ford
motor
department
treasury
state
indiana
argued
december
decided
january
merle
miller
indianapolis
petitioner
john
mcshane
winslow
van
horne
indianapolis
appellees
justice
reed
delivered
opinion
writ
brings
review
action
petitioner
resident
foreign
manufacturing
corporation
respondents
department
treasury
state
indiana
clifford
townsend
joseph
robertson
frank
thompson
governor
treasurer
auditor
respectively
state
indiana
constituted
board
department
treasury
petitioner
seeks
refund
gross
income
taxes
paid
department
measured
sales
claimed
state
occurred
indiana
jurisdiction
district
founded
allegations
violation
article
section
commerce
clause
fourteenth
amendment
constitution
state
statutory
procedure
obtaining
refund
petitioner
followed
set
forth
section
indiana
statutes
district
denied
recovery
circuit
appeals
affirmed
certiorari
tioner
assertion
error
circuit
appeals
decided
important
question
local
law
probably
conflict
applicable
decision
indiana
department
treasury
international
harvester
ind
conclude
petitioner
action
maintained
federal
decide
merits
issue
petitioner
right
maintain
action
federal
depends
first
upon
whether
action
state
indiana
individual
secondly
action
state
whether
state
consented
sued
federal
courts
recently
questions
discussed
great
northern
life
insurance
read
case
held
suit
state
official
proceedings
authorized
statute
compel
carry
state
funds
state
agreement
reimburse
moneys
illegally
exacted
color
tax
power
suit
one
state
said
suit
clearly
distinguishable
actions
tax
collector
recover
personal
judgment
money
wrongfully
collected
color
state
law
relief
sought
general
law
wrongful
acts
state
officials
sovereign
immunity
eleventh
amendment
extend
wrongful
individual
action
citizen
allowed
remedy
wrongdoer
personally
atchison
ry
cf
matthews
rodgers
however
action
authorized
statute
state
officer
official
capacity
constituting
action
state
eleventh
amendment
operates
bar
suit
except
far
statute
waives
state
immunity
suit
smith
reeves
great
northern
life
insurance
read
opinion
petitioner
suit
instant
case
department
individuals
board
constitutes
action
state
indiana
state
statute
prescribed
procedure
obtaining
refund
taxes
illegally
exacted
providing
taxpayer
first
file
timely
application
refund
state
department
treasury
upon
denial
claim
taxpayer
authorized
recover
illegal
exaction
action
judgment
obtained
action
satisfied
payment
funds
state
treasury
section
clearly
provides
action
state
opposed
one
collecting
official
individually
state
decision
called
attention
indicate
different
interpretation
statute
adopted
state
courts
petitioner
suit
federal
district
based
indiana
statutes
therefore
constitutes
action
state
collecting
official
individual
petitioner
brought
action
strict
accord
action
state
department
treasury
complaint
carefully
details
compliance
provisions
require
timely
application
refund
department
prerequisite
action
authorized
section
true
petitioner
present
proceeding
joined
governor
treasurer
auditor
state
defendants
constitute
board
department
treasury
state
indiana
joined
collective
sentatives
state
individuals
personal
judgment
sought
petitioner
assert
claim
personal
judgment
individuals
contested
tax
payments
petitioner
claim
imposition
personal
liability
individual
defendants
sums
illegally
exacted
previously
held
nature
suit
one
state
determined
essential
nature
effect
proceeding
ex
parte
ayers
ex
parte
state
new
york
worcester
county
trust
riley
action
essence
one
recovery
money
state
state
real
substantial
party
interest
entitled
invoke
sovereign
immunity
suit
even
though
individual
officials
nominal
defendants
smith
reeves
supra
great
northern
life
insurance
read
supra
opinion
therefore
present
proceedings
brought
reliance
suit
state
remains
considered
whether
state
indiana
consented
action
federal
eleventh
amendment
provides
judicial
power
shall
construed
extend
suit
law
equity
commenced
prosecuted
one
citizens
another
state
citizens
subjects
foreign
state
express
constitutional
limitation
denies
federal
courts
authority
entertain
suit
brought
private
parties
state
without
consent
hans
state
louisiana
ex
parte
state
new
york
state
missouri
fiske
fidelity
guaranty
great
northern
life
insurance
read
supra
state
mutual
life
ins
ind
hogston
bell
ind
state
immunity
suit
may
waived
clark
barnard
gunter
atlantic
coast
line
state
missouri
fiske
nothing
indicate
authorization
waiver
indiana
present
proceeding
section
authorizes
suit
department
competent
jurisdiction
circuit
superior
county
taxpayer
resides
located
shall
original
jurisdiction
action
recover
amount
improperly
collected
read
case
construed
similar
provision
oklahoma
tax
refund
statute
waiver
state
immunity
suit
state
courts
said
case
state
authorizes
suit
justice
taxpayers
deem
injured
exaction
consonant
dual
system
federal
courts
astute
read
consent
embrace
federal
well
state
courts
dealing
sovereign
exemption
judicial
interference
vital
field
financial
administration
clear
declaration
state
intention
submit
fiscal
problems
courts
creation
must
found
cf
shaw
section
contain
clear
indication
state
intended
consent
suit
federal
courts
provision
section
vests
original
jurisdiction
suits
refund
superior
county
taxpayer
resides
located
indicates
state
legislature
contemplated
suit
state
courts
moreover
interpretation
authorize
suits
state
courts
accords
state
legislative
policy
indiana
adopted
liberal
policy
toward
general
contract
claimants
confines
suits
state
state
courts
remains
considered
whether
attorney
general
state
indiana
conduct
present
proceeding
waived
state
immunity
suit
state
attorney
general
authorized
represent
state
actions
brought
indiana
refund
statute
appeared
federal
district
circuit
appeals
defended
suit
merits
objection
petitioner
suit
violation
eleventh
amendment
first
made
argued
indiana
time
however
eleventh
amendment
declares
policy
sets
forth
explicit
limitation
federal
judicial
power
compelling
force
consider
issue
arising
amendment
case
even
though
urged
first
time
conceded
respondents
within
power
administrative
executive
officers
indiana
waive
state
immunity
done
proceeding
issue
thus
becomes
one
power
state
law
issue
determined
state
must
resort
general
policy
state
expressed
constitution
statutes
decisions
article
section
indiana
constitution
provides
may
made
general
law
bringing
suit
state
liabilities
originating
adoption
constitution
special
act
authorizing
suit
brought
making
compensation
person
claiming
damages
state
shall
ever
passed
interpret
provision
indicating
policy
prohibiting
state
consent
suit
one
particular
case
absence
general
consent
suit
similar
causes
action
since
state
legislature
may
waive
state
immunity
general
law
presumed
absence
clear
language
contrary
conferred
administrative
executive
officers
discretionary
power
grant
withhold
consent
individual
cases
think
general
special
powers
conferred
statute
indiana
attorney
general
appear
defend
actions
brought
state
officials
deemed
confer
officer
power
consent
suit
state
courts
state
consented
sued
state
sions
construe
strictly
statutory
powers
conferred
indiana
state
attorney
general
hold
exercises
powers
statute
possess
powers
attorney
general
law
seem
therefore
properly
authorized
executive
administrative
officer
state
waived
state
immunity
suit
federal
courts
gunter
atlantic
coast
line
applicable
instant
case
since
involved
taxpayer
ancillary
suit
enjoin
south
carolina
tax
officials
collecting
taxes
violation
earlier
decision
upholding
validity
state
agreement
exempt
taxpayer
property
humphrey
pegues
wall
pegues
case
involved
suit
state
person
tax
officials
state
attorney
general
appearing
state
arguing
case
merits
issue
sovereign
immunity
raised
gunter
proceeding
brought
twenty
years
later
defendant
south
carolina
attacked
validity
pegues
judgment
gound
proceeding
state
consented
sued
held
pegues
judgment
res
judicata
binding
state
south
carolina
statutes
conferred
state
officials
attorney
general
power
judgment
state
pages
page
state
submission
authorized
statute
unauthorized
consent
official
farish
state
banking
board
distinction
drawn
federal
state
courts
reliance
placed
contemporaneous
administrative
interpretation
state
statutes
absence
legislative
action
repudiating
attorney
general
conduct
case
failure
state
government
departments
twenty
years
assert
right
conflict
pegues
adjudication
administrative
construction
state
statutes
consent
influence
determining
conclusions
great
northern
life
insurance
read
supra
indicated
read
case
construction
given
indiana
statute
leaves
open
road
review
constitutional
grounds
issues
passed
upon
state
courts
advantage
state
courts
pass
initially
upon
questions
involve
state
liability
tax
refunds
illustrated
instant
case
petitioner
sued
federal
refund
urge
certiorari
federal
erred
interpretation
state
law
applicable
questions
raised
judgment
circuit
appeals
vacated
cause
remanded
district
directions
dismiss
complaint
want
consent
state
suit
vacated
remanded
justice
murphy
took
part
consideration
decision
case
footnotes
need
consider
present
status
board
department
treasury
burns
indiana
replacement
provides
suit
agaisnt
see
indiana
acts
ch
indiana
acts
ch
ch
tucker
state
ind
burns
indiana
replacement
section
burns
indiana
replacement
provides
person
considers
paid
department
year
amount
excess
amount
legally
due
year
terms
act
may
apply
department
verified
petition
writing
time
within
three
years
payment
annual
period
alleged
overpayment
made
correction
amount
paid
department
refund
amount
claims
illegally
collected
paid
petition
shall
set
forth
amount
claims
refunded
reasons
claim
department
shall
promptly
consider
petition
may
grant
refund
whole
part
may
wholly
deny
denied
whole
part
petitioner
shall
forthwith
notified
action
department
grounds
denial
department
may
discretion
grant
petitioner
hearing
respect
petition
person
improperly
charged
tax
provided
terms
act
required
pay
may
recover
amount
thus
improperly
collected
together
interest
proper
action
suit
department
competent
jurisdiction
circuit
superior
county
taxpayer
resides
located
shall
original
jurisdiction
action
recover
amount
improperly
collected
provided
however
shall
entertain
suit
unless
taxpayer
shall
show
filed
petition
refund
department
hereinabove
provided
within
one
year
prior
institution
action
provided
suit
shall
entertained
expiration
six
months
time
filing
petition
refund
department
unless
meantime
department
shall
notified
petitioner
writing
denial
petition
ford
motor
department
treasury
state
indiana
et
see
note
supra
burns
indiana
replacement
section
burns
indiana
replacement
acts
ch
provides
creation
state
board
finance
section
reads
part
follows
board
may
sue
sued
name
action
jurisdiction
whenever
necessary
accomplish
purposes
act
appear
right
sue
department
treasury
erroneous
tax
payments
granted
burns
indiana
replacement
see
acts
ch
pp
repealed
transferred
state
board
finance
acts
ch
otherwise
held
indiana
state
consent
sued
recovery
taxes
covered
rather
opinion
otherwise
advised
indiana
adjudications
consent
limited
suits
state
courts
chapter
acts
creates
state
board
finance
apparently
invests
board
control
public
funds
rather
collection
refund
taxes
reference
particular
state
california
statute
similar
held
warrant
inference
state
legislature
consented
suit
state
state
see
smith
reeves
burns
indiana
provides
person
persons
claiming
money
demand
state
indiana
arising
law
equity
contract
express
implied
may
bring
suit
state
therefor
superior
marion
county
indiana
jurisdiction
hereby
conferred
upon
said
superior
marion
county
indiana
hear
determine
action
section
provides
shall
duty
represent
department
state
indiana
legal
matters
litigation
either
criminal
civil
relating
enforcement
construction
application
administration
act
upon
order
direction
department
state
ex
rel
woodward
smith
indiana
decision
come
attention
involving
authority
state
executive
administrative
officials
consent
suit
state
case
plaintiff
sued
foreclose
mortgage
certain
land
joined
state
indiana
defendant
order
obtain
cancellation
prior
judgment
lien
property
favor
state
defendant
state
filed
affirmative
relief
seeking
satisfaction
lien
intermediate
state
held
since
state
appeared
pleaded
merits
filed
affirmative
relief
thereby
consented
might
made
party
determine
priority
lien
case
involves
application
principle
sovereign
sues
affirmative
relief
deemed
waived
sovereign
immunity
issues
presented
affirmative
claim
state
portsmouth
savings
bank
ind
section
burns
indiana
authorizes
state
attorney
general
represent
state
actions
brought
see
note
supra
provides
shall
duty
state
person
deputy
defend
represent
interests
state
said
superior
marion
county
indiana
also
appeal
section
provides
generally
shall
prosecute
defend
suits
may
instituted
state
indiana
prosecution
defense
otherwise
provided
law
whenever
shall
given
ten
days
notice
pendency
thereof
clerk
suits
pending
whenever
required
governor
majority
officers
state
writing
furnished
within
reasonable
time
shall
represent
state
criminal
cases
shall
defend
suits
brought
state
officers
official
relations
except
suits
brought
state
shall
required
attend
interests
state
suits
actions
claims
state
may
become
interested
state
section
specifically
authorizes
represent
state
actions
brought
provisions
petitioner
suit
brought
see
note
supra
state
ex
rel
home
brewing
ind
julian
et
al
state
ind
various
lower
federal
decisions
held
state
attorney
general
waive
state
immunity
suit
deseret
water
oil
irrigation
state
california
title
guaranty
surety
guernsey
slaker
dunnuck
kansas
state
highway
commission
attorney
general
held
without
power
waive
sovereign
immunity
stanley
schwalby
cf
shaw
see
richardson
fajardo
sugar
without
consideration
limitations
powers
held
attorney
general
puerto
rico
waive
sovereign
immunity