firestone
tire
rubber
risjord
argued
november
decided
january
respondent
lead
counsel
plaintiffs
four
consolidated
suits
federal
district
petitioner
manufacturers
petitioner
moved
disqualify
respondent
representation
plaintiffs
alleged
conflict
interest
arising
fact
petitioner
liability
insurer
also
occasional
client
respondent
law
firm
petitioner
argued
respondent
representation
insurer
give
incentive
structure
plaintiffs
claims
relief
enable
insurer
avoid
liability
thus
increasing
petitioner
potential
liability
accordance
district
order
respondent
obtained
consent
plaintiffs
insurer
continuing
representation
allowed
continue
representation
plaintiffs
petitioner
filed
notice
appeal
pursuant
vests
courts
appeals
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
except
direct
review
may
appeals
held
district
orders
denying
disqualification
motions
immediately
appealable
overruling
prior
cases
made
decision
prospective
merits
affirmed
district
order
permitting
respondent
continue
representing
plaintiffs
held
orders
denying
motions
disqualify
opposing
party
counsel
civil
case
appealable
final
decisions
order
fall
within
collateral
order
exception
cohen
beneficial
industrial
loan
requirement
appeals
must
await
final
judgment
merits
underlying
litigation
petitioner
made
showing
required
cohen
doctrine
immediately
appealable
collateral
orders
order
denying
disqualification
effectively
unreviewable
appeal
final
judgment
merits
propriety
district
denial
disqualification
motion
often
difficult
assess
impact
underlying
litigation
may
evaluated
normally
final
judgment
appeals
conclude
trial
ended
permitting
continuing
representation
prejudicial
error
retain
usual
authority
vacate
judgment
appealed
order
new
trial
pp
appeals
properly
concluding
district
order
immediately
appealable
erred
reaching
merits
district
order
finality
requirement
jurisdictional
nature
appellate
finds
order
party
seeks
appeal
fall
within
statute
inquiry
lacks
discretion
consider
merits
case
without
jurisdiction
thus
jurisdictional
ruling
may
never
made
prospective
pp
marshall
delivered
opinion
brennan
stewart
white
blackmun
powell
stevens
joined
rehnquist
filed
opinion
concurring
result
burger
joined
post
harvey
grossman
argued
cause
petitioner
briefs
william
freivogel
john
gibson
argued
cause
respondent
briefs
martin
purcell
morris
nunn
solicitor
general
mccree
deputy
solicitor
general
frey
edwin
kneedler
filed
brief
amicus
curiae
justice
marshall
delivered
opinion
case
presents
question
whether
party
may
take
appeal
pursuant
district
order
denying
motion
disqualify
counsel
opposing
party
civil
case
appeals
eighth
circuit
held
orders
appealable
made
decision
prospective
therefore
reached
merits
challenged
order
hold
orders
denying
motions
disqualify
counsel
appealable
final
decisions
therefore
vacate
judgment
appeals
remand
instructions
appeal
dismissed
lack
jurisdiction
respondent
lead
counsel
plaintiffs
four
suits
seeking
damages
petitioner
manufacturers
multipiece
truck
tire
rims
injuries
caused
alleged
defects
products
complaints
charge
petitioner
defendants
various
negligent
willful
intentional
failures
correct
warn
supposed
defects
rims
plaintiffs
seek
compensatory
exemplary
damages
app
petitioner
relevant
times
insured
home
insurance
home
contract
providing
home
responsible
types
liability
beyond
minimum
deductible
amount
home
also
occasional
client
respondent
law
firm
based
facts
petitioner
may
filed
motion
disqualify
respondent
representation
plaintiffs
petitioner
argued
respondent
clear
conflict
interest
representation
home
give
incentive
structure
plaintiffs
claims
relief
way
enable
insurer
avoid
liability
turn
petitioner
argued
increase
potential
liability
home
fact
advised
petitioner
course
litigation
policy
cover
neither
award
compensatory
damages
willful
intentional
acts
award
exemplary
punitive
damages
district
entered
pretrial
order
requiring
respondent
terminate
representation
plaintiffs
unless
plaintiffs
home
consented
continuing
representation
accordance
district
order
respondent
filed
affidavit
stated
informed
plaintiffs
home
potential
conflict
neither
objection
continuing
representation
filed
supporting
affidavits
executed
plaintiffs
representative
home
satisfied
requirements
pretrial
order
respondent
able
continue
representation
plaintiffs
petitioner
objected
district
decision
permit
respondent
continue
representation
met
stated
conditions
therefore
filed
notice
appeal
pursuant
although
hear
oral
argument
appeal
eighth
circuit
decided
case
en
banc
affirmed
trial
order
permitting
petitioner
continue
representing
plaintiffs
rim
products
liability
considering
merits
appeal
reconsidered
overruled
prior
decisions
holding
orders
denying
disqualification
motions
immediately
appealable
appeals
reasoned
orders
fall
within
doctrine
cohen
beneficial
industrial
loan
allows
appeals
prior
final
judgment
overruling
prior
cases
stated
reach
merits
challenged
order
fairness
appellant
instant
case
held
future
appellate
review
orders
await
final
judgment
merits
main
proceeding
granted
certiorari
resolve
conflict
among
circuits
appealability
question
ii
courts
appeals
vested
jurisdiction
appeals
final
decisions
district
courts
except
direct
review
may
consistently
interpreted
language
indicating
party
may
take
appeal
section
decision
district
ends
litigation
merits
leaves
nothing
execute
judgment
coopers
lybrand
livesay
quoting
catlin
rule
party
must
ordinarily
raise
claims
error
single
appeal
following
final
judgment
merits
serves
number
important
purposes
emphasizes
deference
appellate
courts
owe
trial
judge
individual
initially
called
upon
decide
many
questions
law
fact
occur
course
trial
permitting
piecemeal
appeals
undermine
independence
district
judge
well
special
role
individual
plays
judicial
system
addition
rule
accordance
sensible
policy
avoid
ing
obstruction
claims
come
permitting
harassment
cost
succession
separate
appeals
various
rulings
litigation
may
give
rise
initiation
entry
judgment
cobbledick
see
dibella
rule
also
serves
important
purpose
promoting
efficient
judicial
administration
eisen
carlisle
jacquelin
decisions
recognized
however
narrow
exception
requirement
appeals
await
final
judgment
merits
cohen
beneficial
industrial
loan
supra
held
small
class
orders
end
main
litigation
nevertheless
final
appealable
pursuant
cohen
shareholder
derivative
action
federal
district
refused
apply
state
statute
requiring
plaintiff
suit
post
security
costs
defendant
appealed
ruling
without
awaiting
final
judgment
merits
appeals
ordered
trial
require
costs
posted
held
appeals
properly
assumed
jurisdiction
appeal
pursuant
district
order
constituted
final
determination
claim
separable
collateral
merits
main
proceeding
important
denied
review
independent
cause
require
appellate
consideration
deferred
whole
case
adjudicated
cohen
establish
new
law
rather
continued
tradition
giving
practical
rather
technical
construction
ibid
see
river
rouge
improvement
bronson
lacrosse
milwaukee
black
forgay
conrad
whiting
bank
pet
recently
defined
limited
class
final
collateral
orders
terms
order
must
conclusively
determine
disputed
question
resolve
important
issue
completely
separate
merits
action
effectively
unreviewable
appeal
final
judgment
coopers
lybrand
livesay
supra
omitted
see
abney
litigation
instant
petition
arises
reached
final
judgment
time
notice
appeal
filed
order
denying
petitioner
motion
disqualify
respondent
appealable
falls
within
cohen
doctrine
appeals
held
circuits
also
reached
conclusion
denials
disqualification
motions
immediately
appealable
collateral
orders
agree
courts
cohen
order
subject
appeal
prior
resolution
merits
order
denying
disqualification
motion
meets
first
part
collateral
order
test
conclusively
determine
disputed
question
issue
whether
challenged
counsel
permitted
continue
representation
addition
assume
although
decide
disqualification
question
resolve
important
issue
completely
separate
merits
action
second
part
test
nevertheless
petitioner
unable
demonstrate
order
denying
disqualification
effectively
unreviewable
appeal
final
judgment
within
meaning
cases
attempting
show
challenged
order
effectively
unreviewable
final
appeal
petitioner
alleges
denying
immediate
review
cause
irreparable
harm
true
finality
requirement
construed
cause
crucial
collateral
claims
lost
potentially
irreparable
injuries
suffered
mathews
eldridge
support
assertion
irreparably
harmed
petitioner
hints
possibility
course
proceedings
may
indelibly
stamped
shaped
fruits
breach
confidence
acts
omissions
prompted
divided
loyalty
brief
petitioner
effect
tainted
proceeding
frustrating
public
policy
petitioner
fails
supply
single
concrete
example
indelible
stamp
taint
warns
ground
petitioner
urged
district
respondent
might
shape
plaintiffs
claims
relief
way
increase
burden
petitioner
cases
however
require
much
ruling
may
considered
effectively
unreviewable
absent
immediate
appeal
appealable
final
collateral
order
challenged
order
must
constitute
complete
formal
trial
final
rejection
abney
supra
claimed
right
denial
immediate
review
render
impossible
review
whatsoever
ryan
thus
permitted
appeals
prior
criminal
trials
defendant
claimed
subjected
forbidden
double
jeopardy
abney
supra
violation
constitutional
right
bail
stack
boyle
situations
like
posting
security
costs
involved
cohen
involved
asserted
right
legal
practical
value
destroyed
vindicated
trial
macdonald
way
contrast
generally
denied
review
pretrial
discovery
orders
see
ryan
supra
cobbledick
supra
rationale
rare
case
appeal
final
judgment
cure
erroneous
discovery
order
party
may
defy
order
permit
contempt
citation
entered
challenge
order
direct
appeal
contempt
ruling
see
cobbledick
supra
also
rejected
immediate
appealability
claims
may
fairly
assessed
trial
macdonald
supra
involving
considerations
enmeshed
factual
legal
issues
comprising
plaintiff
cause
action
coopers
lybrand
livesay
quoting
mercantile
national
bank
langdeau
order
refusing
disqualify
counsel
plainly
falls
within
large
class
orders
indeed
reviewable
appeal
final
judgment
within
much
smaller
class
propriety
district
denial
disqualification
motion
often
difficult
assess
impact
underlying
litigation
may
evaluated
normally
final
judgment
decision
whether
disqualify
attorney
ordinarily
turns
peculiar
factual
situation
case
hand
order
embodying
decision
rarely
ever
represent
final
rejection
claim
fundamental
right
effectively
reviewed
following
judgment
merits
case
us
petitioner
made
showing
opportunity
meaningful
review
perish
unless
immediate
appeal
permitted
contrary
appeals
conclude
trial
ended
permitting
continuing
representation
prejudicial
error
retain
usual
authority
vacate
judgment
appealed
order
new
trial
remedy
seems
plainly
adequate
petitioner
concerns
possible
injury
ultimately
prove
well
founded
second
circuit
recently
observed
potential
harm
might
caused
requiring
party
await
final
judgment
may
appeal
even
denial
disqualification
motion
erroneous
diffe
significant
way
harm
resulting
interlocutory
orders
may
erroneous
orders
requiring
discovery
objection
orders
denying
motions
recusal
trial
judge
armstrong
mcalpin
cert
pending
interlocutory
orders
appealable
mere
ground
may
erroneous
permitting
wholesale
appeals
ground
constitute
unjustified
waste
scarce
judicial
resources
also
transform
limited
exception
carved
cohen
license
broad
disregard
finality
rule
imposed
congress
decline
iii
hold
district
order
denying
motion
disqualify
counsel
appealable
prior
final
judgment
underlying
litigation
insofar
eighth
circuit
reached
conclusion
decision
correct
decision
contrary
precedent
circuit
went
reached
merits
order
appealed
approach
however
overlooks
fact
finality
requirement
embodied
jurisdiction
nature
appellate
finds
order
party
seeks
appeal
fall
within
statute
inquiry
lacks
discretion
consider
merits
case
without
jurisdiction
thus
definition
jurisdictional
ruling
may
never
made
prospective
therefore
hold
appeals
without
jurisdiction
hear
appeal
without
authority
decide
merits
consequently
judgment
eighth
circuit
vacated
case
remanded
instructions
dismiss
appeal
want
jurisdiction
see
dibella
ordered
footnotes
pursuant
judicial
panel
multidistrict
litigation
ordered
suits
multipiece
truck
tire
rim
manufacturers
consolidated
trial
district
western
district
missouri
app
firm
included
home
list
clients
law
directory
occasionally
represented
insurer
matters
unrelated
multipiece
rim
litigation
time
petitioner
filed
disqualification
motion
respondent
defending
home
five
carriers
suit
certain
fire
insurance
policies
home
pay
respondent
firm
retainer
april
home
sent
letters
containing
similar
advice
defendants
consolidated
suits
plaintiffs
actions
represented
respondent
alternative
district
stated
respondent
terminate
representation
home
unrelated
matter
see
supra
trial
based
determination
potential
conflict
existed
interpretation
disciplinary
rule
code
professional
responsibility
adopted
verbatim
local
rule
rule
prohibits
lawyer
continu
ing
multiple
employment
exercise
independent
professional
judgment
behalf
client
likely
adversely
affected
representation
another
client
except
obvious
adequately
represent
interest
consents
representation
district
agreed
petitioner
likely
dual
representation
adversely
affect
respondent
exercise
independent
judgment
app
quoting
international
business
machines
levin
therefore
ordered
either
comply
consent
requirement
terminate
representation
app
district
certified
pretrial
order
disqualification
interlocutory
appeal
pursuant
provides
relevant
part
district
judge
making
civil
action
order
otherwise
appealable
section
shall
opinion
order
involves
controlling
question
law
substantial
ground
difference
opinion
immediate
appeal
order
may
materially
advance
ultimate
termination
litigation
shall
state
writing
order
appeals
may
thereupon
discretion
permit
appeal
taken
order
appeals
also
stated
orders
granting
motions
disqualify
counsel
appealable
question
presented
instant
petition
express
opinion
neither
express
view
whether
order
denying
disqualification
motion
criminal
case
appealable
pendency
appeal
eighth
circuit
petitioner
filed
action
home
charging
consenting
respondent
continuing
representation
plaintiffs
multipiece
rim
suits
insurer
breached
fiduciary
duty
petitioner
app
time
oral
argument
counsel
petitioner
represented
resolution
reached
litigation
tr
oral
arg
addition
eighth
circuit
decision
currently
us
five
circuits
follow
rule
denials
disqualification
motions
appealable
see
continental
investment
armstrong
mcalpin
cert
pending
overruling
silver
chrysler
plymouth
chrysler
motors
melamed
itt
continental
baking
melamed
ii
overruling
melamed
itt
continental
baking
melamed
community
broadcasting
boston
fcc
app
cord
smith
five
circuits
permit
appeals
see
westinghouse
electric
mackethan
peat
marwick
mitchell
kroungold
triester
fullmer
harper
uniweld
products
union
carbide
cert
denied
counsel
respondent
represented
oral
argument
case
time
discovery
stage
tr
oral
arg
see
supra
although
may
situations
party
irreparably
damaged
forced
wait
final
resolution
underlying
litigation
securing
review
order
denying
motion
disqualify
opposing
counsel
necessary
order
resolve
situations
create
general
rule
permitting
appeal
orders
proper
circumstances
moving
party
may
seek
sanctions
short
disqualification
protective
order
limiting
counsel
ability
disclose
act
purportedly
confidential
information
additional
facts
support
motion
develop
course
litigation
moving
party
might
ask
trial
reconsider
decision
ultimately
dissatisfied
result
district
absolutely
determined
harmed
irreparably
party
may
seek
question
certified
interlocutory
appellate
review
pursuant
see
supra
exceptional
circumstances
designed
writ
mandamus
appeals
might
available
see
continental
investment
community
broadcasting
boston
fcc
app
see
generally
comment
appealability
orders
denying
motions
disqualification
counsel
federal
courts
chi
rev
need
concerned
availability
extraordinary
procedures
case
us
petitioner
made
colorable
claim
harm
might
suffer
forced
await
final
outcome
litigation
appealing
denial
disqualification
motion
greater
harm
suffered
litigant
forced
wait
termination
trial
challenging
interlocutory
orders
considers
erroneous
brief
amicus
curiae
challenged
petitioner
standing
attack
order
permitting
respondent
continue
representation
plaintiffs
light
conclusion
eighth
circuit
without
jurisdiction
hear
petitioner
appeal
occasion
address
standing
issue
two
courts
appeals
overruled
precedent
held
orders
denying
disqualification
motions
immediately
appealable
similarly
made
decisions
prospective
therefore
reached
merits
disputes
see
armstrong
mcalpin
citing
need
provide
guidance
district
courts
avoid
waste
judicial
resources
melamed
ii
earlier
ruling
melamed
established
appealability
law
case
extent
rationales
cases
allow
agree
decide
merits
case
without
jurisdiction
respectfully
disagree
justice
rehnquist
chief
justice
joins
concurring
result
agree
result
case
analysis
far
concerns
question
whether
order
denying
disqualification
counsel
effectively
unreviewable
appeal
final
judgment
answer
question
dispositive
appealability
issue
since
completely
unnecessary
however
state
ante
order
denying
disqualification
motion
meets
first
part
collateral
order
test
conclusively
determine
disputed
question
issue
whether
challenged
counsel
permitted
continue
representation
clear
courts
considering
question
order
denying
motion
disqualification
counsel
conclusively
determines
disputed
question
district
remains
free
reconsider
decision
time
see
armstrong
mcalpin
en
banc
cert
pending
van
graafeiland
concurring
part
dissenting
part
fleischer
phillips
cert
denied
recognizes
possibility
ante
abstractly
inconsistent
conclusion
first
prong
cohen
test
satisfied
case
possibility
reconsideration
trial
judge
dismissed
merely
theoretical
petitioner
claim
respondent
advance
theories
liability
absolve
insurer
advance
theories
strenuously
others
although
impossible
discern
true
trial
issues
may
become
clearer
trial
progresses
respondent
actually
present
theories
macdonald
assumed
motion
made
later
point
proceedings
prejudice
better
gauged
denied
seem
totally
unnecessary
probably
incorrect
statements
minor
point
opinion
concur
result