carnley
cochran
argued
decided
april
petitioner
illiterate
tried
florida
state
without
counsel
convicted
serious
noncapital
offenses
record
silent
whether
offered
waived
counsel
clearly
showed
incapable
conducting
defense
held
petitioner
case
one
assistance
counsel
unless
intelligently
understandingly
waived
right
guaranteed
fourteenth
amendment
pp
presuming
waiver
counsel
silent
record
impermissible
sustain
claim
counsel
waived
record
must
show
must
allegation
evidence
show
accused
offered
counsel
intelligently
understandingly
rejected
offer
pp
appointment
harold
ward
iii
argued
cause
filed
briefs
petitioner
james
mahorner
assistant
attorney
general
florida
argued
cause
respondent
special
leave
pro
hac
vice
brief
richard
ervin
attorney
general
justice
brennan
delivered
opinion
petitioner
afforded
assistance
counsel
defense
trial
claims
reason
conviction
jury
record
escambia
county
florida
deprived
rights
guaranteed
fourteenth
amendment
obtained
provisional
writ
habeas
corpus
florida
petition
asserting
claim
however
petition
respondent
return
petitioner
reply
without
hearing
discharged
writ
since
important
constitutional
right
involved
granted
certiorari
appointed
counsel
represent
petitioner
assistance
counsel
might
well
materially
aided
petitioner
coping
several
aspects
case
charged
noncapital
offenses
incestuous
sexual
intercourse
daughter
separate
count
relating
acts
fondling
minor
child
assault
lewd
lascivious
indecent
manner
upon
female
child
age
time
trial
two
sets
florida
criminal
statutes
contained
language
reaching
behavior
sections
florida
statutes
general
criminal
provisions
separately
defining
two
offenses
incest
assault
lewd
lascivious
indecent
manner
addition
offenses
included
within
later
enacted
chapter
florida
statutes
florida
child
molester
act
victim
years
age
younger
florida
plainly
conceived
petitioner
prosecution
offenses
child
molester
act
obviously
plausible
view
lawyer
layman
might
perceived
child
molester
act
invoked
petitioner
respect
conduct
elsewhere
specifically
defined
criminal
decision
florida
copeland
state
raised
doubts
florida
constitution
validity
prosecution
based
act
picture
complicated
fact
child
molester
act
included
reference
incest
prior
amendment
made
subsequent
petitioner
alleged
offense
establishing
basis
petitioner
prosecution
vitally
important
protection
rights
child
molester
act
validly
applied
petitioner
counsel
materially
assisted
invoking
behalf
special
provisions
law
governing
disposition
defendants
charged
sections
authorize
jail
sentences
contrast
child
molester
act
empowers
sentencing
judge
proper
case
commit
convicted
defendant
florida
state
hospital
treatment
rehabilitation
law
also
permits
accused
petition
psychiatric
psychological
examination
purpose
assisting
trial
case
thus
present
considerations
sort
often
deemed
sufficient
require
conclusion
trial
crime
without
defense
counsel
measure
requirements
fourteenth
amendment
see
chewning
cunningham
reynolds
cochran
mcneal
culver
rice
olson
aspects
record
also
support
petitioner
claim
unfairness
trying
without
affording
help
lawyer
must
generally
case
trial
judge
effectively
discharge
roles
judge
defense
counsel
record
shows
trial
judge
made
efforts
assist
petitioner
important
omissions
guidance
gave
fully
apprise
petitioner
vital
procedural
rights
laymen
expected
know
defense
counsel
doubtless
called
attention
omissions
significant
see
cash
culver
gibbs
burke
hudson
north
carolina
despite
allegation
respondent
return
petitioners
carefully
instructed
trial
regard
rights
guaranteed
constitution
florida
constitution
regard
procedures
followed
course
trial
appears
petitioner
advised
need
testify
told
consequences
might
follow
testify
chose
testify
criminal
record
brought
defense
lawyers
commonplace
weigh
risk
accused
revelation
prior
criminal
record
advising
accused
whether
take
stand
behalf
petitioner
question
decided
ignorance
important
consideration
appear
trial
judge
advised
petitioner
right
examine
prospective
jurors
voir
dire
right
submit
proposed
instructions
jury
right
object
instructions
given
circumstances
attending
case
serve
accentuate
unfairness
trial
without
counsel
petitioner
illiterate
interpose
single
objection
trial
two
witnesses
daughter
son
although
petitioner
wife
testified
experienced
disciplinary
problems
children
thus
clearly
revealed
possibly
significant
avenue
impeachment
children
testimony
worthy
name
hold
petitioner
case
one
assistance
counsel
unless
intelligently
understandingly
waived
right
guaranteed
fourteenth
amendment
must
therefore
consider
whether
petitioner
intelligently
understandingly
waive
assistance
counsel
record
show
trial
judge
offered
petitioner
declined
counsel
cf
moore
michigan
nevertheless
state
imputed
petitioner
waiver
benefit
counsel
ground
stated
opinion
follows
record
shows
defendant
counsel
presumed
defendant
waived
benefit
counsel
might
mean
petitioner
suffered
constitutional
deprivation
formally
requested
counsel
failure
make
request
presumed
unless
record
shows
contrary
settled
assistance
counsel
constitutional
requisite
right
furnished
counsel
depend
request
mcneal
culver
supra
petitioner
allegation
requested
counsel
countered
denial
return
petitioner
constitutional
rights
violated
alleged
refusal
appoint
counsel
behalf
state
noted
record
silent
request
held
constitution
grants
protection
criminal
proceedings
without
assistance
counsel
counsel
must
furnished
whether
accused
requested
appointment
counsel
uveges
pennsylvania
see
rice
olson
supra
gibbs
burke
supra
however
florida
may
meant
constitutional
right
counsel
depends
upon
formal
request
may
meant
fact
counsel
present
assumed
trial
judge
made
offer
counsel
petitioner
declined
may
meant
assume
simply
petitioner
knew
right
counsel
willing
forego
course
validity
presumptions
immediately
called
question
accused
way
protecting
trial
except
requesting
counsel
formality
upon
said
right
may
made
depend
answer
say
may
counter
presumptions
collateral
attack
showing
fact
agreed
willing
tried
without
counsel
cast
burden
accused
wholly
war
standard
proof
waiver
right
counsel
laid
johnson
zerbst
pointed
courts
indulge
every
reasonable
presumption
waiver
fundamental
constitutional
rights
presume
acquiescence
loss
fundamental
rights
constitutional
right
accused
represented
counsel
invokes
protection
trial
accused
whose
life
liberty
stake
without
counsel
protecting
duty
imposes
serious
weighty
responsibility
upon
trial
judge
determining
whether
intelligent
competent
waiver
accused
accused
may
waive
right
counsel
whether
proper
waiver
clearly
determined
trial
fitting
appropriate
determination
appear
upon
record
neither
bute
illinois
moore
michigan
supra
way
inconsistent
holding
disposition
bute
petitioner
pleaded
guilty
without
requested
counsel
alleged
advised
right
counsel
held
denial
constitutional
right
expressly
disclaimed
waiver
rationale
decided
simply
nature
charge
circumstances
attending
reception
guilty
plea
recited
record
call
play
constitutionally
protected
right
counsel
moore
record
showed
clearly
petitioner
expressly
declined
offer
counsel
trial
judge
held
accused
show
preponderance
evidence
acquiescence
sufficiently
understanding
intelligent
amount
effective
waiver
burden
imposed
upon
accused
unless
record
hearing
required
reveals
affirmative
acquiescence
case
constitutional
infirmity
trial
without
counsel
manifest
even
allegation
much
less
showing
affirmative
waiver
accused
entitled
relief
unconstitutional
conviction
judgment
florida
reversed
cause
remanded
proceedings
inconsistent
opinion
reversed
remanded
justice
frankfurter
took
part
decision
case
justice
white
took
part
consideration
decision
case
footnotes
punishment
incest
persons
within
degrees
consanguinity
within
marriages
prohibited
declared
law
incestuous
void
intermarry
commit
adultery
fornication
shall
punished
imprisonment
state
prison
exceeding
twenty
years
county
jail
exceeding
one
year
lewd
lascivious
indecent
assault
act
upon
presence
child
person
shall
handle
fondle
make
assault
upon
male
female
child
age
fourteen
years
lewd
lascivious
indecent
manner
shall
knowingly
commit
lewd
lascivious
act
presence
child
without
intent
commit
rape
child
female
shall
deemed
guilty
felony
punished
imprisonment
state
prison
county
jail
ten
years
definitions
offense
provisions
chapter
shall
include
attempted
rape
sodomy
attempted
sodomy
crimes
nature
attempted
crimes
nature
lewd
lascivious
behavior
incest
attempted
incest
assault
sexual
act
completed
attempted
assault
battery
sexual
act
completed
attempted
said
acts
committed
person
fourteen
years
age
copeland
case
supra
florida
held
inclusion
rape
child
molester
act
attendant
alteration
consequences
offense
committed
child
younger
ran
afoul
state
constitution
act
embraced
distinct
crimes
separately
dealt
statutes
act
failed
set
forth
length
general
rape
provisions
pro
tanto
amended
title
act
failed
give
notice
consequences
rape
changed
see
buchanan
state
district
appeal
upheld
child
molester
act
applied
lewd
lascivious
conduct
florida
laws
fla
powers
duties
judge
convictions
person
convicted
offense
within
meaning
chapter
shall
within
power
jurisdiction
trial
judge
sentence
said
person
term
years
exceed
twenty
five
years
state
prison
raiford
commit
person
treatment
rehabilitation
florida
state
hospital
hospital
state
institution
sent
provided
law
age
color
provided
hospital
institution
possesses
maximum
security
facility
prescribed
board
commissioners
state
institutions
provided
law
shall
created
established
florida
research
treatment
center
trial
judge
shall
instead
committing
person
florida
state
hospital
commit
person
instead
florida
research
treatment
center
case
may
discretion
stay
criminal
proceedings
defer
imposition
sentence
pending
discharge
person
treatment
accordance
procedure
outlined
chapter
execution
judgment
may
suspended
probation
requirements
trial
judge
whose
jurisdiction
conviction
obtained
may
suspend
execution
judgment
place
defendant
upon
probation
trial
placing
defendant
probation
may
time
revoke
order
placing
defendant
probation
impose
sentence
commitment
might
imposed
time
conviction
defendant
shall
placed
probation
continue
probation
satisfied
defendant
take
regular
psychiatric
psychotherapeutic
counseling
help
individual
helping
defendant
shall
make
written
reports
intervals
six
months
probation
officer
charge
case
costs
fees
charges
treatment
defendant
probation
shall
charge
county
defendant
tried
fla
examination
petition
order
person
charged
offense
within
purview
chapter
said
person
may
petition
psychiatric
psychological
examination
heretofore
set
written
report
shall
filed
clerk
jurisdiction
offense
purpose
assisting
trial
case
may
initiative
upon
petition
interested
person
order
examination
report
heretofore
set
emphasis
original
wife
testified
tried
firm
seemed
like
firm
got
two
older
kids
stand
pressure
every
time
daddy
get
something
doings
well
oldest
boy
say
well
daddy
sure
regret
get
even
one
way
also
girl
get
mad
flirtified
almost
opinion
entire
witnesses
petitioner
wife
codefendant
follows
cross
examination
willard
carnley
carol
jean
say
mother
went
made
arrangements
get
casket
sister
yes
right
sure
sure
well
tell
wife
joe
gayfer
house
wait
minute
sir
testifying
chance
testify
state
rests
questions
wish
ask
daughter
welcome
cross
examination
pearl
carnley
carol
jean
recall
got
age
maturity
mother
tried
tell
right
wrong
always
teach
right
wrong
yes
taught
right
wrong
thereupon
witness
excused
cross
examination
carnley
period
time
realize
whenever
century
dad
sickness
time
moved
springtime
sick
stomach
taken
serious
attack
reason
employment
yes
realize
said
sick
supposed
sick
know
thereupon
witness
excused
reason
occasion
hold
hearing
case
settle
fact
issue
raised
petition
return
whether
petitioner
requested
counsel
trial
judge
justified
believing
accused
knew
perfectly
well
right
counsel
unnecessary
make
explicit
offer
secure
accused
rejection
offer
petitioner
allegation
requested
counsel
obviously
tantamount
denial
waiver
return
denial
request
however
reasons
already
canvassed
equivalent
allegation
waiver
return
alleged
trial
judge
instructed
petitioner
constitutional
rights
allegation
claimed
support
transcript
inspection
reveals
instruction
constitutional
right
except
right
testify
justice
black
concurring
concur
judgment
reversal
agree
reasons
stated
opinion
petitioner
even
constitutional
doctrine
announced
betts
brady
entitled
represented
counsel
case
decided
held
indigent
defendant
charged
crime
state
right
federal
constitution
provided
counsel
unless
say
appraisal
totality
facts
given
case
refusal
provide
counsel
particular
defendant
constituted
denial
fundamental
fairness
shocking
universal
sense
justice
dissented
denial
counsel
announcement
considered
impossibly
vague
unpredictable
standard
among
grounds
thought
defendant
case
entitled
counsel
belief
fourteenth
amendment
makes
applicable
sixth
amendment
guarantee
criminal
prosecutions
accused
shall
assistance
counsel
defence
still
view
twenty
years
experience
state
federal
courts
betts
brady
rule
demonstrated
basic
failure
constitutional
guide
indeed
served
guide
confuse
courts
person
prosecuted
state
crime
entitled
lawyer
little
expected
however
standard
imposes
upon
courts
nothing
perplexing
responsibility
appointing
lawyers
accused
trial
judge
believes
failure
shocking
universal
sense
justice
sure
recent
years
fairly
consistent
assuring
indigent
defendants
right
counsel
years
gone
compelled
even
betts
rule
reverse
state
convictions
either
new
trial
hearing
determine
whether
counsel
erroneously
denied
result
judgment
due
growing
recognition
fact
bill
rights
correct
assuming
layman
compelled
defend
criminal
prosecution
defendants
convicted
crime
without
benefit
counsel
possibly
bring
cases
us
one
need
look
records
cases
since
betts
brady
state
federal
courts
understand
capriciousness
shocking
universal
sense
justice
standard
bestows
protection
upon
persons
accused
crime
think
time
abandon
vague
fickle
standard
determining
right
counsel
person
prosecuted
crime
state
recognizing
defendants
state
courts
reason
fourteenth
amendment
unequivocal
right
counsel
defendants
federal
courts
held
virtue
sixth
amendment
johnson
zerbst
many
reasons
including
set
mcneal
culver
justice
douglas
joined
justice
brennan
overrule
betts
brady
case
simply
return
holding
powell
alabama
stated
reference
prosecution
crime
state
courts
right
heard
many
cases
little
avail
comprehend
right
heard
counsel
aware
statement
made
capital
case
fourteenth
amendment
protects
life
liberty
property
hold
defendants
prosecuted
crime
entitled
counsel
whether
life
liberty
property
stake
criminal
prosecution
chief
justice
justice
douglas
joining
opinion
also
join
opinion
chewning
cunningham
hamilton
alabama
mcneal
culver
hudson
north
carolina
cash
culver
moore
michigan
herman
claudy
massey
moore
gibbs
burke
uveges
pennsylvania
townsend
burke
wade
mayo
marino
ragen
de
meerleer
michigan
tomkins
missouri
williams
kaiser
cf
quicksall
michigan
gryger
burke
bute
illinois
foster
illinois
compare
flansburg
kaiser
supp
aff
grounds
powell
alabama
parker
ellis
massey
moore
henderson
bannan
ex
rel
savini
jackson
numerous
examples
course
cited
including
contrast
decisions
cited
note
lower
decisions
reversed
held
denial
counsel
erroneous
betts
brady
rule
justice
douglas
concurring
join
opinion
separate
opinion
justice
black
wish
add
word
reasons
justice
brennan
gave
mcneal
culver
overruling
betts
brady
petitioner
admitted
illiterate
forced
try
case
jury
record
proceedings
jury
impaneled
nothing
show
petitioner
told
right
challenge
individual
veniremen
panel
whole
challenged
anyone
cause
exercised
six
peremptory
challenges
granted
florida
law
fla
certain
made
challenge
panel
whole
challenge
must
writing
fla
florida
tells
us
write
even
doubtful
able
show
improper
method
selection
even
discrimination
confined
lengthy
period
prior
trial
five
months
alleged
spent
solitary
confinement
opportunity
therefore
gather
factual
evidence
necessary
sustain
possible
challenge
panel
florida
statute
moreover
explicitly
requires
written
challenge
specify
facts
based
ibid
petitioner
able
write
access
facts
still
probability
able
build
legal
argument
sufficient
challenge
panel
man
low
intelligence
grounds
challenging
panel
might
invoked
petitioner
turn
difficult
questions
state
law
alleged
legislature
passed
special
local
law
providing
summoning
impaneling
grand
petit
jurors
article
iii
florida
constitution
prohibits
special
laws
always
clear
though
whether
particular
law
special
general
see
hysler
state
state
pearson
sophisticated
nature
arguments
necessary
attack
law
special
almost
always
beyond
comprehension
one
unlearned
law
florida
plea
abatement
usual
manner
testing
legality
jury
list
cases
proceeding
mandamus
deemed
proper
remedy
claimed
county
commissioners
erred
manner
selected
panel
jackson
jordan
often
simple
oral
challenge
individual
juror
achieve
much
accused
contends
venireman
qualifications
required
law
fla
yet
obviously
illiterate
expected
know
niceties
criminal
procedure
assuming
accused
decide
challenge
prospective
veniremen
either
peremptorily
cause
must
decide
secure
maximum
benefit
peremptory
challenges
florida
statutes
provide
least
independent
grounds
challenge
cause
fla
ignorance
ground
challenge
defense
denmark
state
mcnish
state
webster
state
objections
qualifications
jurors
raised
trial
considered
appeal
mcnish
state
supra
crosby
state
trial
excuses
juror
motion
accused
right
object
objection
must
timely
made
grounds
therefor
clearly
stated
late
object
juror
excused
ellis
state
appeal
accused
must
able
show
action
prejudicial
constituted
abuse
discretion
williams
state
peadon
state
special
difficulties
facing
accused
jury
trial
end
challenges
panel
individual
jurors
florida
prohibits
trial
judge
commenting
weight
evidence
lester
state
leavine
state
seward
state
expressing
opinion
accused
convicted
wood
state
lest
influence
jury
decision
make
comment
accused
took
exception
error
deemed
waived
appeal
surrency
state
smith
state
except
interests
justice
served
kellum
state
app
hearsay
evidence
takes
added
importance
jury
trials
excluded
prejudicial
owens
state
alvarez
state
admitted
without
objection
generally
regarded
received
consent
sims
state
objection
question
answered
sometimes
held
come
late
schley
state
williams
state
sims
state
supra
yet
motion
strike
may
achieve
result
dickens
state
exchange
questions
answers
prosecution
witness
defendant
without
assistance
counsel
oftentime
find
helpless
object
even
conceive
grounds
objection
hearsay
lie
indeed
constitutes
hearsay
difficult
question
judges
may
always
agree
see
royal
state
evidence
accused
florida
right
jury
instructed
law
case
final
arguments
made
judge
charge
following
immediately
upon
conclusion
evidence
may
enable
jury
obtain
clearer
accurate
conception
duties
particular
case
required
wait
argument
counsel
hear
law
case
judge
smithie
state
right
waived
failure
take
exception
procedure
adopted
defects
instructions
likewise
deemed
waived
accused
fails
make
timely
objection
white
state
app
dist
williams
state
intricate
procedural
rules
restricted
criminal
trials
florida
similar
rules
equally
complex
confusing
layman
may
found
criminal
statutes
assume
might
applied
vigor
layman
defending
one
represented
lawyer
yet
even
rule
betts
brady
projected
jury
trial
faces
layman
labyrinth
never
understand
negotiate
result
jury
system
pride
world
becomes
trap
layman
utterly
without
ability
make
serve
ends
justice
florida
denied
petitioner
application
writ
habeas
corpus
without
hearing
respect
allegation
petitioner
wife
illiterate
unable
defend
admitted
record
showed
conclusively
fact
illiterate
concluded
however
illiteracy
alone
necessarily
import
ignorance
ordinary
things
life
get
money
bank
apparently
classifying
conduct
defense
felony
charge
one
commonplace
things
life
concluded
showing
petitioner
wife
suffered
slightest
lack
intelligence
petitioner
wife
joined
proceedings
party
petition
certiorari