chicot
county
drainage
dist
baxter
state
bank
argued
december
decided
january
mchaney
lasker
ehrman
grover
owens
little
rock
petitioner
hendricks
little
rock
respondents
chief
justice
hughes
delivered
opinion
respondents
brought
suit
district
western
division
eastern
district
arkansas
recover
fourteen
bonds
issued
petitioner
chicot
county
drainage
district
organized
statutes
default
since
answer
petitioner
pleaded
decree
district
proceeding
instituted
petitioner
effect
plan
readjustment
indebtedness
act
may
providing
readjustments
decree
recited
plan
readjustment
accepted
holders
outstanding
indebtedness
fair
equitable
consummate
plan
approval
petitioner
issued
sold
new
serial
bonds
reconstruction
finance
corporation
amount
new
bonds
valid
obligations
also
approval
reconstruction
finance
corporation
purchased
outstanding
obligations
petitioner
amount
delivered
exchange
new
bonds
canceled
certain
proceeds
turned
clerk
disbursing
agent
filed
report
showing
reconstruction
finance
corporation
purchased
old
bonds
petitioner
amount
decree
provided
application
amount
paid
remaining
old
obligations
petitioner
obligations
might
presented
within
one
year
unless
presented
forever
barred
participating
plan
readjustment
fund
paid
except
provision
presentation
decree
canceled
old
bonds
holders
enjoined
thereafter
asserting
claim
thereon
petitioner
pleaded
decree
entered
march
res
judicata
respondents
demurred
answer
thereupon
parties
stipulated
trial
without
jury
evidence
showed
respondents
ownership
bonds
suit
respondents
notice
proceeding
debt
readjustment
record
proceeding
including
final
decree
introduced
district
ruled
favor
respondents
circuit
appeals
affirmed
decision
placed
upon
ground
decree
void
subsequent
entry
proceeding
relating
municipal
district
texas
declared
statute
district
acted
unconstitutional
ashton
cameron
county
district
view
importance
question
granted
certiorari
october
courts
proceeded
theory
act
congress
found
unconstitutional
law
inoperative
conferring
rights
imposing
duties
hence
affording
basis
challenged
decree
norton
shelby
county
chicago
indianapolis
louisville
rwy
hackett
quite
clear
however
broad
statements
effect
determination
unconstitutionality
must
taken
qualifications
actual
existence
statute
prior
determination
operative
fact
may
consequences
justly
ignored
past
always
erased
new
judicial
declaration
effect
subsequent
ruling
invalidity
may
considered
various
aspects
respect
particular
relations
individual
corporate
particular
conduct
private
official
questions
rights
claimed
become
vested
status
prior
determinations
deemed
finality
acted
upon
accordingly
public
policy
light
nature
statute
previous
application
demand
examination
questions
among
difficult
engaged
attention
courts
state
federal
manifest
numerous
decisions
inclusive
statement
principle
absolute
retroactive
invalidity
justified
without
attempting
review
different
classes
cases
consequences
ruling
validity
determined
relation
particular
circumstances
past
transactions
appropriately
confine
consideration
question
res
judicata
comes
us
first
apart
contention
effect
later
decision
constitutionality
elements
necessary
constitute
defense
res
judicata
present
appears
proceedings
district
bring
plan
readjustment
conducted
complete
conformity
statute
circuit
appeals
observed
question
raised
regularity
action
answer
present
suit
alleged
plaintiffs
respondents
notice
proceeding
parties
evidence
effect
showing
compliance
statute
respect
parties
bondholders
full
opportunity
present
objections
proceeding
regularity
fairness
proposed
plan
readjustment
propriety
terms
decree
also
validity
statute
proceeding
brought
plan
put
effect
apparently
question
validity
raised
cause
proceeded
decree
assumption
parties
statute
valid
attempt
review
decree
general
principles
governing
defense
res
judicata
applicable
bondholders
opportunity
raise
question
invalidity
less
bound
decree
failed
raise
cromwell
county
sac
case
beauregard
baltimore
steamship
phillips
grubb
public
utilities
commission
second
argument
pressed
district
sitting
bankruptcy
limited
jurisdiction
conferred
statute
statute
later
declared
invalid
district
without
jurisdiction
entertain
proceeding
hence
decree
open
collateral
attack
think
argument
untenable
lower
federal
courts
courts
limited
jurisdiction
jurisdiction
congress
prescribed
none
less
courts
authority
parties
brought
accordance
requirements
due
process
determine
whether
jurisdiction
entertain
cause
purpose
construe
apply
statute
asked
act
determinations
questions
open
direct
review
may
assailed
collaterally
early
case
mccormick
sullivant
wheat
contended
decree
federal
district
show
parties
proceedings
citizens
different
hence
suit
coram
non
judice
decree
void
said
reason
proceeds
upon
incorrect
view
character
jurisdiction
inferior
courts
limited
jurisdiction
account
inferior
courts
technical
sense
words
whose
judgments
taken
alone
disregarded
jurisdiction
alleged
proceedings
judgments
decrees
erroneous
may
upon
writ
error
appeal
reversed
cause
absolute
nullities
wheat
page
see
also
skillern
executors
may
executors
cranch
des
moines
navigation
iowa
homestead
dowell
applegate
evers
watson
cutler
huston
rule
applies
equally
decrees
district
sitting
bankruptcy
purporting
act
statute
congress
passed
exercise
bankruptcy
power
authority
pass
upon
jurisdiction
decree
sustaining
jurisdiction
attack
open
direct
review
res
judicata
collateral
action
stoll
gottlieb
whatever
contention
jurisdiction
may
whether
boundaries
valid
statute
transgressed
statute
invalid
question
jurisdiction
still
one
judicial
determination
contention
one
validity
question
considered
light
standing
party
seeks
raise
question
particular
application
present
instance
suggested
situation
petitioner
chicot
county
drainage
district
different
municipal
district
ashton
case
petitioner
contends
political
subdivision
state
arkansas
agent
property
owners
within
district
see
drainage
district
poinsett
county
hutchins
ark
refer
phase
case
determinative
merely
illustrating
sort
question
district
might
called
upon
resolve
validity
act
congress
present
application
raised
question
validity
one
determined
judicial
decision
determined
reason
appears
regarded
determinable
district
like
question
affecting
jurisdiction
doubt
question
constitutionality
statute
actually
raised
decided
district
ing
effect
plan
debt
readjustment
accordance
statute
determination
final
save
open
direct
review
upon
appeal
stoll
gottlieb
supra
remaining
question
simply
whether
respondents
failed
raise
question
proceeding
parties
raised
finally
determined
privileged
remain
quiet
raise
subsequent
suit
view
contrary
principle
res
judicata
may
pleaded
bar
respects
matters
actually
presented
sustain
defeat
right
asserted
earlier
proceeding
also
respects
available
matter
might
presented
end
grubb
public
utilities
commission
supra
cromwell
county
sac
supra
judgment
reversed
cause
remanded
district
direction
dismiss
complaint
ordered
reversed
remanded
footnotes
act
general
assembly
arkansas
approved
february
amended
act
general
drainage
law
arkansas
approved
may
stat
originally
provision
limited
two
years
extended
january
act
approved
april
stat
see
field
effect
unconstitutional
statute
yale
law
journal
yale
law
journal
harvard
law
review
virginia
law
review
see
drainage
district
crittenden
county
bank
drainage
district
poinsett
county
see
also
miller
tyler
drinkard
oden
pulaski
avenue
people
russel
beck
state