russello
argued
october
decided
november
petitioner
convicted
federal
district
racketeer
influenced
corrupt
organizations
rico
chapter
organized
crime
control
act
violating
involved
arson
ring
resulted
fraudulently
receiving
insurance
proceeds
payment
fire
loss
building
owned
district
also
entered
judgment
forfeiture
petitioner
amount
insurance
proceeds
pursuant
provides
person
convicted
shall
forfeit
interest
acquired
maintained
violation
section
appeals
affirmed
held
insurance
proceeds
petitioner
received
result
arson
activities
constitute
interest
within
meaning
therefore
subject
forfeiture
pp
section
reach
interests
enterprise
term
interest
specifically
defined
rico
statute
assumed
legislative
purpose
expressed
term
ordinary
meaning
comprehends
forms
real
personal
property
including
profits
proceeds
congress
apparently
selected
broad
term
interest
wish
forfeiture
provision
limited
rigid
technical
definitions
drawn
areas
law
term
fully
consistent
rico
statute
pattern
utilizing
broad
terms
concepts
every
property
interest
including
right
profits
proceeds
may
described
interest
something
profits
illegal
enterprise
divided
participant
may
said
interest
gains
distribution
possessory
interest
currency
items
distributed
pp
congress
intended
restrict
interest
enterprise
presumably
done
expressly
construe
reach
interests
enterprise
blunt
section
effectiveness
combating
illegitimate
enterprises
mean
whole
areas
organized
crime
activity
placed
beyond
reach
rico
statute
pp
fact
controlled
substances
act
specifically
authorizes
forfeiture
profits
obtained
illegal
drug
enterprises
read
imposing
limitation
upon
broader
language
particularly
rico
statute
aimed
organized
crime
economic
power
forms
whereas
narcotics
activity
proscribed
controlled
substances
act
usually
generates
monetary
profits
pp
limiting
construction
supported
fact
certain
state
racketeering
statutes
expressly
provide
forfeiture
profits
money
interest
property
property
real
personal
acquired
racketeering
since
presumably
used
language
avoid
narrow
interpretations
laws
given
federal
statute
certain
federal
district
opinions
legislative
history
clearly
demonstrates
rico
statute
intended
provide
new
weapons
unprecedented
scope
assault
upon
organized
crime
economic
roots
thus
intended
authorize
forfeiture
racketeering
profits
rule
lenity
apply
language
clear
pp
blackmun
delivered
opinion
unanimous
ronald
dion
argued
cause
petitioner
brief
alvin
entin
samuel
alito
argued
cause
briefs
solicitor
general
lee
assistant
attorney
general
jensen
deputy
solicitor
general
frey
sara
criscitelli
justice
blackmun
delivered
opinion
yet
another
case
concerning
racketeer
influenced
corrupt
organizations
rico
chapter
organized
crime
control
act
pub
title
ix
stat
amended
issue
interpretation
chapter
forfeiture
provision
specifically
meaning
words
interest
defendant
acquired
violation
section
june
petitioner
joseph
russello
others
indicted
racketeering
conspiracy
mail
fraud
violation
app
jury
trial
district
middle
district
florida
petitioner
convicted
charged
four
counts
indictment
jury
returned
special
verdicts
forfeiture
four
payments
aggregating
made
petitioner
fire
insurance
company
app
verdicts
related
racketeering
activities
charged
second
count
indictment
petitioner
convicted
district
accordingly
entered
judgment
forfeiture
petitioner
amount
petitioner
took
appeal
former
appeals
fifth
circuit
panel
affirmed
petitioner
criminal
conviction
martino
denied
certiorari
aspect
case
panel
however
reversed
judgment
forfeiture
app
full
granted
rehearing
en
banc
forfeiture
issue
vote
vacated
portion
panel
opinion
affirmed
forfeiture
judgment
entered
district
martino
significant
division
among
judges
appeals
fifth
circuit
majority
stated
holding
squarely
conflict
ed
ninth
circuit
marubeni
america
granted
certiorari
since
seventh
circuit
issued
opinion
agreeing
ninth
circuit
mcmanigal
ii
far
case
present
posture
concerned
basic
facts
dispute
majority
opinion
en
banc
described
succinctly
briefly
evidence
showed
group
individuals
associated
purpose
committing
arson
intent
defraud
insurance
companies
association
fact
enterprise
composed
insurance
adjuster
homeowners
promoters
investors
arsonists
operated
destroy
least
eighteen
residential
commercial
properties
tampa
miami
florida
july
april
panel
summarized
ring
operations
follows
first
arsonists
burned
buildings
already
owned
associated
ring
following
burning
building
owner
filed
inflated
proof
loss
statement
collected
insurance
proceeds
paid
later
ring
members
bought
buildings
suitable
burning
secured
insurance
excess
value
burning
made
claims
loss
divided
proceeds
omitted
iii
title
shall
unlawful
person
employed
associated
enterprise
engaged
activities
affect
interstate
commerce
conduct
participate
directly
indirectly
conduct
enterprise
affairs
pattern
racketeering
activity
collection
unlawful
debt
section
makes
unlawful
conspire
violate
section
provides
person
convicted
shall
forfeit
interest
acquired
maintained
violation
section
sole
issue
case
whether
profits
proceeds
derived
racketeering
constitute
interest
within
meaning
statute
therefore
subject
forfeiture
petitioner
contends
reaches
interests
enterprise
authorize
forfeiture
mere
profits
proceeds
rests
argument
upon
propositions
criminal
forfeitures
disfavored
law
forfeiture
statutes
consequence
must
strictly
construed
rico
case
recently
decided
observed
determining
scope
statute
look
first
language
statutory
language
unambiguous
absence
clearly
expressed
legislative
intent
contrary
language
must
ordinarily
regarded
conclusive
turkette
quoting
consumer
product
safety
gte
sylvania
see
also
dickerson
new
banner
institute
lewis
calls
forfeiture
interest
acquired
violation
section
question
petitioner
russello
acquired
insurance
proceeds
issue
violation
much
definitely
finally
settled
accordingly
proceeds
qualify
interest
forfeitable
term
interest
specifically
defined
rico
statute
silence
compels
us
start
assumption
legislative
purpose
expressed
ordinary
meaning
words
used
richards
ordinary
meaning
interest
surely
encompasses
right
profits
proceeds
see
webster
third
new
international
dictionary
broadly
defining
interest
among
things
good
benefit
profit
random
house
dictionary
english
language
defines
interest
include
benefit
black
law
dictionary
provides
significant
definition
interest
general
term
employed
denote
right
claim
title
legal
share
something
thus
apparent
term
interest
comprehends
forms
real
personal
property
including
profits
proceeds
repeatedly
relied
upon
term
interest
defining
meaning
property
due
process
clause
fourteenth
amendment
constitution
see
perry
sindermann
property
denotes
broad
range
interests
logan
zimmerman
brush
jago
van
curen
undoubtedly
congress
wish
forfeiture
provision
limited
rigid
technical
definitions
drawn
areas
law
selected
broad
term
interest
describe
things
subject
forfeiture
statute
congress
selected
general
term
apparently
fully
consistent
pattern
rico
statute
utilizing
terms
concepts
breadth
among
enterprise
racketeering
activity
ed
participate
petitioner
attempted
define
term
interest
used
insists
however
term
reach
money
profits
says
interest
definition
includes
necessity
interest
something
brief
petitioner
petitioner
asserts
something
emerges
wording
interest
acquired
violation
section
thus
derives
meaning
activities
barred
statute
words
direct
relationship
exists
subject
forfeiture
result
racketeering
activity
constitutes
racketeering
relationship
said
means
forfeiture
confined
interest
enterprise
petitioner
derives
support
approach
marubeni
america
supra
language
contained
two
federal
district
opinions
meyers
supp
wd
thevis
supp
nd
aff
grounds
also
relies
mcmanigal
case
supra
recently
decided
seventh
circuit
tr
oral
arg
agree
every
property
interest
including
right
profits
proceeds
may
described
interest
something
profits
illegal
enterprise
divided
participant
may
said
interest
gains
distribution
possessory
interest
currency
items
distributed
therefore
conclude
language
statute
plainly
covers
insurance
proceeds
petitioner
received
result
arson
activities
iv
fortified
conclusion
examination
structure
rico
statute
disagree
courts
felt
broad
construction
word
interest
necessarily
undermined
statute
forfeiture
provisions
argument
narrow
construction
refuted
language
succeeding
subsection
former
speaks
broadly
interest
acquired
latter
reaches
interest
enterprise
defendant
established
operated
controlled
conducted
participated
conduct
violation
section
similar
less
expansive
language
appears
congress
includes
particular
language
one
section
statute
omits
another
section
act
generally
presumed
congress
acts
intentionally
purposely
disparate
inclusion
exclusion
wong
kim
bo
see
wooten
congress
intended
restrict
interest
enterprise
presumably
done
expressly
immediately
following
subsection
see
north
board
education
bell
naftalin
latter
case
said
short
answer
congress
write
statute
way
refrain
concluding
differing
language
two
subsections
meaning
presume
ascribe
difference
simple
mistake
draftsmanship
evolution
statutory
provisions
supplies
evidence
congress
intended
extend
beyond
interest
enterprise
early
proposed
version
rico
sess
single
forfeiture
provision
limited
interest
enterprise
provision
however
later
divided
present
two
subsections
phrase
enterprise
excluded
first
congress
includes
limiting
language
earlier
version
bill
deletes
prior
enactment
may
presumed
limitation
intended
see
arizona
california
see
weiner
crime
must
pay
rico
criminal
forfeiture
perspective
rev
answer
say
petitioner
brief
petitioner
term
interest
suggested
majority
opinion
appeals
meaning
independent
mere
surplusage
argument
plainly
incorrect
subsection
reaches
interest
whether
enterprise
provided
acquired
violation
section
subsection
hand
restricted
interest
enterprise
interest
need
illegally
acquired
thus
things
forfeitable
one
subsections
note
rico
statute
definition
term
enterprise
encompasses
legal
entities
illegitimate
see
turkette
forfeiture
interest
illegitimate
ordinarily
little
use
association
kind
rarely
identifiable
assets
instead
proceeds
profits
usually
distributed
immediately
thus
construing
reach
interests
enterprise
blunt
effectiveness
provision
combating
illegitimate
enterprises
mean
hole
areas
organized
criminal
activity
placed
beyond
reach
statute
turkette
petitioner
stresses
contained
controlled
substances
act
stat
amended
specifically
authorizes
forfeiture
profits
obtained
continuing
criminal
enterprise
engaged
certain
drug
offenses
brief
petitioner
ninth
circuit
marubeni
placed
similar
reliance
upon
observed
two
statutes
passed
congress
month
feel
however
specific
mention
profits
controlled
substances
act
accepted
indication
broader
language
meant
reach
profits
well
types
property
interests
language
one
statute
usually
sheds
little
light
upon
meaning
different
language
another
statute
even
two
enacted
time
term
profits
specific
term
interest
general
use
specific
one
statute
fairly
read
imposing
limitation
upon
general
provision
statute
addition
rico
statute
aimed
organized
crime
economic
power
forms
natural
use
broad
term
interest
fulfill
aim
contrast
narcotics
activity
proscribed
usually
generates
monetary
profits
fact
explain
use
narrower
term
petitioner
course
correctly
suggests
members
congress
voted
rico
statute
aware
controlled
substances
act
see
cong
rec
remarks
brotzman
remarks
thurmond
remarks
weicker
remarks
kastenmeier
remarks
anderson
unlikely
however
without
explanation
potent
forfeiture
weapon
withheld
rico
statute
intended
use
broad
assault
organized
crime
weapon
included
controlled
substances
act
meant
use
one
part
struggle
congress
intent
one
expect
said
clear
understandable
terms
petitioner
also
suggests
subsequent
proposed
legislation
demonstrates
rico
forfeiture
provision
excludes
profits
brief
petitioner
bills
petitioner
refers
however
introduced
order
overcome
decisions
marubeni
meyers
thevis
see
sess
introduction
bills
hardly
suggests
sponsors
viewed
decisions
correct
interpretations
see
gordon
cert
denied
event
well
settled
views
subsequent
congress
form
hazardous
basis
inferring
intent
earlier
one
jefferson
county
pharmaceutical
assn
abbott
laboratories
quoting
price
see
also
clark
neither
persuaded
petitioner
argument
position
supported
fact
certain
state
racketeering
statutes
expressly
provide
forfeiture
profits
money
interest
property
property
real
personal
acquired
racketeering
brief
petitioner
nearly
state
statutes
postdate
meyers
thevis
district
decisions
see
rev
stat
supp
enacted
laws
supp
enacted
legislatures
presumably
employed
language
different
avoid
narrow
interpretations
laws
along
lines
narrow
interpretations
given
federal
statute
courts
meyers
thevis
necessary
turn
legislative
history
rico
statute
one
finds
history
reveal
petitioner
us
hold
see
brief
petitioner
limited
congressional
intent
legislative
history
clearly
demonstrates
rico
statute
intended
provide
new
weapons
unprecedented
scope
assault
upon
organized
crime
economic
roots
congress
statement
findings
purpose
enacting
pub
stat
set
forth
statement
dramatically
describes
problem
presented
organized
crime
congress
declared
purpose
act
seek
eradication
organized
crime
providing
enhanced
sanctions
new
remedies
deal
unlawful
activities
engaged
organized
crime
recognized
significance
statement
findings
purpose
turkette
congress
directed
pub
stat
provisions
title
shall
liberally
construed
effectuate
remedial
purposes
far
made
aware
substantive
federal
criminal
statute
contains
directive
similar
provision
however
appears
criminal
appeals
act
congress
emphasized
need
fashion
new
remedies
order
achieve
objectives
see
needed
new
approaches
deal
individuals
also
economic
base
individuals
constitute
serious
threat
economic
nation
short
attack
must
made
source
economic
power
attack
must
take
place
available
fronts
legislative
history
leaves
doubt
view
congress
economic
power
organized
crime
derived
huge
illegal
profits
see
blakey
rico
civil
fraud
action
context
reflections
bennett
berg
notre
dame
rev
congress
hoped
successfully
attack
organized
crime
economic
roots
without
reaching
racketeering
profits
congressional
debates
sources
magnitude
organized
crime
income
emphasized
repeatedly
see
cong
rec
cong
rec
remarks
mcclellan
intent
authorize
forfeiture
racketeering
profits
seems
obvious
recites
forfeiture
provision
extends
property
interests
broadly
defined
related
violations
true
congress
viewed
rico
statute
large
part
response
organized
crime
infiltration
legitimate
enterprises
turkette
congress
concerns
limited
infiltration
broader
goal
remove
profit
organized
crime
separating
racketeer
dishonest
gains
forfeiture
interest
enterprise
often
little
deter
indeed
might
encourage
speedy
looting
infiltrated
company
unlikely
congress
intended
enact
forfeiture
provision
provided
incentive
activity
kind
authorizing
forfeiture
interest
little
worth
bankrupt
shell
persuaded
otherwise
presence
letter
deputy
attorney
general
senator
mcclellan
see
measures
relating
organized
crime
hearings
subcommittee
criminal
laws
procedures
senate
committee
judiciary
letter
reference
one
interest
enterprise
indicate
us
congressional
intent
preclude
forfeiture
racketeering
profits
reference
indeed
finally
enacted
earlier
version
forfeiture
expressly
limited
interest
enterprise
letter
merely
following
language
pending
bill
furthermore
real
purpose
sentence
explain
statutory
provision
meant
explain
department
justice
believed
constitutional
rule
lenity
recognized
certain
situations
statutory
ambiguity
see
turkette
application
rule
comes
operation
end
process
construing
congress
expressed
beginning
overriding
consideration
lenient
wrongdoers
callanan
language
rico
forfeiture
provision
clear
rule
lenity
come
play
turkette
therefore
disagree
reasoning
respective
courts
marubeni
mcmanigal
meyers
thevis
cases
affirm
judgment
appeals
fifth
circuit
ordered
footnotes
may
well
factual
situations
subsections
apply
subsections
however
clearly
wholly
redundant
ruling
today
recognize
resolved
ambiguity
might
inherent
terms
profits
proceeds
use
terms
intended
suggest
particular
means
calculating
precise
amount
subject
rico
forfeiture
given
case
hold
simply
interests
subject
forfeiture
limited
interests
enterprise