mcpherson
blacker
argued
decided
october
statement
chief
justice
fuller
william
mcpherson
jay
hubbell
henry
carstens
charles
hiscock
otto
ihling
philip
colgrove
conrad
swensburg
henry
haigh
james
white
fred
slocum
justus
stearns
john
millen
julius
hannah
comstock
filed
petition
affidavits
state
michigan
may
nominees
presidential
electors
robert
blacker
secretary
state
michigan
praying
declare
act
legislature
approved
may
act
pub
acts
entitled
act
provide
election
electors
president
vice
president
repeal
acts
parts
acts
confiict
herewith
void
effect
writ
mandamus
directed
issued
said
secretary
state
commanding
cause
delivered
sheriff
county
state
july
september
notice
writing
next
general
election
state
held
tuesday
day
november
chosen
among
officers
named
said
notice
many
electors
president
vice
president
state
may
entitled
elect
senators
representatives
congress
statute
michigan
ann
provided
secretary
state
shall
day
july
day
september
preceding
general
election
direct
cause
delivered
sheriff
county
state
notice
writing
next
general
election
chosen
many
following
officers
elected
general
election
viz
governor
lieutenant
governor
secretary
state
state
treasurer
auditor
general
attorney
general
superintendent
public
instruction
commissioner
state
land
office
members
state
board
education
electors
president
vice
president
representative
congress
district
counties
shall
belong
rule
show
cause
issued
respondent
secretary
state
answered
petition
denied
refused
give
notice
thus
required
said
always
custom
office
secretary
state
giving
notices
said
section
state
notice
number
electors
printed
ticket
voting
precinct
county
state
following
custom
reference
notice
intention
respondent
giving
notice
section
state
said
notice
elected
one
presidential
elector
large
one
district
presidential
elector
two
alternate
presidential
electors
one
elector
large
one
district
presidential
elector
voting
precinct
election
may
held
accordance
provisions
act
public
acts
state
michigan
amended
answer
respondent
claimed
benefit
demurred
relators
relied
petition
upon
various
grounds
invalidating
act
public
acts
michigan
among
act
void
conflict
clause
section
article
constitution
fourteenth
amendment
instrument
also
provisions
conflict
act
congress
february
entitled
act
fix
day
meeting
electors
president
vice
president
provide
regulate
counting
votes
president
vice
president
decision
questions
arising
thereon
michigan
unanimously
held
none
objections
urged
validity
act
tenable
conflict
clause
art
constitution
fourteenth
amendment
thereof
law
inoperative
far
conflict
law
congress
matter
reference
congress
right
legislate
opinion
found
reported
advance
official
series
judgment
given
june
denying
writ
mandamus
whereupon
writ
error
allowed
october
term
commenced
monday
october
tuesday
october
first
day
upon
application
made
motion
advance
case
submitted
counsel
granted
view
exigency
disclosed
upon
face
papers
cause
heard
day
attention
called
provisions
election
laws
michigan
supposed
immediately
involved
act
pub
acts
pp
chief
justice
monday
october
announced
conclusions
directed
entry
judgment
affirming
judgment
michigan
ordering
mandate
issue
stated
done
immediate
action
state
statutes
apparently
required
might
affected
delay
added
thereafter
file
opinion
stating
fully
grounds
decision
act
public
acts
michigan
follows
act
provide
election
electors
president
vice
president
repeal
acts
parts
acts
conflict
herewith
people
state
michigan
enact
general
election
next
preceding
choice
president
vice
president
shall
elected
many
electors
president
vice
president
state
may
entitled
elect
senators
representatives
congress
following
manner
say
shall
elected
electors
districts
hereinafter
defined
one
elector
president
vice
president
district
shall
known
designated
ballot
respectively
district
elector
president
vice
president
large
district
elector
president
vice
president
large
shall
also
elected
like
manner
two
alternate
electors
president
vice
president
shall
known
designated
ballot
district
alternate
elector
president
vice
president
large
district
alternate
elector
president
vice
president
large
purpose
first
second
sixth
seventh
eighth
tenth
congressional
districts
shall
compose
one
district
known
electoral
district
third
fourth
fifth
ninth
eleventh
twelfth
congressional
districts
shall
compose
district
known
electoral
district
shall
also
elected
electors
congressional
district
state
shall
divided
one
electors
president
vice
president
one
alternate
elector
president
vice
president
ballots
shall
designate
number
congressional
district
persons
voted
therein
elector
district
elector
president
vice
president
respectively
counting
canvassing
certifying
votes
cast
said
electors
large
alternates
said
district
electors
alternates
shall
done
near
may
manner
provided
law
election
electors
president
vice
president
secretary
state
shall
prepare
three
lists
names
electors
alternate
electors
procure
thereto
signature
governor
affix
seal
state
deliver
certificates
thus
signed
sealed
one
electors
first
wednesday
december
next
following
said
general
election
case
death
disability
refusal
act
neglect
attend
hour
twelve
noon
said
day
either
said
electors
large
duties
office
shall
performed
alternate
electors
large
say
eastern
district
alternate
elector
large
shall
supply
place
eastern
district
elector
large
western
district
alternate
elector
large
shall
supply
place
western
district
elector
large
like
case
alternate
congressional
district
elector
shall
supply
place
congressional
district
elector
case
two
persons
equal
highest
number
votes
office
created
act
canvassed
board
state
canvassers
legislature
joint
convention
shall
choose
one
said
persons
fill
office
shall
duty
governor
convene
legislature
special
session
purpose
immediately
upon
determination
said
board
state
canvassers
said
electors
president
vice
president
shall
convene
senate
chamber
capital
state
hour
twelve
noon
first
wednesday
december
immediately
following
election
shall
proceed
perform
duties
electors
required
constitution
laws
alternate
electors
shall
also
attendance
shall
take
part
proceedings
except
herein
provided
said
electors
alternate
electors
shall
receive
sum
five
dollars
day
attendance
meetings
electors
provided
five
cents
per
mile
actual
necessary
distance
traveled
way
going
returning
said
place
meeting
paid
state
treasurer
upon
allowance
board
state
auditors
acts
parts
acts
conflict
provisions
act
hereby
repealed
pub
acts
pp
section
howell
annotated
statutes
michigan
volume
reads
purpose
canvassing
ascertaining
votes
given
electors
president
vice
president
board
state
canvassers
shall
meet
wednesday
next
third
monday
november
day
time
secretary
state
shall
appoint
powers
duties
proceedings
said
board
secretary
state
sending
examining
ascertaining
determining
certifying
recording
votes
results
election
electors
shall
respects
near
may
hereinbefore
provided
relation
sending
examining
ascertaining
determining
certifying
recording
votes
results
election
state
officers
section
howell
statutes
force
prior
may
provided
general
election
next
preceding
choice
president
vice
president
shall
elected
general
ticket
many
electors
president
vice
president
state
may
entitled
elect
senators
representatives
congress
following
sections
article
constitution
michigan
secretary
state
state
treasurer
commissioner
state
land
office
shall
constitute
board
state
auditors
examine
adjust
claims
state
otherwise
provided
general
law
shall
constitute
board
state
canvassers
determine
result
elections
governor
lieutenant
governor
state
officers
officers
shall
law
referred
case
two
persons
equal
highest
number
votes
office
canvassed
board
state
canvassers
legislature
joint
convention
shall
choose
one
said
persons
fill
office
determination
board
state
canvassers
contested
legislature
joint
convention
shall
decide
person
elected
ann
reference
also
made
argument
act
congress
february
fix
day
meeting
electors
president
vice
president
provide
regulate
counting
votes
henry
duffield
miller
fred
baker
plaintiff
error
otto
kirchner
ellis
john
champlin
defendant
error
chief
justice
fuller
stating
facts
foregoing
language
delivered
opinion
michigan
held
effect
act
question
invalid
proper
remedy
sought
words
opinion
act
void
writ
mandamus
awarded
ruled
objections
validity
act
urged
arising
state
constitution
laws
adversely
plaintiffs
error
compelled
consider
dispose
contention
act
invalid
repugnant
constitution
laws
authorized
revise
conclusions
state
matters
local
law
conclusions
accepted
follows
decision
federal
questions
regarded
necessary
determination
cause
de
saussure
gaillard
sup
inasmuch
section
revised
statutes
jurisdiction
writ
error
reverse
affirm
final
judgment
suit
highest
state
decision
validity
statute
state
drawn
question
ground
repugnant
constitution
laws
decision
favor
validity
perceive
reason
holding
writ
improvidently
brought
argued
controversy
judicial
cognizance
said
questions
connected
election
presidential
elector
political
nature
power
finally
dispose
deeision
subject
review
political
officers
agencies
state
board
canvassers
legislature
joint
convention
governor
finally
congress
judicial
power
extends
cases
law
equity
arising
constitution
laws
case
arising
since
validity
state
law
drawn
question
repugnant
constitution
laws
validity
sustained
boyd
state
sup
matters
judgment
reviewed
may
rendered
proceeding
mandamus
hartman
greenhow
concur
state
judgment
affirmed
judgment
reversed
either
event
questions
submitted
finally
definitely
disposed
judgment
pronounce
judgment
carried
effect
transmission
mandate
state
question
validity
act
presented
us
record
judicial
question
decline
exercise
jurisdiction
upon
inadmissible
suggestion
action
might
taken
political
agencies
disregard
judgment
highest
tribunal
state
revised
behalf
plaintiffs
error
contended
act
void
conflict
clause
art
constitution
fourteenth
fifteenth
amendments
constitution
act
congress
february
second
clause
section
article
constitution
words
state
shall
appoint
manner
legislature
thereof
may
direct
number
electors
equal
whole
number
senators
representatives
state
may
entitled
congress
senator
representative
person
holding
office
trust
profit
shall
appointed
elector
manner
appointment
electors
directed
act
michigan
election
elector
alternate
elector
twelve
congressional
districts
state
michigan
divided
elector
alternate
elector
large
two
districts
defined
act
insisted
competent
legislature
direct
manner
appointment
state
appoint
body
politic
corporate
must
act
unit
delegate
authority
subdivisions
created
purpose
argued
ment
electors
districts
appointment
state
citizens
otherwise
qualified
permitted
vote
presidential
electors
state
ordinary
sense
constitution
said
chief
justice
chase
texas
white
wall
political
community
free
citizens
occupying
territory
defined
boundaries
organized
government
sanctioned
limited
written
constitution
established
consent
governed
state
act
people
collective
capacity
political
agencies
duly
constituted
established
legislative
power
authority
except
limited
constitution
state
sovereignty
people
exercised
representatives
legislature
unless
fundamental
law
power
elsewhere
reposed
constitution
frequently
refers
state
political
community
also
terms
people
several
citizens
state
forbidden
required
done
state
forbidden
required
legislative
power
state
constitutions
exist
clause
consideration
read
people
citizens
shall
appoint
state
shall
words
manner
legislature
thereof
may
direct
omitted
seem
legislative
power
appointment
successfully
questioned
absence
provision
state
constitution
regard
hence
insertion
words
operating
limitation
upon
state
respect
attempt
circumscribe
legislative
power
held
operate
limitation
power
legislature
possesses
plenary
authority
direct
manner
appointment
might
exercise
appointing
power
joint
ballot
concurrence
two
houses
according
mode
designated
difficult
perceive
legislature
prescribes
method
appointment
choice
vote
must
necessarily
general
ticket
districts
words
act
appointment
none
less
act
state
entirety
rived
districts
act
act
political
agencies
duly
authorized
speak
state
combined
result
expression
voice
state
result
reached
direction
legislature
whole
subject
committed
first
paragraph
section
art
provided
house
representatives
shall
composed
members
chosen
every
second
year
people
several
electors
state
shall
qualifications
requisite
electors
numerous
branch
state
legislature
third
paragraph
vacancies
happen
representation
state
executive
authority
thereof
shall
issue
writs
election
fill
vacancies
section
reads
times
places
manner
holding
elections
senators
representatives
shall
prescribed
state
legislature
thereof
congress
may
time
law
make
alter
regulations
except
places
choosing
senators
although
thus
declared
people
several
shall
choose
members
congress
language
induced
state
new
york
insert
salvo
power
divide
districts
resolutions
ratification
state
legislatures
prior
prescribing
times
places
manner
holding
elections
representatives
usually
apportioned
state
districts
assigned
representative
act
congress
june
carried
forward
section
revised
statutes
provided
state
entitled
one
representative
election
districts
never
doubted
representatives
congress
thus
chosen
represented
entire
people
state
acting
sovereign
capacity
original
clause
art
twelfth
amendment
superseded
clause
case
failure
election
president
people
house
representatives
choose
president
vote
shall
taken
representation
state
one
vote
state
acts
unit
vote
given
unit
vote
arrived
votes
representatives
congress
elected
districts
state
also
acts
individually
electoral
college
although
reason
power
legislature
manner
appointment
vote
electors
may
divided
constitution
provide
appointment
electors
shall
popular
vote
electors
shall
voted
upon
general
ticket
majority
exercise
elective
franchise
alone
choose
electors
recognizes
people
act
representatives
legislature
leaves
legislature
exclusively
define
method
effecting
object
framers
constitution
employed
words
natural
sense
plain
clear
resort
collateral
aids
interpretation
unnecessary
indulged
narrow
enlarge
text
ambiguity
doubt
two
views
may
well
entertained
contemporaneous
subsequent
practical
construction
entitled
greatest
weight
certainly
plaintiffs
error
reasonably
assert
clause
constitution
consideration
plainly
sustains
position
entitle
object
contemporaneous
history
practical
construction
allowed
legitimate
force
conceding
argument
inspires
doubt
sufficient
justify
resort
aids
interpretation
thus
afforded
opinion
doubt
thereby
resolved
contemporaneous
practical
exposition
constitution
strong
obstinate
shaken
controlled
stuart
laird
cranch
said
word
appropriate
word
describe
result
popular
election
perhaps
sufficiently
comprehensive
cover
mode
manifestly
used
conveying
broadest
power
determination
used
article
articles
confederation
provided
shall
annually
appointed
manner
legislature
state
shall
direct
resolution
congress
february
declared
expedient
convention
delegates
shall
appointed
several
held
appointment
delegates
fact
made
legislatures
directly
involved
denial
authority
direct
mode
constitutional
convention
resolution
september
expressed
opinion
congress
fix
day
electors
appointed
shall
ratified
publication
electors
appointed
senators
representatives
elected
journal
convention
discloses
propositions
president
elected
citizens
electors
chosen
people
several
instead
congress
voted
jour
conv
elliot
deb
proposition
president
electors
appointed
purpose
legislatures
though
one
time
adopted
jour
con
elliot
deb
motion
postpone
consideration
choice
national
legislature
order
take
resolution
providing
electors
elected
qualified
voters
districts
negatived
committee
whole
jour
conv
elliot
deb
gerry
proposed
choice
made
state
executives
hamilton
election
electors
chosen
electors
chosen
people
james
wilson
gouverneur
morris
strongly
favor
popular
vote
ellsworth
luther
martin
preferred
choice
electors
elected
legislatures
roger
sherman
appointment
congress
final
result
seems
reconciled
contrariety
views
leaving
state
legislatures
appoint
directly
joint
ballot
concurrent
separate
action
popular
election
districts
general
ticket
otherwise
might
directed
therefore
reference
contemporaneous
subsequent
action
clause
expect
find
various
modes
choosing
electors
pursued
legislature
joint
ballot
legislature
concurrent
vote
two
houses
vote
people
general
ticket
vote
people
districts
choice
partly
people
voting
indistricts
partly
people
voting
districts
partly
candidates
voted
people
districts
ways
notably
north
carolina
tennessee
question
raised
power
state
appoint
mode
legislature
saw
fit
adopt
none
single
method
applicable
without
exception
must
pursued
absence
amendment
constitution
district
system
largely
considered
equitable
madison
wrote
system
contemplated
framers
constitution
although
soon
seen
adoption
might
place
disadvantage
division
strength
uniform
rule
preferable
first
presidential
election
appointment
electors
made
legislatures
connecticut
delaware
georgia
new
jersey
south
carolina
pennsylvania
act
october
acts
provided
election
electors
general
ticket
virginia
act
november
divided
separate
districts
elector
elected
district
election
congressmen
state
divided
districts
laws
sess
pp
massachusetts
general
resolve
november
divided
state
districts
election
representatives
congress
provided
election
december
time
qualified
inhabitants
district
give
votes
two
persons
candidates
elector
president
vice
president
two
persons
district
greatest
number
votes
two
houses
general
joint
ballot
elect
one
elector
way
elect
two
electors
large
mass
resolves
maryland
elected
general
ticket
five
residents
elected
general
ticker
five
residents
western
shore
three
eastern
shore
laws
md
new
hampshire
act
passed
november
laws
providing
election
five
electors
majority
popular
vote
case
choice
legislature
appoint
many
candidates
equaled
double
number
electors
elected
choice
appointment
made
legislature
senate
agree
joint
ballot
house
compelled
vote
state
might
lost
concur
electors
chosen
senate
state
new
york
lost
vote
similar
contest
assembly
willing
elect
joint
ballot
two
branches
divide
electors
senate
senate
assent
nothing
short
complete
negative
upon
action
assembly
time
election
passed
without
appointment
north
carolina
rhode
island
ratified
constitution
fifteen
participated
second
presidential
election
nine
electors
chosen
legislatures
maryland
laws
md
laws
new
hampshire
laws
pp
pennsylvania
laws
elected
electors
general
ticket
virginia
districts
laws
massachusetts
general
resolution
june
divided
state
four
districts
two
five
electors
elected
two
three
electors
mass
resolves
june
apportionment
april
north
carolina
entitled
ten
members
house
representatives
legislature
session
meet
november
act
congress
march
electors
assemble
december
legislature
passed
act
dividing
state
four
districts
directing
members
legislature
residing
district
meet
november
choose
three
electors
ired
laws
session
act
passed
dividing
state
districts
election
electors
every
four
years
thereafter
id
sixteen
took
part
third
presidential
election
tennessee
admitted
june
nine
electors
appointed
legislatures
pennsylvania
new
hampshire
popular
vote
general
ticket
virginia
north
carolina
maryland
elected
districts
maryland
law
december
entitled
act
alter
mode
electing
electors
provided
dividing
state
ten
districts
districts
appoint
one
person
resident
said
district
elector
laws
md
massachusetts
adhered
district
system
electing
one
elector
congressional
district
majority
vote
provided
one
majority
legislature
make
appointment
joint
ballot
legislature
also
appointed
two
electors
large
manner
mass
resolves
june
tennessee
act
passed
august
provided
election
three
electors
district
washington
one
district
hamilton
one
district
mero
said
electors
may
elected
little
trouble
citizens
possible
certain
persons
counties
washington
sullivan
green
hawkins
named
act
appointed
electors
elect
elector
district
washington
certain
persons
counties
knox
jefferson
sevier
blount
name
appointed
elect
elector
district
hamilton
certain
others
counties
davidson
sumner
tennessee
elect
elector
district
mero
laws
acts
sess
assem
electors
chosen
persons
thus
designated
fourth
presidential
election
virginia
advice
jefferson
adopted
general
ticket
least
uniform
mode
choosing
president
vice
president
shall
prescribed
ment
constitution
laws
massachusetts
passed
resolution
providing
electors
state
appointed
joint
ballot
senate
house
mass
resolves
june
pennsylvania
appointed
legislature
upon
contest
senate
house
latter
forced
yield
senate
agreeing
arrangement
resulted
dividing
vote
electors
niles
reg
six
however
chose
electors
popular
vote
rhode
island
supplying
place
pennsylvania
theretofore
followed
course
tennessee
act
october
designated
persons
name
choose
three
electors
act
laws
tenn
acts
sess
assem
without
pursuing
subject
sufficient
observe
adopted
general
ticket
system
district
method
obtained
kentucky
tennessee
maryland
indiana
illinois
maine
massachusetts
used
general
ticket
system
mass
resolves
june
chose
electors
joint
ballot
legislature
mass
resolves
pp
mass
resolves
used
district
system
mass
resolves
mass
resolves
returned
general
ticket
system
mass
resolves
new
york
electors
elected
districts
district
electors
choosing
electors
large
rev
tit
appointment
electors
legislature
instead
popular
vote
made
use
north
carolina
vermont
new
jersey
electors
chosen
popular
vote
districts
general
ticket
excepting
delaware
georgia
louisiana
new
york
south
carolina
vermont
still
chosen
legislature
electors
chosen
general
ticket
excepting
south
carolina
legislature
chose
including
journals
senate
pp
house
mode
adopted
florida
laws
colorado
prescribed
section
schedule
constitution
state
admitted
union
august
laws
pp
justice
story
considering
subject
commentaries
constitution
writing
nearly
years
adoption
instrument
stating
legislatures
directly
chosen
electors
others
chosen
people
general
ticket
throughout
whole
state
others
people
electoral
districts
fixed
legislature
certain
number
electors
apportioned
district
question
ever
arisen
constitutionality
either
mode
except
direct
choice
legislature
though
often
doubted
able
ingenious
minds
elliot
deb
firmly
established
practice
ever
since
adoption
constitution
seem
admit
controversy
even
suitable
tribunal
existed
adjudicate
upon
remarks
thought
desirable
many
statesmen
constitution
amended
provide
uniform
mode
choice
people
story
const
ed
amendment
urged
time
adoption
twelfth
amendument
suggestion
electors
chosen
popular
vote
divided
purpose
districts
brought
congress
december
resolution
submitting
amendment
failed
carried
amendment
renewed
house
representatives
ber
provision
division
single
districts
choice
electors
received
majority
vote
two
thirds
like
amendments
offered
senate
sanford
new
york
dickerson
new
jersey
macon
north
carolina
december
senator
benton
introduced
amendment
providing
legislature
divide
state
electoral
districts
voters
district
vote
proper
persons
president
vice
president
acted
upon
december
december
amendments
introduced
senate
dickerson
new
jersey
van
buren
new
york
requiring
choice
electors
districts
others
failed
adoption
although
favorable
action
direction
senate
december
amendment
introduced
house
mcduffie
south
carolina
providing
electors
chosen
districts
assigned
legislatures
action
taken
subject
brought
forward
subsequently
need
dwelt
upon
except
may
added
may
report
made
senator
morton
chairman
senate
committee
privileges
elections
recommending
amendment
dividing
electoral
districts
majority
popular
vote
district
give
candidate
one
presidential
vote
also
failed
obtain
action
report
said
appointment
electors
thus
placed
absolutely
wholly
legislatures
several
may
chosen
legislature
legislature
may
provide
shall
elected
people
state
large
districts
members
congress
case
formerly
many
doubt
competent
legislature
authorize
governor
state
agent
appoint
electors
power
conferred
upon
legislatures
constitution
taken
modified
state
constitutions
power
elect
senators
whatever
provisions
may
made
statute
state
constitution
choose
electors
people
doubt
right
legislature
resume
power
time
neither
taken
away
abdicated
senate
sess
cong
review
assisted
laborious
research
counsel
might
greatly
expanded
seen
formation
government
practical
construction
clause
conceded
plenary
power
state
legislatures
matter
appointment
electors
even
heated
controversy
electoral
vote
colorado
cast
electors
chosen
legislature
passed
unchallenged
attention
drawn
previous
attempt
submit
courts
determination
constitutionality
state
action
short
appointment
mode
appointment
electors
belong
exclusively
constitution
remarked
justice
gray
green
sup
officers
agents
members
state
legislatures
acting
electors
federal
senators
people
acting
electors
representatives
congress
congress
empowered
determine
time
choosing
electors
day
give
votes
required
day
throughout
otherwise
power
jurisdiction
state
exclusive
exception
provisions
number
electors
ineligibility
certain
persons
framed
congressional
federal
influence
might
excluded
question
us
one
policy
power
public
opinion
gradually
brought
matter
fact
pursuit
uniform
system
popular
election
general
ticket
fact
tend
weaken
force
contemporaneous
previous
practice
different
views
expediency
prevailed
prescription
written
law
overthrown
laterally
exercised
particular
way
power
might
exercised
way
construction
referred
prevailed
long
uniform
justify
us
interpreting
language
constitution
conveying
meaning
heretofore
ascribed
must
treated
decisive
argued
district
mode
choosing
electors
obnoxious
constitutional
objection
operation
electoral
system
conformed
original
object
purpose
become
view
practical
working
system
doubtless
supposed
electors
exercise
reasonable
independence
fair
judgment
selection
chief
executive
experience
soon
demonstrated
whether
chosen
legislatures
popular
suffrage
general
ticket
districts
chosen
simply
register
appointing
power
respect
particular
candidate
relation
independence
electors
original
expectation
may
said
frustrated
miller
const
law
rawle
const
story
const
federalist
perceive
reason
holding
power
confided
constitution
ceased
exist
operation
system
fully
realized
hopes
created
still
less
recognize
doctrine
constitution
found
march
time
sufficiently
comprehensive
applicable
conditions
within
minds
framers
arising
time
may
therefore
wrenched
subjects
expressly
embraced
within
amended
judicial
decision
without
action
designated
organs
mode
alone
amendments
made
able
discover
conflict
act
fourteenth
fifteenth
amendments
constitution
fourteenth
amendment
provides
persons
born
naturalized
subject
jurisdiction
thereof
citizens
state
wherein
reside
state
shall
make
enforce
law
shall
abridge
privileges
immunities
citizens
shall
state
deprive
person
life
liberty
property
without
due
process
law
deny
person
within
jurisdiction
equal
protection
laws
representatives
shall
apportioned
among
several
according
respective
numbers
counting
whole
number
persons
state
excluding
indians
taxed
right
vote
election
choice
electors
president
vice
president
representatives
congress
executive
judicial
officers
state
members
legislature
thereof
denied
male
inhabitants
state
years
age
citizens
way
abridged
except
participation
rebellion
crime
basis
representation
therein
shall
reduced
proportion
number
male
citizens
shall
bear
whole
number
male
citizens
years
age
state
first
section
fifteenth
amendment
reads
right
citizens
vote
shall
denied
abridged
state
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
slaughterhouse
cases
wall
held
first
clause
fourteenth
amendment
primarily
intended
confer
citizenship
negro
race
secondly
give
definitions
citizenship
citizenship
recognized
distinction
citizenship
state
citizenship
definitions
privileges
immunities
citizens
embrace
generally
fundamental
civil
rights
security
establishment
ized
society
instituted
remain
certain
exceptions
mentioned
federal
constitution
care
state
governments
privileges
immunities
citizens
arise
nature
essential
character
national
government
provisions
constitution
laws
treaties
made
pursuance
thereof
latter
placed
protection
congress
second
clause
fourteenth
amendment
decided
minor
happersett
wall
right
suffrage
necessarily
one
privileges
immunities
citizenship
adoption
fourteenth
amendment
amendment
add
privileges
immunities
simply
furnishes
additional
guaranty
protection
citizen
already
time
adoption
amendment
suffrage
coextensive
citizenship
state
time
adoption
constitution
neither
constitution
fourteenth
amendment
made
citizens
voters
fifteenth
amendment
exempted
citizens
discrimination
exercise
elective
franchise
account
race
color
previous
condition
servitude
right
vote
comes
right
exemption
prohibited
discrimination
comes
first
granted
secured
constitution
last
cruikshank
reese
id
happened
time
adoption
fourteenth
amendment
exercised
elective
franchise
state
michigan
entitled
vote
presidential
electors
right
rendered
permanent
amendment
second
clause
article
amended
longer
appoint
manner
legislatures
thereof
may
direct
yet
result
indicated
language
used
amendments
necessarily
inconsistent
clause
first
section
fourteenth
amendment
refer
exercise
elective
franchise
though
second
provides
right
vote
denied
abridged
male
inhabitant
state
attained
majority
citizen
basis
representation
state
entitled
congress
shall
proportionately
reduced
whenever
presidential
electors
appointed
popular
election
right
vote
denied
abridged
without
invoking
penalty
right
vote
representatives
congress
executive
judicial
officers
state
members
legislature
thereof
right
vote
intended
protected
refers
right
vote
established
laws
constitution
state
color
contention
amendments
every
male
inhabitant
state
citizen
time
majority
right
vote
presidential
electors
object
fourteenth
amendment
respect
citizenship
preserve
equality
rights
prevent
discrimination
citizens
radically
change
whole
theory
relations
state
federal
governments
governments
people
kemmler
sup
inhibition
state
shall
deprive
person
within
jurisdiction
equal
protection
laws
designed
prevent
person
class
persons
singled
special
subject
discriminating
hostile
legislation
milling
pennsylvania
sup
hayes
missouri
sup
justice
field
speaking
said
fourteenth
amendment
constitution
prohibit
legislation
limited
either
objects
directed
territory
within
operate
merely
requires
persons
subjected
legislation
shall
treated
alike
like
circumstances
conditions
privileges
liabilities
imposed
said
barbier
connolly
speaking
fourteenth
amendment
legislation
discriminating
favoring
others
prohibited
legislation
carrying
public
purpose
limited
application
within
sphere
operation
affects
alike
persons
similarly
situated
within
amendment
sup
rep
presidential
electors
appointed
legislatures
discrimination
made
elected
districts
citizen
equal
right
vote
citizen
discrimination
made
unless
authority
vested
legislatures
second
clause
section
article
divested
state
lost
power
appointment
except
one
manner
position
taken
behalf
relators
untenable
apparent
neither
amendments
given
effect
third
clause
section
article
constitution
congress
may
determine
time
choosing
electors
day
shall
give
votes
day
shall
throughout
act
congress
march
provided
electors
meet
give
votes
first
wednesday
december
place
state
directed
legislature
thereof
act
congress
january
electors
appointed
state
tuesday
next
first
monday
month
november
year
appointed
provided
state
might
law
provide
filling
vacancies
college
electors
college
meets
give
electoral
vote
provided
state
shall
held
election
purpose
choosing
electors
failed
make
choice
day
prescribed
electors
may
appointed
subsequent
day
manner
state
may
law
provide
provisions
carried
forward
sections
revised
statutes
rev
tit
act
congress
february
entitled
act
fix
day
meeting
electors
president
vice
president
provided
electors
state
meet
give
votes
second
monday
january
next
following
appointment
state
law
question
fixes
first
wednesday
december
day
meeting
electors
originally
designated
congress
respect
conflict
act
congress
must
necessarily
give
way
part
act
inseparably
connected
substance
parts
work
destruction
whole
act
striking
day
meeting
already
otherwise
determined
act
congress
act
remains
complete
capable
carried
accordance
legislative
intent
state
law
yields
extent
collision
cooley
const
lim
com
kimball
pick
houston
moore
wheat
construction
effect
state
persuasive
force
controlling
weight
think
result
affected
provision
act
relation
tie
vote
constitution
state
michigan
case
two
persons
equal
highest
number
votes
office
canvassed
board
state
canvassers
legislature
joint
convention
chooses
one
persons
fill
effice
rule
recognized
act
also
makes
duty
governor
case
convene
legislature
special
session
purpose
application
immediately
upon
determination
board
state
canvassers
entirely
agree
michigan
held
matter
law
legislature
provided
convened
special
session
provision
relating
time
meeting
electors
contained
act
opinion
date
may
rejected
act
held
remain
otherwise
complete
valid
state
fully
empowered
fill
vacancy
may
occur
electoral
college
meets
give
electoral
vote
find
nothing
mode
provided
anticipating
exigency
operates
invalidate
law
repeat
main
question
arising
consideration
one
power
policy
unable
arive
conclusion
act
legislature
michigan
may
void
contravention
constitution
want
power
enactment
judgment
michigan
must
affirmed
footnotes
see
stanwood
presidential
elections
ed
appleton
presidential
counts
passim
lalor
enc
pol
science
hild
hist
rev
ed
hild
hist
schouler
hist
schouler
hist
schouler
hist
adams
hist
adams
hist
adams
hist
adams
hist
mcmaster
hist
peopel
mcmaster
hist
people
mcmaster
hist
people
scharf
hist
md
bradf
mass
life
plumer
niles
reg
niles
reg
niles
reg
niles
reg
niles
reg
benton
thirty
years
view
benton
cong
deb
benton
cong
deb
niles
reg
niles
reg
annals
cong