bass
argued
october
decided
december
respondent
convicted
possessing
firearms
violation
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
provides
person
convicted
felony
receives
possesses
transports
commerce
affecting
commerce
firearm
shall
punished
prescribed
therein
indictment
allege
attempt
made
show
firearms
involved
possessed
commerce
affecting
commerce
government
contending
statute
require
proof
connection
interstate
commerce
individual
cases
involving
possession
receipt
doubting
constitutionality
statute
thus
construed
appeals
reversed
held
clear
language
legislative
history
whether
receipt
possession
firearm
convicted
felon
shown
individual
prosecution
connected
interstate
commerce
ambiguity
provision
criminal
statute
one
whose
broad
construction
define
federal
offense
conduct
readily
proscribed
must
therefore
resolved
favor
narrower
reading
nexus
interstate
commerce
must
shown
respect
three
offenses
embraced
provision
pp
affirmed
marshall
delivered
opinion
douglas
brennan
except
part
iii
stewart
white
joined
brennan
filed
separate
statement
post
blackmun
filed
dissenting
opinion
burger
joined
post
roger
pauley
argued
cause
brief
solicitor
general
griswold
assistant
attorney
general
wilson
samuel
huntington
beatrice
rosenberg
william
hellerstein
appointment
argued
cause
respondent
brief
phylis
skloot
bamberger
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
respondent
convicted
southern
district
new
york
possessing
firearms
violation
title
vii
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
app
pertinent
part
statute
reads
person
convicted
state
political
subdivision
thereof
felony
receives
possesses
transports
commerce
affecting
commerce
firearm
shall
fined
imprisoned
two
years
conviction
respondent
unsuccessfully
moved
arrest
judgment
two
primary
grounds
statute
reach
possession
firearm
shown
commerce
affecting
commerce
congress
overstepped
constitutional
powers
commerce
clause
supp
appeals
reversed
conviction
view
government
construction
statute
accepted
substantial
doubt
statute
constitutionality
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
among
lower
courts
proper
reach
statute
affirm
judgment
substantially
different
reasons
conclude
ambiguous
critical
respect
sanctions
criminal
government
broader
reading
statute
mark
major
inroad
domain
traditionally
left
refuse
adopt
broad
reading
absence
clearer
direction
congress
wishing
give
point
quip
legislative
history
doubtful
go
statute
begin
looking
text
critical
textual
question
whether
statutory
phrase
commerce
affecting
commerce
applies
possesses
receives
well
transports
government
must
prove
essential
element
offense
possession
receipt
transportation
commerce
affecting
commerce
burden
undertaken
prosecution
possession
statute
read
well
either
view
natural
construction
language
suggests
clause
commerce
affecting
commerce
qualifies
three
antecedents
list
porto
rico
railway
light
power
mor
since
commerce
affecting
commerce
undeniably
applies
least
one
antecedent
since
makes
sense
three
plausible
construction
fact
applies
three
although
beginning
argument
certainly
neither
overwhelming
decisive
significant
respect
however
language
statute
provide
support
respondent
reading
undeniably
phrase
commerce
affecting
commerce
part
transports
offense
phrase
applies
transports
statute
curious
reach
permitting
transportation
firearm
unless
transported
commerce
affecting
commerce
statute
prohibit
possessions
firearms
interstate
intrastate
receipts
since
virtually
transportations
whether
interstate
intrastate
involve
accompanying
possession
receipt
odd
indeed
argue
one
hand
statute
reaches
possessions
receipts
hand
outlaws
interstate
transportations
even
assuming
person
transport
firearm
statute
without
possessing
receiving
reason
consistent
discernible
purpose
statute
apply
interstate
commerce
requirement
transports
offense
alone
short
government
convincing
explanation
inclusion
clause
commerce
affecting
commerce
phrase
applies
word
transports
far
likely
phrase
meant
apply
possesses
receives
well
transports
noted
inclusion
phrase
mirror
approach
federal
criminal
jurisdiction
reflected
many
federal
statutes
nevertheless
government
argues
reading
preferred
defendant
narrower
interpretation
make
title
vii
redundant
title
iv
act
title
iv
inter
alia
makes
crime
four
categories
people
including
convicted
crime
punishable
term
exceeding
one
year
ship
transport
firearm
ammunition
interstate
foreign
commerce
receive
firearm
ammunition
shipped
transported
interstate
foreign
commerce
senator
long
sponsor
title
vii
represented
senator
dodd
sponsor
title
iv
title
vii
indeed
complement
title
iv
cong
rec
see
also
cong
rec
respondent
reading
title
vii
fully
consistent
view
first
although
subsections
two
titles
address
prohibitions
people
statute
also
reaches
substantial
groups
people
reached
secondly
title
vii
complements
title
iv
punishing
broader
class
behavior
even
respondent
view
title
vii
offense
made
firearm
possessed
received
commerce
affecting
commerce
however
title
iv
apparently
reach
possessions
intrastate
transactions
even
interstate
commerce
nexus
limited
sending
receiving
firearms
part
interstate
transportation
addition
whatever
reading
adopted
title
vii
title
iv
part
redundant
interstate
commerce
requirement
title
vii
minimally
applies
transportation
since
title
iv
also
prohibits
convicted
criminals
transporting
firearms
interstate
commerce
two
titles
overlap
readings
government
broader
reading
title
vii
eliminate
redundancy
simply
creates
larger
area
overlap
government
stronger
ground
reading
necessary
give
title
vii
unique
independent
thrust
case
event
circumstances
surrounding
passage
title
vii
make
plain
title
vii
carefully
molded
complement
title
iv
title
vii
senate
amendment
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
amendment
hastily
passed
little
discussion
hearings
report
notion
enacted
dovetail
neatly
title
iv
rests
perhaps
conception
model
legislative
process
pretend
statutes
model
statutes
courts
interpret
statute
eye
surrounding
statutory
landscape
ear
harmonizing
potentially
discordant
provisions
guiding
principles
substitutes
congressional
lawmaking
view
conclusion
drawn
title
iv
concerning
correct
interpretation
title
vii
aspects
meager
legislative
history
however
provide
significant
support
government
interpretation
senate
floor
senator
long
introduced
described
various
evils
prompted
statute
evils
included
assassinations
public
figures
threats
operation
businesses
significant
enough
aggregate
affect
commerce
evils
note
thoroughly
mitigated
forbidding
every
possession
firearm
specified
classes
especially
risky
people
regardless
whether
gun
possessed
received
transported
commerce
affecting
commerce
addition
specific
remarks
senator
read
state
amendment
reaches
mere
possession
guns
without
showing
interstate
commerce
nexus
senator
long
never
specifically
says
connection
commerce
need
shown
individual
case
nothing
statements
explains
interstate
commerce
nexus
irrelevant
individual
cases
phrase
commerce
affecting
commerce
statute
even
senator
long
remarks
crystal
clear
us
apparently
crystal
clear
congressional
colleagues
meager
discussion
title
vii
one
congressmen
discussed
amendment
summarized
title
vii
mak
ing
federal
crime
take
possess
receive
firearm
across
state
lines
cong
rec
statement
pollock
short
legislative
history
act
hardly
speaks
clarity
purpose
congress
supposedly
furnishes
courts
order
enable
enforce
true
universal
camera
nlrb
cases
various
remarks
legislators
sufficiently
ambiguous
insofar
narrow
issue
concerned
invite
mutually
destructive
dialectic
much
fcc
columbia
broadcasting
system
taken
together
statutory
materials
inconclusive
central
issue
whether
statutory
phrase
commerce
affecting
commerce
applies
possesses
receives
well
transports
standing
alone
legislative
history
might
tip
government
favor
respondent
explains
far
better
presence
critical
language
statute
government
concedes
statute
model
logic
clarity
pet
cert
seiz
ing
every
thing
aid
derived
fisher
cranch
marshall
left
ambiguous
statute
ii
given
ambiguity
adopt
narrower
reading
phrase
commerce
affecting
commerce
part
three
offenses
present
conviction
must
set
aside
government
failed
show
requisite
nexus
interstate
commerce
result
dictated
two
wise
principles
long
followed
first
recently
reaffirmed
ambiguity
concerning
ambit
criminal
statutes
resolved
favor
lenity
rewis
see
also
ladner
bell
five
gambling
devices
plurality
opinion
affirmance
various
ways
years
stated
choice
made
two
readings
conduct
congress
made
crime
appropriate
choose
harsher
alternative
require
congress
spoken
language
clear
definite
universal
credit
principle
founded
two
policies
long
part
tradition
first
fair
warning
given
world
language
common
world
understand
law
intends
certain
line
passed
make
warning
fair
far
possible
line
clear
mcboyle
holmes
see
also
cardiff
second
seriousness
criminal
penalties
criminal
punishment
usually
represents
moral
condemnation
community
legislatures
courts
define
criminal
activity
policy
embodies
instinctive
distaste
men
languishing
prison
unless
lawmaker
clearly
said
friendly
justice
frankfurter
reading
statutes
benchmarks
thus
ambiguity
criminal
statute
doubts
resolved
favor
defendant
conclude
congress
plainly
unmistakably
gradwell
made
federal
crime
convicted
felon
simply
possess
gun
absent
demonstrated
nexus
interstate
commerce
second
principle
supporting
today
result
unless
congress
conveys
purpose
clearly
deemed
significantly
changed
balance
congress
traditionally
reluctant
define
federal
crime
conduct
readily
denounced
criminal
congressional
policy
rooted
concepts
american
federalism
provided
basis
doctrines
see
younger
harris
emphasized
last
term
rewis
supra
quick
assume
congress
meant
effect
significant
change
sensitive
relation
federal
state
criminal
jurisdiction
traditionally
sensitive
areas
legislation
affecting
federal
balance
requirement
clear
statement
assures
legislature
fact
faced
intended
bring
issue
critical
matters
involved
judicial
decision
rewis
declined
accept
expansive
interpretation
travel
act
said
alter
sensitive
relationships
overextend
limited
federal
police
resources
noted
us
weigh
merits
factors
went
conclude
fact
even
discussed
legislative
history
strongly
suggests
congress
intend
statute
broad
reach
instant
case
broad
construction
urged
government
renders
traditionally
local
criminal
conduct
matter
federal
enforcement
also
involve
substantial
extension
federal
police
resources
absent
proof
interstate
commerce
nexus
case
dramatically
intrudes
upon
traditional
state
criminal
jurisdiction
rewis
legislative
history
provides
scanty
basis
concluding
congress
faced
serious
questions
meant
affect
balance
way
claimed
government
absent
clearer
statement
intention
congress
present
interpret
reach
mere
possession
firearms
iii
concluded
commerce
requirement
must
read
part
possesses
receives
offenses
add
final
word
nexus
interstate
commerce
must
shown
individual
cases
government
obviously
meet
burden
variety
ways
note
example
person
possesses
commerce
affecting
commerce
time
offense
gun
moving
interstate
interstate
facility
possession
affects
commerce
significantly
broader
reach
however
offense
receiv
ing
commerce
affecting
commerce
conclude
government
meets
burden
demonstrates
firearm
received
previously
traveled
interstate
commerce
narrowest
possible
reading
statute
canons
clear
statement
strict
construction
mean
every
criminal
statute
must
given
narrowest
possible
meaning
complete
disregard
purpose
legislature
bramblett
resolved
basic
uncertainty
statute
favor
narrow
reading
concluding
commerce
affecting
commerce
part
offense
possessing
receiving
firearm
given
evils
prompted
statute
basic
legislative
purpose
restricting
activity
convicted
felons
readings
give
commerce
requirement
although
narrow
appropriate
consistent
regard
sensitive
relation
federal
state
criminal
jurisdiction
reading
preserves
element
offenses
requirement
suited
federal
criminal
jurisdiction
alone
judgment
affirmed
footnotes
respondent
acquitted
another
count
charging
carrying
firearm
commission
felony
sale
narcotic
drug
federal
offense
date
six
circuits
numerous
district
courts
decided
issue
government
view
adopted
cabbler
cert
denied
donofrio
stevens
one
judge
dissenting
synnes
daniels
result
reached
second
circuit
case
also
reached
harbin
supp
nd
ind
steed
cr
wd
may
phelps
cr
md
francis
cr
ed
light
disposition
case
reach
question
whether
upon
appropriate
findings
congress
constitutionally
punish
mere
possession
firearms
thus
need
consider
relevance
connection
recent
decision
perez
question
whether
definition
felony
creates
classification
violating
fifth
amendment
raised
government
petition
certiorari
also
considered
frankfurter
reflections
reading
statutes
rev
compare
standard
brewery
ftc
mandel
brothers
see
also
sutherland
statutory
construction
ed
llewellyn
common
law
tradition
government
noting
comma
transports
argues
punctuation
indicates
congressional
intent
limit
qualifying
phrase
last
antecedent
many
leading
grammarians
sometimes
noting
commas
end
series
avoid
ambiguity
concede
use
commas
discretionary
see
evans
evans
dictionary
contemporary
american
usage
nicholson
dictionary
usage
copperud
dictionary
usage
style
cf
strunk
white
elements
style
grammarians
divided
surely
cheerfully
tolerant
attach
significance
omitted
comma
enough
say
statute
punctuation
fully
consistent
respondent
interpretation
case
grammatical
expertise
help
clarify
statute
meaning
government
urges
transports
includes
act
causing
firearm
transported
therefore
connote
offense
separate
cases
receives
possesses
government
argues
congress
might
felt
broader
scope
term
transports
compared
terms
receives
possesses
justified
qualification
interstate
commerce
requirement
brief
government
view
comparative
breadth
various
offenses
certainly
follow
definition
transports
beyond
argument
congress
might
felt
purely
speculative
finds
support
arguable
purpose
statute
certainly
basis
concluding
congress
less
concerned
transporting
supplying
guns
acquisition
see
prostitution
travel
act
robbery
extortion
strikebreaking
kidnaping
gambling
explosives
et
seq
antitrust
securities
fraud
title
vii
limits
activity
convicted
felons
dishonorable
dischargers
armed
services
persons
adjudged
mentally
incompetent
aliens
illegally
country
former
citizens
renounced
citizenship
see
supra
felony
defined
offense
punishable
imprisonment
term
exceeding
one
year
include
offense
one
involving
firearm
explosive
classified
misdemeanor
laws
state
punishable
term
imprisonment
two
years
less
app
title
iv
reaches
persons
indictment
convicted
crime
punishable
imprisonment
term
exceeding
one
year
fugitives
justice
users
addicts
various
drugs
persons
adjudicated
mental
defective
committed
mental
institution
title
iv
modified
recodified
version
ed
stat
turn
amended
original
statute
passed
stat
amendment
enlarged
group
people
coming
within
act
substantive
prohibitions
transportation
receipt
firearms
interstate
commerce
wording
substantive
offense
remained
identical
although
original
act
provision
possession
firearm
shall
presumptive
evidence
firearm
ammunition
shipped
transported
received
interstate
foreign
commerce
presumption
struck
tot
noted
act
confined
receipt
firearms
ammunition
part
interstate
transportation
extend
receipt
intrastate
transaction
articles
prior
time
transported
interstate
reach
title
iv
question
decided
finally
day
government
presented
learning
evidence
indicating
act
changed
prior
approach
receipt
offense
see
omnibus
crime
control
safe
streets
act
started
life
measure
designed
aid
state
local
governments
law
enforcement
means
financial
administrative
assistance
see
sess
bill
passed
house
august
went
senate
similar
bill
introduced
senate
went
committee
judiciary
rewrote
completely
see
supra
amendments
included
provisions
regarding
admissibility
confessions
wiretapping
state
firearms
control
may
senator
long
introduced
floor
amendment
designated
title
vii
introductory
remarks
set
forth
purpose
amendment
cong
rec
week
later
explained
amendment
brief
debate
reaction
favorable
cautious
thought
study
suggested
several
favorably
inclined
senators
observed
problems
bill
drafted
unexpectedly
however
call
vote
title
vii
passed
without
modification
see
cong
rec
amendment
received
passing
mention
house
discussion
bill
cong
rec
never
received
committee
consideration
study
house
either
see
cong
rec
example
senator
long
began
floor
statement
announcing
prepared
amendment
offer
appropriate
time
simply
setting
forth
fact
anybody
convicted
felony
comes
within
certain
categories
permitted
possess
firearm
cong
rec
additional
reasons
contains
congressional
findings
applicable
decisive
support
government
section
reports
congress
hereby
finds
declares
receipt
possession
transportation
firearm
felons
veterans
discharged
dishonorable
conditions
mental
incompetents
aliens
illegally
country
former
citizens
renounced
citizenship
constitutes
burden
commerce
threat
affecting
free
flow
commerce
threat
safety
president
vice
president
impediment
threat
exercise
free
speech
free
exercise
religion
guaranteed
first
amendment
constitution
threat
continued
effective
operation
government
government
state
guaranteed
article
iv
constitution
government
argues
findings
wholly
unnecessary
unless
congress
intended
prohibit
receipts
possessions
firearms
felons
findings
burdens
threats
simply
state
congress
view
constitutional
basis
power
act
findings
tell
us
much
congress
perceived
power
fact
invoked
findings
fact
support
statute
broader
one
actually
passed
suggested
fact
commerce
affecting
commerce
appear
introductory
clause
findings
even
though
contains
phrase
concededly
reaches
transportation
commerce
affecting
commerce
holmes
prefaced
statement
observation
likely
criminal
carefully
consider
text
law
murders
steals
case
gun
acquisition
possession
unreasonable
imagine
citizen
attempting
steer
careful
course
violation
statute
lawful
conduct
hood
course
state
law
prohibiting
felons
possessing
firearms
new
york
state
penal
law
supp
may
unreal
argue
notice
problems
federal
law
many
however
laws
prohibiting
felons
possessing
firearms
see
geisel
roll
wettick
effectiveness
state
local
regulation
handguns
statistical
analysis
duke
since
limited
federal
gun
control
laws
notice
problem
law
may
quite
real
apex
hosiery
leader
five
gambling
devices
plurality
opinion
ftc
bunte
frankfurter
reflections
reading
statutes
rev
cf
auto
workers
wisconsin
board
palmer
massachusetts
leiter
minerals
hart
sacks
legal
process
basic
problems
making
application
law
tent
ed
reading
preserves
significant
difference
receipt
offenses
title
iv
title
vii
see
supra
justice
blackmun
chief
justice
joins
dissenting
join
opinion
judgment
five
six
courts
appeals
passed
upon
issue
presented
case
decided
adversely
position
urged
respondent
cabbler
cert
denied
mullins
donofrio
stevens
one
judge
dissenting
synnes
wiley
taylor
daniels
crow
second
circuit
stands
opposed
statute
app
speaks
one
receives
possesses
transports
commerce
affecting
commerce
although
arguably
ambiguous
government
concedes
model
logic
clarity
clear
enough
structure
vital
language
punctuation
make
refer
one
receives
one
possesses
one
transports
commerce
one
wished
say
welcome
cat
welcome
dog
welcome
cow
jumps
moon
likely
say
like
cat
dog
cow
jumps
moon
meaning
implants
statute
justified
addition
interposition
comma
word
transports
perceive
warrant
judicial
transfiguration
statute
phrase
date
enactment
act
separated
commas
undeniably
modifies
preceding
words
receives
possesses
transports
obviously
draftsman
congress
knew
use
commas
phrase
modification
give
effect
meaning
attendant
upon
use
specific
finding
app
clearly
demonstrates
congress
attempting
reach
prohibit
every
possession
firearm
felon
congress
found
possession
whether
interstate
intrastate
affected
interstate
commerce
congress
conclude
intrastate
possession
matter
less
concern
interstate
possession
finding
unnecessary
congress
also
required
proof
receipt
possession
firearm
affected
interstate
foreign
commerce
senator
long
explanatory
comments
reveal
clearly
purpose
intent
extent
legislation
prepared
amendment
offer
appropriate
time
simply
setting
forth
fact
anybody
convicted
felony
permitted
possess
firearm
might
well
analyze
moment
logic
involved
man
convicted
felony
unless
bill
sets
forth
expressly
pardoned
president
pardon
person
permitted
possess
firearms
future
man
right
possess
firearms
punished
criminally
found
possession
cong
rec
emphasis
supplied
congress
simply
finds
possession
weapons
wrong
kind
people
either
burden
commerce
threat
affects
free
flow
commerce
business
area
certainly
much
well
like
order
business
go
street
burglars
murderers
arsonists
armed
teeth
innocent
citizens
threat
certainly
affects
free
flow
commerce
cong
rec
emphasis
supplied
amendment
seeks
make
unlawful
firearm
handgun
machinegun
rifle
kind
firearm
possession
convicted
felon
pardoned
therefore
lost
right
possess
firearms
also
relates
transportation
firearms
clauses
describe
persons
actions
demonstrated
dangerous
may
become
dangerous
stated
simply
may
trusted
possess
firearm
without
becoming
threat
society
title
apply
hand
guns
long
guns
murderers
shown
violent
tendencies
committed
crime
infamous
permitted
possess
gun
yet
federal
law
deny
possession
undesirables
killer
medgar
evers
murderer
three
civil
rights
workers
mississippi
defendants
shot
captain
lemuel
penn
highway
driving
back
washington
completion
reserve
military
duty
free
present
federal
law
acquire
another
gun
repeat
sorts
crimes
future
title
vii
every
citizen
possess
gun
commission
first
felony
upon
conviction
however
title
vii
deny
every
assassin
murderer
thief
burglar
right
possess
firearm
future
except
pardoned
president
state
governor
expressly
authorized
pardon
possess
firearm
said
congress
lacks
power
outlaw
mere
possession
weapons
important
point
legislation
demonstrates
possession
deadly
weapon
wrong
people
controlled
congress
without
regard
police
power
resides
constitution
without
question
federal
government
power
control
possession
weapons
possession
become
threat
interstate
commerce
state
gun
control
laws
exist
proven
inadequate
bar
possession
firearms
likely
use
unlawful
purposes
title
vii
impinge
upon
rights
citizens
generally
possess
firearms
legitimate
lawful
purposes
deals
solely
demonstrated
trusted
possess
firearm
whose
prior
acts
mostly
voluntary
placed
outside
society
convinced
enough
constitutional
power
prohibit
categories
people
possessing
receiving
transporting
firearm
amendment
provide
convicted
felon
participates
one
marches
carrying
firearm
violating
law
cong
rec
emphasis
supplied
construction
limiting
application
interstate
possession
receipt
shrinks
statute
something
little
duplication
ascribe
congress
gesture
nonaccomplishment
thus
conclude
intended
reach
possessions
receipts
firearms
convicted
felons
move
decide
constitutional
issue
present
case
unappealed
district
decisions
conflict
upholding
government
position
include
davis
supp
nd
miss
vicary
cr
ed
june
en
banc
childress
ed
boggs
june
opposed
include
harbin
supp
nd
ind
steed
cr
wd
may
phelps
cr
md
francis
cr
ed
pet
cert
congressional
findings
declaration
congress
hereby
finds
declares
receipt
possession
transportation
firearm
felons
constitutes
burden
commerce
threat
affecting
free
flow
commerce