enjoyed
status
society
upheavals
occurring
american
social
structure
reflected
within
prison
environment
prisoners
real
imagined
grievances
demonstrate
protest
right
peaceably
assemble
denied
avenue
open
prisoners
taking
case
prison
compare
dissenters
outside
prison
many
said
able
make
positive
plans
future
knew
indeterminate
sentences
end
seem
feel
living
vacuum
fates
determined
arbitrarily
rather
rule
law
one
aptly
summed
majority
view
words
arrived
prison
discovered
one
including
prison
officials
knew
long
sentence
resort
fighting
case
keep
psychologically
seeking
relief
courts
pursuing
course
action
relieves
tensions
anxieties
created
indeterminate
sentence
system
cooperation
help
laymen
well
lawyers
necessary
right
easonable
access
courts
available
indigents
among
us
new
york
program
funded
office
economic
opportunity
oeo
noted
first
rejected
new
york
courts
called
community
action
legal
services
finally
approved
new
york
courts
board
directors
lawyers
laymen
pp
reitz
federal
habeas
corpus
postconviction
remedy
state
prisoners
rev
hubanks
linde
legal
services
indigent
imprisoned
legal
aid
briefcase
temin
report
postconviction
services
county
prison
legal
aid
briefcase
note
constitutional
law
prison
regulations
jailhouse
lawyer
duke
silverstein
defense
poor
criminal
cases
american
state
courts
preliminary
summary
amer
bar
foundation
note
legal
services
poor
mass
legal
services
symposium
catholic
law
note
legal
services
prison
inmates
rev
uelmen
relief
federal
prisoners
survey
suggestion
rev
rev
rev
stat
comment
right
counsel
criminal
review
proceedings
rev
see
people
shipman
cal
note
indigent
right
counsel
collateral
proceedings
california
people
shipman
rev
lawyers
generally
require
least
fifty
dollar
fee
travel
prisons
consult
prisoner
ones
able
pay
sum
must
resort
next
best
course
action
act
lawyers
disadvantages
prisoner
obvious
lawyer
examining
prisoner
transcripts
conducting
independent
investigation
facts
immediately
advise
course
action
lacking
money
hire
lawyer
prisoner
must
spend
considerable
time
researching
law
preparing
required
legal
documents
filing
sometimes
years
pass
prisoner
discovers
lawyer
told
several
weeks
case
either
lacks
merit
prisoners
militantly
prosecuted
frivolous
actions
wasted
time
devoted
preparing
release
prison
state
shouldering
indigent
prisoners
responsibility
acting
counsel
dissipated
taxpayers
money
wasted
manpower
costs
larsen
prisoner
looks
rev
note
legal
services
poor
mass
note
representation
indigent
criminal
defendants
federal
district
courts
harv
rev
note
representation
indigents
california
field
study
public
defender
assigned
counsel
systems
stan
rev
gardiner
defects
present
legal
aid
service
remedies
rev
note
prisoner
assistance
federal
habeas
corpus
petitions
stan
rev
legal
services
symposium
catholic
law
mancuso
public
defender
system
state
california
barkin
impact
changing
law
upon
prison
policy
prison
see
matter
cornell
legal
aid
clinic
app
div
wilson
legal
assistance
project
leavenworth
legal
aid
briefcase
note
supra
note
representation
indigent
criminal
defendants
federal
district
courts
harv
rev
note
representation
indigents
california
field
study
public
defender
assigned
counsel
systems
stan
rev
sokol
handbook
federal
habeas
corpus
larsen
prisoner
looks
rev
note
supra
freund
remarks
symposium
habeas
corpus
proposals
reform
utah
rev
larsen
prisoner
looks
rev
reasonable
access
courts
right
secured
constitution
laws
guaranteed
state
action
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
far
access
state
prisoners
federal
courts
concerned
right
recognized
ex
parte
hull
right
access
state
prisoners
state
courts
recognized
white
ragen
hatfield
bailleaux
cir
justice
white
justice
black
joins
dissenting
true
majority
says
habeas
corpus
great
writ
access
courts
denied
simply
man
indigent
illiterate
also
true
illiterate
poorly
educated
inexperienced
indigent
adequately
help
unless
secures
aid
source
effectively
denied
opportunity
present
courts
may
valid
claims
relief
mind
matters
seem
clear
argument
rules
unless
state
provides
reasonably
adequate
alternative
may
enforce
rule
inmates
furnishing
help
others
preparing
petitions
say
many
words
apparently
extent
state
duty
interfere
indigents
seeking
advice
prisoners
seems
however
unless
help
indigent
gets
inmates
reasonably
adequate
task
surely
effectively
barred
courts
accorded
help
may
help
effectively
refuse
indigent
pay
actually
fellow
inmate
competent
help
realities
prison
life
leave
indigent
mercies
advising
others
event
problem
incompetent
needing
help
exacerbated
difficulty
courts
dealing
mounting
flow
inadequate
misconceived
petitions
majority
admits
indisputable
jailhouse
lawyers
like
petitioner
sometimes
menace
prison
discipline
petitions
often
unskillful
burden
courts
receive
putting
mildly
disciplinary
problems
severe
burden
courts
serious
disadvantages
prisoner
clients
jailhouse
lawyer
unacceptable
although
jailhouse
lawyers
doubt
capable
necessarily
best
amateur
legal
minds
devoted
jailhouse
lawyering
rather
aggressive
domineering
personalities
may
predominate
may
best
claims
relief
served
clients
weaker
gullible
many
assert
aim
jailhouse
lawyer
service
truth
justice
rather
profit
power
according
prison
officials
whose
expertise
matters
given
consideration
jailhouse
lawyer
often
succeeds
establishing
power
structure
quite
apart
formal
system
warden
guards
trusties
prison
seeks
maintain
jailhouse
lawyer
serves
may
come
morally
sway
one
hope
release
repay
obedience
minor
gifts
favors
available
client
refuses
pay
violence
may
result
jailhouse
lawyer
may
aided
clients
expected
petitions
emerge
process
highest
quality
codes
ethics
champerty
maintenance
frequently
little
meaning
jailhouse
lawyer
solicits
business
vigorously
petition
outright
lies
may
serve
jailhouse
lawyer
purpose
since
procuring
prisoner
client
short
trip
jail
hearing
contentions
petition
writer
credibility
convicts
improved
habeas
corpus
petitions
majority
notes
relatively
easy
prepare
need
set
facts
giving
rise
claim
relief
judge
apply
law
appointing
lawyer
prisoner
giving
hearing
appropriate
fact
buttress
unregulated
jailhouse
lawyer
system
undermines
extent
easy
state
claim
prisoner
need
submit
mercies
jailhouse
lawyer
extent
difficult
necessary
understand
one
rights
possible
set
petition
facts
support
may
fellow
prisoner
adequate
task
well
informed
articulate
prisoners
necessarily
give
advice
aid
altruism
two
qualities
combined
one
man
sometimes
perfectly
adequate
source
help
jails
characteristically
populated
intelligent
benign
capable
altruists
must
rare
indeed
hand
jailhouse
clients
illiterate
whether
illiterate
others
unable
prepare
petitions
need
help
doubt
problem
indigent
convict
solved
subjecting
false
hopes
dominance
inept
representation
average
unsupervised
jailhouse
lawyer
say
therefore
petitioner
johnson
convicted
rapist
serving
life
sentence
whose
prison
conduct
state
wide
discretion
regulating
disciplined
violating
prison
rule
aiding
prisoners
seeking
relief
particularly
showing
prisoner
tennessee
state
penitentiary
denied
access
courts
johnson
confined
services
need
johnson
competent
give
advice
offers
prisoner
testified
johnson
person
available
write
writ
guards
prison
functionaries
furnish
necessary
help
really
prisoner
client
rights
jailhouse
lawyer
need
protection
problem
indigent
ignorant
convict
seeking
relief
substantial
think
better
course
effect
sanction
encourage
spontaneous
jailhouse
lawyer
systems
decide
matter
directly
case
man
needs
help
case
rule
state
must
provide
access
courts
ensuring
help
reasonably
adequate
assistance
preparing
papers
ideally
perhaps
professional
help
furnished
prisoners
encouraged
seek
possible
claims
receive
early
complete
examination
inclined
agree
justice
douglas
neither
practical
necessary
require
help
lawyers
opinions
case
indicate
alternatives
various
burden
impossible
discharge
requirement
might
even
met
establishment
system
regulated
trusties
prison
advise
prisoners
legal
rights
selection
jailhouse
lawyers
prison
officials
scholarship
character
might
assure
inmate
client
received
advice
actually
help
regulation
practice
authorities
reduce
likelihood
coerced
fees
blackmail
legislative
judgment
sustained
concluding
evils
jailhouse
lawyering
justify
proscription
might
also
support
legislative
conclusion
jailhouse
lawyering
carefully
controlled
conditions
satisfies
prisoner
constitutional
right
help
regretfully
therefore
dissent
krause
lawyer
looks
rev
spector
prison
librarian
looks
rev
note
constitutional
law
prison
regulations
jailhouse
lawyer
duke
note
legal
services
prison
inmates
rev
note
prisoner
assistance
federal
habeas
corpus
petitions
stan
rev