the State must" provide the defendant with "access to a competent psychiatrist Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.029 0.244 0.555 0.156 0.016 Ake established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.080 0.460 0.380 0.062 Ake ,--::State ,-- McWilliams was competent to stand trial and had not been suffering from mental illness at the time of the alleged offense. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.076 0.310 0.386 0.179 0.049 which concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.099 0.632 0.226 0.026 which ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams ';McWilliams of capital murder;petitioner McWilliams with rape and murder; McWilliams was likely exaggerating his symptoms Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.042 0.336 0.535 0.073 0.014 He concluded something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.080 0.239 0.601 0.064 He ,Dr. Goff;::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams ';McWilliams of capital murder;petitioner McWilliams with rape and murder; the trial court denied him the right to meaningful expert assistance guarantee by Ake. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.149 0.586 0.168 0.067 0.030 McWilliams argued something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.079 0.519 0.338 0.047 McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams ';::court ,-- Dr. Goff's examination satisfied Ake's requirements. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.131 0.461 0.345 0.040 Court holding something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.134 0.592 0.223 0.028 Court ,--::Goff 's examination ,-- the state must provide a defendant with access to a mental health expert Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.371 0.543 0.051 0.006 Ake established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.080 0.460 0.380 0.062 Ake ,Ake;::state ,-- the volunteer psychologist was available to the defense at the judicial sentencing proceeding. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.050 0.376 0.425 0.128 0.021 that indicate something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.035 0.754 0.193 0.012 that ,--::psychologist ,-- McWilliams did not get all the mental health assistance that he requested. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.073 0.453 0.394 0.064 0.016 record indicates something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.110 0.644 0.204 0.023 record ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams; the State provide the defense with "access to a competent psychiatrist Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.012 0.082 0.543 0.343 0.020 It requires something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.092 0.440 0.327 0.113 0.028 It ,--::State ,-- Alabama met the examination requirement Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.099 0.539 0.303 0.041 it assuming something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.025 0.231 0.634 0.100 0.010 it ,Alabama;Alabama 's;::Alabama ,Alabama;Alabama 's; McWilliams' purported malingering was not necessarily inconsistent with mental illness. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.127 0.610 0.224 0.028 0.012 that might explained something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.025 0.187 0.641 0.132 0.016 that ,--::purported McWilliams ' malingering ,-- the State had failed to provide him with the expert mental health assistance the Constitution requires Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.099 0.679 0.209 0.009 0.004 McWilliams arguing something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.028 0.578 0.367 0.021 McWilliams ,McWilliams;::State ,-- it was. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.089 0.702 0.187 0.012 We hold something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.015 0.081 0.470 0.400 0.035 We ,--::it ,-- the State must provide an indigent defendant with access to a mental health expert Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.043 0.548 0.380 0.025 0.004 none-outerSubject established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.068 0.496 0.380 0.042 none-outerSubject,--::State ,-- Ake Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.029 0.144 0.631 0.154 0.043 McWilliams agree something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.079 0.519 0.338 0.047 McWilliams ,--::Ake ,Ake; the "issue in this case is whether the Constitution requires that an indigent defendant have access to the psychiatric examination and assistance necessary to prepare an effective defense based on his mental condition Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.096 0.689 0.201 0.011 0.003 Court stating something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.144 0.491 0.294 0.044 Court ,--::issue ,-- an indigent defendant have access to the psychiatric examination and assistance necessary to prepare an effective defense based on his mental condition Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.093 0.526 0.284 0.074 0.023 Constitution requires something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.092 0.459 0.278 0.131 0.040 Constitution ,--::indigent defendant ,-- the assistance of a psychiatrist may well be crucial to the defendant's ability to marshal his defense." Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.020 0.124 0.508 0.315 0.033 Court wrote something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.030 0.172 0.505 0.253 0.039 Court ,--::assistance ,-- the indigent defendant have access to a competent psychiatrist for the[se] purpose[s]." Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.054 0.415 0.437 0.079 0.016 Our concern is something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.072 0.200 0.627 0.084 Our concern ,--::indigent defendant ,-- a State must provide a mental health professional capable of performing a certain role Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.065 0.504 0.290 0.121 0.020 Ake establishes something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.016 0.056 0.316 0.521 0.091 Ake ,Ake;::State ,-- McWilliams was competent to stand trial and that he had not been suffering from mental illness at the time of the alleged offense. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.085 0.325 0.353 0.182 0.055 members concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.108 0.654 0.199 0.022 members ,--::McWilliams ,Dr. Nagi;McWilliams;McWilliams ';Mr. McWilliams; "Mr. McWilliams is grossly exaggerating his psychological symptoms to mimic mental illness." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.131 0.702 0.145 0.016 0.006 One wrote something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.008 0.042 0.673 0.253 0.024 One ,--::McWilliams ,-- McWilliams' performance on one of the tests "suggested that [McWilliams] had exaggerated his endorsement of symptoms of illness and the profile was considered a 'fake bad.' " Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.237 0.683 0.074 0.003 0.003 Nagi noted something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Nagi ,--::McWilliams ' performance ,Dr. Nagi;McWilliams;McWilliams ';Mr. McWilliams; [McWilliams] had exaggerated his endorsement of symptoms of illness and the profile was considered a 'fake bad.' " Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.305 0.638 0.052 0.002 0.003 McWilliams ' performance suggested something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.008 0.027 0.333 0.560 0.073 McWilliams ' performance ,Dr. Nagi;McWilliams;McWilliams ';Mr. McWilliams;::none-innersubject,-- McWilliams had a prior conviction. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.022 0.172 0.700 0.093 0.013 none-outerSubject testify something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.055 0.274 0.393 0.226 0.052 none-outerSubject,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams '; McWilliams had a "blatantly psychotic thought disorder" and needed inpatient treatment. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.034 0.168 0.472 0.281 0.045 who concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.009 0.052 0.774 0.153 0.011 who ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams '; he had found no evidence of psychosis Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.008 0.095 0.863 0.031 0.003 Nagi testified something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Nagi ,--::he ,Dr. Kamal Nagi;Dr. Nagi; one of the tests Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.010 0.080 0.697 0.197 0.016 Poythress testified something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Poythress ,--::one ,-- McWilliams had exaggerated or faked his symptoms. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.025 0.190 0.677 0.094 0.013 test 's scales indicated something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.120 0.578 0.259 0.024 test 's scales ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams; McWilliams presented "some diagnostic dilemmas." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.091 0.499 0.341 0.052 0.017 report concluded something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.033 0.113 0.251 0.510 0.093 report ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams '; McWilliams' "obvious neuropsychological deficit" could be related to his "low frustration tolerance and impulsivity Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.276 0.499 0.170 0.031 0.024 report added something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.029 0.107 0.716 0.136 report ,--::obvious McWilliams ' deficit ,-- McWilliams was taking an assortment of psychotropic medications including Desyrel Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.070 0.471 0.368 0.072 0.018 records indicated something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.025 0.604 0.335 0.031 records ,--::McWilliams ,-- "there is no way that I can go through this material Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.105 0.727 0.127 0.032 0.009 counsel protested something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 counsel ,--::way ,-- "the abritrary [sic] position taken by this Court regarding the Defendant's right to present mitigating circumstances is unconscionable resulting in this proceeding being a mockery." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.221 0.679 0.080 0.012 0.008 He said something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.065 0.302 0.586 0.037 He ,defense counsel;::abritrary position ,-- "further participation would be tantamount to exceptance [sic] of the Court's ruling." Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.040 0.406 0.510 0.038 0.007 He added something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.015 0.095 0.801 0.084 He ,defense counsel;::further participation ,-- he has the type of diagnosed illness that we pointed out earlier for The Court and have mentioned for The Court. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.129 0.560 0.241 0.049 0.021 We believe something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.024 0.163 0.506 0.282 0.026 We ,Taylor Hardin, and the Lunacy Commission, and at Holman;the Lunacy Commission;::he ,the Defendant; there were "no mitigating circumstances." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.101 0.568 0.298 0.024 0.009 he argued something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.062 0.589 0.300 0.036 he ,The prosecutor;the prosecutor 's;::mitigating circumstances ,-- he "would be pleased to respond to [the prosecutor's] remarks that there are no mitigating circumstances in this case if I were able to have time to produce . . . any mitigating circumstances." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.062 0.460 0.451 0.021 0.006 counsel replied something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 counsel ,--::he ,The prosecutor;the prosecutor 's; there are no mitigating circumstances in this case if I were able to have time to produce . . . any mitigating circumstances." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.191 0.653 0.147 0.005 0.005 he remarks something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.015 0.069 0.567 0.310 0.039 he ,The prosecutor;the prosecutor 's;::mitigating circumstances ,-- he had reviewed the records himself and found evidence that McWilliams was faking and manipulative. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.061 0.421 0.460 0.046 0.011 judge said something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.008 0.057 0.833 0.093 0.008 judge ,--::he ,The trial judge; " and that "the preponderance of the evidence from these tests and reports show [McWilliams] to be feigning Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.037 0.367 0.443 0.137 0.016 It found something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.017 0.306 0.615 0.057 It ,The court;::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams '; the aggravating circumstances would far outweigh this as a mitigating circumstance." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.135 0.561 0.264 0.026 0.013 court wrote something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.024 0.187 0.339 0.415 0.034 court ,--::aggravating circumstances ,-- the trial court had denied him the right to meaningful expert assistance guaranteed by Ake. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.068 0.518 0.366 0.039 0.008 McWilliams arguing something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.028 0.578 0.367 0.021 McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams ';McWilliams, 640 So;::court ,-- Ake's requirements "are met Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.188 0.511 0.243 0.029 It wrote something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.089 0.627 0.252 0.018 It ,The Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals;The appeals court;The court;the trial court;the trial court 's;::Ake 's requirements ,-- "[t]here is no indication in the record Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.038 0.352 0.475 0.120 0.015 court added something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.009 0.035 0.107 0.751 0.098 court ,--::t ,-- it would have considered a motion to present an expert to evaluate this report" had one been made Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.107 0.573 0.278 0.033 0.009 court indicated something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.069 0.201 0.650 0.065 court ,--::it ,The Alabama Court of Criminal Appeals;The appeals court;The court;the trial court;the trial court 's; McWilliams had "received the assistance required by Ake" because Dr. Goff "completed the testing" Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.075 0.473 0.368 0.068 0.017 He wrote something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.013 0.090 0.369 0.496 0.031 He ,Ake;McWilliams;::McWilliams ,Ake;McWilliams; the conditions Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.003 0.021 0.923 0.049 0.004 one denies something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.069 0.346 0.472 0.094 one ,--::conditions ,-- she was available to the defense at this time. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.110 0.580 0.269 0.024 that indicate something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.035 0.754 0.193 0.012 that ,--::she ,-- Ake's requirements are irrelevant because McWilliams "never asked for more expert assistance" than he got Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.078 0.548 0.295 0.063 0.016 Alabama argues something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.055 0.754 0.157 0.023 Alabama ,--::Ake 's requirements ,-- McWilliams did request additional help from mental health experts. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.114 0.648 0.197 0.022 record indicates something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.110 0.644 0.204 0.023 record ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams; a State must provide an indigent defendant with a qualified mental health expert retained specifically for the defense team Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.071 0.659 0.242 0.023 0.006 Ake established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.080 0.460 0.380 0.062 Ake ,Ake;::State ,-- a defendant must receive the assistance of a mental health expert Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.026 0.216 0.535 0.201 0.022 Ake established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.080 0.460 0.380 0.062 Ake ,Ake;Ake 's;::defendant ,-- "this issue really has been mooted over the last 30-some-odd years because of statutory changes"). Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.129 0.690 0.134 0.036 0.011 none-outerSubject conceding something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 none-outerSubject,--::issue ,-- we granted petitioner's first question presented- Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.012 0.120 0.830 0.034 0.004 We recognize something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.148 0.635 0.183 0.015 We ,--::we ,-- a defendant must receive the assistance of a mental health expert Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.026 0.216 0.535 0.201 0.022 Ake established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.080 0.460 0.380 0.062 Ake ,Ake;::defendant ,-- the court of appeals correctly denied the habeas petition." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.089 0.584 0.227 0.081 0.018 it thought something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.004 0.018 0.394 0.557 0.027 it ,the State;::court ,-- "the requirements of Ake v. Oklahoma . . . are met Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.051 0.429 0.374 0.127 0.019 court held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.010 0.044 0.180 0.699 0.067 court ,--::requirements ,-- Alabama met the examination portion of this requirement by providing for Dr. Goff's examination of McWilliams. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.082 0.310 0.443 0.120 0.046 We assume something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.089 0.694 0.184 0.026 0.008 We ,--::Alabama ,-- McWilliams' purported malingering was not necessarily inconsistent with mental illness (as an expert later testified in postconviction proceedings Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.146 0.637 0.191 0.017 0.009 that might explained something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.025 0.187 0.641 0.132 0.016 that ,--::purported McWilliams ' malingering ,-- Dr. Goff was never ordered to do any of these things by the trial court. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.072 0.562 0.304 0.050 0.012 dissent emphasizes something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.024 0.286 0.670 0.017 0.003 dissent ,--::Goff ,-- the Alabama court decision affirming McWilliams's conviction and sentence was "contrary to Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.030 0.299 0.515 0.140 0.016 we must conclude something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.013 0.072 0.670 0.222 0.022 we ,--::decision ,-- it could have. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.026 0.235 0.573 0.153 0.013 none-outerSubject think something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.010 0.064 0.730 0.180 0.014 none-outerSubject,--::it ,The Eleventh Circuit;the Eleventh Circuit; "[m]alingering is not inconsistent with serious mental illness Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.120 0.714 0.130 0.026 0.009 none-outerSubject explain something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.082 0.540 0.317 0.044 none-outerSubject,--::alingering ,-- an indigent defendant Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.035 0.202 0.513 0.215 0.036 none-outerSubject established something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.068 0.496 0.380 0.042 none-outerSubject,--::indigent defendant ,-- a defendant is entitled to an expert Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.058 0.337 0.351 0.214 0.040 Ake did not establish something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.086 0.455 0.294 0.129 0.036 Ake ,Ake;::defendant ,-- the state court's ruling on the claim . . . was so lacking in justification that there was an error well understood and comprehended in existing law beyond any possibility for fairminded disagreement." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.281 0.524 0.178 0.009 0.009 It show something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.009 0.043 0.533 0.390 0.025 It ,--::court 's ruling ,-- a defendant must be provided "access to a competent psychiatrist" in two circumstances Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.248 0.549 0.157 0.018 we held something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.004 0.015 0.551 0.401 0.030 we ,--::defendant ,-- a defendant in the two situations just noted must be provided with the services of an expert Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.066 0.463 0.341 0.107 0.023 Ake Did establish something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.030 0.144 0.373 0.385 0.068 Ake ,Ake;::defendant ,-- a psychiatrist can "assist in preparing the cross-examination of a State's psychiatric witnesses" and would "know the probative questions to ask of the opposing party's psychiatrists and Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.336 0.578 0.052 0.006 Ake noted something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Ake ,Ake;::psychiatrist ,-- it is important for a defendant to "offer a well-informed expert's opposing view" in the form of "responsive psychiatric testimony." Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.015 0.247 0.651 0.082 Court said something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.027 0.147 0.491 0.292 0.044 Court ,--::it ,the Court; factfinding is improved Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.047 0.113 0.660 0.162 Ake explained something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Ake ,Ake;::factfinding ,-- a State need only provide for a single psychiatric expert to be selected by the trial judge. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.073 0.596 0.297 0.027 0.006 Ake stated something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Ake ,Ake;::State ,-- Baldi did not limit the Court "in considering whether fundamental fairness today requires a different result Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.092 0.523 0.309 0.057 0.018 Ake declared something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.024 0.124 0.512 0.296 0.044 Ake ,Ake;::Baldi ,Baldi; Ake's rights were violated even under Baldi). Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.153 0.596 0.211 0.026 0.014 none-outerSubject arguing something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.108 0.440 0.370 0.059 none-outerSubject,--::Ake 's rights ,-- a defense-team expert must be appointed Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.060 0.337 0.349 0.209 0.045 Justices had agreed something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.024 0.134 0.533 0.272 0.037 Justices ,--::defense-team expert ,-- the exact type of expert required by Ake has remained "an open question in our jurisprudence." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.102 0.374 0.224 0.222 0.078 reasonable conclusion is something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.004 0.011 0.137 0.743 0.105 reasonable conclusion ,--::exact type ,-- Ake requires the appointment of a defense-team expert. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.176 0.624 0.150 0.031 0.019 courts had held something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.007 0.054 0.787 0.140 0.011 courts ,--::Ake ,Ake;Ake -RSB- to a state-funded psychiatric expert; a defense-team expert is not required. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.121 0.541 0.244 0.067 0.027 Circuit had held something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.049 0.888 0.054 0.004 Circuit ,--::defense-team expert ,-- he have access to a competent and impartial psychiatrist"). Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.014 0.296 0.603 0.082 due process requires something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.074 0.390 0.323 0.173 0.039 due process ,--::he ,Ake;Ake -RSB- to a state-funded psychiatric expert; a neutral expert suffices Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.175 0.445 0.308 0.045 panels held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.071 0.391 0.449 0.073 panels ,--::neutral expert ,-- due process requires more than a neutral expert). Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.137 0.657 0.162 0.031 0.014 none-outerSubject holding something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.016 0.098 0.661 0.205 0.020 none-outerSubject,--::due process ,-- Ake does not require appointment of a defense-team expert. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.112 0.562 0.270 0.041 0.016 panel held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.071 0.391 0.449 0.073 panel ,--::Ake ,Ake; "the defense had the right of access to an expert Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.013 0.108 0.421 0.432 0.026 Ake held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.071 0.391 0.449 0.073 Ake ,1545;1551;1985;21 Tulsa L.;Ake;Ake 's;Ake, 30;Competent Psychiatric Assistance After Ake v. Oklahoma, 14 Vt.;Giannelli, Ake v. Oklahoma;Groendyke, Ake v. Oklahoma;::defense ,-- access had to be a defense expert"); Greeley Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.044 0.491 0.405 0.052 0.008 Court did not conclude something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.072 0.471 0.351 0.084 0.022 Court ,--::access ,-- Ake requires only access to an independent psychiatric examination"); Note Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.138 0.596 0.235 0.019 0.011 strong case can be made something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.047 0.235 0.635 0.071 strong case ,--::Ake ,1545;1551;1985;21 Tulsa L.;Ake;Ake 's;Ake, 30;Competent Psychiatric Assistance After Ake v. Oklahoma, 14 Vt.;Giannelli, Ake v. Oklahoma;Groendyke, Ake v. Oklahoma; "whether the Constitution requires one psychiatrist or rather one defense-oriented psy-chiatrist" would "likely be the next constitutional issue adjudicated"). Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.094 0.663 0.192 0.040 0.010 J. predicting something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.038 0.874 0.079 0.004 J. ,--::none-innersubject,-- Ake is satisfied by the appointment of a neutral expert Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.043 0.205 0.326 0.355 0.071 courts held something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.030 0.686 0.256 0.023 courts ,--::Ake ,-- "there could be no reasonable dispute that they were wrong." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.101 0.626 0.239 0.027 0.008 it say something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.039 0.678 0.264 0.012 it ,--::none-innersubject,-- "Alabama here did not meet even Ake's most basic requirements." Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.203 0.603 0.163 0.012 Court holds something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.031 0.216 0.599 0.142 Court ,--::Alabama ,-- Dr. Goff merely submitted his report and did not provide further assistance to the defense. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.155 0.582 0.248 0.009 0.006 crux is something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.056 0.303 0.550 0.078 crux ,--::Goff ,-- we receive adversarial briefing Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.020 0.188 0.703 0.081 0.009 none-outerSubject ensure something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.019 0.081 0.372 0.456 0.072 none-outerSubject,--::we ,These Rules; it did not need to brief the second question presented in McWilliams's petition. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.080 0.525 0.310 0.070 0.014 State believed something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.033 0.134 0.403 0.363 0.068 State ,--::it ,The State;the State; today's ruling requires the Court to conclude that the state court's treatment of McWilliams's Ake claim "was so lacking in justification that there was an error well understood and comprehended in existing law beyond any possibility for fairminded disagreement." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.177 0.613 0.195 0.009 0.005 none-outerSubject remembering something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.124 0.545 0.269 0.039 none-outerSubject,--::today 's ruling ,-- the state court's treatment of McWilliams's Ake claim "was so lacking in justification that there was an error well understood and comprehended in existing law beyond any possibility for fairminded disagreement." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.207 0.630 0.146 0.012 0.006 today 's ruling conclude something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.021 0.104 0.467 0.364 0.044 today 's ruling ,--::court 's treatment ,-- the Court should not have addressed this question at all. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.098 0.631 0.238 0.025 0.008 fundamental point is something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.034 0.129 0.296 0.442 0.099 fundamental point ,--::Court ,-- any error of the sort the majority identifies today was harmless. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.077 0.561 0.311 0.041 0.010 Court has determined something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.013 0.045 0.341 0.511 0.090 Court ,--::error ,-- the Court of Appeals did not "specifically consider whether access to the type of meaningful assistance in evaluating Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.057 0.539 0.348 0.046 0.010 majority claims something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.005 0.043 0.862 0.086 0.005 majority ,--::Court ,-- the error did not have a substantial and injurious effect on the outcome of the sentencing proceeding. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.225 0.534 0.184 0.034 0.022 Court concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 Court ,--::error ,-- "we are a court of review Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.002 0.019 0.773 0.200 0.006 none-outerSubject recites something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.030 0.154 0.529 0.250 0.038 none-outerSubject,--::we ,Appeals '; this evidence "did not rise to the level of a mitigating circumstance Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.074 0.550 0.292 0.073 0.011 court concluded something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.028 0.145 0.232 0.525 0.070 court ,--::evidence ,-- "the aggravating circumstances would far outweigh this as a mitigating circumstance." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.120 0.657 0.169 0.041 0.012 court found something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.025 0.132 0.770 0.067 court ,--::aggravating circumstances ,-- McWilliams's mental state did not reduce his responsibility for his actions. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.042 0.447 0.460 0.045 0.006 none-outerSubject concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 none-outerSubject,--::mental McWilliams 's state ,McWilliams;McWilliams 's; McWilliams was "grossly exaggerating his psychological symptoms to mimic mental illness" and that he "obviously" did so "to evade criminal prosecution." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.121 0.581 0.224 0.055 0.019 One concluded something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.054 0.380 0.454 0.096 One ,--::McWilliams ,McWilliams;McWilliams 's; there was a possibility that hearing from Dr. Goff would change his evaluation of aggravating and mitigating factors Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.067 0.570 0.303 0.051 0.009 judge had thought something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.007 0.050 0.855 0.081 0.006 judge ,--::possibility ,-- the outcome of the sentencing proceeding would have been different if he had been given more expert assistance. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.155 0.655 0.162 0.020 0.008 none-outerSubject show something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.078 0.661 0.225 0.022 none-outerSubject,--::outcome ,-- he was denied effective assistance of counsel because his lawyers did not obtain an expert Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.224 0.641 0.127 0.004 0.004 McWilliams argued something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.079 0.519 0.338 0.047 McWilliams ,Dr. Goff;Dr. Goff 's;Dr. Woods;Dr. Woods 's;McWilliams;McWilliams 's;Mr. McWilliams;Reynolds;::he ,Dr. Goff;Dr. Goff 's;Dr. Woods;Dr. Woods 's;McWilliams;McWilliams 's;Mr. McWilliams;Reynolds; McWilliams's exaggeration of symptoms was not inconsistent with psychiatric problems. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.208 0.635 0.128 0.017 0.012 none-outerSubject testified something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 none-outerSubject,--::McWilliams 's exaggeration ,Dr. Goff;Dr. Goff 's;Dr. Woods;Dr. Woods 's;McWilliams;McWilliams 's;Mr. McWilliams;Reynolds; " agreed that this malingering could have been done for the purpose of avoiding the death penalty Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.040 0.298 0.411 0.226 0.025 Woods acknowledged something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.038 0.226 0.467 0.230 0.040 Woods ,--::tr ,-- this malingering could have been done for the purpose of avoiding the death penalty Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.092 0.521 0.318 0.052 0.016 tr agreed something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.104 0.439 0.374 0.060 tr ,--::malingering ,-- McWilliams's disorder explains Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.010 0.128 0.838 0.021 0.002 none-outerSubject say something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.022 0.128 0.579 0.237 0.034 none-outerSubject,--::McWilliams 's disorder ,Dr. Goff;Dr. Goff 's;Dr. Woods;Dr. Woods 's;McWilliams;McWilliams 's;Mr. McWilliams;Reynolds; nothing "indicate[s] that Mr. McWilliams was mentally impaired on the night of the offense." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.189 0.516 0.236 0.038 0.021 none-outerSubject concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 none-outerSubject,--::nothing ,-- "McWilliams's claims based upon the testimony of Dr. Woods are without merit." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.058 0.495 0.340 0.092 0.015 court found something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.025 0.132 0.770 0.067 court ,--::McWilliams 's claims ,-- he "did not suffer from a mental illness." Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.062 0.442 0.466 0.023 0.007 none-outerSubject concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.036 0.166 0.391 0.340 0.067 none-outerSubject,--::he ,Dr. Goff;Dr. Goff 's;Dr. Woods;Dr. Woods 's;McWilliams;McWilliams 's;Mr. McWilliams;Reynolds; "both the credibility of Dr. Woods and the reliability of his findings are questionable." Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.056 0.508 0.369 0.057 0.010 It found something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.006 0.017 0.306 0.615 0.057 It ,--::credibility ,-- a failure to present" evidence of this sort "made a difference in the outcome." Very negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.572 0.367 0.036 0.004 0.020 none-outerSubject would not find something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.079 0.508 0.333 0.062 0.018 none-outerSubject,--::failure ,-- the expert should be independent of the prosecution?" Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.032 0.250 0.580 0.120 0.019 it did establish something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.009 0.032 0.188 0.693 0.078 it ,the prosecution;this Court held in Ake that an indigent defendant is entitled to meaningful expert assistance for the ` evaluation, preparation, and presentation of the defense;::expert ,-- it had no need to decide the "sweeping" question on Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.049 0.435 0.447 0.059 0.010 Court says something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.042 0.267 0.479 0.179 0.033 Court ,--::it ,the Court;the question;this narrow ground;this possible disposition; Ake requires a defense expert. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.153 0.629 0.168 0.032 0.018 panel held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.071 0.391 0.449 0.073 panel ,--::Ake ,Ake;Ake 's; "Ake does not entitle [defendants] to . . . an [independent psychiatric] expert Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.131 0.659 0.154 0.043 0.013 later panel insisted something. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.080 0.489 0.324 0.085 0.021 later panel ,--::Ake ,Ake;Ake 's; Ake did not itself clearly compel an answer to this question for AEDPA purposes. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.067 0.420 0.393 0.096 0.024 Circuit concluded something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.013 0.092 0.789 0.095 0.011 Circuit ,--::Ake ,Ake;Ake 's; Alabama "devoted an entire section of its merits brief" to the question that the Court decides. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.020 0.050 0.140 0.618 0.171 Court suggesting something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.011 0.070 0.684 0.216 0.019 Court ,--::Alabama ,Alabama; no relief was warranted because he "had a consulting expert Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.123 0.685 0.177 0.010 0.005 Alabama argued something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.010 0.032 0.450 0.436 0.072 Alabama ,Alabama;::relief ,-- Dr. Goff did not play the role Ake requires of an expert because he only examined McWilliams and reported his findings to the trial court. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.185 0.595 0.180 0.026 0.014 Court says something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.042 0.267 0.479 0.179 0.033 Court ,--::Goff ,-- Dr. Goff did not assist the defense in understanding his report prior to the hearing or testify for McWilliams at the judicial sentencing hearing. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.092 0.617 0.251 0.030 0.010 Court concludes something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.023 0.100 0.373 0.429 0.074 Court ,--::Goff ,-- Dr. Goff 's diagnosis and the opportunity to present it to the sentencer was not as important as McWilliams suggests. Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.101 0.658 0.218 0.016 0.006 It suggests something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.014 0.114 0.696 0.166 0.011 It ,--::Goff 's diagnosis ,-- the right to a psychiatric expert at capital sentencing comes into play Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.041 0.268 0.339 0.310 0.042 Ake held something. Positive Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.017 0.071 0.391 0.449 0.073 Ake ,Ake;::right ,-- a capital defendant is entitled to the assistance of a psychiatric expert at sentencing Negative Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.098 0.584 0.257 0.046 0.016 we have never held something. Neutral Type = dense , numRows = 5 , numCols = 1 0.018 0.109 0.660 0.192 0.021 we ,--::defendant ,--