hampton
argued
march
decided
april
walter
hampton
new
york
city
petitioner
attorney
general
mitchell
sol
washington
chief
justice
taft
delivered
opinion
hampton
made
importation
new
york
barium
dioxide
collector
customs
assessed
dutiable
rate
six
cents
per
pound
two
cents
per
pound
fixed
statute
paragraph
stat
usca
par
rate
raised
collector
virtue
proclamation
president
treas
issued
authority
section
title
tariff
act
september
stat
usca
flexible
tariff
provision
protest
made
appeal
taken
section
part
title
chapter
stat
usca
case
came
hearing
customs
treas
majority
held
act
constitutional
thereafter
case
appealed
customs
appeals
day
october
attorney
general
certified
opinion
case
importance
render
expedient
review
thereafter
judgment
customs
affirmed
cust
app
petition
certiorari
filed
may
writ
granted
june
pertinent
parts
section
title
tariff
act
chapter
stat
tit
usca
follows
order
regulate
foreign
commerce
put
force
effect
policy
congress
act
intended
whenever
president
upon
investigation
differences
costs
production
articles
wholly
part
growth
product
like
similar
articles
wholly
part
growth
product
competing
foreign
countries
shall
find
thereby
shown
duties
fixed
act
equalize
said
differences
costs
production
principal
competing
country
shall
investigation
ascertain
said
differences
determine
proclaim
changes
classifications
increases
decreases
rate
duty
provided
act
shown
said
ascertained
differences
costs
production
necessary
equalize
thirty
days
date
proclamation
proclamations
changes
classification
shall
take
effect
increased
decreased
duties
shall
levied
collected
paid
articles
imported
foreign
country
possessions
except
philippine
islands
virgin
islands
islands
guam
tutuila
provided
total
increase
decrease
rates
duty
shall
exceed
per
centum
rates
specified
title
act
amendatory
act
ascertaining
differences
costs
production
provisions
subsidivisions
section
president
far
finds
practicable
shall
take
consideration
ences
conditions
production
including
wages
costs
material
items
costs
production
similar
articles
competing
foreign
countries
differences
wholesale
selling
prices
domestic
foreign
articles
principal
markets
advantages
granted
foreign
producer
foreign
government
person
partnership
corporation
association
foreign
country
advantages
disadvantages
competition
assist
president
ascertaining
differences
costs
production
section
shall
made
tariff
commission
proclamation
shall
issued
section
investigation
shall
made
commission
shall
give
reasonable
public
notice
hearings
shall
give
reasonable
opportunity
parties
interested
present
produce
evidence
heard
commission
authorized
adopt
reasonable
procedure
rules
regulations
may
deem
necessary
president
proceeding
hereinbefore
provided
proclaiming
rates
duty
shall
determines
shown
differences
costs
production
changed
longer
exist
led
proclamation
accordingly
shown
modify
terminate
nothing
section
shall
construed
authorize
transfer
article
dutiable
list
free
list
free
list
dutiable
list
change
form
duty
whenever
provided
paragraph
title
act
duty
duties
shall
exceed
specified
ad
valorem
rate
upon
articles
provided
paragraph
rate
determined
provision
section
upon
articles
shall
exceed
maximum
ad
valorem
rate
specified
president
issued
proclamation
may
stat
reciting
part
foregoing
section
proclamation
continued
follows
virtue
said
section
said
act
tariff
commission
made
investigation
assist
president
ascertaining
differences
costs
production
facts
conditions
enumerated
said
section
respect
barium
dioxide
course
said
investigation
hearing
held
reasonable
public
notice
given
parties
interested
given
reasonable
opportunity
present
produce
evidence
heard
whereas
president
upon
said
investigation
thereby
found
said
principal
competing
country
germany
duty
fixed
said
title
act
equalize
differences
costs
production
germany
ascertained
determined
increased
rate
duty
necessary
equalize
therefore
calvin
coolidge
president
america
hereby
determine
proclaim
increase
rate
duty
provided
said
act
shown
said
ascertained
differences
said
costs
production
necessary
equalize
follows
increase
said
duty
barium
dioxide
within
limit
total
increase
provided
said
act
cents
per
pound
cents
per
pound
witness
whereof
hereunto
set
hand
caused
seal
affixed
done
city
washington
nineteenth
day
may
year
lord
one
thousand
nine
hundred
independence
america
one
hundred
calvin
coolidge
president
charles
hughes
secretary
state
issue
constitutionality
section
upon
depends
authority
proclamation
president
two
six
cents
per
pound
duty
collected
petitioner
contention
taxpayers
argue
section
invalid
delegation
president
legislative
power
article
constitution
vested
congress
power
declared
section
article
congress
shall
power
lay
collect
taxes
duties
imposts
excises
second
objection
section
enacted
avowed
intent
purpose
protecting
industries
invalid
constitution
gives
power
lay
taxes
revenue
first
seems
clear
congress
intended
section
plan
secure
law
imposition
customs
duties
articles
imported
merchandise
equal
difference
cost
producing
foreign
country
articles
question
laying
sale
cost
producing
selling
like
similar
articles
duties
secure
revenue
time
enable
domestic
producers
compete
terms
equality
foreign
producers
markets
may
difficult
fix
exactness
difference
difference
sought
statute
perfectly
clear
perfectly
intelligible
difficulty
practically
determining
difference
congress
seems
doubted
information
possession
enable
make
adjustment
accurately
also
apprehended
changing
conditions
difference
might
vary
way
readjustments
necessary
give
effect
principle
statute
proceeds
avoid
difficulties
congress
adopted
section
method
describing
clearness
policy
plan
authorizing
member
executive
branch
carry
policy
plan
find
changing
difference
time
time
make
adjustments
necessary
conform
duties
standard
underlying
policy
plan
matter
great
importance
concluded
give
statute
president
chief
executive
branch
function
determining
difference
might
vary
provided
body
investigators
assist
obtaining
needed
data
asscertaining
facts
justifying
readjustments
specific
provision
action
president
might
invoked
act
presumed
president
body
advisers
keep
advised
necessity
investigation
change
proceed
pursue
duties
act
reach
conclusion
might
find
justified
investigation
proclaim
necessary
tariff
commission
fix
duties
president
reaches
conclusion
subject
investigation
tariff
commission
must
make
investigation
must
give
notice
parties
interested
opportunity
adduce
evidence
heard
maxim
potestas
non
potest
delegari
applicable
law
agency
general
common
law
well
understood
wider
application
construction
federal
state
constitutions
private
law
federal
constitution
state
constitutions
country
divide
governmental
power
three
branches
first
legislative
second
executive
third
judicial
rule
actual
administration
government
congress
legislature
exercise
legislative
power
president
state
executive
governor
executive
power
courts
judiciary
judicial
power
carrying
constitutional
division
three
branches
breach
national
fundamental
law
congress
gives
legislative
power
transfers
president
judicial
branch
law
attempts
invest
members
either
executive
power
judicial
power
say
three
branches
parts
one
government
field
duties
may
invoke
action
two
branches
far
action
invoked
shall
assumption
constitutional
field
action
another
branch
determining
may
seeking
assistance
another
branch
extent
character
assistence
must
fixed
according
common
sense
inherent
necessities
governmental
field
congress
involves
many
varieties
legislative
action
congress
found
frequently
necessary
use
officers
executive
branch
within
defined
limits
secure
exact
effect
intended
acts
legislation
vesting
discretion
officers
make
public
regulations
interpreting
statute
directing
details
execution
even
extent
providing
penalizing
breach
regulations
grimaud
union
bridge
buttfield
stranahan
kollock
oceanic
steam
navigation
stranahan
congress
may
feel
unable
conveniently
determine
exactly
exercise
legislative
power
become
effective
dependent
future
conditions
may
leave
determination
time
decision
executive
often
happens
matters
state
legislation
may
left
popular
vote
residents
district
affected
legislation
sense
one
may
say
residents
exercising
legislative
power
exact
statement
power
already
exercised
legislatively
body
vested
power
constitution
condition
legislation
going
effect
made
dependent
legislature
expression
voters
certain
district
judge
ranney
ohio
cincinnati
wilmington
zanesville
railroad
commissioners
ohio
said
case
true
distinction
therefore
delegation
power
make
law
necessarily
involves
discretion
shall
conferring
authority
discretion
execution
exercised
pursuance
law
first
done
latter
valid
objection
made
see
also
moers
reading
locke
appeal
one
great
functions
conferred
congress
federal
constitution
regulation
interstate
commerce
rates
exacted
interstate
carriers
passenger
merchandise
traffic
rates
fixed
myriad
congress
required
fix
every
rate
impossible
exercise
power
therefore
common
sense
requires
fixing
rates
congress
may
provide
mission
called
interstate
commerce
commission
fix
rates
hearing
evidence
argument
concerning
interested
parties
accord
general
rule
congress
first
lays
rates
shall
reasonable
considering
service
given
discriminatory
said
interstate
commerce
commission
goodrich
transit
ed
congress
may
delegate
purely
legislative
power
commission
laid
general
rules
action
commission
shall
proceed
may
require
commission
application
rules
particular
situations
investigation
facts
view
making
orders
particular
matter
within
rules
laid
congress
principle
upon
power
upheld
state
legislation
fixing
railway
rates
admirably
stated
judge
mitchell
case
state
chicago
milwaukee
paul
railway
learned
judge
says
page
power
exercised
satisfactorily
done
board
commission
constantly
session
whose
time
exclusively
given
subject
investigation
facts
fix
rates
reference
peculiar
circumstances
road
particular
kind
business
change
modify
rates
suit
varying
conditions
traffic
legislature
gone
step
others
vested
commission
full
power
determine
rates
equal
reasonable
particular
case
whether
wise
us
say
see
transcended
constitutional
authority
delegated
commission
authority
discretion
law
shall
merely
conferred
upon
authority
discertion
exercised
execution
law
pursuance
entirely
permissible
legislature
passed
upon
expediency
law
shall
commission
intrusted
authority
discretion
upon
questions
see
also
language
justices
miller
bradley
case
chicago
minnesota
ex
rel
railroad
commission
conceded
counsel
congress
may
use
executive
officers
application
enforcement
policy
declared
law
congress
authorize
officers
application
congressional
declaration
enforce
regulation
equivalent
law
said
never
permitted
done
congress
exercised
power
levy
taxes
fix
customs
duties
authorities
make
distinction
principle
permits
congress
exercise
power
interstate
commerce
declaring
rule
shall
prevail
legislative
fixing
rates
enables
remit
body
created
accordance
provisions
fixing
rates
justifies
similar
provision
fixing
customs
duties
imported
merchandise
congress
shall
lay
legislative
act
intelligible
principle
person
body
authorized
fix
rates
directed
conform
legislative
action
forbidden
delegation
legislative
power
thought
wise
vary
customs
duties
according
changing
conditions
production
home
abroad
may
authorize
chief
executive
carry
purpose
advisory
assistance
tariff
commission
appointed
congressional
authority
conclusion
amply
sustained
case
advisory
sion
furnished
case
gave
fullest
consideration
nearly
years
ago
marshall
field
clark
ed
third
section
act
october
stat
contained
provision
view
secure
reciprocal
trade
countries
producing
following
articles
purpose
first
day
january
eighteen
hundred
whenever
often
president
shall
satisfied
government
country
producing
exporting
sugars
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
raw
uncured
articles
imposes
duties
exactions
upon
agricultural
products
view
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
may
deem
reciprocally
unequal
unreasonable
shall
power
shall
duty
suspend
proclamation
effect
provisions
act
relating
free
introduction
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
production
country
time
shall
deem
case
suspension
duties
shall
lived
collected
paid
upon
sugar
molasses
coffee
tea
hides
product
exported
designated
country
follows
namely
followed
certain
rates
duty
imposed
contended
section
delegated
president
legislative
making
powers
unconstitutional
examination
authorities
said
congress
delegate
legislative
power
president
act
real
sense
invest
president
power
legislation
nothing
involving
expendiency
operation
legislation
left
determination
president
legislative
power
exercised
congress
declared
suspension
take
effect
upon
named
contingency
president
required
merely
execution
act
congress
making
law
mere
agent
lawmaking
department
ascertain
declare
event
upon
expressed
take
effect
second
second
objection
section
declared
plan
congress
either
expressly
clear
implication
formulates
rule
guide
president
advisory
tariff
commission
one
directed
tariff
system
protection
avoid
damaging
competition
country
industries
importation
goods
countries
low
rate
equalize
foreign
domestic
competition
markets
contended
power
congress
levying
customs
duties
create
revenue
unconstitutional
frame
customs
duties
view
revenue
raising
undoubtedly
true
political
life
country
much
discussion
parties
wisdom
policy
protection
may
go
say
constitutionality
historian
whatever
view
wisdom
policy
protection
contend
congress
since
first
revenue
act
stat
assumed
within
power
making
provision
collection
revenue
put
taxes
upon
importations
vary
subjects
taxes
rates
effort
encourage
growth
industries
nation
protecting
home
production
foreign
competition
enough
point
second
act
adopted
congress
july
chapter
stat
contained
following
recital
whereas
necessary
support
government
discharge
debts
encouragement
protection
factures
duties
laid
goods
wares
merchandises
imported
enacted
etc
first
congress
sat
many
members
constitutional
convention
repeatedly
laid
principle
contemporaneous
legislative
exposition
constitution
founders
government
framers
constitution
actively
participating
public
affairs
long
acquiesced
fixes
construction
given
provisions
myers
cases
cited
enactment
enforcement
number
customs
revenue
laws
drawn
motive
maintaining
system
protection
since
revenue
law
matters
history
hundred
years
later
titles
tariff
acts
stat
stat
declared
purpose
acts
among
things
encouraging
industries
title
tariff
act
stat
section
part
act
provide
revenue
regulate
commerce
foreign
countries
encourage
industries
purposes
whatever
may
think
wisdom
protection
policy
hold
unconstitutional
long
motive
congress
effect
legislative
action
secure
revenue
benefit
general
government
existence
motives
selection
subjects
taxes
invalidate
congressional
action
said
child
labor
tax
case
ed
occasionally
imposed
discretion
legislature
proper
subjects
primary
motive
obtaining
revenue
incidental
motive
discouraging
making
continuance
onerous
lose
character
taxes
incidental
motive
fact
congress
declares
one
motives
fixing
rates
duty
fix
shall
encourage
industries
country
competition
producers
countries
sale
goods
country
invalidate
revenue
act
framed
section
provisions
within
power
congress
judgment
customs
appeals
affirmed